Greg Lavoie is the author of Callings: Finding and Following an Authentic Life, a book about finding your calling. In this episode, we discuss what exactly a calling is and why it's not necessarily the same thing as a vocation. Greg then shares how callings come to people, why they're sometimes unpleasant and challenging, and what you can do to attune yourself to their signals.
00:25:09.080It's something outside of the box for us.
00:25:11.220It's something that's maybe a little more feeling oriented than brain oriented.
00:25:15.740But, you know, in the research I did for the Callings book, every religion on earth agrees that the dreams, and I'm talking about night dreams, because day dreams are ambitions.
00:25:55.300And dreams, if we're willing to work with them, they have a lot of information and a lot of consequences if we ignore that information, because they'll just keep coming back.
00:26:03.880Like, everybody's had experiences of having recurring dreams or certainly recurring themes in their dreams.
00:26:10.020And, I mean, I understand the thing about woo-woo.
00:26:13.260I mean, my God, I live in Santa Cruz, California, and I'm a New Yorker, you know, and this is the land of woo-woo.
00:26:20.700But woo-woo just means the things you can't necessarily explain with logic or science or reasoning.
00:26:29.700And I think to really honor callings, you've got to expand your, you know, your toolkit.
00:26:36.720Am I using all the right manly metaphors here?
00:26:41.160But you have to expand the toolkit and be willing to look at dreams because they're just the information that you're not conscious of during the day.
00:26:50.240And they have a lot of – here, here's an example.
00:26:52.520I was given an opportunity at one point to turn the callings book into a reality-based television show.
00:26:58.580I was flown out to Los Angeles, wined and dined by a couple of execs and an attorney from HBO who were interested in this project.
00:27:08.500And, I mean, they even took me clothes shopping, which I thought was presumptuous at the least.
00:27:15.700But the night before I was supposed to sign on the dotted line, I had a dream about those three people that were taking me around and interested in the project.
00:27:25.480And I dreamed that all three of them were wearing costume jewelry and patent leather shoes.
00:27:32.980And I turned that project down because what it said to me is, I don't trust them.
00:27:39.080Fake leather shoes, patent, you know, costume jewelry.
00:27:42.420And this decision made my more hot-blooded entrepreneurial friends go nuts.
00:28:03.620And I turned the project down and I've never regretted it since.
00:28:06.920So, some people may call dreams woo-woo, but that was real data to me and helped me make an important career decision.
00:28:16.060So, let's talk about different ways in detail about how you can invoke callings in your life.
00:28:20.140One you talk about is rite of passages.
00:28:21.740What is it about a rite of passage that can help people uncover their callings in life?
00:28:26.300Yeah, well, one of the rites of passages that I've done over the years is a vision quest.
00:28:34.060A lot of people have heard of vision quests.
00:28:36.660And this is essentially a rite of passage that pretty much every culture at some point in history has come up with to send one of their individuals out of the village into the wilderness to cry for a vision.
00:28:50.000That's actually a phrase that they use in this rite of passage, crying for a vision, and then bringing that vision back to the tribe.
00:28:58.620So, I've gone on a couple of these, including a 12-day vision quest in Death Valley.
00:29:03.120And this is a brilliant and brilliantly designed rite of passage.
00:29:09.680And it was facilitated by an outfit somewhere here in California called the School of Lost Borders, which I just love.
00:29:18.540And they designed it so that the first four days is you're explaining to the small group of people you're with, maybe a dozen people, why you're there.
00:29:28.600Why have you chosen to step outside your life and try to look back in through the shop window from a distance?
00:29:35.560And it's really important to get off-site for some of these rites of passages.
00:29:42.380Get away from the roles and responsibilities that define who you are and get out there into the wilderness.
00:29:48.220And the second four days is a solo fast.
00:29:51.300You pick a spot somewhere out in the desert and you cry for a vision.
00:29:55.740And the last four days is a return where you sit around the fire again with those 12 people and explain what happened to you out there and what it means.
00:30:07.660So, this rite of passage is great for reorienting people.
00:30:11.700And you know what was interesting to me was the reactions my friends had to hearing that I was going to be taking this vision quest.
00:30:18.660Just about every one of them wanted to book lunch with me the minute I got back and hear about it.
00:30:26.260And that was really significant to me because what I sensed was that a lot of people are feeling like there's something they need to do with their lives that they're not doing.
00:30:38.340They're not letting themselves or getting themselves to do.
00:31:04.860And so, I think that there's something that speaks to people about these kind of rites of passage is as a way to find what your calling is, what your vision is, what your work in the world is supposed to be,
00:31:16.460what your gifts are, what your contributions are.
00:31:20.000And this is stuff that it seems to me everybody wants to know.
00:32:08.600He was active in political life in New York.
00:32:10.700He decides after that, he just quit political life and he started a ranch out in the Dakotas, in the Badlands.
00:32:17.860And just he wanted to get away from things.
00:32:19.660And then after that, that ranch failed.
00:32:21.860But something about that experience out there in nature, away from New York, that energized him for his next phase of his political life where he eventually became president of the United States.
00:33:26.080And a friend of mine said I was detoxing from a lifetime of just being immersed in the prevailing zeitgeist.
00:33:34.660But what began to come to me when I got that quiet out of the desert was the Callings book.
00:33:44.040And I don't know that that would have come to me if I'd stayed in the cities.
00:33:48.180I don't know that I was listening at a deep enough level that I could have heard that book.
00:33:53.320And now I really understand why there's a whole spiritual tradition about moving to the desert, living in the desert, the whole desert father's tradition.
00:34:26.100And sometimes you will do something like this.
00:34:29.180You'll take yourself really out of the box and give yourself one of those.
00:34:33.280And now for something completely different kind of experiences.
00:34:36.600And sometimes that's exactly what you need and you know you need it.
00:34:39.780And that's one of the reasons I recommend things like vision quests or a pilgrimage or a retreat or something that just takes you out of status quo and lets you listen down deep.
00:34:53.880Well, yeah, traveling or going on a journey is another common way people, you know, find their calling.
00:34:58.860Like, I'm going to go on this big trip so I can find myself.
00:35:02.060But, you know, the criticism that people invoke or throw at that is, well, you're not really finding yourself.
00:35:07.020You're just trying to run away from the problems you have here instead of facing them.
00:35:11.900So how can you ensure, right, that you're doing these things like with vision quest or, you know, pilgrimage or going on a trip?
00:35:18.280How can you ensure that you're actually doing that to, like, find that calling instead of just running away from your problems?
00:35:26.700Yeah, it's one of the accusations that's leveled against the restless.
00:35:35.520It's like, are you running towards something or away from something?
00:35:38.200And, you know, I guess every guy's got to discern that for himself, whether whatever I'm engaged in at the moment, is it moving towards something or just distracting myself?
00:35:51.560A word, by the way, that means to be pulled apart.
00:35:54.300And life, of course, is full of distractions.
00:35:56.560So, I mean, it's the same with the calling, too, is how do you know when the material that you need to know hasn't made its way to you yet and you need to continue doing more research and more listening and more self-reflection and more attunement or whether you're just plain old procrastinating?
00:36:14.560And that's something that, you know, takes some time to just tease apart.
00:36:44.440I'm used to having this dilemma where when am I done doing research on a piece and I just need to sit my butt down and write the thing?
00:36:52.980And when have I not completed all the research?
00:36:55.660And I've noticed that sometimes doing research is a way of avoiding sitting down and writing, which is way harder than researching in most cases.
00:37:04.620And especially if you're doing anything like first-person writing as opposed to third-person writing, which really is the difference between confessing and preaching.
00:37:14.020It's scary to sit down and actually write.
00:37:17.380Or for that matter, to do your real work in the world, to follow your real callings.
00:37:22.340So this is a great question is to ask, you know.
00:37:27.180But, you know, I think restlessness has a bad rap.
00:37:30.440One of the people that I interviewed for the book said, interesting word, rest less.
00:37:36.340So if you're experiencing restlessness, what wants to move and where does it want to go, which I love as a reframe of restlessness because we just think of it as escapism.
00:37:47.540And it's – in fact, I interviewed a guy years ago when I worked at the Cincinnati Inquirer as a reporter.
00:37:54.180He was a professor at Ohio Wesley named Bernard Merchland, and he came up with the Ten Commandments of Creativity.
00:38:05.140In other words, never quite being satisfied with the status quo as it is, always wanting to improve and tinker and explore and get into novelty.
00:38:18.000So I just think it's important to sometimes take the pejorative off the word restlessness and ask yourself, what wants to move and where does it want to go?
00:38:26.580Well, speaking of this issue of trying to figure out whether that thing you're doing, whether that trip you're doing is going to something or away from something, a related question that comes up with callings is, is this actually a true calling?
00:38:39.320Or am I just doing something and deluding myself and calling it a calling because it makes me feel better to call it that even though it might not be?
00:38:46.100So, I mean, how do you, how do you figure that out?
00:38:49.460Yeah, that's the, I guess that's what spiritual communities call discernment.
00:38:55.040And yeah, that can be sticky, tricky stuff and sometimes requires patience on the order of years for people to really clarify.
00:39:04.560But, you know, I ask, I ask everybody this question, like I said, is like, how did you know that this was right for you?
00:39:14.920And the responses that people have given me over the years are so incredibly consistent that I'll literally list them because it's that easy.
00:39:24.560People said they know, they knew a call was true because it kept coming back.
00:39:30.780That was one, it just year after year, it just kept coming back.
00:39:36.060They knew that it was true when it came at them from a lot of different directions, not just an idea they got one day or a occupation they picked out of an occupational handbook or something.
00:39:48.560It was coming through their dreams or their little synchronicities that happen or the things that they fantasize about while they're at work.
00:39:59.220I mean, just there's a clustering effect and you have to connect dots.
00:40:02.260People said they knew a call was true because it scared them.
00:40:24.400People said they knew a call was true because their enthusiasm for it sustained itself over a good period of time.
00:40:31.960Didn't just flag after a month or something or a semester in the case of college kids.
00:40:39.100And they found that they even had a certain, what's the word, affinity for all the mundane stuff that's involved in pulling a calling off in the world.
00:40:50.520And they all have it, no matter how exalted or glamorous or exciting a calling feels.
00:40:57.560Every one of them has got its version of licking stamps and stuffing envelopes.
00:41:01.960But people said, like, if you've ever been in a band or performed in a play or something, you know this, that the amount of time you spend rehearsing compared to performing is like 90-10 or 80-20 or something.
00:41:16.480And the fact that people are willing to practice the same lines or the same lyrics or the same chords for, you know, thousands of hours for the chance to take it public a tenth of the time, it says, I think it's largely passion that explains people's willingness to put up with that equation.
00:41:34.840That, to me, your willingness to abide by all of the practice is a diagnostic that you're on the right path.
00:41:46.200So that's another piece in the discernment puzzle.
00:41:50.360The only way I figured this out was I had to try it out.
00:41:53.320I had to go down the path a certain way, even when I wasn't sure it was the path, and take field notes, you know.
00:42:03.280So this ultimately is what it comes down to for discernment.
00:42:07.240Take a step toward something that feels like it's calling to you, whether it's in the vocational arena or the relationship arena or the creative arena, and look at the feedback your life immediately gives you.
00:42:18.460So, you feel better or worse, you feel more awake or more asleep.
00:43:49.960And we'll try to pop through the big ones, especially, until the last possible minute of life.
00:43:55.360Well, something you also point out in the book is that sometimes refusing a call might be a necessary step for you to actually accept the call.
00:44:02.360Yeah, yeah, I'm glad you mentioned that.
00:44:07.500Because part of the beauty of callings is they are negotiable.
00:44:13.480You know, this is not like a divine subpoena.
00:44:15.900They're negotiable, and you have a vote.
00:44:20.160So, I mean, I'm thinking of a guy that I interviewed who was a corporate executive, and his real passion was abstract painting.
00:44:29.700And so, what he did to negotiate that call is he wanted a family, he wanted a house, he wanted money.
00:44:37.980And so, he stuck with the job for 25 years, but he also painted on the side that entire time.
00:44:44.060So, ultimately, this is the point of callings.
00:44:46.380Get it in your life to some degree sooner than later, to some degree.
00:44:53.040He did his painting on the side for 25 years, and when he finally, he had the kids, and he had the house, and when he was ready to shift his life, the painting was up and running.
00:45:04.360He had contacts with gallery owners, he had a body of work, he had confidence in that calling.
00:45:10.600And so, he was able to make this shift, you know, and 25 years is a long time to wait to do something you'd rather be doing full-time.
00:45:19.520But he got to do, you know, he had several callings, and that's what people often have to negotiate, too, is there's a call to have a family, and there's a call to be an abstract painter.
00:45:31.020They don't necessarily go well together.
00:45:32.700But he was able to do both, and so I think there's a way to work that out so that you get the bliss in your life to some degree and say yes to it to some degree.
00:45:46.020Callings are not necessarily asking you to flip the whole circuit, you know, to turn the whole thing upside down and quit your job and whatnot.
00:46:35.160You're often tired at the end of the day.
00:46:36.780And the idea of going down into the painting studio or into the, you know, out to the work shed or whatever, it can be challenging when it's just easier to flip on the TV or any of the multitudes of social media and all that.
00:46:52.320But the fact is, you don't have to quit your job.
00:47:05.680And give it some opportunity to express itself.
00:47:09.160You know, if you've ever been in a grocery store and been standing on a checkout line and seen a parent with a little kid who's tugging on their pants.
00:47:30.300They want some way to express themselves.
00:47:33.140And they're not going to stop tugging on our pants until we do.
00:47:35.820So what role does community or other people play in our callings?
00:47:40.120We often think of calling as a very personal, internal thing, but your decisions affect other people and other people are going to say things about your decision.
00:47:51.120That's, uh, callings are community property.
00:47:54.800I mean, you, you are the one who's called, but you're not the only one who's going to be affected by what kind of a choice you make around that, especially if you're a, have a family or run a company or are in a men's group.
00:48:10.960I mean, it's going to affect all those communities.
00:48:13.600So in fact, I had a young woman come up to me at a university some years ago and say, she loved the presentation, but it's culturally biased.
00:48:22.880She said, because you come from an individualistic culture.
00:48:45.340You alone are called, but that doesn't mean you've got to figure it out all by yourself.
00:48:50.120And I'm, I'm always encouraging people to draw on their community to help them clarify what they're, what they should do.
00:48:57.180And so I'm talking about anything from having a personal board of advisors, which is really, it sounds more exalted than it, than I mean it to.
00:49:06.720That's just a bunch of people you pull together from your circle of acquaintances to meet once a month.
00:49:11.880They come to your house on Tuesday evening, you cook them a meal, and then you sit around for two hours and they ask you questions and they give you feedback and they give you homework.
00:49:27.140And I've been on both sides of this board of advisors things.
00:49:31.080It's, it's another one is the, the Quaker tradition.
00:49:33.820It's called a clearness committee, which you can just Google.
00:49:36.980And this is again, a bunch of people you pull together to help you clarify a call is literally what they were designed for a hundred years ago by the Quakers.
00:49:46.300And so you're sitting around, you're the focal person, there's 10 people sitting around you and there's exactly one rule, questions only, no advice giving, no fixing problem solving or any of that, only asking questions, which is murder, you know, and people often try to couch advice as a question by saying things like, don't you think, you know, technically, yes, that's a question, but it's a leading question.
00:50:12.440So there's another example, a brainstorming session is another example.
00:50:15.900So ways of pulling community together to help you clarify what the call is and how to respond to it is.
00:50:23.980I just think don't isolate is my point.
00:51:05.620Cause it's easy to jump to conclusions and assume that because you quote, and I'm going to put that baby in big quotes, failed at what you perceive as a calling.
00:51:21.740It may need you, you need to farm some things out that you're not farming out.
00:51:26.020It may need, mean you need more education.
00:51:28.900It could be a lot of things, or it could be that this isn't the way to make it happen.
00:51:35.140It could be, it could be a lot of things, but assuming that it's a quote failure isn't necessarily the case, even though of course it feels like a failure.
00:51:43.020And, you know, I remember sitting right before I was going to quit my job to be self-employed, I sat with one of my mentors over lunch and I told him I was terrified of failing at it.
00:51:58.820He said, Hey, you know, if you're not failing regularly, you're living so far below your potential that you're failing anyway.
00:52:08.980Which explained why I had lunch with this guy maybe once a year.
00:52:11.640I mean, there's mentors and then there's tormentors, which is a good thing actually to cultivate.
00:52:17.880But, you know, this, this fear around failure, my dad, again, scientist, he used to say, you'd be better off in life if you quit focusing on failure or success.
00:54:32.500I'm reflecting now that you've mentioned that on several people and people who have been mentors to me who said that I need to hook up whatever I do in my life with a much deeper frame of reference.
00:54:45.520It's a purpose that there's no way I'm going to live long enough to see.
00:54:49.920You know, it would be like something like peace on earth or a cure for cancer or, for that matter, even just building the Chartres Cathedral, which took a couple of hundred years.
00:55:00.560And most of those people never lived long enough to see it.
00:55:02.720But there's something about hooking yourself up to a deeper purpose that is an important part of motivation, is an important part of legacy.
00:55:14.540And so, I think there's a lot to be said for this idea of yours that your calls are hooked up to much, much larger callings, larger voices that want to speak through you.
00:55:24.560And I think that's a very useful way to approach it.
00:55:27.360It doesn't feel like it's just personal to you, but you're hooking up to something bigger.
00:55:33.520Well, so, Greg, what's one thing you think someone can do who's listening to this show and they's like, I want to tap in to this idea of a calling.
00:55:39.340What can they do after they get done listening to the show to start tapping into that?
00:55:43.480Well, where I immediately go is find some kind of self-reflective practice that works for you.
00:55:49.640So, whatever that happens to be, that's just some way that you're going to have a regular conversation, ongoing conversation with yourself.
00:55:59.500I mean, you can do it every morning like I sit down and I do free writing.
00:56:03.960That just means stream of consciousness writing.
00:56:06.200That's one of my primary self-reflective practices.
00:56:08.800Or you could do dream work or you could join a men's group or something that begins a self-reflective practice in your life.
00:56:17.000That would be my go-to recommendation right off the top because it's something people can do and do regularly and find some version of it that works for them.
00:56:26.900Well, Greg, this has been a great conversation.
00:56:28.280Where can people go to learn more about the book and your work?
00:56:30.560Oh, well, World Headquarters for me is greglavoy.com.
00:56:51.660Also, check out our show notes at aom.is slash callings where you can find links to resources where you can delve deeper into this topic.
00:56:57.100Well, that wraps up another edition of the A1 Podcast.
00:57:06.940Check out our website at artofmanliness.com where you can find our podcast archives as well as thousands of articles we've written over the years about personal finance, how to be a better husband, better father.
00:57:15.020We even have a series of articles about vocation and calling, so check that out while you're there.
00:57:18.680While you're there, make sure to sign up for our newsletter so you can get our updates.
00:57:21.720Never miss a new article when it comes out.
00:57:23.580And if you'd like to enjoy ad-free episodes of the A1 Podcast, you can do so on Stitcher Premium.
00:57:27.840Head over to stitcherpremium.com, sign up, use code manliness to get a free month trial.
00:57:31.960Once you're signed up, download the Stitcher app on Android or iOS, and you can start enjoying ad-free episodes of the A1 Podcast.
00:57:37.740If you haven't done so already, I'd appreciate it if you take one minute to give us a review on iTunes or Stitcher.
00:57:41.760It helps out a lot, and if you've done that already, thank you.
00:57:44.080Please consider sharing the show with a friend or family member who you think would get something out of it.
00:57:48.080As always, thank you for the continued support.
00:57:49.780Until next time, this is Brett McKay, reminding you not only to listen to the A1 Podcast, but put what you've heard into action.