In this episode, Brett McKay and Michael Haskill discuss the impact the Class of 1915 at West Point had on American military leadership and how it changed the course of American history. They also discuss the curriculum at the time of the Class's graduation and the impact it had on the development of modern warfare.
00:01:23.020Okay, so your book is about the graduating class of West Point in 1915.
00:01:28.860And in the subtitle, you call it the class the stars fell on.
00:01:33.680What made this class different from previous and subsequent West Point classes?
00:01:39.320Well, there are a couple of things that I think are really important about this class,
00:01:43.660even prior to the fame that these guys achieved later on in their military careers.
00:01:49.680First of all, the class of 1915 at the time was the largest class in West Point history.
00:01:57.080West Point was already over 100 years old, was founded in 1802.
00:02:01.820And this class was significantly larger than any that had come in before.
00:02:06.620And in the end, by the time they reached graduation in June of 1915, the number of graduating seniors in the class was 164.
00:02:19.160And of that 164, 59 actually in their career achieved a rank of brigadier general or higher.
00:02:26.720And in the class through the years at West Point, there was about a little over a 40% attrition rate.
00:02:33.360So a number of people that started with the class didn't make it all the way to graduation.
00:02:38.180So first of all, it was the largest in history.
00:02:42.140And then afterward, these men and then the events that unfolded in the years after they graduated came together to really set this class apart due to the number of individuals who achieved brigadier general or higher in rank.
00:02:59.380There's never been a class before or since that's done that.
00:03:02.000And it was, I think that was interesting, because I guess the way they did enrollment changed that year, right?
00:03:21.100Because it's sort of an interesting time in military history, because you're making that transition from how we did warfare for over 100 years to modern warfare.
00:03:30.400Did West Point change their curriculum any to reflect modern warfare, or did they sort of stick to the same curriculum they did back in the 19th century?
00:03:39.540Well, about that time, the curriculum at West Point was heavily weighted toward engineering.
00:03:46.820West Point was known then and still is as one of the great engineering schools in the country.
00:03:52.260But at the time, if you look at the curriculum, there were topics that would be considered kind of anachronistic.
00:04:03.760For example, hypology, how do you take care of a horse, cavalry tactics, and those types of things.
00:04:12.040And this was in an era where technology had advanced to the point where mechanization was becoming more and more of a standard over time.
00:04:24.540Of course, armies around the world still depended on the horse for transportation in a large part,
00:04:29.780but the horse as a cavalry transportation vehicle was becoming outmoded.
00:04:40.420It was certainly kind of anachronistic at the time.
00:04:44.480And so the curriculum at West Point was in transition as well.
00:04:47.920But in my opinion, based on what I've seen, it was a slower transition than you might expect,
00:04:54.000particularly by the summer of 1915 when a war had been raging in Europe for more than a year, or about a year, let's say.
00:05:03.520So the curriculum was still heavily weighted toward engineering, toward mathematics,
00:05:09.040but it carried that feel of an older, bygone era with it through the care of horses,
00:05:18.200the tactics that surrounded cavalry, some of the things that dated back to the Civil War as far as the tactical use of military formations is concerned.
00:05:30.800If I remember correctly, at that time, they built like this really giant stable or a place where they could ride horses around that.
00:10:23.360He was 61st in the class, which out of 164 put him slightly above the middle of the pack maybe.
00:10:35.740He really amassed quite an impressive number of demerits during his tenure at West Point.
00:10:43.360He did display, obviously, an intellect that had he been more interested
00:10:52.240and more diligent in pursuing some of his academics would have put him higher in standing in the class.
00:10:59.200But as it was, he finished 61st in the class.
00:11:02.760And I still believe, though, based on some of the things that we see in his West Point career,
00:11:08.440that there were instructors, there were other people, there were classmates who recognized in him
00:11:15.220that there was a spark of leadership, there was something about him that maybe set him apart
00:11:21.300just a little bit from some of the other cadets there at West Point.
00:11:25.040And that led to his ability to advance in his post-West Point military career.
00:11:31.760Yeah, I guess you have to have a little bit of edge to be a successful leader,
00:11:36.500be able to take a little risk every now and then.
00:11:39.920Well, you know, you do have to think that the return is commensurate with the risk that you're willing to take.
00:11:50.080And so when you look at risk versus return, that's absolutely correct.
00:11:54.360He was willing to take a little bit of risk.
00:11:56.560He was willing to step out a little bit.
00:11:58.900And in return for that, his abilities were recognized probably more rapidly and more readily
00:12:06.460than others in his peer group at the time.
00:12:10.600Yeah. One of the stories I love that you highlight in Eisenhower's experience at West Point was,
00:12:16.640I guess there was a tradition where the upperclassmen would sort of haze the younger, the newer cadets.
00:12:23.520And one of the things was, if you ran into them, you're supposed to ask the newer cadet, what was his, what was the previous, like your previous post?
00:12:31.940Previous, previous form of servitude or condition of service, something like that.
00:12:38.440Yeah. It was sort of derogatory, right?
00:13:10.920And the young man said, I was a barber, sir.
00:13:14.580And when he got back to his room, he told his roommate, P.A. Hodgson, that he had just belittled a man based on what he did for a living
00:13:25.140and really kind of who he was and what his identity was prior to coming to West Point.
00:13:29.980And I think it resonated with Eisenhower because someone had asked him the question, well, I'm from a lower-to-middle-class family in Abilene, and I worked in a creamery.
00:13:42.520And so at that point, Eisenhower said, I vowed never again to display that kind of attitude and to treat other people that way.
00:13:51.200And that was a great life lesson for him, and I think it carried through in his dealings and his interactions with others throughout his military and then his political career
00:14:01.460and really defined him as one of those things that made him an effective leader.
00:14:29.660Well, at the time that World War I was being prosecuted overseas and some of their classmates had gone on to actually be involved in combat and receive some decorations for bravery,
00:14:43.400both Eisenhower and Bradley remained stateside.
00:14:48.540Bradley was in Butte, Montana, essentially leading guard duty over some copper mines.
00:14:56.540Eisenhower had various posts as an instructor, and that was one of the things that kept Eisenhower here in the United States
00:15:03.260was the fact that he was a very good instructor, and they put him to use in that regard.
00:15:10.200Both of these guys were bitterly disappointed.
00:15:14.560And they believed that the fact that they had not been in combat or at least been in France during World War I was extremely detrimental to their careers.
00:15:25.980At one time, Bradley kind of bemoaned his whole situation and thought, well, maybe, maybe I'll be able to retire after 20 years in the Army
00:15:38.520and hopefully reach the rank of lieutenant colonel.
00:15:42.640And that was about all he felt like he might be able to do.
00:15:47.980They both felt like they had been kind of relegated to the backwaters of the military and that their careers were going to take a backseat to actually those who had been in combat and been in Europe.
00:16:04.620One of the things that's really interesting about that, though, is as they continued their military education at the infantry school,
00:16:12.460at the command and general staff college and those types of things, Bradley made a really interesting point.
00:16:17.960Some of the guys that had been over in Europe had been exposed to tactics and strategies that were archaic, that in the next war would not be applicable.
00:16:29.040And, in fact, if they continued to ascribe to those, would be a real handicap as far as being able to prosecute another war successfully.
00:16:37.100But when Bradley got into the classroom, he hadn't absorbed any of that because he hadn't been in Europe.
00:16:43.620So he had fresh ideas and a fresh perspective on the future, which, in kind of an ironic twist, actually helped him.
00:16:53.440So were there any graduates of the class that served in World War I that showed some distinction?
00:18:25.100He actually served in several wars, not just World War I.
00:18:28.740I thought that was really, I think you said like five different battles or conflicts.
00:18:33.020Well, think about the span of time that was involved there, the Pancho Villa expedition in 1916, World War I, World War II, Korea, and then the Vietnam era.
00:18:49.180By that time, he was basically retired, but he did do some studies on the combat efficiency of special forces in Southeast Asia.
00:18:59.020But James Van Fleet, if you look at the longevity of his career and ending it as a four-star general, is pretty remarkable.
00:19:08.780He's a great example of perseverance and really the will to win kind of was his mantra.
00:19:17.260He endured some setbacks in his career that most people, I would say, would have a great amount of difficulty overcoming.
00:19:26.180First of all, as he was continuing his educational experience in the classroom, he had always been somewhat challenged.
00:19:33.240And we all know people like that who are excellent thinkers, great conceptualists, and able to conceive and execute a plan.
00:19:43.960But maybe when they sit in the classroom and someone puts a test in front of them, that's not their shining moment.
00:19:51.400And Van Fleet was kind of one of those people.
00:19:53.720So he completed one of the courses there for young officers, and his file basically said he really is not suited for further education in the U.S. Army.
00:20:05.820So he kind of had that strike against him early in his career.
00:20:10.280And then for whatever reason, and there's still some mystery shrouded around this,
00:20:15.740But for whatever reason, there was a story that circulated that George Marshall, the Army Chief of Staff, had him confused with another officer,
00:20:24.700but believed that James Van Fleet had a serious drinking problem.
00:20:28.540And so when he would come up for promotion, that would be held against him erroneously.
00:20:34.440And so to that end, he was actually a regimental commander in the 4th Infantry Division on D-Day and had not achieved a rank beyond colonel
00:20:46.540when several of his classmates, obviously by that time, were wearing not one, not two, but three and four stars.
00:20:54.140And so there's a lesson there that once that discrepancy was cleared up, according to all the information that we see,