00:12:38.320In fact, Daniel Levinson and Dan Gould is another one.
00:12:42.340They all were talking about these different transitions,
00:12:45.700mainly going from 20s to 30s to 40s. And Gail Sheehy really drew heavily on Dan Levinson's work,
00:12:54.200but he also did speak about these transitions. But he said it was really a natural part of adult
00:13:01.880development that as you are going into the next decade, and there's periods of stability and
00:13:07.800change throughout adulthood. But he didn't necessarily say that it was a crisis. I think
00:13:13.480it was really not until Gail Sheehy popularized it that that became more of a common term.
00:13:19.240And certainly it's also popularized by Hollywood and novelists who love to portray the midlife
00:13:25.980crisis with these stereotypical views of getting a red sports car, as you know.
00:13:31.760Yeah. And see, I remember growing up in the late 80s and 90s, there's a lot of movies that came
00:13:38.160out made by baby boomers because they were hitting their midlife then. It was about the0.96
00:13:43.020midlife crisis. I remember City Slickers with Billy Crystal. I think there's some other ones
00:13:47.820too. Same sort of thing about these people, baby boomers hitting midlife and they're having this1.00
00:13:51.480crisis and they try to go on this adventure and try to figure things out. And it's kind of1.00
00:13:55.060popularized that idea even more. Yeah. It can be really funny and people do have issues in midlife.
00:14:01.820It is a difficult time. There's a lot of stress. And so it kind of capitalizes on that. And I think
00:14:06.700people can relate to it. And then another thing that happened that entrenched this idea of the
00:14:11.460midlife crisis even more, is that in the 2000s, there was this research that came out that showed
00:14:17.700that people experienced a U-shaped curve of happiness. So they'd start out happy in young
00:14:23.220adulthood, they would get progressively less happy as they approached midlife, and then had their
00:14:29.120happiness go up as they left midlife. Tell us more about that research. This is a very interesting
00:14:35.880period of time when there were many studies that consistently found this U-shape, which basically
00:14:43.660means if you compare people from 18 to 70 and you give them a questionnaire that asks them to rate
00:14:51.040their life satisfaction on a 10-point scale, with zero being the worst possible life and 10 being
00:14:57.500the best possible life, what they found was those who were in their 40s and 50s were lower than
00:15:04.740those who were younger and older. Now there's a number of things that I think are problematic
00:15:10.340with that work. So let me say what I think the problems are. So first, when we looked at the
00:15:16.960data, the differences between those who were younger or older than those in midlife were very
00:15:23.020small. So on this 10 point scale, we're talking about a few tenths of a point. So maybe 7.4 for
00:15:29.780those who were in midlife and 7.8 for those who were in early adulthood or later adulthood. So
00:15:37.260those are really small differences, although with the large samples that they had, and these were
00:15:41.360samples not only in the US, it was really all over the world, these were statistically significant
00:15:45.960differences. So it became really common knowledge that the low point, in fact, they said the nadir
00:15:52.560of life satisfaction is age 47. They pinpointed it to that particular age. So first of all,
00:15:59.240it really was a very small difference. The other point I want to make is that now they have
00:16:05.840retracted, the people who propose this U-shape have retracted it. And it's unfortunate why they
00:16:12.260retracted it. The reason they've retracted it is because it turns out that the younger people,
00:16:18.340those under 40, are the ones who have the lowest life satisfaction. So it really seems that it's
00:16:26.100just a difference in terms of where you rank yourself relative to the other ages at one point
00:16:33.660in time. And that, in my view, is not the best way to be looking at this question about whether
00:16:40.360midlife is good or not. First of all, there are huge individual differences at any age. So on
00:16:47.020average, it doesn't really tell you much about why some people are doing better than others.
00:16:51.040And the other thing is that when we follow people in our longitudinal study, we don't see people going down in midlife per se. We see pretty much what I would call consistent, stable life satisfaction. Most people maintain their levels of satisfaction throughout life. Those who are happy tend to be happy most of the time.
00:17:11.840With some blips when there are problems, certainly if you follow people on a daily basis, you can see their ups and downs.
00:17:18.720But we don't see this downward trend in midlife on average as they do in the U-shape studies.
00:17:38.280We asked this in the very beginning of our study.
00:17:41.280We asked people, and this is from earlier generations, not current generations.
00:17:46.100And they did say they had a midlife crisis, but as you say, it was only about 20 to 25%.
00:17:53.300And I think it's important to qualify that what they meant by a midlife crisis was not necessarily what Elliot Jacks originally had talked about,
00:18:01.900which was people thinking everything's going downhill.
00:18:04.800The kind of things that they talked about were more related to events that happened to them in midlife.
00:18:11.000such as getting divorced, or losing a job, or getting an illness. And those things can really
00:18:17.980happen at any age. If they happen to you in midlife, then you may call it a midlife crisis.
00:18:22.820There were some people who did talk about fears about getting older, but that was less likely
00:18:29.160than those people who are focused on these external events.
00:18:33.200All right. So this idea of the midlife crisis, not really a thing. Some people experience it,
00:18:38.820not very many, but it's not because you hit your 40s and you're automatically going to have an
00:18:43.480existential crisis. You just happen to have stuff that happens in midlife that can cause a lot of
00:18:47.980stress. Most people generally go through midlife satisfied with life. Nevertheless, this idea of
00:18:55.040the midlife crisis still exists. And one of the arguments you make in the book is that believing
00:19:00.480this idea or buying into this idea of the midlife crisis can hurt you. How can it hurt people if
00:19:06.200they buy into this idea that I hit my 40s, it's all downhill from here.
00:19:10.780I'm glad that you brought this up because I will say that as I'm reading articles
00:19:16.460so often these days about the millennial midlife crisis, I am getting concerned. I do think what's
00:19:23.780going on is that many people in their mid-30s and early 40s are experiencing a lot of stress
00:19:30.960because of the financial crisis that we're all going through and things related to housing.
00:19:38.080And this is causing a lot of stress. And I think people are labeling it as a midlife crisis because
00:19:43.540they happen to be in midlife. And it's a very difficult time because there are many people
00:19:47.440depending on them and they're having financial stresses. And so it is really important to
00:19:53.000address this because I think a lot of people are expecting to have a midlife crisis or thinking
00:19:58.800that what they're having is a midlife crisis. Now, why is it so dangerous? I think any negative
00:20:05.440aging stereotype is dangerous. There's been research that shows that if you have a negative
00:20:11.920view of aging, it actually affects your health for years. And in fact, it could even affect your
00:20:17.180longevity and how long you live. So having these negative views of the aging process have been
00:20:23.260shown to be detrimental to your health. But I also think that if you are expecting a midlife
00:20:30.520crisis and you're not doing well, you're feeling stressed, you're unhappy, you may be missing
00:20:36.200things that you can do something about. So you may be depressed. Well, we have a lot of ways to
00:20:41.280treat depression, for example. Or maybe you're experiencing hormonal changes and you think it's
00:20:46.980a midlife crisis. There are things we can do to address hormonal changes. So I think we can miss
00:20:52.560things that are treatable and important if we just label any maladjustment or difficulties
00:20:58.860in midlife as a midlife crisis and chalk it up to that. And so if you think you're just supposed
00:21:04.340to feel terrible when you get to midlife, you might not seek the help that could actually be
00:21:08.520beneficial to you. Yeah. Believing in midlife crisis makes it kind of a self-fulfilling prophecy.
00:21:13.900Yes, absolutely. But I mean, the thing about midlife is it is a transition point because
00:21:20.040you've had about 20 years of adulthood under your belt. And you're probably looking back at your
00:21:25.080life and thinking, how am I doing? I've had 20 years of adulthood. How am I doing in my career,
00:21:30.860in my relationships? Am I as far as I thought I'd be? And some people might look back at this time
00:21:36.680like, boy, I'm really behind on things. I'm not where I want to be. And that can cause some
00:21:41.980depression or some existential angst. But your research has found that there's a thing you can
00:21:47.640do to mitigate some of, you know, sort of internalizing this idea that, okay, I've
00:21:52.420reached midlife. I'm not doing great. I'm having a midlife crisis. And it's this idea of the life
00:21:58.040review. How can a midlife life review help during this transition period between young adulthood
00:22:04.100into midlife? That is a really great point to make because I think there are many people who
00:22:12.740are getting to age 35, 40, 45, and not having accomplished all of the goals that they thought
00:22:21.060they would have by this time. There's just a general trend of people taking longer to reach
00:22:26.640the traditional adult milestones. For example, people are marrying later or not at all. People
00:22:34.760are having children later or not at all. People are taking longer to finish their education.
00:22:40.180People are taking longer to enter the workforce.
00:22:43.520So all of these things that people may have thought if they look at earlier generations
00:22:47.980that they would have accomplished by age 35, 40, and if they haven't, that makes them
00:22:53.760feel that they are behind and that there are problems with not having met their goals.
00:22:59.900But what I like people to think about is there's still a lot of time left.
00:23:03.780There are things that you can still do.
00:23:05.460It's not all or nothing, and there's plenty of time left to accomplish these things.
00:23:10.740Now, the life review is something that I think is very beneficial.
00:23:16.060A lot of times people are so busy in midlife, they're on automatic pilot and they don't
00:23:19.900take time to sit down and reflect and think about where they are or why they are where
00:23:25.660they are or what they really want to do.
00:23:27.980So this is what the goal of the life review is.
00:23:37.460I thought it would be very beneficial in midlife because not only are you looking back to see where you've been, but also where you want to go. And so I think that's very beneficial for people to reflect and think about what their situation is and what they can do to move forward.
00:23:54.160Yeah. I think also doing the life review, you might feel like, oh, I haven't really done much so far. But if you ask some thoughtful questions and be like, well, is that really true? You look back, well, actually, I've done quite a bit. There's a lot of things I have done. I've laid a good ground, a foundation here. I can build off of that for the next 20 years.
00:24:14.880I did something like that when I turned 40 on my 40th birthday, I got a hotel room near my house
00:24:20.520and just want to be by myself. And I took all my journals that I had from since I was a kid
00:24:25.900all the way through young adulthood. And I just read through them all, all night.
00:24:30.900Cause like in that, you get to see how you developed. And I also in these journals,
00:24:34.060I kind of established my goals I had for myself at different periods of my life.
00:24:37.980And I was able to kind of see, Oh, how did I do? And then how have, how have my goals changed?
00:28:32.900Go to jackarcher.com and use promo code get Jack for 15% off your first order and see
00:28:38.880why thousands of people have given the jet sitter tech pant five stars.
00:28:41.820That's jackarcher.com promo code get Jack for 15% off your first order.
00:28:46.460If you're the kind of person who tracks your workouts, sleep and nutrition, but you've
00:28:49.820never looked at your gut microbiome, you might be missing a big piece of the puzzle. Last year,
00:28:54.420I had microbiologist Brett Finlay on the podcast, and one of the things that intrigued me was the
00:28:58.260idea of actually testing your gut microbiome instead of just guessing what supplements or
00:29:02.200probiotics you should use. So I decided to give Tiny Health a try. I ordered the test, I sent in
00:29:07.720my sample, and it was incredibly easy. You do everything at home, you send it off, and now,
00:29:12.480right now, I'm waiting for my results. It takes a little time because Tiny Health uses metagenomic
00:29:16.320sequencing the same technology used in clinical research to analyze your entire gut ecosystem
00:29:21.240once the results are ready you get a personalized action plan with diet lifestyle and supplement
00:29:25.420recommendations based on your biology not generic advice i'm looking forward to seeing what mine
00:29:29.660says and i'll definitely keep you posted start improving your health with real data from tiny
00:29:34.200health tiny health is offering my listeners their most aggressive offer yet fifty dollars off your
00:29:39.340first at-home test kit at tinyhealth.com slash aom that's tinyhealth.com that's spelled t-i-n-y
00:29:45.680h-e-a-l-t-h.com slash aom for $50 off tinyhealth.com slash aom.
00:29:53.740And now back to the show. All right, let's talk about some of the things you will experience
00:29:59.760in midlife because you are getting older and your body and mind changes. One thing I've noticed
00:30:05.460about being in my 40s is that sometimes I feel like I'm just not as smart or as quick as I used
00:30:11.480to be. I mean, there'll be times when I'm at my computer trying to figure something out and think,
00:30:15.680when did I get dumb? I used to be able to do this really fast. Am I imagining this or do you kind of
00:30:23.840get dumber in midlife? Definitely not. You don't get dumber. You actually get smarter in midlife.0.99
00:30:30.500Now that said, things are slowing down. This is part of the natural aging process, but they
00:30:36.580shouldn't be slowing down so much that you really notice it on a daily basis. It might take a little
00:30:41.560bit longer to think of something or to do something than it was when you were in your
00:30:45.480twenties. But the slowing is a natural part of the aging process and probably the one that's
00:30:51.380most noticeable. But you're not dumber. There are two kinds of intelligence that we talk about.0.98
00:30:58.760One is fluid intelligence, which is on the way down. It's slowly, gradually declining,
00:31:05.020but it really shouldn't affect things that you do in your everyday life, especially because
00:31:09.980the things we do we're familiar with and we have learned how to do them and we can improve on them.
00:31:17.400So it's only when we take people into the lab and give them novel stimuli and give them a speed
00:31:22.740test, make them do something really quickly that we see significant declines in midlife. But those
00:31:27.820really don't translate into daily life. So yes, there are some things that are going down. On the
00:31:33.780other hand, and this is really what's most valuable, is crystallized intelligence is going up. And
00:31:39.140that's basically your knowledge and your experience and all that you've acquired for your 30, 40, 50
00:31:46.140years, you have so much knowledge and so much that you can apply to new situations. And that can
00:31:52.640really compensate for any changes that you might experience in the fluid intelligence.
00:31:57.920All right. So yeah, our fluid intelligence in midlife, it's slowing down a little bit. So we're
00:32:01.900not as quick on our feet as we might've been in our 20s. But that crystallized intelligence is
00:32:07.260going up, sort of stuff we know in our head. And I think there's been studies done that showed that
00:32:13.080individuals with a lot of crystallized intelligence, older people can often outperform the younger
00:32:18.540people who have maybe higher fluid intelligence, but because they don't have that crystallized
00:32:23.080intelligence, they kind of flounder a bit before they get the answer. And then, you know, the wise
00:32:27.100old people like, well, here's the answers, I already know it. Yes. In fact, probably the
00:32:32.080simplest example is on a vocabulary test. When you're in high school taking your SATs, you've
00:32:38.360got to study these vocabulary words and try to do well on the test. And if you compare performance
00:32:44.140of a young adult on a vocabulary test with that of a middle-aged or older adult, the middle-aged
00:32:50.300and older adult will outperform the young adult just because they have lived longer and they've
00:32:55.580read more and they know more. It's just a natural process of gaining more knowledge and experience.
00:33:00.860I think another thing that happens in midlife and why it might feel like your fluid intelligence
00:33:05.640isn't as good. I think in midlife, you just have a lot more to think about and use your
00:33:11.260fluid intelligence for, because I'm thinking about in my forties, I'm like juggling work
00:33:15.500and then I'm juggling kids schedule and I'm juggling, you know, paying bills and I'm
00:33:19.760juggling, you know, other responsibilities. And so my fluid intelligence or my prefrontal
00:33:24.240cortex has got a bunch of stuff in the hopper that's got to sort through. And when I was
00:33:28.860in my 20s, I hardly had anything going on. I didn't have kids. I didn't have a house. I didn't
00:33:33.820have much responsibility. And so it was easy to be quicker because I had less to think about.
00:33:39.440Exactly. I like to think of this in terms of executive functioning. So executive functioning
00:33:44.840is what we use to juggle schedules and to plan and to organize things. And so multitasking in
00:33:53.300midlife is huge. And so executive function is still pretty good in midlife. Again, it's on
00:33:59.840this downward trajectory, but the good news is that all of the experience of juggling and doing
00:34:08.420all these things in midlife actually is good for you in terms of maintaining your executive
00:34:13.160function. So the more activities you do, the more things that you do to draw on your executive
00:34:18.400functioning in midlife, the better able you are to maintain your executive functioning into your
00:34:23.140later years. All right. So having kids can help you and help midlife because you have to balance
00:34:27.140all that stuff. Absolutely. Yeah. Okay. So that's good to know. So you're not going to get dumber
00:34:32.280in midlife. In fact, you have this crystallized intelligence that can beat that quickness you0.88
00:34:37.740might've had more of when you're in your twenties. So yeah, that's good to know. I'm glad to know
00:34:42.180that. One thing I've also noticed people complain about in midlife is that their memory gets worse.
00:34:48.300like, ah, where did I put the keys? Why didn't I remember to do this thing? Does our memory get
00:34:53.320worse in midlife? Yes, to a certain extent, it does. Again, it's part of this natural aging
00:35:00.340process. Most people don't notice major memory changes in midlife. Again, the slowing could
00:35:07.260affect it. Sometimes it takes a little longer to remember something. You might feel something's on
00:35:12.260the tip of your tongue, but you can't quite get at it. That starts to happen in midlife.
00:35:16.940But there are things that are affecting it. Changes in the brain are happening. So things like shrinking of the regions of the brain, cardiovascular disease can affect memory. So yes, there are memory changes in midlife, but for the most part, they're not problematic or pathological in the sense that we think about dementia, which that really doesn't happen in midlife.