The Code They Killed For — Honor, Manhood, and the American Gunfighter
Episode Stats
Summary
When you picture a gunfighter, you probably think of a Hollywood cowboy. A jangling six-shooter on his hip, squaring off at high noon in a dusty frontier town. But gunfighters weren t just products of Hollywood. They were real men who lived and died by a code, one rooted in a particular sense of honor. My guest today is Brian Burrow, author of The Gunfighters: How Texas Made the West Wild.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
Brett McKay here, and welcome to another edition of the Art of Manliness podcast.
00:00:11.420
When you picture a gunfighter, you probably think of a Hollywood cowboy.
00:00:15.400
Spurs jangling, six-shooter on his hip, squaring off at high noon in a dusty frontier town.
00:00:20.420
But gunfighters weren't just products of Hollywood.
00:00:22.700
They were real men who lived and died by a code, one rooted in a particular sense of honor.
00:00:27.980
My guest today is Brian Burrow, author of The Gunfighters, How Texas Made the West Wild.
00:00:33.360
We dig into the true story behind America's gunfighting era, how it grew out of the South's dueling culture,
00:00:38.860
was intensified by the violence of post-Civil War Texas, and spread across the frontier via the cattle drive.
00:00:44.340
We explore why so many gunfights had less to do with crime and more to do with reputation,
00:00:48.460
why the Colt Revolver transformed personal conflict into deadly spectacle,
00:00:52.260
and how young men came to see violence as a right of manhood.
00:00:54.780
Along the way, Brian also explores how gunfighters went from frontier figures to pop culture icons,
00:01:00.160
and which films, in his view, captured their essence best.
00:01:03.560
After the show's over, check out our show notes at awim.is slash gunfighters.
00:01:25.320
So you recently published a book called The Gunfighters, How Texas Made the West Wild.
00:01:29.540
And this is all about the Old West gunfighter that you see in old westerns and TV shows.
00:01:36.540
I'm curious, why did you do a deep dive into the gunfighter?
00:01:44.240
This was a field of study, if you want to call it that,
00:01:48.240
that was probably at its high watermark 50, 60 years ago in the 60s and 70s.
00:01:54.520
And while there have been books on individual gunfighters, in fact, you know, there's a new Jesse James book pretty much every year,
00:02:02.900
I kind of felt like it had been quite a while since anyone had come in and really taken a fresh look at the entire subject,
00:02:09.520
the entire field, and tried to tell the whole story of this gunfighter era that took place in America on the frontier after the Civil War.
00:02:18.200
And I wasn't quite sure what I was going to say new, but I just felt like it was time to freshen up the cannon
00:02:27.020
and that I could take a big, I thought I could swing for the fences on this one.
00:02:31.020
And so I kind of did, it kind of went out over my skis a little bit to badly mix my metaphors.
00:02:36.160
And the reception, you know, as you know, has been very generous and very surprising.
00:02:40.880
Yeah, I think what you do in this book, I really appreciated this,
00:02:43.640
is you provide the context of why there was this period in American history where you had guys shooting at each other.
00:02:52.060
Let's talk about this, like what makes a gunfight a gunfight and like what makes a gunfighter a gunfighter?
00:02:57.340
Well, typically the way you would differentiate is a gunfighter is anyone, I think widely defined,
00:03:04.820
as anyone who had an exchange of gunfire on the American frontier that did not involve the military,
00:03:25.440
But having said that, it comes in every way, shape and form.
00:03:28.980
I guess the one thing that makes a gunfight a gunfight is if there is an exchange of gunfire as opposed to,
00:03:35.760
you know, for instance, Jesse James, most of the people he killed, he just executed.
00:03:39.340
So there is a difference between a murderer and a gunfighter, and I think generally that's pretty clear.
00:03:45.820
If you think about the classic gunfighter, look, most of us know about this from movies,
00:03:51.120
and the classic one that came up in Westerns in the middle of the last century was, you know,
00:03:57.180
two men standing alone in the middle of a sandy street in a small town, and then they draw and they shoot.
00:04:04.240
And while that's not unknown, I can maybe point to 10 or 15 actually like that.
00:04:13.620
In fact, Old West gunfights are not typically different in style from any gunfight today.
00:04:19.840
I can point to you gunfights on horseback, gunfights where one guy was laying down and the other was standing up.
00:04:26.420
I got one where one guy shot another while he was down in a well.
00:04:29.680
I mean, it just happened in every way, shape, or form, but the rarest was probably that classic two men squaring off.
00:04:38.420
Although, ironically, the one that I opened the book with and the first nationally recognized gunfight,
00:04:44.240
what really began to make the gunfighter a thing was very much that type of classic cliched gunfight,
00:04:53.000
In this case, it involved the famous gunfighter Wild Bill Hickok in his first nationally recognized gunfight in July of 65 in Springfield, Missouri.
00:05:02.440
And it was very much in the style of an old duel, like from the Old South, where they came together and, you know,
00:05:09.300
in the middle of the square in Springfield, Missouri, this fight was over a gambling dispute with townspeople lined up on both sides.
00:05:21.620
And shortly thereafter, an Eastern writer for a big magazine found out about this, wrote about it.
00:05:26.580
And it was really the first moment where Americans became aware, oh, not only are there people shooting each other out on the frontier,
00:05:35.060
but that this is – it somehow struck a chord.
00:05:37.780
Something in the American character that really – you know, at a time where people were shooting each other on the streets of Boston and Baltimore every night,
00:05:44.540
nobody cared other than it being a crime, this seemed to be something different.
00:05:49.720
And the gunfight, the frontier gunfight has fascinated Americans really for 160 years ever since.
00:05:56.220
I mean, we're still talking about this stuff 160 years later.
00:06:04.040
Well, one big challenge for me going into this, of course, is that how do you write a book about gunfighters when they're all over the place?
00:06:15.560
And most of these – you know, Jesse James has nothing to do with Billy the Kid, who has nothing to do with John Wesley Harden.
00:06:20.440
And so the first thing I did was demarcate my time.
00:06:23.580
So I grandly call what I dubbed the gunfighter era from July of 1865 until 1901 when Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid famously got on that freighter for South America.
00:06:35.660
The ending of the last brand name outlaw seemed like an appropriate place to end it.
00:06:40.360
And so then the question became, how do you tell that all as a single story?
00:06:44.740
And I think I found a way that I could actually hold it all together as one story.
00:06:50.620
And how many gunfights were there during that era, you think?
00:06:53.440
It would all depend on how you define gunfights.
00:06:59.120
I know Bill O'Neill, a well-known Texas historian.
00:07:02.940
In fact, I believe he was a state historian for a while.
00:07:04.780
I want to say he came up with like 580 what he called significant gunfights.
00:07:11.300
And again, very difficult to explain to you what significant is.
00:07:15.160
But in large part, they're the ones that made the newspapers and thus the history books and typically more than one newspaper suggesting some public interest.
00:07:23.240
So certainly things like the gunfight beside the O.K. Corral, starring Wyatt Earp, certainly anything involving Billy the Kid, John Wesley Harden.
00:07:31.980
In general, the notable gunfights, what I call marquee gunfights, are those that made more than one newspaper at the time.
00:07:39.720
Okay, so you mentioned that all these gunfights, they happened all over the place.
00:07:47.020
So your challenge was trying to figure out, okay, what is the connection?
00:07:50.680
And your connection that you found was Texas, where you live, your home state.
00:07:56.360
And what I took away from the book, Texas contributed several factors that gave rise to the gunfighter.
00:08:08.400
Let's talk about this cultural component of the gunfighter.
00:08:10.940
You talk about how they're developed after the Civil War, or even before the Civil War, this idea of Texan honor that developed out of Southern honor.
00:08:23.940
Tell us about the Southern honor code, and then how did that develop into the Texan honor code?
00:08:28.220
And then we can talk about how that led to the gunfighter.
00:08:31.100
When you're looking at a way to explain why all this happened, it's the only thing that I could figure out to do was to understand why it happened, why it happened there, and what were the factors that caused all these gunfights.
00:08:44.320
And I remember one of the first times it really hit me was in reading accounts of that first Hickok gunfight in 1865.
00:08:52.760
And, you know, they were ostensibly fighting over the other guys, took Bill Hickok's watch as a gambling debt, and Hickok wanted his watch back.
00:09:01.300
And later somebody said, why on earth would you kill a man over a watch?
00:09:04.300
And he said, I'm not killing a man over a watch.
00:09:10.020
I'd read stuff like that before in Western literature.
00:09:13.040
And I happened to be from the South, and I happened to be from Texas.
00:09:20.180
And just immediately I realized, well, when was the only time in American history before the gunfighters, after the Civil War, that a group of, you know, civilian men were famous for shooting each other?
00:09:32.260
And it was in the dueling culture in the antebellum South from the 1790s or so into the 1840s.
00:09:42.080
And what mattered to me was less the formal structure of the duel, because obviously we didn't have a ton of duels in the Old West, but rather the factors that caused it.
00:09:51.760
There's this thing that historians write an awful lot about in the antebellum South, and it's the male honor culture.
00:09:57.840
And that is, you know, it calls for things that you might expect, you know, to be brave and kind to women and kind to horses and such.
00:10:06.080
But the part that matters for our story is that any time that a Southern male in that time period was challenged, if he was told that he was ugly or his wife was ugly or his horse was ugly, you know, he had an opportunity and in many cases an obligation to respond with force, even deadly force.
00:10:26.720
And what you find as you, you know, follow that culture as it moves west with the South into Texas, Texas became, you know, another Southern state.
00:10:40.120
It was the only Southern state that had not one but two violent frontiers, the Mexican border, of course, but also we forget the Native American, the Comanche frontier, which split the state in half on a diagonal into the 1870s.
00:11:00.580
It was the Texans, the Texas Rangers, to be sure, who initially discovered and popularized the first Colt revolvers.
00:11:09.960
But it really wasn't until the 10 years after the Civil War, when Texas was engulfed with a rebellion against the federal government, that that type of hyper-violent ethos really rose to the fore, where it was just Texas was during Reconstruction.
00:11:26.860
And I think just about every academic study puts it this way, by far the most violent of the Southern states.
00:11:32.880
You can find academic analyses that will say that the decade of civilian violence in Texas after the war may have been the bloodiest period of civilian violence in American history.
00:11:44.320
And what I posit is that it made the Texan a little bit of a different animal.
00:11:50.320
If you go and look at the marquee gunfights out there, Brett, I'm saying 60, 70 percent of them involve a Texan in some way.
00:11:59.140
And what I had not understood, what confused me initially is, well, what were Texans doing having gunfights in Arizona, in New Mexico, in Wyoming, in Nebraska?
00:12:08.060
And that's when I discovered the thing that spread Texas culture and this Texas kind of hyper-violence across the frontier was the open-range cattle industry.
00:12:17.020
It was a business that began in Texas and that thrived in Texas after the war.
00:12:22.300
Texans pretty much had a monopoly on beef cow for a few years.
00:12:26.640
And what began to spread Texas cattle and Texas cattlemen, Texas cowboys, across the frontier, of course, was the need to get to northern markets.
00:12:34.380
It's when they began driving these cattle up the cattle trails, up the Chisholm Trail, most famously, into Kansas, which really became kind of the beginning of this gunfighter era when gunfighters began to get national attention.
00:12:49.500
But honing on this honor idea, I think this is very foreign for a lot of modern listeners.
00:12:56.460
Because, I mean, this idea of honor that these guys had in the South, and you see it somewhat in the North, not as much, but it really took hold in the South.
00:13:11.880
And if your reputation was somehow called into question, you had to defend it with violence.
00:13:17.800
And there's like a theory that the reason why the South has a particularly strong notion of honor, I think, was it Richard Nisbet, his book, The Culture of Honor?
00:13:27.860
Talked about how a lot of people in the South, they came from these shepherding cultures in Scotland.
00:13:37.800
With those who work around livestock, it's always been violent cultures, in part for the need to dissuade thieves.
00:13:44.820
And for whatever reasons, much of it becomes wrapped up in honor.
00:13:50.260
You can read so many explanations of why Southerners became obsessed with honor.
00:13:55.940
You know, a lot of historians seem to believe it has to have something with slavery.
00:13:59.000
You can read people that say it has, you know, has something to do with the heat.
00:14:03.100
I come down with the feeling that it basically arose from the planters class, the wealthiest class in the South, where we had something in the South that we never had in America,
00:14:13.740
which was the idle rich, an entire class of idle rich for whom black people, slaves, did most, if not all, of their work.
00:14:22.740
And so in a need to kind of differentiate themselves from those, you know, below them who worked,
00:14:29.480
they modeled themselves after the aristocrats of Europe, for whom honor had been sacrosanct for hundreds of years.
00:14:36.960
And that's kind of my feeling on how Southerners became obsessed with honor.
00:14:42.680
And, you know, it filtered down through the classes.
00:14:45.440
If you wanted to move up, you know, you needed to have honor.
00:14:48.780
And, you know, this happened in a world where not a lot of people had college degrees or educations that they could talk about or financial statements.
00:14:56.600
And in a world where everybody, you know, kind of looked the same, honor became the way you measured people, the way you measured men.
00:15:04.860
And as silly as it may sound to our ears today, if someone went up to you in New Orleans in 1844 and pinched your nose or called you ugly or made a remark about your children,
00:15:18.880
you know, you were expected to lash back in some way, shape or form.
00:15:23.100
And I think it was the development of that culture that migrated into something different,
00:15:29.280
something even more violent via Texas on the old West frontier.
00:15:33.240
Yeah, my take on it was the honor code in the South.
00:15:37.200
And again, you saw it somewhat in the North, but it was really pronounced in the South.
00:15:40.560
The way you protected your honor differed amongst classes.
00:15:44.280
So amongst the upper class in the South, you would follow the código duelo, like the dueling code.
00:15:51.740
And it was designed basically to prevent violence.
00:15:53.940
Like there's all these different, you know, protocols you went through.
00:15:56.300
You had a second, you tried to do some negotiation.
00:15:58.480
And then oftentimes you just show up and like shoot your pistol in the air and you called it good.
00:16:04.340
The lower class, they tended to just like, they didn't use weapons.
00:16:11.560
They would just oftentimes engage in like, they called it the rough and tumble.
00:16:14.980
I mean, I'm telling you, fight, fist fighting and wrestling back in those days was a different
00:16:20.460
I mean, you're talking about gouging out eyes and ripping people's mouths.
00:16:24.600
I mean, several states had to pass laws against eye gouging, if you can, if you can imagine.
00:16:29.900
Anyway, this whole honor thing seems to have come out of the Revolutionary War when American
00:16:34.760
officers kind of got close and personal with their British and French counterparts for whom
00:16:41.480
But it stopped in the North, as you point out, and most people believe that was about the Aaron
00:16:47.080
Burr-Alexander-Hamilton duel in Weehawka, New Jersey in 1803.
00:16:51.280
After that, duels all but disappear from the North.
00:16:55.020
And yet, they not only don't disappear in the South, they're all but embraced.
00:16:58.640
I mean, you can point to any number of known people, Andrew Jackson, Sam Houston, Abraham
00:17:04.080
Lincoln, who all either involved in duels, you know, shot people in duels, or in Lincoln's
00:17:12.120
Duels were not, like, I think we look back now and think, oh, that's kind of a lunatic
00:17:17.860
But if you look at the people who are engaged in duels, who, you know, put out public notices,
00:17:23.400
they were often politicians and people involved in public life for whom an assault on their
00:17:32.180
If you were an up-and-coming congressman in St. Louis and somebody, you know, talked bad
00:17:37.460
about you, I mean, you were challenging them to duel.
00:17:39.980
Missouri was, Missouri and St. Louis was kind of the northern boundary of all this.
00:17:45.240
I mean, for our listeners, if you want to see an example of, like, a lower class notion
00:17:49.500
of honor, like the rough and tumble that we were talking about, that wrestling, like,
00:17:52.620
no-holds-bar wrestling, there's a great scene in the Gangs of New York where the DiCaprio
00:17:57.940
character, who's from Ireland, he first meets Bill the Butcher, and there's, like, some
00:18:01.680
other, one of Bill the Butcher's heavies is there, and there's some sort of insult or
00:18:06.580
slight, and then they just immediately take off their coats and they start punching each
00:18:10.720
other, but then there's some, like, fish hooking and things like that.
00:18:12.640
I'm like, that's an old-school Civil War notion of honor amongst the working class.
00:18:24.380
Okay, so, and then this notion of honor, it moved to Texas.
00:18:27.560
And I think what happened in Texan, in this sort of notion of Texan honor, it got democratized,
00:18:34.460
It wasn't just, like, the aristocrats who were protecting their honor.
00:18:38.800
It was these guys who had herds who felt like they needed to maintain their reputation for
00:18:44.640
violence so people would just not mess with them.
00:18:46.540
And then you see this introduction of, you mentioned earlier, the Colt Revolver.
00:18:52.080
So there's a technological component to the gunfighter.
00:18:56.060
How did the Colt Revolver change the game in the Old West?
00:19:03.680
If you think of it, back in antebellum days when they would have duels, typically it would
00:19:10.440
So bang, the other guy goes bang, and then everybody takes 15 seconds to reload.
00:19:15.000
You can't exactly kill a lot of people in that way.
00:19:18.120
But when you had a six-shot revolver, you could do an awful lot of damage.
00:19:22.260
We sometimes forget that when Colt first, Colt was kind of a nobody, a rich kid out of Massachusetts
00:19:28.260
who was fascinated with tinkering and thought he could make a revolving gun.
00:19:34.060
But when it was introduced for the first time in, I want to say, 1837, it was a complete
00:19:37.900
In fact, five years later, Colt is out of business and no one's using revolvers.
00:19:43.060
And then out of nowhere, a young officer named Jack Hayes in the Texas Rangers, who spends
00:19:49.740
much of his time on the Comanche frontier fighting Native Americans, stumbles on a shipment of
00:19:55.080
them that was basically sitting in a warehouse.
00:19:58.020
It had initially been sent, I love this, to the Texas Navy back when Texas had a Navy as an
00:20:04.340
Jack Hayes took these revolvers, showed his men how to use them.
00:20:07.580
And famously, in 1844, at the Battle of Waller Creek, northwest of San Antonio, he was engaged
00:20:15.160
with his crew of, I want to say, 23, 24 guys against a group of Comanche that was set to
00:20:22.900
And for the first time, the Rangers charged into the Comanche, firing the revolvers.
00:20:27.560
And in the ensuing fight, 23, 24, Comanche were killed and only one Ranger.
00:20:34.040
And the great takeaway, quote, afterwards, years later, the chief who had been involved
00:20:39.360
there said, I shall never fight Jack Hayes again, for he has a bullet for every finger
00:20:46.120
And then how did the Colt change the game for gunfighters?
00:20:52.000
Well, first off, you don't notice a huge difference immediately, countrywide, until the years after
00:21:00.280
the Civil War, when you can talk about how the war influenced gunfighters and these people
00:21:07.640
doing this violence to each other out on the frontier.
00:21:10.180
And common sense tells you the war must have had something to do with it.
00:21:13.160
It's often been speculated that many of these gunfighters must have been suffering from
00:21:16.520
something like PTSD, which is compelling and probably correct, but it still has to remain
00:21:21.920
speculative because we don't have anybody at the time, you know, blaming, I'm sorry,
00:21:29.080
But what you can point to about the war influencing violence is that in 1865, 1866, something on
00:21:38.640
the order of 1.3 million handguns were auctioned or given away by the federal government after
00:21:45.200
the war. And so for the first time, what we call today is open carry.
00:21:50.080
Well, not unheard of before the war, you can find memoirs in which people say, oh, I saw a man
00:21:56.820
wearing a gun on his hip in Georgia in 1815. It happened. But what becomes clear is that after the
00:22:03.240
war in the 1860s, it becomes commonplace, such that people are just kind of stunned that men across
00:22:09.580
the South, across the frontier, are wearing pistols with no more thought than the way they used to
00:22:14.800
wear a necktie or their glasses. And one of my favorite memoirists out of Missouri, you know,
00:22:21.300
reference to that rough and tumble type of style says that that type of, you know, problem resolution
00:22:27.700
is gone now. People here handle handle such things with a pistol in a much quicker and more efficient
00:22:34.460
fashion. And that's really the dawn of the gunfighter era.
00:22:38.200
We're going to take a quick break for your words from our sponsors.
00:22:45.800
Okay. So you had this notion of honor instead of a duel with these elaborate procedures and
00:22:53.020
rituals. You just had guys who were like, let's just take care of it now. And they're all heavily
00:22:58.540
armed. They're all carrying pistols. Some guys had two pistols on them. It's just everyone was armed
00:23:04.020
in Texas and in the frontier. Pretty much. Another aspect or another way technology contributed to the
00:23:09.860
rise of the gunfighter was the telegraph and mass media. Tell us about that.
00:23:15.700
It's funny. I think most people that look at this think that gunfighting and gunfighters were somehow
00:23:21.440
a creation of the media, a creation of dime novels and pulp fiction. In fact, the gunfighter type
00:23:28.460
type violence that I'm writing about here and that we see in movies was very real. I think what
00:23:34.120
telegraphs and the media allowed is for the fascination with this phenomenon, which, by the
00:23:41.420
way, did not begin in the East. It begins in the communities where these things happen. You can read
00:23:46.340
it in the local newspapers. All the pulp fiction and dime novel writers did was pick up on something
00:23:53.200
that was initially very popular in the West. You can read one of my favorite stories about this.
00:23:59.300
It's from very early in the game when Mark Twain, as a young writer, went out to Nevada during the
00:24:05.660
Civil War to become a journalist. And on the way, on these stagecoaches, all anybody ever wanted to
00:24:12.000
talk about was a certain gunfighter, a guy named Jack Slade, who was a local legend. And that was months,
00:24:18.940
if not years, before anybody uttered his name back East. So I think that the media, and we see this
00:24:24.500
especially with Hickok's creation, you know, the media broadcast this legend, but they don't create
00:24:31.180
it. I think that's where a lot of cynics want to say they created it. And I would argue, no,
00:24:37.200
this was a genuine organic phenomena that they picked up because it fascinated Americans. For some
00:24:43.160
reason, and we can speculate why, you know, this type of behavior really struck a chord with Americans.
00:24:48.940
So there would still have been gunfighters, but I'm not sure they would have become the American
00:24:54.660
archetypes they did, if not for media. Why do you think it struck a chord with Americans at the time?
00:25:01.520
I think it has to do with the fact that the American West really became the American origin story.
00:25:09.140
You know, we can tell all the tales we want about George Washington and men in powdered wigs
00:25:13.900
beating the British. And that's clearly the actual origin story. But stylistically, and in terms of
00:25:20.000
values and behaviors that we might want to emulate, I'm not sure there was that many that people look to
00:25:26.840
the, the revolutionary war to find. Instead, I think when people think about American values,
00:25:33.540
when they think about the American dream, the American dream, as I define it, would be
00:25:39.260
the idea that any person, and certainly any man in America can rise from humble beginnings and chart
00:25:47.340
his own way. And nowhere was that more evident than on the frontier, where thousands of Americans went
00:25:53.980
out, you know, and pitched a dent on a patch of dirt and tried to make something of themselves.
00:25:59.700
And it made the frontier, I think, kind of a cradle for the American worship of individualism,
00:26:06.520
the idea that anyone can do it. And there's something about the gunfighter who's kind of
00:26:11.220
the ultimate individual, isn't he? You know, what's more, what is more of an equalizer than a gun
00:26:16.980
where a man who's four foot 11 could kill a man who's seven foot tall and a wrestler? The gunfighter
00:26:22.520
became kind of a symbol, one of many probably, but a symbol, an abiding symbol of American individualism
00:26:29.360
and of the American dream. That's my theory, at least.
00:26:32.180
Yeah. So these gunfights are happening organically. Back East, they picked up on it,
00:26:37.300
started writing about them in the paperbacks and the dime novels. And then the National Police
00:26:42.660
Gazette was a big place where all these stories were published. I'm curious, I've heard that,
00:26:49.340
kind of fast forwarding and looking at another area of American history related to crime and violence,
00:26:56.560
The Godfather, the movie The Godfather. I'm going a completely different stream here,
00:27:03.500
Some people speculate that the movie The Godfather influenced the mob, the actual mob. Like these
00:27:09.480
mobsters, they watch The Godfather and they're like, well, we got to act this way because that's
00:27:13.360
what it says in The Godfather. Do you come across anything like that where you see that with the
00:27:17.300
gunfighter? Like there's young men who are reading these dime novels and they're like, well, I got to,
00:27:21.240
I got to carry my gun this way or I got to do this so I can be like the gunfighters that I read
00:27:25.620
about on the National Police Gazette. I know way too much about The Godfather and you're exactly
00:27:30.500
right. I mean, the woods are so full of mafia guys, you know, back in the 80s, 90s who talked
00:27:37.080
about how, yeah, they, they needed to live that way. And you see exactly the same thing in the old
00:27:42.060
West. I can think of individual moments, for instance, Butch Cassidy in his second robbery in
00:27:48.020
Utah. And I want to say 1896, which was very late in the game on the frontier. He had a partner named
00:27:52.680
LZ Lay. And I can remember in the middle of this robbery when one of the guys that they were robbing
00:27:59.360
tried to make a move. LZ Lay said to him something like, don't pick up that gun or I'll fill your
00:28:04.660
belly full of hot lead. Like who talks like that? The fact is nobody talks like that. It's so clear
00:28:11.020
that he got that from Pulp Fiction. He got that from a dime novel. But you also see that from the very
00:28:16.800
beginning with the Texas cowboys who spread across the frontier, first to Kansas, but then to New
00:28:24.480
Mexico and beyond, you can find memoirs. I'm thinking of Teddy Blue Abbott, a famous cowboy
00:28:29.900
memoir. And he talks about how he was yearning to get to Kansas so he could shoot someone, so he could
00:28:36.800
prove his honor, so he could prove his manhood. You know, being involved in a gunfight was not
00:28:42.780
something in that time, in that place among those people that was something to be shied away from.
00:28:48.860
It was something, in fact, that a lot of young men attempting to prove who they were yearned for
00:28:55.660
and sought. And it's one way that, you know, when you look at the behavior of Texas cowboys
00:29:01.580
in the 1870s, especially, I mean, there's so many things where you're like, really? They shot him over
00:29:07.160
that. They shot him because he got jostled in a bar. They shot him because somebody, you know,
00:29:12.200
beat him at Go Fish. They're just silly things that caused gunfights. But if you take into this
00:29:19.020
the context that many young men wanted to prove their manhood with guns, some of those silly gunfights
00:29:25.620
make much more sense. Well, speaking of the cowboys, that was another factor that contributed to the rise
00:29:31.040
of the gunfighter. It was an economic factor. You see the rise of the Texas cowboy and the Texas
00:29:37.520
long, the longhorn, the steer. How did the cattle boom from Texas contribute to the gunfighter?
00:29:44.240
Well, the cattle boom took a Southern honor culture that had been already, you know, pumped up to pretty
00:29:51.480
new heights in Texas and added kind of the final block to the wall, if you will. And that is
00:29:58.720
the Texas cattle business, especially as expanded into new areas in the 1860s and 70s. So moved from
00:30:06.660
South Texas into much of the rest of the Texas, especially Central Texas, was legendarily violent
00:30:12.960
because this was open range cattle ranching. So no barbed wire fence. Cattle range free. You put a
00:30:20.520
brand on them. And when it was time to go to market, you went and rounded them up. Well, obviously that
00:30:25.180
made this industry especially prone to thievery, to theft of livestock. And so that's the reason why Texas
00:30:32.540
cattlemen, like generations of cattlemen before them, resorted to violence so readily. You know, often it
00:30:39.500
was hanging. And this, by the way, played out in a dozen of kind of feuds across Texas in the decade after
00:30:48.060
the Civil War, all of which dwarfed the body count of a feud like Hatfield and McCoy. This was, you know,
00:30:54.860
probably eight of the 10 worst feuds in American history were around the cattle industry in Texas.
00:30:59.580
And a lot of the violence was hanging, but much of it was also gunfights. And especially as those
00:31:06.460
behaviors spread across the West, that's how you explain Texas cattlemen in gunfights pretty much
00:31:13.020
everywhere you want to look in the West. And this is, this is why you say, you know, Texas made the
00:31:17.580
West wild. The cattle industry spread through what was an Indian territory up to Kansas, Abilene,
00:31:24.740
Dodge City. And that's why we had that famous gunfight in Arizona, the OK Corral. I mean,
00:31:29.860
that was basically... I mean, Texans practically colonized New Mexico, Texas cattlemen. When you look
00:31:36.560
at Arizona, I think Arizona went from, I want to say, 3,000 cattle in 1870 to 5 million in 1890.
00:31:43.020
And all those were brought in by Texans. It's funny, when you look at the outlaw gang that Wyatt Earp
00:31:49.700
fought against in Tombstone that led to the famous gunfight beside the OK Corral, they were known
00:31:56.560
as the Cowboys, usually spelled cow hyphen boys, except from below the border where they stole many of their
00:32:03.240
cattle. Mexican ranchers called them the Tejanos because so many of them were from Texas.
00:32:10.160
All right. So the rise of the gunfighter, we've got the honor culture that morphed into Texan honor
00:32:14.920
culture, the rise of the Colt Revolver, and then the cattle boom spread this violence across the
00:32:21.060
American West. Something else I was struck by in your book, a lot of the gunfighters you highlight
00:32:25.280
were gamblers. What was the connection? Why were so many gunfighters gamblers?
00:32:29.260
Well, first off, almost everybody in the Old West was a gambler because there wasn't much else to
00:32:35.100
do. Keep in mind, no TV, no internet, no radio, nothing much to do but sit around and talk and
00:32:43.080
drink and, oh yeah, play cards. So almost every main gunfighter I can think of, other than maybe
00:32:49.860
Jesse James, who is not really a gunfighter, but that's a story for another day, engaged in gambling
00:32:56.000
as a pastime and occasionally, you know, as their profession. And there you could cite Doc Holliday,
00:33:02.760
you could cite the Texan Ben Thompson and the Texan Luke Short as being kind of the three great
00:33:08.260
gambler gunfighters. But to raise a question that perplexed me at the beginning, which is if you start
00:33:13.200
to look at these marquee gunfights, you see a disturbing number of them involve arguments over
00:33:19.660
gambling, which just didn't make much sense to me. If you and I are sitting there playing five-card
00:33:23.780
draw, Brett, and I throw out two fives and you throw out two fours, well, it's pretty obvious I
00:33:28.640
won. What is there to argue about? And then I started reading the histories on gambling and it
00:33:33.080
turns out that gambling on the frontier was a little bit different today. And the reason it was so
00:33:38.900
violent, I came to believe, is that, well, two things. One, Americans finally figured out that most
00:33:46.860
gambling, certainly card-based gambling was fixed, that the people who did it professionally or did
00:33:53.520
it often knew how to cheat. This was thanks to a riverboat gambler who in the 1840s came out and
00:34:00.440
wrote a book about all the ways that gamblers could cheat and did. So everybody on the frontier
00:34:06.240
was on the lookout for cheating and cheating was endemic. And certainly any challenge of cheating,
00:34:13.200
and that's what an awful lot of the gambling-based arguments were about was you cheated. I'll, you
00:34:18.480
know, prove it. Well, here's a gun. But if you were, if you were challenged to cheating, that was an
00:34:24.200
acute challenge to your honor. And that led to a lot of gunfights, an awful lot of them. I mean, maybe,
00:34:30.080
I don't know, maybe 30, 40% of the gunfights that I write about seem to have something to do the
00:34:34.840
gambling. Yeah. It's called, I think it's called giving someone the lie. It's like when you cue someone
00:34:38.880
of a line. Ooh, I wish I knew, I wish I'd known that. That's a good line. Yeah. Let's talk about
00:34:43.120
some particular gunfighters that stood out to you. So a lot of these gunfighters, thanks to the,
00:34:47.600
the dime novels, the pulp newspapers, they had a lot of hype around them. Like, well, this guy killed
00:34:53.440
30 men and this guy killed 50. If you look at the actual numbers, most of them maybe killed one or two
00:34:59.140
guys. Some of them got up to the, you know, maybe five. Out of all the gunfighters you researched and
00:35:04.860
wrote about, which one actually lived up to the hype that they had? John Wesley Harden of Texas,
00:35:10.880
who of the, the, what I call the big five gunfighters, meaning the most famous, those
00:35:16.040
would be Wyatt Earp, Wild Bill Hickok, Billy the Kid, Jesse James, and the least known as John Wesley
00:35:21.360
Harden, who very much is a transition figure from kind of exclusively Texas violence to violence out
00:35:28.940
on the frontier. He was just another kid in rural Texas until he killed a black man in 1868 when he
00:35:39.380
was 15, an argument over a wrestling match, at which point he was obliged to become a fugitive.
00:35:46.320
And Harden, very much like Jesse James and many of the earliest gunfighters, was a diehard rebel
00:35:52.780
who felt like the South was being unjustly occupied and dominated by Northern troops. And so Harden,
00:36:00.920
you know, embarked on a career for six years where he kind of wandered Texas killing people. And
00:36:08.500
generally not for reasons he expected, almost always because of arguments and things that went
00:36:15.180
around. You know, Harden was the type of guy, if you said something wrong about Texas, he would shoot
00:36:19.800
you. I mean, he was literally a serial killer and he was almost certainly, by the dictionary
00:36:26.100
definition, a psychopath. He also embodies this spread of Texas violence because after killing and
00:36:33.840
he is credited between 24 and 42 killings. By the time he was 21, most before he was 18. And of course,
00:36:43.880
his most famous jaunt was the single cattle drive. He took up the Chisholm Trail to Abilene in 1871,
00:36:51.540
where he came face to face, but did not shoot while Bill Hickok, who silkily kind of disarmed him
00:36:57.440
before gunplay. But in the four months that Harden was in the Abilene area, I think Ike taught it up
00:37:04.160
that he killed, believably, eight men, five at once in a big gunfight out on the prairie with his
00:37:10.760
cousins. And the most famous of Harden's gunfights, which really was not a gunfight, was the one
00:37:16.480
where supposedly it was always said that he killed a man for snoring. And of course, for 150 years,
00:37:22.540
people have kind of rolled their eyes and said, oh, that's just a Texas myth. But the facts are he
00:37:26.700
was asleep or drunk in his hotel room there in Abilene at four in the morning. And he shot a man
00:37:32.760
in the next room through the wall with four gunshots. And, you know, they probably didn't get into an
00:37:38.780
argument since they were in separate rooms and couldn't see each other. I think, why else would
00:37:43.680
you shoot somebody through a hotel room wall than if they were snoring? So I'm prepared to believe it.
00:37:53.080
Johnny Ringo. He was very famous up until, let's say, the last 50 years. Like there were Johnny Ringo
00:38:00.060
television series in the 50s. There were Johnny Ringo movies during the 60s. He was kind of a second
00:38:06.820
tier gunman in Tombstone, best known, you know, as a gunfighter who had a particular animosity for
00:38:14.780
Doc Holliday. But beginning in the 70s, a series of researchers basically realized that not only was
00:38:22.980
he not a gunfighter, he had never been in a gunfight of any type. The only time we ever know,
00:38:28.080
understand that he actually fired a gun in anything like anger was once in a drunken argument with a
00:38:35.200
miner, in which I think the miner was winged. And the only other gunfighter he was ever in, he
00:38:39.760
was probably the one that killed him. In fact, we believe he committed suicide. You know, found dead
00:38:44.900
against a tree in the middle of nowhere. Wyatt Earp famously, years later, decades later, bragged that
00:38:49.540
he did it, but he didn't. And we now know that Johnny Ringo, and none of this was Johnny Ringo's fault.
00:38:56.160
You know, the Old West kind of disappeared from American conscience for about 30 years,
00:39:00.880
from the 1890s into the 1920s, when it was rediscovered famously by a magazine article in
00:39:07.740
which the writer's lead was, Who Remembers Billy the Kid? Which ignited this interest in gunfighters
00:39:14.700
and all manner of Western things. And that was really the beginning, and in some ways, the peak
00:39:20.000
of Ringo's fame. I mean, there were people that wrote in books that he was not only the greatest of
00:39:25.280
American gunfighters, but that he was a college man known for spouting stories in Latin, all of
00:39:31.940
which is purely made up by modern writers or writers from the 1920s. Poor Johnny Ringo was not
00:39:38.060
responsible for any of it. The runner-up, though, was probably Wild Bill Hickok, who, while he became
00:39:43.940
a gunfighter of note, when he first got all the attention as a result of that opening gunfight
00:39:49.020
there in Springfield, Missouri in 1869, the writer wrote with a straight face in Harper's Weekly,
00:39:55.800
you know, a notable magazine, that he had no doubt that Hickok had killed over 100 white men.
00:40:02.560
And by my count, the exact number at that point would appear to be two, although two men that he
00:40:09.060
wounded and one of them died, but they were killed by other people. So technicality. But even that is a
00:40:14.260
long way from 100. So that type of thing, you know, you see in three or four of these careers.
00:40:19.700
On the other hand, Brett, there's any number of gunfighters whose stories are even better than
00:40:25.300
we remember. You know, Hardin's is probably underappreciated solely as a source of, you know,
00:40:32.160
gunfighter mayhem. This is probably a morbid question, but after all your research, like which
00:40:37.540
gunfight was the most impressive, for lack of a better word? Well, you know, I mean, I hate to go
00:40:44.340
to the one everybody knows, but OK Corral is amazing. Eight men, it was initially 10, and several of them
00:40:51.840
backed away. And so it was four Earps versus three bad guys. So seven guys shooting from ranges from
00:40:58.660
five to 15 feet. And a gunfight that lasts 30 seconds, three guys end up getting killed. That was
00:41:05.120
pretty impressed. The other two crazy ones were one from California of all places during the gold rush
00:41:12.740
before the actual gunfighter era, but in kind of a manic prelude in which one guy on a mountain trail
00:41:19.660
with his sack of gold powder was ambushed by a bunch of bandits. And he killed 11 of them by himself
00:41:26.480
with a gun and then with a knife. But hands down, the craziest gunfight of all, I think, and I got to
00:41:33.220
give you the short version of this because the long is too great, was a group, a young Hispanic
00:41:39.520
deputy in New Mexico in 1884, in what's today the town of Reserve, way out on the Arizona border up at
00:41:48.420
altitude, had the temerity to arrest a drunken Texan for shooting his gun in the air. And the next morning
00:41:54.480
after he processed him through the courthouse, he came out and there was a crowd of 80,
00:41:58.740
8-0 Texas cowboys who worked at the ranches outside town, who chased him down. He took refuge
00:42:06.040
in an adobe hut and they kept him under gunfire, under siege for the next 36 hours. He ended up
00:42:13.600
killing four of them and he walked out unhurt in part because everyone only learned afterwards
00:42:18.940
that this little adobe hut had a false bottom and he was able to lay flat about 18 inch below ground
00:42:27.180
level. And these cowboys just kept shooting and shooting and shooting and every single shot went
00:42:31.140
over his head. And the young man's name was El Fago Baca and he went on to be tried and found
00:42:37.600
innocent twice of murder and went on to a long career in New Mexico as a politician and a sheriff
00:42:43.520
of note. So we've talked about the gunfighter era. When did it start drawing to a close?
00:42:48.380
You know, after the early 1880s, that's pretty much the peak of the gunfighter era. You certainly see
00:42:53.480
gun violence for another 20 years. But a lot of the craziest stuff from the early days begins to pass
00:43:00.740
and gunfights in the 1880s and 1890s tend to be much more about something, typically about fights
00:43:07.520
over the division of resources, whether it's cattlemen, you know, fighting farmers or fighting
00:43:13.260
sheep farmers. It more often becomes about something in those later years.
00:43:20.260
Not as much. I mean, you can certainly find gunfights that seem to be taking part for a
00:43:25.860
man's honor. But what you see much more often is, you know, big feuds over land. And, you know,
00:43:32.920
after 1901, there were certainly gunfights. I can name some. But what you find there is that
00:43:40.440
in terms of newsworthiness and cultural importance, frontier violence kind of gives way to a fascination
00:43:48.980
with frontier entertainment. So Western movies first, but also Western literature. I'm thinking
00:43:56.280
of the Virginia Owen Wester's 1901 book, certainly the rise of Remington and his sculpture. You know,
00:44:03.000
so I argue that, you know, it's in that decade, in those years, in the early part of the 20th
00:44:08.500
century, where Western violence begins to move from headlines to history. And so I think that's
00:44:15.360
Yeah. And then, as you said, the gunfighter kind of got forgotten a little bit, but then there was
00:44:21.100
this revival in the 20s. And it just seemed like for the next 30 years through the 1950s, I mean,
00:44:26.800
it just provided fodder for Hollywood for these stories where they're pumping out TV shows, radio shows,
00:44:33.720
comic books, movies. What do you think was going on there? Like, why this sudden uptick in the
00:44:39.840
interest in the Old West, and particularly the gunfighter?
00:44:42.720
Well, it's funny, because the gunfighter really wasn't a thing in the Old West. I mean, you could
00:44:47.760
read stories about gunfighters, but in terms of like dime novels and popular entertainments,
00:44:53.900
Indian fighters, even detectives, soldiers were much more popular stock figures than gunfighters.
00:45:04.720
Much bigger deal than Hickok. Or, you know, Billy the Kid became a household name, but he was the
00:45:09.040
rare gunfighter that at the time achieved true national fame. And much of that was just because
00:45:14.480
he had a stellar nickname. But it really wasn't until the 1920s that the gunfighter was introduced
00:45:20.860
in a serious way into American entertainment. But what took it to the next level was the introduction
00:45:26.460
of television around 1950, which suddenly out of nowhere had, you know, three or four networks
00:45:31.920
and a real need for what we call today original content, for original programming. And frankly,
00:45:38.660
a gunfighter show was stunningly cheap to make. You just needed a back lot with, you know,
00:45:44.660
some Old West buildings. And then it's what, you know, 10 white guys and some guns. I mean,
00:45:49.080
this is not expensive television to be made. And something like a third or 40% of every TV show on
00:45:57.620
in during the 50s, during the first 10 years of modern television was a Western and most of those
00:46:03.120
featured a gunfighter. But, you know, what really got good though, for those of us who were aficionados
00:46:08.960
was in the late 60s and early 70s with the introduction of Butch Casting and the Sundance
00:46:13.440
Kid in 69, it really introduced something like more realistic Westerns to Hollywood cinema. If
00:46:21.800
you look at the Westerns that came out from Hollywood from 69 for the next decade, I'm thinking
00:46:26.860
about the, you know, Peckinpah's Wild Bunch, McCabe and Mrs. Miller with, wasn't that Warren Beatty? I
00:46:32.440
mean, suddenly, you know, we lost kind of the glamour and the glitz and the, you know, singing to
00:46:39.420
damsels in the moonlight and got something that was gritty and dirty and nasty and bloody.
00:46:45.400
And that, those are the movies I think that, that have fueled to the extent that gunfighters have
00:46:51.120
continued to be a thing. I think much of it was because of those movies more even than 50s era
00:46:56.960
television. Having said all that, and with apologies to Taylor Sheridan and Yellowstone and all that,
00:47:02.160
you know, the gunfighter is just not what it used to be. A lot of the adventures,
00:47:06.780
a lot of the narratives that used to star gunfighters now are set not in the Old West, but in outer
00:47:12.400
space. And, you know, it's, it's a shame. There's still a Hickok or a Billy the Kid movie every five
00:47:18.280
or 10 years. And sadly, they no longer really attract the best and brightest. A lot of them just go
00:47:23.480
kind of what we used to call straight to video. What do you think is the best movie that depicts a
00:47:28.740
Old West gunfight? Ooh, you're killing me here. There's so many. I mean, I like Butch Cassidy and
00:47:35.840
the Sundance Kid a lot. It's closer to reality than a lot of people want to believe. The Wild Bunch
00:47:40.080
has to stand out because it was not only the most violent, but people forget it was the first most
00:47:46.880
violent, you know, and it was the first over the top violent Western. I think today, you know,
00:47:53.140
just thinking about movies made in the last 40 years, it's hard not to nod toward the Kurt Russell
00:47:59.760
Tombstone from 93, which people just seem to love. And with the passing of Val Kilmer earlier this
00:48:06.300
year has kind of been rediscovered for a lot of people. I watched that again the other day.
00:48:11.500
And some of the performances in that movie from Powers Booth as Curly Bill Brocious to Michael
00:48:16.960
Bean as Johnny Ringo are just really wonderful. But even though Val Kilmer, of course, steals it,
00:48:24.620
are just really wonderful. And yesterday, I just watched the movie that it went up against,
00:48:29.060
which was the Kevin Costner, Wyatt Earp movie, which put me to sleep then and pretty much put
00:48:34.980
me to sleep again the other day. How do you make a boring Wyatt Earp movie? Well, they pretty much
00:48:39.440
did. Yeah. I remember when I saw Wyatt Earp when it first came out of the movie, I fell asleep in
00:48:42.860
the movie theater. There you go. One movie that I remember, you mentioned it, and it's not very good,
00:48:48.020
but I remember when I watched this when I was, I don't know why I was watching this because it was
00:48:52.140
rated R. I was like nine or 10. But back then, my dad didn't care. He was like, well,
00:48:56.180
you know, he just watched HBO. And if you decide to watch with him, he'd just let you watch a rated
00:49:01.100
R movie. Young Guns. I, for some reason, I watched that movie and I became fascinated with Billy the
00:49:05.880
Kid after I watched Young Guns, but it's pretty cheesy. You know, but it's not cartoonish. Yeah,
00:49:12.200
the facts don't really, I mean, it's, it's, it's what the best thing you could say about it is it's two
00:49:17.800
or three cuts above Young Guns 2. And the one thing that I appreciate about it, watching it,
00:49:23.020
is that Emilio Estevez's portrayal of Billy is, is someone who's not totally stable.
00:49:29.120
And that is a sense that you get about Billy, that he was not entirely stable. And I thought
00:49:34.900
more than a lot of, um, Billy the Kid movies, he brought that out. Well, Brian, this has been a
00:49:40.760
great conversation. Where can people go to learn more about the book in your work? Oh, golly. You
00:49:44.660
know, I, this is my eighth book. It's called The Gunfighters. It's available on Amazon and in pretty
00:49:48.800
much all bookstores now. It's the first one I've written about the old West. It's the third I've
00:49:52.980
written about Texas. I wrote it for people who don't know much about the old West, but we're
00:49:57.940
looking for one book that would kind of not only introduce them to a lot of these characters,
00:50:02.960
but would really fill in in footnotes and elsewhere with other books where you can go to read, you know,
00:50:08.160
if you want the best books about Billy the Kid, the best books about Wyatt Earp and such, you know,
00:50:12.860
I made a point to point to other people's work here too.
00:50:16.680
It has. Well, Brian Burrell, thanks for time. It's been a pleasure.
00:50:21.380
My guest here is Brian Burrell. He's the author of the book, The Gunfighters,
00:50:24.040
How Texas Made the West Wild. It's available on amazon.com and bookstores everywhere.
00:50:28.140
Check out our show notes at aom.is slash gunfighters where you find links to resources
00:50:31.860
where you delve deeper into this topic. Well, that wraps up another edition of the
00:50:42.460
AOM podcast. Make sure to check out our website at artofmanlies.com where you find our podcast
00:50:46.240
archives and make sure to sign up for a new substack newsletter. It's called Dying Breed.
00:50:50.580
You can sign up at dyingbreed.net. It's a great way to support the show directly. As always,
00:50:55.780
thank you for the continued support. Until next time, it's Brett McKay. Remind us how
00:50:58.400
the listening podcast would put what you've heard into action.