Hercules at the Crossroads — Choosing the Hard Path That Leads to a Good Life
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
166.69856
Summary
In a story from ancient Greek philosophy, Hercules faces a choice between two paths: one promising pleasure and ease, the other hardship and struggle. According to today s guest, this ancient parable is more relevant than ever. Dr. Paul Taylor, a psychophysiologist and the author of the new book, The Hardiness Effect, returns to the show to argue that comfort has become our default mode and it s making us mentally and physically sick.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
So earlier this year, Kate and I started a substack.
00:00:04.720
that wouldn't be a good fit for art of manliness,
00:00:11.680
First, there's Kate's wonderful Short Sunday Firesides.
00:00:18.820
that explores topics like luck, success, media theory,
00:00:31.340
plus articles like 20 Lessons from 20 Years of Marriage,
00:00:35.400
what Kierkegaard can tell us why professional sports
00:00:42.560
a tour of our home office, and a lot, lot more.
00:00:57.920
Head to dyingbreed.net and become a member today.
00:01:29.220
this ancient parable is more relevant than ever.
00:01:39.260
and it's making us mentally and physically sick.
00:01:54.800
We then dive into the physiological side of hardiness.
00:02:09.080
check out our show notes at awim.is slash hardiness.
00:02:11.520
All right, Paul Taylor, welcome back to the show.
00:02:36.100
You got a new book out called The Hardiness Effect,
00:02:42.620
And we're going to talk about what that is exactly,
00:02:45.200
but I want to talk about how you open up this book
00:02:47.340
and how it frames what you talk about in the book.
00:03:05.020
Yeah, look, it's one of my favorite stories as well, Brett.
00:03:28.840
One was Cacchia, who said her name was happiness,
00:03:42.220
one of luxury, one of comfort and pleasure without effort.
00:03:46.700
Everything he could possibly want would be handed to him.
00:04:00.480
It would demand discipline, courage, and effort,
00:04:03.760
but it was the only one that led to true fulfillment.
00:04:20.220
that he had to undertake that forged his character,
00:05:04.920
but seduces us with a life of comfort and convenience,
00:05:33.920
We've now medicalized normal emotional experiences.
00:05:40.700
and created a society where the default is comfort.
00:05:56.000
So really, the story of Hercules at the crossroads
00:06:09.120
or Arate's path of discipline, growth, and meaning?
00:06:21.240
and physiological capacity to take the hard path
00:06:24.960
because that is the one that leads to the good life.
00:09:58.660
Yeah, look, it's a bit of a close cousin to resilience,
00:10:03.100
and often they're used interchangeably in the research,
00:10:15.180
So it was first identified by Dr. Suzanne Kobasa
00:10:22.500
and really explains why some people thrive under stress
00:10:34.000
and they were going through a corporate crisis,
00:10:38.420
about two-thirds of the employees fell apart under pressure,
00:11:03.760
as opportunities for growth rather than threats.
00:11:11.760
or heavily influence your environment or your destiny,
00:11:14.580
and in psychology, we call that an internal locus of control,
00:11:42.440
and he's a bit of a mentor of mine in this area.
00:11:51.140
who passed and who failed basic military training,
00:12:01.500
it's been shown that hardiness predicts career longevity
00:12:06.660
such as the military, police, and first responders.
00:12:21.100
as well as predicting success in high-pressure environments.
00:12:25.480
High hardiness scores predict better cardiovascular health,
00:12:50.100
statistically significant in mental well-being,
00:13:14.020
is today's version of choosing the path of Aratae.
00:13:23.740
And the payoff is a life that's not just longer,
00:13:34.860
There's psychological and physiological hardiness.
00:13:45.780
That makes up psychological hardiness, correct?
00:13:50.760
Well, let's dig deeper into these different components,
00:13:56.220
This is about seeing adversity as a challenge instead of a stressor.
00:14:01.140
How can seeing stress and adversity in your life as a challenge,
00:14:07.160
how does that change your psychology and even your physiology?
00:14:21.060
challenge orientation is about how we appraise stress.
00:14:39.020
actually dictates both your psychological leaning
00:14:58.080
it's what we call approach orientation in psychology.
00:15:34.400
And this is the fight part of the fight or flight.
00:15:42.640
it is about the hormones adrenaline and noradrenaline,
00:16:08.140
your body is back to homeostasis within five minutes.
00:16:13.440
the half-life of cortisol is well over an hour.
00:17:08.540
and could translate it into better performance.
00:17:25.600
So your perception influences your performance as well.
00:17:30.120
And the Stoics understood this 2,000 years ago.
00:17:40.740
And the idea is that the friction is the forge.
00:17:45.220
Hardiness is about leaning into that friction deliberately.
00:17:51.220
I think that's a powerful concept to understand.
00:18:02.840
on how you can strengthen your challenge muscle?
00:18:14.360
even the Stoics who talked about life being hard.
00:18:18.540
the first noble truth of Buddhism is life is suffering.
00:18:34.960
you are going to come through challenges in your life.
00:18:48.180
it's just accepting that life is going to be hard,
00:18:51.140
that occasionally you will get sandwiches from the universe.
00:18:54.840
And that acceptance puts you into a state where you can then reappraise.
00:18:59.700
This reappraisal is training your brain to interpret stress as fuel rather than poison.
00:19:25.340
So it's about getting yourself up for the contest of life and seeing these things as challenges to actually test and develop you.
00:19:35.720
And that reappraisal of viewing stuff as a challenge rather than a threat,
00:19:40.600
you can do it not just in the moment when you're dealing with stress,
00:19:45.240
but also you can look back on it and actually taking time for your listeners to think of times in your life that were really hard or stressful.
00:20:20.880
It's about having an internal locus of control.
00:20:23.400
What can the Stoics and Admiral James Stockdale teaches about developing an internal locus of control?
00:20:43.940
This is really about the Stoic dichotomy of control.
00:20:47.200
And it's one of the most powerful psychological tools ever developed.
00:20:59.680
And this is really what's at the heart of the control component.
00:21:06.160
you don't waste mental energy on things you can't change.
00:21:27.880
So the Stoics said that we must focus on that which we can control
00:21:31.920
and refuse to invest our energy in that which we can't control.
00:21:36.300
And a lot of people get into trouble psychologically
00:21:38.180
when they're investing their energy in stuff they can't control.
00:21:41.460
They're in their own heads wishing their past to be different,
00:21:59.760
And he really embodies this control orientation.
00:22:33.980
he could see the Viet Cong coming in to capture him.
00:22:45.200
And he knew that he couldn't control his captors
00:22:57.340
He maintained leadership over the other prisoners
00:23:04.520
And it was that focusing on what he can control,
00:23:08.240
that was really central to his success in there
00:23:11.380
and him helping his other fellow prisoners to get through.
00:23:15.060
Now, studies in both military and organizational settings
00:23:18.800
show that people who have a strong internal locus of control,
00:23:32.800
And you can actually train yourself into this way as well.
00:23:36.620
You can develop your control muscle if you like.
00:23:56.380
It's actually about self-awareness is really the first thing.
00:24:14.020
because what you're actually training yourself to do
00:24:50.600
And then it's about doing little small daily acts.
00:24:57.880
finishing your workout even when you don't want to, right?
00:25:06.480
hey, I made a conscious choice there around control.
00:25:10.040
Every little action just builds that muscle bit by bit.
00:25:16.880
What is it about commitment that makes us more hardy?
00:25:22.720
There's a number of different elements to commitment,
00:25:26.760
So first, it's really about being fully engaged in life.
00:25:31.880
And I am increasingly concerned about modern society,
00:25:41.460
who are spending an increasing amount of their spare time
00:25:50.980
either scrolling on social media or watching crappy TV.
00:25:54.040
These people are what I call passive consumers of life.
00:25:59.960
And it's the polar opposite to high-hardiness commitment.
00:26:03.600
High-hardy, committed people are fully engaged in life,
00:26:14.380
because they're curious, they bring positive energy,
00:26:27.440
So in our culture, it's really easy to live that passive life
00:26:37.080
But when you're committed, you're really present.
00:26:40.380
And the Stoics really talked about this as well.
00:26:42.620
And Seneca said, it's not that we have a short time to live,
00:26:48.620
And this is about whether or not you are fully engaged.
00:26:53.000
Now, linked to that in commitment to orientation
00:26:58.560
And in Viktor Frankl's book, Man's Search for Meaning,
00:27:05.160
And he showed that those who survived the concentration camps,
00:27:11.520
but they were the people who were committed to a purpose
00:27:15.660
And the hardiness research actually echoes that.
00:27:19.680
Salvador Maddy found that people who were high in commitment,
00:27:28.660
They handle stress far better than people with low commitment.
00:27:32.360
And they actually experience a lot less burnout.
00:27:36.100
So what are some things we can do to develop our commitment muscle?
00:27:40.960
So what is about really clarifying your values?
00:27:44.420
And I think part of the problem in modern society
00:27:55.020
But I think what religion did was it gave people a sense
00:28:02.740
And when that's missing, if you don't deliberately find it,
00:28:08.600
So it's really about getting clear on your values,
00:28:21.480
So this gets into another part of commitment orientation,
00:28:30.400
that will actually help you to get to the person
00:28:34.760
that you want to be and ideally linking them to your values.
00:28:54.480
you know, thinking of how would I be thought of
00:29:41.620
You know, it takes 10 to 12 years off your life.
00:29:54.320
was they created this thing called the tap code
00:29:57.160
where they could tap out the letters of the alphabet
00:30:11.540
you release oxytocin and vasopressin in your brains.
00:30:17.900
but they are also the most potent anti-stress chemicals
00:30:39.660
than people who don't have those social connections.
00:30:47.880
And social support is one of the most powerful buffers
00:31:02.160
and she showed that people with strong relations,
00:31:09.700
than people who don't have those relationships.
00:31:13.540
So connection for me is hugely, hugely important.
00:31:16.340
And that's part of today's massive problem of Kakeya,
00:31:29.120
when it comes from to a face-to-face perspective.
00:31:47.280
that can, basically, we don't feel like we're lonely.
00:32:01.960
it is very, very different to online interactions.
00:32:05.720
And he makes a good point that we don't actually notice it
00:32:17.800
that it is about catching up with people in person.
00:33:05.320
Whether it's a side hustle you've daydreamed about
00:33:07.260
or an idea people keep telling you to run with,
00:33:09.620
2026 is the year to stop talking and start doing.
00:33:13.000
And Shopify is the platform that helps you do it.
00:33:15.320
We've been using Shopify for the Art of Manly store
00:33:21.340
You can create a great looking site that works well
00:33:24.780
And it takes care of the not-so-glamorous stuff,
00:33:40.900
As your business grows, Shopify grows with you.
00:33:43.100
Whether you're shipping 10 orders a week or 10,000,
00:33:54.620
and start selling today at shopify.com slash manliness.
00:34:20.720
And we had you on last time talking about your book,
00:34:25.380
And one of the things we talked about in that podcast
00:34:42.900
it's summed up by the words of Friedrich Nietzsche,
00:34:46.900
and I'm sure all your listeners can finish the sentence,
00:34:55.780
Edward Calabresi first noticed in his PhD research,
00:35:29.980
And so when your body is presented with stressors,
00:35:35.020
something called the cell danger response kicks off.
00:35:38.900
And that is the cells actually responding to stress
00:35:55.640
and they drive cellular cleanup processes like autophagy.
00:36:27.220
because of exposure to small amounts of stressors,
00:36:35.180
all three of these activate these stress response pathways.
00:45:22.800
So it's between 100 and 150 nanomoles per liter