Increase Your Influence With the Science of Immersion
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
192.56757
Summary
Dr. Paul Zak is a professor, scientist, and the author of Immersion. In this episode, Dr. Zak shares what he s learned from decades of neuroscience research on how to create immersive experiences that'll set you apart as an individual or business, and increase your influence.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
Brett McKay here and welcome to another edition of the Art of Manliness podcast.
00:00:11.500
Why are so many social, business, and classroom interactions so dang dull?
00:00:16.060
This state of affairs isn't only a bummer for those on the receiving end of these underwhelming
00:00:22.360
It means that people are failing to connect with others, teachers are failing to impart
00:00:25.800
knowledge, and salespeople are failing to make sales.
00:00:28.340
Because when you don't engage people, you don't influence them.
00:00:31.720
My guest says that the secret to making an impact on others is learning to turn ordinary
00:00:35.680
experiences into extraordinary ones through the science of immersion.
00:00:39.420
Dr. Paul Zak is a professor, scientist, and the author of Immersion.
00:00:43.500
Today on the show, Paul shares what he's learned from decades of neuroscience research on how
00:00:47.380
to create immersive experiences that'll set you apart as an individual or business and
00:00:53.140
We discuss the elements that create immersion, what goes on in the brain when it occurs, how
00:00:57.100
long it can last, and how to induce immersion, whether you want to teach a more engaging
00:01:00.840
class, wow your customers, or simply make everyday interactions with friends and family more
00:01:06.680
After the show's over, check out our show notes at aom.is slash immersion.
00:01:27.700
So you've spent your career studying why people or why certain things engage us more emotionally
00:01:40.260
What led you down this research path and how did your career end up having you research,
00:01:46.720
So there's an honest answer and a dishonest answer.
00:01:50.440
I like the, I want the story, the dishonest one.
00:02:00.480
Or, you know, I mean, why do we have so many experiences in our life that are sucky, right?
00:02:07.240
Why isn't everything like the first date with the person you fall in love with or an amazing
00:02:13.400
So, you know, if you talk to businesses, they all agree customer experience is really
00:02:21.260
So the first, you know, dishonest answer is I'm just fascinated that we cannot figure
00:02:27.380
out how to wow people every time we have an interaction, whether that's social, whether
00:02:37.840
The honest answer is that I'm a Martian and I find the human species to be extraordinarily
00:02:44.420
And we began to study why people are nice to each other, which seems to be like a weird
00:02:56.560
I mean, you know, the bad behavior gets in the news, but basically we're pretty nice to
00:03:05.620
Shouldn't we be grabbing resources and anything we want from each other and murdering each other
00:03:13.000
And so we started doing this work, made some progress, and then the U.S. military and some
00:03:18.780
other agencies of the U.S. government with letters that I shouldn't mention started funding
00:03:23.500
us to ask us to identify signals in the brain that in combination would accurately and consistently
00:03:31.260
predict what people would do after a message or an experience.
00:03:36.300
They wanted us to build a neurologic prediction engine in order to train soldiers to have a
00:03:43.680
So if I could understand from a brain perspective what will motivate you to take an action, then
00:03:54.700
We're constantly influencing those around us, whether we know it or not.
00:03:59.160
So my view is we might as well be as good as possible at influence by understanding the
00:04:03.880
factors that promote or inhibit people to cooperate with us.
00:04:07.400
So in your book, Immersion, you share this research you've done in a very easy-to-read,
00:04:15.300
And you explain the neuroscience of what makes certain activities, certain moments in life
00:04:22.340
really engaging or just lights us up and causes us to take action.
00:04:25.700
And you say one of the key features is that these moments, they're extraordinary experiences
00:04:36.380
Like how do you define what's an extraordinary experience?
00:04:38.680
And then what do you mean by the state of immersion?
00:04:42.180
So there's a real dilemma when we started doing this work, which is if I ask you to rate an
00:04:48.460
experience like, I don't know, the cup of coffee you had this morning, how good was
00:04:56.760
You know, I always say like, compared to my kids, my kids talk back to me, forget my
00:05:04.860
And so if we ask people to consciously report what they think they like, it predicts nothing.
00:05:22.760
We gave people an experience and then we allowed them to do something that was difficult or costly.
00:05:28.680
So for example, we showed them a public service announcement about some social ill.
00:05:39.440
At the end, we said, by the way, do you want to donate some money to American Cancer Society
00:05:44.360
And we just compared brain activity for people who did something after an experience versus
00:05:50.940
So our assumption was, if this experience was so exciting to your brain that it provoked
00:05:57.220
you to do something difficult, it must have been really extraordinary.
00:06:02.780
And in doing that, we discovered this neurologic state of called immersion, which is a set
00:06:10.800
So it's brain data that's associated with being present, right?
00:06:15.280
The experience is not going to be great if I'm distracted, if I'm not able to be fully
00:06:19.840
And with the emotional value of that experience.
00:06:22.960
So if I'm here, I'm present, and this experience is emotionally compelling to me, those two things
00:06:28.980
together tell me that this experience is valuable.
00:06:32.000
And that neurologic immersion is a continuous variable.
00:06:35.700
So it can be low, it's an okay thing, or it can be really high.
00:06:42.440
And so by being able to quantify neurologically, second by second, the value that people's brains
00:06:49.100
assigned to an experience, we can work backwards.
00:06:51.980
And this is what the book Immersion does, is to take 50,000 plus brain observations and
00:06:57.540
say, well, how do I create a great message as a marketer?
00:07:04.620
So we've learned so much from people measuring those activities so that we can create more
00:07:14.080
So what are you looking at in the brain to measure this immersion state?
00:07:18.820
Because as you said, I want to talk more about this.
00:07:22.780
So you say you like something, but it actually didn't engage you.
00:07:27.180
What are you actually measuring to figure out whether someone's in this immersive state
00:07:33.160
And again, we're doing this all the time, right?
00:07:35.020
We try to assess, should I get out with that guy or girl?
00:07:40.500
We're really trying to assess our own preferences.
00:07:42.760
But those preferences, Miter Lab and many others have shown, are deep in the unconscious
00:07:48.720
So they're not really open to conscious awareness, at least not very clearly.
00:07:52.560
So we found this immersive state is associated with the brain's binding of a neurochemical
00:07:56.900
called dopamine that probably most listeners have heard of that's associated with things
00:08:03.540
It's the same chemical that drugs of abuse like cocaine and methamphetamine increase a million
00:08:10.540
So first thing all, it's this arousal chemical.
00:08:12.180
Well, I've got to be turned on by this thing so that I'm present.
00:08:15.560
And the second neurochemical is called oxytocin, which is that emotional resonance, like how
00:08:21.720
So if I have this kind of arousal state, dopamine, and I'm getting emotional value from this,
00:08:27.560
that combination together, the dance of those two neurochemicals induces electrical activity
00:08:32.480
that we can measure with big $100,000 machines or now with things like smartwatches while
00:08:41.540
So it allows us to actually quantify second by second when something is good or bad.
00:08:50.700
So we built a platform so that anybody can measure what the brain loves.
00:08:56.920
And one of our longest term subscribers to the platform is the professional services company,
00:09:02.840
And they have found in the $1 billion they spend a year on corporate training that their employees
00:09:09.380
cannot stay immersed in training for more than 20 minutes.
00:09:12.960
So if I want to get this information in your brain, Immersion says it's important, important
00:09:18.780
information to save in the brain in a way that makes it easily accessible.
00:09:22.820
Accenture has now broken down their training into 20-minute segments so that they get the
00:09:28.160
most impact for the money they spend on training.
00:09:32.360
I don't know why it's 20 minutes, why it's not 18 or 22, but they found around 20 minutes,
00:09:41.140
They fatigue with use and Immersion is really metabolically costly.
00:09:45.400
So if I'm going to influence you, if I want to get information in your head, I've got to
00:09:48.920
give you this intensive and generally short experience so that the information is categorized,
00:09:55.040
put in your brain, and then potentially influences your behavior.
00:10:00.880
Okay, so when we are experiencing an immersive moment, there's dopamine.
00:10:05.100
Our dopamine levels rise because this thing is grabbing our attention.
00:10:08.040
But then also combined with that, oxytocin levels rise as well.
00:10:12.420
And oxytocin, I think people have heard it as like the nurturing molecule.
00:10:15.020
It's like the thing that helps us bond to people.
00:10:17.880
But you're saying it also helps us experience that emotional, like it makes the event we're
00:10:30.560
And again, those activate large networks in the brain.
00:10:33.380
What we found is that if we grab data from the brain's output file, which is these 12 cranial
00:10:38.520
nerves that come out of your head and send information to the rest of your body, I can grab a huge
00:10:42.960
amount of information, networked information from the brain.
00:10:46.280
And that was the real breakthrough that we made about 10 years ago is that as opposed to putting
00:10:51.220
you in an MRI scanner or putting a big, you know, EEG cap on your head, that we can actually
00:10:56.220
grab these data from your cranial nerves and get really good signal where we're able to
00:11:01.240
predict things like hit songs through months in advance with 97% accuracy using immersion
00:11:06.040
or predict mood in the elderly with 98% accuracy.
00:11:11.080
So we're really capturing, I'm going to use one bad word, I hope that's okay.
00:11:14.800
Today, I'm really capturing what one of our subscribers, the software platform called the
00:11:20.920
So because the brain is so metabolically costly, so energy hungry, it wants to just cruise most
00:11:27.900
So when we see this neurologic state immersion, it's really expending a lot of metabolic energy.
00:11:33.120
So the brain is investing all this energy to process this experience.
00:11:40.620
The brain goes, wow, this is the best thing ever.
00:11:45.380
So again, think of that, you know, gorgeous guy or girl you see walking down the street,
00:11:49.760
you're like, whoa, this is, how did nature create this amazing creature?
00:11:54.480
Or I don't know, the best meal, I just came from South Africa.
00:11:57.900
I had one of the best meals of my life, a two hour dinner, course after course, this chef's
00:12:09.180
And I was just, you know, totally immersed the entire time.
00:12:14.860
So by knowing this, this immersion idea and that there's this dopamine and the oxytocin,
00:12:20.080
as you said, you can reverse engineer this to create more engaging experiences.
00:12:24.540
Like a lot of things in our life, they grab our attention, right?
00:12:27.360
We all have smartphones and there's things that we, when we're scrolling through, it grabs
00:12:31.620
our attention, but they don't, they're not emotionally resonant.
00:12:37.480
Why, why are some things, you know, they grab our attention, but they don't emotionally
00:12:41.420
So like what, what makes an attention grabbing moment have that oxytocin boost as well?
00:12:51.660
So one is if I grab your attention, but I don't get any emotional value from it, I call
00:12:57.660
Like I want this YouTube ad to be great, but after six seconds, I hover over the skip and
00:13:03.560
I want to go away or, you know, some, I don't know, new show, whatever it is, right?
00:13:10.460
I got the dopamine effect, but just not getting much value out of this.
00:13:14.940
So the second question is like, how do I do that?
00:13:19.160
What we found now in measuring just tons and tons of experiences is that if I use a narrative
00:13:25.760
arc, if I create tension, I have a human scale story, we are as social creatures fascinated
00:13:40.620
We're really interested in what the other humans are doing and we can learn from them.
00:13:44.800
But if I craft that information as a story that is introducing characters who have a crisis
00:13:51.440
or mystery, who have to resolve that mystery, who have to do something often extraordinary
00:13:56.760
to do it, that seems to be the most effective way to sustain immersion.
00:14:03.760
If we're, Brett, you and I are out at a bar at happy hour hanging out, we're going to be
00:14:08.960
So, and that's essentially what we're doing right now on your podcast.
00:14:13.400
I'm telling a little more technical story, but I'm still trying to craft that around a human
00:14:19.420
So when we measure stories, like when we work with movie studios and TV networks, you can
00:14:26.360
see second by second when that story, by measuring immersion, when that story starts to lag.
00:14:31.420
Now, you don't want to be at 100% immersion all the time.
00:14:36.500
But even in our own daily lives for listeners, right?
00:14:39.580
Think about having, crafting a really effective story in three minutes, in five minutes.
00:14:46.980
It's got to open hot and you've got to get me in this story.
00:14:50.280
Open hot means, you know, grab that dopamine attentional response.
00:15:01.220
Here's something that was unexpected that we had to overcome.
00:15:05.280
That narrative arc is really the most effective way to entertain, but also to influence people.
00:15:11.920
So to create immersive experiences, you have to tell a story.
00:15:17.040
Not any story, but it's really got to be, you know, tight.
00:15:21.720
You know, they go to these clubs, they practice these comedy routines and small clubs over and
00:15:26.280
over and over until they've really tightened up the language of storytelling.
00:15:30.600
So we as, you know, civilians, you know, we just tell stories all the time kind of randomly.
00:15:35.900
But I would say if you want to influence others, and that's what human creatures do all the
00:15:42.680
If you want to do it really well, craft that story, practice that story, you know, get it
00:15:47.240
really nailed down so that in particular, if you want to influence someone, you want that
00:15:52.720
call to action or that request to happen at an immersion peak.
00:15:57.120
So you want to craft your narrative so that there is a peak immersion, high attention,
00:16:02.740
high emotional resonance at this point where you've really captured this person emotionally,
00:16:08.040
and then you can move them in a direction that you'd like them to go in.
00:16:20.860
But if I'm going to try to influence you to do something that you can choose to say yes
00:16:25.320
or no to, I might as well do it as well as possible.
00:16:28.160
So when you're crafting a story, what causes those peak immersion moments?
00:16:43.000
You know, they're sort of Jack Nicholson, you know, really great acting.
00:16:47.220
If you're telling your own story, it's really showing your emotions.
00:16:49.900
So I, and I think a lot of guys tend to be not that emotional, but if I want to actually
00:16:55.160
influence you or entertain you, I actually need to express my emotions, right?
00:17:00.780
And so it doesn't mean I'm crying about something, but it means I'm, you know, really authentically
00:17:08.120
So the cool thing about immersion is it's contagious, right?
00:17:10.880
If I'm excited about this experience, you tend to get excited about it too.
00:17:15.340
And so that's how social creatures influence each other.
00:17:21.460
So the caveat to that is if you're making this up, if it's fictional, it's really hard
00:17:26.580
to tell a good lie because as social creatures, we're really good at picking up the unconscious
00:17:37.100
So we've shown in lots of published scientific research that, you know, basically these signals
00:17:41.580
for uncertainty or weirdness, we see those in the brain.
00:17:46.140
We don't always consciously know it, but our brain knows it.
00:17:48.880
And we have that kind of innate sense, like, I don't know, this dude, something's wrong
00:17:54.660
I can't put my finger on it, but something feels off.
00:17:59.880
So again, if you want to influence someone or want to get that cute girl to go out with
00:18:07.080
And again, we sort of know that, but be yourself.
00:18:09.500
But craft that story, craft, rehearse that thing you want to say so that it's very natural.
00:18:16.860
So Brett, you know, I gave a talk at TED Talk about 10 years ago.
00:18:31.240
I had people critique how it was standing, how it was moving.
00:18:36.040
All that was, you know, 10 months of writing and practicing and rehearsing.
00:18:47.360
But, you know, a lot of prep is necessary to really craft a great narrative.
00:18:53.060
So to tell a good story, you want to show authentic emotion.
00:18:58.940
But paradoxically, I think a lot of people think that in order to be authentic or sincere,
00:19:07.420
But in order to say what you really feel, you often have to intentionally practice it
00:19:12.160
to express, you know, what you want to express instead of offering, you know, sort of jumbles
00:19:19.520
So what else goes into an effective emerging producing story?
00:19:26.300
So kind of think of three things for listeners.
00:19:28.260
Just three things you can control that influence how much impact you will have on somebody.
00:19:32.480
That impact, again, could be just entertainment.
00:19:35.760
It could be buying a product if you're a salesperson.
00:19:43.700
I want this person to be relaxed, the person I want to interact with, right?
00:19:47.520
And so that means you've got to be relaxed, make sure they're comfortable.
00:19:50.780
They, you know, if you have a full bladder, that takes away neural bandwidth and you can't
00:19:54.380
listen to my story or my pitch, whatever it is.
00:20:06.800
Number two is think of structuring that content.
00:20:10.800
Have this tight structure with a hot open and have, if you want to influence someone,
00:20:17.020
And the third is how you deliver that content, right?
00:20:20.180
So deliver it, as I said earlier, with energy, with your own excitement about it so that you
00:20:28.680
So establish psychological safety, structure the content, and then deliver the content with
00:20:34.960
And that structure, I think the important thing you talked about, there has to be that sort
00:20:37.820
of tension where you think it's not going to be resolved, but then you do resolve it.
00:20:43.220
So again, for listeners, look at, just go online and pull up any old movie trailer, theatrical
00:20:51.860
And you'll see that those movie trailers introduce characters.
00:20:55.560
They put them in a weird situation where those characters don't know what to do.
00:21:03.100
And then they don't tell you what happens after the crisis.
00:21:05.340
You have to buy a ticket to go and watch that movie or stream that movie to find out what
00:21:10.940
That's a perfect structure for a call to action.
00:21:14.100
I don't want to resolve the conflict because now you have to pay to figure out what happens.
00:21:20.180
If it's just flat, Bob and Sue showed up, they went to their classes in college, and then
00:21:30.760
But they go to their classes, and then a bomb went off.
00:21:37.160
Okay, now, holy crap, maybe once in my life, a bomb will go off, and I'll use this information,
00:21:43.880
this story, so I can learn what to do in that situation.
00:21:51.500
But in the storytelling space, we want to actually create tension in other people.
00:21:57.440
From the listener's perspective, we want tension.
00:22:00.320
We're going to take a quick break for your words from our sponsors.
00:22:07.060
And what's interesting, this story arc that you can use to create tension and create those
00:22:11.720
peak immersive moments, you can do this when you're doing a sales pitch, and we can talk
00:22:16.820
about some of the things you do when you're teaching, and you have a chapter on that.
00:22:20.020
But you can do this with events, with physical things you're actually doing.
00:22:26.740
They do a great job of telling a story when you're going through an attraction.
00:22:31.700
Even when you're waiting in line, they're telling a story.
00:22:35.580
They're creating those narrative, those immersive moments, then it'll go down because you need
00:22:40.060
a break, and then it'll go back up, and then you go through the ride, and you have a completely
00:22:46.920
So if you think of the most famous rides at Disneyland or Disney World, like Space Mountain,
00:22:51.780
Space Mountain is just a roller coaster in the dark.
00:22:54.160
But it's wrapped around this amazing story of going to a space flight, and you're entering
00:22:59.820
into the space center, and you have to get on this ship.
00:23:02.960
And so, yeah, Disney was brilliant in wrapping the attraction around a story.
00:23:11.520
And we found that, on average, for the eight or nine rides we went on at Disneyland, that
00:23:17.000
they were the 98th percentile, averaging 98th percentile compared to all other live experiences
00:23:29.240
As you're queuing up, you have so many things to look at and listen to and hear and smell.
00:23:33.540
And so they really create this experience where, again, they're kind of warming you up for
00:23:40.940
So they're kind of, again, establishing that psychological safety.
00:23:47.120
So let's do this in our daily lives as much as possible.
00:23:49.780
Again, you don't want to just tell your family member or loved one, how's work today?
00:23:56.500
Well, that doesn't really tell your family member much.
00:24:01.580
And the most weirdest thing happened ever, a coyote walked into my office.
00:24:12.520
So, you know, think about giving people the information that is going to be most interesting
00:24:19.280
And when we're talking, when we have conversations just like this, you know, we wanted those
00:24:23.040
conversations to be interesting, engaging, immersive.
00:24:26.100
We want all those things to happen so that we learn something new.
00:24:29.220
And it's the new information that creates tension in a story.
00:24:33.020
As you were talking, it made me think about why Christmas is such an immersive holiday.
00:24:40.720
You've got, you know, of course, you get the nativity story.
00:24:45.020
And you have all these things that, you know, peak your immersion.
00:24:47.860
And then you get to Christmas Eve, you're counting down.
00:24:51.040
And you don't know, like when you're a kid, it's like, well, is Santa going to come or
00:24:54.820
And it's just, our brain's getting hammered with oxytocin during Christmas time.
00:24:59.420
And you have all those memories of the previous Christmases and all the amazing things that
00:25:06.740
And so, because the brain is so energy hungry, those memories actually influence our immersion
00:25:15.440
In other words, I'm actually kind of taking that immersion and putting it on steroids because
00:25:21.100
I have all these good experiences from the past that build up my immersion in the current
00:25:27.480
And that's why we want to repeat highly immersive experiences, whether it's dating that person
00:25:35.320
that you're crazy about, you want to see them over and over, whether it's going to Disneyland
00:25:41.920
I just mentioned I came back from South Africa.
00:25:46.080
The most amazing flight attendants who smiled, who just made my flight so interesting and nice
00:25:53.720
And you're just kind of beat up after all that time on airplanes and airports.
00:25:58.220
And yet, the people there made the experience so valuable for me.
00:26:03.540
How would you make the DMV experience more immersive with this information that you've
00:26:13.160
So, again, I want to establish psychological safety.
00:26:17.800
So, have a greeter out front, just like Walmart does.
00:26:28.560
First of all, just that alone will make my experience better.
00:26:32.260
And then second, tell me what's going to happen, right?
00:26:34.120
Give me that kind of journey, that narrative about the journey.
00:26:38.020
So, we're going to have you check in at Windows 7.
00:26:47.940
So, we should be out of here in about 20, 25 minutes.
00:26:52.220
If you have any questions, come talk to me anytime.
00:26:57.120
Now, the problem with the DMV, of course, is it's a government office.
00:26:59.500
And so, they don't have a profit incentive to keep me coming.
00:27:05.180
But, you know, think of how many stores you go in.
00:27:07.520
I was a store on Fifth Avenue in New York, Brett, I don't know, a couple years ago,
00:27:19.160
And literally, there were three salesmen standing there, you know, grab-assing with each other
00:27:27.980
Literally, one of the salespeople was like, you guys don't want to talk to me?
00:27:34.560
And one guy finally said, what are you looking for?
00:27:38.180
I mean, I had to beg them, as opposed to, hey, welcome to our store.
00:27:44.940
You know, we have some amazing new sport coats in.
00:27:49.880
All right, you're telling me a story now, right?
00:27:52.960
So, you know, really think about the best way to communicate as storytelling.
00:27:57.340
Okay, so with an event like the DMV, you don't necessarily have to create, like, a fantastical
00:28:02.160
story like at Disneyland, where you have a queue and you're going through some kind of
00:28:06.360
cool Star Wars expedition, because people would just be turned out like, oh my gosh,
00:28:11.380
But it's just, the story could be like, here's what's going to happen on your journey during
00:28:15.880
You're going to wait in line here and you're going to go there.
00:28:20.940
But how about every 50th customer, you're in a lottery for, I don't know, something awesome.
00:28:26.500
A free year of registration for your car, whatever.
00:28:31.220
Like, we want to actually make this, you know, we're going to gamify it.
00:28:34.220
So, gamification is really useful because it builds that tension.
00:28:40.720
Wouldn't that be great to have some kind of gamification at the DMV or any place?
00:28:45.000
I want to go back to this idea that this disconnect between us liking things and then us actually
00:28:52.940
And you did this, you found this with some Super Bowl commercial experiments you did.
00:28:56.300
So, you showed people Super Bowl commercials and asked them, what did you think about this
00:29:00.720
And what you guys found was people would say they liked this one commercial, but if you
00:29:06.100
actually looked at their data from their brain, they actually weren't responding to it.
00:29:10.480
So, what's going on when we say we like something, but our brain is saying, is not really paying
00:29:17.060
Like, why do we like things that we're not really emotionally resonant with?
00:29:24.120
And people lie not because they're malicious, usually because they're nice.
00:29:27.700
And we're asking them this impossible question.
00:29:36.220
So, when we started doing this work commercially, you know, I started getting that weird feeling
00:29:40.360
like, okay, I can do this in my lab, I can publish research, but if companies are paying
00:29:45.300
us a lot of money to help them create immersive experiences and measuring the experiences they've
00:29:50.220
already created, I want to make sure I'm really doing it right.
00:29:53.660
Yeah, so we started measuring Super Bowl commercials because we can measure this live.
00:29:57.740
We would go to a bar, we would arrange with a bar to, you know, have 50 people come in
00:30:02.840
and we'd buy them drinks and snacks and then measure the Super Bowl live while it's going.
00:30:08.800
And then also ask them, you know, which commercials?
00:30:10.940
We didn't care about the game, we care about the commercials, right?
00:30:13.360
This is, you know, the commercials are the apotheosis of advertising, right?
00:30:18.280
And those commercials are rated by USA Today newspaper every year.
00:30:24.400
And every year we have found a zero correlation between what people say they like in a commercial
00:30:33.280
Because things we like are things that are easy, things that are familiar.
00:30:39.000
We don't want to say stuff is awful generally, if you ask people like in a focus group.
00:30:44.620
Um, but there are a lot of commercials that are not really likable that really shake up
00:30:51.220
So, to me, the return on the investment of advertising is, I shook up your brain so much
00:30:59.360
So, now when you go to the store or go to the car dealer, you remember that experience.
00:31:04.360
Immersive experiences are saved in the brain in a very special way because they have high
00:31:10.820
So, if I want to shake up your brain deep in the unconscious parts, you don't have conscious
00:31:17.860
So, we like things that are easy, that are funny, that are whatever.
00:31:21.340
And by the way, it doesn't matter if they're funny, sad, you know, weird.
00:31:24.540
Some of the most immersive commercials are super weird.
00:31:28.520
And I don't know, they're just, they're like surprising.
00:31:31.600
So, generally, people value neurologically things that are similar to what they know, but a
00:31:41.000
We have genres we like, and I want to have more of that genre, but I also want a little
00:31:45.380
bit of new stuff added to it, but not too new, right?
00:31:47.860
If it's completely weird, then it's too far outside my general preferences.
00:31:52.280
Yeah, you talked about one commercial that people didn't say they liked.
00:31:58.520
But if you actually look at the data, it's the one they most responded to.
00:32:02.580
And it was like some woman just kind of dancing like Elaine Bennis, like sort of off kilter.
00:32:09.080
But that was the one that got the most response.
00:32:16.580
Yeah, some super tall, skinny woman dancing in this weird, awkward way.
00:32:21.860
It's shot with very asymmetrically against a yellow wall.
00:32:27.780
But it has a narrative structure, and it's like a car accident.
00:32:36.440
But again, I think that's the mistake that we make when we create content, is that people
00:32:42.180
Now, we do find that highly immersive experiences, when we ask people, are rated as enjoyable.
00:32:49.320
But enjoyable doesn't mean it's immersive, right?
00:32:51.680
If I like it, it doesn't mean that it shook up my brain.
00:32:55.480
I want to shake up your brain so you go, holy moly, I got to do this thing.
00:33:01.380
Well, and you also talk about this disconnect between liking and it resonating.
00:33:07.800
Like you talk about Pluto Nash, that Eddie Murphy movie in the 90s.
00:33:11.880
And what happens is these movies get made because they do focus groups.
00:33:19.140
And then the director and the producer start making changes based on what the focus group
00:33:26.540
They might like it, but they're not actually emotionally resonating with it.
00:33:37.560
So I think I quote in the book, I think Ridley Scott, some other directors who just ignore
00:33:44.920
You know, the classic example is, remember the movie Marley and Me from early 2000s?
00:33:52.800
They ask people about the movie, what they like, what they dislike.
00:33:57.380
Like the whole point of that movie is a dog at the end has to die.
00:33:59.920
Sorry, spoiler alert for people who haven't seen this 15-year-old movie.
00:34:02.640
So the dog has to die so the humans can take the lessons they learned from the dog and go
00:34:10.020
But if you're not a storyteller, if you don't understand structure, if you don't understand
00:34:14.120
why, you know, a movie has resonance emotionally, then of course you don't want the dog.
00:34:23.620
So again, I think asking naive people who are not experts, but even experts don't know, right?
00:34:29.420
Because we have this thing, Brad, I call the Freudian hangover, which is we think from this
00:34:36.080
coke addict Freud that if I just probe you the right way, I can make the unconscious conscious.
00:34:44.440
The unconscious part of your brain is probably 99% and it's largely not available to our consciousness.
00:34:50.840
So if I want to have you tell me about your unconscious emotional response to an experience,
00:35:00.100
It's like asking your liver how much it enjoyed your lunch today.
00:35:04.740
That's the same thing about asking, you know, let's ask your brainstem how much it has enjoyed
00:35:12.300
Yeah, and I think this disconnect can explain like why some movies become cult classics, right?
00:35:17.980
They might have come out and they bombed initially for whatever reason.
00:35:21.300
But because they immerse people into something, it has a long life, like I'm thinking like Christmas,
00:35:29.060
We're talking about Christmas, a Christmas story.
00:35:32.480
But now it's become this cult classic that everyone watches every Christmas and they have
00:35:37.080
memories about this movie, watching it as a child.
00:35:40.880
So you get that double whammy, you get the nostalgia, that memory effect.
00:35:48.540
So again, one of the factors that we found almost always is that shorter is better.
00:35:54.040
I'm not going to watch a Christmas story, you know, 40 times before Christmas.
00:36:01.160
So that time limited, you know, this is the operators are standing by now, right?
00:36:07.520
We're going to turn that tension into a decision and that decision has got to happen faster.
00:36:12.700
But yeah, with streaming, there's so many movies that are out there that, yeah, didn't
00:36:16.420
find an audience for whatever reason, they weren't marketed well or people just didn't
00:36:20.820
And then they're absolute classics and it's so great to have them.
00:36:24.980
But again, for listeners, you know, if you rewatch a movie, it gives you a great opportunity
00:36:29.320
to see the hooks they put in there to modulate your immersion.
00:36:34.100
And for long form storytelling, again, I don't want you to be at maximum immersion because
00:36:38.460
I just exhaust you and then you just want to quit.
00:36:41.000
I want to kind of have this sine wave pattern up and down, different storylines with different
00:36:47.120
And then generally those two or three storylines merging in the end into a big climax.
00:36:53.820
So again, you can learn from your favorite movies or favorite TV shows, you know, how
00:36:59.620
So Seinfeld, I think, was extraordinarily well written where there are almost always three
00:37:04.120
different storylines that at the end of that 22 minute episode converged into kind
00:37:10.760
And so, yeah, just for people interested, you know, watch a couple old Seinfelds and see
00:37:16.000
how they wrap these three stories together that modulate tension from high to low and
00:37:22.440
Well, let's talk about some applications of this immersion idea.
00:37:25.560
There's people who might be teaching in schools, but if you have a job, you might be doing
00:37:31.320
How can we use this immersion idea to help students recall information better?
00:37:43.360
So 20 minutes of maybe explaining what you're going to do and then 20 minutes of something
00:37:48.780
that's active, participatory, people working at their desks or tables.
00:37:55.940
So it's really the flipped classroom on steroids.
00:38:00.960
Accenture has found that breaks should be longer because I'm, again, exhausting those
00:38:06.520
So put a break in there so people can kind of refresh.
00:38:10.020
You can use things like movement together to get a class or a training session.
00:38:16.440
So stand up and we're going to all clap together.
00:38:22.160
So when you coordinate, you actually increase immersion because we're all moving the same
00:38:28.260
So brains will actually, physical movement will coordinate neurologic activity, which is super
00:38:38.200
So if you're not measuring immersion directly, look for those signs like shuffling feet, movement
00:38:44.320
in the seats that tell you that you're kind of losing people.
00:38:47.720
So when I give public lectures, I always listen for those kind of movements or look for those
00:38:57.400
So what I do when I'm speaking for, say, an hour is I put in what I call pivots.
00:39:00.960
If the audience is getting restless, I have a backup plan.
00:39:05.260
And I have actually every 20 minutes in a talk, I have a pivot that I may or may not
00:39:12.280
If the people are getting restless, then pivot into that.
00:39:18.860
I'll have props or I'll have things prepared so that I'm ready to continue to engage others.
00:39:25.720
The shortest answer actually is use multimedia.
00:39:29.280
So if I'm giving an hour talk, I'll probably show three to four videos to break it up.
00:39:35.040
So I'll show a short three or four minute video.
00:39:38.940
And then I'll go back and talk about that video.
00:39:43.560
If we have technology, talk, talk, talk, and then ask them to think about something or ask
00:39:54.540
What about, how can you use this immersion idea to be more persuasive, right?
00:39:58.040
Let's say there's a guy in sales making a sales pitch.
00:40:04.660
Second, really think about the outcome you want to get, right?
00:40:12.240
Not like, would you like to buy one of our products?
00:40:15.780
I looked at your company and I think our Nespresso coffee maker is going to be perfect for your
00:40:23.020
And then you can go through the history of how it was made and the technology and you
00:40:27.620
And then, you know, we made version one of the Nespresso.
00:40:39.780
And then they brought in this Italian engineer.
00:40:44.720
He actually created the most beautiful machine you've ever seen.
00:40:48.160
And this thing will make 5,000 cups of coffee in a row before you need to service it.
00:40:58.400
I'm just looking at my coffee maker in my office.
00:41:01.060
So, you know, it's really crafting that story and then getting to a point where, hey, 5,000
00:41:10.940
Take that a high immersion moment and then close the sale.
00:41:15.500
What we often do with storytelling is we resolve the tension and then we wait from a sales perspective.
00:41:21.640
What you want to do is when you've got high tension, that's when you want to make the
00:41:25.160
So you don't want to wait till that tension's dissipated.
00:41:30.580
Peak immersion moments last for maybe 20 to 30 seconds at most.
00:41:33.980
So you've got that small window where you've really captured that person emotionally.
00:41:37.940
That's when you want to ask them to do something.
00:41:40.340
What about, we've been kind of talking about this throughout our conversation, but just making,
00:41:43.640
using these ideas to make, to create more extraordinary experiences in our daily lives.
00:41:49.700
It could be just a social interaction we have with somebody.
00:41:54.140
What are some examples you've seen in your own life and in your research?
00:41:59.680
So one of the kind of motifs of the book or key takeaways is that once we train ourselves
00:42:05.740
to be deeply immersed in experiences, we open up a wealth of opportunities to have stronger
00:42:12.720
social connections, more influence on others, happier and longer lives.
00:42:19.280
So I really want to be connected to the humans around me.
00:42:23.460
I'm working very hard to be a human by really investing in relationships.
00:42:28.060
So we can do this by number one, the first step, being present, right?
00:42:37.040
I'm going to give you the gift of my full attention.
00:42:40.080
And then I want to be open and listening and absorbing what you're telling me, right?
00:42:46.200
I want that oxytocin effect to be really immersed.
00:42:48.960
And I want to share the emotions that you are expressing as you're talking to me, telling
00:42:55.960
So it's really training ourselves to be in the here and now and to be open to experiences.
00:43:02.520
And once we do that, gosh, at Starbucks or on the airplane, as I said, with a nice flight
00:43:08.180
attendant, amazing 15-hour flight person who was smiling the entire time.
00:43:13.980
Then I'm happier when I get off the plane and I see my family and I'm happier, right?
00:43:18.060
There's this, again, this sort of contagion effect in which it flows.
00:43:21.960
So it's really understanding that to flourish as human beings, we've got to connect to others
00:43:28.440
at a fundamentally deep level, at an immersion level.
00:43:31.680
And when we do that, we get better and better at it.
00:43:34.960
And even Martians like me can actually simulate being a human and actually having those full
00:43:41.200
emotional connections to the people who care about us.
00:43:44.840
Well, Paul, this has been a great conversation.
00:43:46.260
Where can people go to learn more about the book and your work?
00:43:48.320
You can go to getimmersion.com, immersion with an I, or pauljzack.com.
00:43:54.700
The book is Immersion, The Science of the Extraordinary and The Source of Happiness.
00:44:01.200
I want extraordinary experiences and I want to be happy.
00:44:03.680
So if you want those things, you'll get some lessons in the book.
00:44:12.200
It's available on amazon.com and bookstores everywhere.
00:44:14.720
You can find more information about his work at his website, pauljzack.
00:44:19.920
Also check out our show notes at aom.is slash immersion, where you can find links to resources,
00:44:32.840
Well, that wraps up another edition of the AOM Podcast.
00:44:35.900
Make sure to check out our website at artofmanliness.com, where you can find our podcast archives,
00:44:39.640
as well as thousands of articles that we've written over the years about pretty much anything
00:44:43.660
And if you haven't done so already, I'd appreciate it if you take one minute to give us your
00:44:50.460
Please consider sharing the show with a friend or family member who you think will get something
00:44:54.200
As always, thank you for the continued support.
00:44:57.620
Remind your time to listen to AOM Podcast, but put what you've heard into action.
00:45:03.460
Thank you for the freedom you've heard from your heart.