Robert Davis is a Freemason and the Executive Secretary of the Scottish Rite in the United States. He is the author of the book Understanding Manhood in America: Freemasonry's Enduring Path to the Mature Masculine. In this episode, Robert talks about the history of American masculinity and the role of the fraternal movement in shaping the ideals of masculinity over the last 300 years.
00:00:00.000Hello, Brett here. Before we get to today's show, got a quick favor to ask of you. If you've been
00:00:03.880enjoying the Art of Manliness podcast, I'd really appreciate it if you take one minute to give us a
00:00:07.780review on iTunes or Stitcher. It helps us out a lot. And if you've done that already, thank you
00:00:11.720so much. Please consider sharing the show with a friend or family member who you think would get
00:00:15.240something out of it. Word of mouth is the primary way the Art of Manliness grows and spreads. So
00:00:19.440please share. Text a friend, send an email, do whatever, however you communicate. Tell them to
00:00:23.760check out a particular episode if you think they'd get something out of it. Thank you for
00:00:26.200your support and now on to the show. Brett McKay here and welcome to another episode of the Art of
00:00:47.980Manliness podcast. Now masculinity in America has a complex history. Big historical events and social
00:00:54.060movements like wars and the civil rights movement have all had an effect on shaping manliness in
00:00:58.480the United States. But an often overlooked social movement that had a profound effect on masculinity
00:01:03.180in America was the Freemason and social club movement. Are social groups like Freemasonry and
00:01:08.880the Odd Fellows still relevant today in helping men become better men? Well, our guest today has
00:01:13.140written a book on this subject. His name is Robert Davis and he's the author of the book Understanding
00:01:17.520Manhood in America, Freemasonry's Enduring Path to the Mature Masculine. Robert is a Freemason
00:01:23.720and also the Executive Secretary of the Guthrie, Oklahoma's Scottish Rite. In addition to
00:01:28.300understanding and writing Understanding Manhood in America, Robert has authored two other books
00:01:32.140on the subject of Freemasonry. Robert, welcome to the show. Hey, it's great to be here, Brett. Thank
00:01:37.800you for inviting me. So Robert, tell us about this book. What inspired you to write Understanding
00:01:42.000Manhood in America? Well, I think first of all, as a Freemason, the rituals and private ceremonies
00:01:50.300of this old, old fraternal society reflect the journey of man's life from childhood to mature
00:01:58.680masculinity. And I've been a Mason a long time and I became increasingly concerned that with
00:02:06.840the growth of the fraternity, we have gotten so bogged down in the words of the rituals that
00:02:12.800sometimes we don't integrate the meanings behind the words. This journey, of course, relates to
00:02:21.300the psychology of being. And I wanted to investigate how men have looked at the ideals of masculinity
00:02:29.220over the 300-year period of the American landscape, and then how the fraternal movements have sort of
00:02:38.380moved in and out of the center of defining the ideals of masculinity for American males over this period
00:02:45.360of time. And I think, just as importantly, I'm a man. And I am becoming increasingly concerned with how
00:02:54.880our male gender is being sort of downplayed and overlooked as relevant in today's culture.
00:03:01.380And I think there is, in fact, a growing crisis in mature masculinity in our own time because of
00:03:09.880high mobility of men, high divorce rates, the lack of adequate models of mature men. There's really
00:03:17.380no cohesive institutional structure for actualizing the process of becoming and being men. At least I know
00:03:26.940of no other organization outside of Freemasonry itself that is focused on this very process.
00:03:35.240And it's pretty much, we live in a culture that's pretty much every man for himself. Most men just
00:03:40.600kind of fall by the wayside with no clear idea of the broad and important goals of manly development. So
00:03:46.740I think that was my motivation for focusing on this journey of being a man.
00:03:51.880Well, in your book, you kind of do a, I guess, a 300-year summary of American masculinity.
00:03:59.860And one of the things you mentioned, you kind of mentioned throughout the book, are these three
00:04:03.220archetypes of American masculinity. What are these archetypes and can you describe them to us?
00:04:09.120Well, there's, of course, there are several types of archetypes which are related to the male
00:04:15.220gender. And depth psychologists like Freud and Jung have made us aware that deep within
00:04:21.740every man, of course, are genetic blueprints, which kind of represent the hard wiring of the
00:04:27.800mature masculine soul. And these are sort of a map which identify the foundational characteristics of
00:04:35.240our nature. And generally, when we read books about this kind of archetypes, we're talking about
00:04:44.340hidden energies. And these are often categorized in a general way as the king, warrior, you know,
00:04:50.700magician and lover kinds of archetypes. And I focus on those kinds of archetypes to a degree,
00:04:59.280but I was more interested in looking at the possibility that there had been broader cultural
00:05:06.380or societal archetypes where the social behavior of men can kind of be lumped into several broad
00:05:14.520categories or groups. And I discovered that the foundational archetypes of the American colonial
00:05:20.820era, these were the archetypes that we actually inherited from our European forefathers, were
00:05:27.700usually listed as the genteel patriarch and the heroic artisan and the self-made man.
00:05:35.900And so I made a decision in my book to try and discover if these cultural archetypes of our
00:05:44.780founding fathers are still valid today and prevalent. The genteel patriarch is kind of comprised of the
00:05:54.440classical European definition of man. He was the dignified aristocrat, I'm sorry, a man with an
00:06:02.860upper-class code of honor and a character of exquisite taste and refined sensibilities. He understood the
00:06:09.720nature of class. He was instructed as a young man into all of the protocols and the adequates of
00:06:16.940becoming a gentleman. And so to the general patriarch, manhood to him meant property ownership,
00:06:25.940the accumulation of wealth, the accumulation of wealth, and at the same time sort of a benevolent
00:06:31.340patriarchal authority at home, he was responsible for providing for the moral obstruction of his
00:06:37.520sons, whereas his wife was responsible for taking care of the moral instructions of the daughters.
00:06:44.780He was very definitely the patriarch of his tribe. And at the same time, his world encompassed
00:06:52.740compassion, kindness, duty. And this was represented in this type of man through public philanthropy and
00:07:01.400usefulness. And probably in the American founding era, the genteel patriarchs are best represented by
00:07:10.280George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, John Adams, James Madison, you know, many of the signers of the
00:07:19.740Declaration of Independence and the Constitutional Authors. And these were probably the best known
00:07:26.220models for the genteel patriarch. And then the second archetype that we inherited from Europe was the
00:07:34.220heroic artisan. Heroic artisan can trace his lineage to the craft guilds of the Middle Ages. I was
00:07:43.240interested in the heroic artisan because most scholars believe that Freemasonry itself evolved from the
00:07:51.100craft guilds of the Middle Ages. The idea about this individual and his character is that he was highly
00:07:58.540independent. He was virtuous and honest, very formal in his relationships with women, extraordinarily loyal to
00:08:07.580his male comrades. And whether he was the master of his family farm or the proprietor of his urban shop, he was always the
00:08:17.240honest toiler, had a very strong work ethic, proud of his craftsmanship and self-reliance. And in our colonial period, I
00:08:29.180think Paul Revere, the silversmith, probably represents, you know, the ideal of the heroic artisan.
00:08:36.740And I think the third and the trio of these male archetypes, certainly at the end of the 18th century and
00:08:44.240the first half of the 19th century, was a self-made man. And this fellow derived his identity from his
00:08:51.660activities in the public sphere. It was measured by his own accumulation of wealth and status, but also by his
00:09:00.080geographic and social mobility. As far as the great movement west from the eastern seaboard, you know, we
00:09:08.620definitely became a land of immigrants with democratic ideals. And so the self-made man would be the kind of
00:09:17.680guy that we would most affectionately believe seemed to be born with America. He was constantly on the go.
00:09:25.940He was competitive. He was restless. He was aggressive. He was chronically insecure. He was a man desperate to
00:09:33.240achieve some form of stability and masculine identity. And he very rarely stuck around long enough to set a
00:09:41.720founding of cultural roots. And so I think the best ideals of the self-made man were the pioneers,
00:09:49.840the soldiers, Daniel Boone, Davy Crockett, guys like the explorers like Lewis and Clark. And, you know, all of these men
00:10:01.220moved west. And there were all kinds of them, the farmers, the trappers, the adventurers, the outlaws, the ministers and the
00:10:10.660schoolteachers, the soldiers and the miners. And the man who kind of became the national hero, the cultural icon that would embed
00:10:22.900himself in the masculine mind, I think, was the frontiersman. And so the self-made man probably is the most enduring of those three
00:10:35.220archetypes. And I was just curious if if those archetypes are still around and what's going on with them.
00:10:42.720So and are they still around? Yes, they are. But the very, very difficult, a lot more difficult to define today. And yet some of the
00:10:53.540characteristics are are still there. The old icons of masculinity have become so clouted in our own culture that you have to really
00:11:05.140dig through a lot of murky stuff to identify those archetypes.
00:11:10.460So, Robert, in your book, you kind of talk about some of the cultural history of masculinity through in America and kind of
00:11:16.600the conclusion that I got from in talking to you is kind of kind of reinforces that conclusion that you feel that men are
00:11:22.440kind of lost in the wilderness when it comes to defining or achieving a mature mass masculinity. Why? How did that happen?
00:11:28.960How did men become lost in this path to the mature masculine?
00:11:32.720Well, it I think it largely is a 20th century phenomena. I could make an argument that
00:11:44.180in the 19th century, the Civil War created some problems of loss of identity. But really,
00:11:53.080the 20th century is where I think men became lost. And this this happened for because of several
00:12:02.700societal societal things that really were under nobody's control. And probably the first and most
00:12:11.220significant event that changed man's understanding of who he was, was the Great Depression of the 1930s.
00:12:20.440Prior to the Depression of the 1930s, we still pretty much lived in a patriarchal society.
00:12:27.880It was not unusual at all for there to be in each household three or four generations of males. And so
00:12:38.880the connection that young men had with the with the elders within their own homes gave them a sense of
00:12:49.900of connectedness to manhood, to maleness, and to the lessons that could be passed down from elder to son. And since there were multiple generations in these households, it pretty much was clear that we lived in a patriarchal society.
00:13:10.360And the Depression, of course, moved everyone out of the family home. You know, something like, you know, one out of four men found themselves without job. A person could no longer, especially in the Midwest, make any money or sustain his family at farming.
00:13:34.560And so we saw this huge out-migration that basically broke up the three or four generation male household.
00:13:44.560And when the men left the traditions of their childhood, they never returned. They moved to the urban centers. They became, you know, they became a part of an entirely different culture, and they had to literally reinvent themselves.
00:14:02.920And then a couple other things happened at the same time. The Depression had such an enormous social impact on families that we actually became, to some extent, a welfare state.
00:14:19.300Men no longer felt like they could control their own livelihood or their own stability or preserve the, you know, the condition of their own family.
00:14:33.860And they started feeling more and more helpless. And the more helpless they felt, the more connected to governmental relief agencies they became.
00:14:45.980So it kind of took away, I think, the old model of strength and being able to work through all problems on your own as a man.
00:14:55.400And it happened to the entire culture at the same time.
00:14:58.800And then immediately following the Depression era, World War II came along.
00:15:04.680And the result of that, of course, was that men joined the military by the tens of thousands, and they went overseas.
00:15:14.960They were away from home for a long enough period of time that women started taking over traditional male jobs back on the domestic side of things.
00:15:30.320And so when the men returned after the war, they found a new competition for jobs.
00:15:35.800And the competition for jobs was with their wives and the women in their communities and in their cities.
00:15:44.840And so they sort of started feeling this loss of patriarchy that began at the first of the Depression
00:15:56.000and then just seemed to sort of vanish during the recovery period after World War II.
00:16:01.540And then, of course, in order to employ America, after men came back from the war,
00:16:07.320the government created all kinds of programs to keep people in working positions.
00:16:14.340And that's where a lot of our government agencies were established in the large bureaucracies.
00:16:20.360And so men found themselves just moving into salaried positions in large employee pools
00:16:29.920where they had absolutely no control or authority over what happened with their lives.
00:16:38.740It's kind of like it's the man in the gray flannel suit type of...
00:18:05.760Of course, you know, the war took place at the same time that the drug culture grew by leaps and bounds during that era.
00:18:14.680Again, we sort of created a generation of men who chose to isolate themselves from the icons of masculinity of their fathers and their grandfathers.
00:18:29.880And it especially affected Freemasonry.
00:18:32.680It was the first generation where men did not follow their fathers into the fraternity.
00:18:38.460It was the first time in the history of the fraternity that Freemasons had to look outside their own families for a sustaining membership.
00:18:52.740And so, yeah, that was – and it's not that – and I'm not trying to bash the Vietnam-era males.
00:19:00.820I'm just saying that the media became so prominent in reflecting the events of our lives day in and day out that we quit paying attention to ourselves
00:19:17.920and what we should be doing as our own gender to sort of get back on the right track of manly development.
00:28:35.620The fraternity created boxing leagues and baseball leagues in order to accommodate the enjoyment of men.
00:28:43.100And during the Depression years, the fraternity created these world relief societies to try to take care of the families of men who were within the fraternity.
00:28:55.960So it's been always a fraternity first, but a fraternity that responded to the interests of men.
00:29:05.620And that has been its fundamental strength in almost every generation.
00:29:11.900And then overlying all of that, of course, is that all of these activities and these strategies occur in private conclaves of men
00:29:23.420where three and four generations are participating in the dialogue in Lodge at the same time.
00:29:30.920So we're one of the few organizations left in the world that focuses on this old icon of stability in the male gender
00:29:45.340through connectedness and communications and conversations with multiple generations of men.
00:29:52.200So, Robert, how do you respond to people who say that, well, okay, so Freemasonry had an important role in the lives of men for my grandfather,
00:30:02.900for the founding fathers, but it's no longer relevant?
00:30:06.400What they teach is no longer relevant to the ritual.
00:37:36.660Robert is the Executive Secretary of the Guthrie, Oklahoma, Scottish Rite, and the author of the book, Understanding Manhood in America, Freemasonry's Enduring Path to the Mature Masculine.
00:37:46.220And you can pick up Robert's book on Amazon.com.
00:37:48.480That wraps up another edition of the Art of Manliness podcast.
00:37:57.060For more manly tips and advice, make sure to check out the Art of Manliness website at artofmanliness.com.