On this week's episode of Relatable, we discuss the latest in the abortion debate, including the latest from the University of Georgia and the controversial comments from a conservative Christian pastor. We also hear from a woman who has come out in favor of abortion as she is running for the U.S. Senate seat currently held by Sen. Kyrsten Sineman.
00:06:05.260We are talking about the violent poisoning and or dismembering of helpless babies.
00:06:12.680That's what we're talking about when we're using the soft music with the warm filters to make it seem like we're really thoughtfully, empathetically thinking through this complicated, private, personal issue.
00:06:25.920We are talking about the murder of people, okay?
00:06:29.380We are talking about chopping up babies.
00:06:32.260There's not much nuance to this, okay?
00:06:34.940So excuse me if I don't have a lot of patience for your pragmatism.
00:06:42.200So her video was in response to a ruling by the Arizona State Supreme Court that allowed an 1864 statute banning abortion to stand.
00:07:05.320And you'll remember Carrie Lake is a former Arizona governor candidate, and now she is an Arizona Senate candidate, and she wanted to respond to this because she is trying to win that independent vote that, of course, she lost when she ran for governor.
00:07:24.300Now, can I just be honest about what my take on Carrie Lake has always been?
00:07:28.440There was one day that we were going to have her on the show, and it didn't work out logistically.
00:07:41.380They get a lot of media requests, and she was kind enough to accept our invitation to come on the show.
00:07:46.380It didn't end up working out, and so I'll say that, that I'm thankful for, I guess, the respect that her team showed us in accepting our request, however long ago that was, maybe a year ago.
00:07:59.400However, I have never, I have never been a Carrie Lake fan.
00:08:06.960Do I think that it would have been better for the state of Arizona to have her as the governor versus who they have now?
00:08:14.380Absolutely, because the governor now, of course, is far left and absolutely stands for everything that I stand against, and Carrie Lake would have been better on immigration.
00:08:25.440She probably would have been better on abortion, better on gender, better on a lot of things, but when I look at her history, I don't see any kind of solid history of conservatism, and personally, I just, and you can say that this is superficial.
00:08:40.360You can say, you know, it's shallow, emotional, whatever.
00:08:43.380I just didn't like her persona, and when she lost, I completely understood why.
00:08:49.060And this whole gimmick of claiming that it was election fraud, that I'm not saying there's never any funny business going on in elections.
00:08:55.840You guys know that I understand that that's a definite possibility and even happens, but that she didn't actually lose that whole tear that she went on claiming that this was some kind of fraudulent fake election and that really she won.
00:09:13.900There's no possible way that her opponent could have won fair and square because she was so popular.
00:09:21.000I knew immediately that this is someone that wasn't going to appeal to most people in the purple state of Arizona and certainly wasn't going to appeal to a lot of women.
00:09:31.900It's interesting, and I think that she would probably agree with this, that she's kind of switched a little bit because she had an extremely, as she was running, a very masculine energy, like a very I'm so based Carrie Lake energy.
00:09:48.280And a lot of the male commentators in this space really liked her, always praised her and just thought that she was so strong, going to be an amazing champion for conservatism.
00:10:00.080And I just sat back and knew and knew I didn't say anything during the election because, of course, I thought that she'd be a better choice than her opponent.
00:10:07.840But now I'm looking at this and I'm like, OK, I see what she's doing.
00:10:13.400She realizes that she lost the female vote in Arizona because she was way too aggressive and not in an appealing way at all.
00:10:24.580And now she is trying to win back those women by pretending to be like or maybe she really is.
00:10:32.400I don't know, like this soft, gentle, genteel person and equivocating on something like abortion because she thinks that she is going to ingratiate herself to this group of women.
00:10:44.420I don't think that it's going to work.
00:10:46.900And it's for the same reason that I don't think that it's going to work for Donald Trump.
00:10:51.820I don't believe that there is this group of independents or this group of moderate conservatives or this group of independent, conservative or apolitical women who are all just waiting to vote Republican and all just waiting to vote for Donald Trump or waiting to vote for Carrie Lake, who is very much aligned with Donald Trump.
00:11:15.760But they just need to hear that Carrie Lake and Donald Trump are moderate on abortion and then they've secured their vote.
00:11:24.040I'm sorry. No, people who are in that camp that I just described, they don't like Trump.
00:11:48.800They could never tell their friends that they voted for him or anyone aligned with him.
00:11:55.100And they see him as potentially a convicted felon.
00:12:00.280So there is so much of a stigma surrounding MAGA that these people that Carrie Lake and Donald Trump are trying to appeal to are not going to be effectively swayed by this.
00:13:01.240I think that that is also going to chip away at the enthusiasm of the pro-life Christians who Donald Trump and other Republicans like him need to be their evangelists and be their apologists and be their supporters who will go out and tell other people and convince other people to vote for them.
00:13:24.700Now, those pro-life Christians will still vote for Donald Trump.
00:13:28.260I'm still going to vote for Donald Trump because I understand the binary option there.
00:13:35.060And RFK is just not an option for me because he is way too radical on abortion and some other issues.
00:13:41.560But while those pro-life Christians will vote for Donald Trump and might vote for Carrie Lake, will vote for the most pro-life option, they're going to have a hard time going out amongst their friends and communities and say, yes, it is your moral imperative to vote for this Republican candidate.
00:14:01.280Because at the end of the day, right now, we're looking at a field of pro-choicers.
00:14:05.420We're looking at a bunch of evil options when it comes to their abortion position, and we're just trying to decide which one is least evil.
00:14:15.380And abortion is a big enough issue that this is going to become very morally sticky for a lot of people who tend to vote Republican, a lot of Christians who tend to vote Republican.
00:14:28.880I just don't think that they are winning anyone over by this position, but you are potentially losing people by this position.
00:14:36.920And you're certainly losing their enthusiasm by this position, not to mention the fact that it is immoral.
00:14:43.080Like, we have justified other human rights atrocities not too long ago under the banner of states' rights.
00:14:57.540But it belongs in the same category as slavery because it is the objectification and the subjugation and the dehumanization of vulnerable, helpless people.
00:15:11.580And so in the year of our Lord, 2024, as we can look back at history and see exactly what it looks like when we treat a human being as if they are subhuman,
00:15:23.260when we decide that one group of people does not deserve rights based on how they look, based on what size they are, the abilities that they bring to the table, their innate characteristics,
00:15:36.980we understand that that kind of mentality leads to the systemic and atrocious trampling on the value and the dignity of that group of people.
00:15:55.340We can look at different conflicts throughout history and which one group of people is dehumanized.
00:16:01.060And we can see the trouble that that causes, that that doesn't actually lead to some kind of, like, big picture victory, that that doesn't help lead us to a place of freedom.
00:16:52.280When we think about it from the perspective of what an abortion is, what the procedure entails, what it is doing, and whom abortion is actually victimizing, a living, wiggling human being, then there's really no other moral or logical position to take except for, no, this has to be banned.
00:17:17.040And a baby that is conceived through rape, a baby that is conceived through incest is no less a baby.
00:17:26.140Tell me the difference between a baby that's conceived in rape and a baby that's not.
00:17:33.000When you're looking at it from the perspective of the victim, from the perspective of the baby, these kinds of exceptions are not only illogical, but yes, also immoral.
00:17:43.040And I just want to say one thing about the life of the mother argument that I heard Donald Trump make.
00:18:01.980Donald Trump said, okay, we have to have compassion and we have to make exceptions for rape, incest, and the life of the mother.
00:18:12.680So I already gave my stance on the rape, incest exceptions.
00:18:16.000As I've said many times before, I believe that rapists should get the death penalty, not the baby.
00:18:20.400The pro-choice position is that, and Donald Trump's position is that babies should be able to get the death penalty for a rape that someone else committed.
00:18:37.940So I'm of the radical extreme position that rapists should get the death penalty, not a baby.
00:18:43.840The pro-choice position, again, is actually the opposite, that we shouldn't have a death penalty for rapists or even murderers, but we should have the death penalty for babies.
00:18:56.180I know, I'm so crazy that I believe that that is egregious and immoral.
00:19:02.600But on the life of the mother, there is no reason for abortion to save the life of the mother.
00:19:10.780Every single pro-life law that exists allows for the removal of ectopic pregnancies.
00:19:21.420We do not consider that as pro-lifers, as Christians, an abortion.
00:19:25.400You are simply removing a child that did not grow where they have to be growing in order to survive.
00:19:35.060And because both the life of the mother and the baby are at risk, we save the life that we can save.
00:19:42.020So that is the pro-life position, is that we believe that the value of the mother's life is equal to the value of the baby's life.
00:19:51.780And so, when the mother's life is at risk when she is pregnant, we believe in delivering the child.
00:19:59.620Even if it's early, even if that child has to be put on life support, even if that child has a slim chance of surviving,
00:20:08.540we believe that if the mother is going to be saved by removing that child from the womb, then the child should be removed.
00:20:15.480But there is no reason for the child to be killed first.
00:20:18.000Because either way, early delivery, induced labor, and abortion, the baby is still coming out.
00:20:27.380There is no medical reason for the baby to be poisoned or dismembered first.
00:20:31.960If the baby needs to be removed to save the life of the mother, then deliver the baby.
00:20:36.720And do everything you possibly can to save that child, no matter how many weeks gestation that you are.
00:20:41.520I understand that before 24 weeks gestation, like the odds are very slim.
00:20:47.380I think the earliest has been 19 weeks, which is super, super, super preemie of a baby being born and actually surviving after being in the NICU for several months.