Ep 766 | The Gospel Coalition’s Scandalous Sex Article
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
170.0563
Summary
In this episode, Allie talks about her weekend in California, her experience at a pro-life rally, and her thoughts on the recent controversy surrounding sex as a symbol of the gospel. This episode is brought to you by Good Ranchers. Use promo code ALLIE at checkout for $5 off your first GoodRanchers membership!
Transcript
00:00:00.000
The Gospel Coalition published, then removed what some are calling a very scandalous article
00:00:14.840
Also, a pastor in Canada is facing jail time for protesting Drag Queen Story Hour.
00:00:21.540
Why aren't more prominent Christians talking about this and similar stories around the
00:00:27.060
This episode is brought to you by our friends at Good Ranchers.
00:00:57.700
As I said last week, or I guess yesterday on the pre-recorded episode, I was in California
00:01:05.800
I was actually in Florida last week for a speaking engagement.
00:01:13.940
I was talking to a pro-life organization, Christian organization, and I love being around people
00:01:19.840
like that and getting to encourage them because you're just reminded of the good work that
00:01:24.260
the Lord is doing that doesn't always make headlines and just how many genuine and generous
00:01:28.700
Christians there are out there who care so much about the least of these, who care so
00:01:33.880
It is an honor and a privilege to be able to use whatever words the Lord gives me to
00:01:38.940
be able to inspire them and to tell them that what they're doing is worth it.
00:01:42.380
And then I got to speak for California Family Council on Sunday and then Monday at their
00:01:50.020
pro-life rally on Monday and then at an event that they had on Sunday night.
00:01:56.500
I mean, California Christian conservatives, obviously they feel like they're up against a lot, but
00:02:01.400
something that I said that I really feel like the Holy Spirit gave to me in the moment is
00:02:05.580
that if the gospel was strong enough, was powerful enough to be able to strengthen Christians under
00:02:15.600
Nero, it is powerful and effective enough to strengthen Christians under Newsom.
00:02:23.500
I said it better in the speech, but it's the general sentiment is the same, that Christians
00:02:30.880
before us have had even bigger obstacles, even nastier tyrants, even more bloodthirsty
00:02:37.920
politicians, bigger challenges than the ones we are facing today and still do throughout
00:02:45.500
the world have bigger challenges than the one that we're facing.
00:02:56.640
And the same father protected them with their presence.
00:03:00.400
And so if they can do it, if Christians before us have been carrying this torch for the past
00:03:06.460
2000 years on behalf of the gospel, on behalf of the most vulnerable, then we can continue
00:03:13.900
So that's what the past few days of my life have been about.
00:03:16.960
Just speaking to Christians who kind of needed that encouragement.
00:03:19.240
So thankful, so thankful for everyone that I met out there who's listening to this podcast.
00:03:24.460
Maybe you're listening for the first time because you heard me speak or you, or you met me, or
00:03:29.400
maybe you've been a longtime listener and it's always great to meet you guys in person.
00:03:32.920
So thanks so much for coming and thank you all also for being here.
00:03:37.420
So, um, also, oh, one thing I wanted to say too, just to encourage you.
00:03:41.980
So I was giving my speech on the steps of the Capitol in Sacramento, California, just talking
00:03:47.140
about the importance of defying or pushing back as much as we can against the legislation
00:03:52.500
coming down the pipeline in California that literally legalizes infanticide.
00:03:56.820
And some are going to, um, try to basically close down pregnancy centers by opening them
00:04:04.100
up to all of these frivolous and ridiculous lawsuits.
00:04:06.820
And so as I was, as I was talking, it was a very quick speech yesterday.
00:04:11.120
I had, you know, counter protesters in the back and they had their emergency sirens that
00:04:17.600
They're screaming and they're shouting, of course, trying to drown out any of the, any
00:04:24.040
And so, um, thankfully the speakers were the speakers themselves, not the speaker, me speaking,
00:04:29.680
but the, you know, the speakers amplifying the sound were very loud.
00:04:33.220
And so I also got to go up and just thank them and say, you know what?
00:04:36.540
I think that you guys are playing sirens back there because you realize what an emergency
00:04:40.500
it is that California allows abortion through all nine months of pregnancy.
00:04:45.900
I don't think that they appreciated that, um, very much, but again, thank, thank all of
00:04:52.220
you who came out there courageously, who took the time to come out there and rally for
00:05:00.620
We're going to get into this gospel coalition story.
00:05:03.220
I'm not going to be able to talk about it as much as I want to, because we've got a
00:05:06.160
lot of ground to cover with the other stories that we're talking about, but I'll tell you
00:05:09.420
my surprising, I think you'll find a surprising opinion on this.
00:05:24.420
So the gospel coalition, big Christian website, you guys are familiar.
00:05:28.520
They released an article by Josh Butler, and it was actually an excerpt from the intro of
00:05:36.180
So in this excerpt that was posted as an article, Butler argues that sex is not salvation.
00:05:42.780
So in it, he argues that sex is not salvation, but points to salvation.
00:05:47.840
He said that he used to look for sex, um, to sex, to basically save him, to make him whole.
00:05:54.120
And he realized that this was never going to happen.
00:05:56.740
But he also argues that he realizes that sex points to the one who does fully satisfy you,
00:06:04.380
So he says the sexual act between a man and a woman within marriage is an icon of salvation.
00:06:14.280
It shows the relationship between Christ and the church.
00:06:17.880
So he says some things in this article that are pretty graphic, more graphic than I think
00:06:29.760
So generosity and hospitality, he says, are both embodied in the sexual act.
00:06:35.860
Generosity involves giving extravagantly to someone.
00:06:38.060
And what deeper form of self-giving is there than sexual union, where the husband pours out
00:06:43.120
his very presence, not only upon, but within his wife.
00:06:46.980
Hospitality, on the other hand, involves receiving the life of the other.
00:06:51.260
Here again, what deeper form of hospitality is there than sexual union, where the wife welcomes
00:06:56.020
her husband into the sanctuary of her very self?
00:07:00.020
He talks about during a honeymoon, the groom goes into his bride.
00:07:03.540
He is not only with his beloved, but within his beloved.
00:07:06.120
He enters the sanctuary of his spouse, where he pours out his deepest presence and bestows
00:07:10.560
an offering, a gift, a sign of his pilgrimage that has the potential to grow within her into
00:07:22.440
The bride gladly receives the warmth of his presence and accepts the sacrificial offering
00:07:26.880
he bestows upon the altar within her most holy place.
00:07:30.720
So he doesn't say it's actually much less explicit than he could be.
00:07:34.580
Obviously, he is using the metaphor and he is hoping that we understand the mechanics of
00:07:46.380
So they published this because he is a fellow in a new fellowship program, which is the, let's
00:08:01.040
He is a fellow in that new program that was established by the Gospel Coalition.
00:08:09.460
And there was immediate backlash from the conservative side that said, OK, this is weird.
00:08:17.780
And then you saw from the progressive side, too patriarchal.
00:08:26.260
This is not considering the victimhood throughout history of women.
00:08:34.680
So Beth Allison Barr, she's a professor and she's an author.
00:08:37.780
She says that I really think the TGC should do some self-reflection about why they thought
00:08:43.820
It reveals so much that is deeply wrong with complementarian ideas about women.
00:08:48.000
Complementarian means that men and women are equal in worth, but they have different roles
00:08:56.160
I believe that that's biblical versus egalitarian, which means that men and women can actually
00:09:00.780
have the same roles within marriage and within the church, which I think is profoundly unbiblical
00:09:05.500
in a lot of ways, that they perceive women as passive objects and men as sexual overlords.
00:09:11.440
When this article is put in context of what male leaders who ascribe to complementarian theology
00:09:15.900
are taught, Jonathan Pakluda, wow, we've had him on this podcast, and I think that he's
00:09:21.260
His objectification of a woman makes so much sense.
00:09:28.700
Jacob Denhollander says, he says, basically, he argues that this article teaches the objectification
00:09:37.120
of women, the sacralizing of male orgasm, likening the Holy Spirit to redacted, and the spiritualization
00:09:58.180
She takes issue, again, with the objectification and the patriarchal themes that she sees inherent
00:10:04.280
She says the problem is that the Keller Center has five female fellows and 22 male fellows.
00:10:10.580
At TGC 2023, only 17 of the 90 speakers are female.
00:10:17.100
So she sees that as part of the problem, again, kind of patriarchy.
00:10:20.580
So after this pushback, TGC actually took down the article.
00:10:24.140
They issued a statement, and they said, you know, we've listened to our critics and the
00:10:31.500
And we accepted Josh's resignation as a Keller Center fellow.
00:10:40.800
They say thank you so much for being patient with us.
00:10:44.120
And then he also had some people who had previously endorsed his book say, you know what?
00:10:53.600
He is very progressive, very social justice centric.
00:10:57.040
He issued this long statement saying, you know, I don't.
00:11:00.260
I know I issued an endorsement for this book, but I don't actually endorse the book.
00:11:08.440
And after hearing people's criticisms and reflecting on it, I realized that it's not just wrong,
00:11:18.840
Now, the interesting thing about Rich Viotas is that he wrote a book.
00:11:26.520
He wrote a book that argued a very similar thing.
00:11:33.300
He says this in his book, The Deeply Formed Life.
00:11:37.360
And this is according to, by the way, Stive and Peter at The American Reformer, who talks
00:11:45.680
He says, what makes Viotas' retraction instructive for demonstrating the dynamics of the negative
00:11:50.140
world is that Viotas and Butler share virtually identical positions on sex.
00:11:54.440
Viotas has also written a book on cultural apologetics, The Deeply Formed Life, in which
00:12:01.700
Lovemaking in and outside the bedroom is a revelation.
00:12:07.580
Our lovemaking is to manifest our union with each other, and in so doing, manifest God's
00:12:13.240
So Peter says this, though Viotas is not as graphic as Butler, the same concepts are present
00:12:21.460
But both want to capture that sex reveals something about the divine.
00:12:25.360
Jesus initiates by giving his body to the church in self-giving love.
00:12:29.260
Per Ephesians 5, the man is the head of the marriage who gives himself to his wife,
00:12:34.260
To be clear, Butler and Viotas believe the same things about how the sexual act reveals
00:12:39.180
God and mirrors the pattern of initiation and reception between Christ and the church.
00:12:44.440
In fact, Viotas says this, moreover, lovemaking is an act of mission.
00:12:47.660
When a couple is in love, giving and receiving each other in bodily, emotional, and spiritual
00:12:51.020
communion, they can't help but overflow in love to the world around them.
00:12:55.840
So he basically argues the same thing as Josh Butler does, but he retracted his endorsement
00:13:01.700
because he got pressure from progressive feminist activists who said that this is patriarchal
00:13:09.840
Roger, he also wrote an article about this in the American Conservative.
00:13:15.500
And basically, he says that the reaction to this by evangelicals is totally overblown.
00:13:20.680
And let me just say, because I haven't revealed my opinion yet, but you can probably pick up
00:13:25.800
I think the reaction to this on both the left and the right is absolutely overblown and ridiculous.
00:13:33.020
Someone sent me this article and was like, oh my gosh, have you seen this?
00:13:37.860
Let me just tell you, I read it and I was like, what?
00:13:42.360
I mean, yeah, it's more graphic than I would like.
00:13:44.540
Of course, I wouldn't have thought of that or written that article.
00:13:52.300
And this person, you might not like his argument.
00:13:54.000
You might not agree with his argument, but I do not agree with the people saying this
00:14:02.900
I mean, enough to make me a little uncomfortable.
00:14:05.500
But are we really so prudish that we cannot talk about sex like this?
00:14:11.080
Josh Butler, in his article that the Bible is actually very explicit.
00:14:14.980
Like the Hebrew word for sex is he went into her.
00:14:18.640
Much more explicit than we are when we use our euphemisms like lovemaking and sleeping together
00:14:27.200
But he's making the point that the Bible is actually very explicit about what sex is
00:14:32.060
and that that is a representation of Christian marriage and not just Christian marriage,
00:14:36.640
but the joining in of a man and a woman as one flesh, which is indicative of sex.
00:14:43.520
And he is saying, just as Ephesians 5 argues, that marriage in its own mysterious way is a representation
00:14:54.880
The husband representative of Christ, the wife representative of the church,
00:15:00.480
just as Christ laid down his life for the church.
00:15:03.960
So a husband is to lay down his life for his wife in many different ways.
00:15:09.240
And the wife is to submit to her husband as to the Lord.
00:15:13.500
Husbands, love your wives as Christ loved the church.
00:15:23.040
And he is saying that that's not just true in just the relationship dynamics there.
00:15:31.820
Now, there's a lot of interesting debates about this.
00:15:33.980
People who are much more theologically savvy than me and who know more about the interpretation
00:15:39.620
and exegesis of the Bible disagree with his theology when it comes to this.
00:15:45.800
But I agree in general that absolutely not just the marriage relationship,
00:15:49.780
but the dynamic of sex between a man and a woman in that marriage relationship
00:15:55.380
is actually reflective of in particular ways of Christ in the church.
00:16:01.480
And Rod Rear wrote this article basically saying to evangelicals not understand this
00:16:05.460
because he says that Catholic and Orthodox theology recognize sex as some kind of icon
00:16:18.220
And then Denny Burke, he wrote an article defending complementarianism
00:16:23.900
since people have been attacking complementarianism and complementarian theology because of this.
00:16:28.960
And I think that his article on this is really good, by the way.
00:16:37.540
And he talks about the importance of the complementarian dynamic.
00:16:43.280
He looks at 1 Corinthians 11, 9, Ephesians 5, 20, 25,
00:16:47.520
and how this is displayed in Christ's sacrificial death and resurrection.
00:16:54.580
And he says that TGC's apology should have clarified these issues,
00:16:59.040
confronted problems in Butler's article, affirmed scripture's husband-wife typology,
00:17:02.920
and rejected the accusations against complementarian theology.
00:17:06.860
Because TGC's theology, you don't really know what they're apologizing for.
00:17:10.340
You don't really know what they're apologizing for.
00:17:14.040
You're kind of like, wait, are you saying that this was patriarchal,
00:17:17.500
that this was anti-woman in some way, which I really don't read at all?
00:17:23.060
So I honestly, like, I did not have the same issues with this article that people on the left
00:17:30.360
Again, I'm not sure that it was all completely theologically solid,
00:17:34.880
but people, honestly, you need to get a grip a little bit.
00:17:38.180
But it's okay for people to write things that are, I mean,
00:17:42.080
it's okay for people to write things that we don't like, right?
00:17:46.200
But the TGC absolutely should have done a better job at responding to this.
00:17:50.120
And I do think that this is like cancel culture, by the way.
00:17:54.220
And I don't think it's wrong for people to be canceled for right reasons.
00:17:56.780
I just think this person is canceled for wrong reasons.
00:17:59.060
I'm sure that there are things that we disagree on theologically, by the way.
00:18:02.220
The fact that he had Rich Viotas as someone who was endorsing his book
00:18:05.720
means that he's probably actually progressive in a lot of ways.
00:18:10.060
However, I just really, I just really think that he was mistreated in this instance.
00:18:16.560
And I think that the reaction to this article is absolutely, absolutely overblown.
00:18:32.000
Now let's talk about that Canadian pastor that was recently arrested
00:18:41.980
The fact that those four words can even go together.
00:18:46.260
And we all understand what we're talking about,
00:18:48.860
that there is such thing as a drag queen story hour,
00:18:52.280
where men are dressed up as caricatures of women,
00:18:57.400
scantily clad women, reading books to children,
00:19:01.720
in some cases, dancing before children for money.
00:19:05.320
The fact that that is even a thing that we discuss on a fairly regular basis,
00:19:10.860
because it is so pervasive in the United States and in Canada
00:19:30.160
I think this is maybe even a direct quote from Calvin Robinson,
00:19:33.320
although many of us have said this in different ways,
00:19:37.860
Ask not why children want to see drag queens perform.
00:19:44.580
Ask yourself rather why drag queens want an audience of children.
00:19:49.860
There is no innocuous, there is no non-perverted reason for a grown man to want to dress in fishnets
00:20:00.300
and sometimes a thong and in fake boobs and present themselves to children.
00:20:10.300
And, you know, I've been thinking about this before we even get into the story,
00:20:14.380
the parental rights movement that we have in the United States,
00:20:17.680
that thankfully has been led by a lot of conservative moms and dads
00:20:22.020
who have said, you know, the state is not our co-parent
00:20:24.660
and public schools don't get a say in how we raise our children.
00:20:30.740
They're not going to indoctrinate our children with a worldview
00:20:36.140
which, by the way, that is just inherent in public school.
00:20:42.940
and to be the primary influence in our child's life.
00:20:47.380
But something that we say is that parents know what is best for their children.
00:20:51.520
And in general, I do believe that parents do what is best for their children.
00:20:57.320
But maybe it's more accurate to say that parents do what they believe is best
00:21:03.180
because obviously looking at these videos that I see every single week posted,
00:21:09.540
but other conservative commentators and journalists
00:21:11.800
showing parents willingly, voluntarily, cheerfully bringing their children
00:21:21.780
where these scantily clad men are twerking for money.
00:21:25.320
I think, you know, I'm not sure that that's really true.
00:21:30.240
I'm not sure that it's true that parents in general
00:21:33.980
or that all parents do what is best for their children.
00:21:37.920
Like, obviously, we know that there are abusive parents,
00:21:47.980
But then when you see these parents totally shamelessly
00:22:04.700
I'm just not so sure that we can say confidently
00:22:09.720
that parents are doing what is best for their children.
00:22:16.000
I think good parents do what is best for their children.
00:22:18.720
I don't think that we can say parents in general
00:22:25.340
and are trying to do what's best for their children,
00:22:29.000
that masked their 18-month-old to their two-year-old
00:22:31.880
who still do so in the name of trying to protect their health,
00:22:38.060
not really because they care so much about their child
00:22:43.860
that this is what it looks like to be virtuous.
00:22:49.040
we can trust the discernment and the judgment of parents,
00:22:56.920
So what, I mean, what exactly do we do about that?
00:22:59.580
Because at the end of the day, that's the issue, right?
00:23:13.240
If there weren't parents that were bringing their kids
00:23:25.500
There's always going to be some perverts out there
00:23:38.100
Why aren't all parents absolutely appalled by that?
00:24:02.240
it goes back to exchanging the God of Scripture
00:24:19.260
And thankfully, conservative states like Tennessee,
00:24:24.080
I mean, the parents obviously aren't stepping in
00:24:42.340
who are sending these kids to these story hours.
00:24:44.320
And he's saying, okay, I'm going to do something.
00:24:48.720
to this absolute disgusting display of sin and iniquity.
00:24:55.880
And he believes that this is what God has called him to do.
00:25:03.820
And they host a regular Reading with Royalty event
00:25:06.820
that feature family-friendly storytime programs
00:25:09.060
led by local drag queen, king, and monarch performers.
00:25:13.860
And so Pastor Derek Scott Reamer of Mission 7 Ministries
00:25:27.320
peacefully protesting this event at the library.
00:25:30.920
Okay, we don't have a reply to the camera, Zach.
00:25:41.020
so it is your choice to leave or deal with the police.
00:25:50.920
We're exposing the darkness on this wickedness.
00:25:55.400
And we're coming down to more and more of the shows
00:26:14.640
So I don't know if you could hear what he said,
00:26:17.040
but there's nothing that he said that was wrong.
00:26:19.880
That is evil to have a pervert dressed like this
00:26:51.680
has been charged with one count of causing a disturbance
00:27:00.840
This bylaw carries a $500 fine for communicating with a person
00:27:04.320
in a manner that could reasonably cause offense or humiliation.
00:27:13.100
for talking to a person in a way that causes offense.
00:27:18.260
Including referring to a person's gender identity
00:27:42.800
on the condition that he stayed away from drag queen events.
00:27:47.520
and his next bail hearing will be on March 14th.
00:27:50.880
As of last night, police claim he was released,
00:27:54.560
And he has not been in contact with friends and family.
00:28:06.780
It's more important that we stay six feet away,
00:28:28.420
He was not the only pastor who was put in jail.
00:28:31.600
There were several pastors who were imprisoned,
00:28:33.940
who were arrested simply for opening their church
00:28:38.660
You can't say that Canada is a democratic country.
00:28:51.660
that fools people into thinking that they're democratic
00:29:15.080
and pretty actually democratic and free country.
00:29:23.980
and wielding it against Christians and conservatives.
00:29:26.960
I mean, we saw that also in the trucking protest
00:30:02.240
and how there were sirens playing in the background
00:30:06.700
Like, did I call for those people to be arrested,
00:30:15.260
because I know my ideas are better than theirs.
00:31:35.760
I guess this is when he was feeding the homeless