In this episode of Relatable, Allie interviews Monique Dusson, founder of the Center for Biblical Unity, a ministry that advocates for unity within the church from a historically Christian or biblical perspective. In this episode, we discuss critical theory and race theory, and why they are so incongruent with Christianity.
00:31:53.020If we can just put it out there, like plainly, white people are first bad.
00:31:57.380And we don't, this is not how we participate.
00:31:59.820So I would say be free from that narrative and that mindset and know that you've been created with dignity, value, and worth in the image of God.
00:32:06.860And you have something to contribute within the body and within, within community.
00:32:13.280So for the white person, and we're speaking in those terms because that is, that's the framework that critical race theory has given us in, in helping people try to kind of get out of that.
00:32:24.240And I think we do have to, you know, we have to say that for the, for the white woman who does sit down, maybe with their black friends, the black friend who says, you know, you, um, white people have white privilege and everyone is a victim of systemic racism.
00:32:44.020And if you're not, I'm worried that you're racist.
00:32:45.660There are friendships that have been seriously hurt because of this mentality.
00:32:49.920So what does the white Christian say to their black Christian friend who seems to have bought into critical theory and critical race theory?
00:32:58.060How do you lovingly push back on that?
00:33:00.980I think you try to win the next conversation, but you live in truth.
00:33:04.980So we can ask the question of, you know, biblically, where do you see that?
00:33:09.860How do you see us when the scripture says that we are now brothers and sisters?
00:33:14.880You know, how do you see us living in the same family from this standpoint?
00:33:18.860When we talk about things like systemic racism and it's everywhere, well, how are you defining systemic racism?
00:33:25.400Are you saying that the entire system is broken, like every system everywhere across all time?
00:33:29.880Or are you saying that there may be pieces of a system that are broken?
00:33:34.580What do you think should be done to be able to correct the system?
00:33:38.780How do you see reparations as not being theft?
00:33:41.960If I didn't have, you know, direct relationship with slaves, how do you see my participation in a system like slavery, thus needing my reparations?
00:33:54.940Where do you find the concept of reparations in the Bible?
00:34:15.880If I'm a white person, I'm going to ask, well, I can I can give reparations.
00:34:20.880I can't like there's nothing to stop me.
00:34:22.620But shouldn't that come from out of the conviction and compelling of my own heart to the people that I have specifically wronged if I'm going to participate, according to Zacchaeus?
00:34:56.660And what I've had to understand is that in black and white, because I've had I get messages from white people all the time that I am on the wrong side of history, that I am.
00:35:09.360We got a message this morning that I'm garbage, you know, so, you know, people will get upset.
00:35:14.620And at some point, you just have to stand for truth and understand that in allowing people to have their own thoughts and their own beliefs and views and you standing for truth, it may create a riff in your friendship.
00:35:39.680And if he is the way, the truth and the life, and if we believe that his word is truth, which as Christians we do, we don't have to acquiesce and we don't have to worry about meeting the world's definitions of justice and compassion, because we are actually seeing those play out right now in the streets of Kenosha and the streets of Seattle and Portland and Oakland.
00:35:57.520We're seeing the secular critical theory definition of justice and compassion played out right now.
00:36:03.840We are seeing collectivist justice, that justice that is not based on fact, that is not direct, that is not proportionate, that is not truthful as God's justice is.
00:36:16.020And it means destruction for innocent lives and livelihoods.
00:36:20.000It means punishment for people who did not commit a crime.
00:36:22.580And if that is not the definition of injustice, like, I don't know what is, but you get people who say, well, riots are the voice of the unheard.
00:36:35.380I've heard Christian pastors, evangelical pastors say, you just need to sit back and ask yourself, well, why is this happening before you criticize the rioters?
00:36:46.240Do you think that that's the right approach?
00:36:47.740No, but I hear what you're saying that one of the questions that gets me is, well, you need to ask yourself, why are you uncomfortable with this?
00:36:54.780I'm uncomfortable because it's my business, you know, like they're burning my business down.
00:37:01.040But this is what we're being approached with, and it's because it's coming into evangelicalism in huge waves that we are now thinking we need to adopt a secular framework in order to be unified, in order to walk in unity or to do justice.
00:37:17.800When scripture is clear on how we do justice and we can bring that over and say, okay, within our modern context today, what does that look like?
00:37:28.280Why is it that the church, I mean, otherwise it seems like solid evangelical pastors who I grew up listening to, some of them, one of them in particular that I'm thinking of, who has totally, it seems like given in to this rhetoric, is soft towards things like critical theory, they're preaching white privilege from the pulpit.
00:39:06.200And they have believed that the civil rights movement is the same as the movement that's happening today.
00:39:14.280But I've had a couple people on my podcast, Samuel Say, recently pointed this out, which I thought was a good point, is that the premise of the civil rights movement was just the manifestation of our founding values, that all men and women are created equal in the eyes of God.
00:39:29.520And therefore, they should be treated equally under the law.
00:39:31.840That was a true premise with a true pursuit towards that.
00:39:37.260That's not what we're arguing about today.
00:40:07.240That is why a lot of people ask, you know, why does Black Lives Matter only?
00:40:10.620They don't care that Black people are dying.
00:40:12.960They care about how Black people are dying.
00:40:14.660So they don't care about, you know, the hundreds of young men that are dying in Chicago.
00:40:19.220But I think it's because of this critical theory framework that it's not really about what is happening.
00:40:27.400It's about why something is happening and if it's between the oppressor and the oppressed.
00:40:33.620And I think that is part of why we're seeing just so much confusion and talking over each other right now.
00:40:39.280And honestly, I don't know what the conclusion will be.
00:40:43.900Yes, and we could get onto a whole Black Lives Matter conversation another day because I completely see that as being so destructive within the Black community.
00:40:54.460But yes, they are concerned with who is dying at the hands of white people, who are dying at the hands of the oppressed.
00:41:03.120And it doesn't matter if a white person is trying to defend themselves.
00:41:06.320It doesn't matter if a Black person is trying to rob them or not even a Black person.
00:41:10.920Any person of any color is trying to rob a white person and that white person defends themselves and the person of color ends up dying.
00:41:44.940If we play that all the way out, like it, it doesn't land us in a very good place.
00:41:50.300Yeah, it lands us in the same place that every left-wing revolution over the past hundred years has landed us from the Bolshevik revolution to today.
00:41:58.020It always is done in the name of some form of social justice, this anti-colonialism, anti-Westernism, anti-Americanism, imperialism.
00:42:08.620If you study any of the left-wing revolutions, whether it's North Korea or Mao's China or Pol Pot's Cambodia or the USSR, the Bolshevik revolution, it's all the same thing.
00:42:19.680That in the name of equality and justice, the same thing in Venezuela and Cuba, we are going to defeat who we say are the oppressors.
00:42:30.560And they win over the rich through shame and they win over the poor through encouraging resentment.
00:42:47.460It is always more destruction, more oppression, further disparities, suffering, poverty.
00:42:55.780And so, and I'm always just so curious, what do the people who are going out and destroying the cities in the name of critical theory, knowingly or unknowingly, what do they seek to build, at least ideally?
00:43:07.280And I just, this is one of my last questions, but when you were a part of this world, what did you see as the utopia or the kind of world that you wanted to grow?
00:43:19.400I would say that there would be all voices at the table that, especially like going back to my years in university, it was predominantly white university.
00:43:28.580We read predominantly white, white authored textbooks.
00:43:33.700I was like, you know, what about voices like mine?
00:43:35.580And so from this, from this point, I think people innocently get in and they're like, well, we need to elevate all the voices, but they aren't understanding that all the voices can actually be more problematic.
00:43:48.700That this idea of inclusivity and the way that we go about it, if we're not going about it from a Christ-centered view, then we are automatically in trouble.
00:43:57.960The idea of utopia that's being put forward today is this thing of equity and equality that everyone will have like this equal wealth distribution that everyone, you know, there, there won't be any poverty.
00:44:11.200But in scripture, we find that the poor will be with you always.
00:44:14.460So this, this endeavor will be with us forever.
00:45:13.820Or out of the goodness of our heart, like the early church did, are we supposed to give everything that we have to these people?
00:45:20.360And also just looking throughout history, what has happened when we have had total redistribution of so-called power and capital to the point of trying to force communism on people?
00:45:39.560So you gave such good advice when you were talking about, you know, speaking to the person who might disagree with you on this, is pointing to scripture, defining terms.
00:45:48.620I think that is kryptonite to critical theory.
00:45:50.460And asking clarifying questions, also kryptonite, to critical theory.
00:45:58.920And if you could, just for our last question, could you please explain one more time the difference between the directives and the goal and the heart of critical theory and the gospel of Jesus Christ?
00:46:13.140Well, I would say that the definition or the directive of critical theory would be to look at who are the oppressed and who are the oppressors within a society and how do we redistribute wealth?
00:46:26.760How do we overturn those who have the power, those who sit in a place of power so that those who are oppressed also have power or overturn those who have power and actually the oppressed would have more power?
00:46:41.620Now, within Christianity, what we see is that the rich and the poor, we have versions of righteous rich and versions of righteous poor.
00:46:54.360We see something that is based on our own personal responsibility, our own free will.
00:47:02.480There isn't a theft mentality in the gospel.
00:47:07.300I don't have to have someone take my money and redistribute it in order for there to be equality, in order for me to be seen as an equal with you before the father.
00:47:19.720This is where critical race theory or critical theory really gets off and goes off on its own sideline is how it's saying we achieve equality.
00:47:28.860There is no foundational equality between us, which, again, is something completely different than what's in Christianity.
00:47:37.960We see a complete redefinition of history and what history means in critical race theory.
00:47:44.620So critical race theory, again, is always looking back to oppressed and oppressor.
00:47:49.160In Christianity, we are looking at Jesus.
00:47:52.000You know, all of history points us to Jesus and everything from now until the Lord returns is pointing to Jesus.
00:47:59.840There are some, again, I spoke about identity.
00:48:03.000There's some foundational issues with who we are intrinsically.
00:48:07.360So I'm not sure if I'm answering all of your questions or if there are some definite contradictions, I call them, between critical race theory and critical theory.
00:48:23.160And I'm sorry, critical race theory and Christianity.
00:48:25.820And we have to understand what are the terms?
00:48:29.140How are we defining things like racism?
00:48:30.740Because if we aren't clear on that, we'll join in with the culture's rhetoric, not understanding that anyone can participate in racism.
00:48:56.340Yeah, and that can, as we see, that can just be such a destructive mentality, ascribing guilt and innocence based not on people's real guilt and innocence, but again, based on a perception.
00:49:09.300And critical theory is an entire worldview.
00:49:11.420You can't have two worldviews at the same time.
00:49:16.560And I think that is so often, I've seen it in my own friends' lives, where they say their politics change because they say, well, this side is the only side that cares about the oppressed, the only side that cares about racism.
00:49:29.320These are the biggest problems in our society.
00:49:31.180And they start, without realizing it, changing their definitions of justice, changing their definitions of racism, changing their definitions of sin and responsibility.
00:49:42.920I see them no longer affirming that Jesus is the only way, the only truth, and the only life.
00:49:47.840They stop affirming things like biblical marriage.
00:49:49.920And it's like, hang on, how did those two things happen?
00:49:53.560Because they don't seem like they have to do anything with each other until you realize that it is a holistic worldview that affects every single thing that you believe.
00:50:03.020And I think the wonderful news is that you articulated so well is that the gospel has a better message.
00:50:09.280God has a better definition of justice, and he has a better definition of solutions for unity.
00:50:14.600He has a better way of reconciliation than reparations.
00:50:17.740I mean, he paid for all of that on the cross.
00:50:20.700Ephesians 3 is, or Ephesians 2 is very clear that if he can bring the Gentiles and the Jews together, two very disparate groups, he can bring any group together.
00:50:30.000And we celebrate, I mean, we celebrate that kind of diversity within the body of Christ as long as we remember our unity is in the gospel and is in the cross and not in anything else.
00:50:49.440And the gospel takes the pressure off of us.
00:50:52.220It understands that we need something bigger and better than us.
00:50:57.000We have wicked hearts, and it's not to, you know, put us down or anything like that, but that's just the reality of humanity, that we have broken relationship with a holy God.
00:51:07.540And if that's the case, I'm going to need something bigger than myself in order to completely walk out unity, to walk out ideas of justice that can't be weighed on my shoulders.
00:51:19.280I'm going to need instruction for how to do that, and that instruction must come from Scripture.
00:51:23.720And the gospel is the great equalizer.