The Art of Manliness - #635： The Existentialist's Survival Guide

00:00:00.000 Brett McKay here and welcome to another edition of the Art of Manliness podcast.

00:00:11.140 Life isn't an easy road to navigate. We're moody creatures susceptible to a ray of psychological

00:00:16.220 setbacks, emotional ups and downs, fruitless searches for meaning, and trials posed by anxiety,

00:00:21.720 depression, and despair. The kind of journey one needs a survival guide for, and my guest today

00:00:26.120 says, one of the best can be found in the writings of existential philosophers. His name is Gordon

00:00:30.400 Marino. He's a football and boxing coach, a professor of philosophy, and the author of

00:00:34.240 Existentialist Survival Guide, How to Live Authentically in an Inauthentic Age. Gordon and I

00:00:38.560 begin our conversation with how he personally found existentialism and how his coaching intersects

00:00:42.840 with his teaching. We then get into what existential philosophy is all about and the thinkers and

00:00:46.600 authors who are considered to be existentialists. Gordon shares what he thinks is the greatest

00:00:50.200 existential novel and which of Soren Kierkegaard's books he most recommends reading. From there,

00:00:54.200 we delve into what Kierkegaard had to say about anxiety, how he thought existential angst was the

00:00:58.280 ultimate teacher, the distinction he drew between depression and despair, and why he argues that

00:01:02.340 procrastination is one of our greatest moral dangers. We then unpack the different models of living an

00:01:07.080 authentic life that the existentialist espoused and what Nietzsche meant with his injunction to live

00:01:11.480 dangerously. We then get into what the existentialist's take on love is, why love is actually hard to

00:01:16.040 accept, and why you should presuppose love in others. And we end our conversation with what

00:01:20.100 boxing can teach about existential philosophy. After the show's over, make sure to check out our show notes.

00:01:24.200 AOM.IS slash existential.

00:01:34.680 All right. All right. Gordon Marino, welcome to the show.

00:01:37.020 Thanks so much for having me. Been looking forward to it.

00:01:39.680 Yeah. So you are a professor of philosophy at St. Olaf College. You're the author of the book,

00:01:43.360 The Existentialist Survival Guide, How to Live Authentically in an Inauthentic Age. 0.57

00:01:48.320 Let's talk about your backstory of how you became a professor of existential philosophy.

00:01:52.200 How did you discover existential philosophy? And just tell us about that. I think it's really

00:01:57.200 interesting. Well, I was a football player at Bowling Green State University, and I had this

00:02:01.500 wonderful, wonderful professor in a philosophy class. And he told me, well, you know about elite

00:02:07.720 athletics and stuff like that. Well, you need to get some elite training in the mind. And so I

00:02:11.380 transferred to Columbia University. And his name was Serge Kappa, a huge influence.

00:02:16.340 So I studied philosophy there. And it was later on, I got into a, well, it was during a time when I

00:02:23.120 went through a terrible divorce. It was a young man, a very hard time. And I was in a coffee shop

00:02:29.540 and picked up this book of Kiergaard's. And it was like a light. It's just a beautiful, amazing page

00:02:34.080 because one of the things I was having such a hard time. And one of the things I found was that

00:02:38.260 Kiergaard and other existentialists really addressed the impediments in our lives,

00:02:42.560 our inner lives and the difficulties we face and being decent people. I mean, it's really,

00:02:47.020 it's easy to be a good person when everything's going well, but quite different when you hit the,

00:02:53.820 when the, when the lights turn red. Right. It's, it's easy in theory, but when you actually have to

00:02:58.000 do it, it gets a lot harder. And you're also a boxing coach at St. Olof.

00:03:02.800 Well, I'm at St. Olof. I'm a professional boxing coach and a trainer and a, and a USA boxing

00:03:08.820 coach. So I've trained both amateurs and pros and, uh, over 30 years, mostly kids in town.

00:03:14.340 Although I've had a couple of boxes from St. Olof.

00:03:16.860 And then how's that influenced your thinking about philosophy boxing?

00:03:20.700 Well, the teaching and coaching really influence one another really go together in an important way

00:03:25.540 that, uh, being a coach helps me be a better teacher, helps me read kids more accurately,

00:03:31.460 know who to push, when to push that kind of thing. And, and it's really, uh, I coach also coach

00:03:37.180 football here and I found that you really get the landscape of, when you have a, when you have

00:03:41.660 somebody in class and in their, and in the gym and, or the football field, you really get to see

00:03:47.000 the landscape of their mind in a way that you wouldn't have otherwise. And it's, uh, really

00:03:50.700 more remarkable because, uh, some kids, if I, if I hadn't had them on the football field, I wouldn't

00:03:55.460 have, they wouldn't have opened up and I wouldn't have known how rich their thinking was. So it's been,

00:03:59.560 it's been marvelous like that. Now, of course I get a lot of questions of, uh, how can you train

00:04:04.180 these people's brains and at the same time, get them bashed in and stuff like that. So I get a lot

00:04:08.140 of, get a lot of jabs about that over the years, less so now, but in the beginning.

00:04:11.620 Yeah. Well, what do you, I mean, how do you, what do you respond to that?

00:04:14.540 I'm very, uh, I'm just, I'm very careful with, with my, with my boxers and, uh, I've never had

00:04:21.220 anybody get hurt or close to it. So I don't think people understand that if you did it's a well

00:04:25.780 supervised boxing, it'd be quite safe.

00:04:27.760 Right. And I mean, we've had Mark Edmondson on the podcast.

00:04:30.660 Oh yeah.

00:04:31.000 Professor. Yeah.

00:04:31.540 At Virginia.

00:04:31.980 Yeah. And yeah, he wrote that book, why football matters. And I thought, I mean, he, he answers

00:04:37.260 that too, that sort of question, like, how can you, you know, be in favor of a sport that where

00:04:41.760 people get, you know, traumatic brain injury or whatever. And you know, it's, it's a tough

00:04:46.720 one, but he, he still thinks there's value in the sport because it can teach you something

00:04:50.620 about life that you can't otherwise learn in the classroom.

00:04:54.360 Right. And there's also a risk in living a risk averse life. That's something you learn

00:04:58.020 from Kierkegaard. It was very important. One of his main ideas is that

00:05:01.860 to not to venture, not to risk is to take one of the greatest risks in life.

00:05:07.140 Right. Well, that's a good transition, you know, sport as a way to transition to existential

00:05:13.280 philosophy. But let's start with this. Like, what is existentialism for those who aren't

00:05:17.700 familiar with it? You know, what philosophical questions are they, the existential philosophers

00:05:22.100 primarily concerned with?

00:05:23.740 Well, there's a, there are, there are a real motley crew and they're joined more by themes

00:05:27.160 than by any kind of general theory. So the themes are very much things like the individual,

00:05:33.320 there's a limits of rationality, limits of the idea of clarity, being concrete in your thinking,

00:05:39.380 right? I'm relating your thought to your existence, not, not being too abstract. Again,

00:05:43.840 dealing with addressing painful emotions like despair, depression, anxiety, issue of freedom,

00:05:51.300 choice. Those are some of the themes that like, and every, everybody has a different roster.

00:05:54.980 Who's on the, who's on the roster. Some people have Shakespeare on there, you know? So it's a

00:05:59.480 quite a, quite a, quite a array of lack of agreement about who's really an existentialist. And actually

00:06:05.740 only, only Camus and maybe Marcel and Simone de Beauvoir ever really identified themselves. I'm sorry,

00:06:10.940 Sartre, not, not Camus. Camus denied he was an existentialist, but there's only two or three

00:06:15.740 people that ever identified themselves as such and only for a short time. But I identify myself

00:06:20.440 as an existentialist.

00:06:21.400 Right. Well, you said there's a motley crew. I mean, not only are there philosophers, but there's

00:06:25.240 also that you lump in people lump in novelists in there as well. So yeah, let's talk about,

00:06:29.840 yeah, let's like, who are some of the big names that people get usually thrown around as existentialists?

00:06:33.940 Oh, okay. So, so certainly Kierkegaard, Sartre, Nietzsche, Camus. Those are, those are some of

00:06:41.100 the main ones. Simone de Beauvoir. Okay. In terms of novelists, Tolstoy, Dostoevsky,

00:06:48.120 Miguel de Anamuno. Those are some of the people that read. In fact, everybody should read Tolstoy's

00:06:52.400 The Death of Ivan Ola, which is the greatest existential novel ever. Unbelievable. Amazing book.

00:06:58.440 I've, I've also heard like, you know, Thoreau and Emerson thrown in there as well,

00:07:02.180 every now and then. Yeah, there's connections, I think, there. Yeah. I mean, Nietzsche carried

00:07:06.920 around, it was, there's a book that argues that, that European philosophy was very much influenced

00:07:12.960 by American philosophy in the sense that Nietzsche always carried around a copy of Emerson,

00:07:18.600 you know? And so, yeah, there's some overlapping themes. I mean, how, how does existentialist,

00:07:23.840 because it kind of started coming to, I mean, the first existential philosopher was Kierkegaard.

00:07:28.200 That's sort of how people point to him. That's how many people, right. But like, how does,

00:07:31.980 how does existentialism differ from philosophy before existentialism? Like, what's the big

00:07:36.240 difference? Okay. One of the big differences is that this understanding of the lack of limits of

00:07:41.380 reason, right? So for Kierkegaard to become mature is to understand that there's a lot of things beyond

00:07:48.200 our understanding that are important to life. So another thing is just idea of making your ideals

00:07:55.160 concrete. So he thinks a lot of people, there's a lot of talk about, say, social justice or whatever,

00:08:00.100 then you have to ask yourself, well, what really have I done to advance that at all? Have I done

00:08:04.460 anything? Have I, have I walked the talk to use a cliche, you know? And so there's a lot of emphasis

00:08:09.620 on that, on action that you don't find in other philosophies. And I mean, also it seems like

00:08:14.900 existentialism is somewhat, it's psychological too. Yeah. Like, as you said, I think Kierkegaard said,

00:08:21.080 like the idea of the self, like what is the self? And it's like, the self is the self relating to

00:08:26.320 itself or something like that. Yeah, definitely. That's something like that. That's from the opening

00:08:31.840 page of the sickness on a death, which I think is his greatest book. So if you're, if your listeners

00:08:36.980 are interested in one book of Kierkegaard's, I would certainly recommend the sickness on a death.

00:08:41.520 And in that book, I really found this distinction in him between despair and depression between a

00:08:47.180 spiritual disorder and a psychological disorder. But for Kierkegaard, we're born with a self that we

00:08:52.880 need to become. For him, it's that we're born a child of God, that we need to be loving,

00:08:57.620 nurturing human beings, faithful. And with my students, a lot of time, I really press them to

00:09:03.180 think not just about what they want to do, which they're kind of obsessed with, but what kind of

00:09:06.660 human being do you want to be? What kind of, what kind of person do you want to be? And there's a lot

00:09:11.620 of that emphasis in Kierkegaard. Well, let's talk about some of the questions you tackle in the

00:09:16.820 existential survival guide that you think existentialism, and these are big life questions that you

00:09:21.580 think existentialists have some, not maybe not answers, but like, you know, questions to help

00:09:25.400 you start thinking about this stuff. And the one question that existentialists grapple with is

00:09:31.500 anxiety. Because I think everyone here who's listening to the podcast probably heard this,

00:09:34.600 or used the phrase, you know, existential angst. And the existential philosopher who really explored

00:09:39.940 this idea the most of existential anxiety was Kierkegaard. So let's talk about what is existential

00:09:45.940 angst and how does that differ from anxiety about, you know, a test that you're taking in college?

00:09:52.080 Right, right. Well, existential angst, the way it's used today, it means it's a kind of a threat to

00:09:56.660 our existence, right? That's the notion. But one of the things with Kierkegaard was that he insisted

00:10:02.840 that the fact that we're anxious, anxiety is in a sense, our kind of visceral understanding of the

00:10:08.260 fact that we're free. It's a blessing to be anxious, right? And it's not a symptom of an illness.

00:10:14.540 It's something that marks us out of spirits itself, because we're free. It's an anxiety that you

00:10:20.080 understand that you're free. And he thinks anxiety is one of the greatest, greatest teachers. It's

00:10:25.880 contrary to what a lot of people in the medical profession would say that we need to be able to sit

00:10:30.580 with anxiety. And today we have so, so little patience for that. It's just a symptom, get rid of

00:10:35.920 it, this kind of thing. And so it's quite a different view between Kierkegaard and the medical

00:10:39.960 establishment on that issue.

00:10:41.420 Yeah. Didn't he say something that also like the human beings are unique in the, in the world

00:10:46.340 that we're, we're the combination of the infinite and the finite.

00:10:50.160 That's right. Yeah. You got it. You got it. You're going to get an A in the course. Yeah,

00:10:53.860 definitely. Yeah. Yeah. That we're, we had these, um, he thought this is what you look at,

00:10:58.720 you're referring again to sickness on a death and theory says we have these different aspects of

00:11:04.040 ourselves, finitude, infinitude, temporality, eternity, possibility, and necessity. These are

00:11:09.860 contradictory kind of aspects of our, of our lives. And as a human being, we need to, we have to be

00:11:14.700 able to relate those things to one another, to be able to get some balance, to integrate them.

00:11:19.340 Right. And so, I mean, that's hard to integrate the infinite with the finite and that it's,

00:11:22.860 it's something you like, I don't, is it, I would, did Kierkegaard think it'd ever be resolved?

00:11:27.220 No. One of the things, one of Kierkegaard's main messages is that life is an ongoing process. So

00:11:33.540 you can never, so for people who say, well, I've been saved, it's all over. He'd say,

00:11:36.540 that's balon, that's bull, you know, that it's always, life is always a struggle. You always have

00:11:41.600 to, to battle against certain temptations or whatever. Right. There's no, there's no end to

00:11:46.520 it. Right. Right. So it's, it's a process. He's very adamant about that. And then at any moment you

00:11:53.100 could lose it. I mean, so he talks about, there's this one story in the book that you've looked at,

00:11:57.240 a sickness on a death about a monk from India who's lived on do his whole life. He comes into the city,

00:12:02.620 has one drink and becomes a, becomes an alcoholic. So that's what our, that's what our situation is.

00:12:07.920 We're that vulnerable. We're that fragile. We need to remember that.

00:12:11.600 And so, I mean, it sounds like for Kierkegaard, like anxiety can, can teach you. Yeah. I mean,

00:12:18.260 like it would, if you didn't feel anxiety, would Kierkegaard say something's wrong with you?

00:12:23.640 Oh yeah. I'd say you were spiritless. He literally says that in, in the concept of anxiety,

00:12:27.980 right. That to, that it's, it's a mark that we're spirits. Right. And that we want to do it. And

00:12:34.580 the anxiety is really about this, our spiritual potential. And he would say that what many of us

00:12:39.620 do is concretize our anxiety, kind of finitize it in terms of, I'm afraid I won't get this job,

00:12:45.860 or I'm afraid of doing this interview or doing this or doing that. Right. We, we try to turn our

00:12:50.660 anxiety into these finite fears to escape it. Right. That's, that's one of his views. It's kind of a

00:12:56.320 defense mechanism against the anxiety, but the anxiety is really about, we have the potential

00:13:00.140 to become human beings, full persons for him, which again, for him means being a person of faith.

00:13:06.340 But if faith, the idea of faith is offensive to you, it would mean, look, your main task in life

00:13:11.220 is not to sit on the beach, not to, not to accrue a, build your resume up, but to be a decent human

00:13:17.700 being. Yeah. And that idea of being spiritless, if you don't have anxiety, that reminds me of

00:13:23.600 Nietzsche as like the last man, right? Yeah. Oh yeah. That's a good connection.

00:13:27.480 Very good connection. Yeah. Yeah. It's funny because Nietzsche did read some Kierkegaard

00:13:32.740 late in the 1880s, apparently, and they disagree on a lot, but there's, they both agree that nihilism

00:13:39.920 is this, this, this sense that nothing matters is the greatest danger. And for the last man,

00:13:44.820 he just wants to, the last man is just concerned about when's my vacation, divides your life into

00:13:49.720 work time and play time and, you know, what's on Netflix tonight. And, uh, you know, so yeah,

00:13:55.200 that's a very good point. Yeah. The last man is like, I've heard it described as, I forgot the

00:13:59.460 name of the guy who's like the Nietzsche expert. He died, Solomon. Yeah. He described the last man

00:14:04.260 as the ultimate couch potato. That's right. That's a good description. He was very, Solomon was very

00:14:07.740 good. Yeah. Yeah. No, that's, that's, that's a really good description of the good couch potato.

00:14:11.860 Yeah. Just watches Netflix and just blinks. That's, that's all, that's all life is. Okay. So we,

00:14:17.040 we talked about anxiety and I guess Kierkegaard doesn't have much of a solution. Just kind of

00:14:20.720 sit with it, learn what the anxiety can teach you with you. That's right. It's not a, there's no

00:14:24.180 solution. Yeah. The solution would be to sit with it and not finitize it, not because he thinks it's

00:14:29.600 dangerous. He says it can lead to suicide. So in that sense, he recognized it can be very dangerous,

00:14:34.600 but yeah, to sit with it and not to translate it into what I'm really anxious about is whether or not,

00:14:41.180 you know, I get into med school or this or that. Right. And it's okay to be anxious about those

00:14:46.200 things, but that's not the, that shouldn't become your sense of identity. So can, can I make a little

00:14:53.340 turn here? Sure. Yeah. Yeah. So for him, I think there's, there's three, this is where we can get

00:14:59.580 into this distinction for him between despair and depression for him. It's basically three selves.

00:15:04.160 You have a concrete self, right? Right. The self you are. And then you have this ideal self. And then

00:15:10.320 there's the self you were born to be, this child of God. Right. So when this concrete self doesn't

00:15:15.820 become its ideal self, you might get all your anxiety, all your fears, or am I going to get,

00:15:20.880 get into med school or whatever. Right. He says, when the concrete self doesn't get to be its ideal

00:15:25.420 self, it can't stand, wants to get rid of itself. It can't stand being, being itself. Right. It's kind

00:15:31.620 of a, kind of a self, self hatred. And, um, and he also says that for the person who, who does become

00:15:38.420 successful, so that that's despair. Despair is wanting to be rid of yourself. Got it. Got it.

00:15:44.000 Okay. Right. And it sounds, this, this kind of despair sounds a lot like depression. Okay. But he

00:15:48.380 also says the person who realizes the dream is equally in danger because they become the big shot

00:15:54.780 or whatever. Right. And they don't think about, look, I'm real. This is a, whether or not I'm the head of

00:16:00.560 the rotary or all kinds of whatever stuff, you know, that, that, that's, that's not the aim in

00:16:04.440 life. It's, it's to become this, a certain kind of human being. He says, they're also in despair,

00:16:09.400 even though they don't feel bad. So for Kierkegaard, despair is not a feeling. It's a, um, state of the

00:16:14.700 self of being unaware of being a self and, or being unwilling to be a self. Whereas depression is this

00:16:21.320 kind of self hatred. And I think we've lost that distinction. Right. So yeah, with depression today,

00:16:26.900 like it's, we've medicalized it. Like every time you feel sad, like we'd be like, well, here,

00:16:32.760 even like grief, like here, take this, this antidepressant, you'll feel better. And Kierkegaard

00:16:37.420 would say, wouldn't say, maybe don't, maybe don't do that. That's not, not, maybe that's not healthy.

00:16:41.880 Yeah. Learn to, learn to sit with, and I don't think he'd be against all medications. I mean,

00:16:46.420 there's times when we were just, when they can really rob us of our sense of, you know, life can

00:16:51.220 rob us of our sense of agency at some point, but we've gotten to the point where we have a very

00:16:54.440 low threshold for dealing with anxiety and being able to sit with our feelings, sit with bad

00:16:59.240 feelings. And I think that that's, that's been, that's been lost. You know, I think we need to

00:17:04.140 really work at that, you know, in our society. Yeah. As you said, I mean, sometimes though,

00:17:08.660 when people are dying, doctors will prescribe serotonin uptake drugs or antidepressants to

00:17:13.780 the family, it is a kind of prophylactic against grief. Right. So we've taken human predicaments

00:17:19.600 that are, you know, that are going to hit us all and turn them into pathologies, illnesses.

00:17:24.840 Right. And I think Kierkegaard would take great issue with that.

00:17:27.580 And this idea, this distinction between depression and despair, like there's people,

00:17:31.460 Kierkegaard was a depressive, you know, you quote these lines where he like, he, you know,

00:17:34.840 he's at the party. Oh yeah. He was witty. And then when he came home, he wanted to kill himself.

00:17:39.440 Right. And he'd write that in his journal, but he said, it's normal to feel down like that. The,

00:17:44.060 the thing you got to be careful of, like you said, you can't let that depression fall into despair.

00:17:48.700 Okay. But despair here would not be like, it would be giving up on the project of, I mean,

00:17:56.120 suppose like you got some terrible disappointment and you said, ah, screw it, man. I don't care

00:18:01.140 anymore. And you give up on the project of being a good, faithful person. Right. That's when despair

00:18:07.560 comes in, not with the bad feelings. Right. It's when you give up on being a self, give up on being

00:18:13.800 a human being. Right. You know, so that's where I think the distinction between despair and

00:18:18.700 depression comes in. You can, I mean, he says, so he acknowledges depressive, but he doesn't think he

00:18:23.160 was in despair. And how do you, how do you know if you're in despair or not? Okay. That's a,

00:18:29.740 that's a complicated question for him because you have to have the right concepts. So he says a lot

00:18:34.220 of people in this world will, they'll experience a jolt, you know, something terrible will happen

00:18:38.320 and they'll, and they'll say they're in despair. Yeah, they're right. They're in despair, but they

00:18:42.460 have the wrong concept. So you know what I mean? So they're right that they're in despair, but it's

00:18:48.580 as though, uh, they don't understand what despair really is. The real despair is they've given up on

00:18:53.960 being a self. Right. Right. They just, they just, you know, that's not a big, that's not an issue for

00:19:01.020 them. So it'd be like, okay, let's, so the example of, I like the example of what to explore this idea

00:19:06.140 with the person who's doing well in life, who's happy, got a great job, great family,

00:19:09.980 but they're still in despair, Kierkegaard said, because maybe they've given up on being that,

00:19:14.240 that self, that true self. Yeah, everybody's patting them on the back. Right.

00:19:18.420 So they don't think of the, they don't really think who their true self is. They ask themselves,

00:19:22.860 have I, have I been a good, faithful person? Right. That's really, and if everybody,

00:19:27.060 if you're rich and powerful, everybody's, nobody, nobody gives you any crap. Right. Right. 0.98

00:19:30.580 You just pat you on the back and you're, you know, you're able to give money away without making

00:19:34.480 any sacrifices and it's very, very intoxicating. So, uh, again, you could do that and, uh, you

00:19:41.320 could be very successful and be very happy. He thought happy was happiness. It was really just

00:19:45.300 a matter of, you know, we make a God term out of it for Kierkegaard. It was just a, um, it was a lot,

00:19:49.820 had a lot to do with luck, fortune, you know, and it was a passing kind of thing and it shouldn't be

00:19:55.420 the aim of our life. Self-fulfillment, happiness. Right.

00:19:58.600 Our aim should be decent human beings.

00:20:01.520 And, but even these like happy, successful people, they'll, they might have those moments

00:20:06.360 where they recognize, like they're lying in bed at night and they realize this is empty. This is

00:20:10.700 not, uh, so like they recognize the despair, but Kierkegaard would say, well, you, you might have

00:20:15.440 the wrong concept of it because what they probably end up doing is they just keep doing more of the

00:20:18.560 same, right? Yeah. It's interesting that you just bring that up. That's a good point because he,

00:20:22.080 um, he recognizes that kind of a person where they have this glimmers of like, yeah, everyone thinks I'm

00:20:27.380 really great, but something's missing. And he says they, they generally go right back to sleep.

00:20:33.720 They just jump into it again and try to forget those moments. He says that that's the ordinary

00:20:37.860 tendency, but yeah, it's a good, that's a good example of some, some big CEO sitting in bed at

00:20:43.660 night and he's placed on the beach or whatever. And he's thinking, well, you know, I'm very successful,

00:20:49.760 but right. Right. And the next day he's back to work or she's back to work.

00:20:55.960 And then when Kierkegaard say that as soon as you recognize that disconnect between who you are and

00:21:00.220 who you should be, you got to act like you have to do something immediately or otherwise you'll just

00:21:04.340 start rationalizing like, well, I got a mortgage to pay. I've got to do this thing. I got to do that.

00:21:10.180 You know, it's, it's, that's an excellent question because a lot of people ask about Kierkegaard's

00:21:14.680 ethics. And I think his greatest contribution to ethics was this idea that of our capacity for

00:21:20.120 self-deception and we don't need more ethics classes or workshops, whatever we need to hold

00:21:25.540 on to truths that are going to lead us against our self-interest a lot of time. Right. I think I

00:21:30.800 bring it up in the book, this case where, you know, I was going to tax resist because of our

00:21:34.820 involvement in Nicaragua, the Contras. And a friend of mine told me that it was down, they were saying

00:21:39.220 they were killing all the midwives, the Contras. Right. And I was going, I'm going to tax resist. Right. 1.00

00:21:43.800 But at the same time I was up for a finalist for a Fulbright and someone says, well, you're

00:21:48.000 tax resistant. Guess what's going to happen with a Fulbright? And I said to myself, well,

00:21:52.460 yeah, I bet, I think I better wait until later on in life. I can make a more, a stronger

00:21:56.360 stand. So he thought procrastination was one of our greatest moral dangers as you, as you're

00:22:01.560 mentioning. Right. Yeah. That you, if you think about it too long, you're going to convince

00:22:05.800 yourself that the right way is the easy way. Right. And that's a very important insight.

00:22:11.440 You know, I think really important insight that you can convince yourself that the right

00:22:15.860 way is the easy way. When in fact, the right way is oftentimes going to lead you into a

00:22:20.200 collision with the world. The example you just gave of your own personal experience of

00:22:24.040 like, that reminded me, we talked about Mark Edmondson not too long ago, but he had that

00:22:27.780 great book, Self and Soul, where he just, it's, I think it's an existential book. He explores

00:22:32.640 this idea. There's these two cells inside of you that are competing. And sometimes, you know,

00:22:37.820 the soul part, which is sort of our higher conception, you know, that true self that

00:22:41.900 could guard say. Right. And there's oftentimes in life when those, like their self part, which

00:22:45.900 is like, you know, our need for recognition, our need for money, whatever. Yeah. That

00:22:50.520 conflicts and you have to, you have to decide, you know, what is it you really want?

00:22:55.560 That's right. That, well, yeah. Well, it's not, not so much what you really want, it's what

00:23:00.760 you should do, right? What you should do. What's the right thing to do? Yeah. That's, that's

00:23:05.800 true. And a lot of times, I mean, I think, I think in the course of history, I've always

00:23:10.240 mentioned that, you know, the family's treated as the core of all moral values, et cetera,

00:23:14.340 et cetera. But a lot of times it's the biggest temptation to doing the right thing. For example,

00:23:18.980 when lynchings used to, these thousands of lynchings that took place in America, there

00:23:23.040 are people in those towns that hated them, disagreed with them, but you spoke out, you were

00:23:26.920 gone. And then if you're in that situation where you're going to speak, want to speak out and

00:23:31.340 you got kids, you say, well, you know, I got my family. What do you think Nelson Mandela? He had

00:23:35.480 kids, you know? So sometimes the family can become a moral temptation. I think to hide

00:23:39.960 by, I'm sure that was the case in Nazi Germany, right? I'd, I'd resist, but I have a family 0.54

00:23:46.100 to take care of. Right. You know? Yeah, that's hard. It's a, that's a tough one to do, to think

00:23:51.860 about. But it could also make life easy because then you're, you're free from any kind of having

00:23:55.860 to make some painful decisions too. We're going to take a quick break for your words from our

00:24:00.840 sponsors. And now back to the show. Well, uh, let's talk about another question that

00:24:07.440 existentialists grappled with is the idea of authenticity. And everyone talks about authenticity

00:24:13.380 these days. You think so? I don't care. I don't care. Well, they, they, but they talk about

00:24:16.880 it. I don't think in the way that existentialists like, cause I mean, I, while I guess like, you

00:24:21.000 know, a couple of years ago, you'd see companies really, you know, talk about, we have authentic

00:24:25.120 artisanal, whatever. Oh yeah, that's right. And I, but I, or like, you know, people on

00:24:33.200 your sort of self-help type people, they're like, you got to live your, your true self

00:24:37.520 living my, my truth. I'm living my truth. I got to be authentic. And I think we have the

00:24:43.420 existentialist to thank for, you know, this sort of, I don't know, this watered down version

00:24:46.880 of authenticity, but I mean, let's talk about what did the existentialists think what it meant

00:24:50.560 to be an authentic person. Well, Kierkegaard didn't, didn't talk about, use that term very

00:24:57.360 much, although it's dragged out of a lot. People find that in him. So for him, it would

00:25:02.800 become your true self. Okay. But I think there's someone like Nietzsche would have thought that

00:25:08.540 to become authentic would be to, it was an act of self-creation, which is a lot of what people,

00:25:13.880 I think at some levels think today, right? It's the not define yourself in terms of the crowd

00:25:18.780 to become what he calls the sovereign individual, you know? So there's this one,

00:25:23.680 one notion of authenticity that might involve, you have this true self, which you were born to

00:25:26.980 become, right? And the other is authenticity is creating yourself. And, and so those are two

00:25:34.980 different takes on it, but I think we also have to consider the possibility. Well, I mean, suppose

00:25:39.320 you're a real jerk and you're, you're authentic. I mean, so I, authenticity could be a bad thing if 0.99

00:25:45.000 you're, if you're an evil person, you know? So it's not, wouldn't always be a good, wouldn't

00:25:50.980 always be a good thing in that sense. But, but two different models there. Do you have this

00:25:55.080 self you're born to be, or is it one of creating yourself to doing what you feel like really,

00:26:00.500 you know, which is the one I think that's marketed most today, right? Follow your passions,

00:26:05.060 that kind of stuff. And what would the existentialists think about, I mean, would they like the follow

00:26:10.340 your passion thing? Would they, I guess, would some of them be on board with that? Or would

00:26:15.040 they be like, or you? Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Yes. Again, they disagree on a lot. I mean, you have

00:26:20.700 atheists that are existentialists, you have true believers like CERN. But yeah, Kierkegaard was

00:26:28.700 very emphatic about the importance of passion, right? That's for sure. But he wouldn't, he wouldn't

00:26:33.740 say that our destiny in life is to follow our passions. I mean, suppose I have a, you know, a passion

00:26:40.220 for playing beach volleyball or something and I'm able to do it. Well, I wasn't put here on earth to

00:26:44.540 play beach volleyball, you know, even though I, right. I mean, so he would say we have duties and

00:26:51.140 things like that, that, that are, that are very important. Well, he would say like, I mean, I know

00:26:55.900 Kierkegaard didn't say the word authentic, but he would say the, I mean, if we were to pull it out of

00:26:59.300 him, like for him, the authentic self would be like, you know, a child of God or whatever.

00:27:04.400 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Or a good, a good, I mean, for people who find talk of God,

00:27:10.060 blasphemy, it would be being a good person, being a good person, being, that's what you

00:27:14.880 were born to be. You weren't put here to hike all day or drive or ride your bike a thousand

00:27:20.400 miles. You were here to help each other. We're here to help hold hands and be together and help

00:27:23.980 each other. And I like this idea, you know, I think Nietzsche, he was saying, you're quoting

00:27:28.780 the poet Pindar, become who you are. Yeah. Your, your task in life is to become who you are.

00:27:35.060 And I think that's an interesting concept because it's like, okay, you have to first

00:27:39.560 you to know, who are you? Like what, what is the you you're supposed to become? And

00:27:44.040 then what does that process look like?

00:27:46.840 Yeah. But I think for Nietzsche, it's an artistic process. Becoming who you are is not

00:27:51.520 like, it's not like Kierkegaard where you were born with a certain, you were born with

00:27:55.840 self before God or whatever. Right. For Nietzsche, it's more rise above the crowd, develop the

00:28:01.920 discipline. Don't, don't evaluate yourself in terms of the, you know, the market value

00:28:07.720 or the herd. Right. And it involves a lot of self-discipline and everything. And so he

00:28:13.300 talks about as a sovereign individual, but it's more, it's much more of an act of creation

00:28:17.800 for him. Gotcha. Right. Self-creation. And I think for, for Sartre as well, he thinks of

00:28:22.840 it as like an artistic project. And I think Kierkegaard and Dostovsky probably would

00:28:29.300 disagree with that. Right. But what do you think of authenticity? What, what are your

00:28:34.800 thoughts on it? I don't know. Like it's one of those, so I've read. What do you think

00:28:39.480 are authentic people? Who have you said, man, that person's authentic? Man. So, I mean, I've

00:28:45.580 met a few people like, so I think Kierkegaard described this person, you know, going back to

00:28:49.320 Kierkegaard sort of Christian roots, like the person without guile. Yeah. I think so too.

00:28:53.100 Like you, like you interact with them and you know, they've got no other agenda. They're

00:28:57.220 just nothing up their sleeve. I've interacted with a few people like that. And it's like

00:29:01.080 really refreshing because it's just like. And don't you think. You don't. And at home

00:29:06.280 on their skin in some way, at home on themselves without being, uh, without being arrogant or

00:29:11.220 something like that. I, I associate that with, um, yeah, but you're right. Being a little

00:29:15.180 in a, I think it's Nathaniel, the disciples made the tree and Jesus says something like he's

00:29:20.640 a person of no guile. Yeah. I, I, I agree with you. Yeah. Nothing up your sleeve.

00:29:25.960 And I also like, I mean, the idea of when I've thought about the become who you are thing

00:29:29.740 from Nietzsche. So it is an act of self-creation, but I think the way I've read it is that Nietzsche

00:29:33.800 would recognize there are limitations to your creation, right? You have to sort of understand

00:29:38.940 the limits that you have. So like for me, example, I'm not particularly athletic. So like

00:29:42.880 becoming an NBA or an NFL player, probably not in the books for me, but, but there's other

00:29:49.940 things that I could do with, with discipline and, and will that I could become who I am.

00:29:57.360 Yeah. Yeah. That's right. I think that, I think that's right. Yeah. He's certainly one that want

00:30:00.700 us to encourage you to recognize your, the necessity, the concreteness in your life. Yeah.

00:30:06.340 Now what, but I'm like, you're guarding. We wouldn't have any normative kind of moral

00:30:10.500 parameters on that. So if you wanted to become, if you were like a Viking type person or a killer

00:30:17.300 or something like that, and that's what your true passion worked at, I don't know what there

00:30:20.960 is in nature that would say you can't do that, but that's wrong. Right.

00:30:24.100 So he's, he's kind of, um, he's, he doesn't have a lot of normative force there. Right.

00:30:29.980 But he has things that teach us about the moral life. I mean, in particular, not to be that much

00:30:35.660 of our lives driven by resentment and the emotions like that. So I think he's, and even for people of

00:30:41.920 faith, I think he's, he's very, uh, he's very refreshing and very insightful. Yeah. And to let

00:30:47.980 things go like, uh, he, and he read, um, before he wrote the genealogy of morals, which is one of

00:30:53.060 his greatest books, he read, uh, Dostoevsky's notes from underground. And it's all about this

00:30:58.640 capacity for self laceration, for tearing ourselves apart for nature. You recognize there's something

00:31:04.160 wrong. You let it go. I mean, forget about it. I mean, you know, you try to change your ways,

00:31:07.440 but you don't like just chew yourself up about it. Right. And he thinks there's a lot of that

00:31:12.620 in our society, a tendency to what he calls bad conscience to turn all aggressions inward.

00:31:18.420 So he says like, for example, to, to forgive someone is to just forget it. Right. There's a

00:31:24.700 lot of like, yeah, I'll forgive you. Cause I need to move on in my life as though forgiveness

00:31:28.460 were a form of therapy. It's not, he said, you need to forget it, let it go. So that's, that's

00:31:34.620 an important moral insight on his part. Yeah. I guess each would say the noble soul

00:31:38.340 would do that. Like the noble, he would just, they'd forget it, but like the resentful person

00:31:42.040 filled with resentment would hold that grudge forever. Even basically. That's right. Yeah.

00:31:48.000 Yeah. Yeah. And I think that's a beautiful, that's a refreshing insight the way he describes

00:31:52.680 it to anybody. He says that even with respect to our own lives, right? Like, have you ever,

00:31:58.980 I don't know, I've had times when I just gone over, I can't believe I did such and such. Oh my God,

00:32:02.960 man. You know, like stuff from 50 years ago, whatever. And it's like, let it go, man. Like

00:32:08.380 don't, don't last. He thinks this kind of self-laceration is part of a, of part of what

00:32:14.360 he calls a slavery bull, but that's, that's another story. And Camus would agree. And if 0.98

00:32:17.800 you read Camus, The Fall, amazing book, right? This tendency towards self-laceration.

00:32:23.120 You know, speaking of Nietzsche's sort of ideas about ethical and moral decision, one thing

00:32:27.280 you taught, you kind of suss out from him is that Nietzsche is a, his, he has a call

00:32:32.660 for people to live dangerously. What do you, what do you think he means by that?

00:32:37.700 Well, to take risks, right? And so that's another, that's something, again, where Kiergaard

00:32:41.820 and Nietzsche would compliment one another is that this willingness to take risks, to venture,

00:32:46.140 right? Which he thinks in our, our society is, you know, you know, keep all their bases open.

00:32:51.420 And, you know, we live, you know, very pragmatic. And he says, no, man, live dangerously, take

00:32:56.780 chances. I yell at my students when they don't speak up in class. I'll come on, live dangerously,

00:33:01.620 ask a damn question, will you? Right? I mean, they're like, you know, we're reading Nietzsche 1.00

00:33:06.580 and they're afraid to raise their hand. So I say, come on, live dangerously, ask a question. We're

00:33:12.740 not leaving until I get three questions, I'll say. But yeah, so this, this willingness to take risks.

00:33:17.400 Well, the story you give that was related to that, you know, you talk about how around exam

00:33:23.380 time, you get all these emails from your students asking like, what's going to be on the test? You

00:33:27.120 know, is this answer, would this answer be right? And you finally tell them, it's like, you guys just

00:33:30.880 need to get a grip, right? Because like, they're concerned about, you know, I got to get the A so I

00:33:35.300 can graduate and get the internship, whatever. They're thinking last man, they're being like last men,

00:33:40.460 Nietzsche would say. And you would say, you guys got to get a grip. Like, you know, you talked about,

00:33:45.100 you know, it was like the anniversary of D-Day. And you're saying, that's right. There was 20 year

00:33:49.740 olds who were just, they were storming Normandy. And you're worried about whether you're going to

00:33:54.440 get an A on this test. That went over really big. Yeah. I said, hey man, about this time in 1944,

00:34:00.460 Eisenhower came out and said, a bunch of you, most of you people won't be coming back tomorrow, baby.

00:34:05.060 Most of you people won't be coming back. I said, that was something to be anxious about.

00:34:09.160 Get it in, get a grip. And oh man, that was, some people didn't like that talk.

00:34:14.280 Right. But I mean, yeah, they wanted to play it safe. Like they wanted to know what, like the,

00:34:20.240 they wanted to fill in the box, but you would say, Nietzsche would say like for a test about

00:34:24.580 existentialisms, like Nietzsche would say, be bold, live dangerously, answer something that,

00:34:29.080 you know, it's coming, you know, from yourself that creates something. Even if the professor

00:34:33.600 doesn't like it, like he would say, just go for it. Yeah. Well, I wouldn't say. I don't know.

00:34:39.860 I've had some students go for it, but yeah. Yeah. Rather than leave the blank, but yeah,

00:34:45.060 but do your study in, but, but don't be so, don't be so scared, scared of like, I mean,

00:34:50.000 I love students. They'll freak out if they don't get an A and they get an A minus. I mean,

00:34:56.680 that kind of stuff. They're just so frightened of not being successful, you know, not, you know,

00:35:03.680 this kind of obsession with her, you know, whatever, right. And, uh, as opposed to, uh,

00:35:08.700 they don't, they don't, well, I mean, academically what happens all the time is they won't take any

00:35:12.900 risks. The only people will only take courses. They know they can get a good grade in. They won't

00:35:17.000 study. They'll come to a liberal arts college and won't, I won't stretch themselves. Won't study

00:35:22.280 things that they wouldn't, you know, they don't run in their ballywick. So yeah. Uh, but

00:35:27.700 that's where the coaching comes in though. When I, when I had times like that, where I'm like,

00:35:33.000 get a grip, stop the baby stuff. We take a punch. Yeah, man. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And they'll

00:35:40.080 come. Uh, yeah. So, well, and, and going back to sort of Kierkegaard's idea of like, you know,

00:35:45.160 he, he's, he would agree with Nietzsche about this idea of you had to live dangerously for him.

00:35:49.280 This kind of segues nicely to Kierkegaard's concept of faith. You know, for, for Kierkegaard faith was

00:35:55.180 kind of a, it was a scary thing. It was a dangerous thing for Kierkegaard. Yeah. I would

00:35:59.560 disagree with Freud. It was someone who Freud or who says, uh, believe because we want protection

00:36:04.600 for, yeah, to stand before God to, to realize that's, that's terrifying for Kierkegaard and

00:36:09.840 to stand out from the crowd. He thinks he requires great imagination, right? Cause you know, this,

00:36:16.080 he says to both the faith is an offense to reason. It's a collision with the understanding,

00:36:20.280 you know? So it's very, it's very scary. I mean, I never, right. I mean, like,

00:36:24.140 I don't see proof of Jesus and I'm going around or anybody getting up from the grave and the

00:36:28.700 lately, you know? So yeah, it's, it's very, it's, it's scary for him. Yeah.

00:36:33.500 So, I mean, another, another concept or an idea that existentialist grappled is his idea of love.

00:36:39.420 Yeah. How do they, I mean, obviously they had differing ideas about what love was or what it

00:36:43.900 meant in life. What sort of kind of bird's eye view of what existentialists thought about love?

00:36:48.540 For Kierkegaard, it was a passion, a duty, right? It involved a feeling. He has all these, it's a lot

00:36:55.440 of different admissibles, but it's primarily a duty. We have a duty to love others. And that involves a

00:37:00.320 lot of things like becoming blind to their sins and that kind of, that, that kind of a thing.

00:37:08.020 I don't, I don't, Sartre doesn't write about it that much, but I found one of the most illuminating

00:37:13.400 passages was from Dostoevsky in the Notes from Underground where he, he thinks that we have a

00:37:20.040 hard time accepting, I mean, it's so amazing to be, to be loved by someone who freaking knows you,

00:37:26.200 right? I mean, who knows what an ass, what a jerk you can be, right? And that's just remarkable. I 1.00

00:37:32.100 mean, we all want to be loved for like being cool or, you know, our accomplishments, right? But

00:37:37.780 I've said this at weddings, I guess, but to be loved by someone who really knows you good and

00:37:45.600 bad qualities is just amazing. And Dostoevsky said, we have a hard, because the power dynamic,

00:37:54.460 we don't want, the problem is a lot of time to accept being loved for who you are, right? It's

00:37:58.960 not, we always think of love as, I want to get as much as I can, or I want people to love me.

00:38:03.380 Now he says, it's, it's really one of, of being able to accept love from someone who knew you. I

00:38:08.960 had a, and I think, and he thinks that's the problem. That's one of the offensive things about

00:38:13.000 Christianity is that, that Jesus knows us and loves us and forgives us. And there's nothing that

00:38:19.860 makes, Dostoevsky thinks there's nothing that makes people more angry than to be told, I forgive you,

00:38:25.880 right? So we don't often think about the task of being able to accept love from people who know all

00:38:33.360 our flaws. And I think that's a beautiful insight, right?

00:38:38.400 No. Yeah. I mean, I mean, I like this quote in the book that you have. He says, we need,

00:38:42.540 we need the love of others to love ourselves, but in order to be nurtured by the love of others,

00:38:47.160 we need to love ourselves sufficiently to accept that love.

00:38:50.840 Yeah. And that's why I think one of the issues today with issues about race and social justice,

00:38:55.820 I mean, just, you know, all the boxers that I train and Mexican immigrants, man, they get nothing 1.00

00:38:59.940 but crap half the time, you know, everyone looked down on them like invisible, right? That can affect 0.97

00:39:05.000 your ability to love yourself. Now we think we need to think of racism and the social injustice as

00:39:11.420 infecting people's ability to love themselves. Because a lot of times when you have that kind

00:39:15.460 of social injustice, you also have economic things going on at home that are bad. Parents are always

00:39:21.520 pissed off or split up. You go to school angry, you get nothing but crap from teachers, you know? 0.99

00:39:26.860 And so we, they say, and I think Kierkegaard missed the boat on this one, that to truly love 0.96

00:39:33.020 ourselves, it really helps to get love from others and not be treated as dirt or invisible, which is

00:39:39.920 how a great many human beings are treated.

00:39:43.540 Well, Kierkegaard did say this thing, he talks that you need to presuppose love in others, that other

00:39:47.760 people are capable of love.

00:39:49.740 Yeah, that's right. You've been doing your studying, man. Yeah, well, that's impressive. Yeah, that's

00:39:53.400 right. And I think there is saying, this is hard stuff because I like to hate certain people. There's

00:39:58.820 certain people I really like to be angry at. But yeah, the task of love is to assume that the love

00:40:06.600 in the other person, which I take to mean that it's to presuppose their ultimate goodness, which is,

00:40:13.260 that's a leap of faith, right?

00:40:15.040 Yeah, that is a leap of faith.

00:40:16.200 I mean, really, like somebody just, don't think it's a monster, but just somebody

00:40:20.480 irritates the hell out of you, right? I mean, some of them are just like, ah, I just, you

00:40:24.880 know, argh, right? To just, you know, David Foster Wallace said, you probably heard, what

00:40:31.180 is it, all his water?

00:40:32.080 Yeah, right.

00:40:33.540 Yeah, a beautiful, beautiful graduation speech. Almost up there with some of Kurt Vonnegut,

00:40:38.280 whom I love. But this idea of like, just thinking about what might be going on in someone else's

00:40:42.680 life. Like a lot of times I've gotten pissed off at people and then found out later what

00:40:47.340 they were going through. And that, so sometimes the impediments, so we feel like we're having a

00:40:53.340 hard time presupposing love. We're caring about somebody who irritates the hell out of us.

00:40:57.640 So at that point, we might want to catch that feeling and say, amen, something might, something's

00:41:00.960 going on here. Or maybe, you know, could be something, something I don't know.

00:41:05.940 Yeah, no, I mean, like sometimes, yeah, whenever we, someone's annoying, we sometimes justify

00:41:10.160 ourselves to not care about or love that person. It's like, well, they're annoying. They deserve

00:41:15.620 it. Like they don't deserve.

00:41:17.180 Yeah.

00:41:17.360 But I mean, so Kierkegaard would say, I mean, by presupposing love and others, Kierkegaard

00:41:21.360 saying, I think maybe this is what he said, maybe tell me if I'm wrong, is that you're recognizing

00:41:25.440 that the other person is spirit or has the potential for an authentic or whatever.

00:41:30.480 So let's, let's bring back boxing into this. What do you think boxing can teach us about

00:41:38.080 existential philosophy?

00:41:39.980 Well, it's not what boxing can teach us. It's what, how boxing can change your life.

00:41:44.300 Okay. So in order to be a decent, I guess there's connection with existential, I keep harping

00:41:49.880 on and preaching in order to be a good person, we've got to be able to deal with emotions

00:41:53.960 like anger and anxiety, but we don't get many workshops on that in everyday life.

00:42:00.480 Most people live in these protect circumstances, right? You know, where they're never, you

00:42:06.860 know, take some medication for your anxiety and anger sometimes treated as more taboo than

00:42:12.240 sexuality, you know? So, and those are really key emotions. And, and in boxing, there's a,

00:42:18.960 it's like a workshop for dealing with those. You can't be in your, George Foreman once told

00:42:23.840 me, cause he's a devout Christian and very, man of great faith, a lot of respect for him.

00:42:28.440 And he once told me, man, you know, boxing makes people less violent because you can't

00:42:33.900 be successful at the sport unless you learn to control your emotions. You should see people

00:42:40.760 in the first three or four bouts if they ever, I mean, they just, it's just, it's just fight

00:42:45.400 or flight. But over time they learn how to control their emotions. But more, more than that,

00:42:50.500 he said, you know, cause he was, he came back, his comeback, he started his comeback after

00:42:56.560 about being out of boxing 13 years to finance his gym he was running. And he said, man, there's

00:43:02.000 a lot of people, there's a lot of kids in that gym that their parents never, their fathers

00:43:06.660 never, never around, but as soon as they start, start boxing, the folks are there. So all of

00:43:13.080 a sudden, some people will get this affirmation that they don't get anywhere else in life.

00:43:17.480 You know, and we all need affirmation somewhat, like most of us, you know, a lot of us are

00:43:22.080 patted on the back. Oh, you're smart. You're this, you're that. There's a lot of kids who

00:43:25.100 never get that affirmation. And then they go to the boxing gym and they work at it. And

00:43:30.060 man, they're going, you're cool. You're this, you know, that's really, you're something.

00:43:33.220 We don't want, we don't, you know, we don't want just, you know, this kind of well respect

00:43:37.480 for each other. We need more than that. There's a, we need intimacy and a kind of, a kind

00:43:42.320 of closeness that you get, that you also get in a boxing gym. It's like a family, man.

00:43:45.680 There's no racism in boxing. I mean, everybody, it's a family, but more than that, you get

00:43:50.400 affirmed just by, just by getting in the ring. And so that, that need for affirmation, I

00:43:55.860 think is huge and can make people blossom. I was a boxing writer for the Wall Street Journal

00:44:00.500 for many, many years and HBO and everything. And you meet these champions who come from rough

00:44:06.240 circumstances and you see how they've been molded by, how they've been changed by, you know,

00:44:11.280 Mike Tyson's different. I mean, how they've been changed by, by the love they've gotten

00:44:15.720 from the sport, you know, so self-discipline and affirmation can come out of boxing. And

00:44:20.840 it can, and again, there's not many other places, even when coaching football, nobody

00:44:24.160 talks about courage anymore. It's all about strategy and all this technique and stuff like

00:44:27.520 that. Boxing, man, it's like, stick in there. You got to be courageous. You know, you got to

00:44:31.900 deal with your fears. It's a workshop on that, but it's got to be in a place where, in a gym

00:44:37.060 where people know what they're doing and it's safe. Yeah. We've had a podcast guest on about

00:44:41.620 that idea of affirmation. He says, he said, he made the case. People need two things. They

00:44:45.080 need to be noticed and they need to be needed. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. That's a good point. Yeah.

00:44:50.180 That's right. That's right. And a lot of time we just talk about respect. Respect is such

00:44:53.940 a cold idea, right? I mean, we've got to respect others. Yeah. We've got to respect others,

00:44:57.560 but we need more than respect. We need, we need love, man. We need, we need togetherness. We need

00:45:03.860 to be sometimes to be told we're good at something. And it also involves telling people

00:45:08.320 when they're screwing up. I mean, I think one of the things I learned from in boxing from

00:45:13.140 my mentor, a Marine, when I used to head coach at VMI was to love somebody to tell them stuff

00:45:18.960 they don't want to hear. And so, you know, the loving thing to do sometimes, because most

00:45:23.960 people don't want to do that because it leads to, you know, it's, it's not fun. Person might

00:45:29.440 get pissed off that we need to be able to, as, as mentors to tell people they don't things

00:45:35.540 they don't want to hear sometimes, you know, and they're still, and you got to have that

00:45:40.340 base of love where they, they know you're not rejecting them wholesale. Right.

00:45:44.560 Well, Gordon, this has been a great conversation. Where can people go to learn more about your

00:45:48.180 work and your book?

00:45:49.480 Well, my book is the existential survival guide. It's published by Harper and I can just go

00:45:54.080 on Amazon and get it in most bookstores. Uh, people, if people have questions, they can

00:45:57.980 email me at Marino at Stoll of dot edu. If I'm happy to take questions, I'm on Twitter

00:46:03.860 at Gordon Marino and, um, I have a website, but I haven't got my kids trying to help me

00:46:09.620 get it up, up and running. And so I'd be happy to take any questions. And it's been a real

00:46:13.960 joy talking with you. That's you did. And, uh, really appreciate your knowledge of

00:46:18.340 care card, et cetera. So I'm going to, I'm giving you a, I'm giving you an A for the class.

00:46:23.540 I appreciate that. Well, Gordon Marino, thanks for your time. It's been a pleasure.

00:46:26.940 Oh, thank you, my friend. Be well.

00:46:29.580 My guest today was Gordon Marino. He's the author of the book, the existentialist survival

00:46:33.140 guide. It's available on amazon.com and bookstores everywhere. Check out our show notes at awim.is

00:46:37.420 slash existential. We find links to resources. We delve deeper into this topic.

00:46:47.780 Well, that wraps up another edition of the AOM podcast. Check out our website at artofmanliness.com

00:46:52.260 where we find our podcast archives, as well as thousands of articles rewritten over the years.

00:46:55.600 And if you'd like to enjoy ad-free episodes of the AOM podcast, you can do so on Stitcher

00:46:59.000 premium. Head over to stitcherpremium.com, sign up, use code manliness at checkout for a free

00:47:03.080 month trial. Once you're signed up, download the Stitcher app on Android or iOS, and you can start

00:47:06.720 enjoying ad-free episodes of the AOM podcast. And if you haven't done so already, I'd appreciate if you

00:47:10.260 take one minute to give us a review on Apple podcast or Stitcher. It helps out a lot. If you've done that

00:47:14.000 already, thank you. Please consider sharing the show with a friend or family member who you think

00:47:17.620 will get something out of it. As always, thank you for the continued support. Until next time,

00:47:20.520 this is Brett McKay reminding you not only to listen to the AOM podcast, but put what you've heard into action.

00:47:24.800 Thank you.

The Art of Manliness - August 12, 2020

#635： The Existentialist's Survival Guide

Episode Stats

Summary

Transcript