SNEAKO - August 05, 2022
This Gender Fluid Girl is Completely DELUSIONAL
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
201.09644
Summary
In this episode, we have a special guest on the show, a transphobic Trump supporter and Trump supporter. We discuss the concept of gender and gender roles, modern gender theory, and whether or not there are more than two genders.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
chat can there be more than two genders what do you think this is one of the most viral this video
00:00:05.600
got shadow banned it has 43 million views and you can't even find it when you search it but they
00:00:09.520
still like the truth really prevails i personally think there's only two genders but what do you
00:00:14.300
think put the number in the chat you know this is just a series we do where a lot of people know my
00:00:19.220
point of view there are two genders go ahead and change my mind it's the opposite of cable news
00:00:22.300
we're not going to edit anything out of context you said you disagreed i'm open to new ideas
00:00:29.120
i'm wondering the phrasing of the question are you arguing that um there's not more than like
00:00:38.720
man and woman are you arguing there's not a damn chat everybody says no you know that you're all
00:00:43.560
part of the problem you're all toxic and problematic do you know you're all transformer phobic
00:00:49.040
sex and gender or yeah i think i think there are two genders male and female
00:00:54.240
okay so you're you're saying that male and female is a gender not a sex that's the dumbest
00:01:00.020
argument that these people make gender and sex are two different things sex is biological and
00:01:04.720
gender is a construct chat are gender and sex not just exactly the same thing just different words
00:01:09.540
come on bro okay so okay and see that's that's where i would have to disagree okay
00:01:15.920
gender is a social construct male and male and female is something that uh would be by breath for
00:01:22.540
example uh you probably have a penis a male sex organ as what i but why would you assume that
00:01:29.100
do do you but you assumed it though okay i did i apologize no he's already transphobic and he just
00:01:37.200
started yeah i'm not trying to do any gotcha yeah it's interesting to me that you assumed that i
00:01:41.140
have a penis why uh because you look like a man bro look at him having to do mental gymnastics um
00:01:47.940
why did i assume that because you uh uh uh uh because of is it because of a societal construct
00:01:57.740
yeah because he's a man bro just say it that's why yes it wasn't because of my bone structure
00:02:03.800
or my penis bulge male and female is different than being a man or a woman okay and the fact that
00:02:16.180
we have as a society created man society man in the male gender roles uh and just as women gender roles
00:02:23.500
uh just as we would chat do we create do we create those roles or are they just natural
00:02:29.680
is that just what's supposed to happen in every species is this something that someone decided
00:02:35.660
and made up someone wrote legislation for generals or is that just the most natural thing ever
00:02:40.120
um anything else the same way that we would say that uh i don't know that music is good or
00:02:48.360
we have we have created it to place people into roles and so i'm saying that if you were male or female
00:02:56.140
if you identified more as a man and the gender roles that go with being a man that you have that
00:03:02.340
so you're saying so you're saying that that sex and gender are very different yes okay i understand
00:03:08.640
so that's your premise um so that's based on on kind of modern gender theory uh when did that start
00:03:14.700
i i i wouldn't know okay don't so i someone just don't know if i've said stephen crowder's an l i don't
00:03:19.300
understand why he he speaks facts for the most part i listen to him like yeah he's a white dude and so
00:03:24.160
people like oh you're a trump supporter but i have the same opinions as these guys but i don't get
00:03:28.580
labeled the same way as them i think because i'm not a white dude it's really easy to label these guys
00:03:34.540
all right okay so why let me ask you this before i guess before we get to the history why do you
00:03:42.220
accept that premise uh because he was told because it makes uh it makes the most sense to me i mean uh
00:03:51.440
the argument that we've created roles such as um being being feminine and we have associated it with
00:04:00.580
being female as opposed to being female is being feminine sure uh you understand you understand
00:04:07.720
that there are inconsistencies there for example with your presumption of my you know my penis
00:04:11.000
um let me ask you this then how many genders are there uh i would say if we're um we would say
00:04:18.680
that there are two genders being men and uh man and woman and then that there would be people that
00:04:25.860
don't accept either of those and that would be in a x or non-identifying category what's what's the
00:04:32.960
number how many genders are there i would infinite amount i can tell you isn't that important
00:04:37.660
um i mean they were the point is that before you know uh 1948 with simone de buvois and then
00:04:45.840
judith butler with modern sort of post-modernism feminism theory gender and sex were effectively
00:04:51.340
interchangeable you can even look on legal documentation depending on the permit they
00:04:54.340
are legally interchangeable i mean this is the way it's been with societies for millennia we've had
00:04:58.940
male and female um so when you radically change that you do have to have a number in in my opinion
00:05:06.440
and some kind of an end game it can't just be we're going to shift the rules based on how people
00:05:11.220
feel so i can understand if someone says hey you're exactly what we're doing is we're just shifting
00:05:15.600
the rules based on people feel and that's why people are now identifying as birds identifying as
00:05:20.820
they them these are my pronouns and you must say them matt walsh had a great point he said why do you
00:05:25.960
get to declare your pronouns do i get to declare my adjectives can i just identify as my adjectives
00:05:31.340
are handsome brilliant how is that any different from declaring your pronouns wrong that there's
00:05:37.200
difference between sex and gender but the burden of proof at that point would be on the person
00:05:42.160
asserting that they're different to tell me how many genders there are because we the society right
00:05:47.880
have to know this we have to function within certain parameters um and i and i would say that those
00:05:55.060
uh those parameters for gender would be whatever that person wants whatever they feel it to be
00:06:02.320
if they identify as a man or a woman or or a bird or plane they don't identify that would be
00:06:11.080
their prerogative and that it's not my place or your place to tell them that
00:06:16.640
they have to identify with being a man even if they are male or they have to identify as a woman even
00:06:22.480
if they are female um but we but we do that all the time people want to be things that they aren't
00:06:27.680
and we say that's not the case you know this is we constantly do that as a society so i don't
00:06:32.220
understand why it's i'm really sorry to interrupt your conversation but i have some logistical
00:06:35.580
questions for you my name is lauren chum and i work at smu student activities yes we manage the
00:06:40.120
outdoor events request process and we're gonna kick you up because i work at the student activity
00:06:44.580
shut the fuck up look at her chat what emoji should we spam for her i don't i'm not saying it
00:06:53.160
it's college republicans actually and you can speak with uh darren wherever darren is he spoke with drew
00:06:58.320
and we have a permission so okay thank you very much so sorry i'd like to continue on that thought
00:07:03.620
uh where were we sorry i forgot uh you were talking about um we have we do it all the time we do it all
00:07:09.660
the time so why why is it a problem to do it if someone we know biologically is a male or a female
00:07:15.060
um and that can never be changed yeah it can never be changed biologically uh but someone chooses to
00:07:21.740
say that they're not that's a very that's a very modern idea um and the question is why do we now
00:07:28.620
have to subscribe to that and then it gets in the idea chat chat she's brave stop compulsion of
00:07:34.960
language compelling language you know uh i work for the student activities association and i don't
00:07:40.060
like what you're saying so go away gender pronouns um what's allowed what's hate speech right it's a
00:07:45.940
it's a fundamental re-transformation of society based on from what i'm hearing from you unless i'm
00:07:52.820
mistaken abstracts i haven't heard a number i haven't heard what defines male or female only how
00:07:58.640
people feel and i just that's to me that's not very convincing or conducive toward a productive
00:08:03.800
society okay and i would uh and i would argue that um we're talking about uh like like you said when
00:08:12.440
i assumed that you had a penis when i have no idea if you have a penis or not um and that was pretty
00:08:17.760
racist to you i got a got a nice big penis there okay and so that people when uh boom book up people
00:08:24.280
subscribe to being uh you would say you see somebody that uh you would presume to be male and you ask
00:08:30.800
and you would assume that they are would identify as being a man sure um as you did yeah yes and uh
00:08:37.160
and so if um but if you had told me that you were that you um in fact don't identify as being a man
00:08:45.300
that you identify as being oh my god bro identify me identify this is why people get mad like what like
00:08:51.340
why are you not patient why don't you sit down to have a formal conversation because you hear this
00:08:55.660
nonsense coming out of his mouth i would believe that would be wrong of me to try and uh subscribe
00:09:01.680
you to being a man when you say you identify as a woman what if i told you that i believe i am a bobcat
00:09:08.280
well then i would say that that's how you identify and that's your prerogative good for you man good for
00:09:14.700
you i can allow that and just people are you you can identify as a cat now it makes no sense that
00:09:22.080
makes no sense what would you accept that would it be wrong of you to not accept it
00:09:26.260
yes really okay well listen i appreciate your intellectual consistency why would it be wrong of
00:09:35.320
you to not accept my identification as a bobcat because uh if you i did if you identify as a bobcat
00:09:44.900
man go for it great for you i hope you're the best bobcat on the fucking earth man even he knows
00:09:51.680
while he's saying it how dumb that is i appreciate it i think you're a nice guy i hope i hope this has
00:09:55.620
been productive and you you i believe this has been civil but um you do see obviously this is very
00:10:01.420
this is a very emotive uh argument that you're making right you're making an argument from a very
00:10:05.540
emotional place and i think it's because you're compassionate it's because you're a good person
00:10:08.360
but and i appreciate your intellectual consistency but the ramifications of saying that we have to
00:10:16.220
acknowledge somebody legally who identifies as a bobcat you understand would be insurmountable
00:10:22.660
the ramifications would be all sorts of new legal identifications that would be required which don't
00:10:28.100
currently exist why the conversation i would love it if you want to sit down afterward and i would love
00:10:33.700
to sit down and have look at her bald girl like and they're always they're always like i know that
00:10:40.460
there's but it's usually like a mid-white person i found this correlation with the transformers and
00:10:46.080
how much identifying they do it's usually just an average whitey who just needs a personality
00:10:52.400
continue this conversation i would well are you thank you thomas are you done yeah i appreciate it
00:10:57.680
thomas thank you i'm madison i'm co-president of spectrum how long until she gets triggered chat how
00:11:04.120
long is she going to last before she gets triggered and leaves lgbt organization
00:11:07.080
great love to talk to you about this great thank you madison my name's steven okay uh i appreciate
00:11:18.380
it uh you sitting down and um what is it that you disagree with so um i think you happen to be you're
00:11:25.020
confused on the idea of gender versus sex i'm confused okay yeah okay so when we say there are
00:11:30.480
only two genders we often confuse the idea of gender and sex sure this is a generalization and gender is a
00:11:36.300
social construct of xy chromosomes so we assume that or you know xy xx you know combination of
00:11:41.920
chromosomes um so we assume that you know male and female comes from your chromosomes right but uh
00:11:46.640
that's really just the idea that there's only two chas you ever see caillou possibilities of sex
00:11:53.880
right so even within sex itself you know you can be born uh intersex which means that you're born
00:12:00.340
with bro there's only like i hate this argument because there's literally like four people who are
00:12:04.480
intersex like you don't need okay they can have a different pronoun if you got a dick and a pussy
00:12:08.960
fine sure but that's like three people that doesn't have to the people identify i'm they them gender
00:12:15.680
fluid it's them sexual characteristics of both what we would consider male and female um and then you
00:12:22.040
have gender and gender is more about a mental state based off of societal societal so within our western
00:12:28.200
society we often discuss gender as being binary meaning that there's two options sure so boy girl man
00:12:34.240
woman however in other societies non-western societies there are more than two options okay
00:12:39.600
can i can i ask you a couple questions there to unpack wrong um appreciate you taking the time by
00:12:44.900
the way so what was your your name madison madison madison so let's go to the sex concept before
00:12:49.820
gender i think because the idea of gender being different from sex is predicated on the idea that
00:12:54.700
sex is um binary that's where you mentioned that term gender i hate that i have the same cut as
00:12:59.440
them her binary so you mentioned intersex during your quarantine when i couldn't go to the barber
00:13:04.800
i used to get the same exact cut as them but now the fade's already growing in but we have the same
00:13:10.280
cut okay i'm aware of intersex now of course intersex doesn't necessarily mean that someone is
00:13:15.500
completely between sexes usually they have very identifiable characteristics like a very large clitoris
00:13:20.440
or micro penis in that case it also affects 0.08 people think this is funny it's just true
00:13:25.500
less than 0.08 percent chat name one intersex person have you ever heard an intersex person
00:13:32.420
most of you don't even know what that is have you ever even met one it's a dude with a dick and a
00:13:36.760
pussy or a girl with a dick and a pussy they they go they just and most of the time they just chop it
00:13:41.120
off and choose one of population earth but they still exist they exist so i get to change my gender
00:13:47.220
because they exist look at you appropriating intersex culture ah from an anatomy class uh how many
00:13:54.580
fingers are you taught human beings have uh we're told typically that people have 10 however there
00:13:59.120
are people however there's other people with nine shut the fuck up but you're taught 10 right yeah so
00:14:04.580
we don't teach people there are people born with 11 fingers there are people born with 12 fingers yeah
00:14:07.520
but we don't completely dismiss that those people exist just because that they're uncommon do we we
00:14:12.500
teach that human beings have 10 fingers i would wager that everyone here has been taught yeah human
00:14:18.460
beings have 10 it's such a dumb conversation but look everyone's like intently listening
00:14:22.420
but this is just really really obvious shit figures of course there are anomalies that's the same way
00:14:27.980
that we treat intersex or these as you said you mentioned chromosomes genetic abnormalities that are
00:14:32.920
very very extreme case so i think what we need to do is remove this extreme case with sex just as we
00:14:38.360
would with how many fingers toes how many kidneys you have how many feet you have there's something
00:14:42.820
that's typical or something that's atypical then you go to gen chat stop putting the pig emoji
00:14:47.420
she's a queen he's their queen um this is where listen i'm open everyone has said sex is different
00:14:52.980
from gender and gender is not non-binary um so i would like allow you to kind of unpack that for me
00:15:00.380
yeah so uh in western society at least society so in our country in our society we believe we tend to
00:15:08.220
think of gender to be on this binary spectrum you don't well not even really a spectrum just a binary
00:15:13.300
so you have man woman and that's it those are the only two options however gender really is more
00:15:17.960
of a spectrum so it's non-binary there are not just two options okay you have man woman and then
00:15:24.140
everything that doesn't fit into just man and woman is considered non-binary that's an umbrella term
00:15:28.640
and that includes a lot of different categorizations so how many genders are there
00:15:32.620
there's infinite as many as you want i can't you can't put a number on the number of genders called it
00:15:37.300
because everyone uses different words to classify themselves i would how dumb is that that everybody
00:15:42.240
uses different words if everybody uses different words to classify themselves the language has no
00:15:47.420
meaning disagree i'm not that's where it changed my mind i'm not convinced that anyone can just use
00:15:53.300
any classification for themselves for their gender and certainly not that then we have to compel society
00:15:58.060
to address them this way right i'm sure you can understand that the compelling of language is an
00:16:05.080
issue so what gender do you think you are well i'm a male okay well i think maybe i think you're a
00:16:10.080
woman no legally i'm a male oh i think you're a woman what what it says on my driver's license that
00:16:15.880
i'm a male okay so that's your sex no it's yeah but i'm also a male that's your sex it says on my
00:16:21.140
carrier certificate that i'm a male semantics that's your sex not your gender gender some legal
00:16:25.560
documentation say gender what if i said i don't believe you it doesn't matter okay exactly it
00:16:29.780
doesn't matter if you don't believe me no it doesn't matter because biologically what gender do you
00:16:32.860
think i am i have no fucking clue caillou i would assume you're female yeah so you're making
00:16:47.080
it's just mid-white people it's average looking white people who just don't look feminine enough
00:16:54.500
and so they kind of look like a boy and so instead of just being an ugly girl
00:16:58.520
they're non-binary hey i don't respectfully it that doesn't matter it does matter now let me ask
00:17:04.840
you this what would you say if i have what pronouns you use for me it matters how i'm socializing
00:17:09.060
society it matters my gender it matters how i'm socializing society it matters the way that
00:17:15.100
bottom the chat bro i'm allowed to express myself it matters what bathroom i use it matters who i'm
00:17:19.740
allowed to live with it affects every aspect of my life so you saying so chat if i just identify as
00:17:24.180
non-binary can i go in the girl's bathroom and just yeah look at that non-binary dick bitches
00:17:30.200
what pronouns should i use you should use they them pronouns so you saying that you don't believe me
00:17:35.240
what if i don't if you don't i would consider that disrespectful and that's actually an act of
00:17:38.780
violence to misgender or trans an act of violence it's an act of violence to not use whatever
00:17:45.260
pronouns she decides what if i say it's an act of violence that my adjectives aren't handsome
00:17:51.020
slash brilliant what does violent mean none of these words have meaning anymore these people
00:17:57.340
literally live in imagination land bro it's an act of violence that is an act of violence to
00:18:02.120
intentionally misgender someone here we come to the issue and this is why i'm out here you don't
00:18:06.420
even know what violence means um you just said that's an act of violence that means it's an
00:18:10.420
actionable offense that means it's a crime so you believe that for me it's a crime i said it's an
00:18:14.120
act of violence okay an act of violence is a crime you stupid them things that are not
00:18:18.480
considered crimes or acts of violence okay so you believe it's a non-aggressive act of violence
00:18:22.600
i think that okay when you misgender someone if you were to misgender a trans woman yes trans women
00:18:29.220
especially trans women of color are the most are it's always a whitey talking about trans women of
00:18:35.100
color you don't want to get shut the fuck up about people of color bro just go back to shaving your
00:18:39.000
head and looking like caillou have the highest rate of murder within the lgbt community right
00:18:43.080
so if you were to intentionally misgender a trans woman that could put her at risk of murder you
00:18:49.120
understand that what i'm a victim i'm a victim i'm a victim because people think because i don't
00:18:59.480
i don't understand i'm sorry i don't understand i think that really does show that you're privileged
00:19:03.240
in the situation then yes i believe we're both i think you're extremely privileged in the situation
00:19:07.700
that you don't have to you're privileged you see this is the problem she can't accept the fact that
00:19:12.320
she's privileged so she just makes up a bunch of shit to become a minority because she doesn't want
00:19:17.320
to have to work for admiration she just wants to go find it with the pronouns you are privileged you're
00:19:23.420
a white bitch you're privileged your existence is privileged you have it so easy but you're just
00:19:29.800
mid and shave your head and now you're a minority okay cool well no you go back to being white bro
00:19:35.460
it's not all white people it's them bro like what the hell are you doing that or that you don't
00:19:40.280
have to worry about that or consider that that you don't feel like you need to respect people's
00:19:44.240
pronouns i'm considering this i'm asking you questions you said these are the pronouns i need
00:19:48.400
to use i said what if i don't you said that's an act of violence yeah i would consider that an act
00:19:52.020
of violence against me okay so that's a crime an act of just because you consider it an act of
00:19:56.840
violence doesn't make it an act of violence dummy violence against you is a crime she needs jesus
00:20:01.160
thank you finest gosh you need jesus i would consider that i know it's not just white people
00:20:05.780
i know it's nothing but pretty much but pretty much i've never met a non-binary fucking asian
00:20:11.520
have you met a non-binary like straight off the the border hopping off the wall mexican no they just
00:20:17.840
get to work these white people are bored bro in the midwest they got nothing going on so it is
00:20:22.340
this what they do i would consider you being disrespecting me as a person and that's not okay
00:20:27.480
and that's not even ethical it doesn't matter if it's legal it's not ethical and i don't know how
00:20:31.720
you can do something that's considered unethical i don't know how you i can't believe you would say
00:20:35.820
that cannot allow me to speak and ask questions based on your own premises please this is we're
00:20:40.320
trying to keep this civil i haven't yelled at you i haven't accused you of anything you're getting
00:20:43.640
very heated you said that's an act of violence how long until she gets up and leaves she's already
00:20:47.480
triggered but how long until she dips that's a crime okay i didn't say that was a crime an act of
00:20:52.420
violence against you is a crime so i did not say that yes you did
00:20:57.000
yes you did wrong you said it is an act of violence against you i said it's an act of
00:21:01.260
violence and i said misgendering anyone's an act yes you said it's an act of violence against that
00:21:05.020
person that is in fact a crime so here's my question since we've now decided we don't know
00:21:08.960
the number of genders it's a spectrum it exists there is no set number you've asserted the premise
00:21:14.480
that we are required to use the pronouns that are preferred by the individual we have no idea how
00:21:19.540
many pronouns there are we can never know how many pronouns there are and to not use a proper
00:21:23.020
pronoun you could ask is an act of violence against them did you ask my pronouns before you sat down
00:21:27.280
no no you didn't you fucking toxic homophobic racist incel no i didn't ask your pronouns because i
00:21:37.600
haven't referred to you with pronouns you didn't ask my pronouns though you just said you can ask
00:21:41.580
yeah you can ask what are your pronouns but you didn't ask what are your pronouns now she's asking
00:21:46.880
why you just talked about me being privileged you understand no one goes around asking pronouns
00:21:51.980
before they speak with people i asked and so to ask of a restructuring of society i did ask you
00:21:56.840
how you based on a number that's not tangible with gender versus sex is something that is
00:22:01.540
incredibly corrosive did i not ask you how you identify yourself no i don't believe so yes i did i did
00:22:06.400
actually you said you identify as male and that would after the conversation sure okay let's let's say
00:22:10.640
that sure so we need to ask pronouns before every person and if we don't use those pronouns yeah
00:22:14.880
how many pronouns are there uh as many as people feel like it ready they're it's the same kind of
00:22:21.060
thing there aren't like a limited number of pronouns just so people can see the sign would it be okay if
00:22:24.320
you just step aside for just a second there's no there's not a limited number of pronouns thank you
00:22:27.800
very much there's no limited number of pronouns no i would say the typical ones are she her hers
00:22:32.680
him his her his okay sorry him him who ha he ha lo zem zem they them theirs kapu papu kayu he him his and
00:22:42.540
they them theirs those are the typical number of pronouns we usually use three okay so i just want
00:22:47.780
to again the goal is here to change my i'm open to new ideas yeah there's no set
00:22:52.020
different kind of space around us i think i don't know no one's no one's being accosted here
00:22:58.820
we're just having a conversation there's no question of accosting we're just trying to like
00:23:02.060
bring the conversation so that it's not like a look at him trying to silence an open discussion he's
00:23:07.840
being respectful and they want this to end so bad they want to live in their nonsense so bad you
00:23:13.380
can't even have open dialogue bro like a separate stage spectacle kind of deal so like we're all in
00:23:18.780
conversation around and we can like engage with your sign sure i appreciate but it's but it's not
00:23:23.320
though actually it's a conversation between two willing participants right now and i will go other
00:23:26.980
people talking as well though i'm not i don't consent so um this is your setup and we're supposed
00:23:33.020
to just follow your rules yes yeah it's his fucking show stupid make your own why are you complaining
00:23:39.300
one is invited and we've gotten the proper permissions and i've said open campus a college
00:23:43.100
campus sure it's an open campus you can do whatever you want you can protest but it doesn't mean
00:23:48.180
that we're i'm going to be engaging in conversation with the crowd no that's not incorrect but i would
00:23:54.140
but i would love to continue my conversation here so when we talk about jen bro he's such a w interviewer
00:23:59.300
bro i would have been heated by that shit that's stupid ass like actually this is a campus and i
00:24:03.900
could do whatever i want okay but like he's not doing nothing wrong he's asking questions having an
00:24:10.580
exercising freedom of speech and she's that yeah i would have been already tight bro gender and sex
00:24:15.640
right this is a very new idea you said in western society it's not a new idea really no it's not so
00:24:20.100
when did when did gender theory start when did gender and sex become separate well they're actually
00:24:24.560
it it's not necessarily the idea of gender theory it's the idea that there have been different genders
00:24:30.140
outside of man woman for centuries okay how so yeah uh india in india you know they have third gender
00:24:37.660
native american cultures they have third genders in ancient egypt they had third genders okay you know so
00:24:43.500
that's a very it's a very western idea to say that there are only two genders and that this
00:24:47.680
whole thing is a new idea changing well you know what else is a very western idea so it seems to me
00:24:51.660
your your presupposition there correct me if i'm wrong is that because other cultures have done this
00:24:56.620
there's a precedent yeah most cultures everywhere of all time have had two genders i don't think that
00:25:03.640
we're hermetically sealed in any way so you do realize um and you talk about how very different it
00:25:08.100
was from western culture so antithetical to western culture you named india chat w who's w for
00:25:13.440
okay one for stephen two for caillou who's winning so far ancient egypt you know what else uh we also
00:25:19.820
believe in that's antithetical to those cultures we're against slavery
00:25:22.780
i'm sorry i'm so i'm really confused as to why you brought slavery let me let me i'm offended and
00:25:30.840
that's an act of violence about gender i would love to bring it up yeah it's kind of that's kind of my
00:25:34.700
point is because your premise is because it's found in other societies therefore it's okay
00:25:39.740
or it is to be good my point is there are plenty of other practices well i'm trying to get to why i
00:25:45.320
believe it's harmful and you're explaining why you don't but the point is if something was practiced
00:25:48.680
in another society and it was harmful in another society and we agree that it's harmful for example
00:25:53.360
we both agree that slavery was harmful we both agree that maybe cannibalism is harmful you can find
00:25:57.540
these practices in societies where the where the lgbqs at like who where you at bro i don't see any
00:26:03.960
my point is it's not a valid argument to simply say it's been found in other societies
00:26:08.280
if that practice is harmful so it comes down to the idea of is it productive or harmful for us to
00:26:18.960
so that's that's the question so other societies have done harmful things i think we can agree that
00:26:26.600
doesn't necessarily mean that it's i'm sorry i don't think i don't think respecting someone's
00:26:29.780
identity makes that harmful i don't understand i think i don't agree with you comparing gender
00:26:35.480
identity to cannibalism or slavery that seems pretty offensive i know it seems you think a lot
00:26:41.120
of what i've said is offensive you've been set up here from the get-go for it to be offensive and i'm
00:26:44.560
not trying to offend because they only know how to be triggered they just said in like i'm right
00:26:48.760
and i'm triggered and i can't believe you would say that and their whole argument tactic is just
00:26:54.440
waiting to call you a racist misogynistic bigot that's all they want to do they don't actually
00:27:00.140
want to talk to you let me re-explain what it is take any practice okay take the practice of
00:27:05.200
neck stretching for example which is you see that crossed arms like yeah you're you're a man and i
00:27:11.660
you're you're harmful okay it is harmful actually okay well some people well actually you're committing
00:27:18.440
a crime don't think it's harmful they don't think it's harmful in these societies take any
00:27:21.460
practice that's relatively benign that we believe to be harmful that they don't believe to be harmful
00:27:25.260
the point is just because another society at one point has practiced it doesn't make it correct
00:27:30.700
can we agree on that i i'm sorry i just i think you're making really false comparisons no i'm not i
00:27:37.800
do i think can we agree can we agree because listen they're also many chat rate rate or fit
00:27:43.100
like librarian vibes like bro you're in college you look like you're 53 like a society is the other
00:27:49.340
way right who've only ever remember two genders two sexes but that doesn't mean that's most other
00:27:53.300
genders don't exist that's most so you're implying that those societies were wrong i'm i'm implying
00:27:58.800
that they have their other societal standards societal standards are based off of a lot of things
00:28:04.280
it's very intersectional what we decide to accept in society so if you're going to say
00:28:08.980
well because you're essentially making the same art yeah society can be wrong society was wrong about
00:28:14.300
gay marriage you know i think people are wrong saying that you know gay marriage being gay is
00:28:19.920
unnatural and being gay is a crime not society being wrong but you know what we adapt to modern
00:28:25.220
times and i think that this is she's getting heated she's ready to start throwing hands right here
00:28:29.620
no debate this she just wants to fight but you just compared us to ancient egypt and india as though
00:28:35.280
that was a valid argument for convincing me why look at that how much pressure this is and he's still
00:28:40.100
staying composed all these college kids just ready to start a protest right now this isn't an ancient
00:28:45.420
practice this is still going on sure in other countries this is still but you just said it's
00:28:48.960
not fair to use other societal comparisons uh i'm saying it's not fair to compare gender to slavery
00:28:54.360
no no no no no i'm i'm trying to get to the premise of the argument i'm trying to get to the premise
00:28:58.980
gender you can't compare gender to slavery i'm a victim slavery's bad um actually slavery's bad
00:29:06.160
like that's not what he's saying dummy the premise of your argument here okay the premise i'm trying
00:29:10.260
to get this as very respectful as possible you've said this has been practiced in other societies for
00:29:14.340
a long time yeah my point is that's not an argument because there have been horrible things maybe benign
00:29:19.540
things maybe semi-harmful things in other societies we would both agree on that so it's not a valid
00:29:23.900
argument to bring slavery back though no one is arguing to bring slavery exactly so why are you
00:29:27.740
actually they are and of course it still exists in other countries in the middle east and some
00:29:30.460
countries that you've mentioned like i said i just i don't think you're making a fair comparison
00:29:33.240
i think you're kind of making a very fair i think you're kind of just going on a tangent in order
00:29:37.060
to try my point is it's not it's not an argument it is an argument i think it's an argument okay so
00:29:41.540
i will i will use your our western standards yo shout out to you to judith okay are not necessarily
00:29:46.660
the pinnacle of what we should be doing western societal standards do not mean that we all need
00:29:52.720
to be following the same thing because we're not all western and we don't all follow those beliefs
00:29:57.380
so if a native american person of course you do if it's the law we all have to follow the law
00:30:01.000
yeah okay so yeah the law is different i think the law is different than a societal a societal
00:30:05.220
standard so legal societal standard well hold on a second how is how is the law different it is just
00:30:10.980
a bad fit like you just look like you suck the societal standard legally legally yeah yeah yeah
00:30:18.800
let's stay within those parameters okay sure so um in other there's other countries that are
00:30:24.600
considered western that would recognize a third gender sure yeah yeah i know that okay so why not so how
00:30:30.660
many genders are there it comes back to if we're going to chat who does she look like we're going
00:30:34.240
to change this who does they look like i'm sorry i'm sorry for misgendering you
00:30:37.660
so we are um sitting here talking about gender yeah so if i were do you hear the feminist fucking
00:30:46.520
just reciting articles right now while they're having a conversation they're so childish talk so
00:30:52.680
this is a modern theory in the united states right sex and gender were interchangeable no i'm gonna finish
00:30:57.060
one sentence here okay i would appreciate that you've been very privileged in in speaking over
00:31:00.620
me um i'm not convinced right the john do you hear in the background in 2013 fox news just like
00:31:06.140
they're fucking children up here to sit down and change my mind i think that's very productive for
00:31:10.120
you to do with other people on campus i don't think this is a way to change somebody's mind i don't
00:31:14.280
think you want your mind changed i i have had my mind changed well instead of instead of assuming that
00:31:19.260
how about actively trying to change it so my point is you've mentioned that it's non-binary but you
00:31:25.640
haven't given me a number of genders and how we restructure society you've merely pointed out that
00:31:30.180
it's an act of violence to use an improper pronoun now she dead looks like lesbian peter griffin okay
00:31:36.360
okay sorry that would have you just talked about a societal standard if the societal standard is using
00:31:41.740
the wrong pronoun is an act of violence against somebody i think that's an incredibly dangerous
00:31:46.760
societal standard and it's one that nobody can uphold consistently would we not agree i said i
00:31:51.980
mean intentionally using the wrong gender i mean when you know someone's pronouns you intentionally
00:31:56.500
use the wrong pronouns because you don't agree with them or you don't recognize their identity to be
00:32:00.380
real so if i accidentally call you a he because you kind of look like a dude i'm committing an act
00:32:05.920
of violence that's an act of chat said she looks like if 11 from stranger things ate 11 that's purposely
00:32:11.940
disrespecting someone you no one wants to be purposefully disrespected i i am
00:32:16.740
believe me i understand you the wrong name all the time how would you feel i i would feel very
00:32:21.160
disrespected how would you feel exactly if you for example came in bombastically and other people
00:32:25.320
interrupting i'd feel very disrespected can she develop that act of violence thing like where
00:32:30.300
does that take us if someone uses the offensive pronoun it's yeah so it's intentionally using the
00:32:34.740
wrong pronoun so if you ask someone their pronouns or they were correct you and say no sorry these are
00:32:38.800
my correct pronouns and you continue to disrespect them you have to understand how much that puts a
00:32:45.120
trans person at risk yeah does that person go to get arrested for using the wrong pronoun or
00:32:49.960
like it's an act of violence active violence i don't and i know that you like to say that an
00:32:54.260
act of violence mean that it's legally a crime it is that's not how i'm defining an act of violence
00:32:59.340
it doesn't matter how you define an act of violence this is the thing we have to have legal definition
00:33:02.300
how you define an act of i identify as an act of violence no matter how the law defines the act of
00:33:08.340
violence i don't think it does you don't think it matters how the law defines i know i'm saying that
00:33:13.060
an act of violence does not have to mean that it's a crime i'm saying that it's an act of violence
00:33:17.400
against another person unwilling participant you know she just said if it's disrespectful it's an
00:33:23.140
act of violence is in fact a crime legally there's no way around that can we agree on that
00:33:27.140
can we agree on that let's find some common ground can we agree an act of violence against
00:33:31.000
somebody else is a crime and no one should commit it i'm saying no one should commit it i'm not
00:33:35.200
going to say that it's necessarily oh my god okay but it is illegal say something that makes sense
00:33:39.900
for five seconds carl from jimmy neutron i'll allow i'll allow you to assume what you want but
00:33:44.740
it is illegal thought then i would like you to finish your earlier thought but i think this is a
00:33:48.140
very central point to the argument because this is one of the first things that you've said all she
00:33:51.480
has done is just in her all they have done is interrupt the whole time and we haven't found
00:33:55.780
common ground we don't agree on that i do find that the idea of yeah no sorry can i hear what
00:34:01.420
she has to say chat have you also she just misgendered her she didn't even ask how she
00:34:05.500
identifies before asking her questions so chat who's winning have you has your mind been changed
00:34:10.640
at all by carl from jimmy neutron and she wants to take my question so since this is an equal setup
00:34:16.280
no i appreciate well you can sit down afterwards and we'll have a conversation no no listen i would
00:34:22.140
like to have a conversation with one person and then you can all line up and have one on one
00:34:25.420
conversation but i do i don't consent so i'll have a one-on-one conversation
00:34:31.060
it's not shoving a microphone dummy it's his fucking show i'm not shoving a microphone jesus christ you
00:34:40.940
see how they only know how to be victims you're literally shoving a microphone in her face they
00:34:45.520
just victimize themselves with the microphone it's an act of violence to interview somebody
00:34:51.160
i'm simply holding it so let her have the mic but you just said let her it's a name feminist you
00:34:59.020
just misgendered her that's an act of violence this is not an equal setup i've paid for this microphone
00:35:04.000
this is my microphone so would you like to would you like to have her take your place i'd like to
00:35:10.680
finish my thought that you haven't let me finished yet actually okay do we have a time code
00:35:14.880
do we have a time code these people are just the worst i believe it's been about uh over 30 minutes
00:35:20.260
but go ahead yeah so i would like to finish my thought because i it actually hasn't been over
00:35:23.500
30 minutes it's been less than 30 minutes okay go ahead um so my thought is that you talk about
00:35:27.640
legal ramifications how many look at him shoving the microphone in her face by leaning in so that she
00:35:32.160
could be audible genders are there okay so when you have countries that recognize third genders
00:35:37.700
or non-binary gender options you know how they put that on their form non-binary other yeah she's
00:35:44.980
non-binary they're non-binary the feminist who was speaking up for her just misgendered her
00:35:49.000
and they didn't even say nothing about it you know they're gender right how is that complicated
00:35:54.940
well can i can i tell you how it's problematic how is that problematic it's problematic because you
00:35:59.400
have people who've been sued arrested or put out of business for unknowingly using the improper
00:36:03.980
pronouns and that's the point that i'm making there's been a you're you're referring to a
00:36:07.900
societal standard what can be filled out on a form that's your premise michael i've connected it to
00:36:12.620
the mainframe you can hack it to your phone and make sure to text us so you can get the message in
00:36:16.800
michael i'm saying there's been a societal standard one that's biologically based for millennia which
00:36:22.240
we've now changed and we're punishing people who don't agree so you may think it's disrespectful for
00:36:26.180
someone to not use the pronouns that you demand i think it's equally respectful but disrespectful
00:36:30.120
to demand that somebody live in a spectrum that hasn't been agreed to and they don't even
00:36:34.940
understand look she's like pouting right now why are you frowning lester from gta
00:36:41.000
that yo check w comparison i didn't come up with that i don't know who did it in the chat but that
00:36:47.360
is too accurate how what businesses have been put out what you can put out a business for not using
00:36:53.480
the right pronouns oh in the uk this happens all the time in canada you know bill c16 specific business
00:36:57.900
yeah and both c16 in canada is really important for example we have uh we have comedians who've
00:37:02.080
been put before human rights tribunals so canada recognizes a third gender though
00:37:05.660
can't yeah canada does legally recognize their gender so the law is their legal standard that's
00:37:10.140
their societal standard right so the people who aren't you agreeing with that aren't agreeing with
00:37:14.280
their societal standard right but it's a societal standard that flies in the you're not agreeing with
00:37:17.600
my societal standard for mr t lexify face of biology and my issue is do you believe that people
00:37:24.680
should be put before human rights tribunals for using the improper gen gender is biology it was
00:37:29.360
until 1948 you know that right uh no i don't agree with you on that i'm sorry okay but when did
00:37:33.880
gender theory start i don't know the year of gender theories like two years ago it's funny this
00:37:38.440
video came out in 2017 and like it's still it's getting it's getting but now there's birds bro
00:37:43.100
i'm sorry i'm not a human encyclopedia okay it was 1948 simone de beauvoir and judith butler
00:37:48.700
these are people by the way when he started it there were still only two genders gender was a
00:37:51.780
grammatical issue usually used to refer to as a noun i'm french canadian so in french we have
00:37:55.900
masculine and feminine right it really is a very new concept and one that is not rooted in any kind
00:38:01.380
of biological precedent to say that there are unlimited genders that's the issue and so when
00:38:06.700
you are jailing people and punishing people for not adhering to an entirely new system that you
00:38:11.240
yourself hasn't that you haven't defined i do think that that's a problem i think saying that
00:38:16.020
somebody using improper pronouns is an act of violence against someone i just disagree i think that's
00:38:21.200
i think it's a real problem and i would hate this disrespectful i think it's disrespectful to
00:38:25.740
force somebody to use pronouns i think they're being invented by the day if i told they're not
00:38:30.360
yo chat doesn't she look like a strong six light seven being invented by the day i don't know where
00:38:35.520
you're getting that information how many genders are there how many pronouns are there she's literally
00:38:39.600
transition i can't define the number of genders or the number of pronouns exactly because anyone can
00:38:45.020
determine them they are being invented by the day new genders each day so if i told you that i
00:38:50.240
identified as you know if i said hey i want you i like the rattling high hats to use just my name not
00:38:56.820
my pronouns sure does that make you uncomfortable no right that wasn't hard transition was it no it
00:39:06.400
wasn't hard yeah exactly that's what people are asking you to do no yeah you know as a matter of fact
00:39:11.100
you have a ta we just had her on the program yesterday who uh sorry on monday um who got in
00:39:16.520
trouble for using the student's name because a student demanded that he use fem uh use masculine
00:39:20.980
pronouns even though she was a girl and he said listen i'm not comfortable with that i will use her
00:39:24.580
name masculine pronouns i believe that person would be using masculine pronouns and you just misgendered
00:39:29.820
them yeah also the feminist defending you misgendered you dummy name you said he used the name
00:39:35.980
said her yes yeah i did because she's a female um that's not how that works i think that is how
00:39:40.840
that works so we established that is how that works you agreed with me previously that we and we
00:39:45.040
established previously gender and sex are totally different no i don't agree no how do you know that
00:39:49.100
person's a female i know that because of biology and here's the thing gender theory did you look at
00:39:53.620
them did you like it's just like just shut the fuck up like happen to just like examine them and
00:39:58.360
decide that person's a female because of what you saw is their external genitalia can i ask you a
00:40:02.420
question yeah do you genuinely feel that i've been interrupting you more than you
00:40:06.020
you keep saying you're not able to finish a thought i haven't finished a phrase
00:40:14.020
i think you just finished a phrase that was a question bro do we want to score points or do we
00:40:19.660
want to be i think you've been interrupting me quite a bit and you just assumed a premise
00:40:23.360
i don't agree with no i that's my point that i've not been able to make is gender theory as you're
00:40:30.440
describing it is very new it started with simone de barboire in 1948 and what you're discussing is
00:40:35.640
the idea that actually came with judith butler the only the first time there was this idea that
00:40:39.000
there were more than two genders was john money i'm sure you're familiar with that case um that's
00:40:45.160
behind this theory it is based on an emotive response so i don't agree that gender and sex are
00:40:56.820
separate legal documentation sometimes don't say they're separate we're trying to adapt
00:41:00.580
that now based on how people feel and i don't think that we should adapt the law considering
00:41:07.800
something an act of she looks like walter white before the cancer violence because someone uses
00:41:11.720
a pronoun which is biologically correct because you consider an act of violence against you what's a
00:41:17.320
biological pronoun he her his how do we determine that language you fucking idiot whether they're
00:41:29.320
male or female yeah but how do we determine that what if we decided that she her hers was what we
00:41:34.940
we're going to use for males it doesn't matter it doesn't matter we right now yeah right now we have
00:41:40.100
male and female his or her standard right no it's a logical standard the words that we use are based
00:41:50.980
off of like what we as a society as a society yeah their reflection is pretty societally based okay
00:41:57.020
societally societal amphibian what about amphibians is that societally based an amphibian is a
00:42:04.660
is it i don't you know what i'm not a science major but i will say an amphibian is
00:42:09.040
a like scientific care classification of a reptile yeah it's a
00:42:16.120
classification of an animal species bush tree blueberry yeah okay these societal terms the point is that
00:42:24.860
language is a reflection of standards that we have a society are doctors sexist i think some doctors
00:42:31.800
are sexist are doctors transphobic to refer to their patients who have a penis and they come in
00:42:35.780
for a process those doctors are committing an act of violence it examines glasses kid from polar express
00:42:41.760
the male is that doctor hate speaking is that an act of aggression i think if that doctor misgenders
00:42:46.600
their patient then yeah they are being transphobic okay well i don't i my mind is not changed but i
00:42:51.920
think uh and i tried to find some common ground i'm sorry that we didn't i'm sorry i'm sorry that you
00:42:56.320
feel that way yeah thank you medicine i'm not gonna i figured oh whoa you can't even shake a hand
00:43:03.240
look at him you came out on top bro spam out of the chat for fucking bully from bully
00:43:24.600
nah not being able to shake his hand is fucking
00:43:38.800
hey i'm doing well thurman how are you what's your head steven nice to meet you thurman sorry
00:43:47.900
yeah by the way if you'd like to hold the mic his name is thurman
00:43:51.900
okay the feminists also misgendered you and shoot and thank you for disrespecting me oh wow
00:44:08.800
you're just gonna commit an act of violence thank you i'm staying in a place that i don't like
00:44:13.560
i could be in a class of doing anything else but i'm staying where i'm triggered okay here's the
00:44:19.760
thing that was actually by accident because i've been using he and her for my entire life it's not
00:44:25.320
meant as an act of disrespect and now you see the problem in claiming that's an act of violence
00:44:29.180
against somebody i'm sure you can establish intent with every person you encounter thurman
00:44:35.040
how are you sir fantastic yeah it seems like there have been people who've gotten into a
00:44:42.540
fight at the dinner table and now we all have to put a good face on but thurman i'm i'm glad to
00:44:46.680
have you here i'm open to having my mind changed um so i'll just break this down for you basically
00:44:57.580
basically you guys are trying to establish like sex and gender which technically are different
00:45:09.900
down to more uh you know reproductive uh potentials and gender is like a lifestyle
00:45:16.900
and everything like that more societal yeah okay yeah yeah um look at him he's already willing to
00:45:24.780
take part in the theme of the show change my mind he's like okay let me just sit down be open-minded
00:45:29.020
i'm not going to sit and cross my arms and be triggered the whole time i really don't know
00:45:32.180
what to make of the uh of the new like gender standards now is in terms of like you know people
00:45:39.900
just living whatever lifestyle they want so if let's say someone that appears to be you know
00:45:45.440
lives a male's lifestyle um i don't understand where we transition to like having new classifications
00:45:54.160
and everything like that uh but technically speaking there are sexuality spectrum and gender
00:45:59.700
spectrum right so you have you know your typical healthy male your xy you have your typical healthy
00:46:05.260
female xx so if you have something like client filters right chad how much anime does you watch a day
00:46:11.720
now this isn't just i think there's variations of how many x rooms can i say one one question there
00:46:17.360
why do you say healthy xx xy um healthy meaning basically the standard non-deviant
00:46:24.580
what people would consider normal okay yeah so if you have client filters right technically speaking
00:46:31.900
that would be non-binary and that's not a lifestyle who does thermos look like that actually is a
00:46:39.100
biological thing sure so we discuss people who are intersex yeah yeah yeah so you'll have like
00:46:43.860
and that's not to say they're hermaphrodites because we don't have that in our species but
00:46:47.160
you know they'll have the two x's and the y's of under uh underdeveloped male um
00:46:52.160
sex um machinery i still see your shadows in my room
00:46:58.940
it's okay it's not going on it's not you're not going to worry we don't need to censor anything
00:47:04.180
you can use the right word and they can we talk about this either some men with like they call it
00:47:07.060
micropenis it's been used as an insult but it's an actual term yeah what you're referring to
00:47:10.280
or enlarged clitoris these are these are medical conditions as you're discussing
00:47:13.720
they have enlarged breasts you know smaller you know male reproductive organs high-pitched voices
00:47:18.840
you know genomastica yeah yeah so sure in that case and i'm not disagreeing with that yeah so in
00:47:25.120
that case yes there's no debate you know you technically are both sex wise and gender i i honestly
00:47:32.520
have no idea how to how to choose that that really kind of depends on sure or like how like severe
00:47:39.440
how severe cases sure um can i can i address a couple things there maybe follow up with some
00:47:44.100
questions um we talked about it earlier with intersex you know it affects such a small percent
00:47:47.620
of the population yeah um and most of these people actually have very identifiable um you know sexes
00:47:54.600
generally speaking it's not just right in the middle to be considered to talk about like the
00:47:58.140
previous conditions you mentioned men with these conditions or female with these conditions
00:48:01.000
that's often the the rule with intersex um not always right but um as we said we teach there are
00:48:07.480
people have two feet now some people don't have two feet in anatomy class we teach people have
00:48:12.200
ten toes we teach people have one heart we teach people have one head all of these things have
00:48:17.420
exceptions to the rules right all these medical aspects so the point is we don't use extreme
00:48:22.200
exception to define our rules as a matter of fact that's how we consider those exceptions yeah um so
00:48:28.160
biologically sex male and female this is how it's been taught i think we would all read that but sex
00:48:33.300
has been taught that way and then you've talked about gender you said you're not entirely sure so
00:48:37.580
i would like to hear your thoughts your opinions on on gender how that differs from sex and how we
00:48:43.380
define it uh just by definition gender is basically like your lifestyle like choices or lifestyle rules
00:48:50.100
so if you were saying hey baby i want to take you on a date like by the way would you like some water
00:48:57.300
all right i know it's hot out here no okay i appreciate it no so like if you're finding roles
00:49:02.580
right so like uh like let's say like courting so you know steve you ask a girl you know thinks
00:49:08.820
she's cute you say courting yeah yeah i ask a dame ask i ask i go court a dame i love it you're
00:49:14.820
using all term now no no i like it that's very respectful courting that means you're a gentleman yeah
00:49:20.020
so uh anyway so yeah you know you see a girl you know she's cute you take her out you asked her you
00:49:26.420
pay you know typically this how that goes so that would be like your gender roles your gender role as
00:49:32.020
a man okay yeah well you mentioned gender roles right and i hear that a lot we say gender roles
00:49:38.820
so are we to mean that gender as you know authenticated through whatever documentation we
00:49:44.020
provide right now or how we have to identify people are we really just saying is gender a synonym for
00:49:48.980
gender roles gender roles is the behavior of your gender does that make sense so like how you like
00:49:54.740
identify somebody's gender sure is basically the lifestyle choice just by definitions well i'm only
00:50:01.460
i'm only asking this again none of this has got you i'm asking because when i asked you how gender
00:50:04.740
was different you said it was more it was performative it was based on behavior yeah and then you said but