Relatable with Allie Beth Stuckey - Ep 327 ｜ The Truth About Critical Race Theory

00:00:00.000 Hey guys, welcome to Relatable. Happy Monday. Hope everyone had a wonderful weekend. Hope

00:00:15.820 you guys enjoyed my interview with Dave Rubin on Friday. He really is one of the easiest

00:00:21.800 people to talk to. I've had him on the show before. I've been on his show as well. Back

00:00:27.860 when I was big pregnant a couple years ago and that was really fun. You guys probably

00:00:32.900 don't realize, but not everyone on the show is easy to interview and easy to talk to.

00:00:39.120 But Dave Rubin is just one of those people that you could talk to forever. So if you

00:00:42.860 haven't listened to that, go back and listen to Friday's episode. Today we are doing something

00:00:47.440 that I love to do. Today's kind of episode is one of my favorite kinds of episodes, if

00:00:53.440 not my very favorite kind of episode. And that is we're breaking down a complicated

00:00:58.780 topic, which means that this will be one of those episodes I'm just foreseeing that people

00:01:04.160 will go back to that you will probably share with your friends just because it is breaking

00:01:10.280 down as simply as I can to the nitty gritty as I can, something that is very complex and

00:01:16.760 very pervasive. And if you have listened to my podcast for any amount of time, you have

00:01:21.420 heard me talk about this a lot and I'm sorry that I'm wearing you out with this. But even

00:01:25.880 if you have listened to all of my episodes, I promise that this will be an important and

00:01:31.340 edifying and informative episode for you. And we are talking about critical race theory.

00:01:38.600 I'm going to break it down in a way that we haven't broken it down before. I'm going to

00:01:41.760 apply it in a way that we haven't applied it before. And I'm going to link past episodes

00:01:46.120 that we've done on it because I've had a lot of conversations with experts about it. And

00:01:50.760 I feel like I have learned so much about this school of thought and what I'll argue is really

00:01:57.200 a worldview and almost a religion over the past few months. My most listened to episode

00:02:03.800 is my conversation with Dr. Neil Shenvey, who really has become the foremost Christian expert

00:02:11.500 and critic of critical race theory. He's just a very knowledgeable, insightful, and

00:02:16.560 very compassionate person who has made it his job to read all of these books that are

00:02:22.560 perpetuating critical race theory and break them down using logic and also using a biblical

00:02:29.100 perspective. And he has a website, shinveapologetics.com. I'll link it in the description to this that

00:02:34.920 I really recommend. He does a lot of book reviews. So many of you guys have asked me,

00:02:39.940 can you talk about Be the Bridge, for example, or can you talk about White Fragility? Can you talk

00:02:44.640 about the, I forget what it's called, Jamar Tisby's book? And he has actually done a lot of

00:02:51.680 work on this and very fairly, and I think kindly and honestly, reviewing these books and drawing out

00:02:58.220 where critical race theory has infiltrated a lot of them. A lot of people don't like him because of

00:03:05.660 this because he pushes back on this, but he's been a very good resource for me. My second most

00:03:10.480 listened to episode, I believe, is my conversation with Votie Bauckham, where we also talk about this.

00:03:16.040 We talk about social justice ideology. That's my most watched episode on YouTube. And so if you

00:03:22.260 haven't listened to those or watched those, I highly recommend that you do that. I had an interview

00:03:26.580 with Christopher Ruffo, who has uncovered how critical race theory has infiltrated our

00:03:33.440 government agencies and is being funded by our tax dollars. He kind of helped the executive order

00:03:41.300 that was signed by President Trump to ensure that we are not funding with our tax dollars,

00:03:48.400 critical race theory. Of course, if Joe Biden is officially the president, he will overturn that

00:03:53.380 and I'll be back to regularly scheduled funding of divisive ideologies. But it was it was good while

00:04:00.140 it lasted. And I will talk about why I believe this is it is good to resist this. I'm going to break

00:04:06.720 it down, hopefully in a way that makes it really simple and allows you to allows you to be able to

00:04:15.940 see it in real life. So when you're scrolling through Instagram, when you see one of your friends

00:04:19.440 share something, a lot of people buy into critical race theory without even realizing what it is or

00:04:24.980 what they've done. Also had a conversation with Monique Dusan. She runs Center for Biblical Unity.

00:04:30.240 Highly recommend following her and listening to that interview as well. So critical race theory,

00:04:35.300 if you don't know, and a lot of you don't, and this is why I'm doing this episode, by the way,

00:04:39.200 because I get so many questions on this. Still, even though we've talked about it so much,

00:04:43.040 but people are new to my podcast or they start following me on Instagram, they see me talking about

00:04:47.000 this and they have no idea what I'm talking about. And why would you? I mean, it doesn't seem to

00:04:51.740 affect our everyday life. It's not something it's not a phrase that we would necessarily teach our

00:04:56.660 children. It's not a phrase that you even hear if you're in corporate America and you're going

00:05:02.080 through diversity and inclusivity training. They're not going to use this particular word.

00:05:06.640 But it's important to know that critical race theory is the ideology that is behind most of these

00:05:12.360 diversity and inclusivity trainings and why they're actually counterproductive, why they're leading

00:05:17.660 to actually more implicit bias and a fear. Unfortunately, this is a tragic consequence of

00:05:23.580 all of this, a fear of by employers of just a fear of running their company because they are afraid that

00:05:32.680 they are not going to be able to meet the new standards of so-called anti-racism that is prescribed

00:05:40.580 by critical race theorists. So let's talk about, let's talk about what it is because it really is

00:05:46.340 so pervasive. It is a lens through which to see the world. It is, in other words, a worldview. We talk

00:05:53.240 about worldview a lot on this podcast. It shapes how its adherents view politics, theology, personal

00:05:59.600 interactions, education. It's described as a learning tool by people who use it, but in reality, it is much

00:06:07.320 bigger than that. It is more central than that. It is the hub of your wheel into which all of the

00:06:12.940 spokes of life must fit into. All worldviews are. And the worldview of critical theory views the world

00:06:19.540 through the lens. I'm going to use a lot of vocab words today, and I italicized them in my notes

00:06:25.300 because I might put them in the description because it's important for us to know the vocab words.

00:06:31.460 And so we hear it, we can think critical race theory. It is viewing the world through the lens

00:06:37.100 of hegemonic power structures. So hegemony means the dominance of one group over another group. So

00:06:44.500 critical race theory or critical theory, you can just say critical theory, sees everything as the

00:06:50.720 oppressed versus the oppressor. You might've heard of critical reading or critical math or critical

00:06:59.300 describing different fields of study in education and academia. What they mean by that is very

00:07:06.680 different than something like critical thinking. It is deconstructing those concepts until you get

00:07:13.080 down to how they fit into this worldview of the oppressed versus the oppressor. So critical math,

00:07:21.060 for example, in the realm of critical theory would advocate for teaching what they would call

00:07:27.440 marginalized kids differently than you would teach white kids and you wouldn't hold them by the same 0.96

00:07:33.220 standards because it is viewing the world, everything, every interaction, every field of study through

00:07:40.480 hegemony, through the lens of power structures of the oppressed versus the oppressor. And in critical

00:07:48.800 theory in general, these categories are determined by which groups have had more privilege or at least

00:07:55.540 perceived privilege. So white rich people, Christians, straight people, so-called cisgender people,

00:08:04.020 they are on the side of the privileged. And even in some cases, in most cases in the world of critical

00:08:10.680 theory on the side of the oppressor, whereas black and brown people, poor people, non-Christians, 0.99

00:08:16.880 gay people, transgender people are on the side of the marginalized or the oppressed. Now that's critical

00:08:23.840 theory, something also known as intersectionality, where you are looking at the intersections of

00:08:29.760 group membership that a certain person belongs to, and you are assigning oppression points based on that

00:08:37.680 membership. So for example, I am white. That's one point against me in the camp of the oppressor,

00:08:44.240 but I am a woman. And so I am oppressed by the patriarchy. And so I have some privilege,

00:08:50.260 some marginalization, and those points translate into, in this world of critical theory and

00:08:56.260 intersectionality, into social capital, into credibility. And so in the world of critical

00:09:01.620 theory, because I have at least one marginalization oppression point, I can speak to certain things with

00:09:10.440 a certain kind of authority, but I cannot speak to racial issues. For example, I could talk about how I've

00:09:19.500 been oppressed by the patriarchy, but I wouldn't be able to talk about, you know, systemic racism from

00:09:25.840 any place of authority. And so that is what intersectionality is. That is what critical theory

00:09:30.880 is in general. And as I'll get into, although it does emphasize these superficial identity points,

00:09:38.400 and it does say, you know, you're assigning oppression and oppressor according to your group membership

00:09:46.260 and your identity, like skin color and sexual orientation and things like that, what it really

00:09:52.180 prizes more than any of those things is ideology. So even though it gives me authority according to

00:09:58.900 intersectionality as a female because of my oppression, if I were to say, for example, well, I don't believe

00:10:05.620 that I'm oppressed by the patriarchy, they would say that I am just internalizing misogyny and that I am

00:10:13.200 still wrong. And so even though it does try to assign authority based on your gender or based on your skin

00:10:19.080 color, if a black person, for example, says, you know what, I don't believe that systemic racism exists

00:10:24.080 in 2020 in America and I'm actually not oppressed and I have had equal opportunity, intersectionalist,

00:10:31.080 critical theorist would say you're internalizing white supremacy. So even though on its face,

00:10:36.740 it does elevate these identity points like race and gender, if you go against the leftist dogma that

00:10:45.180 critical theory is a facade for, covers for, is a part of, then you're not actually a part of those

00:10:53.500 groups. Does it make sense? It shouldn't make sense if you are a sane person. But I have waded into

00:11:00.300 these waters of craziness for you so we can understand it and recognize it. So that's kind of critical

00:11:06.040 theory, intersectionality. Let's talk about critical race theory. So critical race theory, it's a part of

00:11:16.100 critical theory and of course intersectionality, but it categorizes people as the oppressed versus the

00:11:21.760 oppressor, not based on all our other identity points, but primarily, if not exclusively by race. So white 0.97

00:11:29.720 people, according to critical race theory, are the oppressors and non-white people are the oppressed, 0.91

00:11:35.100 specifically as we've, um, as we've seen most prominently, uh, black people are part of the

00:11:41.320 oppressed in critical race theory. White people have had privileges, according to critical race 0.88

00:11:46.360 theory, that non-white people don't. And we're just talking about, uh, we're, we're brushing people 0.99

00:11:51.100 with a broad brush right now because that's what critical race theory does. It's a collectivist

00:11:55.740 worldview rather than an individualistic one. White people, according to this theory, have culpability

00:12:00.840 and responsibility, corporate culpability and responsibility and debt that non-white people, 0.72

00:12:07.760 uh, do not have, uh, no matter what, no matter what you've actually done in your life, no matter

00:12:14.460 what you've actually said in your life, no matter what you have actually been actively a part of,

00:12:19.460 it doesn't matter because your identity as a white person has given you privilege, according to this

00:12:24.200 theory and your identity as a non-white person, as a black or brown person has, uh, given you,

00:12:31.260 has marginalized you and has made you a part of the oppressed. White supremacy and critical race theory

00:12:37.680 is a hegemonic power structure under which all systems and individuals are negatively affected,

00:12:43.620 hence the term systemic racism. This is a fairly new term. So if you look on LexisNexis,

00:12:50.400 for example, that's a really great tool to see like when words became popular and when we started

00:12:56.200 using them, although it's been around in some form or another for a while, it just recently became

00:13:03.280 mainstream used by politicians, used by places like the New York times and the Washington post

00:13:07.880 used in academia, uh, academia becoming part of our social lexicon. This is a very, uh, not a necessarily

00:13:14.580 new idea, but it is a newly popular idea in 2020. And so under critical race theory, systemic racism

00:13:24.440 must be obliterated, uh, in order to gain liberation and equality and justice for non-white people, 0.99

00:13:30.020 because it is an indication of a hegemonic power structure under which, like I said, all systems 0.77

00:13:36.920 and individuals are negatively affected according to critical race theory. Um, okay. I'm going to get into

00:13:43.880 more of what that means and a further definition of that, but we got to take a quick ad break.

00:13:59.180 Okay. So in critical theory, in critical race theory, the way to this liberation from a systemic

00:14:06.740 hegemonic power structures is to change the power dynamics so that non-white people are brought to 1.00

00:14:15.100 the same place as white people. There must be a transfer of power and privilege. So that means 0.95

00:14:21.760 according to critical race theory, that, uh, black people in particular should receive monetary

00:14:26.640 reparations from white people. That's one example. White people should quote, listen and learn from 0.52

00:14:32.360 non-white people. You've probably heard that phrase a lot recently and that we need more, even in some

00:14:37.420 cases, disproportionately more non-white representation in all fears of society, that there should be 0.65

00:14:43.500 different treatment or even academic, uh, or employment standards for non-white people. There

00:14:48.880 was a measure in California to ensure, um, that tried to pass. Thankfully the majority of Californians

00:14:55.140 voted against it, but to actually, uh, to allow discrimination in the employment process, uh, allow

00:15:04.340 racial discrimination so that companies would be able to legally discriminate against white people in

00:15:10.960 an effort, again, to change these power structures to ensure equal outcomes. And so you can see how a

00:15:17.700 changing these power structures, according to critical race theory, actually, um, encourages and

00:15:23.520 necessitates bias. It necessitates some form of discrimination in order to try to get everyone

00:15:30.180 even. Um, it is also advocating, for example, for the justice system to make judgments in light of

00:15:38.820 privilege that, uh, the accused has rather than on sheer culpability. I mean, this is part of why the

00:15:47.160 Black Lives Matter movement started. Even though George Zimmerman, uh, he went through the proper trial and

00:15:53.340 he had due process. And even though the Obama DOJ said, look, the, the verdict of this case is

00:15:59.320 actually correct. There's nothing more than that we can do. Black Lives Matter still said, no, that's

00:16:05.720 not that that's not right. And that's why we're going to start this movement. That's why there are

00:16:09.800 going to be riots and unrest. They say no justice, no peace. What they actually mean by that is this

00:16:15.760 justice as defined by critical race theory, where you're actually supposed to account for

00:16:21.780 these hegemonic power structures and, um, and racial history and racial privilege. When you are

00:16:31.480 making cases in court, um, uh, when you are deciding upon the verdict of a case in court, critical race

00:16:38.740 theory views all disparities as proof of discrimination. So if white people, for example, make more money on

00:16:46.280 average than Black people, that is because of racial discrimination. According to this theory,

00:16:51.280 if the crime rate is higher among Black people, that is actually because of racism as well. If the

00:16:56.800 graduation rate is lower among Black people, that is because of racism. If the employment rate is lower

00:17:02.500 among Black people, that is because of racism. According to this theory, um, there is no further

00:17:07.700 evidence that is needed of systemic racism than the disparities that exist. That is what, uh, that is

00:17:14.920 the theory that they perpetuate because again, they don't see racism necessarily as direct discrimination,

00:17:21.700 but as an entire power structure, you'll hear words like the legacy of slavery. So it's a power

00:17:27.660 structure that has always existed, that is keeping certain groups down, that is lifting other groups

00:17:33.220 up. And we have to have a complete and radical revolutionary shift of power in order to change those

00:17:39.220 things. There is never any other explanation for any kind of racial disparity and outcome. It is

00:17:44.660 always because of white supremacy and its hegemonic power structure, according to CRT, critical race

00:17:50.440 theory. Um, and that is because again, just to go back, according to CRT, Black and Brown people are in 0.98

00:17:57.920 the category of the oppressed. Therefore, any disparity will always be a signifier of oppression,

00:18:03.760 which according to CRT is caused by white supremacy. So now you can maybe see, maybe you've

00:18:10.060 already deduced this, where we get the idea that it's not possible, according to people like Ibra

00:18:14.920 Max Kendi, to be non-racist because CRT asserts that racism is not just something that you do or say

00:18:22.100 or think, but it's an entire system. And as long as you play a role in it, whether you mean to or not,

00:18:27.420 you are complicit. Uh, if you're not outright guilty, you are guilty of perpetuating a racist

00:18:33.160 system, according to this thinking. So you have to be actively anti-racist as Kendi argues, which

00:18:40.060 doesn't just mean not being racist yourself or calling out people for saying something racist or

00:18:45.560 saying a racist joke, but you have to actively work towards opposing systemic racism. So closing the

00:18:52.240 gaps between white people and black people, which means again, shifting the power dynamic, which requires 0.67

00:18:57.780 a few things, according to CRT. And these have a lot of vocab words in it that I know you guys have

00:19:03.040 heard, and I hope it's making connections for you now. So in order to shift these power dynamics,

00:19:08.000 which is the only way, according to this theory, that you can be truly anti-racist, which is what

00:19:12.620 you have to be in order to gain any sort of righteousness within this worldview, you have to

00:19:18.260 number one, recognize, call out, and then repent of your own place in the white supremacist system as

00:19:24.820 an oppressor. Again, this doesn't mean that you've actually done or said anything that is racist,

00:19:30.500 but by your mere existence as a white person in CRT and your lack of action in dismantling the

00:19:36.920 hegemonic power structure of white supremacy, you are perpetuating oppression. So step one in

00:19:43.740 dismantling the so-called system is recognizing the racism within yourself. You have to read things like

00:19:50.280 white fragility, which of course is written by a white person, which is ironic. That goes back to what 0.56

00:19:55.080 we said at the beginning, even though they elevate these identifiers like skin color and gender,

00:20:02.400 what is really most important in CRT is ideology. And because Robin DiAngelo, who wrote a white 0.53

00:20:08.920 fragility, even though she's white, she is saying the right things. And so that qualifies as a book 0.99

00:20:14.680 that you can read in the realm of CRT that is going to help you in step one of tearing down these power

00:20:21.160 structures, which is recognizing the racism within yourself and repenting of it. Racism, according to

00:20:27.180 CRT, taints everything that a white person does. They're basically born that way and they can't get 0.76

00:20:35.280 rid of it until they realize that it is part of everything they do. This work is also known as

00:20:40.360 decolonizing yourself. You've probably heard of that term, maybe. Decolonizing yourself, your work,

00:20:46.940 in your life, according to CRT, to decolonize is to remove the domination from a particular place. So

00:20:54.160 by recognizing your role in oppression as a white person in colonialism or asserting white domination,

00:21:02.080 you are beginning the work of decolonizing yourself in the spaces in which you occupy. This is not so

00:21:08.420 different than what we see in what is described by these proponents as Christianity, deconstructionism.

00:21:18.720 You have to deconstruct all of these parts of your theology in order to get to the truth. Well,

00:21:24.180 this is a similar concept. You have to decolonize yourself and dig down and find the white supremacy

00:21:29.020 and how it is actually tainting everything you think, say, and do in order to be anti-racist and fight

00:21:37.020 against the hegemonic power structure that is white supremacy and CRT, which leads to the second

00:21:42.700 thing that you must do, which I know you guys have heard this for the past few months. You must listen

00:21:47.880 to, learn from, and then teach to others the idea of people of color who teach CRT. This is a way of

00:21:56.600 setting aside your, quote, privilege and learning from the oppressed. So under this point, it's important

00:22:04.920 to realize that according to CRT, you do not have a right as the so-called oppressor to argue,

00:22:10.960 to bring up statistics, to disagree, or to at all question the assertions, the word choice,

00:22:16.820 the tone, the behavior, or the narrative of an oppressed person, which would be in this worldview,

00:22:23.520 a black or brown activist or educator who is teaching you about how to be anti-racist. This is

00:22:29.280 what they would call policing, and you're not allowed to do that in CRT as a white person or

00:22:34.380 an oppressor. You don't have the right to police black or brown people in any way. This idea is 0.86

00:22:42.360 called another vocab term, standpoint epistemology, which we've talked about on this podcast before.

00:22:49.220 Epistemology is the study of knowledge. Standpoint epistemology asserts that knowledge comes from your

00:22:55.460 standpoint as part of an oppressed group. And like all of these ideas and terms, this is

00:23:00.420 a new academic term that is now making its way into the mainstream. So it means that people who

00:23:06.920 have privilege, especially white privilege, cannot arrive, according to standpoint epistemology,

00:23:13.440 which is a part of CRT, or you could say a CRT is a part of standpoint epistemology,

00:23:18.260 cannot arrive at true knowledge because their privilege has blinded them. And therefore,

00:23:23.800 they need to learn from the standpoint of an oppressed person, and in this case, a black or

00:23:29.960 brown person, to gain that special knowledge. So this is why a white person is not allowed to question 0.81

00:23:36.780 the logic or the morality of a so-called oppressed person, because according to CRT, being in a group

00:23:43.400 that is categorized as oppressed gives you access to special knowledge that so-called oppressors do not

00:23:49.280 have and is therefore inarguable. So this is why you see a lot of shutdown of debate when it comes to this

00:23:56.040 stuff, because they actually see debate as a sign, as the language of the oppressor. That's another phrase

00:24:05.620 that you will hear a lot if you have any pushback whatsoever. It is the language of the oppressor.

00:24:13.580 Another word for standpoint epistemology, what I just described, is Gnosticism. So Gnosticism means

00:24:22.660 special knowledge. So Vodibacham, which we've talked about, or who I've talked to on this podcast,

00:24:28.880 I've also talked about him a lot, calls this line of thought ethnic Gnosticism, the idea that your

00:24:34.780 ethnicity gives you a special knowledge that white people cannot have without a non-white person 1.00

00:24:40.680 teaching them. Gnosticism is a form of paganism. It's a form of a religion seeking special knowledge. 0.97

00:24:47.520 It's a new age idea, which is actually very connected to all of this. We've talked about

00:24:51.820 the new age a lot on this podcast. It is very intertwined. You often hear this Gnosticism

00:24:58.740 described through the phrase, there's another vocab term, lived experience. So lived experience

00:25:05.980 becomes the pinnacle of knowledge and of truth in the world of CRT, in that worldview. This means

00:25:13.820 you cannot argue with it. Statistics are irrelevant and even offensive, no matter what. Refutations

00:25:20.040 of a portrayal of history, like the 1619 Project, which has been debunked over and over again by

00:25:27.240 non-partisan, even left-leaning historians, or questioning any assertion of systemic racism,

00:25:33.980 or the quote legacy of slavery, it all shows your racism. If you push back against this in any way,

00:25:40.080 it shows your lack of empathy, your embodiment of oppression. So again, push back using any kind of

00:25:47.800 form of argumentation, no matter how accurate, will be deemed unempathetic. Empathy, another term

00:25:56.180 that has been more popularized than ever in these conversations, is the most important and really

00:26:02.040 the only characteristic that you as an oppressor must have. And really, what it means in these

00:26:07.960 contexts is agreement with the assertions being made by the CRT adherent. So it's not the definition

00:26:14.540 of sympathy and empathy that we know and that I believe is very good to listen to someone, to hear

00:26:22.140 their experience, and to say, wow, you know, I've never gone through that. That is really hard. I'm so

00:26:28.720 sorry that you went through that. That's not the form of empathy that we are seeing encouraged through

00:26:34.760 CRT. It is agreement to and submission to whatever the CRT adherent is saying. So as you've probably

00:26:43.880 heard, disagreement or defensiveness when it comes to these conversations is not just unempathetic,

00:26:50.540 we hear, but it's also a sign of white fragility. So you are fragile. You are actually proving your 0.99

00:26:58.260 racism if you at all try to refute what, for example, a Black Lives Matter activist asserts or

00:27:04.580 suggests or the conclusions that they come to based on their, quote, lived experiences. So really,

00:27:09.920 your only option as a white person is a so-called oppressor, as someone who CRT deems as privileged,

00:27:17.200 no matter what your life has looked like, is to listen, to learn, and not just be sympathetic,

00:27:23.720 but to agree and to submit and to jump on the train. That is the only way, according to this

00:27:29.560 worldview, that you can truly be anti-racist. Otherwise, you're a racist, no matter what you

00:27:34.220 think, do, or say, which means that you must also, number three, this is what you are to do to

00:27:41.260 decolonize and to deconstruct the hegemonic power structure that CRT says is white supremacy. You must

00:27:47.260 also, number three, advocate for the policies that activists tell you you must advocate for. So that's

00:27:54.600 defunding the police, reparations, the redistribution of wealth and capital, a powerful centralized

00:28:00.480 government that eliminates all disparities of outcome by any means necessary. Non-coincidentally,

00:28:06.840 they are always left-wing policy proposals. The solutions to these disparities or to real

00:28:14.880 discrimination is never, hey, you know, we need school choice or we need a stronger family unit.

00:28:21.040 We need free markets and economic opportunity. We need to get Planned Parenthood out of minority 1.00

00:28:25.960 neighborhoods where they prey upon these poor teen moms. Those are never the solutions. The answer is 1.00

00:28:31.820 always more governments because the government is the only institution with the power to redistribute

00:28:37.840 wealth, demand reparations, requiring things like, quote, anti-racist curriculum in public school,

00:28:43.940 take funding away from the police and reconfigure the justice system. All the things critical race 0.99

00:28:49.340 theorists say will close all the racial gaps. But it's important to realize that critical race

00:28:54.400 theorists don't care about the racial gaps in abortion, for example. They're not interested in the racial

00:28:59.380 gaps, for example, in fatherlessness. They're not interested in those gaps. They're not interested

00:29:05.300 in the homicide rate gap. They are only interested in the gaps that allow them to present solutions that

00:29:14.460 are always left-wing solutions. Their stated goal is to close those racial gaps. Really what it is,

00:29:21.800 is just to perpetuate and promote any left-wing policy. They believe the government is the only

00:29:31.080 institution that can accomplish the retribution and reparation that CRT adherents say the oppressed

00:29:39.240 deserve. And that's the only way to liberation and to happiness and equality in the future. This is what

00:29:45.300 liberal activists in this vein would call social justice, another term I know you guys have heard.

00:29:53.240 And social justice sounds innocuous. It sounds really good. It sounds godly even. But it is defined

00:29:59.280 in this way as an effort toward closing those gaps. Social justice is very different than what I'll at

00:30:06.780 least for now call traditional justice, the traditional definition of justice. It is not treating everyone

00:30:14.260 equally as we understand justice. It's not blind or making sure that everyone is treated fairly. It is

00:30:21.100 ensuring equal outcomes by whatever means necessary. That means in social justice, partiality, as we've

00:30:28.640 already noted, or even bias is required. You have to hold back those who are categorized as oppressors.

00:30:34.920 You have to push forward those that are categorized as the oppressed. Again, regardless in CRT of what your 0.74

00:30:43.680 life has actually been like and what obstacles or opportunities you have been given, regardless of

00:30:50.300 the choices that you've made, this is done by the policies that we've already listed, the redistribution

00:30:55.980 of power until everyone has the same outcomes in life. And I'll show you exactly what that looks like

00:31:02.680 in just one second. But we've got to take one more ad break.

00:31:14.480 Okay, so social justice. Social justice is collectivist in nature. It is not individual.

00:31:21.300 It views every group by their membership, not by who they are or what they've done individually. So you

00:31:27.620 see the connection between social justice and CRT. We see examples of this. Affirmative action is one.

00:31:34.440 We're seeing things like what's happening in California schools and some California schools

00:31:39.000 where they're getting rid of academic standards. This was also happening in New York so that some

00:31:44.960 groups will pass and graduate despite their effort and despite their actual performance. And social

00:31:51.900 justice, especially in CRT, would say that is something that you have to do to guarantee equal outcomes.

00:31:57.000 If you have to have a different hiring standards for different groups or discriminate against one

00:32:01.980 group in favor of another, like affirmative action does, like what California just tried to make

00:32:06.560 legal, then that's something that you have to do according to social justice ideology. If you have

00:32:11.040 to issue different sentences for people based on their skin color, you do it. If you have to take money

00:32:16.220 from one group and give it to another group, you do it. All in an effort for equal outcomes as Kamala

00:32:22.760 Harris, the assumed vice president elect, I'll say that, said in a video she put out a couple days

00:32:30.740 before the election that equity, that's another term that is used a lot right now, equity means

00:32:36.840 everyone ends up in the same place. In the world of CRT, equity does not mean everyone is treated equally

00:32:43.800 and fairly as we would think of equity, but that everyone has the same outcomes in life. If this

00:32:51.120 at all sounds familiar to you, so we started in the details and now we're kind of getting to

00:32:56.780 where this actually comes from and the foundation of this idea. If this at all sounds familiar to you,

00:33:07.000 that's because this is an old ideology that is being repackaged in a new racialized way. This

00:33:15.360 is Marxism now. People on the left are so tired of people on the right talking about Marxism.

00:33:20.820 Everyone says this is just a buzzword. Well, a buzzword is simply used without actually defining

00:33:27.040 what it is in order to shut down conversation. That is never, ever my intention. I actually think it

00:33:32.980 is my obligation. It is very important for me to be exact in the terms that I use and to define my

00:33:38.880 terms because actually CRT and social justice ideology, they're constantly using buzzwords

00:33:44.400 without defining the terms at all and they confuse people into agreeing with them. That's not my goal

00:33:49.260 at all. I want you to understand this completely. So when I say Marxism, I mean Marxism. I'm not just

00:33:55.540 using this as a buzzword. Karl Marx was the 19th century German philosopher who wrote the

00:34:00.240 Communist Manifesto. The Black Lives Matter leaders have openly called themselves Marxist. So I'm not

00:34:06.680 just assigning that description to them. They said that they are trained Marxists. And I really do

00:34:12.120 appreciate that honesty. For the most part, I think Black Lives Matter is pretty honest. I mean,

00:34:16.720 they had on their website that they want to disrupt the Western prescribed nuclear family,

00:34:21.360 as we've talked about on this podcast. A mom and a dad and a child is now Western prescribed. 0.92

00:34:26.920 That has been the family unit for the history of the world and most parts of the world. The Bible is

00:34:32.580 not a Western book. It is an Eastern book. And we see the creation of the nuclear family in the very

00:34:39.020 beginning. Whether or not you believe in the authority of the Bible, the Bible was written

00:34:43.000 thousands and thousands of years ago in the East. So this is not a modern concept of the nuclear family,

00:34:49.760 but they're very honest. Black Lives Matter and saying that they want to disrupt and dismantle it. 0.99

00:34:54.900 Of course, they took it off their website after several months of getting so much pushback and

00:34:59.200 it becoming this point of contention for a lot of people who wanted to support Black Lives Matter,

00:35:04.020 but couldn't because of that. Well, they took that down. They also, if you, and there's evidence of

00:35:10.140 this, we've got the receipts of them saying parents and mothers, but never referring to fathers. That is

00:35:15.480 because, again, they see the patriarchy and the nuclear family as a hegemonic power structure that must be

00:35:22.420 taken down. That's all part of Westernism and white supremacy. And this all goes back to Marxism. It

00:35:28.780 goes back to communism. Their entire movement and organization is built on critical race theory,

00:35:34.320 which is rooted in Marxism, which inspired communism, which is the ideology and way of

00:35:39.280 governance that forces people into equality of outcome. So again, Kamala was being very honest in

00:35:45.760 her video, which is frightening, but I appreciate. So communism, in case you don't understand,

00:35:51.820 and it's socialism too, as I'll argue. The state owns all industries. It owns housing. It owns

00:35:56.740 property. The means of production are nationalized. So they belong and are run by the government.

00:36:03.080 The state becomes your family. It becomes your moral arbiter, your caretaker, and it ensures that no

00:36:08.340 one has more than another person. And the communists, what they would call utopian vision,

00:36:13.120 there is no nuclear family. Everyone belongs to themselves. They belong to each other in communes

00:36:19.080 because there can't be any hierarchy or power structure that is outside of the state because

00:36:23.920 any hierarchy or power structure or self-reliance or reliance on one another that is outside of the

00:36:29.540 state threatens the power of the state. The power of the state is central and it's vital to the existence

00:36:35.860 of communism. So you see what is behind breaking all of these power structures down. And here's where we

00:36:42.920 start breaking down critical race theory and explaining why it is a fallacious, a destructive

00:36:47.880 and unbiblical worldview where we are seeing it's a scene at rear its ugly head most recently and how

00:36:56.460 we as parents, as Christians, as students, as educators, as employees, as employers can resist it

00:37:03.780 with everything that we have. So Marxism also categorizes people as the oppressed versus the

00:37:08.680 oppressor, except unlike in critical race theory, they do so along socioeconomic lines. And so

00:37:14.160 Karl Marx, he said the oppressed were the poor or the proletariat, the oppressors are the capitalists,

00:37:20.500 the rich people and the bourgeoisie. And what had to happen in order for the poor people to no longer

00:37:25.780 be poor and for there not to be this gap between the rich and the poor, the proletariat must have an 0.96

00:37:31.260 uprising and they must take over. It will be a violent uprising. They will forcefully redistribute the

00:37:36.760 property, the power, the capital, the money from the bourgeoisie to the poor. So everything has

00:37:42.020 everyone equally. And for a while, the proletariat class, according to Karl Marx in the Communist

00:37:46.280 Manifesto, must rule by force to ensure that everyone has everything the same. But then after a

00:37:52.260 while, he thought everyone would be so happy with having equally everything and sharing everything and

00:37:57.960 everything will be so good that you won't any longer have to have a government that everyone

00:38:01.920 will rule themselves. Obviously, this hasn't worked. And if you're thinking, well, that's

00:38:08.260 different than socialism. Well, communism, as Vladimir Lenin said, the leader of Soviet Russia

00:38:13.780 said, is the goal of socialism. So communism is the goal of socialism. So whether you're talking

00:38:18.500 about socialism or communism, you're talking about essentially the same kind of governance where

00:38:23.200 the state must own everything to ensure equal outcomes. Ayn Rand, author of Atlas Shrugged and

00:38:29.280 the Fountainhead, a critic of communism and socialism, said this, there is no difference

00:38:33.840 between communism and socialism except in the means of achieving the same ultimate end.

00:38:38.260 Communism proposes to enslavement by force, socialism by vote. It is merely the difference

00:38:42.760 between murder and suicide. The reason it doesn't work is because it goes against human nature. As I've

00:38:48.220 argued, leftism always does. Human beings were created to create, to be productive, to earn,

00:38:54.040 but not just for the state, to steal it and then to redistribute it as the state sees fit,

00:38:58.400 but to provide for yourself and to provide for your family from a biblical perspective.

00:39:03.540 We see that work existed and was created before the fall of man. It's not a product of sin. It's

00:39:09.260 not a necessary evil. It's something good and right that men and women were created to do. We have every

00:39:14.940 reason to think that we will work in heaven, that we will be working and productive in the new heaven

00:39:19.200 and the new earth. Genesis 2.15 says that the man was put in the garden to work and to keep it before

00:39:24.580 the fall. Ephesians 4.28 says, let the thief no longer steal, but rather let him labor doing honest

00:39:30.960 work with his own hands so that he may have something to share with anyone in need. So right

00:39:36.220 there in Ephesians 4, we see two indictments of socialism and communism, which again is the

00:39:41.220 ideology under CRT, Black Lives Matter, social justice, so much of what we're seeing right now.

00:39:47.000 Two indictments. Do not steal. Do not steal. And that is essentially what the government is doing

00:39:54.100 in a socialist and communist country and a commandment to do labor so that you will be

00:39:59.820 able to directly share with anyone in need. You work, you earn, you give to others directly and

00:40:06.120 voluntarily. Two of the 10 commandments speak against communism and socialism. Do not steal and do

00:40:13.140 not covet. God cares about private property so much that he issues two of 10 commandments protecting

00:40:20.460 it, not just from theft, but also from someone even wanting your stuff. So that shows you that

00:40:25.440 God honors personal property. He honors private property, that what I have is not yours and vice

00:40:30.520 versa, and that it's even a sin for me to want what is yours. If you have more property and more capital

00:40:36.760 than I do, I am not entitled to it according to God. So God does not say that you have a right to

00:40:45.260 other people's stuff or that it is the state's job to confiscate those things and to redistribute it to

00:40:50.520 other people. That is theft, that is covetousness, which God is very clear is a sin in his sight. God

00:40:57.180 does call us to care for the poor. He does call us to care for the least of these. The early church

00:41:01.520 gave everything they had to one another. The key descriptor there is that it was voluntary. It was

00:41:07.500 out of the power of the Holy Spirit and the goodness of their heart. God is very clear that

00:41:11.780 giving under compulsion and under force, which is what socialism and communism does, is not godly.

00:41:17.780 It doesn't count when it comes to God honoring generosity. Second Corinthians 9 7, each one must give

00:41:23.880 as he has decided in his heart, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver.

00:41:30.480 So giving your money to the government because you are required to or else you'll go to jail

00:41:35.200 is compulsion. That is not cheerful, voluntary giving. That is not God's definition of compassion

00:41:41.220 or generosity. As I often say, you know, we hear from the Democratic Party, from liberals that

00:41:46.760 we care for people after they're born because of all of these liberal policies. Look, you are not

00:41:52.580 more compassionate for voting for the politician who promises to take money from people richer than you

00:41:59.200 and give it to people poorer than you than the person who votes for small government, low taxes,

00:42:05.800 and takes it upon themselves to cheerfully and voluntarily give what they have to other people

00:42:10.620 because that is following God's commands. Now, the Bible does say that we are to pay taxes and that

00:42:16.640 the government has the authority to demand those taxes. Romans 13 7, pay to all what is owed to them,

00:42:22.800 taxes to whom taxes are owed, revenue to whom revenue is owed, respect to whom respect is owed,

00:42:28.280 honor to whom honor is owed. So it is not wrong for the government to use taxes and to use it as

00:42:33.880 they see fit. Jesus says, render to Caesar what is Caesar's. And that is what Christians are called to 0.99

00:42:43.200 do. But we also see Jesus condemning over taxation and the exploitation of people by tax collectors

00:42:49.740 collecting too much in taxes. But in socialism and communism, where the state controls your money,

00:42:55.940 your property and promises to distribute these things in the name of compassion, that is not allowing

00:43:06.100 that is not allowing the God honoring generosity that we are called to. Communism and socialism,

00:43:13.520 collectivism also misunderstands power. When you give more power and you give more money to the

00:43:19.060 government, they are not benevolent. It's never happened in the history of the world. Power corrupts,

00:43:23.800 absolute power corrupts, absolutely. Absolutely. That is how all of these socialist regimes in places

00:43:28.820 like Cuba, in Cambodia, in China, in Soviet Russia, in Eastern Germany, that's how they took power.

00:43:36.100 By baiting you with social justice and saying, you need to redistribute your privilege and your power

00:43:42.120 to us so we can redistribute it to the poor. That is compassionate. That is right. In the name of

00:43:46.760 liberation and justice and equality and education and prosperity, we, your benevolent government,

00:43:52.720 just need more of your money. We need more of your power. We'll redistribute it and then everyone

00:43:57.380 will finally be happy and equal. And if you don't do that, it's because you're rich and you're greedy

00:44:01.680 and you're privileged and you're racist. That's how this has always gone. This is how left-wing 0.67

00:44:06.280 revolutions more or less have always gone. Different terminology for different times and

00:44:10.400 countries. But that is how people are always baited into it. But you only vote for socialism and

00:44:17.340 communism once. And so people don't understand that CRT and so much of the terminology that we just use

00:44:23.820 is the gateway into socialism and communism. Because again, it's not a coincidence that all of the

00:44:29.480 solutions that critical race theorists give for closing those racial gaps and obliterating the

00:44:34.940 hegemonic power structures are left-wing solutions. They're never, hey, personal responsibility. Let's

00:44:41.520 teach people about finances. Let's do school choice. Let's be pro-life. It's never that. It is

00:44:47.380 always more government, more centralized power, less freedom. This is why it never works. Because

00:44:53.960 collectivism, socialism, and communism go against human nature. It misunderstands how power works.

00:44:58.940 And what happens because of that is always violence. One, because left-wing revolutions play

00:45:05.720 upon people's real desperation. So it uses a crisis, a political crisis, a socioeconomic crisis,

00:45:12.900 or an economic crisis, or a public health crisis. And it uses the desperation in that crisis to create

00:45:19.220 resentment in the masses to then revolutionize the system to create the world that they want to

00:45:25.560 create. That requires destruction. That requires violence. That requires looting. It requires arson.

00:45:32.660 It requires creating chaos and creating a place of desperation for people. And so they will say,

00:45:38.420 please, someone, government, take over. Make things fair and right and normal again. And you can see the

00:45:44.380 reflections of that going on right now in our streets. And unfortunately, a lot of people are playing

00:45:50.440 along, not because they want to openly advocate for violence, but because they have bought into social

00:45:54.900 justice and CRT, and they don't know what it's connected to or where it leads to. They are doing

00:46:02.360 so by, for example, while they're perpetuating the ideology of critical race theory, they are ascribing

00:46:07.940 to value people, to people based on race. They are ascribing collective guilt to people who are white,

00:46:13.180 for example, assigning oppression to people who are not, again, not as individuals,

00:46:17.280 but as members of groups, elevating lived experience above objective truth, adding empathy

00:46:22.620 onto the list of the fruits of the spirit, using phrases like white privilege, going along with the

00:46:28.100 rewriting of history, like in the 1619 project, going along with the redefining of the word justice,

00:46:33.740 going along with the corporate culpability based on ancestry and skin color by the reapplication of Bible 0.83

00:46:40.260 verses like Micah 6, 8 to mean something that they do not mean. We're seeing this in the church.

00:46:47.280 We're seeing this in corporate America. We're seeing this in the Democratic Party and even

00:46:50.960 some Republicans. We're seeing this in Hollywood. We're seeing this on social media. We're seeing

00:46:55.120 this in the mainstream media. And in all of that, Christians who are latching onto this, not only 0.84

00:47:02.060 are we refusing to critically think and to ask the simple question, what is actually true?

00:47:07.560 What is actually right and good according to God's word? Remember, critical thinking is the antidote

00:47:13.760 to critical theory. But we're also missing the gospel as Christians. We are missing the gospel,

00:47:19.060 which means all of this doesn't just have very real political consequences and therefore consequences

00:47:24.000 for people's lives that end in suffering and destruction for the very people that these

00:47:28.240 revolutions start out wanting to save and help. It has eternal implications, spiritual implications.

00:47:34.120 We are missing the one thing that actually reconciles and brings peace. We're almost done. Let me read

00:47:39.760 this passage and then tell us some steps that we need to take in resisting all of this.

00:47:45.640 Ephesians 2, 13 through 19, this is talking about Jews and Gentiles. But if Jews and Gentiles can be 1.00

00:47:50.760 reconciled through Christ, then any two groups can. Talking about abolishing the law of commandments

00:47:56.760 expressed in ordinances that Jesus might create in himself one new man in place of the two,

00:48:02.140 so making peace between Jews and Gentiles and might reconcile us both to God in one body through the

00:48:07.920 cross, thereby killing the hostility. And Jesus came and preached peace to those of you who are far

00:48:13.160 off and peace to those who are near. For through him, we both have access in one spirit to the Father.

00:48:18.920 So then you are no longer strangers and aliens, but you are fellow citizens with the saints and members

00:48:23.660 of the household of God. That's the only hope of reconciliation that we've got. And if we are

00:48:29.540 preaching anything else from our pulpits, we are preaching destruction and division.

00:48:32.980 We are aiding and abetting a godless ideology that also and always leads to violence. It leads to

00:48:41.580 suffering. Do we right wrongs? Yes. Do we correct oppression? Yes. Do we push for justice? Yes.

00:48:47.940 But these things have to be rooted in fact. They have to be rooted in truth. They have to be rooted

00:48:52.380 in God's definition of justice, which, as you guys know who have listened to this podcast so many times,

00:48:58.440 God's justice is what? It's direct. It's truthful. It's proportionate and impartial. Whether we are

00:49:06.320 talking about punishment for the wrongdoer or restitution for the victim, those are the four

00:49:10.600 qualifications, according to God's word, which we have cited so many times throughout scripture on

00:49:14.620 this podcast, that's what justice is. Social justice is the opposite in the world of CRT. It's indirect.

00:49:21.360 It's collectivist. It's untruthful. It's based on perception rather than evidence and lived experience.

00:49:27.000 It's disproportionate. And so it's punishing people for something that they did not individually do.

00:49:32.000 And it is partial. It shows bias towards people despite their culpability. We have to refuse those

00:49:39.140 things. That means we have to refuse to resist all of this craziness. We have to refuse the redefinition

00:49:44.000 of words. We have to refuse the redefinition of justice. We have to refuse the redefinition of right

00:49:51.240 and wrong that is being attempted. We have to refuse the rewriting of history. We have to question

00:49:56.360 phrases like the legacy of slavery, which Thomas Sowell breaks down so well in all of his books,

00:50:01.080 like Quest for Cosmic Justice. We have to refuse the rewriting of history through narratives like

00:50:07.080 the 1619 Project, which again, I'll just link some of the fact checks on that. Refuse to believe

00:50:12.860 everything that you see and hear. Refuse to follow people that sound good, but something in you is

00:50:17.500 telling you that this is not biblical. Refuse to allow the world, those who do not know God, 1.00

00:50:22.600 who do not follow Christ to tell you what justice looks like, what the dignity of life and the

00:50:27.380 sanctity of life looks like. God tells you what those things are and you are his friend and you

00:50:32.280 have access to his wisdom. Refuse to take blame for that which you did not do. Refuse immediate

00:50:37.520 emotional reactions to news stories, even though the world is telling you that you must react in a

00:50:42.600 certain way and repeat certain phrases in order to be virtuous. Refuse to judge people, for better or for

00:50:47.700 worse, by their skin color. We're hearing a lot about how terrible white women are because 57% of 1.00

00:50:53.480 them voted for Donald Trump even more than last time. And Kamala Harris said black women are the 1.00

00:50:58.000 backbone of democracy. That sounds all well and good coming from Kamala Harris, but what we're actually

00:51:04.100 seeing is a pitting against black women and white women. Black women as the backbone of democracy, 1.00

00:51:09.920 simply because they tend to vote for Democrats. And as if that is what democracy means,

00:51:17.280 just voting liberally and white women are apparently enemies of the state because the majority of us 1.00

00:51:23.220 voted for Donald Trump. This kind of identity politics, this kind of critical race theory

00:51:28.680 is what divides. It sounds innocent enough. It sounds positive enough, but really it is describing guilt

00:51:35.020 and innocence, virtue and immorality, according to people's skin color and essentially, more importantly,

00:51:41.660 again, their ideology. We have to refuse to hold different standards or rules for different people based on

00:51:47.080 their skin color before you repeat any new mantra, any phrase, any words you hear being used by the

00:51:52.800 mainstream. We have to refuse to latch onto it. Stop, think, break it down. Go to God's word. Ask the

00:51:58.940 question, is this true? Is this what God says is good and right? Write your state representative and go to

00:52:06.700 your local school board. Talk to school administrators if you are seeing this stuff being taught in your

00:52:11.780 schools. Take your kids if there's any possibly way you can. Take your kids at a public school or any

00:52:18.380 private school or charter school that's teaching this stuff. I've been talking a lot about this on my

00:52:23.020 podcast and I'll talk more about it soon. I've talked a lot about it on Instagram of a highlight

00:52:27.500 bubble about public education and the importance of being in control and in charge of your child's

00:52:33.180 education for their well-being, not just academically, but also morally and biblically as well. So those are the

00:52:40.200 things that we have to do. We have to resist and refuse. We have to resist and refuse that which is

00:52:46.040 not true, that which God says is not good, that which always inevitably leads to destruction.

00:52:52.680 I could go on and on about this and I kind of had to rush towards the end because I got to get out of

00:52:56.780 here, but I hope that at least gives you a foundation. If you have questions, I want to clarify for you.

00:53:02.440 So send me your questions on Instagram, email, whatever, and I will try to answer them in a future

00:53:08.540 episode. But I hope this has given you an understanding of what this ideology is, what it leads to, and

00:53:13.560 where you can find it in the real world and how you can resist it. Okay, that is all for today. I will see

00:53:19.540 you guys back here on Wednesday.

Relatable with Allie Beth Stuckey - November 16, 2020

Ep 327 ｜ The Truth About Critical Race Theory

Episode Stats

Summary

Transcript