On the precipice of a federal budget, David talks about the Big Bad Budget Battle and why he thinks it s going to fail. Plus, an update on the ostrich farm, and a new poll that suggests more Canadians want the government to spend more.
00:00:00.800Hey, welcome back to another episode of Stand on Guard. I'm your host, David Creighton, broadcasting to you live from Ottawa on a very overcast, rainy day here in our nation's capital on the precipice, on the cusp of a federal budget. We'll have more about that. Yes, and an update on the ostrich farm when we return in mere moments.
00:00:23.620The Prime Minister lied and his minions continue to... Your home is your castle. We're calling on the government to introduce and immediately pass the Stand on Guard law. But we also need a resolve to resist.
00:00:54.120We'll do it live! I'll write it and we'll do it live!
00:01:02.020We're still doing it live. Thanks for joining me today.
00:01:05.620We call this show the Big Bad Budget Battle, and that's supposed to sound like an old Dragnet episode.
00:01:12.480Do you remember the old Dragnet episodes? About 52 to 59, I believe, in black and white, came back in color from 67 to 70.
00:01:23.880Do you remember those? Yeah. Jack Webb, great shows, great shows.
00:01:28.560And Jack was not liked, by the way. And I... Don't let me get distracted here, but, you know, the other side of me, of course, is entertainment.
00:01:37.360So I should do more of, because politics can get you down.
00:01:41.560Jack Webb was a freewheeling, fun-loving guy, married to Julie London at one time,
00:01:47.460who was one of the most gorgeous and best female singers of the 1950s and 60s.
00:01:57.120And the two of them used to go to nightclubs and just listen to jazz music.
00:02:01.320And I did that the other night at a local hotel in Ottawa, Brook Street.
00:03:17.400Maybe it's a bit of an update about what's happening here.
00:03:20.380Two days before Mark Carney presents his first federal budget, it's still not clear which party will help the minority liberal government pass it.
00:03:29.120We don't need a higher cost of living through a higher-costed budget.
00:03:33.220We need an affordable budget for affordable lives for all Canadians.
00:03:36.620The Conservatives and the bloc both say they're willing to help on their own terms.
00:03:41.860Pierre Polyev is calling for fewer taxes and less spending.
00:03:45.720The inflation that that spending has caused has landed on the shoulders of single moms and seniors and others who can't pay their bills.
00:03:53.700But new polling by Nanos Research for CTV News shows more Canadians are willing to accept a higher level of spending if it means investing in programs for Canadians.
00:04:04.340Support for the idea is up to 47% from 35% two years ago.
00:04:27.380It sounds like, oh, more Canadians want the government to spend more money.
00:04:31.020And this is Nick Nanos' reporting, polling, by the way.
00:04:34.480And I do find that NB's 10s, whether it's wittingly or unwittingly, whether it's because of the way they phrase the questions, I find that NB's polling favors the Liberals.
00:04:45.880So 47% of Canadians want the government to spend more money.
00:04:53.180Well, more are still in favor of a balanced budget.
00:04:57.440So, but that's not the gist of what you get from this report.
00:05:00.440Neck and neck with those hoping for a balanced budget that cuts taxes.
00:05:05.360The single most important thing this budget needs to work towards is increasing investment in Canada.
00:05:10.720We have both immediate challenges with what we're doing with the United States and long-term challenges around growth and productivity.
00:05:19.020Support for infrastructure investment as a top budget priority has doubled since 2023, now just behind tackling the deficit.
00:05:26.580But health care remains the top priority for Canadians.
00:05:30.440Even as issues like inflation, housing and tariff relief take away some of the focus.
00:05:35.460For average Canadians, what they want to see is no cuts to health care at this particular point in time.
00:05:39.760But they're going to want to see investments in the long term.
00:05:42.500Mark Carney campaigned on a $4 billion investment in community health care and has repeatedly promised not to cut provincial health transfers.
00:05:51.080While the Liberals don't have the votes to pass the budget on their own, they could do it if some opposition members abstained from voting.
00:05:59.280Asked about that today, Poiliev says his Conservative MPs will be there Tuesday and do their jobs.
00:11:44.300We believe in 26 different deals with nine different countries, with every single G7 country, along with other allied countries from four different continents.
00:11:59.060The vast majority of those deals were with countries other than the United States.
00:12:04.820The United States did participate in that.
00:12:22.720So I fundamentally reject your premise.
00:12:26.100What we are doing is aligning ourselves with the G7.
00:12:29.900We are aligning ourselves with a multilateral approach to solving this problem.
00:12:35.480The U.S., though, has been spearheading for a long time, trying to prompt actions from allies, traditional allies, I should say, to counter China's dominance in the critical mineral space.
00:12:48.620I combine the announcement today, and I take your point that it is a multilateral effort, with three other announcements, pardon me, which give the U.S. government specifically increased access to strategic assets in this country.
00:13:03.140While at the same time the White House is throwing down tariffs, the ambassador is lambasting us, the president is referencing us as the 51st state, how do you reconcile that for Canadians?
00:13:14.120Why are we handing that leverage over, Minister?
00:13:17.560So let me give you a little bit of a history lesson.
00:13:21.120For the last many years, people have been talking about the challenges of critical mineral supply chains.
00:13:46.660We got the agreement of the other G7 countries.
00:13:50.660We suggested the other countries appoint critical mineral envoys, which they all did in response to our request.
00:13:59.260And since the summer, we, Canada, have been taking the lead with our critical mineral envoys, working with the critical mineral envoys of nine other countries, including every single G7 country, to turn that talk into real action.
00:14:16.360And that real action is $6.4 billion of Canadian projects now moving ahead to go from talk to reality.
00:14:28.940I think that's a great example of Canada punching above its weight.
00:14:33.840Thank you, Minister, for the history lesson.
00:14:35.240But it doesn't address the substance of my question around why.
00:14:39.760Thank you, Minister, for the history lesson.
00:14:45.540We are allowing the U.S. government, not U.S. companies, the U.S. government, increased access to strategic assets at a time when we are engaged in a trade war, at a time when the prime minister has specifically said the relationship, as we know it with the United States, as far as economic and security interdependence, is over.
00:15:05.080Is that not the converse of what your party and your government has told Canadians?
00:15:10.820Again, I don't think you have it accurate.
00:15:13.980Again, I just don't think we're talking at the same intellectual level.
00:15:22.540I don't think this conversation is at all coherent, largely because you don't seem to understand the point.
00:15:33.520Is that not the converse of what your party and your government has told Canadians?
00:16:04.520Again, I don't think you have it accurate.
00:16:08.880We have never said we don't want to trade with Americans.
00:16:11.800Americans have been great trading parts.
00:16:13.480What we've said is we want to diversify and grow our trading relationships.
00:16:17.420What the prime minister has said is we will significantly grow our trading relationships with other allies, with other allies who share our values.
00:16:29.140We just announced 26 deals with nine different countries, including every single G7 country.
00:16:38.980We are doing what we said we would do, which is to diversify our trading relationships, grow our relationships with our allies.
00:16:48.420That is what we've said from the very beginning.
00:16:50.460That's what Canadians expect us to do.
00:16:52.840We are not proposing to shrink our relationship with the Americans.
00:16:57.260We are proposing to grow our relationship with others.
00:17:00.100Are you sure that you and your party colleagues have never said that you're proposing to not keep the relationship where it is with the United States?
00:17:10.160Because I remember the prime minister saying our old relationship we have with the U.S. based on deepening integration of our economies and tight security and military cooperations is over.
00:17:19.420That is the message with great respect, minister, that Canadians received during the campaign and after.
00:17:24.720I understand that what you did today is about multilateralism, but not everything on the critical mineral file falls into that category.
00:17:32.040And the examples I provided are about deepening the relationship with a White House, with a U.S. government that has taken direct aim at our country.
00:17:42.640She gets four stars out of four for that question, for that statement, for saying, without saying, Mark Carney lied consistently, chronically, constantly during the election campaign with the elbows up BS.
00:17:58.200He had no intention of changing the trade relationship with the United States.
00:18:02.040He hasn't done anything with the United States since becoming the elected prime minister.
00:20:33.620Sorry, I'm brain fart, as we used to say in the military.
00:20:36.940Those fantastic rallies across the country where he mobilized, he galvanized, he motivated, he inspired conservatives.
00:20:46.000Remember, at those rallies he talked about, not a single member of my caucus or cabinet, I think he said both cabinet and caucus, will be allowed to go to Davos, Switzerland, to attend World Economic Forum conferences when I'm prime minister.
00:21:02.560And that got him the biggest standing ovation of anything he said, every time.
00:21:08.500That's what the grassroots want to hear.
00:21:40.380He needs to sound a little like Maxime Bernier and the People's Party of Canada.
00:21:45.780Because if they're not afraid to tackle these issues, they know they're not going to win this next election.
00:21:51.840And maybe that has something to do with the fact that they have a lot more courage and bravery to talk about issues that peer polio doesn't.
00:21:58.940But if only the Conservative Party of Canada would realize that it shouldn't be a question of courage or bravery.
00:22:07.340It should be a question of common sense to talk about so many of these issues that matter to conservative voters.
00:22:14.220And it matters to common sense voters.
00:22:16.040Talk about freedom of speech in Canada.
00:22:17.680How the Liberals tried to destroy it in a few short months for surveillance censorship bills in front of Parliament.
00:22:26.340That was the focus of the Mark Carney government.
00:22:28.720Not getting a deal, a trade deal with the United States.
00:22:31.560That was the last thing on Mark Carney's mind.
00:22:33.500He did everything possible to sabotage it, along with Doug Ford of Ontario.
00:22:38.560Mark Carney worked very hard on censorship and surveillance bills.
00:22:43.020And that's the only legacy he has since winning the April 28th federal election.
00:22:49.940That's what conservative voters and that's what common sense voters on all sides of the spectrum need to be reminded of.
00:22:57.180This is a Carney government that wants to shut your mouth and put you in jail for saying things they disagree with.
00:23:29.680But here's, I think polio does a great job of fencing with her here.
00:23:34.940Like everywhere Mark Carney goes, with these grand meetings and photo ops, we end up with more tariffs.
00:23:42.260His failures abroad are costing us at home.
00:23:44.600He met with the Chinese president, you know, and they made a decision that their officials were going to get together and try and solve the trade irritants.
00:24:13.840I said that I would face President Trump and the rest of the world from a position of strength.
00:24:18.760Right now we're in a position of weakness.
00:24:20.620The Americans know we can't sell our goods to anyone else because we don't have pipelines and LNG plants to get our most valuable export to other markets.
00:24:28.680I would pass the Canadian Sovereignty Act, which would rapidly greenlight and legalize pipelines, LNG plants, and other infrastructure.
00:24:37.740Well, the government is doing some of that.
00:24:39.260There's an LNG plant that's happening.
00:25:55.260And that means doing what I was sent here to do by the record 8.3 million people who voted for us, which is to fight for an affordable life, fight for our young people to be able to afford homes, fight for parents to be able to have safe streets for their kids to grow up on.
00:27:11.940I want to play another segment from that interview.
00:27:13.920I think this is a very spirited defense of the use of the notwithstanding clause.
00:27:18.920In this case, to overturn what the Supreme Court has recently said about possession of child pornography.
00:27:26.440They said they've struck down the mandatory minimum one year sentence.
00:27:32.800Now, pure poly of it always takes courage to say that notwithstanding clause should be used because according to the liberal media, it's in the Constitution.
00:27:43.540It's Section 33 of the Constitution, but don't ever use it.
00:32:37.180I will criticize whomever I think needs to be criticized.
00:32:42.160But right now, Katie needs to do a little bit more than walking around the farm talking about how things have gone for the past few weeks.
00:32:51.040She needs to fight harder in terms of saying the farm has issued a notice to the RCMP that the Canadian Food Inspection Agency has been illegally occupying their farm since September 24th.
00:33:06.040And they need to get the hell off of their farm.
00:33:58.080Now, what's going to happen on Thursday morning?
00:34:02.080Supreme Court could say we're not hearing the appeal.
00:34:05.680We'll get to what that means in a second or a minute.
00:34:11.120The Supreme Court said we are going to hear the appeal.
00:34:13.840That will give the farm untold months to continue to build goodwill, to move public opinion, if, in fact, it needs to be moved much further,
00:34:25.360but to continue to get the word out about how their research has been fantastic, how these birds are healthy, have no reason to call them,
00:34:36.020how the CFIA has time and time again refused to test them, it refuses to count them,
00:34:41.940how this farm has provided research that is not just valuable for ostriches and birds, but for humankind.
00:34:50.000This farm has done invaluable research.
00:40:25.620I embrace what has been going on here to stop the government's dissolution of private property rights, which I know aren't in the Constitution.
00:41:42.940And that's why I don't pretend to be objective about this story.
00:41:46.460I think it is another example of Canada's freedom being taken away by a ravenous government that doesn't give a damn about your rights or mine.