ManoWhisper
Home
Shows
About
Search
SNEAKO
- May 22, 2023
SNEAKO Tries To Convert Melina To Islam
Episode Stats
Length
22 minutes
Words per Minute
231.04472
Word Count
5,161
Sentence Count
609
Misogynist Sentences
2
Hate Speech Sentences
14
Summary
Summaries are generated with
gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ
.
Transcript
Transcript is generated with
Whisper
(
turbo
).
Misogyny classification is done with
MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny
.
Hate speech classification is done with
facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target
.
00:00:00.000
I explained a long time ago, but you don't seem to understand.
00:00:03.480
There's nothing that humans are able to conceptualize that does not have a beginning.
00:00:08.780
There's no example of anything you could bring up that does not start somewhere.
00:00:12.560
So if you think that the universe created itself, that doesn't make any sense.
00:00:15.600
We have never seen anything that didn't come from a start.
00:00:18.400
Everything has a start.
00:00:20.020
The only explanation for how everything was created, because as part of Allah's creation,
00:00:25.260
the only explanation is that something must be divine that we are not able to understand
00:00:30.980
because it's better and because it's greater than us that created everything that exists.
00:00:35.560
Thank you for the five zombie beasts.
00:00:37.200
Melina is still in that childish phase of sex, drugs, and travel.
00:00:39.780
I remember being like that when I was 18.
00:00:41.280
When she grows and matures, she will become a good wife, inshallah.
00:00:44.040
Great message.
00:00:44.980
That's good. Thank you.
00:00:46.580
When do you think you're going to grow up and accept Islam?
00:00:53.420
That's the one true religion.
00:00:54.280
Well, someone needs to convince me first.
00:00:56.500
I would have to like need a full-on convinced dream, you know, or something.
00:00:59.980
Okay, I can give you Dawah right now before we...
00:01:01.420
We have a lot of stuff to react to, chat, but should I...
00:01:03.480
Tell me what if I should give her Dawah right now.
00:01:05.440
I tried to last time and then you just went off a tangent.
00:01:07.140
I started explaining.
00:01:07.800
You're like, what about Buddhism?
00:01:09.000
Like, I didn't even finish.
00:01:09.900
Yeah, I'm just so gay.
00:01:10.420
I kind of want you to like read about Buddhism.
00:01:11.720
I think you just like Buddhism because you can just do a bunch of Haram stuff
00:01:14.520
and then not really get any repercussions for you.
00:01:16.260
It's just about like love and everything around you and like God and universe and everything.
00:01:20.100
That's kind of what it is about.
00:01:21.180
It's just about love.
00:01:22.120
It's just about love.
00:01:23.340
Yeah, I like that.
00:01:24.760
So you just do whatever you want.
00:01:25.920
You love everything.
00:01:26.660
You love awareness and existing.
00:01:28.280
Like, that's like really cool.
00:01:29.360
Doesn't that sound cool?
00:01:30.340
Are there any rules?
00:01:32.580
I actually don't know.
00:01:33.780
I don't know too much about it, but like just the main idea of it.
00:01:36.080
That's what I'm saying.
00:01:36.400
It sounds like you just like it because there's no repercussions for your actions in Buddhism.
00:01:39.860
I don't know if like negative rules, like making people not do certain things.
00:01:43.780
I like the idea of just like being aware, like not being forced is like a certain thing.
00:01:49.380
Otherwise, you're not like a real thing for it or whatever.
00:01:52.280
Like, yeah.
00:01:55.240
Okay.
00:01:55.680
That's probably why.
00:01:56.120
Why do you think the entire universe?
00:01:57.840
I'll tell you.
00:01:58.420
I'll explain it to you the way I found Islam.
00:02:01.520
How do you think everything was created?
00:02:03.660
Everything that you see, everything that's around us.
00:02:05.160
Oh, I have absolutely no idea.
00:02:06.220
That's like the question that we're all asking, right?
00:02:09.020
We have no idea why we're here, what we're doing.
00:02:11.760
Well, don't you sometimes have you noticed because you believe in love all the time
00:02:15.300
that there must be an instance of something divine.
00:02:19.160
Like sometimes when you're in nature and then the birds will come at a certain time
00:02:22.400
or you look at the ocean and the way the waves hit
00:02:24.280
or you look like the way a flower grows
00:02:26.260
or you see a baby and how pure it is
00:02:27.980
that there's something or like the patterns you see how some plants look like genitals,
00:02:32.620
for example, or how you see things that look alike.
00:02:35.120
Like sometimes you can look in the sky and things look like an eye, for example.
00:02:39.240
You see a lot of patterns and there's a lot of signs.
00:02:43.160
Can you admit that you've seen a lot of signs that show that there must have been
00:02:46.760
some sort of divine creator?
00:02:49.020
I'm not really sure if it would be a divine creator that would be like the answer to it,
00:02:53.500
but that things are really magical, yeah.
00:02:55.840
Okay.
00:02:56.100
So if things are magical, then it doesn't mean that everything,
00:02:59.060
everything that you see is not just random.
00:03:04.520
It could be.
00:03:05.360
You've noticed patterns.
00:03:06.320
Yes, we do notice patterns, but we also put things together
00:03:08.740
that doesn't necessarily have to be a pattern.
00:03:10.820
Like an animal wouldn't notice probably a pattern in the same way as a human does, right?
00:03:14.920
So it could be the case that we're just like seeing things everywhere.
00:03:17.140
Like if I take mushrooms.
00:03:18.100
How do you know that's not true that animals don't see patterns, for example.
00:03:21.480
Like they all are connected.
00:03:22.740
You see birds fly in a flock and they don't really, they don't even communicate in a way
00:03:26.140
that we understand.
00:03:26.440
Yeah, it might be the case that they are seeing it.
00:03:28.240
But like, okay, have you ever done mushrooms before?
00:03:31.060
Yeah.
00:03:31.520
You have.
00:03:32.180
You see patterns that you probably wouldn't see as much if you were sober.
00:03:37.080
Right.
00:03:37.520
Yeah.
00:03:38.380
So I think, I feel like it has to do with that a lot more.
00:03:41.320
Like, do you think that if you're high on mushrooms, you might be more connected to God in that
00:03:44.820
case because you see a lot of patterns?
00:03:46.680
Possibly.
00:03:47.460
Yeah.
00:03:47.940
But you don't do mushrooms.
00:03:49.160
I have done mushrooms.
00:03:50.040
I don't do it anymore.
00:03:50.580
I don't, I don't feel the need to because once you understand like what it's helping
00:03:53.700
you see, there's no need to do it.
00:03:55.260
Yeah, that's true.
00:03:55.860
And where do mushrooms go from the earth?
00:03:57.620
So something from the earth that like, no one made that in a lab.
00:04:01.180
It's something that comes from the earth.
00:04:02.120
You think that's better?
00:04:02.620
But I asked you to do kava once and you said no, even though that's also.
00:04:05.600
I don't do drugs anymore, but I know, but a mushroom, mushroom is a drug too, right?
00:04:09.140
But it comes from earth or smoking weed is the same thing.
00:04:11.480
It's a plant.
00:04:11.940
So there are these things that can alter your brain that come from the earth.
00:04:15.260
Yeah.
00:04:15.400
So there, there must be some, those are okay.
00:04:16.880
It's like smoking weed is okay.
00:04:17.840
It's not about okay.
00:04:18.720
There you're pointing out things that must show that there's some sort of divine creation
00:04:22.680
out there.
00:04:23.560
Something, there's someone there that must have created this.
00:04:26.100
I don't know.
00:04:26.560
I don't know about that.
00:04:27.300
It can't just exist from nothing.
00:04:30.240
No, but I don't know if it's a person or like.
00:04:32.620
I didn't say a person.
00:04:33.360
No, it could be just like the universe itself should be a creation, right?
00:04:37.720
Right.
00:04:38.060
So something created it or the universe created itself.
00:04:41.340
Maybe.
00:04:42.180
And we don't know if it's a creator, if it's like, just like the universe that happened.
00:04:45.720
It doesn't have to be, you're, you're attributing the image of a creator and that maybe that's
00:04:50.160
holding you back, but something, something, in essence, whatever you want to believe in
00:04:53.760
it.
00:04:53.860
If it's love, if it's universe, there, there is something that created everything.
00:04:58.020
Maybe.
00:04:58.660
I mean, we don't know that, but let's say that it is.
00:05:02.000
Okay.
00:05:03.140
And then you have to look at the one religion that respects that there is one creator and
00:05:08.600
that acknowledges the only monotheistic religion.
00:05:11.440
And that's Islam.
00:05:12.460
Islam has stood the test of time.
00:05:14.140
The book is written 1400 years ago.
00:05:15.560
It hasn't been altered.
00:05:16.620
And then everything that came from Muhammad's peace be upon him that came from his mouth
00:05:20.120
when he was reciting the Quran, he didn't even really know how to read and write properly.
00:05:24.960
He was sent by the creator and he just started reciting his words.
00:05:28.300
He started telling exactly what Allah wanted him to say.
00:05:31.540
And then they were able to go and transcribe it.
00:05:33.660
And from that day, he was able to describe the patterns in the universe.
00:05:37.060
He was able to describe the waters.
00:05:39.020
And he, he even knew that there was an orbit.
00:05:40.800
He knew about the sun and the moon and what times of day that we should pray and how it
00:05:43.840
correlates to the rest of the plants.
00:05:45.000
There's a lot of signs in the Quran that show that it, it cannot just be from the mouth
00:05:51.200
of a, of a human.
00:05:52.900
It can't just be, it must've been the creator sending him a message.
00:05:55.740
How do you know that it's just one creator, not plenty?
00:05:58.580
How would you know that for sure?
00:05:59.860
Because even if there are plenty of creators or plenty of prophets, which there were, there
00:06:04.000
must've been, there's always has to come to one.
00:06:06.680
Something must've created everything.
00:06:08.100
We don't know that.
00:06:09.300
I feel like there's no proof of that, that there's one creator or there's multiple.
00:06:12.740
Nothing can exist without somebody creating it.
00:06:14.980
Without something.
00:06:15.520
Yeah, but who created that person?
00:06:16.840
Who created the God?
00:06:17.900
There has to, it has to end at one point.
00:06:19.880
It has to.
00:06:20.100
Yeah, but who created the God in that case?
00:06:22.300
That's where it ends.
00:06:23.040
Yeah, but you said that it can't end.
00:06:25.360
So what if there's like several gods, like it doesn't make sense.
00:06:29.100
If, even if there were several gods or several prophets, for example, it always has to go
00:06:33.040
back to one divine creator, something that is greater than us, greater than we can even
00:06:36.780
conceptualize, greater than we can even understand.
00:06:41.140
Yeah.
00:06:41.520
But if you're saying that, why one in that case?
00:06:43.860
Why couldn't it just be the same thing with like, let's say that it's five different creators
00:06:47.120
that created everything.
00:06:48.480
And you say someone must have created them, but in that case, I could say that someone
00:06:51.480
must have created that one God in that case too.
00:06:54.200
Why couldn't it just be five in that case instead of one?
00:06:56.680
Because it always has to go back to something that's more divine than the rest.
00:06:59.580
There's always something that's greater than other.
00:07:03.460
If there were five.
00:07:04.700
How do you know that it has to be that way?
00:07:06.660
What proof do you see in the real world?
00:07:09.100
Because there's always a hierarchy.
00:07:10.480
There always has to be some sort of supremacy.
00:07:14.320
That's how everything is made.
00:07:15.840
A chicken can't come without an egg being laid.
00:07:20.580
Yeah, but who laid the egg?
00:07:21.460
A chicken always comes.
00:07:23.420
So don't think about it like that.
00:07:25.080
There's a divine chicken and the universe is the egg.
00:07:29.740
One greater thing that we cannot understand, that it's not worth explaining, that it's not
00:07:33.900
worth trying to go and draw or really try to conceptualize or figure out, there must be
00:07:38.040
one.
00:07:38.460
And there's no point in us even trying to understand what this is, but there's something
00:07:42.380
divine that is responsible for our existence here.
00:07:44.740
Okay, so how do we even know in that case that this one creator has set a bunch of rules?
00:07:50.360
Like, what do those rules come from?
00:07:51.840
Like, how do we know that, like, from the things that we see around us, that these has
00:07:55.320
to be the cases of rules?
00:07:56.320
Like, how do we know that that is 100% true?
00:07:58.460
Because all the things that we're seeing, if we see a flower that looks like another one
00:08:01.460
or something like that, we see a bunch of patterns.
00:08:02.800
How does that end up into words of, like, this is what you're allowed to, and this is
00:08:06.480
what you're not allowed to do?
00:08:08.680
Because it's very specific, right?
00:08:09.600
What does it have to do with the flower?
00:08:11.200
Like, you're telling, it sounds like you're telling me, or maybe you're not, that all the
00:08:17.140
things that's in the Quran or the Bible or whatever, there's a bunch of, like, rules,
00:08:21.240
right?
00:08:21.520
How do we know that those rules are actually real?
00:08:23.680
Because you say, like, oh, we see everything around us, so we must think that there has
00:08:27.540
to be a bunch of, like, there has to be a God, there has to be things, because there's
00:08:30.740
patterns around us, we can read into those patterns, oh, how to live life in the best
00:08:34.640
way possible.
00:08:35.400
So how do we know that the things that's in the Quran is actually the correct way of living?
00:08:40.120
Because we are the one species that we don't just act, we can think before we act.
00:08:47.500
Other species, they're born, and then they know exactly what they have to do.
00:08:50.820
They don't contemplate the same way we do.
00:08:52.980
They don't hold a banana, or they don't hold a piece of fruit.
00:08:56.120
A flower doesn't look at itself and think, I don't want to be a flower.
00:08:59.600
I asked about the patterns, like, why do you think the rules in the Quran are the rules
00:09:02.920
that is the real ones?
00:09:03.160
Because the rules apply for us, for people, because we are...
00:09:05.940
Yeah, no, but isn't the same thing in the Bible?
00:09:08.120
It is, but the Bible has, that's true, there's, but the Bible has more inconsistencies and does
00:09:14.260
not believe in, they believe in the Trinity, they don't believe in one creator, they believe
00:09:17.020
that Jesus was also God.
00:09:18.960
So a man cannot be God.
00:09:21.660
There has to be one divine creator.
00:09:23.360
That's an inconsistency, a hypocrisy within the Bible that doesn't make sense.
00:09:27.960
In Islam, there's just one creator, and we worship him.
00:09:31.180
And even if you look at the Bible, Jesus, he prayed down, he put his head on the, put
00:09:34.940
his head to the floor when he worshiped Allah.
00:09:36.300
Wasn't he praying at God?
00:09:37.420
Was he praying to himself?
00:09:38.420
He was praying to God.
00:09:39.200
That's why the Bible didn't get everything right.
00:09:40.760
But he is a God as well.
00:09:41.500
Is it true God?
00:09:42.080
The Christians got it wrong.
00:09:43.500
They got it wrong.
00:09:44.180
They thought, they thought that Jesus was God.
00:09:46.280
He was one of the prophets, peace be upon him, that was sent by Allah, but Muhammad was
00:09:49.580
a, peace be upon him, was a final prophet.
00:09:51.740
So the Christians were, they have been misguided.
00:09:54.240
They think that, if you look in the Bible, Jesus would pray exactly the way Muslims do.
00:09:59.020
Jesus believes in the Father.
00:10:00.200
Jesus believed in God.
00:10:01.260
Jesus, in essence, was a Muslim.
00:10:03.420
He was ethnically a Jew, but the way he prayed in the worship and the way he believed,
00:10:06.780
he was Muslim.
00:10:08.180
I see.
00:10:09.160
They don't say that in the Bible, but everything that he practiced, like you could definitely
00:10:12.740
argue that Jesus was a Muslim.
00:10:14.760
Not ethnically, but theologically, yeah.
00:10:17.400
Mm-hmm.
00:10:18.860
So why not Buddhism or Hinduism?
00:10:22.220
Why?
00:10:22.600
Because they believe in multiple, they believe in like different gods and energy.
00:10:27.040
I think that's Hinduism that believes in multiple gods.
00:10:28.880
Yeah, they believe in all these different weird idols.
00:10:31.200
But I feel like Buddhism kind of just like believes that the universe is God itself.
00:10:35.240
That doesn't make any sense.
00:10:36.260
Why?
00:10:36.480
How can the universe, the universe can't have created itself.
00:10:39.340
That doesn't make sense.
00:10:40.340
Why not?
00:10:41.260
How could something create itself?
00:10:42.720
Why would you need like an individual to do it?
00:10:44.740
Why couldn't it just create itself?
00:10:46.340
Because I feel like that makes a lot more sense that the universe could just create itself.
00:10:48.180
Explain something that's created itself.
00:10:50.420
I can't explain that.
00:10:51.420
So why even argue that?
00:10:53.080
But from the start, something was going to happen.
00:10:54.620
That's what I'm saying.
00:10:55.260
This is why Islam is the only religion that makes sense.
00:10:56.600
But I can't like figure out that there's like an individual or like one thing that like
00:11:00.300
created the entire thing.
00:11:01.260
I feel like that makes a lot less sense than just like it created itself.
00:11:04.840
Because we are.
00:11:05.540
To me personally.
00:11:06.160
Because we exist in the universe.
00:11:07.600
We are part of the universe.
00:11:08.760
We are not greater than the universe.
00:11:10.340
So we cannot have created it.
00:11:11.680
Something always.
00:11:12.380
The creator has to be something that's greater than its creation.
00:11:15.400
So for anything to have existed, there has to have been one divine creator.
00:11:19.580
Something that we can't conceptualize.
00:11:21.460
That created everything.
00:11:22.600
I feel like it makes more sense that everything is created itself.
00:11:24.800
I feel like it makes sense.
00:11:26.180
But explain something that's created itself.
00:11:28.900
How does that make more sense?
00:11:29.640
I can't explain it.
00:11:30.200
So how does it make more sense if you can't explain it?
00:11:31.700
But from time, with time and space, things has happened.
00:11:34.140
And I feel like it just has developed by itself.
00:11:37.120
From like being...
00:11:37.560
Name one.
00:11:38.020
Okay.
00:11:38.200
But you're saying that makes more sense.
00:11:39.060
But also like...
00:11:39.900
But also from the...
00:11:40.740
We don't even know where the start is.
00:11:42.180
Like it probably is no starts.
00:11:43.480
Everything is just happening.
00:11:44.620
Like everything is just happening randomly.
00:11:46.940
What does it have a start?
00:11:47.980
Explain something that doesn't have a start.
00:11:48.680
The universe.
00:11:50.040
But you can't explain that because you haven't seen it.
00:11:51.640
No, I have absolutely no idea.
00:11:52.880
Yeah, but you can't explain that there's an individual person that's started everything, right?
00:11:56.360
But that's the only logical explanation because...
00:11:58.920
Explain something that you have seen and what you know of the universe and everything.
00:12:02.380
It does not have a beginning and an end.
00:12:04.900
Something that you have seen.
00:12:05.820
Something that you can conceptualize that doesn't have a beginning and an end.
00:12:08.260
Everything you know has started, has been created.
00:12:10.560
Everything.
00:12:11.360
There's nothing that just exists.
00:12:12.760
Well, not really.
00:12:14.600
Not really.
00:12:15.700
What?
00:12:16.140
Because it's not like a flower comes from absolutely nothing.
00:12:18.680
There's like a bunch of different particles that comes together, right?
00:12:20.980
Like everyone a star does.
00:12:23.540
Like it's like the earth wasn't just like created just like that.
00:12:27.900
Like it's a lot of different things that happen in time and space.
00:12:31.220
Right, the seed creates a flower, but something has to create the seed.
00:12:33.560
And then you can go back and say the fertilizing or the dirt, but it always goes back to something.
00:12:37.700
Something is not created without something.
00:12:39.520
Something you can't just create.
00:12:40.900
Yeah, but it's not.
00:12:41.420
Something can't create itself.
00:12:42.300
But the atoms itself is already there, right?
00:12:45.200
No, it's not.
00:12:46.020
Of course it is.
00:12:46.520
It always has to go back.
00:12:47.520
If you trail back anything, it has to come from some creation.
00:12:49.500
That's like a thing itself, but like, how do I explain this?
00:12:52.820
Like if you poop, it becomes dirt.
00:12:54.840
And then in that dirt, it grows flowers.
00:12:56.560
But you created the poop.
00:12:57.220
And they're just doing that.
00:12:58.260
Yeah, I know.
00:12:59.000
And it does that forever.
00:13:00.000
My point is.
00:13:00.360
But why does it have to, but why does it have to.
00:13:01.960
My point is, you didn't answer my question.
00:13:03.680
I'm asking you to explain something that you have seen that does not have a beginning.
00:13:07.260
Everything that you are aware of.
00:13:08.340
But it doesn't really have a beginning.
00:13:09.260
It just goes, it just goes on forever, right?
00:13:12.640
To eternity.
00:13:13.220
Can you name something, something that you know in existence that does not have a beginning?
00:13:17.680
That doesn't have a beginning.
00:13:18.700
Yes.
00:13:19.160
I don't think that anything really has an end or a beginning.
00:13:23.740
Like we can look at like a flower that dies, whatever, but it's a lot more complicated
00:13:26.780
than that because it's all the atoms and everything, right?
00:13:28.520
But before it was a flower, it wasn't a flower.
00:13:29.820
It was something.
00:13:30.400
Yeah, but it's not like.
00:13:31.180
There you go.
00:13:31.700
For it to become a flower.
00:13:32.180
But where is the start?
00:13:33.100
There's no start or an end.
00:13:34.300
It just keeps going on forever.
00:13:35.660
But before it was a flower, it's something else.
00:13:37.360
So the creation of a flower started, there was an inception of a flower.
00:13:41.340
You mean that the energy that started to grow the flower is God?
00:13:45.700
Is that what you mean?
00:13:46.300
Because the flower was something else before it became a flower, clearly, because that's
00:13:50.640
like how physics work.
00:13:52.480
Do you see how you're not answering like what I'm saying?
00:13:56.000
I don't understand what you're saying.
00:13:57.800
I'm asking you to explain something that you know of that did not have a beginning.
00:14:01.820
The flower, and I understand that it comes from something else.
00:14:04.660
Yeah.
00:14:04.800
But it has a beginning that you are aware of.
00:14:07.840
It came from something.
00:14:08.500
You mean when it's like when it is existing as a flower?
00:14:10.860
Yes.
00:14:11.040
It has a start and an end.
00:14:12.480
Yeah, sure.
00:14:12.940
Everything that exists has a start.
00:14:15.600
Yes.
00:14:15.900
Everything that you are aware of.
00:14:17.280
Everything.
00:14:17.860
But I don't think you could think about it that way.
00:14:20.460
Right?
00:14:20.820
I don't think that really works.
00:14:21.880
What are the ways that I think about it?
00:14:23.300
Like you can think about life as a start and an ending and stuff like that.
00:14:26.320
Right?
00:14:26.560
But you can't really like like rocks.
00:14:32.440
Where does that come from?
00:14:33.840
It comes from sand.
00:14:34.980
Yeah.
00:14:35.380
Or yeah.
00:14:35.940
And then it becomes rocks if it puts together in a long time.
00:14:38.940
And then it becomes sand again.
00:14:40.120
And then it does that over and over and over again.
00:14:41.540
Right?
00:14:42.140
Okay.
00:14:42.400
But it had to have come from sand first.
00:14:44.160
So everything has a beginning.
00:14:45.280
Or I mean.
00:14:45.680
Everything that you were going to explain.
00:14:46.940
But it's a rock from the beginning too.
00:14:48.280
Right?
00:14:48.440
It gets like crushed.
00:14:49.540
And then like by time it becomes together again.
00:14:52.200
But eventually it started from a piece of sand.
00:14:53.820
So my point is everything that you can think of and conceptualize.
00:14:56.320
I'm sure it comes from a rocket from the space.
00:14:59.440
Like billions of years.
00:15:00.700
Regardless of what you're saying.
00:15:02.160
Everything has a beginning.
00:15:03.600
You see what you're saying?
00:15:04.840
Yes.
00:15:05.300
Everything comes.
00:15:06.420
But something happens before that too.
00:15:08.480
There's things that come.
00:15:09.300
There's a lot of things that happen before that.
00:15:10.260
Do you know what happened before that?
00:15:11.860
If you go all the way back.
00:15:13.720
It must have been a divine creator.
00:15:15.520
That's the only explanation for the universe.
00:15:17.580
You can't just go back and then.
00:15:18.940
Or it could just go on forever.
00:15:21.140
And everything just kind of like happened.
00:15:23.200
We don't know if it has a certain beginning.
00:15:24.440
If it does go on.
00:15:24.880
If the universe does go on forever.
00:15:26.560
It must have had a start.
00:15:28.780
No.
00:15:29.260
Nothing could go on forever without a beginning.
00:15:30.900
Well it.
00:15:31.820
But not really.
00:15:32.280
And you explained that just now.
00:15:33.360
By not bringing up anything that does not have a beginning.
00:15:35.620
No.
00:15:36.240
But like life could.
00:15:37.680
Sure.
00:15:38.000
Like something like existing or living.
00:15:39.740
Or like becoming like a thing that we can physically see.
00:15:41.960
We can like think about a flower as an individual thing.
00:15:45.000
But before that flower was a flower.
00:15:46.460
It was something else.
00:15:47.340
You're going in circles now.
00:15:48.680
No.
00:15:49.140
This is legit what it is.
00:15:50.320
Right.
00:15:50.560
Like the part.
00:15:52.040
Like the autumns was something else before that.
00:15:55.040
Yeah.
00:15:55.440
We agree.
00:15:56.000
So there was no start and ending.
00:15:57.560
It was just the same thing.
00:15:58.500
But like it got created to like a thing for a little bit.
00:16:02.180
And then it died.
00:16:03.080
And then it like became something else later on.
00:16:05.080
But that goes on forever.
00:16:06.900
Of course.
00:16:08.000
Yeah.
00:16:08.580
But it has nothing.
00:16:09.240
Well then if you go back like I've explained.
00:16:11.340
But in that case there must.
00:16:12.120
If you think about it as a God.
00:16:13.520
There has to be something from the beginning as well.
00:16:16.080
What was God before it became a God?
00:16:17.920
It has to be that case.
00:16:18.860
Because that's what everything is.
00:16:19.920
But that doesn't make any sense.
00:16:20.340
The only logical explanation is there must be something divine.
00:16:23.460
That is greater than all of the creations that we are able to conceptualize.
00:16:27.260
Because it comes from.
00:16:28.320
Because right.
00:16:29.020
Because.
00:16:29.620
You're not understanding.
00:16:30.760
If you're thinking about God as a flower.
00:16:32.680
You're in the argument mode.
00:16:34.380
It's not.
00:16:34.880
No.
00:16:35.020
I'm trying to.
00:16:35.840
You're telling me that the flower has a beginning and an end.
00:16:39.820
So God has to have the same thing.
00:16:42.640
But the flower is like.
00:16:43.460
Yeah.
00:16:43.720
Like being a flower has a beginning and an end.
00:16:46.160
But before that it was something else.
00:16:48.020
Yes.
00:16:48.340
You said this five times now.
00:16:49.480
You said this five times now.
00:16:50.280
Yeah.
00:16:50.580
If you think about the flower as a God.
00:16:53.180
Right.
00:16:53.800
What?
00:16:53.980
Because if you think about the flower as a God.
00:16:56.840
It must have a before in that case.
00:16:58.520
That's not what anybody said.
00:16:59.340
But you said that everything goes like this.
00:17:01.340
It must be one creation.
00:17:02.700
And then it all spread out to like a bunch of existence.
00:17:05.300
Right.
00:17:05.840
That's like how you're explaining it.
00:17:07.580
Right.
00:17:08.160
You're explaining that everything comes from a beginning and an end.
00:17:11.000
But you haven't given me an argument for why that is.
00:17:14.260
Because I explained a long time ago.
00:17:17.060
But you don't seem to understand.
00:17:18.700
There's nothing that humans are able to conceptualize.
00:17:21.840
That does not have a beginning.
00:17:24.020
There's no example of anything you could bring up.
00:17:26.040
That does not start somewhere.
00:17:27.640
So if you think that the universe created itself.
00:17:29.680
That doesn't make any sense.
00:17:30.740
We have never seen anything that didn't come from a start.
00:17:33.600
Everything has a start.
00:17:35.040
The only explanation for how everything was created.
00:17:38.100
Because as part of Allah's creation.
00:17:41.600
The only explanation is that something must be divine.
00:17:44.160
That we are not able to understand.
00:17:46.460
Because it's better.
00:17:47.560
And because it's greater than us.
00:17:48.880
That created everything that exists.
00:17:51.280
Something cannot create itself.
00:17:53.260
That has never existed in existence.
00:17:55.280
And there's no point in arguing that.
00:17:56.520
Well we don't know that.
00:17:57.820
100%.
00:17:58.040
If you have never seen that.
00:18:00.260
If you have never understood that to be the case.
00:18:03.520
Then why argue for that?
00:18:05.320
What am I?
00:18:06.260
I'm not arguing for God.
00:18:07.740
I'm not arguing.
00:18:08.640
You're arguing against God.
00:18:10.400
Yeah.
00:18:10.620
I don't think there's like an individual that has created everything.
00:18:13.820
And that's all that goes back to.
00:18:15.340
I think we don't know.
00:18:16.720
That's what I think.
00:18:17.780
Because it doesn't.
00:18:19.480
I don't think there's an individual or a star.
00:18:21.600
I don't.
00:18:22.080
I feel like it's probably just infinity.
00:18:26.020
How could.
00:18:26.840
Okay.
00:18:27.320
I feel like everything is just infinity.
00:18:28.940
But you need to stop going based off of what you feel.
00:18:31.720
And think about what makes sense.
00:18:33.400
If you are.
00:18:33.780
I mean infinity is probably a real thing.
00:18:35.460
Don't you think?
00:18:36.500
But it's not just about how I.
00:18:37.980
I can't just feel like it's infinity.
00:18:39.820
No.
00:18:40.360
But I can explain.
00:18:41.420
I'm giving you the logical explanation for this.
00:18:42.440
I feel like I can explain what infinity is.
00:18:44.620
Because something goes on forever.
00:18:45.960
Yeah.
00:18:46.500
Okay.
00:18:46.740
And from before too.
00:18:48.580
But you don't believe in infinity in that case.
00:18:49.860
No.
00:18:51.000
No.
00:18:51.360
Something.
00:18:51.700
Because infinity doesn't work without a star.
00:18:53.140
It's a.
00:18:53.780
Nothing.
00:18:54.280
Nothing that you.
00:18:54.960
Okay.
00:18:54.980
In that case I'm curious.
00:18:55.900
If you cut your.
00:18:57.020
Not that one.
00:18:58.020
If you cut this in half.
00:18:59.880
Let's say we took this part here.
00:19:01.180
We cut it in half.
00:19:02.200
How many times do you think you could do it until there's an end?
00:19:07.120
An end to what?
00:19:08.820
It will get smaller and smaller.
00:19:10.460
Yeah.
00:19:10.980
How long?
00:19:11.660
Until it stops.
00:19:12.980
Well it would be smaller than my knife.
00:19:14.500
So I wouldn't be able to cut it anymore.
00:19:15.820
No I know.
00:19:16.180
But let's say that you could.
00:19:17.600
How many times could you do that?
00:19:19.140
You think.
00:19:19.820
Physically.
00:19:20.220
Like how many times can you do it?
00:19:21.920
You could do it until infinity.
00:19:23.860
No.
00:19:24.220
There's no knife that would be that size.
00:19:25.640
No no no.
00:19:26.000
Let's say that there's no knife.
00:19:26.920
Let's say that there's a magic knife that can cut it all the way.
00:19:30.380
How.
00:19:30.860
How long can you do it?
00:19:31.900
Or let's say that you take this and you double it up.
00:19:33.900
And you do knots.
00:19:34.920
What's the point of this argument?
00:19:37.280
Infinity is a real thing.
00:19:39.860
That's what I'm trying to argue for you.
00:19:41.520
So we don't know if there's.
00:19:42.780
But you see where the start comes from?
00:19:45.080
It always starts somewhere.
00:19:47.660
Everything has a start.
00:19:48.980
Well you could always like double it up as well.
00:19:51.260
Right?
00:19:51.840
You could always like make it.
00:19:52.940
That doesn't refute my argument.
00:19:53.840
That doesn't refute my point.
00:19:55.200
Everything that you can conceptualize has a beginning.
00:19:57.820
And you haven't been able to debunk that.
00:19:59.780
I mean you could do it forever.
00:20:01.160
That's the thing.
00:20:01.760
Like everything is.
00:20:03.160
You can cut everything to infinity.
00:20:04.680
But you could also like plus everything to infinity.
00:20:06.400
Right?
00:20:07.040
Like it's the same thing with numbers.
00:20:08.100
If you think about numbers.
00:20:09.220
It could go on forever.
00:20:11.200
Right?
00:20:12.300
Just like anything.
00:20:13.280
So life could be the same thing.
00:20:14.560
Like or not life.
00:20:15.440
But like existence.
00:20:16.040
Where do you start counting from?
00:20:18.840
Well.
00:20:20.760
Present.
00:20:22.120
Buddhism.
00:20:23.120
Being right here right now.
00:20:24.160
But that's.
00:20:24.880
That has nothing.
00:20:25.720
That's not numbers.
00:20:26.600
Numbers isn't Buddhism.
00:20:27.440
Where do you start counting?
00:20:28.680
I have no idea.
00:20:29.360
You can start counting from anywhere.
00:20:30.660
Right?
00:20:31.080
But like.
00:20:31.500
But it's.
00:20:31.860
It's literally infinity.
00:20:33.260
Where does numerology start?
00:20:35.940
What's that mean?
00:20:36.480
Sorry.
00:20:37.200
When you start counting.
00:20:38.340
What number do you start counting from?
00:20:40.020
Usually one.
00:20:41.300
But you could also.
00:20:42.020
But you could also.
00:20:42.780
Yeah.
00:20:43.060
Zero.
00:20:43.380
But you could also go down.
00:20:44.500
Right?
00:20:44.720
And you could also go up.
00:20:45.640
My point is.
00:20:46.540
Is that.
00:20:47.860
It doesn't seem like.
00:20:49.460
It's just like a flower.
00:20:50.660
Everything has a start.
00:20:51.560
It's just not like a flower.
00:20:52.460
Everything has a beginning.
00:20:53.320
Even numbers.
00:20:54.580
But not really.
00:20:55.200
Because you can go down.
00:20:56.440
Yeah.
00:20:56.540
But like.
00:20:57.720
You could still go both ways.
00:20:59.740
Is my point.
00:21:00.820
So.
00:21:00.920
Sure.
00:21:01.340
But you're equating time.
00:21:02.480
Yeah.
00:21:02.680
You could start counting with a flower.
00:21:04.580
But you could also think about what happened before it was a flower.
00:21:07.160
And what happens after it's a flower.
00:21:08.620
Right?
00:21:09.100
But just because there's a start.
00:21:10.840
Or whatever.
00:21:11.160
Doesn't mean.
00:21:11.620
That there hasn't been like.
00:21:13.480
Well.
00:21:14.020
It kind of is the existence.
00:21:15.420
Right?
00:21:16.100
Like.
00:21:16.440
A long time ago.
00:21:17.640
There has to be a God that created everything.
00:21:19.500
Right?
00:21:19.660
So.
00:21:19.940
We kind of are.
00:21:20.860
We kind of think.
00:21:21.660
We have to think about time.
00:21:22.600
I don't think you need to think of it in terms of time.
00:21:24.080
Or in terms of when.
00:21:25.520
But something must have created.
00:21:28.080
That's all.
00:21:28.640
That's.
00:21:28.880
You need to.
00:21:29.820
Like.
00:21:30.040
You've seen those space movies.
00:21:31.680
That where time isn't real.
00:21:33.180
Or whatever.
00:21:33.720
And it's cyclical.
00:21:34.420
Or whatever.
00:21:35.060
Don't think in terms of time.
00:21:37.380
There's.
00:21:37.720
It's irrefutable.
00:21:38.740
That everything we are aware of.
00:21:41.600
Has a start.
00:21:42.760
True or false?
00:21:44.360
I don't.
00:21:45.360
I think I know of that.
00:21:47.100
I don't think I believe that actually.
00:21:49.840
I mean.
00:21:50.440
You could start it from a certain spot.
00:21:52.280
But there has been stuff that's happened beforehand.
00:21:54.460
Just like the flower.
00:21:55.980
Like.
00:21:56.280
Before the flower was a flower.
00:21:57.280
It was something else.
00:21:59.140
So there's not.
00:21:59.740
Like.
00:22:00.020
We don't know if there's a start.
00:22:01.560
Or an end.
00:22:01.860
That's kind of the whole thing.
00:22:02.860
Yeah.
00:22:03.460
I try.
00:22:03.880
I try.
00:22:04.920
You can try.
00:22:05.480
I mean.
00:22:05.780
You're.
00:22:06.300
Here's a.
00:22:06.640
You can.
00:22:07.000
You can try a lot.
00:22:08.060
You're perfectly fine for it.
00:22:11.100
I'm sorry.
00:22:11.960
Okay.
00:22:18.060
That's it.
00:22:18.600
Is this your job?
00:22:19.200
Is this your job?
Link copied!