Relatable with Allie Beth Stuckey - October 17, 2022


Ep 692 | Sorry, Ulta: Men Can’t Be Moms


Episode Stats

Length

46 minutes

Words per Minute

173.03697

Word Count

7,995

Sentence Count

546

Misogynist Sentences

20

Hate Speech Sentences

27


Summary

On today's episode of Relatable, Allie talks about the heated debate between her and Raphael Warnock about what it means to be a woman in the 21st century. Plus, she gives her thoughts on the heat in the South, and whether or not you should wear sweaters in the summer.


Transcript

00:00:00.000 Ulta gives two grown men the opportunity to tell women what it means to be a girl.
00:00:06.540 I have a lot to say about that.
00:00:09.740 And we'll look at a couple highlights from the Herschel Walker-Raphael Warnock debate
00:00:13.540 that had people talking last week.
00:00:15.960 This episode is brought to you by our friends at Good Ranchers.
00:00:18.820 Go to GoodRanchers.com slash Allie.
00:00:20.400 That's GoodRanchers.com slash Allie.
00:00:30.000 Hey guys, welcome to Relatable.
00:00:33.540 Happy Monday.
00:00:34.820 Hope everyone had a wonderful weekend.
00:00:37.520 It is kind of starting to feel a little bit like a whisper of fall where I am,
00:00:44.540 which means it's dropped below temporarily, 80 degrees.
00:00:48.400 I saw someone that I follow posting a video of their backyard in Minnesota the other day,
00:00:54.360 and you had like six inches of snow.
00:00:57.160 And this person talked about starting Christmas music.
00:00:59.320 I don't even know what that means.
00:01:02.620 My brain doesn't have the capacity to comprehend it.
00:01:05.340 I've realized that in certain parts of the South that remain hot,
00:01:09.660 we pretty much have two seasons, maybe three.
00:01:12.620 It's tolerable heat and intolerable heat.
00:01:15.400 Right now we're intolerable heat stage.
00:01:17.740 And then intolerable heat is like June through, I don't know, October 5th.
00:01:22.880 And then we have like three days of unbearable cold where no one can go outside or function
00:01:28.020 and maybe all of your power goes out.
00:01:29.920 But I realized in our two dominant seasons, tolerant or tolerable heat and intolerable heat,
00:01:37.940 when it comes fall, you really just have to think of the clothes that you're going to wear as a costume.
00:01:43.940 You don't wear the sweaters for any practical reason.
00:01:47.700 There is no pragmatic purpose to your scarf or to your boots.
00:01:51.620 You would be totally comfortable, even more comfortable, wearing a tank top and shorts and flip flops.
00:01:58.240 But because you want to transition into a new season, I think that's part of human nature.
00:02:03.140 You just have to decide, OK, I am going to be sweaty outside all day, but I'm going to wear my autumn costume.
00:02:11.300 You have to think about your jackets and your vests and your sweaters and your scarves and your boots and your jeans and your corduroy,
00:02:19.200 all more like a costume rather than clothes that you have to wear for any particular purpose.
00:02:24.300 And you just can't judge people.
00:02:25.880 You can't judge people when it's 75 degrees outside and they're wearing a cowl neck.
00:02:30.780 You just have to be like, yeah, I get it. That is the fall costume.
00:02:33.840 And we're all just pretending here in the South that it's autumn.
00:02:37.260 So that's what stage that we're at now.
00:02:39.000 We're in the pretending that it is cold enough to have to wear a jacket.
00:02:42.440 I'm wearing a sweater and boots right now because I am embracing my fall costume.
00:02:47.740 Anyway, OK, lots to get to today.
00:02:49.680 One thing I did want to mention last Thursday's episode where we talked about Pitbull, not Mr. Worldwide,
00:02:55.680 the other kind of Pitbull, the dog kind of Pitbull.
00:02:58.420 I knew it was going to be controversial and I addressed literally every single argument for Pitbulls that I've heard.
00:03:06.680 And still, that has not stopped people from commenting the very same arguments that I refuted.
00:03:14.200 And not in a refutation of my refutation of their original argument,
00:03:18.540 but actually saying the original argument like I've never heard it before.
00:03:21.300 Like people commenting, oh, this is the same thing as banning guns or while pitties used to be nanny dogs or chihuahuas also bite.
00:03:30.560 I addressed all of those what I consider to be very silly and illogical arguments in my episode.
00:03:36.500 And still people actually they refuse.
00:03:38.640 This is what bothers me about anything.
00:03:40.700 And I try not to ever do this.
00:03:43.880 I really don't comment on other people's like videos or things at all.
00:03:47.800 But if I did or if I sent someone a message of disagreement, like I really try to take their argument
00:03:54.840 and respond to what was actually said, not just say something that I want to say or that I think that they need to hear.
00:04:00.880 That is like beyond annoying, honestly.
00:04:04.500 But I do appreciate, well, there's tons of messages and comments of support and agreement.
00:04:09.260 And that's great.
00:04:09.740 But I also appreciate those of you who disagree and you're like, hey, I disagree.
00:04:13.460 You like your pit bulls.
00:04:14.820 You like pit bulls in general.
00:04:16.680 That's fine.
00:04:17.560 I think you're wrong.
00:04:19.200 You think I'm wrong.
00:04:20.480 But we realize that we're talking about a dog.
00:04:23.480 And while I do think it's an important subject, I do.
00:04:26.080 And I think it's an important disagreement.
00:04:27.920 This is not like a salvation issue.
00:04:30.380 And now some of you, now I say some of you, you're not probably listening to this anymore.
00:04:35.260 Some people take this to the level of it literally almost being to them a salvation issue.
00:04:42.980 Like I got a message this morning from someone that I had never responded to before, but I
00:04:48.200 was able to scroll up and see her previous messages.
00:04:50.820 And she had sent me messages of agreement of saying that, you know, she supports my book.
00:04:55.420 Great.
00:04:55.700 And then she literally devolves into saying that I can't support you anymore.
00:05:02.060 I used to be a fan of you.
00:05:03.720 I can't believe that you're saying this about pit bulls.
00:05:06.500 Lady, this is a dog.
00:05:08.040 This is a dog.
00:05:08.900 And I was talking about several stories in which elderly people or toddlers were mauled.
00:05:13.660 And people take their love and adoration of pit bulls to a level of almost, I'm not saying
00:05:19.220 everyone, I'm not saying everyone.
00:05:21.900 But some people in my comments have taken their love of pit bulls to a level of idolatry,
00:05:26.360 to a level of worship so that you cannot tolerate people blaspheming what you have made a little
00:05:35.480 g-god.
00:05:36.260 Honestly, like that is the level of like apologetics that I see in some of the comments.
00:05:44.680 It's, I mean, it is beyond.
00:05:48.020 It is beyond to me.
00:05:49.640 I understand if you love pit bulls, you have a pit bull.
00:05:53.260 Maybe your family has always had pit bulls.
00:05:55.200 You have never had to bear the brunt of pit bull aggression.
00:05:58.480 Your child has never been mauled.
00:06:00.640 Your pet has never been killed by a pit bull.
00:06:03.880 You believe that it's only the owner.
00:06:06.400 This is the only breed ever, I guess, that doesn't have a nature.
00:06:11.280 It's the only breed ever that is completely dependent on the owner and training for behavior.
00:06:16.680 That's wild to me.
00:06:17.380 It doesn't make sense, but maybe you're someone who believes that.
00:06:19.400 That's fine.
00:06:20.480 I don't think that you're not a Christian or not a good person or that we can't be friends.
00:06:25.980 I actually have friends who have a very gentle pit bull who has never, as far as I know,
00:06:31.160 ever shown any aggression.
00:06:32.920 And I love these people.
00:06:34.120 They're awesome people.
00:06:36.160 Obviously disagree on the pit bull issue.
00:06:38.100 But to those of you who take this criticism of pit bull to the level of like not being able
00:06:44.600 to function anymore, like not being able to have a polite or rational conversation, there is,
00:06:51.080 and I say this in love, like there is something that you need to dig into there.
00:06:55.160 There is.
00:06:55.960 I'm not saying that you have to change your mind on pit bulls, but if you devolve into
00:07:00.480 almost a temper, a toddler like temper tantrum, when someone criticizes pit bulls, then you
00:07:07.180 need to just dig down deep and ask yourself why that is, like why they are on such a pedestal.
00:07:15.940 Okay?
00:07:16.460 They're animals.
00:07:17.860 They're animals.
00:07:18.920 And I'm talking about an animal versus the safety of image bearers.
00:07:23.860 And I am going to side on that side.
00:07:27.280 Again, maybe you disagree with a variety of arguments within that argument, and that is
00:07:32.600 fine.
00:07:32.760 And I'm not saying that you don't care about human beings too, but let's cool our jets.
00:07:38.920 Let's cool our jets.
00:07:40.620 The fact that people like so much rage is inspired around pit bulls actually makes me like dig
00:07:46.760 my fall boot heels in even more because I'm like, okay, there is like, there's something
00:07:53.420 weird going on about the just, if I am able to say rabid, defense of pit bulls.
00:08:00.760 If you don't know what I'm talking about, go back and listen to Thursday's episode.
00:08:03.740 We also talked about a lot of other things too, then maybe you'll get something out of
00:08:06.400 it.
00:08:07.100 And I hope that we can be friends.
00:08:09.620 I do.
00:08:09.920 I really do.
00:08:10.500 I hope that we can be friends disagreeing on, disagreeing on pit bulls.
00:08:15.400 This is not a salvation issue.
00:08:16.800 It's not a secondary theological issue.
00:08:18.700 It's not a tertiary theological issue.
00:08:21.920 It doesn't even come on like four or five or six or seven on the list.
00:08:24.800 Maybe like number 10.
00:08:26.200 But we've got a lot of disagreements before that, that we can have and still be friends,
00:08:30.480 right?
00:08:32.160 All right.
00:08:33.040 Thanks for listening to that little rant.
00:08:35.400 All right.
00:08:35.640 I want to get into this Dylan Mulvaney story.
00:08:38.320 All right.
00:08:49.440 So we are going to watch a little clip from this interview that was platformed by Ulta Beauty.
00:08:58.500 They have a podcast that's called The Beauty Of.
00:09:01.740 The premise of this podcast is apparently to feature conversations that widen the lens
00:09:06.320 surrounding traditional beauty standards.
00:09:09.220 It's hosted by a person named David Lopez.
00:09:12.440 This person says that he is quote unquote gender fluid, wears a lot of makeup and dresses
00:09:20.020 and things like that.
00:09:21.220 Also has a beard.
00:09:22.540 The first episode of this podcast is called The Beauty Of Fatness, features like an obese
00:09:28.620 woman talking about like taking her body back from a fat phobic society.
00:09:33.060 We have talked about the kind of the goods and the bads of the so-called body positivity
00:09:40.020 movement in the past.
00:09:41.120 If I can find that previous episode, I will try to link it in the description here.
00:09:45.340 And in this particular episode, they talked about this person, David Lopez, and this person
00:09:51.560 named Dylan Mulvaney about quote unquote the beauty of girlhood.
00:09:56.680 Now Dylan Mulvaney is a very, very popular TikToker with tens of millions of followers and also
00:10:03.680 has a very large platform on Instagram.
00:10:06.620 And honestly, it's not hard for me to see why.
00:10:09.780 And before I get into describing all of this, let me just say, in case you're new here, I
00:10:15.400 do not use pronouns that are mismatched with someone's biology because I do not believe that
00:10:22.520 biology is bigotry and because, as I will explain in detail in just a minute, I believe that
00:10:29.020 God made us male and female in his image.
00:10:32.460 It is not okay for me.
00:10:35.660 It is not acceptable for me to lie and to perpetuate a delusion that I think is not just harmful
00:10:42.140 to the individual, but is harmful to society as a whole.
00:10:45.200 And so I will not use she, her for someone that I know is a man.
00:10:52.240 And Dylan Mulvaney, while he is trying to be not just a woman, but says that he is trying
00:10:56.640 to be a girl, is a man.
00:10:59.100 And I think it is good to be a man.
00:11:00.820 I think God made our bodies purposely.
00:11:04.220 And it's good to be a man.
00:11:05.640 It's good to be a woman.
00:11:06.740 And I don't think that that is bigoted at all.
00:11:08.780 And I'm going to affirm the identity that God gave him when he created Dylan inside the
00:11:14.300 womb.
00:11:14.440 So I will be saying he.
00:11:16.560 Now, I understand why Dylan is popular, as I was saying.
00:11:21.340 He is very entertaining.
00:11:23.100 He comes across as very likable.
00:11:25.460 His background, I believe, is in acting and maybe singing.
00:11:28.940 I think that he was in musical theater.
00:11:31.920 And that very much comes across.
00:11:34.300 So I totally understand why he is so popular.
00:11:38.640 But I also, as you can imagine, understand why he has inspired so much controversy.
00:11:43.120 And it's because of how he presents not just himself, but girlhood.
00:11:50.140 So before I play you a clip of this interview that we are going to then discuss and I'll
00:11:56.640 respond to, let me play you just a little montage, in case you don't know who Dylan Mulvaney
00:12:01.040 is, of his what he calls journey to girlhood.
00:12:08.000 Day one of being a girl and I have already cried three times.
00:12:11.800 Day two of being a woman.
00:12:13.100 I am at the Rose Bowl flea market with my best friend and we are wearing matching dresses.
00:12:17.760 Day three of being a girl and I've already become a bimbo.
00:12:20.560 Day seven of being a girl.
00:12:22.160 And oh my gosh, one whole week of being publicly a woman.
00:12:25.960 Day 10 of girlhood.
00:12:26.960 And today I am singing.
00:12:28.940 I need to pick out a few female songs.
00:12:30.640 So let's see which ones we like.
00:12:32.020 13 of being a girl and it feels like Christmas morning.
00:12:34.920 I am finally going to get laser hair removal on my face and my body.
00:12:39.140 So in March of this year, he announced his transgender identity.
00:12:43.300 He started to take talk series called Days of Girlhood and he documents each day of his
00:12:49.160 transition.
00:12:49.640 Now, maybe you watch that or listen to that and you're like, I thought you said that this
00:12:53.760 was like entertaining and you don't see how this is likable at all.
00:12:56.820 I do understand why to a large group of people.
00:13:01.400 This is something that they want to watch.
00:13:05.080 He said that he is becoming a woman, but he still wants to.
00:13:09.740 This is a grown man, adult man.
00:13:11.240 He says that he wants to call himself a girl.
00:13:17.160 And so that is who this person is.
00:13:19.740 That is how he has amassed so many followers.
00:13:22.500 And I'll also talk about all of that whole branding of himself and of what he thinks
00:13:30.280 is femininity after I play this clip.
00:13:35.440 This is from that Ulta Beauty interview.
00:13:39.780 Now I know I can find love.
00:13:41.480 I know I can still be a performer.
00:13:43.600 I know that I can have a family.
00:13:44.920 I want to be a mom one day and I absolutely can.
00:13:47.640 And that's why the narrative still has a long way to go.
00:13:50.420 Because when I was grieving boy Dylan, I didn't know those things were even accessible to me.
00:13:56.300 So before I respond to that, what I think, and this is like the nicest way I can say it
00:14:02.000 is like ridiculous statement.
00:14:03.780 Before I respond to that ridiculous statement about wanting to become a mom, I also like another
00:14:08.400 aspect of this person that I understand people are attracted to is that he comes across as very
00:14:16.280 vulnerable and very gentle and also very honest.
00:14:22.420 Like he will talk about like the different kinds of like procedures that he wants and like hormones
00:14:28.300 and things like that.
00:14:31.060 And so I think people like what seems like a level of transparency and vulnerability.
00:14:36.220 People like that on social media in general.
00:14:39.000 And you can kind of see that come across there.
00:14:42.020 However, people were not deceived by or they weren't taken in by his delivery.
00:14:50.880 It didn't soften the blow at all.
00:14:52.920 On Twitter, Ulta got absolutely dragged and lambasted for this because this is two grown men
00:15:01.900 telling an audience of women what it is like to be a girl.
00:15:07.800 And over the next couple of days, you are going to see a lot in conservative media of
00:15:12.720 people mocking this.
00:15:14.940 And I think that that is justified.
00:15:18.180 I think that mocking false and harmful ideas is actually a healthy and necessary way to make
00:15:24.640 an important and truthful point.
00:15:25.980 That's why I believe in satire.
00:15:27.740 That's why I do it when I can, because it makes a point in an ironic way, which is sometimes
00:15:33.500 even more effective than literalism.
00:15:36.180 And so there's going to be a lot of mockery in the next few days.
00:15:40.080 But I do on this episode want to take the time to dig a little bit deeper on this.
00:15:46.100 A lot of women are saying that this is really sad for women because it erases women.
00:15:51.760 It belittles motherhood.
00:15:53.480 It's insulting to moms.
00:15:55.300 And I understand that because we are getting it from both sides as women when it comes to
00:16:00.500 this transgender movement, if you will.
00:16:02.600 For the women who claim to be men, we all have to be birthing people and menstruators
00:16:09.020 so as not to offend them.
00:16:10.360 And then for the men who claim to be women, we have to allow them into our private spaces
00:16:14.520 on our sports teams and share titles and characteristics with them like motherhood that have always been
00:16:20.240 unique to the female experience.
00:16:22.640 Personally, though, while I understand all of that, and while I do think that is absolutely
00:16:29.780 a form of erasure, and that is something to be angry about and to even mourn over, I do
00:16:37.320 not personally feel like he is taking away from my femininity.
00:16:42.480 Like I don't feel lesser at all.
00:16:46.340 I don't feel like he is diminishing my experience as a mother.
00:16:50.340 And this is what I mean by that.
00:16:52.040 When I see a clip like that, I feel more gratitude than ever for who I am.
00:16:58.480 When I read a lot of the posts that circulate on Twitter from Reddit from the men who are
00:17:03.400 trying to be women who are like really, really wanting to be perceived as a woman and have
00:17:08.760 female experiences, and they have to like jump through all of these hoops just to pretend
00:17:12.760 to be a woman, to try to get a feeling that they're a woman, to try to convince other
00:17:17.380 people that they're a woman, like I am just so grateful for the thing that maybe, I mean,
00:17:24.480 I've always been happy about, but maybe took for granted before that I am a woman.
00:17:29.280 I don't have to try.
00:17:30.720 Like I actually am a mom.
00:17:32.580 And the experience I have is both of those things is real.
00:17:36.240 I don't have to fake it.
00:17:37.300 I don't have to have procedures to be a woman.
00:17:39.240 I don't have to change anything.
00:17:40.520 I don't have to declare my pronouns.
00:17:42.020 God made me one.
00:17:43.460 He made me a girl in my mother's womb, who is also a woman in her mother's womb, and
00:17:51.820 on and on and on.
00:17:52.980 And God made me a mom.
00:17:54.720 That's incredible.
00:17:56.000 Wow.
00:17:56.340 I realize honestly more than ever because of all of this, how amazing it is and how thankful
00:18:01.920 I am for that.
00:18:02.760 I am so grateful for and so confident in my femininity that a man playing a caricature
00:18:09.420 of a girl or a woman truly cannot do anything to diminish that.
00:18:15.140 So praise God.
00:18:16.200 And you should be praising God too.
00:18:18.200 Whether you're a man or a woman, you should be praising God that you're a man because it's
00:18:21.480 good to be a man.
00:18:22.820 I know that in a lot of ways society tells you that it's not and tries to hinder and
00:18:27.760 inhibit true healthy masculinity in a lot of ways, but it's good to be a man.
00:18:32.760 It's good to be a woman.
00:18:34.280 It's good to be feminine.
00:18:35.440 It's good to be able to do the things that only our bodies can.
00:18:40.260 That is what we should, by the way, as parents, be telling our kids, it is good to be a boy.
00:18:46.440 It is good to be a girl.
00:18:47.700 Your body is good.
00:18:48.960 Your characteristics are good.
00:18:51.140 We should be trying to cultivate this kind of gratitude and confidence in our kids from
00:18:56.300 the youngest age that we possibly can.
00:18:59.320 And so I don't actually feel when I watch this.
00:19:02.640 I know a lot of people feel like something's being robbed from them, and I get that.
00:19:06.720 That is, I think, a valid concern and a valid feeling because that is, I don't think that
00:19:11.000 that is this person's desire.
00:19:13.760 Like, I don't think that that is his goal in this, but I understand how people feel like
00:19:17.400 that is an indirect consequence of something like this and a company like Ulta promoting
00:19:23.620 something like this.
00:19:24.540 That's not personally how I feel because this person, what he is trying to represent as much
00:19:30.460 as he calls himself a girl, he represents a caricature of a woman.
00:19:35.480 This is a grown man playing a character of a pre-teen girl.
00:19:41.080 He calls himself a girl.
00:19:43.260 And that is not only disturbing.
00:19:45.620 It is insulting in a lot of ways to actual women.
00:19:49.460 This person, in all of his videos, as you saw a little bit a few minutes ago, reduces
00:19:53.740 femininity down to silliness and flamboyance and klutziness.
00:19:58.780 And I don't know a single woman or even a single girl who acts like that.
00:20:04.100 So this is overcompensation.
00:20:05.760 It is a man trying to figure out what femininity is and being unable to successfully do so.
00:20:11.160 And I understand, again, why he has so many followers.
00:20:15.160 I understand why this has some entertainment value.
00:20:18.000 And I understand, actually, you might be so confused about this, but I understand why
00:20:23.740 many women like him.
00:20:25.620 Women are attracted platonically to non-threatening males.
00:20:29.740 I haven't fully unpacked why, but since the dawn of the gay best friend, or maybe even the
00:20:35.500 dawn of time since it was possible for girls to friend zone a guy, women have liked being
00:20:40.800 around masculine energy that is not a threat to their safety.
00:20:46.180 And I might be controversial to say, I think it's absolutely true.
00:20:49.120 I'm sure there's some kind of study or some kind of literature on that out there.
00:20:52.440 That's just my personal observation.
00:20:54.620 And this person, I think, has mistaken that support for affirmation of his stated identity
00:21:03.920 or validation of his stated identity, solidification of it.
00:21:10.860 Like, he has mistaken all of the compliments and all of the following as authenticating who
00:21:18.160 he says that he is.
00:21:19.280 He said recently, he said, the world sees me as a girl.
00:21:22.780 And I promise, and again, this is not me trying to be mean.
00:21:28.240 This is trying to affirm who God has made as a male.
00:21:34.320 The world does not see this person as a girl.
00:21:37.020 Go to any person outside of Western civilization and he can put on makeup, heels and a dress
00:21:42.180 and ask a person in China or Zambia or India or Iraq what he is.
00:21:48.240 Heck, most people in the West wouldn't even bring themselves to say that this person is a
00:21:52.240 girl or a woman just like actual girls and women.
00:21:56.680 There's a very small percentage of people who have convinced themselves that gender is
00:22:00.440 actually something that you identify as.
00:22:02.680 There's a lot of people who say that they believe that.
00:22:04.980 There's a lot of people that will function politically like that.
00:22:08.160 There are a lot of doctors who will make money off of that belief.
00:22:10.660 But when you get down to what people really believe, there are very few people that have
00:22:17.140 deluded themselves so far into believing that.
00:22:19.700 That a grown man with a five o'clock shadow can be a girl.
00:22:24.120 OK, that is the truth.
00:22:25.980 That is not rude.
00:22:27.160 That is not mean.
00:22:28.460 Saying a man looks like a man or a woman looks like a woman is not mean spirited.
00:22:33.540 That is affirming reality.
00:22:36.020 I do not have ill will towards this person.
00:22:37.940 I do not wish him harm.
00:22:39.180 And I understand the manipulative tactic that is always employed that says, well, if you
00:22:45.640 think if you say that a man who thinks he's a woman is a man, you're perpetrating abuse
00:22:50.220 and encouraging self-harm.
00:22:51.500 But that is emotional extortion used to silence people out of telling the truth.
00:22:55.860 Talk to any detransitioner, which I know a lot of people are uncomfortable doing.
00:22:59.460 And they will tell you that their suicidal ideation had nothing to do with being misgendered or
00:23:04.420 pronouns or people not affirming them, but instead had to do with a lot of underlying
00:23:09.040 mental issues that were not being addressed.
00:23:12.120 My goal, my goal is not to offend, although I know that this is offensive.
00:23:17.260 That's not my goal.
00:23:18.440 It's not to hurt is to tell the truth.
00:23:20.620 And it's not just any truth, because some truths don't need to be said, right?
00:23:24.200 Like if you see someone and you don't like their outfit, you don't need to tell that
00:23:29.040 truth or you don't like their pants don't match their shirt and you're not on that level
00:23:33.920 of friendship to where like they really want to know.
00:23:36.360 There are some truths that are not necessary.
00:23:39.200 This is a necessary truth because under the guise of authenticity and affirmation, this
00:23:45.000 ideology is encouraging people to be what they are not.
00:23:49.580 And then it is infringing upon the rights of women in sports.
00:23:53.260 In abuse shelters, in prisons, it's breaking families apart.
00:23:57.420 It's encouraging minors to go through with life altering, sterilizing, genitalia maiming
00:24:02.640 procedures.
00:24:03.580 So telling the truth here is the most compassionate and necessary thing that we can do.
00:24:09.820 Dylan can never become a mom because he is not a woman.
00:24:14.180 He would have to buy the eggs of one woman and rent the womb of another woman to do what
00:24:18.420 he never can.
00:24:19.580 And that is bear a child.
00:24:20.900 That baby will then go into his arms, the arms of a stranger who doesn't smell or feel
00:24:26.220 like the woman who birthed him, who doesn't smell or feel like woman at all, and will
00:24:29.860 not feel the instinctive connection and longing that a child has for her mother.
00:24:34.780 Also, he can perpetuate a delusion at the expense of the right of a child to a mom and a dad,
00:24:40.500 at the expense of the long-term well-being of a child who has an innate desire to know from
00:24:46.600 whom she comes.
00:24:48.180 He will likely go through his process in the hope that doing so will make him a mom and
00:24:55.900 it will not.
00:24:57.800 Now, maybe he will adopt.
00:24:59.560 That would be better than buying eggs and renting wombs, which is, as we've talked about many
00:25:04.220 times, not much different than prostitution.
00:25:05.780 This is, it's often desperate women who are given the opportunity to make a lot of money
00:25:10.740 and they sell their bodies, taking on all kinds of risks, many of which they're not,
00:25:16.760 they don't even know about to feed their families.
00:25:18.740 But he would still not be a mother because he is not a woman and nothing will change that.
00:25:26.820 Now, maybe he could have been an amazing father.
00:25:29.380 However, I'm not doubting that he would love his child, but amazing dads still are not
00:25:35.680 moms.
00:25:43.440 All right, let me, let me talk about this a little bit further in on a deeper and more theological
00:25:53.680 level.
00:25:54.560 And this is, this is the most important part.
00:25:58.080 And there might be some of you out there who have never heard someone speak clearly
00:26:03.820 about this.
00:26:04.360 I might be the first person that you've heard talk clearly about this.
00:26:07.420 I hope that you'll go listen to some previous episodes that we will link in the description
00:26:11.800 of this podcast so you can learn more about this.
00:26:14.860 Most people are afraid of being called a name.
00:26:17.360 They're be, they're afraid of being called a transphobe.
00:26:19.680 And so they just go along to get along.
00:26:22.660 They go with the mainstream.
00:26:23.940 One of the things that we say on this podcast is that we are salmon.
00:26:28.780 We are swimming upstream.
00:26:30.120 When everyone is going one direction, we try to go the other.
00:26:33.080 Actually, let me, let me tell you this metaphor before I get into the rest of my explanation.
00:26:37.600 But I was thinking, so I go to this workout class and it's really important to stay on the
00:26:41.900 beat.
00:26:42.220 And there are some times when the entirety of the class is almost the entirety of the class
00:26:47.880 is on the wrong beat.
00:26:49.160 And in order for me to stay on the correct beat that I can hear, I have to close my eyes
00:26:55.080 and I just have to listen to the music and do the move that I know is right at the right
00:27:00.660 time, even if the people who are around me are on the wrong beat or else the entire,
00:27:09.680 I mean, or else it's just chaos or else you can't even like enjoy the workout.
00:27:13.940 And so that is also true when it comes to truth.
00:27:17.980 That's also truth when it comes to morality.
00:27:20.700 In reality, there are going to be times when everyone around you is offbeat and maybe they're
00:27:25.260 just a little offbeat or maybe they're doing completely different movements.
00:27:28.500 But you hear the music, you know God's word, you know what is true, and you have to close
00:27:32.900 your eyes to what other people are doing and simply follow what you know is right.
00:27:39.500 And that is true, certainly when it comes to these cultural issues that put so much
00:27:43.820 pressure on us, especially believers, to just swim downstream.
00:27:49.360 It's really easy to kind of fall into these nonsensical maxims like, oh, just live your
00:27:56.480 truth.
00:27:56.920 That person is just living their truth.
00:27:58.300 Or, oh, this person is just embracing authenticity.
00:28:01.460 And isn't it just good to be yourself or follow your heart?
00:28:05.300 Or, well, whatever makes someone happy or just follow your dreams.
00:28:09.340 I wrote an entire book about these lies that came out in 2020 called You're Not Enough
00:28:14.320 and That's Okay, Escaping the Toxic Culture of Self-Love and how they can lead to the delusion
00:28:19.160 of gender ideology, but also to justifying all different kinds of sin and irrationality.
00:28:26.060 So we'll link that too.
00:28:27.480 But people also fall into even crazier, even more illogical and even circular maxims like
00:28:36.440 trans women are women.
00:28:39.080 Like that doesn't make any sense if you actually try to define those words in any concrete sense.
00:28:45.440 Or maybe you and those around you have convinced yourself that this just doesn't affect you.
00:28:51.960 Like why does it even matter?
00:28:53.900 And we've talked a lot on many episodes about how this tangibly affects people and why it
00:29:00.320 matters.
00:29:01.460 So you can go back and listen to those.
00:29:03.860 But let me try to make a case to you from a biblical standpoint.
00:29:07.780 While I understand why a secular person might cling to these sayings and come to those conclusions,
00:29:14.020 these are simply not options for the Christian.
00:29:17.300 It's not a mentality that aligns with Christianity at all.
00:29:20.860 As Christians, we do not believe in our truth or their truth.
00:29:24.780 We do not believe that authenticity is a replacement for reality or morality.
00:29:29.220 We do not believe that happiness is an excuse for delusion.
00:29:32.480 We do not believe that male or female is something that can be declared, decided, or identified
00:29:36.840 as because the very first chapter of the Bible makes clear that God made us in his image as
00:29:43.140 male and female.
00:29:44.560 God created the gender binary and he saw that it was very good.
00:29:48.820 The binary is reiterated throughout scripture.
00:29:51.980 It is even the basis for the most significant union and symbol in the Bible, and that is
00:29:56.800 marriage.
00:29:57.820 Ephesians 5 tells us that the marriage between one husband and one wife is a depiction of
00:30:03.520 the eternal union between Christ, the bridegroom, and the church, his bride.
00:30:08.520 Just as the church submits to Christ, wives are to submit to their husbands.
00:30:12.640 Just as Christ sacrificed himself for the church, so husbands are to sacrifice themselves
00:30:17.820 for their wives.
00:30:19.700 So we see that the definition of both gender and marriage are not simply physical realities
00:30:26.400 that God made, but also point to a spiritual eternal reality.
00:30:31.780 In alliteration that I often use, that I've used many times, you've heard if you've been
00:30:37.380 listening to Relatable for any amount of time, the definition of gender and marriage in
00:30:42.940 the Bible is rooted in creation.
00:30:45.360 It is reiterated throughout scripture in places like honor your father and mother.
00:30:53.120 That's the first commandment with a promise.
00:30:55.080 Those gender roles and gender identifications are not arbitrary.
00:31:01.080 They are not switchable.
00:31:02.360 They're not accidental.
00:31:03.420 They are purposeful.
00:31:04.240 Honor your father and mother.
00:31:05.300 It's repeated by Jesus himself, Matthew 19, 4 through 5, representative of Christ and the
00:31:12.940 church, as we see in Ephesians 5, and therefore is reflective of the gospel.
00:31:19.940 So to be made in God's image is to be made male or female.
00:31:24.640 This is the basis of not only existence, but also the basis of marriage, which is the basis
00:31:30.880 of the family, which is the foundation of any functioning and flourishing society.
00:31:36.140 So to purposely try to distort that by repudiating God's creation is not only a disruption to society,
00:31:43.300 which then causes chaos.
00:31:45.060 It is not only an assault on the person as an image bearer, but most significantly, it is
00:31:50.360 an affront to God.
00:31:52.020 It is blasphemy.
00:31:53.560 It is the worst form of idolatry because it is self-idolatry.
00:31:57.560 It is an exchange of the God of Scripture for the God of self.
00:32:01.060 At least people who worship, say, a carven image realize that they have to go outside
00:32:07.200 of themselves for the power and for the wisdom that they're looking for.
00:32:11.380 But those who exchange the God of Scripture for the God of self have been so deluded by
00:32:16.660 their idolatry that they actually believe that they are sufficient in themselves to find
00:32:21.440 everything that they need.
00:32:22.600 The God of Scripture demands that we submit to who he says that we are, what he says is
00:32:30.300 good and right and true, whereas the God of self wants to simply submit to every feeling,
00:32:36.440 to every whim.
00:32:37.740 And that is why the burden and the yoke of the God of self is so heavy and so difficult.
00:32:44.840 But the burden that Jesus offers is light and the yoke that Jesus places on us is easy because
00:32:52.360 he tells us who we are.
00:32:54.400 He says our identity.
00:32:55.960 He says what our purpose is.
00:32:57.780 He says where our joy comes from.
00:33:00.240 He is where our joy comes from.
00:33:03.100 We don't have to follow our hearts.
00:33:04.780 We don't have to follow our feelings.
00:33:06.980 We believe in the Jesus who is the same yesterday, today, and forever.
00:33:11.780 Hebrews 13, 8, who also says in Matthew 19, 4 through 5, that we were made male and female.
00:33:17.540 Easy.
00:33:18.420 Easy.
00:33:19.360 We don't have to struggle with the turmoil of trying to figure out who we are and whose
00:33:24.740 we are because God has already told us that is the liberation and the joy and the freedom
00:33:30.960 that comes from Christianity, that comes from the gospel, and the order that comes from the
00:33:36.180 biblical worldview.
00:33:37.100 The worldview that is underlying transgenderism says that who we really are is what we feel
00:33:44.720 on the inside.
00:33:45.780 People will say that Dylan is being himself because he is trying to manifest what he feels.
00:33:51.280 Christianity rejects that form of superficial and distorted authenticity.
00:33:56.580 Christianity rather has a high view of the body as something that is a part of your identity,
00:34:02.760 a high view of physical reality.
00:34:05.080 We believe that God made our bodies from our chromosomes to our extremities.
00:34:09.420 They were purposely designed.
00:34:10.800 We believe that God loves our bodies.
00:34:13.220 1 Corinthians 6, 19 says that the Christian's body is a dwelling place for the Holy Spirit.
00:34:18.200 Jesus is God made flesh.
00:34:20.380 He died a bodily death on the cross and was raised in a bodily resurrection.
00:34:24.740 One day we are going to be raised in a bodily resurrection too.
00:34:28.420 That's how significant to God the body is.
00:34:31.760 That body that he knit together in our mother's womb will one day rise from the tomb.
00:34:39.880 That is how significant our body is to God.
00:34:43.560 Far be it from us to try to distort it or mutilate it or change it to be a different gender than
00:34:52.120 what God created us to be.
00:34:54.360 We do not as Christians believe it is possible to self-create or self-identify or self-declare
00:35:01.760 because God created us and identified us in the beginning and declares who we are.
00:35:08.900 That is not our responsibility.
00:35:10.200 That is not our job.
00:35:11.680 And I understand there are always going to be people who look for exceptions and say,
00:35:17.000 well, what about intersex?
00:35:18.840 What about people who have chromosomal abnormalities?
00:35:22.160 What do you say about people who have different body parts that put them somewhere in the middle?
00:35:28.800 Okay, that is a disability.
00:35:30.580 That is an anomaly.
00:35:32.440 Just because there are some people that are born with one leg does not mean that human beings are
00:35:37.600 not bipeds.
00:35:38.540 Yes, we understand the rule in that the exception does not rewrite the rule.
00:35:43.540 And someone who is born intersex is not the same as someone who is a man deciding when he is 30 years
00:35:48.360 old that he wants to be a girl.
00:35:51.220 It's not the same thing at all.
00:35:52.760 And I actually think that it's crazy and even rude to try to lump those people who were born with
00:35:59.200 that abnormality into a movement that is primarily driven by sex and the feelings that someone has
00:36:09.440 on the inside.
00:36:11.680 And so that is why, and that's a pretty thorough summary of why I think it is so important for
00:36:17.620 us to talk about this, for us to care about this, especially as Christians.
00:36:21.220 And this is not something to be wishy-washy on.
00:36:24.100 This should be easy for the Christian.
00:36:25.480 It goes back to the first chapter of the first book of the Bible.
00:36:29.480 If you're not going to be clear on Genesis 127, it is really hard for me to believe that
00:36:35.400 you will be clear on the far more controversial verse in the Bible, which is John 14, 6.
00:36:40.780 Genesis 127, God made us in his image, male and female.
00:36:46.060 He created us.
00:36:46.880 John 14, 6.
00:36:47.840 Jesus is the way, the truth, and the life.
00:36:50.520 No one comes to the Father except through him.
00:36:52.420 The reason I say that is because John 14, 6 is a lot more controversial than Genesis 127.
00:36:58.600 Genesis 127 is seen through reality.
00:37:01.200 I mean, it's seen through science.
00:37:02.680 Even a person who doesn't believe that the Bible is God's inspired word can see that we
00:37:08.320 are made male and female.
00:37:09.740 They may delude themselves into thinking otherwise, but it is scientifically obvious that we are sexually
00:37:15.220 dimorphic.
00:37:16.020 But John 14, 6, saying that Jesus is the only way to heaven, that we are all dead in our
00:37:23.960 sin apart from him, that we need him to be reconciled to the Father, that we need him
00:37:28.940 to forgive us of our sins, to absolve us of our iniquity so we can be free of the bonds
00:37:35.460 of sin today, but also spend eternity with God.
00:37:38.080 That is controversial.
00:37:39.200 The gospel is controversial.
00:37:40.720 I have a hard time believing if you won't go against the culture when it comes to something
00:37:45.140 as obvious as gender, that you're going to go against the culture when it comes to who
00:37:49.920 Jesus is.
00:37:52.360 So that's just something to chew on.
00:37:54.120 That's something to consider.
00:37:54.960 All right.
00:38:06.240 So I wanted to talk and I wish I had more time to spend on this one because I really kind
00:38:11.420 of wanted to break it down.
00:38:13.200 But with a follow up and a follow up to an episode that I did last week on Herschel Walker
00:38:19.000 and the Christian Walker, his son controversy.
00:38:21.500 The question that I asked was, should Christians vote for Herschel Walker?
00:38:26.040 And I kind of laid out my thought process about that, what I thought about Christian,
00:38:30.020 what I thought about the story about Herschel Walker.
00:38:33.000 Allegedly, according to the Daily Beast, paying for an abortion in 2009, he denies that.
00:38:38.280 I did want to look at the debate between Herschel Walker and his opponent, Democrat Raphael Warnock,
00:38:44.520 who I think from everything that we know about him, not just his values and how he will vote,
00:38:50.360 but also just the stuff about his personal life that has come out, I think is a terrible,
00:38:54.840 terrible candidate, obviously.
00:38:56.680 I mean, he's anti-life.
00:38:58.720 He has anti-every biblical value while calling himself a pastor.
00:39:01.860 So they had a debate in Georgia and Herschel Walker did well.
00:39:05.500 Like people were very impressed by how he did.
00:39:08.420 So let me play you this first clip where Raphael Warnock brings up the allegation that he,
00:39:17.320 that Herschel paid for this abortion in 2009.
00:39:20.860 And here is Herschel Walker's response to that.
00:39:23.800 As I said, that's a lie.
00:39:25.680 And, you know, what most thing I put, I put it in a book.
00:39:28.780 One thing about my life is I've been very transparent, not like the senator.
00:39:33.300 He's hid things.
00:39:34.700 But at the same time, I said, that's a lie.
00:39:36.740 And on abortion, you know, I'm a Christian.
00:39:39.260 I believe in life.
00:39:40.160 And I tell people this, Georgia is a state that respects life.
00:39:44.420 And I'll be a senator that protects life.
00:39:46.660 And I said, that was a lie.
00:39:48.080 And I'm not backing down.
00:39:50.760 OK, so he says that it was a lie.
00:39:53.420 Christian Walker seems to think that it was true and that it was his handwriting on the
00:39:59.760 on the receipt.
00:40:02.460 And so but he is saying, look, I support life.
00:40:06.340 Now, obviously, Raphael Warnock or any of the Democrats in the audience should not have
00:40:11.120 any moral qualms with that because they think that should be totally fine for someone to
00:40:14.700 be paying for an abortion.
00:40:16.200 I think people are pointing out that it would be hypocritical if that happened.
00:40:19.280 I really hope that it is absolutely not true because it would be hypocritical and it would
00:40:23.800 have been much better for him to be honest about that up front and to say, you know what?
00:40:27.360 I've been sanctified.
00:40:28.960 God saved me from that.
00:40:30.140 And I've repented.
00:40:30.880 And I regret that.
00:40:32.320 I think a lot of people would have a lot of forgiveness in their heart.
00:40:35.600 So I hope that he's not lying.
00:40:37.040 I do hope that he is telling the truth about that.
00:40:38.940 But he handled that question as well as he could.
00:40:42.620 All right.
00:40:43.120 Let's play this next clip.
00:40:44.400 I stand where I've said I stand in the past that a patient's room is too narrow and small
00:40:49.660 and cramped a space for a woman, her doctor and the United States government.
00:40:54.160 We are witnessing right now what happens when politicians, most of most of them men, pile
00:41:01.480 into patients rooms.
00:41:03.040 You get what you're seeing right now.
00:41:04.960 He's a neat talker.
00:41:06.840 But did he not mention that there was a baby in that room as well?
00:41:11.060 And also, did he not mention that he's asking the taxpayer to pay for it?
00:41:18.740 So he's bringing the government back into the room.
00:41:21.140 So he's not talking about that.
00:41:23.580 Mm-hmm.
00:41:24.440 That is a good point.
00:41:26.920 He did really well.
00:41:27.980 Well, first of all, he is much more unassuming and he doesn't have nearly as much pretense
00:41:37.580 as Raphael Warnock does.
00:41:39.500 He seems like a much more down to earth.
00:41:42.640 That's how he comes across.
00:41:43.680 He's a much more down to earth person than Raphael Warnock.
00:41:46.200 He's right.
00:41:47.080 He's a neat talker.
00:41:48.240 He's a smooth talker.
00:41:49.540 He knows how to say things like, oh, the room is too cramped.
00:41:53.840 It's too cramped for the doctor in the United States government and a woman.
00:41:58.920 And Herschel Walker brought up a great point.
00:42:01.040 There's a baby in that room, too.
00:42:02.880 So if that's your argument that the government has no say in when we kill someone and when
00:42:10.420 someone can be assaulted, then you're basically making the argument that there should be no
00:42:14.080 law at all against murder or against assault.
00:42:16.680 Why is it different just because the human being happens to reside in a woman's womb,
00:42:20.700 just because the human happens to be small, just because the human being happens to be
00:42:25.040 underdeveloped?
00:42:26.260 That is a justification for it to be legal to murder someone.
00:42:30.220 That seems horrific, especially for someone who considers himself a Christian like Raphael
00:42:35.540 Warnock.
00:42:36.120 And that's an amazing point, too, that Herschel Walker makes that actually you do want the
00:42:40.760 government.
00:42:41.700 You want the government in the business of abortion because you want the government to force
00:42:46.660 taxpayers to fund abortions.
00:42:48.820 So you're bringing the government in and you're bringing all the taxpayers in the room.
00:42:52.540 You want to talk about a cramped doctor's room, try to fit the entire state of Georgia
00:42:56.220 and their tax dollars in the doctor's room.
00:42:58.500 And that's exactly what Raphael Warnock wants.
00:43:01.100 There is nothing more wicked than forcing human beings, forcing citizens of the United States
00:43:06.940 to pay for the slaughter of babies.
00:43:08.800 And that is what Raphael Warnock wants.
00:43:10.540 All right.
00:43:12.020 I think we have is it one more clip or OK, here's a clip that a lot of people were talking
00:43:18.880 about online.
00:43:20.700 One thing I have not done.
00:43:22.420 I've never pretended to be a police officer.
00:43:26.600 And and and I've never I've never threatened a shootout with the police.
00:43:32.800 Well, and now I have to respond to that.
00:43:35.600 We are we are moving on.
00:43:37.160 Gentlemen respond to that.
00:43:38.760 And you know what's so funny?
00:43:40.460 I am with many police officers.
00:43:43.340 And at the same time, Mr. Walker, Mr. Walker, Mr. Walker, Mr. Walker, Mr. Walker, excuse me,
00:43:49.320 Mr. Walker.
00:43:50.080 When he said out of respect, I need to let you know, Mr. Walker, you are very well aware
00:43:55.760 of the rules tonight.
00:43:56.960 Yes.
00:43:57.340 And you have a prop that is not allowed, sir.
00:44:00.000 I ask you to put that prop away where it's not a prop.
00:44:03.200 This is real.
00:44:04.320 So a lot of people are talking about that, making fun of Herschel Walker.
00:44:07.300 He was an honorary deputy.
00:44:10.220 I don't think that he ever said, as far as I know, that he was actually, you know, like
00:44:14.260 a police officer in the same way.
00:44:16.620 But he was an honorary deputy and he did help the police force work with people who were
00:44:23.440 having mental health issues.
00:44:24.640 And he has talked about his own mental health episode.
00:44:27.400 So that's what Raphael Warnock was bringing up there.
00:44:31.060 So this is an election to watch.
00:44:33.160 I mean, Raphael Warnock is about as wicked as they come when you're thinking about who
00:44:38.000 to vote for.
00:44:38.720 Go back, listen to my previous episode for just kind of how I am thinking, thinking
00:44:43.640 through that particular election and the difficult allegations, I think, for Christians who want
00:44:50.960 to be thoughtful in how we vote and whom we vote for.
00:45:05.620 All right.
00:45:06.320 There was a whole other story that I wanted to talk about.
00:45:08.500 I don't have time to get into that.
00:45:10.620 I'll respond to it tomorrow or Wednesday because I could have like a whole 30 minute monologue
00:45:15.960 on this particular viral tweet about marriage, but I will talk about it soon.
00:45:20.260 We've got a lot of great interviews tomorrow.
00:45:22.180 I'm super excited.
00:45:23.080 So I am talking to a guest.
00:45:26.120 He goes by the moniker Chris Beats Cancer.
00:45:29.640 And he talks a lot, not just about different ways to combat cancer before your diagnosis
00:45:36.440 or after your diagnosis that I find interesting.
00:45:39.720 But he also talks a lot about pinkwashing and how Breast Cancer Awareness Month is not
00:45:45.460 what you think.
00:45:46.760 And I thought that was fascinating when I first heard it.
00:45:48.900 So he's going to come on the show and explain exactly what he means.
00:45:52.040 If you can think of questions that you have, particularly when it comes to breast cancer,
00:45:57.160 he offers or he believes that veganism can help with these kinds of health issues.
00:46:03.820 And so if you have any questions about that or about pinkwashing, let me know.
00:46:07.800 And I'll try to get those questions to him tomorrow.
00:46:10.420 And I will see you guys back here then.