In this episode of the podcast, I sit down with my good friend and long-time co-worker, Alex Blumberg, to talk about the current state of relations between the United States and China. We talk about China's relationship with the West, the Trump administration, and much more.
00:07:13.360Well, I think like the Uyghur issue is a big example of that.
00:07:17.460And that's something that I previously had kind of like fallen to as well, because, you
00:07:22.340know I hadn't been to the mainland in a while and I hadn't been back to Asia like in a while and
00:07:26.620you know you hear a lot about things about the Uyghurs but like you can actually go to Xinjiang
00:07:32.340right now like you can go you can check it out you can just go talk to them that's possible
00:07:36.860um so you actually have like people who are actual Uyghurs themselves saying like no like a lot of
00:07:41.660the stuff that they're saying isn't true you can be Muslim and practicing in China that's fine now
00:07:47.000I think China should have more religious freedom you know because the way the Chinese government
00:07:51.860works is that basically you need to have monitoring by by the government and i don't i don't believe
00:07:57.600in that so again this is not me trying to glaze china there's actual problems with regard to
00:08:01.740religious liberty but the idea that they were just rounding up you know chinese muslims and
00:08:06.280putting them in camp camps that's not accurate and it's also frustrating because you know
00:08:11.220simultaneously i'm seeing all these right-wing accounts who pretend to care about chinese
00:08:14.760muslims basically they don't like chinese people they don't like muslims but suddenly they care
00:08:18.620about chinese muslims that's kind of okay i don't know if i believe that but anyway so all of these0.99
00:08:24.380maga accounts who are you know we need to bomb them they're terrorists blah blah blah when it0.98
00:08:29.320comes to gaza suddenly they care about the chinese muslims um but when it comes to japan who's0.98
00:08:34.800basically saying muslims gtfo now all of a sudden oh that's super cool and it's like you know it's0.89
00:08:40.920there's a huge double standard if china does something it's terrible and evil if japan does0.87
00:08:45.220the same thing it's based in cool that's a good comparison whenever japan they did something i
00:08:50.400saw recently i'm not sure if it's fake but they said that japanese culture cremates the dead body
00:08:55.680you don't bury it so muslims can't have their own burial ground but china for example and i don't
00:09:01.440know if that's the perfect example because i think the uyghur genocide if that is a real genocide
00:09:05.680based off of your what you're saying i haven't seen this talked about it seems like it's something
00:09:10.120that's that's kind of kept under wraps i've only heard about it from uyghur people i go to a uyghur
00:09:14.560restaurant pretty frequently and i've never seen it talked about the way that you know a lot of the
00:09:20.540other propaganda like the sweatshops and stuff is spoken about well they were talking about it a lot
00:09:27.680you know like around 10 years ago since then it's kind of died down um you know because there there
00:09:33.200was like a basically a big work program for some of the criminals in a prison a lot of the footage
00:09:38.120you see of like the viewers in camps is actually from like a literal prison so i'm not saying that
00:09:42.680these people were free but there also just weren't random muslim people who were rounded up because
00:09:46.300they were muslim um but i mean basically for anyone who like doesn't believe me and who thinks china
00:09:52.940is that bad ironically my my advice would be go check it out go see for yourself people go to
00:09:58.960like vacation in china all the time you can go explore this yourself talk to people who are on
00:10:03.080the street like don't take my word for it and is there a complete media blackout because
00:10:08.200professor jang for example i speak to him pretty frequently and he says that he's unknown in china
00:10:14.480he's very famous in the western world but these social media websites are not you're not able to
00:10:19.740access them without a vpn in china is that is everybody on wechat everybody's on wechat um
00:10:26.420sorry people are saying that i have an echo i can kind of hear it like from my end on you but i i
00:10:31.560don't know i'm sorry guys uh don't know how to fix that but uh so like everybody basically has a vpn
00:10:37.680my husband he plays eve and there's like an there's entire chinese corps that all have their
00:10:42.940vpns so it's not like getting a vpn it's not a huge workaround i think a lot of people don't
00:10:48.140listen to him just because they're not interested in it so that's a good that's your example i heard
00:10:54.960jackson hinkle said the same thing and i hadn't heard that before he said that it was all cia
00:10:58.760propaganda that this is a lie but it seems interesting that that would be their source
00:11:03.400of anti-China propaganda because Muslims are demonized so much from the propaganda here,
00:11:09.340right? We have the terrorist propaganda. We have all these lies about Muslims being evil,0.85
00:11:13.760Muslim invaders and stuff, ignoring the wars that are causing this mass immigration,0.97
00:11:19.240especially in Europe, and it's not really big in America. Why would they choose Muslims as1.00
00:11:23.060an example to demonize China if they're also the end of the stick of so much propaganda?
00:11:28.460up because they are they are a minority in china which is overwhelmingly ethnically homogenous
00:11:34.700and so like a good example another piece where like they're demonizing china over is that there's
00:11:40.520legislation now that the minority groups in china have to learn mandarin chinese in addition to
00:11:46.440whatever language they speak which sounds very sane but the you know a lot of these anti-china
00:11:54.280people they're trying to portray it as china wiping out the i don't know the what do they call
00:12:00.480it like basically it's akin to genocide they're trying to trample on the rights of all these
00:12:05.520like smaller groups even though they're still going to be learning their own languages but
00:12:09.220they will just be learning mandarin in addition to that okay so a couple things i don't know if
00:12:15.500you saw it yet is that is the echo bad are they complaining i don't know they say it's it's they
00:12:21.160hear but it's not worth fixing okay i think they don't want me well we'll just let i'll keep it
00:12:26.840i'll keep it somewhat brief so i don't interrupt your floor i'd be just interested to speak to you
00:12:31.240because this is a major meeting and i think it's going to mark a shift so what can we know or what
00:12:37.400do you know about the ai surveillance that china has because one goal there is definitely going to
00:12:42.840be an ai surveillance state ai is going to expand and you can see all these tech billionaires there
00:12:47.400this does seem like it's going to be the new model it's almost guaranteed how far advanced0.87
00:12:51.960is china with their ai surveillance and if it's brought here how would things change
00:12:58.760well i think ai surveillance is like definitely a real thing even in like chinese airport airports
00:13:04.200um you know you can go and there are this is solace convenience but it kind of reveals how
00:13:08.920far their ai and facial recognition has come you can go to airports stand in front of a camera and
00:13:14.200And they're going to bring up like this info board will bring up where your flight is, you know, all the information just based on your face, which is convenient.
00:13:22.260But it's also like, obviously, there are computers that are tracking all of this.
00:13:26.280So I think it's definitely the technology is there.
00:13:32.160I think they're on the way to implementing that as well.
00:13:34.620um but i don't think this is a an issue where like the state has in you know in america they
00:13:42.400are on some sort of moral high ground and i say this as someone who again you know has been
00:13:49.040debanked in the united states uh was basically made persona non grata through like an extra
00:13:56.960judicial process so is it is it good no but i don't think china is unique in pursuing this i
00:14:02.720I mean, we saw that whole, what you call it, that whole controversy over one of the AIs that the military is using.
00:14:10.040They basically came out and said, we don't want it to ever happen that AI is making a call as to whether, you know, to take someone out, which I thought was very reasonable.
00:14:20.540And I'm pretty sure the U.S. military basically said, we're not using you anymore and switched over that.
00:14:25.960So the AI surveillance state is coming and it's not a good thing, but I don't see that issue as like a China versus the West type of thing.
00:14:34.700So how do you think that that can be described, China versus the West?
00:14:38.460Because especially post-COVID with the Wuhan lab theory, we were demonizing China a lot and saying that they are an example of an oppressive state, overly tyrannical, spying on citizens.
00:14:51.040But it seems like that's calmed a lot.
00:14:52.760what can we expect and how would you describe the difference between china and the west because we
00:14:57.580have free speech here we don't follow communist values if you can even classify that as communist
00:15:01.780um i mean i so like a lot of the issues surrounding american free speech
00:15:09.000it's not here's the thing what people complain about china for with a social credit system
00:15:17.260We have free speech in terms of the government for the most part, but if we look at the consequences that you can endure through your totally legal speech, whether that's being debanked, being banned out of clubs, being put on the no-fly list, I don't think, again, like, this is me having gone through everything that I did legally.
00:15:38.680i don't think the u.s especially the west more broadly talking about places like the uk i don't
00:15:45.960think we're in a position to wag our finger at somewhere like china over not having freedom of
00:15:51.400speech the uk is the world leader in arrest for social media posts they have non was it
00:15:57.240non-crime hate incidents and that's that's pretty ridiculous and yeah again like i i believe in
00:16:05.040free speech so insofar as china does not allow political dissent that needs to change but me
00:16:13.160after like after everything i've been through i no longer look at the you know the western world
00:16:19.760as completely anti-authoritarian anymore like the government took like all of our savings never went
00:16:26.880to court i've been debanged like there have been international investigations over it like
00:16:31.900I'm not the same I don't have the same views that I used to about the state I was always critical of
00:16:37.580it but the idea that we live in a society that embraces free speech that has you know due process
00:16:44.360I'm very skeptical about that now so what are your grievances and what do you disagree with
00:16:50.200when it comes to China currently I did find it interesting that especially after Venezuela you
00:16:55.020have so much demonization of communism this is why it's justified to do what Trump is doing to Cuba0.97
00:17:00.500saying we needed to go kidnap that socialist in Venezuela, Maduro's evil, he's a drug dealer.0.74
00:17:05.700And then they go to China and they start saying, this is a great place. I love it.0.97
00:17:09.240Rubio is looking up at the ceiling as if he's never seen one before.
00:17:12.580Is China really communist? And a separate question, I think it's two part is like,
00:17:17.120what are your grievances? What can us as Americans be wary of?
00:17:22.720Well, I think like state overreach is just like a huge thing. But when it comes to whether China
00:17:27.760is communist i mean if you look at economically china objectively is not communist right
00:17:33.040they have state-run capitalism it's a market economy you can have private property there
00:17:38.980are billionaires in china you can start your own business in china you have private property in
00:17:43.420china you have a currency in china that you can invest and trade in none of these are
00:17:49.280characteristics of an actual communist economy uh and you know the people who say china is evil
00:19:35.220But, you know, I've spoken to people who don't know that there are actually elections in China because they're just so like, oh, well, it's communism.
00:19:42.740You hate democracy. No, there are elections in China.
00:19:44.900Basically, you can vote on a local level and then every level chooses the leaders that rule above them.
00:19:51.820But yeah, so it's just it's its own thing.
00:19:54.040Don't try to make China to the USSR.0.59
00:25:14.240And so, yeah, that like Taiwan being Ukraine, like Taiwanese people dying as cannon fodder for, you know, Western powers to exert influence over China.0.70
00:41:33.480Well, we stand with Lauren. We're not going to go and contribute to that hatred. I didn't know that it got that bad like that. What about Candace? Candace Owens? Have you spoken to her?
00:41:41.700um she sent me a text saying like you know when i kind of came out saying that she never really
00:41:48.080believed any of it which was appreciated but and to be clear like i i do still like anna like i
00:41:53.100think she's the most entertaining thing on the young turks by far so i i encourage you to i
00:41:57.960thought also she was great with with pearl i watched that and it was kind of it was interesting
00:42:03.360because anna casparian she's the leftist but at the same time like she's been happily married for
00:42:07.800quite a while she's pro-marriage she loves her husband i really respect that she never
00:42:12.260like she she never says anything bad about her husband publicly which i can never stand when
00:42:17.080people drag their spouse publicly she's but she's supposedly the leftist the feminist meanwhile she's0.76
00:42:24.020she looks feminine she's defending marriage and so i thought that was kind of like an interesting0.68
00:42:28.400dichotomy between her versus pearl so and anna is smart as well like i'm not sure if pearl was0.96
00:42:34.840thinking that she's just some dumb feminist but Anna is she's smart she's not stupid yeah so she's0.80
00:42:40.740not she's not an easy debater at all actually I don't know if you saw but I think the next person1.00
00:42:45.800Pearl is debating is Lauren Southern I don't know too much about her I just know that she was part
00:42:50.740of the the destiny thing or something Andrew Wilson mentioned something but I don't really
00:42:54.000know anything about her Anna's good though and I think she agrees so I don't really think it's
00:42:58.780about left and right it's about right and wrong and it seems like Anna I doubt she would really
00:43:02.840call herself the leftist feminist today if you ask her privately she might say that to be on the
00:43:06.380young turks but she's seeing that a lot of these politics are just meant to divide us and aren't
00:43:10.960really accomplishing anything and she has far more in common with the right than she does with the
00:43:16.140left and it's really it's just a way to give yourself a populist movement but so many of the
00:43:21.400things that the left pushes she doesn't align with but lauren so i don't know the lore what's
00:43:26.740lore and southern lore um well basically lauren southern she kind of became well known because0.87
00:43:34.240she was doing a lot of like um anti-immigration content and she she's done some on the ground
00:43:40.240documentaries that were really big she did borderless and farmland so talking about the1.00
00:43:44.420the migrant crisis in um in europe documenting how ngos are kind of facilitating the movement
00:43:50.880of people farmland she was documenting the uh south african uh white farmers like all the
00:43:56.320violence that they go through so she does really good uh documentary long-form content on the
00:44:01.020ground stuff but she um you know she she has a kid her she was married but it didn't work out
00:44:07.440unfortunately she's kind of talked about that publicly so that's not me you know uh but now
00:44:13.060i think she she previously probably would have identified with the trad movement but now she's
00:44:18.160a lot more skeptical of it just because of everything she's gone through in her life so
00:44:21.280So I'm not – I'm really interested to see that conversation and where it's going to go.
00:44:27.320But she's – yeah, Lauren, I don't know if she makes content regularly now, but she was recently – do you know who Jeremy Boring is?