00:01:29.580Also, I've seen a lot of you asking me when the Dr. James White and the Trent Horn debate on Catholicism and Protestantism is coming out.
00:01:41.760It's going to be out in a couple weeks.
00:01:44.420And I think that there might have been some confusion about it being on the show versus for Blaze TV subscribers.
00:01:52.720It is going to be for Blaze TV subscribers.
00:01:57.180And as I talked about last week, it's so important for us to offer content that is behind the paywall because the more content that we have just for subscribers,
00:02:06.740the more we can protect ourselves from the censors on places like YouTube and Apple Podcasts and places that like to stifle conservative and Christian views.
00:02:20.480We will always continue to offer this free content, but we are going to be building up our content behind the paywall as well for subscribers.
00:03:04.400A ton of you have been messaging me about this Alabama ruling and asking me what I think about it.
00:03:10.500The Alabama Supreme Court ruled that frozen, unimplanted embryos qualify as human children.
00:03:19.940Obviously, this has many implications for things like in vitro fertilization.
00:03:25.880IVF is probably one of the most controversial topics that I discuss and have been discussing since either 2019 or 2020.
00:03:37.040So obviously, there have been a lot of thinkers and commentators who have been discussing this for a lot longer than I have for decades and decades.
00:03:47.240Really, since the inception of IVF, you've had a lot of Christian and Catholic thinkers discussing some of the ethical issues with IVF.
00:03:57.900However, it hasn't really been a central conversation in evangelicalism.
00:04:04.380And I think a lot of it has to do with just kind of our lack of cohesive theology of the body.
00:04:14.120I think we've kind of got down what we think about sex versus sex outside of marriage, gender, sometimes gender roles.
00:04:26.620But when it comes to IVF, when it comes to surrogacy, when it comes to reproductive technology, I found that many evangelicals, and yes, many Catholics too, but since I'm surrounded by so many evangelicals, I just see a lot of thoughtlessness when it comes to these subjects.
00:04:44.240And it's kind of just the mentality of, well, I'm pro-life, and so I'm pro-baby, and I think any method or means that we employ to create life is good.
00:04:57.520And really, there hasn't been a whole lot of consideration of how the life is created, if it's moral, if it's ethical, to use in vitro fertilization and then to put embryos on ice.
00:05:11.100And there's really a disconnect because we as pro-lifers say life is life at conception, made in the image of God, made with purpose and with dignity.
00:05:22.440And just like any other human, that tiny human at the earliest stages of development is entitled to human rights, the foremost being the right to life, the right to not be murdered, mistreated, abused.
00:05:35.420And we don't then have that same mentality, though, when it comes to embryos, when it comes to these unimplanted human beings that are still made in the image of God.
00:05:50.620And yet, through IVF, or very often left in a freezer, sometimes indefinitely, very often they are discarded because the parents have decided they've had all the kids that they want, or sometimes there's a divorce.
00:06:04.100And so the parents don't want the embryos that they have extracted and created and frozen, or sometimes, actually very often, I would say, in the vast majority of the cases of IVF, there is a eugenics process that goes into it.
00:06:22.860And the scientists, the scientists, the doctors, can test these embryos to see if they have any kind of genetic disorder or some kind of special need.
00:06:32.780Of course, they can test whether the embryo is a boy or a girl, and then parents can make the decision based on those findings, which embryos they want to kill, discard, which embryos they want to implant, or which embryos they want to surrender,
00:06:50.940which embryos they want to pay to stay in a freezer for years and years.
00:06:55.240And my basic take is that that's no way to treat a child.
00:06:58.840Like, that's no way to treat a human being.
00:07:00.740If we believe, as Christian pro-lifers, that these humans are made in the image of God, and therefore they have dignity, they have innate worth, and therefore they are entitled to human rights,
00:07:13.980then we shouldn't be treating these little human beings like this.
00:07:17.660Just because an adult wants to be a parent, just because they may have gone through a very difficult fertility and pregnancy process,
00:07:28.860which we can have a lot of compassion for, these things don't justify treating human beings like this.
00:07:35.560And I understand there are different methods, well, not really different methods of IVF, but there are different scenarios.
00:07:41.780There are some scenarios in which the parents implant all the embryos that have been created.
00:07:49.500And of course, I think that is a much, much better and more ethical option than creating a ton of embryos, which is what most people do.
00:07:58.940Like Paris Hilton, I think, has, she said, like has 20 embryos on ice.
00:08:02.880She's obviously not going to implant all of those embryos.
00:08:05.840So I think it's much better to only create as many embryos as you are willing to implant and have.
00:08:12.000But the implantation process is very risky for the embryo as well.
00:08:19.160I mean, there are many cases when, unfortunately, the embryo thaws before it has been implanted, and so the embryo dies.
00:08:27.800And so even in those cases, we are asking these little human beings to take a big risk in that implantation and freezing and implantation process to satisfy our own wants as adults.
00:08:44.700And I think that is simply disordered.
00:08:56.780And they're precious children, of course.
00:08:59.340But that does not mean the IVF process is something that we should advocate for or support as Christians.
00:09:07.340So that's basically where I stand, just to give a summary of my stance on IVF.
00:09:15.180And so, as you can probably imagine, I support the reasoning in this Alabama Supreme Court ruling that said these unimplanted embryos qualify as human children.
00:09:27.440And so they have rights like human children.
00:09:30.040So we'll get into exactly what the ruling says and what that means in just a second.
00:09:47.220This summary of this ruling is via World Magazine and also the Alabama Reflector.
00:09:54.180So the Alabama case emerged from an incident in 2020 in which embryos from three couples were apparently destroyed when an unauthorized person gained access to the embryos stored by the Center for Reproductive Medicine in Mobile, Alabama.
00:10:08.900That's another thing here is that, like, as your children are in this freezer, in this lab, they are being supervised by people who don't know or love them.
00:10:21.800And very often they care for them just fine.
00:10:25.780And this is this accident or this this mistreatment of these embryos is not unique.
00:10:34.100This actually happens, unfortunately, across the country.
00:10:37.220So this person caused the embryos produced by the three couples to be destroyed.
00:10:41.660The couples filed a lawsuit and a lower court found that Alabama's wrongful death of a minor act didn't apply to a human embryo located outside of a mother's womb.
00:10:52.880But the couples, obviously devastated by this, they appealed to the state Supreme Court.
00:10:58.060And just days ago, that court handed down a decisive eight to one ruling.
00:11:03.200Declaring that unborn children are children without exception based on developmental stage, physical location or any other ancillary characteristics.
00:12:03.960Okay, well, you can apply any of those factors to people outside of the womb and tell me, do any of those factors justify killing a person?
00:12:13.580Like a toddler is smaller and less developed than a teenager is.
00:12:18.180Does that toddler have fewer rights than the teenager because of those things?
00:12:23.360The Alabama Supreme Court is just carrying that sound logic into a case about embryos.
00:12:31.160In a majority opinion, Justice J. Mitchell wrote that there was no exception for frozen embryos under an 1872 law allowing civil lawsuits for the wrongful death of children or under a 2018 state constitutional amendment amendment that required the state to, quote, ensure the protection of the rights of the unborn child.
00:12:51.980The upshot here is that the phrase minor child means the same thing in the wrongful death of a minor act as it does in everyday life, in everyday language.
00:13:02.740An unborn or recently born individual member of the human species from fertilization until the age of majority.
00:13:11.080Nothing about this act narrows that definition to unborn children who are physically in utero.
00:13:17.060Instead, the act provides a cause of action for the death of any minor child without exception or limitation.
00:13:25.040You know, I see sometimes people say, well, babies inside the womb aren't children or embryos aren't children.
00:16:22.220These are all based on the Christian God's commands to do certain things and against other things.
00:16:33.000And the founders would have acknowledged that.
00:16:35.060And the founders of the states would have acknowledged that, too.
00:16:38.260The founders of our country did not separate God and law,
00:16:41.520even as they did try to make distinctions, and I think rightfully so,
00:16:46.340between certain churches and the state.
00:16:49.320Again, mostly for the protection of the church,
00:16:51.840but also protecting people against the establishment of a particular national church.
00:16:59.600And obviously the history that the founders were fleeing from informed their desire to make sure that that separation was there in the beginning.
00:17:38.900In summary, the theologically-based view of the sanctity of life adopted by the people of Alabama encompasses the following.
00:17:45.800One, God made every person in his image.
00:17:47.860Two, each person, therefore, has a value that far exceeds the ability of human beings to calculate.
00:17:53.100And three, human life cannot be wrongfully destroyed without incurring the wrath of a holy God who views the destruction of his image as an affront to himself.
00:19:18.640So again, I completely support this reasoning.
00:19:22.000So here's what the ruling says specifically on the impact to the IVF industry.
00:19:29.380Although it is for the legislature, so the Alabama state legislature, to decide how to address this issue,
00:19:35.020I note briefly that many other westernized countries have adopted IVF practices or regulations that allow IVF to continue while drastically reducing the chances of embryos being killed.
00:19:46.260Even the most progressive nations like Canada and many countries in Europe have way stricter laws when it comes to reproductive technology than America does.
00:19:56.060America is truly the wild, wild west when it comes to reproductive technology.
00:20:35.600If the legislature agrees that it is time to regulate the IVF industry, then the good news is it need not reinvent the wheel.
00:20:46.420Other westernized countries have given Alabama some examples to consider, like Australia and New Zealand dictate that physicians only make one embryo at a time.
00:20:55.700Wow, that is way more conservative than what's here in the United States.
00:20:59.420The European Union countries set a legal limit on the number of embryos transferred in a single cycle.
00:21:06.020And this is not only to protect the embryos, by the way.
00:21:08.520It's also because it can be very deleterious to the health of a woman.
00:21:11.920We've talked about before with Jennifer Law, how there are some doctors are starting to look at the correlation, the causal relationship between what goes on in IVF and egg retrieval and cancer.
00:21:31.040I mean, it can't be good to pump your body with all of those artificial hormones.
00:21:37.060There are going to be consequences to things like that.
00:21:39.780And so that's another thing to consider.
00:21:41.320Is this good for a woman's body in addition to, is this right to treat a child this way?
00:21:50.260Italy banned cryopreservation of embryos except in the case of a health risk or a major event preventing the embryo from being immediately transferred.
00:22:08.340So therefore, although certain changes to the IVF industry's current creation and handling of embryos in Alabama will result from this decision to the extent that dissenting Justice Cook is predicting that IVF will now end in Alabama, that prediction does not seem to be well founded.
00:22:24.740Well, I think that it's kind of telling that so many people are saying the IVF is going to end in Alabama because of a ruling that says the embryos are human children.
00:22:38.340So are you saying that IVF is mistreating human children?
00:22:42.720Because, again, I think that that kind of shows us what we all already know about IVF and the IVF process.
00:22:50.720And it's also showing an unwillingness by the reproductive industry to take any steps toward the well-being of these children that they are creating.
00:23:02.420I think this is a step in the right direction.
00:23:05.020Like, I would see it as a huge win if we got to the point in IVF where you are only creating one embryo at a time and you are doing everything you can to transfer, to implant that embryo as quickly as possible.
00:23:21.860As it stands right now, we have over a million, probably millions, of frozen embryos.
00:23:29.160And a lot of times parents just pay the fee every month because they don't want to give their embryos up for adoption.
00:25:01.140But, like, these are the things that we have to think about.
00:25:03.520And, by the way, the church needs to be helping people think about this.
00:25:08.000I understand that this is controversial.
00:25:10.540And so many pastors, unfortunately, think that they shouldn't wade into controversial topics.
00:25:15.280Well, look, you shouldn't be leaving it to podcasters to wade into these issues, pastor.
00:25:19.800You shouldn't be leaving it to TikTokers and influencers to talk about the hard things.
00:25:26.180Like, if you want to shepherd your flock and you want to make sure that they truly have a biblical worldview, especially when it comes to protecting vulnerable life, which the church is supposed to be a champion of, then you need to wade into the very difficult and controversial issues.
00:25:40.520If we believe that these are all little image bearers, then Christians have an obligation to stand up for them.
00:25:49.580Obviously, Washington Post is not happy about this.
00:25:54.680None of the liberal outlets are going to be happy about this.
00:25:58.320I do want to talk about a little bit what Albert Moeller said about this in his podcast episode in just a second.
00:26:10.520Okay, so Dr. Moeller, whom we've had on this podcast a couple times, he's someone that I certainly look to for a lot of answers when it comes to complicated, complex issues.
00:26:29.340He said the hard thing is that many who consider themselves to be pro-life have refused to extend their own logic to the huge moral crisis posed by IVF procedures.
00:26:38.240That's exactly what I said, and I hadn't even read this yet.
00:26:52.540If we really do believe this, how do we reckon with millions of frozen children locked in an indefinite freeze and destined for destruction due to IVF procedures?
00:27:03.220I do just want to say someone that has helped me think through this, and maybe Dr. Moeller, too, because I know they've had conversations.
00:27:09.080Katie Faust is an excellent voice on this, an excellent resource.
00:27:12.700So is Jennifer Law, both of these women I've had on my podcast, and they have been very helpful for me in helping me develop my stance on these things and also just igniting a passion in me about these things.
00:27:22.760The court's reasoning, Dr. Moeller says, is unassailable.
00:27:26.820I mean, wherever that embryo may be found, if that is not true, the pro-life movement has been lying.
00:27:31.320If it is true, and it is true, then evangelicals have better make certain our affirmation of human dignity and the sanctity of human life is clear.
00:27:40.900And I do just appreciate so much Dr. Moeller's ability to succinctly and biblically give us good analysis and answers about these very controversial topics.
00:27:53.760Now, you can imagine the pro-abortion industry is very angry about this.
00:29:49.440And it is worth thinking through them.
00:29:52.080Just because there are unanswered questions or questions that progressives don't want to answer doesn't mean a ruling like this is ridiculous.
00:30:00.260Actually, that's basically what the ruling said when it comes to IVF, that we need to do a better job of thinking through this.
00:30:06.220We need to weigh the right and the dignity of babies when we are looking at reproductive technology.
00:30:20.460Other countries have thought through it.
00:30:22.260Other countries that progressives here say are so superior to America because they're far more progressive in some ways.
00:30:29.520Well, they're a lot more careful and conscientious about this than America is.
00:30:33.900So why is it so difficult for us to ask some of these questions and actually work on answering them?
00:30:39.220Someone else that the skim posted said, according to the Alabama Supreme Court, a shelf full of frozen embryos is legally a daycare center.
00:32:33.480I look forward to all women being able to get life insurance for their baby starting the moment they get a positive pregnancy test in Alabama.
00:32:40.200Okay, if we do that, will you be pro-life?
00:32:43.560If we go there, which like I'm willing to do that, I'm willing to say, sure, that's fine.
00:32:51.960We can make sure that a woman who is pregnant gets all of the benefits of a woman who has a child outside of the womb.
00:33:15.180And if not, then why are you even bringing this up?
00:33:17.460Of course, these are all fallacious points that the skim doesn't feel like thinking through.
00:33:26.000And I guess that's why it's called the skim.
00:33:27.800They're not really encouraging people to think.
00:33:29.920They're encouraging people to just skim and not to delve deep into their brains and actually give careful consideration to very complex topics.
00:33:42.280And so, again, I am in support of this and I'm happy about it.
00:33:55.420But that means even the smallest humans, even the most dependent humans.
00:33:59.980That is literally, by the way, the Christian ethic.
00:34:02.540The Christian ethic is that the vulnerable and the helpless and the powerless and the voiceless, the weakest among us deserve our utmost help and our utmost compassion.
00:34:18.420Of course, in this godless and depraved age that we are in, we have flipped that around to say that we should sacrifice the weak and the young in service to the satisfaction of the desires of adults.
00:34:36.980And yes, even a good desire to be a parent does not justify treating a child the way the IVF treats them.
00:35:29.860So this summary is from the Daily Wire.
00:35:32.980Willis is the first female district attorney for Fulton County, Georgia.
00:35:36.560Remember Fulton County during the election in 2020 when they had like a bathroom leak or something and so they couldn't count all of the votes that night?
00:35:56.820So she came to fame when she launched an investigation against former President Donald Trump, along with 18 others, for attempting to overturn the election results in the state.
00:36:05.580Willis was raised primarily by her father, which is interesting to note, a criminal defense lawyer and member of the Black Panthers, the radical political party that championed black civil rights.
00:36:17.560And he actually comes into this story at some point.
00:36:20.460So on August 14th, 2023, a Fulton County grand jury voted to charge Trump and others with the alleged crimes.
00:36:28.300But the case is now in jeopardy because it was recently revealed that she had an affair.
00:36:34.120That Fannie Willis had an affair with Nathan Wade, the lead prosecutor that she hired for the case.
00:36:41.600One of Trump's co-defendants has asked a judge to dismiss her from the case due to the allegations that she misused taxpayer dollars and showed favoritism to Wade.
00:36:51.760Of course, it was alleged that the two took luxury trips together, paid for with money Mr.
00:36:57.320Wade earned from his work on the probe.
00:37:13.640On February 15th, the hearing to disqualify the prosecutors and dismiss the case over the alleged misconduct began.
00:37:21.340So far, witnesses have testified that Willis and Wade were romantically involved from 2019 to 2022 before Willis hired him for the Trump case.
00:37:30.940Trump attorneys accused Willis and Wade of having an improper relationship that led them to profit off the prosecution.
00:37:36.900At the expense of taxpayers, Fannie Willis was not happy when she was asked in court about her relationship with Wade.
00:39:07.640When I took out a large amount of money on my first campaign, I kept some of the cash of that.
00:39:11.900Like, okay, she's talking about like why she gave Nathan Wade large payments of cash, which again is believed to be Fulton County taxpayer money.
00:39:23.100So not a good lady, obviously very corrupt here.
00:39:26.600And she probably just pursued this Trump prosecution for fame.
00:39:33.460And her dad actually came to her defense in this case, in this questioning too.
00:39:38.280And obviously any dad is going to come to the defense of his daughter.
00:39:42.740But it's interesting to see that he is still apparently involved in her political life.
00:39:49.700But for all of this, for having an affair with a married man and then having that married man play a role in this case against Donald Trump,
00:40:03.200that she is using for fame and then misusing taxpayer dollars in the midst of all of that,
00:40:09.320she is being hailed as a hero in some Georgia churches.
00:40:14.360So we've created just kind of like a short montage of several pastors at churches in Georgia saying,
00:40:23.520wow, Fannie Willis, she is doing God's work.