SHNEAKO - Orthodox Muslim debates Rabbi Aaron Golfiz after Rabbi Mizrachi LEAVES CALL

00:00:00.000 God's covenant with Israel is contingent upon their obedience and righteousness.

00:00:07.780 If you obey me, you will be my people and I will be your God.

00:00:13.640 But you kept killing God's prophets.

00:00:16.940 You worshipped a yellow cow after you ate bread and food from heaven. 0.84

00:00:22.740 You tried to kill Jeremiah.

00:00:24.960 Repeat that again, Aaron.

00:00:28.520 Genesis 1-1.

00:00:30.000 Okay, in the beginning, in the beginning, God created the heaven and the earth.

00:00:35.380 Okay, translate this.

00:00:39.260 I know the verse, brother.

00:00:44.080 Jews, you know, I'm sure a lot of people are watching this.

00:00:46.620 Jews are not here to go against anybody, fight people.

00:00:50.800 We want peace.

00:00:51.540 We love people.

00:00:52.400 We're not against it. 1.00

00:00:53.420 We all know, even the Palestinians.

00:00:54.860 I would love for the Palestinians. 1.00

00:00:56.320 You know, there's a lot of Arabs that live with Jews, become doctors, lower, go to the 0.99

00:00:59.660 schooling system you know i believe in free palestine but free palestine oh oh but from 0.88

00:01:04.400 thomas okay then then y'all shouldn't fund them then bb shouldn't give them 35 million again i

00:01:10.060 i don't think he's funding them but he is only watch my film torah and science that's it i'm not

00:01:15.500 asking we can we can have a discussion right now we've been speaking 2v1 you brought somebody in

00:01:19.860 let's speak about the inconsistency after you will watch my film torah and science there would be no

00:01:25.860 reason to discuss this ever again if you if you appreciate the truth then we can we can have this

00:01:30.340 conversation now about the inconsistencies in the quran this is muslim orthodox so okay so again

00:01:35.620 again listen to me when i just say please go rabbi mizrahi torah come on before you promote

00:01:41.460 let's you can't discuss i'm not if your people wants to listen to me they know where to find me

00:01:47.860 instagram youtube divineinformation.com you made a lot of claims about islam let's clarify i'm not

00:01:53.140 Asking that I'm on I'm only asking to watch to learn science and then come back to me

00:01:59.320 With the land the land belongs to the Muslims rabbi. God gave us gave it to us 4,000 years ago on Sinai 0.88

00:02:09.740 King David King David was a Muslim the ancient Israelite state is almost

00:02:13.860 I was a Muslim if Islam started only 1,300 years ago and King David 3,000 years ago. Oh good question 0.99

00:02:21.080 How was Abraham a Jew according to the Talmud?

00:02:27.180 Don't let me finish brother, please

00:02:31.560 Nico Nico, I gotta go please

00:02:43.340 Thank you so much

00:02:46.460 Why are you running? I care about the

00:02:50.740 According to the Talmud, Abraham kept the Torah and the rabbinic commands of the Torah.

00:02:59.760 That's in the Talmud. 0.97

00:03:00.580 So if they want to talk about anachronism, well, how on earth could David be a Muslim if Islam didn't come? 0.81

00:03:07.540 Well, how on earth could Abraham keep the Torah and the mitzvot from the rabbis if the Torah was revealed after Abraham? 0.91

00:03:16.620 Go ahead, Aaron. 0.96

00:03:18.020 This is a very good question.

00:03:19.560 Okay.

00:03:19.760 there's multiple answers to it right now

00:03:22.560 that's not the conversation right now

00:03:24.480 we're talking about other things

00:03:25.360 this is what we're talking about

00:03:27.680 if you want to know the answer

00:03:29.840 I got to go soon also

00:03:31.600 no I don't have time

00:03:34.360 everything you said about

00:03:36.620 Islam is false

00:03:37.640 everything 1.00

00:03:38.820 I just answered your question

00:03:41.820 the Jewish people

00:03:44.820 only started at

00:03:46.480 Mount Sinai, before that we were just

00:03:48.360 israelites did abraham keep the torah that's your answer did abraham what does that mean

00:03:52.440 there's again the talmud again you guys i've never studied talmud yeah do you know how to read

00:03:56.520 hebrew or no yes i know how to read hebrew yeah not not not not not the best but i learned the

00:04:03.480 alphabet you know how to read if you gave me if you gave me a letter a word i could try my best

00:04:10.120 but don't don't don't don't don't pull out a book and don't run away answer the question

00:04:15.240 no so that has nothing to do with me reading hebrew or not i don't i don't understand i

00:04:20.040 if you pulled a book in hebrew i wouldn't be able to understand it so i could read

00:04:24.040 barely but i'm just saying listen listen let me just look that's besides the point let me finish

00:04:31.640 listen that's a question listen i'm not an expert in talmud i don't know every question

00:04:36.760 in the world i'm not coming to answer every question but i'm just saying i remember learning

00:04:40.440 this there's multiple answers to this question and i'm just saying i don't think you've ever

00:04:44.840 Are you an expert in Islam because you were saying things about Qur'an having mistakes, the Prophet Muhammad didn't have any witnesses. Do you want to talk about that?

00:04:56.340 I know my basics.

00:04:58.300 Okay, you made some claims. Do you want to talk about it?

00:05:01.500 Listen, you came at like an hour into the conversation.

00:05:06.260 Come on, dude.

00:05:07.500 I'm just saying I don't have time to argue right now.

00:05:10.300 You're so confident. We have the truth.

00:05:12.760 Wait, I want to say, I want to just say, let me just ask you a couple of things.

00:05:16.360 You can answer his questions, but now you can ask questions.

00:05:19.300 No, I don't, listen, there's, I remember learning the answers.

00:05:22.000 I can't tell you at the top of my head.

00:05:23.620 That's, I'm not going to say, you know. 0.98

00:05:25.060 Brother, you were just telling Sneeko all kind of things about Islam.

00:05:29.420 Oh, okay, so wait, I just want to, I just want to quickly say something.

00:05:33.120 First of all, again, we respect every Muslim.

00:05:36.180 We expect every Christian.

00:05:37.960 You know, we're not against anybody.

00:05:39.560 and we can have you know everybody knows jews believe in one thing christians believe another

00:05:43.640 muslim believe but we can still live peacefully with that's fine okay i have a question for you

00:05:47.240 just wait no no so i have a question if god it's nico didn't answer this question if god has a

00:05:52.920 track record that he started judaism the truth with millions of people there right yeah how come

00:05:58.200 with christianity and islam why did he only start with one person every religion besides for judaism

00:06:03.240 It didn't. That's not true.

00:06:05.640 There were many prophets.

00:06:07.060 Muhammad was by himself. 0.99

00:06:09.040 Final prophet. 0.97

00:06:10.400 Let me answer that. Aaron, you want an answer?

00:06:13.740 Because God didn't

00:06:15.140 start Judaism. The revelation 0.72

00:06:17.300 on Sinai is the revelation 0.88

00:06:19.420 of Islam to Moses.

00:06:21.620 Moshe Rabbeinu.

00:06:22.420 Okay, so where does it say in the Quran

00:06:24.020 about Islam? Where does it say one time about Islam?

00:06:26.860 Sorry, in the Torah.

00:06:28.660 Where does it say it? Show me one place.

00:06:31.000 I got you.

00:06:31.600 and if that's the case

00:06:34.000 why are you not letting me answer anything

00:06:36.780 let him answer

00:06:38.060 you ask one question

00:06:39.300 let him answer the question

00:06:40.200 let me answer you brother

00:06:44.360 you want an answer

00:06:45.980 you're panicking already

00:06:48.460 so the revelation

00:06:50.800 the revelation of God

00:06:52.600 of his religion

00:06:54.380 does not necessitate

00:06:56.340 that he reveals

00:06:57.840 each prophet

00:07:00.400 the same law

00:07:01.560 For example, do you believe Noah followed the Torah?

00:07:05.220 Did God reveal?

00:07:06.820 God gave him the seven Noah high laws. 0.98

00:07:09.040 Good. 0.96

00:07:09.540 So he didn't follow the same law as you, right? 0.94

00:07:12.620 He gave the seven Noah high laws, yes. 0.85

00:07:14.300 Did he follow the same law as you? 0.92

00:07:15.920 No, he didn't have the 613 commandments.

00:07:17.640 Okay, beautiful.

00:07:18.980 Good, good.

00:07:19.860 But you still think he's still upon the religion of God, yeah?

00:07:24.440 Because he wasn't commanded.

00:07:26.100 He wasn't obligated.

00:07:26.760 Good, good, good. 0.62

00:07:28.040 So the Muslims at the time of Moses were commanded with the Torah. 0.76

00:07:34.240 The Muslims at the time of Abraham were commanded with whatever God told Abraham to do. 0.91

00:07:38.900 The Muslims at the time of Noah commanded whatever Noah was commanded to do. 0.96

00:07:42.740 And the Muslims at the time of the Prophet Muhammad were commanded with the Gentile law. 0.98

00:07:48.260 The coming kingdom of God prophesied in the Torah and the Tanakh and the Prophets. 0.93

00:07:52.580 Daniel speaks about it. Isaiah. Deuteronomy speaks about it.

00:07:55.560 If we want to talk about it, I could show you.

00:07:57.640 No, but you're missing a point.

00:08:00.960 When you look at the total difference between the Noah high laws and the 613 commandments.

00:08:06.100 The Noah high laws, God gave for all humanity. 0.91

00:08:10.680 And the Jews were obligated to keep those laws. 0.92

00:08:13.940 But once Mount Sinai kicked in, God gave 613. 1.00

00:08:17.920 Good, I agree with you. 0.99

00:08:19.920 And if you ever read the Torah, have you ever read the Torah before?

00:08:22.540 No, I'm just curious.

00:08:23.820 Yes?

00:08:24.720 So if you know, it says it all over the Torah.

00:08:26.360 The commandments will always apply.

00:08:28.400 I will never know by my commandments.

00:08:30.440 Can I respond to that?

00:08:31.080 So my question to you is, where is your Shabbat?

00:08:33.400 Where is your kosher?

00:08:34.180 I'm going to respond.

00:08:35.820 Yes.

00:08:36.100 So Aaron brings something very interesting.

00:08:39.460 He says, well, you know, the Torah says that...

00:08:42.100 I got to really go in 10 minutes.

00:08:43.860 Okay, let me answer you.

00:08:45.940 According to you, you just said,

00:08:47.600 the Torah says that the commandments, the mitzvot, 0.87

00:08:51.280 are forever. 0.56

00:08:53.200 Ha'alam. 0.62

00:08:54.080 Alam they're forever right that's what the Hebrew says well guess what he says that well according to this the Torah will never end 0.55

00:09:03.680 Now this is only according to Rambam and a rabbi 0.80

00:09:08.940 Joseph

00:09:10.160 Albo refutes Rambam and he says that the Torah never says that the commandments are forever as a matter of fact

00:09:18.080 If you go to the Levit. Yeah, yeah, yeah, you see if you go to

00:09:24.080 Let me finish. Let me finish. Let me finish bro. Rambam. Rambam gives that as a principle. The other rabbis disagree with Rambam like Joseph Alba who says Rambam is wrong with this. I could show you that. We could read it together right now.

00:09:40.540 Let me finish, bro.

00:09:42.440 You keep cutting me off, man.

00:09:43.400 Let me speak.

00:09:45.100 Okay?

00:09:45.940 When the Torah says that certain laws are forever,

00:09:49.560 first of all, it doesn't say it for every law.

00:09:51.260 It says it for some laws.

00:09:52.580 That you'll practice this from generation to generation forever. 0.85

00:09:56.960 Now, according to the same Torah, 0.51

00:09:59.480 it says forever for certain things,

00:10:02.400 but it's a long period of time.

00:10:04.000 For example, God says to the Israelites,

00:10:06.480 I have carried you from forever, from olam.

00:10:09.200 But the Israelites weren't carried by God forever.

00:10:12.420 God says to the children of Aaron that he will establish the Levitical priesthood forever.

00:10:19.720 But guess what?

00:10:20.960 If you go to 2 Samuel, he cancels that priesthood because they disobeyed.

00:10:27.780 And he takes it away from one of his sons.

00:10:30.040 So did God contradict himself there?

00:10:31.860 Wait, wait, wait.

00:10:32.600 Go back there.

00:10:33.540 Did God contradict himself when he said, I will establish the priesthood forever?

00:10:36.740 First of all, they just didn't serve in the temple.

00:10:40.400 They were still priests.

00:10:41.420 Did he take it away?

00:10:43.280 They couldn't serve in the temple, but they were still priests.

00:10:44.800 I said, did he take it away according to Samuel?

00:10:47.300 What's the verse?

00:10:48.020 You're talking about the sons of Eli?

00:10:49.420 Who are you talking about?

00:10:49.940 Yes.

00:10:51.040 He says, he quotes it.

00:10:52.720 God speaks.

00:10:53.840 He quotes the Torah.

00:10:55.040 He says, I told you before that you will serve as my priest forever.

00:11:00.760 But now I tell you, far be it from me.

00:11:04.560 he cancels his eternal promise right again I have to go look at the verses I'm

00:11:09.900 not you know it's on the top of my head and I'm not gonna go like look at it

00:11:12.720 right now but I thought I don't I don't remember every single verse in the Tanakh

00:11:19.680 by heart you know I'm not Toby a singer you know you should go to him for that

00:11:22.680 but I just want to interview to be a singer on my channel but I just want to

00:11:26.700 go to the verses that I do know the revealed is for us and our children

00:11:29.940 forever to carry out all the words of the Torah Deuteronomy 29 28 he established

00:11:34.140 testimony in Jacob and set down a Torah in Israel which you commanded our fathers to make them known

00:11:38.300 to their children so the final generation may know children yet to be born arise and tell their own

00:11:44.220 children so that they put their confidence in God and not forget God's great deeds and they'll

00:11:48.700 observe his commandments psalm 78 5 to 7 okay the Torah is steadfast for all eternity formed in truth

00:11:55.400 and fairness he commanded his covenant for all eternity psalms 111 8 to 9 my son and this is

00:12:01.420 Proverbs 3.1. My son, do not

00:12:03.420 forget my Torah. Let your mind retain

00:12:05.260 my commandments. Isaiah says it

00:12:07.200 beautifully, 48.

00:12:08.760 Grass withers and flowers fade,

00:12:11.160 but the word of God is not forever.

00:12:12.620 Can we deal with one by one?

00:12:15.180 I'm just saying.

00:12:16.320 You're not actually responding to my point.

00:12:18.720 I am. My point is,

00:12:20.760 you're completely contributing to the Torah.

00:12:22.920 The Torah says the commandments.

00:12:24.180 I don't believe.

00:12:25.600 Wait, wait. Let me finish.

00:12:26.840 This looks bad, Aaron.

00:12:29.620 You're not letting me talk.

00:12:30.660 You're not actually wanting to have a convo.

00:12:32.620 You just want to read verses and not talk about them.

00:12:35.360 Wait, wait, you spoke.

00:12:36.760 Okay, okay, go ahead, go ahead.

00:12:38.400 Okay, thank you.

00:12:39.160 I appreciate that.

00:12:40.160 All I'm saying is I don't,

00:12:42.120 I myself don't think you have to keep the commandments.

00:12:44.780 That's not what I'm saying, okay?

00:12:46.780 Only if you're born to, you know, 1.00

00:12:48.360 Jewish mother or whatever,

00:12:49.360 or you converted to Judaism, 0.65

00:12:50.660 okay, then you're obligated. 0.71

00:12:51.920 So I'm not saying for you to keep it,

00:12:53.800 but I'm just saying if you're claiming to be 0.97

00:12:55.340 the real Jewish people,

00:12:56.520 like the black Israelites.

00:12:57.440 I didn't say that. 0.53

00:12:59.600 Okay.

00:12:59.820 So I don't believe the commandments apply to you,

00:13:02.280 but it applies to the Jewish people. 1.00

00:13:03.460 You're not getting it.

00:13:04.660 What's the argument?

00:13:05.160 You're not getting it.

00:13:05.920 So brother, deal with the point at hand.

00:13:08.160 You quoted me verses that say the Torah is forever.

00:13:10.680 I already quoted you Rabbi Joseph Alba

00:13:12.960 who says forever doesn't mean forever.

00:13:14.960 And that there are certain...

00:13:15.900 That's not true.

00:13:16.880 Brother, you keep cutting me off.

00:13:19.140 You read Stether Ikarim or no?

00:13:20.760 Yes, yes, yes.

00:13:22.760 You read from beginning to end.

00:13:23.840 Okay, what are the three things?

00:13:25.980 What is it really?

00:13:27.000 Brother, stop cutting me off.

00:13:29.040 I'm trying to make my point you keep

00:13:37.400 Let's see

00:13:39.160 I don't think you read the book

00:13:41.700 This is not part of the point

00:13:42.660 Yo, this guy, brother, stop cutting me off

00:13:45.900 I'm trying to tell you, man

00:13:46.900 It's alright

00:13:47.860 There's no problem

00:13:49.180 I'm asking you, did you read that book or not?

00:13:54.180 Brother, do you want me to have a conversation with you

00:13:56.860 Or you just want to run, bro?

00:13:57.820 No, I think you're not okay. We'll see just stop. Just zip it for a second. Just zip it, bro

00:14:04.700 Just zip it for a sec. Okay, so your point was a Torah's forever because the Torah says forever over and over again

00:14:10.480 I told you rabbi is like Joseph elbow disagree with that and he does that and suffer how Kareem 0.63

00:14:15.680 Okay, now if you disagree with that, we could go ahead. I have I have the PDF book here 0.98

00:14:20.640 I have all the passage height that we can go through it. That's besides the point

00:14:27.820 brother do you have brother are you autistic by any chance do you have a problem in your head 0.92

00:14:33.700 all right so let me finish that stop being autistic you can't say 100 points and then 0.97

00:14:38.260 say what you have to say oh my god brother you just keep let me engage your points bro stop 0.98

00:14:43.620 so you said the torah says forever i told you forever in the hebrew does not mean forever

00:14:51.120 means for a long time or an uh assuming that the conditions are fulfilled here is the evidence

00:14:57.780 for that does the torah say that the slave must serve his master forever yes or no

00:15:03.940 would tell me the verse wait wait wait wait wait wait wait wait wait wait wait wait wait wait

00:15:08.980 this is not fair you keep going to a new point to be fair it is the same point it is the same

00:15:14.980 point why do you keep you don't want to engage you get to attack it's not another argument we're

00:15:21.940 talking about being forever it's the same thing can you clarify that okay i'm i'm right now talking

00:15:27.220 of the Rav Yosef Abu stop going to your point you want to read it you want to read it no no wait

00:15:32.660 wait i'm asking you a simple question because you said sure let's read it let's read it no no don't

00:15:36.660 use chat gbt i didn't give me chat you can see i'm on google drive i have it on my drive bro wait

00:15:41.860 answer the question i'm asking you a question and you want me to pull it up for you here we go

00:15:46.660 wait wait you're not answering me name me the three things Rav Yosef Abu said are the

00:15:51.780 The Ikarim of Amunah

00:15:53.020 are the main foundations of Amunah. 0.79

00:15:55.120 Name me the three things.

00:15:55.920 So first of all,

00:15:58.340 I didn't say that I read

00:15:59.520 every single month mark.

00:16:01.360 Okay, so you don't even know

00:16:02.260 what the book is saying, my friend.

00:16:03.360 Let me finish, dudes.

00:16:05.340 I didn't say, remember,

00:16:07.160 you're talking faster than you could think

00:16:09.020 because you're panicking.

00:16:10.640 Okay, when you asked me,

00:16:12.160 did you read the whole book?

00:16:13.400 I told you, I was about to answer you,

00:16:15.180 but you cut me off.

00:16:16.560 I was going to say, no, I've only...

00:16:18.880 Dude, what's wrong with you?

00:16:19.940 I'm listening, I'm listening.

00:16:21.120 i i was gonna say no i've only read mamar 30 where he we discusses this issue i only read

00:16:28.560 where he discusses this issue not the whole book and that found it let me finish no no no because

00:16:37.920 no no i never cut you guys off i was speaking 2v1 for an hour i never cut you guys off

00:16:43.280 this is not fair yeah but same thing with rabbi mizray i allowed you guys to finish

00:16:47.520 speaking before i spoke this is incredible you didn't even read the whole book and he's acting

00:16:51.920 like what the book says you're panicking let's read it you want to read it let's read it let's

00:16:57.120 read it you want to read it here we go you don't because you have to you don't want to read it he

00:17:00.480 doesn't want to repeat it i want to read it let's just read it let's just read it let's just read

00:17:06.560 it okay go same yes let's let me let me pull it up here i got it right here on my google drive

00:17:17.520 I got to go in one minute.

00:17:19.880 I'm sorry.

00:17:21.520 That's not enough to read it, brother.

00:17:23.340 I know.

00:17:23.860 Please just hurry.

00:17:25.700 Because I'm so awake right now.

00:17:27.320 Here we go.

00:17:29.420 Joseph Elbow.

00:17:30.380 Perfect.

00:17:31.360 So he says in Mamar 3, 16, he says,

00:17:36.200 This is on Sepharia.

00:17:38.560 Nor can any evidence be found in the expressions eternity or unto eternity

00:17:44.560 or a statute for eternity or to eternity for these expressions and their like are also applied

00:17:51.960 to a limited and not an infinite time thus we read remove not the ancient landmark which thy

00:18:01.140 fathers have set the word olam is here used to denote a time limited and dating from the fathers

00:18:09.540 Then he says, Thus Hannah said, I will bring him that he may appear before the Lord and abide there forever.

00:18:17.080 The expression here means only 50 years, which the term of a Levite, as we find from the age of 50 years, 0.61

00:18:26.140 and they shall return from their servant of the work and shall serve no more. 0.74

00:18:30.220 The expression on to eternity also is applied to a finite time and not known to man, but to God alone.

00:18:36.980 So does he say what I said there?

00:18:38.220 okay but i think you're taking it out of context there's certain things when yeah it is this is

00:18:44.100 oh so now when i want to talk all of a sudden all right so how am i made taken out of context go

00:18:49.100 okay number one there's certain things right when there's an exaggeration forever okay like you saw

00:18:55.520 what you just read when hannah said okay i'll give my son forever fine whatever whatever verse you

00:18:59.900 just said okay first of all if you read sefer ikarim which i again like you said you've never

00:19:05.020 read it in your life okay i didn't say that i said i read the whole thing sorry the whole book i'm

00:19:10.240 saying it's literally the heading of the book dude i know you find that line if you never read the

00:19:21.980 book okay fine you go to safaria you look up joseph elbow you find his book how do you know

00:19:27.620 you go to you go to mamar three how do i know how do i i do my own research what how do i know

00:19:39.860 okay fine no i read the section where he refused to say that about the man you actually

00:19:45.780 yes he does that about the commandments oh my god okay okay no no no no no no no no

00:19:51.140 Aaron, Aaron, Aaron, Aaron, Aaron, Aaron, you are panicking right now, you are running away, you're panicking, you're running away from the point, you're running away from the point, okay, I thought you have to leave in a minute, go ahead, go ahead, and I want you to respond to the verses in the Torah.

00:20:11.860 I just, okay, I just, those, okay, you're quoting specific commandments.

00:20:16.960 Who said that applies to all commandments?

00:20:19.080 That's number one.

00:20:19.980 I just showed you verses.

00:20:21.120 I gave you all the verses here that God clearly says,

00:20:24.080 I want the Jewish people to observe the Torah for all generations and all the commandments.

00:20:28.240 And how did I respond to that?

00:20:29.940 Okay, yes.

00:20:31.140 What did I respond to that?

00:20:32.740 Wait, I know, you can't, you're just applying the word le'olam.

00:20:36.160 Again, you don't know Hebrew, I'm sorry to say.

00:20:37.460 No, no, what did I respond to that?

00:20:39.340 What did I respond to that?

00:20:40.440 You're just saying, wherever you see 0.97

00:20:42.540 le olam, right, that doesn't

00:20:44.560 mean for all generations. That's not what I said.

00:20:46.580 Okay, but wait, let me just finish. You're not listening.

00:20:48.560 You're not listening. Let me finish my point.

00:20:50.360 Bro, this guy's wasting time.

00:20:52.240 Wait, let me finish my point.

00:20:54.260 He doesn't want to engage. Okay.

00:20:56.500 Rabbi Yosef Abel, you never read his book.

00:20:58.380 His book says that

00:21:00.100 he's going on the Rambam.

00:21:02.700 Rambam said there's 13 principles of Judaism.

00:21:04.920 He agrees to all the principles

00:21:06.500 Rambam said, but he's saying what?

00:21:08.600 But he's trying to say 0.90

00:21:09.740 Rambam, I agree with you

00:21:12.500 meaning what? I agree with the 13 1.00

00:21:14.400 he believes in all 13 principles

00:21:15.860 but he says that what?

00:21:17.620 that these 13 can be put into 3 categories

00:21:20.840 the belief in God

00:21:22.000 the belief in the divinity of Torah

00:21:23.660 and the idea of reward and punishment

00:21:25.580 so Rav Yosef Abel, yes you're giving examples

00:21:28.660 of certain mitzvot, for example

00:21:30.320 again I think you're giving the

00:21:32.280 Yovel example where it says Laulam, fine

00:21:34.120 yes there's certain examples

00:21:36.340 but again, that doesn't mean

00:21:37.820 that applies to all the commandments and he himself you're making it seem like he doesn't

00:21:41.920 believe in that which that's not true he does believe all the commandments always apply to

00:21:45.640 the final generation so i'm sorry how i let this guy speak and he doesn't let me speak

00:21:49.220 you see that wait now i would now i would love to interrupt me so now i would love to for you

00:21:54.980 to stop being a bot and actually engage like a regular human being i oh my god i think i think

00:22:01.480 your way of just doing it oh my god let's be fair let's be fair let's be fair let's be fair

00:22:07.060 you just spoke it uninterrupted come on no i know i mean you're just you're just way out of your

00:22:15.900 depth you feel you feel threatened that's why you feel you're just trying to oh my god just 0.98

00:22:22.400 shut up okay you don't need to say shut up let's hear the response let's hear the response no 0.96

00:22:26.700 interruptions for 30 seconds 30 seconds before before you before you leave let's just hear 30 0.98

00:22:34.140 seconds under interrupted go go so aaron doesn't actually want to engage with the evidence from

00:22:40.120 the torah i do i just quoted you you just said you were going to have autism bro you you have

00:22:47.420 autism i'm convinced of it yeah thank you so he doesn't actually want to engage with the evidence

00:22:51.880 from the torah right i quoted him joseph elbow he says oh have you read the whole book what's

00:22:57.720 the specific passage from this yeah that these theatrics don't work okay joseph elbow believes

00:23:04.600 in all the commandments there's no way dude come on man come on so anyways joseph elbow the whole

00:23:12.520 mamar there is him discussing my marty's idea of can the torah be abrogated can a prophet come

00:23:21.880 and say no more Torah.

00:23:24.300 Maimonides says no. 0.95

00:23:26.100 Joseph Albo says yes

00:23:27.960 with the specific condition

00:23:29.680 that he's greater than Moses,

00:23:31.800 which can't be met.

00:23:33.580 Therefore, nobody can come

00:23:35.100 and abrogate the Torah.

00:23:36.120 But hypothetically,

00:23:37.400 if there's a greater prophet than Moses,

00:23:39.640 and I see you shaking your head, 1.00

00:23:40.580 that means you agree,

00:23:41.700 that means somebody can come 0.96

00:23:43.340 and abrogate the Torah

00:23:43.920 only under that condition.

00:23:45.800 And under that hypothetical condition, 0.81

00:23:47.940 well, how do we deal with the Torah 0.77

00:23:49.260 being eternal?

00:23:50.020 Well, it doesn't actually mean

00:23:50.980 being eternal.

00:23:51.460 and so on and so forth, right?

00:23:54.000 And he brings the passages

00:23:55.260 we're on to eternity.

00:23:56.520 Ha'olam can refer to

00:23:58.120 a long period of time.

00:23:59.180 Now, I brought the evidence

00:24:00.520 from the Torah

00:24:01.120 where God says

00:24:02.740 that the Levitical priesthood

00:24:04.320 for the sons,

00:24:05.440 for a specific son of Aaron

00:24:07.020 will be forever.

00:24:09.880 Aaron, direct question.

00:24:11.540 Give me the verse

00:24:12.540 because I got to look inside.

00:24:13.560 Give me the verse.

00:24:14.180 Go.

00:24:14.720 Give me the verse. 0.99

00:24:15.420 Okay, let's pull it up. 0.99

00:24:17.140 Let's pull it up.

00:24:17.700 Okay, but I really have to go.

00:24:18.960 I have it.

00:24:20.620 I have it right here.

00:24:22.460 Don't worry.

00:24:22.900 It's not going to take a long time.

00:24:23.860 But again,

00:24:24.360 he believes in all commandments

00:24:25.760 so always apply.

00:24:26.800 And he just says,

00:24:27.580 it doesn't disqualify you as a Jew.

00:24:29.460 Here we go.

00:24:30.520 You asked for the verse, please.

00:24:32.060 Don't go somewhere else.

00:24:33.460 Okay.

00:24:33.760 So it's Exodus 29.9.

00:24:36.320 That's where God gives the eternal promise

00:24:39.120 to the son of Aaron.

00:24:41.020 He says,

00:24:41.660 wrap the sashes around the waist.

00:24:43.020 No, no, I know that.

00:24:43.500 You don't need to give that verse.

00:24:44.280 Give the verse in Samuel.

00:24:45.320 Okay.

00:24:45.760 Okay.

00:24:46.140 So you agreed that he says

00:24:47.480 this will be binding forever in Exodus, right?

00:24:50.200 Okay.

00:24:50.620 yes okay good yeah go to first Samuel 230 read from verse 27 actually 227

00:25:09.340 it's like a kai sinat stream

00:25:28.460 mashallah peaceful 0.95

00:25:31.420 did you read it let me know when you read it oh my gosh gross

00:25:38.460 yeah oh my gosh is right let me know when you read it 0.99

00:25:43.060 it doesn't say he took away the priest did you read it he's gonna kill his descendants

00:25:50.660 did you read it did you read it okay let's read it for everybody right

00:25:54.500 let me read let me read it for everybody i got it right here now a man of god came to

00:25:59.920 Eli and said to him, this is what the Lord says, did I not clearly reveal myself to your

00:26:04.340 ancestors' family when they were in Egypt under Pharaoh? I chose your ancestor out of

00:26:08.840 all the tribes of Israel to be my priest. Are you reading Exodus? Samuel. 2 Samuel 22, 27 to 30.

00:26:18.320 Then he says, why do you scorn my sacrifice and offering that I prescribed for my dwelling?

00:26:24.840 This is God speaking.

00:26:26.080 Why do you honor your sons more than me by fattening yourselves on the choice parts that the offering made by the people of Israel?

00:26:33.340 Verse 30. Here we go.

00:26:35.200 Therefore, the Lord, the God of Israel declares, I promised that members of your family would minister before me forever.

00:26:45.100 But now the Lord declares, far be it from me.

00:26:50.180 Those who honor me with their lips I will honor.

00:26:54.680 For those who despise me will be dishonored.

00:26:57.660 So does God recall the eternal promise?

00:27:00.740 And does He say, far be it from me?

00:27:03.560 Okay.

00:27:06.500 It's very clear.

00:27:07.720 I wish you read the rest of the verse.

00:27:09.780 It's very simple. 1.00

00:27:10.500 You know Kohanim. 1.00

00:27:11.360 I don't know if you know,

00:27:12.460 like, you know, if you ever read the whole Torah.

00:27:13.880 We just want a direct answer, please.

00:27:15.580 Okay, I'm giving you an answer. 0.87

00:27:16.360 Kohanim have many, many descendants, right? 1.00

00:27:19.020 Oh, boy. 1.00

00:27:19.500 A lot of descendants.

00:27:20.220 Can you answer the question?

00:27:22.000 I'm answering the question.

00:27:23.220 Does he take away the eternal promise?

00:27:25.040 Wait, let me, let me, see, you also interrupt.

00:27:27.360 Do you see?

00:27:27.860 And then I just want a direct answer.

00:27:29.660 I'm not calling you names.

00:27:30.780 I'm not trying to respond.

00:27:31.840 I'm not, I'm not either.

00:27:32.880 Can you do a direct answer? 1.00

00:27:34.720 There are many Kohanim. 1.00

00:27:36.180 And because the sons of Eli were, Eli, were being bad, 1.00

00:27:41.380 Hashem said to him, guess what? 1.00

00:27:44.260 The Kohanim, instead of your family, 1.00

00:27:46.460 I'm going to choose a different Kohanim family. 1.00

00:27:48.700 Oh, good. 1.00

00:27:49.620 And meaning what? 1.00

00:27:51.080 I'm going to kill your descent, 1.00

00:27:52.160 meaning your descendant wait wait wait let me finish meaning meaning what your descendants 0.99

00:27:56.960 are gonna die but that doesn't mean there's no such thing as coonium i didn't say i didn't say

00:28:01.500 there's no such thing as coonium anymore but if you read the rest of the verse listen the original

00:28:07.080 wait wait you're panicking you're panicking dude let him do it let him respond let him respond you

00:28:12.280 just love saying panicking that's your attack because that wasn't my that wasn't that wasn't

00:28:18.600 my question. I didn't say there's no priesthood anymore. I didn't say that. That wasn't my

00:28:27.840 question. I'm not asking about priesthood. I wanted to hear your response, but can you

00:28:34.100 answer? He just basically said, I'm going to kill your kids. That's how they're not going 1.00

00:28:36.980 to be priests anymore. Nice. Okay. Nice. That doesn't answer my question. It does answer

00:28:40.720 your question. He didn't remove. Okay. Hold on. Let's pause for a second. Let's pause

00:28:47.460 for a second let's hear the direct question direct question direct answer can we just do that

00:28:52.580 wait can you wait what's your question what's your question here's the question did god say

00:28:58.140 hey eli i promised your descendants forever but now never mind well he did he did still have some

00:29:08.800 did it say all his descendants oh my god wait wait wait were you quoting the verse where it

00:29:13.120 says Ellie's descendants forever. Oh my God. Let's read it again. Now a man from God came to Eli.

00:29:20.140 Samuel 1. Verse 227. Verse 227. 30 is where he says I promise forever. Therefore the Lord, read 30, that's where it is.

00:29:29.780 Therefore the Lord, the God of Israel declares, I promise the members of your family, speaking to who? Eli.

00:29:38.100 Would minister before me forever. Wait, wait. Can I read the verse? I'm sorry. I'm reading it.

00:29:42.780 No, I don't want to hear from your...

00:29:44.500 I don't know what you're...

00:29:45.000 Oh, you don't want to hear from your...

00:29:45.800 Can you read it aloud then? 0.99

00:29:47.020 I have the original Hebrew.

00:29:48.420 Can you read it aloud? 0.97

00:29:51.440 Translate it so we can hear?

00:29:53.220 Yeah, just give me...

00:29:54.020 Let me just read it in my head.

00:29:55.420 Give me a second.

00:29:56.440 A man of God came to the end of the session.

00:29:58.680 Did I not appear to your ancestors' family

00:30:00.060 when they were in Egypt slaves to the house of Pharaoh 0.99

00:30:02.180 and choose them from all the tribes to be Kohen? 0.97

00:30:04.380 He's talking about Aaron, okay? 0.80

00:30:06.740 Because Elie wasn't in Egypt.

00:30:09.160 He's talking about Aaron, okay? 0.99

00:30:11.400 To the Kohen, huh? 1.00

00:30:12.020 and choose for him 1.00

00:30:12.660 among all the tribes

00:30:13.280 to be Kohen

00:30:13.820 he's talking about Aaron again

00:30:14.820 to burn the incest

00:30:15.880 to wear the effort before me

00:30:16.940 and to give your ancestors

00:30:18.060 family from the five offerings 0.95

00:30:19.240 of the children of Shem

00:30:19.740 meaning the sacrifices

00:30:20.500 why do you scorn my sacrifice

00:30:22.120 and my meal offerings

00:30:22.840 which I commanded

00:30:23.280 because you know why 0.99

00:30:23.900 who scorned 0.96

00:30:24.720 who scorned

00:30:25.540 he's mad at Eli

00:30:26.860 because Eli didn't

00:30:27.720 he's speaking at Eli right

00:30:29.360 yes

00:30:30.080 okay keep going now

00:30:31.360 why do you scorn my sacrifice

00:30:32.660 and my meal offerings

00:30:33.140 that I commanded you

00:30:33.800 brought in the Dolly Place

00:30:34.540 and your sons

00:30:35.500 and you honor your sons

00:30:37.520 more than me

00:30:38.100 why

00:30:38.660 didn't say deserve to die

00:30:40.180 right

00:30:40.760 because they were doing

00:30:41.400 they were doing sins his sons okay so okay to fadden yourselves wait therefore this is the word

00:30:49.160 of hashem god of israel i had indeed said that your family and your father and your father's

00:30:53.160 family would walk before me forever but now the word of hashem far be it for me to do so

00:30:57.780 i'm reading it reading it and scorn and and those that scorn me be cursed behold the days are coming

00:31:05.940 when i cut off your arm in the arm of your family's father from being any person in your family and 0.94

00:31:10.300 and you will see a rival koinan dwelling place. 1.00

00:31:12.600 But again, I have a question for you. 0.86

00:31:14.700 No, just wait.

00:31:16.000 Wait, wait, wait.

00:31:17.100 He said, bro, come on.

00:31:18.800 Let me answer. 0.98

00:31:19.900 Did God take the kingship away from Sha'ul? 0.69

00:31:21.600 What are you answering? 0.70

00:31:23.200 I haven't made the point.

00:31:24.700 What are you answering? 0.97

00:31:26.000 Did God take the kingship away from Sha'ul? 0.94

00:31:28.300 Yes or no? 0.96

00:31:30.100 You know Sha'ul is or no? 0.97

00:31:31.400 Yes. 0.98

00:31:31.900 God made it conditional. 1.00

00:31:33.800 So among the koinis, God said to Eli, 1.00

00:31:36.800 he made it conditional. 1.00

00:31:37.800 This guy is in literal panic mode.

00:31:39.900 Can I make the point before you answer?

00:31:41.440 I'm not in panic, but I don't know why you say panic.

00:31:43.300 Okay, so here's the clear question.

00:31:46.040 We're looking for a clear answer, okay?

00:31:49.060 Did God say, I promised you forever, but now be it far from me?

00:32:06.480 Listen, do you know what I need?

00:32:07.640 I need to look up the verse.

00:32:08.460 Can I get a clear answer, please?

00:32:10.560 I need to look up the verse.

00:32:11.280 Let me look up the verse now.

00:32:11.800 It says it in front of you.

00:32:13.860 No, no, because we're not like you guys.

00:32:16.720 We're not like you guys.

00:32:17.800 We believe in the oral Torah.

00:32:19.020 We don't just read the Bible literally like that.

00:32:21.300 We have the oral Torah.

00:32:22.060 Yo, bro, this is crazy.

00:32:24.700 Wait, let me just see what the Torah Shabal Pez says.

00:32:26.520 I have to go look at the oral Torah.

00:32:27.700 All right.

00:32:28.540 All right, let me see.

00:32:29.500 Let me look at the Torah.

00:32:30.120 Let me look at the quotes.

00:32:31.580 Okay, Tanakh.

00:32:33.780 We said judges. 0.98

00:32:36.260 We said Samuel 22.

00:32:37.900 What did you say?

00:32:38.460 22 27 27 at 30 okay give me a second

00:32:44.480 wait where did you say promise which verse says the word promise i'm just curious

00:33:07.340 He read it a few times now.

00:33:08.660 Wait, wait.

00:33:09.040 Can you just give me the exact verse where it says promise?

00:33:11.080 I'm just looking for the verse.

00:33:12.120 Oh, Lord.

00:33:12.880 Verse 30, brother.

00:33:16.300 You literally read it.

00:33:18.540 I intend it for you.

00:33:19.240 Wait, wait.

00:33:19.740 I'm just looking at it. 1.00

00:33:20.940 Different Tanakh. 1.00

00:33:21.640 I intend it for you and your Father. 0.84

00:33:22.880 I intend it for you and your Father to me.

00:33:23.320 I intend it for you forever.

00:33:26.420 Okay, wait. 0.65

00:33:36.360 And it was only the sons of Isham, or the explanation of Isham, or the idea of the creator, your family, father, Isham, originally made a rise of the koan, and a serpent from God, and stayed removed around to his ministry, and his son, however, at the time of the concubing, themselves of the mitzvah, and who was still doing to his fucking chassab, and his socio-koan, and I therefore took the koan away from them, and gave it to you, for you, the sons of Isham, and I gave that to Isham.

00:34:04.220 Oh it's literally

00:34:10.540 plain English. He's just saying

00:34:13.440 I just took away the koanin from you and I gave it to another 1.00

00:34:15.620 koanin. Good and he says 1.00

00:34:16.940 I told you it's going to be forever

00:34:19.560 but never mind right?

00:34:22.100 Well I think he gave it to him

00:34:23.380 conditionally. Yes. No!

00:34:25.820 Yes it was conditionally.

00:34:27.620 Just look does he say

00:34:29.160 I gave it to you forever

00:34:31.020 but now never mind?

00:34:34.220 Meaning, it would have been forever if you didn't sin.

00:34:37.180 Thank you! Yes! Amen! Welcome to Islam.

00:34:42.060 So we believe that the Torah is forever. 0.98

00:34:46.300 Okay, go ahead. Say what you're saying.

00:34:47.720 So then, God's covenant with Israel is contingent upon their obedience.

00:34:58.040 if you obey me

00:35:00.980 you will be my people

00:35:02.780 and I will be your God

00:35:04.520 but you kept killing 0.78

00:35:07.100 God's prophets 0.82

00:35:08.040 you worshipped a yellow cow 0.99

00:35:10.660 after you ate bread

00:35:12.360 and food from heaven 0.57

00:35:14.300 you tried to kill Jeremiah

00:35:16.780 you sow Isaiah

00:35:18.760 in half

00:35:19.440 where do you know all that from?

00:35:22.660 that you don't believe in

00:35:23.980 the Torah that you guys say is corrupted

00:35:25.200 I don't believe in it

00:35:26.400 you guys

00:35:28.220 what do you mean

00:35:29.080 Islam believes the Torah is corrupted

00:35:30.740 just because I believe it's corrupted

00:35:32.820 it doesn't mean that

00:35:33.660 how do you know which verses are which are the actual verses

00:35:36.500 but listen

00:35:37.160 I could answer that for you

00:35:39.920 how we know the distinction

00:35:42.380 is we

00:35:43.220 if you're not a Muslim

00:35:44.640 then you apply the historical critical method 0.77

00:35:46.980 and if you are a Muslim

00:35:48.780 and you've been convinced of Islam

00:35:50.720 and the Quran has been established for you

00:35:53.120 then you use the Quran as a muhaymin over it

00:35:55.720 Wait, can I just quickly just give you the same verse from Samuel 1, 12-22?

00:36:01.480 Just to answer your question, and let's just finish off.

00:36:03.860 God said, because you said God rejected the Jewish people,

00:36:06.560 for the sake of His great name, God will never abandon His people,

00:36:10.820 seeing that God undertook to make you His people.

00:36:14.020 Then let's look at Leviticus 26, 44-45. 0.68

00:36:17.120 Yet, even when they, the Jewish people, are in the land of their enemies, 0.99

00:36:20.140 I will not reject them or spurn them to destroy them. 1.00

00:36:23.480 Why? To cancel my covenant with them.

00:36:25.300 For I am the Lord their God.

00:36:26.700 I will remember them in their favor in the covenant

00:36:28.560 with the ancients whom I freed from the land of Egypt

00:36:30.880 in the sight of the nations to be their God, I the Lord.

00:36:33.400 Ezra 9.9

00:36:34.260 Though we are their servant,

00:36:35.320 God has not abandoned us in our bondage.

00:36:37.360 So what you're talking about is something like,

00:36:39.040 for example, the kingship.

00:36:39.960 Can I respond to you now?

00:36:40.640 The kwanut, which the Torah says,

00:36:42.940 for example, King Shaul, yes, that can be lost.

00:36:45.620 But when God said the Jewish people

00:36:47.000 are making an eternal covenant,

00:36:49.180 God is not a man, God is not a liar.

00:36:50.660 Can I respond to you now?

00:36:51.580 And God clearly says,

00:36:52.440 I will never reject the Jewish people.

00:36:53.820 Can I respond to that now?

00:36:55.300 Can I respond to that now?

00:36:56.960 Okay.

00:36:57.440 Okay, just let me, I know you got to go, but let me, you can't just throw verses and just go.

00:37:01.680 I know because you're going to see the last point and I'm going to have to respond in this discussion forever.

00:37:06.300 Just look, it's very simple.

00:37:08.040 But quickly, how do you answer that verse?

00:37:10.060 I'm answering right now.

00:37:11.780 Have you read Ezekiel's vision of the restoration of the temple?

00:37:16.760 Okay, yeah.

00:37:18.240 Okay, when the vision is restored, is it the same Torah or a different Torah?

00:37:24.440 What does that mean?

00:37:26.260 Is it the same commandments in Ezekiel or different commandments?

00:37:30.980 Listen, I have to go through the whole...

00:37:33.640 Listen, I didn't...

00:37:34.820 I'll give you an example.

00:37:36.560 No, no, but listen, listen, listen.

00:37:39.100 I'm not...

00:37:40.320 Listen to me, listen to me right now.

00:37:41.540 You're just not engaging. 1.00

00:37:43.660 I'm not coming to claim I'm an expert Tanakh. 1.00

00:37:45.580 You can go, bro. It's okay. 0.84

00:37:47.280 We appreciate your presence.

00:37:48.800 We thank you for being here.

00:37:50.200 It's okay.

00:37:51.080 If you can't answer, it's okay.

00:37:53.040 No, I'm not claiming to be an expert Tanakh.

00:37:54.920 Go ask Rabbi Toviyah Singer that question.

00:37:56.660 He's an expert in Tanakh.

00:37:57.580 He'll answer that question for you.

00:37:58.860 You asked me,

00:37:59.900 how do I know God didn't reject the Jewish people 1.00

00:38:02.500 and choose Islam, right? 0.95

00:38:03.800 I just gave you the verse 0.86

00:38:04.960 and you didn't answer that.

00:38:06.260 God said,

00:38:07.180 I will never leave the Jewish people 1.00

00:38:08.840 even when I put them in exile. 1.00

00:38:11.320 So I tried answering.

00:38:12.980 By giving verses that I thought could...

00:38:15.260 Oh, you want me to give you YouTube videos?

00:38:19.460 Of course I'm going to give you this.

00:38:20.300 I'm just saying.

00:38:21.960 So look, so I tried answering.

00:38:24.080 How about this?

00:38:24.480 You don't let me speak, man.

00:38:27.180 Get this book called Indisputable Truth.

00:38:28.340 Now you want to give your book a plug-in.

00:38:31.160 Get this book Indisputable Truth.

00:38:32.420 Go for it.

00:38:33.060 You'll see evidence for God's existence,

00:38:35.120 the Torah being true,

00:38:36.440 and the purpose of the life. 1.00

00:38:37.560 The book sucks. 0.99

00:38:39.280 God said you'll never leave the Jewish people. 1.00

00:38:40.940 I'm letting you know right now.

00:38:42.180 God is not a liar.

00:38:43.180 That's it.

00:38:43.760 I know God is not a liar.

00:38:45.920 That's why God is not a liar.

00:38:48.000 That's why he established with the Muslims

00:38:51.000 the covenant of Sinai.

00:38:52.460 He sent them the prophets. 0.84

00:38:53.480 You know, you know, you know, it's funny about the air if you knew Torah if you were a good Jew and you actually knew Torah you 0.80

00:39:15.280 You wouldn't know that God says in Deuteronomy 18 guys watch this boom in 0.68

00:39:20.340 In Deuteronomy 18, he says God won't speak to the people nationally anymore.

00:39:27.320 Yes, God.

00:39:28.380 Let me finish.

00:39:29.820 Let me finish.

00:39:31.780 There will never be a mass revolution again.

00:39:34.380 Just leave.

00:39:35.720 If you don't want to let me finish your sleep, bro.

00:39:39.500 Because every time you get cooked, you talk over me.

00:39:42.020 No, it's not cooked. 1.00

00:39:42.800 You give a great proof for Judaism.

00:39:45.200 You don't have to talk every time I'm speaking, bro.

00:39:48.040 You don't have to talk either.

00:39:49.620 No, I'm making my point.

00:39:50.920 What are you doing, man?

00:39:52.100 So you said, no, no, stop, bro.

00:39:54.720 Stop.

00:39:55.420 Just be quiet for a second.

00:39:56.940 Just one minute.

00:39:58.140 Your point is invalid. 0.93

00:39:59.540 You said, oh, well, why didn't God give another national revelation for Islam?

00:40:04.880 Well, the whole point is that the same God of Islam says in Deuteronomy 18, 0.65

00:40:10.920 when he says, 0.66

00:40:11.620 in Deuteronomy 18, 18, Deuteronomy 18, 16,

00:40:16.620 when he says that, he says that

00:40:19.020 in response to verse 15-16

00:40:20.760 where he says, let me not

00:40:22.940 hear the voice of the Lord my God

00:40:25.300 lest I die

00:40:26.660 meaning that Israel speaking saying

00:40:28.920 we don't want to hear God's voice 0.85

00:40:31.000 nationally anymore, send us prophets 1.00

00:40:33.220 so God, Allah 0.97

00:40:34.860 has sent prophets 0.99

00:40:37.100 Muhammad being the last of them 0.99

00:40:38.820 without any more national revelation 1.00

00:40:40.500 so thank you for cooking yourself

00:40:41.880 it's a great point where you're saying

00:40:44.440 I really like that

00:40:45.220 I think it's a great point, but it's very simple.

00:40:48.820 Prophecy ended 2,000 years ago. 0.96

00:40:50.760 Muhammad came after, and God told us. 0.99

00:40:53.120 Let me give you the final verse, and we'll finish with this. 0.96

00:40:55.680 Okay, let me read you this verse.

00:40:57.300 Give me a second.

00:40:57.880 Let me just find it.

00:40:59.900 Here, give me one second.

00:41:01.060 I'm going to just leave you off with this.

00:41:03.640 That's a good point you're making, but I'm going to give you a verse like this.

00:41:08.160 God says, Deuteronomy chapter 5, verse 1 through 4, right? 0.69

00:41:12.000 Why did the Jews believe in Moses, right? 0.95

00:41:14.380 It's not because of the miracles. 0.94

00:41:15.560 It's not because of that, right?

00:41:16.960 Because, wait, wait.

00:41:18.200 Give me a second here.

00:41:19.100 Where's the verse?

00:41:37.460 Give me a second.

00:41:38.220 I have to find the verse.

00:41:40.220 Give me one second.

00:41:41.060 You're looking for Daniel chapter 9, brother.

00:41:43.500 No, no, no, no.

00:41:44.100 it's not the verse i'm looking for malachi no no wait a second can you just give me one minute i'm

00:41:49.140 sorry let me just find the verse sure ah peace reminds me of the ottoman rule jews and muslim

00:42:01.880 coexisting this is like the caliphate alhamdulillah peace no i don't hear any bombs now

00:42:14.100 sorry I'm just

00:42:20.760 I forgot the verse where it was

00:42:22.400 I have the book

00:42:23.200 I'm just trying to find the verse

00:42:24.600 Rabbi Libyano 0.99

00:42:25.780 you should be a rabbi

00:42:27.440 many people call me

00:42:30.300 the Rabbi Libyano

00:42:33.780 actually I used to go by that

00:42:35.220 back on my TikTok days

00:42:36.400 maybe I should

00:42:38.700 maybe I should

00:42:39.380 start teaching some Torah

00:42:41.220 and the yeshiva

00:42:41.900 okay

00:42:42.600 this is the book right here

00:42:46.140 okay i'm just gonna read you the rambam and i'm gonna finish because i just really gotta go right

00:42:51.780 now it's like i'm getting blown up right now my time you're gonna give me the rambam you're gonna

00:42:55.840 give me a no no no no no he's quoting a verse maimonides from spain what the heck what's wrong

00:43:04.180 you brought him i'm gonna bring him back listen to this i'm gonna read it and i gotta go okay

00:43:09.400 all right

00:43:10.420 it's a little bit long

00:43:31.260 okay 0.98

00:43:31.760 the Jews did not believe

00:43:32.660 in Moses our teacher

00:43:33.340 because of the wonders

00:43:33.980 that he performed

00:43:34.640 for whenever

00:43:35.460 anyone belief

00:43:36.240 is based on wonders

00:43:37.120 he has misgivings

00:43:37.940 because it is possible

00:43:38.640 to perform a wonder

00:43:39.440 through magic or sorcery.

00:43:40.800 All the wonders performed

00:43:41.660 by Moses and Dez

00:43:42.360 were not intended to serve

00:43:43.220 as proof of the legitimacy

00:43:44.080 of his prophecy,

00:43:44.940 but rather were performed

00:43:45.740 for a purpose

00:43:46.560 it was necessary 1.00

00:43:47.100 to drown the Egyptians, 1.00

00:43:48.480 to split the sea. 0.99

00:43:50.160 And, you know,

00:43:51.220 I'm just going to say it.

00:43:51.840 Let me see if I can just say it outside

00:43:52.920 without reading everything inside.

00:43:55.060 Are you reading a verse

00:43:55.940 from the Tanakh?

00:43:56.980 No, no, no.

00:43:57.440 I'm just reading the Rambam,

00:43:58.700 but he's quoting a lot of verses.

00:43:59.960 We know Rambam agrees with you.

00:44:01.920 That's the point.

00:44:02.700 I disagree with Rambam.

00:44:03.520 No, no, no.

00:44:03.940 He's quoting verses.

00:44:05.760 Okay.

00:44:06.580 Okay.

00:44:07.540 This is the idea.

00:44:08.640 To be a prophet, okay?

00:44:11.360 There's criteria.

00:44:12.340 So there's no verse from the Tanakh?

00:44:13.980 No, no, no.

00:44:15.060 I'm going to tell you right now.

00:44:16.140 I'm just saying it out of that.

00:44:16.920 There's no verse in the Tanakh, brother.

00:44:18.620 Let me tell you that right now.

00:44:19.320 No, wait.

00:44:19.580 What verse from the Tanakh?

00:44:20.300 I don't know what you're saying right now.

00:44:21.340 There's no verse in the Tanakh that says

00:44:23.600 that prophecy ended with Malachi.

00:44:26.100 No, no, no, no.

00:44:27.160 That's not what I'm saying.

00:44:28.100 That's not what I'm saying.

00:44:29.240 Did prophecy end with Malachi?

00:44:31.500 No, no.

00:44:32.280 We know from the book of Deuteronomy

00:44:33.900 what is...

00:44:34.760 How do we know it's a real prophet?

00:44:36.380 A real prophet versus a fake prophet?

00:44:38.160 chapter 13 and 18 of Deuteronomy

00:44:40.020 that's easy I haven't memorized

00:44:41.320 now the idea is why don't we believe he's a prophet

00:44:44.840 because the idea is

00:44:46.580 anybody who comes and says

00:44:48.760 you don't have to keep the Torah anymore

00:44:50.700 and tells you

00:44:51.380 that's the verse I'm trying to get

00:44:53.520 I just don't remember the verse

00:44:55.280 it says if anybody tries to tell you to stop keeping the Torah

00:44:58.120 I think that again

00:44:58.960 so then Ezekiel is a false prophet

00:45:03.320 because he tells you to not keep the Torah anymore

00:45:05.200 no you're again

00:45:06.820 Do you want the verse?

00:45:08.560 I know what you're saying.

00:45:09.660 Do you want to read the verse?

00:45:10.540 It's very cryptic.

00:45:11.640 There's a whole thing.

00:45:12.400 Do you want to read the verse, Ezekiel?

00:45:15.080 Again, you want to read the verse or not?

00:45:17.400 Wait, wait, wait.

00:45:19.120 Ezekiel's a false prophet then.

00:45:20.460 You want to read it? 0.74

00:45:21.500 No, no, no.

00:45:22.040 It's not.

00:45:22.900 No?

00:45:23.720 Oh, no.

00:45:24.140 I don't remember.

00:45:25.060 Trust me.

00:45:26.040 Wait, wait, wait.

00:45:27.220 No.

00:45:28.420 Just stop right there.

00:45:31.020 Dude, you're not engaging.

00:45:32.440 Whatever.

00:45:32.940 The idea I'm trying to say,

00:45:34.280 I can't find the verse.

00:45:35.120 The idea I'm trying to say is,

00:45:35.920 we don't you're asking why we don't believe in him because he doesn't follow the criterias of

00:45:41.020 the prophets to be a prophet you have to make prophecies he never made one prophecy in the

00:45:45.920 quran number two he did a prophecy that came true okay yes number two yes you want to talk about it

00:45:53.480 anybody anybody i think he's in deuteronomy anybody that tells you not to keep the torah 0.70

00:45:59.660 or go against the torah god says don't listen to him and that's a false prophet i'm testing you to 0.80

00:46:05.240 see if you're going to be loyal to me okay so ezekiel is a false prophet wait wait do you know

00:46:09.380 that verse or no do you know what verse i'm talking about i don't can you quote me that verse i just

00:46:14.240 it's somewhere it's somewhere in deuteronomy wait i think it's uh um that's the verse i want to go

00:46:21.720 through that verse it's okay you don't have to get i know what you're talking about no no no

00:46:25.560 you know what i'm talking about but not everyone the thousands of people listening okay so we'll

00:46:30.260 just sit here till you find it then instead of talking about the points at hand yeah i'm just

00:46:34.320 try i'm sorry but my memory is a little bit bad because you told us you have to leave like 15

00:46:38.120 minutes ago but i know i know the person is blowing up my text right now that i'm not answering them

00:46:42.860 but i i don't want to leave the benjamin netanyahu told you at all yes benjamin netanyahu told me

00:46:48.720 where is the verse is it anybody tell him if he wants him to you know if he wants to learn how to

00:46:55.960 you know study torah let me know i could give him a few lessons you don't even know how to read

00:47:01.340 Hebrew so I don't know like learn Hebrew English translation sure I don't know how to read Hebrew

00:47:08.000 okay so what is Bereshit bara oh now we're moving topics so you want to say him hold on hold on he

00:47:14.000 just he just asked me repeat that again Aaron Bereshit bara Elohim etashomai veta aret Genesis

00:47:20.420 1-1. Okay, and what

00:47:22.140 translated? Ah!

00:47:23.460 In the beginning, God created the heavens

00:47:26.240 and the earth. Okay, translate

00:47:27.780 it. Okay, translate this.

00:47:31.280 I know the verse, brother.

00:47:35.700 I know the verse.

00:47:37.700 I know the verse.

00:47:39.700 I don't fully speak Hebrew.

00:47:48.100 That's too fast. 0.68

00:47:49.200 That's too fast, man.

00:47:50.120 The word, the word, the word, the word of Israel, the children of Israel, it's too, it's too fast, it's too fast, man, sorry, like, I don't know how to get that one, yeah, Rabbi Libyano, this guy really tried, he thought he was going to get a clip there, but he got clipped,

00:48:15.600 okay here

00:48:17.840 all right

00:48:19.360 where's the verse

00:48:21.100 I think this is the verse

00:48:22.320 it's Deuteronomy 13

00:48:24.780 2 to 6

00:48:25.460 okay but actually

00:48:26.420 I'm serious

00:48:27.080 actually I really got it

00:48:29.040 okay

00:48:30.300 Deuteronomy 13

00:48:31.740 2 to 6

00:48:32.340 because we're going to

00:48:32.940 just keep going back

00:48:33.600 and forth forever

00:48:34.320 again

00:48:37.320 see how you said

00:48:38.220 back and forth forever

00:48:39.440 I know

00:48:40.140 in a very long time

00:48:41.220 okay but I'm just saying

00:48:43.760 there's going to be

00:48:44.560 too much back and forth

00:48:45.460 Okay, quickly.

00:48:46.500 Deuteronomy 13, chapter 13, 2-6.

00:48:51.300 It says, if they're...

00:48:52.260 Okay, ready?

00:48:53.060 Read this verse.

00:48:53.660 This is why we don't believe he's a prophet. 0.98

00:48:55.120 And that's why we don't follow the Quran.

00:48:56.600 Again, not that we don't disrespect Muslims and whatever,

00:48:58.940 but I'm just saying why we don't believe in it. 0.99

00:49:00.980 If there should stand up in your midst

00:49:04.180 a prophet or a dreamer of dreams,

00:49:05.760 and you produce to you a sign or a wonder,

00:49:07.780 and the sign or wonder comes about,

00:49:09.480 of which he spoke to you, right?

00:49:11.180 And he says, you know,

00:49:12.360 let us follow gods of others

00:49:13.620 that you do not know,

00:49:14.280 and we shall worship them.

00:49:15.460 Do not hearken to the words of that prophet.

00:49:16.980 We don't follow other gods.

00:49:18.600 Wait, wait. 0.86

00:49:19.520 For Hashem your God is testing you to know whether you love Hashem your God

00:49:22.360 with all your heart and with all your soul.

00:49:24.580 Hashem your God you shall follow.

00:49:25.660 And Hashem your God you shall fear.

00:49:27.680 His commandments you shall observe.

00:49:29.220 And His voice you shall hearken and serve Him and you shall cleave.

00:49:32.260 Right?

00:49:32.700 And that prophet, again, it's saying His commandments you shall cleave to.

00:49:35.760 If you read the first verse, if you read chapter 13 verse 1.

00:49:40.020 Brother, brother, come on.

00:49:40.760 Wait, wait, wait.

00:49:41.280 Let me finish.

00:49:41.980 Let me finish.

00:49:42.460 You just twisted the Torah.

00:49:43.620 Wait, wait. 0.65

00:49:44.240 You're doing what Allah says to do in the Qur'an.

00:49:47.120 Let me finish.

00:49:48.360 The first verse, I forgot to read the first verse.

00:49:50.300 I started with the second.

00:49:51.140 It says, the entire word that I command you,

00:49:53.340 that you shall observe to do,

00:49:55.920 you shall not add or subtract to it.

00:49:57.840 So it says, keep the Torah. 1.00

00:49:59.360 And obviously the Muslims subtract from the Torah 0.97

00:50:01.100 because they say not to keep the Torah. 0.98

00:50:02.720 But then it brings that whole verse of a false prophet.

00:50:05.100 And it says the idea that you don't follow him,

00:50:08.180 you should keep the commandments of God

00:50:09.880 because that prophet is obviously telling you

00:50:11.300 not to keep the commandments of God.

00:50:12.460 and that prophet

00:50:13.360 and the dreamer 1.00

00:50:13.880 shall be put to death 0.99

00:50:15.000 for he has spoken 1.00

00:50:15.880 perversion against

00:50:16.720 Hashem your God 1.00

00:50:17.440 who takes you 1.00

00:50:18.080 from the land of Egypt

00:50:18.840 to redeem you 0.99

00:50:19.680 from the house of slavery

00:50:20.480 to make you stray

00:50:21.740 from the path

00:50:22.340 which Hashem told you

00:50:23.240 and Hashem told you

00:50:24.000 a hundred times 0.88

00:50:24.580 don't go off the derech 0.94

00:50:25.900 keep my mitzvot 1.00

00:50:26.780 keep all your commandments

00:50:27.480 should I respond

00:50:28.060 should I respond to that?

00:50:29.380 your God

00:50:29.960 has commanded you

00:50:30.960 to go that path

00:50:31.740 you shall destroy

00:50:32.440 the evil from your midst

00:50:33.140 so Hashem is basically saying

00:50:34.280 if anybody

00:50:34.940 then tell you

00:50:35.700 wait wait

00:50:36.020 if anybody comes

00:50:37.080 and tells you

00:50:38.260 to go against God

00:50:40.100 don't observe

00:50:40.680 his commandments

00:50:41.100 whether it's for

00:50:41.760 idolatry, any mitzvah,

00:50:44.240 whether to add or subtract from it, 1.00

00:50:45.860 which Islam for sure does. They added a mitzvah 1.00

00:50:47.980 and they subtracted. God says, 0.73

00:50:49.700 don't listen to that person. He's a false 0.81

00:50:51.520 prophet. That's why we don't 0.82

00:50:53.640 believe in the prophet. Also, we believe

00:50:55.200 Moses is the greatest prophet. So anybody who comes

00:50:57.700 and says, oh, you don't have to keep the Torah 0.74

00:50:59.840 because look at it. None of the 0.84

00:51:01.720 prophets... You see how he talks for 10 minutes

00:51:03.600 and nobody cuts him off? I'm just saying. He just goes on and on

00:51:05.680 and on. I appreciate that. But I'm just saying.

00:51:07.600 But then you're going to leave after this. None of the prophets

00:51:09.660 go against Moshev. 0.95

00:51:11.420 Muhammad clearly goes against Moses 0.77

00:51:13.720 and says, don't keep the Torah.

00:51:15.680 You guys don't keep Torah.

00:51:16.520 You don't keep Tafil, you don't keep Siti.

00:51:17.820 Okay, but listen, I really got to go.

00:51:19.700 It was very nice to meet you.

00:51:20.380 But you're not going to let me respond to that, right?

00:51:21.960 Because it's going to just go back and forth.

00:51:23.540 It's fine, it's fine.

00:51:24.160 You can go, I'll respond to it after you.

00:51:26.580 Yeah, yeah, yeah.

00:51:27.160 When I go, just respond to whatever you want to say.

00:51:28.860 I appreciate you coming on.

00:51:30.160 And if Rabbi Rosh Rahi wants to come on again,

00:51:32.860 let's set up another one.

00:51:33.940 Do you want to set up another one?

00:51:35.380 Let's talk to Rabbi, yeah.

00:51:37.280 Let's do it.

00:51:37.640 I thought it was great.

00:51:39.100 Was everything before you leave?

00:51:40.160 was everything handled properly you're very respectful you're very respectful you didn't

00:51:44.480 you know like i'm saying sneak or whatever you also it's very nice to meet you and i like how

00:51:48.400 you know you know you learn torah please try to learn you know i you know go through the tanakh 1.00

00:51:54.000 in hebrew i really highly recommend it also learn it with the oral torah because jews don't read the

00:51:57.920 tanakh by itself because if you read the tanakh by itself it says god is physical it's it sounds 0.54

00:52:02.240 like god's physical but then the torah says god's not physical so you have to read it with the oral

00:52:06.320 Torah. Whatever, I'm not going to go into that conversation.

00:52:09.440 Well, just 0.84

00:52:10.120 quick, the Talmud says God is a big rabbi

00:52:12.240 who studies Torah. The oral Torah 0.61

00:52:14.300 it doesn't, it says

00:52:16.160 God plays with a fish.

00:52:18.100 No, no, it's metaphorical. For three hours a day,

00:52:20.100 He plays for a fish, God, in the Talmud. I don't know

00:52:22.280 where you're quoting from the Talmud. Can I read it?

00:52:24.420 Can I read it right quick before you leave?

00:52:26.360 No, no, but all I'm saying is, I just want to teach

00:52:28.400 you a rule. I just want to teach you a rule.

00:52:30.260 I really have to go. Anything you see in the Talmud that

00:52:32.240 says literal stuff like that, like the Talmud

00:52:34.220 says Moshe was 15 feet tall we don't believe that okay we don't take everything that it says

00:52:38.460 there's certain parts that are teaching you deeper messages but it's hidden in story format okay

00:52:42.220 but I'm not going to go to that conversation again that's why I wrote my book I talk about

00:52:46.020 older but whatever okay very nice to meet you how old are you by the way man I'm 25

00:52:50.420 okay well look although listen I look I just want to say I want to I'm not I'm not I'm not

00:52:58.560 going to debate you bro I just want to say I apologize if I came across a little bit tough

00:53:02.760 and harsh it's okay don't worry i know i'm just saying i didn't say to you like yeah i didn't

00:53:07.820 just look i look you're actually respectful it's my fault for calling you names here and there

00:53:13.840 it's my bad i shouldn't do that thank you so thank thank you but i'm just saying can i just

00:53:18.320 say something jews don't again this is a very important idea jews you know i'm sure a lot of

00:53:23.800 people are watching this jews are not here to go against anybody fight people we want peace we love

00:53:30.320 people we're not against it we all know even the palestinians i would love for the palestinians

00:53:34.880 you know there's a lot of arabs that live with jews go become doctors or go through the schooling 0.83

00:53:38.560 system you know i believe in free palestine but free palestine oh oh but from come on okay then 0.92

00:53:45.200 then yahoo shouldn't fund them then bb shouldn't give him 35 million again i i don't think he's

00:53:49.600 funding them but he is just saying i'm just saying hamas again even the numbers you see of all the

00:53:54.320 civilians dying you know the un gives you that number and they get it from gaza and obviously

00:53:58.160 hamas is in control of the gaza government all the numbers so what's the six million in the holocaust

00:54:01.840 i'm just saying i'm just saying when they say 70 whatever the number of people died so what's the

00:54:05.920 six million distinguish between hamas fighters and civilians that's a very important fact to know

00:54:10.560 and israel again i know people in the army okay people in the army if you god forbid kill a

00:54:16.080 civilian an innocent civilian you go to jail we before we go and let's say hamas is shooting

00:54:20.800 rockets from hospitals and whatever we literally send leaflets we send phone calls leave and

00:54:26.800 And double-tap missiles.

00:54:28.220 And double-tap missiles.

00:54:29.180 I'm just trying to say, again, I don't know, again.

00:54:31.380 You don't believe the children are innocent.

00:54:33.740 You don't believe the children are innocent. 1.00

00:54:35.720 You say kill them first. 1.00

00:54:37.220 Kill them first. 1.00

00:54:38.540 First of all, you're doing Khalil Hashem right now. 1.00

00:54:41.360 Again, you believe in that same Torah. 0.94

00:54:43.380 And the same Torah is not talking about Palestinians.

00:54:45.060 It's talking about, I don't know, I think it was talking about Canaanites. 0.57

00:54:48.520 And God didn't, even with the situation with the Canaanites,

00:54:51.520 God didn't say just kill them.

00:54:52.520 God gave them an option. 0.99

00:54:53.520 No, no, no.

00:54:54.340 You know, either leave the land, whatever.

00:54:56.080 I'm not gonna go into all that. You know, but you don't think the Palestinians are innocent. 1.00

00:55:01.040 No, I think they're brainwashed by Hamas. I feel so bad. Are they innocent?

00:55:05.120 Do they deserve to die according to Torah? No, I don't believe anyone deserves to die. 0.58

00:55:08.400 I think Hamas is hijacking. Instead of all the billions of dollars you got,

00:55:11.600 they could have made beautiful societies. If you had more time. They invested in tunnels,

00:55:15.440 they invested in rockets. If you had more time, I would show you from the Talmud

00:55:21.600 and from the Torah, and how you understand it, and how Rambam understood it, that you don't think 1.00

00:55:26.960 Palestinians are innocent, you think they deserve to die. That's not true, I'm sorry, I know that, 0.90

00:55:30.160 listen, I've been learning in yeshiva, I'm sorry, I'm not trying to disrespect you, but I'm Jewish,

00:55:34.560 I've been learning in yeshiva for many, many years, I've been learning Torah for many, many years,

00:55:38.400 I know how to read all that, I know the Torah, there's not one thing in the Torah that says, 0.95

00:55:42.160 go kill Muslims, we're not like that, we're here. It does, 1 Samuel 15.3. Samuel what? 1 Samuel 15.3. 0.93

00:55:49.600 are you talking about

00:55:50.280 killing Amalek 0.99

00:55:51.000 the kids of Amalek 1.00

00:55:52.940 the children

00:55:53.500 okay

00:55:54.260 that's a whole conversation

00:55:55.820 about Amalek

00:55:56.480 I recommend

00:55:57.080 I recommend

00:55:58.320 watching a video on YouTube

00:55:59.360 by Rabbi

00:55:59.860 wait wait

00:56:00.820 first of all

00:56:02.260 you believe in that same Torah

00:56:03.440 because you believe in the Tanakh 0.97

00:56:04.540 that's number one 1.00

00:56:05.140 I don't believe in that

00:56:06.520 you don't believe in that

00:56:08.000 it says not in the Tanakh 0.92

00:56:09.440 but it says to kill Amalek

00:56:10.660 I don't believe God 0.97

00:56:11.240 and we don't know who 0.82

00:56:12.360 and we don't know who Amalek is

00:56:14.160 and God told that to the prophet

00:56:16.060 we're not prophets here

00:56:17.120 to go tell you

00:56:17.780 was it right or wrong

00:56:19.120 And Amalek, wait, wait.

00:56:20.780 Was it right or wrong when God said it? 1.00

00:56:23.100 Their mission was to kill all the Jews. 1.00

00:56:25.020 Was it right or wrong to kill the kids of Amalek? 1.00

00:56:28.120 They didn't, again, again.

00:56:29.660 They're not talking about... 0.83

00:56:30.260 Is it right or wrong to kill the kids of Amalek? 0.99

00:56:32.420 Listen, listen. 0.97

00:56:33.460 You're saying something that it says in the Tanakh. 1.00

00:56:36.260 You're being sneaky, man. 1.00

00:56:37.880 Okay?

00:56:38.560 I'm not saying that. 0.99

00:56:39.580 Is it right or wrong to kill the kids of Amalek? 1.00

00:56:42.400 Listen, I have a question. 1.00

00:56:43.800 Did God...

00:56:44.440 Wait, wait, wait.

00:56:45.780 Why did you answer? 0.78

00:56:46.560 Did God say in the Quran kill all the apicorsim? 0.90

00:56:52.040 The apicorsim, yes or no? 0.81

00:56:54.060 The what? 1.00

00:56:55.020 God says kill all the heretics. 0.99

00:56:57.260 No, he doesn't say that. 0.97

00:56:58.260 Oh, it doesn't say that in the Quran?

00:56:59.780 Only those who fight him. 0.70

00:57:01.200 Only those who fight him, yeah. 0.97

00:57:01.860 And it doesn't say slaughter all the Jews 0.99

00:57:03.520 when they hide behind the tree? 0.99

00:57:04.860 It doesn't say that.

00:57:05.700 Oh, it doesn't say that.

00:57:06.260 Bring the verse.

00:57:07.020 Bring the verse.

00:57:07.460 In the hadith, it doesn't say it?

00:57:08.640 It doesn't say kill innocent Jews.

00:57:10.000 Oh, yeah?

00:57:10.200 So you don't know your own hadith.

00:57:11.620 It doesn't say kill innocent Jews. 0.89

00:57:12.820 The rock will scream out. 0.99

00:57:14.860 It doesn't say kill innocent Jews. 0.99

00:57:16.260 you haven't answered yet are the kids are the kids of amalek is it right to kill the kids of amalek 0.99

00:57:22.100 and a muhammad slaughtered innocent jewish community all that you know this guy this guy 0.91

00:57:27.380 this guy is funny they weren't innocent in high bar high bar they had they had they betrayed the 0.92

00:57:32.260 commander communities they were not they were not they were not Jewish communities they wiped out 0.59

00:57:37.380 i'm just saying don't act like if you want to talk about this we can but you just you just want to

00:57:47.860 leave but you also don't want to leave which one no because you just keep throwing in things and 0.94

00:57:52.260 i don't want can i get a clear yes you know is it okay to kill the kids of amalek is it okay 0.95

00:57:58.420 we don't know who's amalek so no we don't know we don't know we don't know today 0.95

00:58:02.820 We don't know who's Amalek.

00:58:04.780 Not today. 0.68

00:58:05.960 We don't know who's Amalek. 0.99

00:58:06.960 You can't kill anybody. 1.00

00:58:07.960 I didn't say you know them.

00:58:09.360 What?

00:58:09.560 If God came to Prophet Shaul, 0.87

00:58:11.200 first of all, 1.00

00:58:12.180 it was only for the royal family

00:58:15.280 because it was only for the royal family.

00:58:17.460 That's what Moshe Feinstein says.

00:58:18.860 But regardless,

00:58:19.760 check out... 0.99

00:58:20.380 Was God right when he said kill the kids? 0.95

00:58:22.540 Listen,

00:58:23.020 I don't have a whole conversation. 0.63

00:58:23.880 Was God right when he said kill the kids?

00:58:25.900 You can't give it.

00:58:26.860 God wasn't right?

00:58:28.440 Wait, wait, wait. 0.66

00:58:29.420 Was God right when he said kill the kids of Amalek?

00:58:31.960 I don't want to do this 0.77

00:58:33.040 because I know what you're going to do.

00:58:34.100 You're going to cut a clip out of it.

00:58:35.260 Was God right when he said...

00:58:37.040 Okay, was God right when he said 0.97

00:58:39.740 give all the kids of Amalek? 1.00

00:58:41.060 I'm going to do the best thing 0.97

00:58:41.660 because I'm not going to...

00:58:42.420 Yo, Sneeko, push it.

00:58:43.560 Let him make him answer this, bro.

00:58:44.860 Wait, wait.

00:58:45.240 This is a 15-minute conversation 0.55

00:58:47.080 to give you the whole background of Amalekis. 0.93

00:58:49.020 You can't give such a complex answer

00:58:50.540 in 10 seconds.

00:58:51.520 I said the kids of Amalek.

00:58:53.200 No, no, no.

00:58:54.040 Wait, wait.

00:58:54.660 It's not...

00:58:55.040 You have to know the whole background.

00:58:56.440 I'm telling you,

00:58:57.000 whoever's watching this,

00:58:57.920 if you want to know the true answer,

00:58:59.000 go to youtube right rabbi daniel oh come on 0.69

00:59:02.320 and it's all it's it's the opposite your religion is the one that but you're you're a rabbi

00:59:15.420 you're a rabbi can i just get the answer is it because it no it's because it's not like the

00:59:19.980 answer is not a one minute answer it's a 15 minute answer and i told you 500 times

00:59:22.900 It's very easy.

00:59:24.900 You keep adding more questions.

00:59:27.900 I'll make it simple.

00:59:29.900 If you care about truth, it's not a black and white answer.

00:59:32.900 It's not simple.

00:59:33.900 It's not black or white to say you condemn killing kids.

00:59:37.900 It's not black and white to say I don't agree with killing kids, guys.

00:59:41.900 No, no, I don't agree with killing kids.

00:59:43.900 So you don't agree with 1 Samuel?

00:59:45.900 No, but you have to know the context of what's going on. 0.55

00:59:48.900 Is there any context where you can kill kids?

00:59:52.900 Listen, you have to go, it's a 15-minute conversation. 0.99

00:59:56.900 Is there any context where you can kill kids? 0.99

00:59:59.480 And I'm not saying to kill any Palestinians. 1.00

01:00:01.100 Is there any context in which you can kill kids? 0.99

01:00:04.060 I just told you what to do. 0.96

01:00:05.560 You see, he doesn't want to answer, bro.

01:00:08.340 No, I'm not trying to answer it.

01:00:09.840 He doesn't want to answer.

01:00:10.820 Just like, wait, wait.

01:00:12.560 God only said there's a nation called Amalek. 1.00

01:00:15.100 Amalek's mission is to kill all the Jews. 1.00

01:00:17.340 Okay? 1.00

01:00:18.140 And it's talking about, according to our relationship, 1.00

01:00:19.560 Can you kill their babies? 1.00

01:00:21.700 Can you kill their babies? 1.00

01:00:22.540 at that specific time to wipe them out why because if you don't and their babies right 1.00

01:00:27.500 okay but wait wait you you believe in that book so don't wipe out their babies right

01:00:31.820 just tell me why about their baby wait no no no no because you're gonna cut 0.98

01:00:36.540 no no no no no no no no situation i didn't say kill all the amalekites because some hold it's 0.98

01:00:41.100 only the royal family just to kill out the world and their babies right and the royal family in 0.98

01:00:45.980 there and whoever is a part of the family and their babies and their babies the royal family

01:00:50.460 why because they're going to come after you and they're babies but no one could do that

01:00:54.060 god said that's the show and all christians who believe in the bible and all muslims who believe

01:00:59.180 in the bible and their babies right you you again i just you're you're trying to cut things out so

01:01:05.580 i'm giving you yeah he's not he's not he's not gonna say it hey you're not gonna say it because

01:01:09.980 you're gonna try making it hey you're not gonna say it we don't think that at all but i'm saying 0.75

01:01:16.140 In the time of show, God said to wipe out the Amalekite, some hold, it's the whole nation, some hold, it's just the royal thing. 0.99

01:01:26.200 And their babies, right? 1.00

01:01:27.920 Okay, it says that God says just those people.

01:01:31.540 And their babies, right?

01:01:33.060 But again, do you believe in the Torah?

01:01:34.980 And their babies, right?

01:01:37.000 Again, I don't want you to...

01:01:38.320 You're trying to cut a clip. 1.00

01:01:38.980 Out of their badmothers! 0.99

01:01:41.960 Should their babies be wiped out?

01:01:44.840 wait do you but can you you don't need to ask me this question it only applied to that time to 0.63

01:01:50.360 those people under god's command if god said that that's what god said i'm not so those babies should

01:01:55.140 be what so those babies should be wiped out right i don't i'm whatever it says in the bible whatever

01:02:01.100 god says to those people not anybody today and don't apply to anybody so if god if god told you 0.99

01:02:09.100 today to kill the babies of palestinians you'd think it's good right well god didn't tell anybody 0.98

01:02:13.420 that and I wouldn't say it. I said if he did. 1.00

01:02:15.360 I have a question. If God told you today,

01:02:17.260 kill all the Jews, would you kill all the Jews? 1.00

01:02:19.340 No, because it's... 1.00

01:02:21.000 You want me to answer that? I can answer that for you. Yeah, answer it.

01:02:22.820 If God told you, kill all the Jews in the world, you know it's 100% God. 1.00

01:02:25.500 I'm going to answer it. 1.00

01:02:27.400 So it's metaphysically impossible

01:02:29.200 for God to do that because it would be

01:02:31.180 logically contradictory. Okay.

01:02:32.900 God, if you're a prophet, is Muhammad not a prophet? 0.51

01:02:35.060 Let's say God gave you a prophet. No, he's 0.77

01:02:37.180 a prophet and it's metaphysically...

01:02:39.500 If you are a prophet, you are a prophet.

01:02:41.380 I just told you, Rabbi Aaron, the answer is it's metaphysically impossible for God to

01:02:53.260 command that which is universally a priori wrong.

01:02:57.420 So we believe murder is wrong a priori.

01:03:01.380 We believe lying is wrong a priori.

01:03:03.500 Let me finish.

01:03:05.740 I'm answering.

01:03:07.120 You just don't like it.

01:03:09.280 You don't like it.

01:03:10.220 No, you're going around the question.

01:03:11.380 if God asked you

01:03:13.040 no I didn't ask you

01:03:14.220 a prior situation

01:03:15.140 boy let me finish

01:03:16.400 let's say in God's world

01:03:18.040 I'm asking according to

01:03:19.520 what you just asked me

01:03:20.400 in God's world

01:03:21.200 God told you 0.99

01:03:22.300 to kill somebody 0.99

01:03:23.380 I'm not saying 0.98

01:03:24.360 I don't believe in prophecy

01:03:25.240 there's no prophecy today

01:03:26.360 God's not going to tell anybody

01:03:27.340 but I think it's hypothetical to you

01:03:29.260 in a hypothetical

01:03:30.140 God said this is the moral thing to do

01:03:33.560 would you do it or no?

01:03:34.720 I'm answering now

01:03:36.000 you have to understand my answer

01:03:38.060 and let me know

01:03:38.840 if I'm you

01:03:39.260 I understand your answer

01:03:40.340 You're just going around it because you don't want to answer it.

01:03:42.480 Let me finish.

01:03:43.640 The answer is there are things that are a priori wrong.

01:03:48.220 And because we believe God, you see how he's going around it?

01:03:50.120 He doesn't want to answer it.

01:03:51.200 We're not talking about an a priori about Babaji.

01:03:52.640 You see how you keep calling me out?

01:03:54.380 Babaji, what the heck is Babaji doing, bro? 1.00

01:03:58.660 It's Parsi. 1.00

01:03:59.740 Babaji needs my friend.

01:04:00.760 Do I look Pakistani or Persian, too?

01:04:02.700 Hey, look.

01:04:03.420 Okay.

01:04:03.700 Let me finish, bro.

01:04:05.080 Answer the hypothetical.

01:04:06.460 I'm answering, bro.

01:04:08.000 He did kind of answer it.

01:04:09.380 He did answer it.

01:04:10.020 you kill everybody he doesn't want the answer i think he didn't answer no he said that it would

01:04:16.500 be metaphysically possible i'm repeating i'm repeating it and he doesn't like it so let me 0.62

01:04:20.740 let me actually repeat it again and substantiate it so we believe god is good by nature goodness

01:04:28.340 is known as a self-evident principle that is common universally okay so murder is something

01:04:36.980 impossible for god to command or do i understand what you're saying let me finish man let me finish

01:04:43.620 okay this is like asking me can god throw moses in hell and put pharaoh in heaven well this would

01:04:53.140 be metaphysically impossible because god would be committing injustice okay so then how come 0.96

01:04:58.980 is that injustice when you say to kill the heretics let me that's okay we don't believe 0.85

01:05:03.620 we don't believe that that's what you yeah you do right you don't know the difference 0.96

01:05:10.020 the difference between me and you is we believe god it is impossible for him to do wrong

01:05:18.900 like murder for you you don't agree with that okay listen listen listen i'm really so listen

01:05:26.580 i'm respectfully no no no just go because i'm getting a hundred texts i i gotta go the person

01:05:31.700 I know. They're like, leave that stage

01:05:34.100 now. No, no, no.

01:05:35.780 We're going to go forever. You're not answering

01:05:37.860 the question. You're clearly going around.

01:05:39.080 I said in a world 1.00

01:05:41.900 where God told you, kill. Don't

01:05:43.720 ask me. Don't give me the whole

01:05:45.960 going around. I'm telling you it's

01:05:47.640 modally impossible. Okay.

01:05:50.040 There's no possible world

01:05:51.580 without it. We're talking in a hypothetical.

01:05:53.900 So in a hypothetical, we can break that down.

01:05:55.940 That's like asking hypothetically

01:05:58.100 if a square circle existed.

01:05:59.800 No, because who defines good and bad?

01:06:01.700 who defines the morality according to good good morality i mean i'm gonna answer that now that's

01:06:06.900 a very good philosophical question okay wait listen i'm gonna answer i'm really sorry sorry

01:06:11.940 what you just asked the question i know you want the answer listen listen respectfully i really

01:06:16.260 gotta go okay it's all right it's been an hour i appreciate it i appreciate it hope to talk soon

01:06:22.500 very nice what sorry what's your name i didn't get your name the orthodox muslim what's your

01:06:26.740 actual name abdul hamid abdul hamid very nice to meet you and i you know thank you rabbi for your

01:06:32.900 time shalom aleikum thank you take care guys bye bye thank you have a good one

SHNEAKO - June 29, 2026

Orthodox Muslim debates Rabbi Aaron Golfiz after Rabbi Mizrachi LEAVES CALL

Episode Stats

Summary

Transcript