The Fascinating Differences Between Male and Female Friendships
Episode Stats
Words per minute
168.07864
Harmful content
Misogyny
93
sentences flagged
Hate speech
49
sentences flagged
Summary
Dr. Jamie Krims, who runs UCLA s Social Minds Lab, has a lot of interesting insights about how and why men and women approach friendship differently. She explains why men have a greater tolerance for their friends flaws than women do, why men want to be friends with each other, and how each sex experiences friendship jealousy.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
We're at McKay here, and welcome to another edition of the Art of Manliness podcast.
00:00:11.360
Friendships are a central part of the lives of both men and women.
00:00:14.360
But from personal observation, you probably noticed the dynamics of male and female friendships
00:00:19.660
You may not, however, have been able to articulate what those differences are or have known what's
00:00:24.380
While there's still a lot of facets of friendship that haven't yet been researched, Dr. Jamie
00:00:27.920
Krims, who runs UCLA's Social Minds Lab, has a lot of interesting insights about what
00:00:32.160
we do know about how and why men and women approach friendship differently.
00:00:36.200
Today on the show, she explains why men and women form friendships and the differences
00:00:39.280
in the size and nature of their social circles, how long their friendships last, and what they
00:00:45.020
We also discuss why men have a greater tolerance for their friends flaws than women do, why
0.69
00:00:49.140
men and women would want to be friends with each other, and how each sex experiences friendship
00:00:54.340
After the show's over, check out our show notes at awim.is slash Krims.
00:01:15.140
So you are a social psychologist who researches friendship, but you do it through an evolutionary
00:01:23.080
Well, I studied classical archaeology and translated Latin.
00:01:34.120
And then I let myself get bored and found books by Steven Pinker.
00:01:41.840
Other people think about the world and the mind like this.
00:01:44.660
And I came to evolutionary psychology, worked in Rob Kurzban's lab at Penn, Robin Dunbar's
00:01:52.800
lab at Oxford, and Newberg and Kenrick's at ASU.
00:01:56.900
And I thought, this is the way to make the world make sense.
00:02:01.180
As for what I study, it's in part because two of my best friends had a 26-page, two-hour
00:02:14.660
And I found it because one of them was a moron and did it on my computer.
00:02:18.400
So I wanted to understand friendship dynamics for quite some time.
00:02:23.440
Yeah, friendship dynamics amongst women, particularly.
0.99
00:02:25.880
A lot of your studies are on what friendship dynamics look like with women.
0.93
00:02:28.420
But you also, in the process, look at how it differs from men.
00:02:32.140
That whole thing about finding the G-chat, about how your friends hated you.
00:02:37.540
If you have a sister, you probably encountered this as well.
00:02:40.200
I remember growing up, my sister, something like that happened.
00:02:43.400
She found out that this girl that she thought was her friend was just dogging her.
00:02:54.340
My friend that I was on the phone with, I was crying to her.
00:02:56.860
She couldn't understand a damn word I was saying.
00:03:01.520
Oh, you know, like their parents never loved them.
00:03:09.000
And so, yeah, thanks to them, I get to work at UCLA.
00:03:13.300
Okay, so I want to talk about your research on how men and women socialize and form and manage friendships.
00:03:20.660
And from an evolutionary perspective, why do men form friendships?
00:03:27.220
So I don't think that we can really pull apart why men and women do these.
00:03:36.760
So the function of friendship seems to be about social insurance, and that's for both men and women.
00:03:47.140
So John Tooby and Lita Cosmides have a really great idea that friendships solve the problem
00:03:54.520
of accessing resources and other support when people are most in need.
00:03:59.640
So if I asked you, Brett, you're a bank, you have some money to invest in, one person.
00:04:07.060
Would you rather invest that money in sort of a Ryan Gosling in the beginning of the notebook
00:04:13.340
or a slick, suited, rich Ryan Gosling in crazy, stupid love?
00:04:19.640
The rich guy, the slick, that's what I'd probably invest in.
00:04:24.500
And so the paradox is that people in need often don't get what they need, right?
00:04:29.100
Banks invest in the rich folks, and people invest in those likely to repay it or reciprocate.
00:04:37.880
But we need help when we're in need, and friendships might be the way that we solve this problem.
00:04:44.940
These relationships where another person has a stake in my continued welfare means that
00:04:50.680
when I am in need, they'll invest in me, and so I survive helping them when they eventually
00:04:59.100
Because I have a stake in their continued welfare.
00:05:04.500
So it's when you're most in need of help, people are least inclined to want to invest
00:05:09.060
in you because people want a relationship that's more benefit than cost.
00:05:13.820
But if you already proved yourself to be a valuable friend, then people, they'll stick with you
00:05:17.660
because they see value in continuing the relationship.
00:05:23.640
All right, so friendship builds our credit for hard times.
00:05:28.640
Like, why not just rely on grandma and grandpa and aunts and uncles and cousins?
00:05:34.240
Some people do think that friends act like family.
00:05:37.260
A related explanation, the alliance hypothesis of friendship, suggests that it's more about
00:05:45.780
So on this view, friendship is in part the output of cognitive mechanisms designed to
00:05:50.960
assemble support for future agonistic conflicts and fights.
00:05:54.220
And so in a conflict between two of my friends, I should preferentially support the friend who's
00:06:00.180
more likely to support me in the future, helping that person win their conflict and survive to
00:06:07.260
Whereas our siblings might be around to do that, our parents and our grandparents will eventually
00:06:16.340
So we might need to generate more kin, generate more other folks who have a stake in our welfare,
00:06:23.440
who are going to maybe be at the same life stage as us and live longer than our elderly kin.
00:06:37.900
There's some idea that women's friends act as sort of kin replacement, given a long history
1.00
00:06:48.140
Women left their community and married someone else and went to that community.
0.99
00:06:53.440
And so being without family, women really needed to replace those kin.
1.00
00:06:59.920
And that might be why their friendships are so close.
00:07:03.180
By contrast, men may have been sort of co-fighters in intergroup warfare and group defense.
00:07:13.820
But even then, friends can act and probably do act as social insurance.
00:07:20.720
Among hunter-foragers in South America, for example, illness, injury, it's inevitable.
00:07:27.760
And it would have been in our evolutionary history.
00:07:30.420
And so you can imagine that looking at these folks, when they do get ill and injured, they
00:07:37.000
They're less likely to die if they have good friends.
00:07:41.180
So generally, what social psychology has found is that women's relationships or friendships,
0.50
00:07:52.400
Men's friendship networks tend to be they're larger and they're looser.
00:08:00.840
Why the difference between how those friendships manifest themselves?
00:08:03.780
Yeah, so you'll hear me say this a lot, but we don't have a good answer to this.
00:08:12.320
It could have to do with the function of what men's friends do versus what women's friends
00:08:22.140
They help one another in intergroup warfare and group defense.
00:08:29.400
Women's friends tend to be more along the lines of alloparents.
1.00
00:08:41.300
Part of it could just have to do with function and the time constraints of group structure.
00:08:47.120
So because women spend so much time or maybe have to spend so much time creating any one
1.00
00:08:54.820
friend and investing in those really close and, like you said, dyadic, intense relationships,
00:09:01.120
they don't necessarily have time to spend on a lot of other friends.
00:09:06.540
So it could be that the way that women's friendships work, being close and dyadic like that, force the
1.00
00:09:13.740
fact that they can only have so many friends, whereas men are allowed to put more eggs in
0.66
00:09:20.780
So just to recap there, men have that looser, larger, they want a lot of friends who are
00:09:26.280
It's the intensity of the relationship is not going to be as much as women who prefer the
00:09:31.580
close-dyadic relationship because women are looking for an alloparent.
0.86
00:09:34.920
And I think it makes sense if you argue, okay, well, the reason why men form these clubs or
00:09:39.220
gangs or coalitions, if it's to fight and war, if one buddy dies or gets eaten by a saber-toothed
00:09:45.560
tiger, it's like, well, I can just replace them with another guy who can do the job.
00:09:49.000
If a female friend, like an alloparent, you're trying to replace your kin, if that person goes
1.00
00:09:54.020
away, that's a problem because you can't, it's hard to replace.
00:09:57.560
Not only is that person hard to replace because you must have built up a lot of trust to put,
00:10:03.020
you know, this tiny packet of your genes that we call our offspring in their hands.
00:10:08.640
They can also be dangerous to replace if you lose them, not through death.
00:10:13.960
So because women's friendships are so intense and emotionally open and so on,
0.92
00:10:21.780
Much more than men do, we talk about people we don't like, what we don't like,
00:10:28.520
And that information can be ammo for the friend that we told.
00:10:32.920
And that could be very dangerous if the friendship ends as well.
00:10:36.180
So it's kind of like you're afraid that they're going to blackmail you.
00:10:38.380
Like you, you got information on them and they got information on you and you want to
00:10:41.820
keep the relationship together because you don't want them talking about you if it goes south.
00:10:47.920
And that honestly, that's kind of a difficult situation to be in because for women,
1.00
00:10:52.420
this kind of self-disclosure is almost required to ratchet up the closeness of the relationship.
00:10:58.520
And then if the relationship dies, that same self-disclosure can come back to bite them.
00:11:10.540
For women, is there a greater benefit than cost in female friendships?
1.00
00:11:15.780
Like, is it worth it to have female friends?
1.00
00:11:21.700
She'd marshal the evidence and say, nah, I don't think so.
00:11:24.540
She'd say that female friendships are probably on average costlier than beneficial and costlier
1.00
00:11:35.580
I think that there can be a lot of benefits from female-female friendships, protection against
1.00
00:11:41.460
predators, protection against male coercion, advice and guidance, especially in friendships
00:11:47.340
where two women are not necessarily at the same life stage.
00:11:51.260
And we don't really study those friendships very much.
00:11:54.840
So I do think that there are benefits, but I could just be blinded by the fact that my
00:12:02.900
Let's talk about some of the other differences between men's and women's friendships.
00:12:09.700
Are there any differences between men and women in how long their friendships last?
00:12:15.140
So the data right now suggests that women's friendships or really girls' friendships are
00:12:24.820
We don't know what this looks like across the lifespan.
00:12:29.020
It could be that, you know, your adult wife's friendships are going to be just as long-lasting
0.97
00:12:36.160
But in girlhood, she would have experienced more best friends than you did.
00:12:40.340
We also don't know what this looks like across cultures.
00:12:44.140
And we also don't know the average time to unfriend, right?
00:12:50.080
We don't have sort of a survival analysis of male and female friendships or cross-sex friendships.
00:12:56.280
But what I can tell you is that if you ask a room of even awkward scientists, tell me about
00:13:02.380
a time that you lost a friend, all of the women's hands shoot up and they want to tell you about
0.98
00:13:08.040
this acrimonious split they had and this horrible person that they're no longer friends with.
00:13:13.060
And the men sort of act like dogs hearing a high-pitched noise.
00:13:21.420
So there does seem to be a difference even in how people, at least in my generation and
00:13:27.700
those folks older than I am, have experienced friendship loss.
00:13:32.840
Because when I look at my own life, I can't think of any friends that I've lost because
00:13:40.700
Like, you know, we moved or, you know, we just, our lives went in different directions
00:13:48.520
When I talk to women I know, they've all got stories of like, oh, this is this, I had this
0.92
00:13:53.620
roommate and she did this and we were best friends, but we're no longer best friends anymore.
00:14:03.560
That is something that might affect both men's and women's friendships and the ability to
00:14:09.260
And so that's interesting to hear that that's really what did some of your friendships in.
00:14:13.580
Yeah, I would say that's what did most of them in.
00:14:18.320
What are the theories of why do, with the research we've done, I guess it's just been
00:14:23.960
And why do their relationship tend to be shorter lived than men's friendship?
00:14:31.460
So there's sort of these paradoxes in female friendship the way that I see it.
0.86
00:14:36.560
One paradox is that female-female friendships are at once like the paradigm of friendships.
0.92
00:14:43.240
Girls are so close and emotionally intense and open and affectionate with one another.
00:14:49.980
Versus other folks say female-female friendships are actually an impossibility.
1.00
00:14:55.860
There's so much, they're rife with actual envy and jealousy and hatred that they can't
00:15:03.300
The second paradigm is that they are so emotionally intense and close and open.
00:15:08.580
But we also know from the data that they're fragile and shorter lived.
00:15:11.980
The third is that they seem to be strictly egalitarian.
00:15:15.800
There are these rules and friendships among women that, or at least girls, that you really
0.99
00:15:27.180
So they're strictly egalitarian and non-competitive.
00:15:31.120
But in reality, there's a lot of competition going on there.
00:15:35.420
I mean, the term relational aggression, which some people often use as indirect aggression
00:15:40.320
or social aggression, was really coined to be able to characterize the kinds of aggression
00:15:46.380
that takes place characteristically in female-female relationships.
1.00
00:15:50.380
So it could be that they are unable to tolerate the sort of everyday issues in friendships, the
00:16:00.380
turbulence that men are more likely to look at and either not be bothered by or reconcile
00:16:08.240
And in fact, there's some really cool evidence suggesting that male-male friendships are more
00:16:12.940
likely to experience issues and get back together than female-female friendships.
0.55
00:16:18.220
As to why that happens, again, the best idea that we have right now is that insofar as women's
0.97
00:16:28.140
friendships need great trust because of a long history of evolutionary functionality of
00:16:34.300
alloparenting, so we have to really trust this person to be able to take care of our
00:16:39.260
offspring and our future offspring, we don't brook any turbulence.
00:16:45.460
Whereas among men, you know, yeah, he might be a dick.
00:16:50.040
Yeah, he might have, you know, run over my bike.
00:16:53.180
But in the end, more is better than fewer because we might have to come up against this other
00:17:00.220
Yeah, speaking to the tolerance that men have for their friends, for their just their foibles
00:17:05.160
and the intolerance that women have, I think Joyce Benenson did a study on roommates and
1.00
00:17:11.020
she found that men and men roommates, they just tolerate each other.
00:17:15.480
Yeah, the guy ate my Cheerios and I was pissed for a little bit, but then I just got over it.
00:17:22.320
Women, they've got a bigger problem with that.
1.00
00:17:24.880
Yeah, the emotional reactions there kind of suggest that women often see other women,
00:17:32.840
even their friends when things go awry, as the other woman's mere existence is costly.
1.00
00:17:40.140
And I think Joyce would trace this back to a sort of behavioral ecology idea in our primate
00:17:46.020
ancestors that every extra female added to the group could, you know, take my mate, could mean
00:17:51.980
that I'm carrying this infant and now I have to walk further for food, they're costly to me.
00:17:57.920
Whereas every extra guy added to the group doesn't cost other men in the same way and provides a
00:18:08.340
So women, I mean, tell me if I'm wrong on this, women, even their best friends, women might still
0.92
00:18:15.380
Absolutely, at least in the women that we've studied, right?
0.86
00:18:20.640
So that's typically college students and then in developmental psychology.
00:18:26.360
When we talk about men's and women's friendships, you know, we can compare men and women, we can
00:18:31.240
compare some women to other women and some men to other men, but all of this relies on having
00:18:37.840
One of the problems in this area of research is that we have a lot of good data from girls
0.99
00:18:43.380
and boys because people are interested in studying friendships in girls and boys.
00:18:49.440
But as soon as girls and boys grow up, they hit puberty and they can have romantic relationships.
00:18:54.880
It's as if researchers flee for the romantic relationship hills and just want to study those
00:19:01.360
So we don't have great data beyond some young adults and certainly not in, say, mothers or
00:19:10.080
We're starting to get them, but we don't have great data on male-male, female-female friendships
0.95
00:19:15.940
across the lifespan for me to actually tell you this is what's going on.
00:19:21.440
It would be interesting to get that data because I think you could theorize that maybe some of
00:19:26.780
the conflict among college-age women underlying that, even unconsciously, could be competition
1.00
00:19:33.600
And then later in life, when each person is married, each secured their mate, maybe friendship
00:19:41.500
So are there studies being done on that today, like looking at friendships, how they change
00:19:47.860
So, I mean, if you went to the big social psych conference of any talk about a relationship,
00:19:55.120
seven out of 10, they're going to be about romantic relationships.
00:19:58.440
Fewer than one out of 10, on average, is going to be about friendships.
00:20:06.700
We've developed the UCLA Center for Friendship Research.
00:20:10.620
There are multiple faculty that want to understand friendship and solve the problems of friendship,
00:20:21.480
Not nearly as well-studied as you'd imagine it would be, certainly.
00:20:24.580
Do men and women today look for different things in potential friends, and what would evolutionary
00:20:34.840
So a lot like the research on mating or romantic relationships, we often talk about the things
00:20:43.820
I should emphasize the fact that the biggies, the things that everybody wants in friends,
1.00
00:20:53.780
I'll also note that in my lab, we've actually figured out that that doesn't hold the way
00:21:00.640
So we want our friends to be really kind, right?
00:21:04.260
And we don't want our friends to be mean, right?
00:21:08.640
We want our friends to be really kind to us, less kind to other people than they are to
00:21:15.020
And sometimes we even want our friends to be more vicious than they are kind when they're
00:21:25.380
But at the same time, yeah, men and women also face some sex-specific challenges.
00:21:30.660
And to the extent that their same-sex friends help them solve those challenges, then men
0.86
00:21:36.900
and women should look for different things.
1.00
00:21:39.260
So what we've found is that women tend to look for friends who provide emotional support,
00:21:48.700
They also tend to rate intrinsic traits, like being supportive, trustworthy, and respectful
00:21:57.840
Whereas men tend to prioritize male friends' physical formidability, high status, and wealth.
00:22:04.700
Their sort of wingmanship or ability to afford access to potential mates as really important
00:22:12.220
And they also rate instrumental traits more highly than women do.
0.72
00:22:15.940
Traits like being able to provide material benefits.
00:22:21.540
Dudes with skills, with high status that can help them out.
00:22:24.760
So hunter-gatherers wanted male allies who were big and strong.
00:22:29.000
Men today still respect strength in each other.
00:22:31.180
But today, you know, guys want to be friends with a guy who can help them fix their car.
00:22:35.980
Or maybe they have a large professional network.
00:22:38.820
You know, maybe they can help you find a job, start a business, meet women, etc.
00:22:42.720
And there's some preliminary data that suggests that even the way that men and women use their
00:22:50.820
So women will use their best friend as a study buddy, as a wing woman, as a you name the challenge,
1.00
00:22:58.840
they're going to take their best friend with them.
00:23:03.760
They have one guy for studying, one guy for wingman, one guy for the basketball game.
00:23:14.880
But I've got, I don't have a problem with having a friend.
00:23:25.400
And I think when I look at the women in my life, they want a friend who can do everything.
0.99
00:23:29.200
Yeah, so this relationship scientist, Eli Finkel, talks a lot about how in the modern U.S. in particular,
00:23:37.580
we put so much pressure on our romantic relationships to do everything for us and even take the place
00:23:45.300
And it's kind of the way that the data suggests women are thinking about their friendships.
00:23:50.980
They want one best friend to be a Swiss army knife.
00:23:55.360
We're going to take a quick break for a word from our sponsors.
00:23:57.460
We're going to take a quick break for a word from our sponsors.
00:24:09.360
Women typically tend to have close didactic, intense, emotionally intense relationships.
0.98
00:24:14.140
I'm curious, is there any research on male best friends?
00:24:18.020
So like men tend to have like, you know, a large group of friends that they go to.
00:24:22.560
But, you know, men have best close didactic relationship with one of those friends every now and then.
00:24:30.060
So we often include male best friendships in our studies, if only to look at the differences
00:24:39.080
And there's some developmental work on, you know, boys friendships.
00:24:43.980
But what I think you're asking is more about research into sort of the potentially distinct
00:24:48.940
qualitative nature of male and female best friendships.
00:24:53.340
And there, we really haven't paid attention to men as much as we have to women.
00:24:58.420
And in fact, that attention is sort of doubly small, so to speak, because we're not looking
00:25:06.840
What I can tell you anecdotally is that, so again, more than ever, people are moving.
00:25:13.740
And when couples move later in life, which happens a lot in academia, there are a lot of women
1.00
00:25:20.280
who essentially try and find playdates for their husbands.
1.00
00:25:23.700
They would just like him to have some friends, you know, put him on a kickball team, sign
00:25:32.320
And so I feel less bad about working and going to my friendships and tending to all my friends.
00:25:38.640
We don't know why it's harder for men to maybe make friends in later life, as it seems to be.
00:25:44.780
We have no idea because we haven't paid attention yet.
00:25:48.080
Just listening, why is it hard for men to make close friends?
00:25:51.600
I know a lot of men might join a club or like a CrossFit gym, and they'll have maybe some
00:26:01.160
But for the guys who want a closer friend, I think it's just harder for guys because
00:26:05.200
they might have less time than some women because they're working and then they've got
1.00
00:26:10.000
family responsibilities and then they're doing kid stuff.
00:26:19.060
He's done this research on how long it takes to make a friend.
00:26:24.700
I forgot the number, but it was just a really long time.
00:26:28.440
Ryan, you think about that when you're in high school and college, it was easy to acquire
00:26:32.480
that 200 hours because you're with these people at school every day and then you got to hang
00:26:36.480
out with them after school, doing your extracurricular activities, hanging out on Friday night.
00:26:40.240
To get 200 hours with somebody, that's really hard when you're a working adult.
00:26:47.180
But let me say this, people, especially young folks, spend a ton of time on apps trying to
00:26:56.620
We don't spend the same amount of time trying to find our friends.
00:27:07.020
We just don't know a lot about it because there just hasn't been a lot of research on it.
00:27:10.260
If you are a podcast listener and looking for a PhD project, there it is.
00:27:18.500
We are the world leader in studying friendship.
00:27:21.860
Me, Matt Lieberman, Carolyn Parkinson, Naomi Eisenberger.
00:27:25.880
We want to understand what the heck is going on.
00:27:28.980
So yeah, come support our research, be our grad students, figure this stuff out with us.
00:27:34.000
So something else the research has shown about male and female friendship is that it tends
00:27:40.380
That is, men are friends with men typically, women are friends with women typically.
00:27:46.360
Have you done or have you come across any research on heterosocial friendships, so like when men
00:27:59.260
There is some work by Hannah Bradshaw that's really cool about guys-girls.
00:28:04.860
So what do people think of women who are primarily friends with men?
00:28:11.100
There is some cool work on the way that people pick their cross-sex friends.
00:28:17.220
So for men in particular, it might be the case that when they're looking for a friendship,
00:28:24.520
Um, so they want the same thing in their prospective girlfriends as they would in their
00:28:31.160
So there is some work there, but this is another place where we don't do it.
00:28:37.180
I'll say part of the reason that we don't is honestly that in, in, in much of my work,
00:28:42.040
I specify same-sex friends because I don't want there to be a presumption of romance or
00:28:51.460
So we got to find out if, is, is Harry right and Harry met Sally?
00:28:57.160
I mean, I think that's probably easier when men are already investing in their offspring.
00:29:04.240
And especially if they are friends with a woman who's investing in hers, there does seem to
00:29:09.780
be a sort of fundamental trade-off that people face in investing their energy in mating and
00:29:17.440
And so the more that you are investing your energy and things like parenting, maybe, you
00:29:24.920
know, you are not going to be on the prowl or on the lookout and it could be easier to
00:29:30.960
But yeah, that will remain a question that people ask forever.
00:29:38.700
I just think people will automatically say, absolutely not.
00:29:42.120
And absolutely, of course, what kind of sexist are you that you don't think women can be
00:29:46.740
Well, going back to this idea of why men and women would choose to be friends with each
00:29:51.260
So men, they might be friends with a woman as a backup mate, right?
0.99
00:29:56.060
So, well, if I can't get this one gal, then maybe I can go for her.
1.00
00:29:59.220
But I think some other benefits of having a female friend, like a female friend could give
00:30:04.720
you like advice on how to approach a potential mate.
00:30:09.360
She could have an in with, you know, she's like the friend of the girl that you like.
00:30:13.340
And so you can figure out like, well, what should I do to get, I don't know, Jennifer to
0.62
00:30:20.220
I mean, they likely have knowledge that the other sex doesn't have, including the very
1.00
00:30:29.900
Some other folks have talked about that women can potentially be the people that men talk
00:30:41.800
But folks like Amanda Rose would question whether or not men even want to engage in that kind
00:30:50.920
Just because we know women want to and seem to benefit from it doesn't mean that men want
00:30:59.060
So it's another place we need to be really careful about telling people what to do with
00:31:07.540
We've been alluding to this throughout the conversation.
00:31:09.620
Sometimes when we approach friendship, even academically, we view the female idea of friendship as the
1.00
00:31:15.120
So it's like, well, you know, friends should disclose things and be really intimate with
00:31:23.480
And it's like, well, maybe you guys don't want that.
00:31:26.620
Why do we why do you think we put female friendship as the ideal of friendship?
1.00
00:31:36.340
So, you know, Aristotle would talk about friendship and he just focused on men because he didn't really
00:31:41.540
think women could be friends and other researchers have put forward this idea that,
0.88
00:31:47.080
well, women can't really be friends with each other because there's always this underlying
1.00
00:31:54.000
So now we more often see something different that women's friendships are privileged.
1.00
00:32:05.240
And honestly, part of me wonders if that's not just because that's what sells.
00:32:12.680
And so we write about female friendships, right?
00:32:15.080
When men's friendships are featured, you know, it's Sam and Frodo or Jean and Phineas.
00:32:22.640
This is a long-winded way of saying, yeah, I wish I had an idea.
00:32:29.540
And it would be kind of lovely to explore the media landscape of male-male and female-female
00:32:35.920
friendships to show what are people even putting out there and consuming.
00:32:41.560
Maybe that'll help us figure out what it is that people are trying to say our friendship
00:32:47.900
I don't think that'll really answer the question of why do we tell people to be like women's
0.99
00:33:09.920
So men might be friends with women because they're a potential backup mate.
0.93
00:33:14.320
Or a female friend might help him secure a mate.
0.92
00:33:17.900
Why would women want to be friends with men?
1.00
00:33:20.980
So there are a few reasons, and we even see this in some non-human primates.
00:33:26.620
So folks like Frans Duol have written about this.
00:33:33.260
So if I'm worried about the coercion or physical attacks from other men, or I'm a woman, I'm
00:33:41.760
Having another woman might not necessarily be as effective in protecting me from that
1.00
00:33:47.480
male's physical aggression as another male in my corner.
00:33:51.820
So that's one reason is that we get some of those benefits.
00:33:56.040
But the same way that you said, well, you know, men might want to have women friends because
00:34:01.620
women have access to information that men don't, the flip side is true as well.
1.00
00:34:07.100
Men might have some information about even simply their friend group that the women won't
0.86
00:34:16.920
One thing I've heard anecdotally, why some women like to be friends with dudes, is they're
1.00
00:34:27.520
So I would say that there is, but it's only tangential.
00:34:31.440
So Joyce Benenson's work on that, so a six-month female-female friendship is going to have more
1.00
00:34:39.420
issues and fights and, you know, sort of more turbulence than a six-month male-male friendship.
00:34:46.580
And part of this is related to the research on how women aggress.
00:34:55.020
I can say, oh, it's so brave of you to wear that.
00:34:57.940
I can say, you know, when I said we're all going for ice cream, I didn't mean you, Brett.
00:35:04.500
There are these somewhat more subtle ways of aggressing than punching one another in the
00:35:11.220
And women tend to aggress like this, aggress in ways that are more subtle and sometimes
1.00
00:35:18.300
So when a woman is talking to another woman, it's almost like there's a secret language
0.99
00:35:27.120
In fact, I have some work on this with respect to disgust faces.
00:35:31.520
Women tend to make disgust faces at other women they don't want around.
1.00
00:35:37.580
Women tend to notice or at least infer that other women's disgust faces directed maybe at
1.00
00:35:44.780
them, maybe not, means that that woman is going to try and avoid me.
1.00
00:35:49.800
And the more worried I am about having friends, the more I think that that woman's disgust
1.00
00:35:55.940
face potentially at me, it makes me sad and unhappy.
00:36:00.700
Well, I want to talk more about female aggression.
0.94
00:36:03.840
We talked about this idea that the female friendship is like the best.
1.00
00:36:10.140
And that somehow women are less aggressive.
1.00
00:36:14.440
But the research shows that women are just as aggressive as men.
00:36:19.500
Talk to us more about what does female aggression look like with each other?
1.00
00:36:24.940
So first, I should say that we've been sadly loose with our language and research about
00:36:30.560
this and given people the idea that women don't punch, they only gossip, which is not
0.64
00:36:38.160
And given people the idea that when men aggress, they punch, they don't gossip, which I think
00:36:45.500
So what's really going on here is that women are way more likely to use tactics of aggression
1.00
00:36:50.600
that we'd call indirect aggression, social aggression, or relational aggression than they
00:36:58.940
Those tactics of aggression are really characterized by hurting other women where it hurts, which
00:37:07.580
So yes, there's the exclusion and the sort of asides that you say it just loud enough to
00:37:13.640
make the other woman overhear how much you hate her.
00:37:15.960
But really what indirect aggression is often aimed at doing is harming other women's relationships
00:37:23.440
or even potentially precluding other women's ability to form relationships.
1.00
00:37:28.100
Because we say what a horrible friend she is, how selfish she is, that she has an STD and
00:37:37.660
So it's basically like, if you've seen Mean Girls, is it like that?
00:37:43.320
And it, I think I haven't seen that movie in a long time, but there are a lot of instances
00:37:49.460
of aggression among women that many men might not even realize were acts of aggression.
00:37:56.620
And it's not to say that men don't do that as well.
00:38:01.660
They certainly derogate one another and try and harm one another's reputations.
00:38:06.640
Women seem to be attuned to avoiding the costs of engaging in competition and aggression.
1.00
00:38:14.220
So they do it in ways that is more likely like implicature, deniable, kind of the same
00:38:20.140
thing when you're like, Hey, officer, is there a way we can take care of this ticket here?
00:38:34.620
Why do men prefer the direct conflict and women prefer the indirect social conflict?
0.99
00:38:42.160
So I don't know that I'd say women, uh, men necessarily prefer direct conflict, but they'd
0.99
00:38:50.580
Some of our data suggests that if another person pisses a man off, the most likely thing
00:38:58.620
After that, then maybe he'll avoid the guy or exclude the guy.
00:39:08.880
So everybody's more likely to do nothing than avoid unlikely to punch.
00:39:14.920
Women really are much more likely to use indirect aggression than direct aggression though.
1.00
00:39:20.040
And the logic, and this is some work by Ann Campbell called Bjorkvist is that women are really
0.99
00:39:30.100
So they don't want to engage or start physical aggression and they don't want to engage in
00:39:36.840
aggression that is overt and can end up in retaliation that would, you know, kind of physical
00:39:45.460
And in fact, Ann Campbell studied girl gangs and found that, yeah, when there's physical
1.00
00:39:52.980
It starts because somebody maligns somebody else's reputation.
00:39:56.620
So why don't women or why are women so attuned to avoiding the costs of physical aggression?
1.00
00:40:04.600
Again, this is Ann Campbell's work, but some of the ideas are that women are more expensive,
1.00
00:40:15.700
We have a high possibility of having a child if we want to versus men's sort of small, cheap
1.00
00:40:22.480
gametes, their sperm, and it's harder for men to find a mate than it is for women to find
0.99
00:40:30.240
So we really don't want to ruin our ability to pass on our genes.
00:40:36.300
And that seems to be the idea that has taken hold the most is that women are trying to avoid
1.00
00:40:43.140
aggression because we're potentially more fragile, but much more than that, we're more expensive.
00:40:53.000
I guess there probably hasn't been research on that.
00:40:54.600
Does that change when you're 50, 60, 70 years old?
00:40:59.600
If it's about protecting your reproductive potential or if you're a mother, you...
0.84
00:41:05.900
So I should have said part of what Ann Campbell also says is that women avoid aggression that
1.00
00:41:11.740
could be physical or lead to physical aggression because as mothers, we're much more important
0.99
00:41:17.820
to the survival of our offspring than fathers are.
00:41:21.100
So if that is the case and it's really about protecting our future reproductive potential
00:41:26.300
or protecting our current young offspring, then we should see more physical aggression among
00:41:35.160
I don't think there's any evidence that we really, you know, ramp it up.
00:41:40.260
So something else must be going on that sort of boosts men's aggression.
00:41:46.500
Mechanistically, that might even be testosterone, right?
00:41:49.300
But we really don't have a good handle on why women aggress the way that they aggress.
0.99
00:41:56.160
I think we do now have a very good handle on the fact that women and men aggress differently.
00:42:02.740
Whenever a new friend, like a new person comes into the friend group and that other person
00:42:08.280
could possibly become the new best friend of your best friend, that can cause a lot of
00:42:17.040
There's been a lot of research done on romantic jealousy.
00:42:19.960
You've done some research on friendship jealousy.
00:42:30.940
Robin Dunbar would point out that having friends is the next best thing you could do
00:42:38.380
And so we should be attuned to the concern that we're going to lose our friend to somebody else.
00:42:45.580
Yeah, our friends only have so much time in the day and we want them to spend that time
00:42:52.540
But it's particularly, we want that friend's support for us over other people, their other
00:43:01.120
And so what we find is really simple stuff that people feel jealous when their friends
00:43:09.340
might make new friendships, but not just when their friends sort of that friendship fizzles
00:43:16.540
People are more jealous when their closer friends might be usurped by other people versus their
00:43:24.140
And people are really attuned to cues that their best friends are replacing them with
00:43:32.640
So for example, we ask people, how jealous would you be if your best friend started a
00:43:38.560
new romantic relationship versus a new friendship?
00:43:41.820
And if people are only concerned with spending time with their best friend, then they should
00:43:47.640
be more concerned when they form a new romantic relationship because our new romantic partners
00:43:53.620
But if it's really about replacement and replacing the function that this person serves for you
00:43:59.260
and vice versa, they should be more jealous when their friends make new friends.
00:44:04.720
People are more jealous when their friends form new friendships, particularly new same-sex
00:44:11.120
No, you actually, there's a, in the study, you started off this paper with a quote from an
00:44:16.200
author named Andrea Laventhal and she says this, most girls won't admit this, but they'd rather
00:44:22.580
you hit on their significant other than their best friend.
00:44:26.620
So I think that's from a New York times article when I read that paper back in the day and
00:44:31.580
it was really hitting home the point that particularly for women, their best friendships might even
00:44:40.360
be longer lasting than many of their romantic relationships, which again, it, I hate using
00:44:46.700
the word problematize, but it problematizes or challenges this idea that female friendships
0.92
00:44:55.100
There might just be a lot of them until we find the friend one, but that does seem to be
00:45:02.620
So when we do find sex differences, we find that females report greater jealousy at losing
0.96
00:45:09.000
their best friends and close friends than men do.
00:45:12.420
We also find, and this is a small effect, I don't know if it's real, but when men are
0.99
00:45:18.220
asked to think about their friends as being on part of a team and how they'd feel if their
00:45:23.360
friend sort of left their team for another team, they tend to be more jealous there.
00:45:28.680
That increases men's jealousy, not compared to men, compared to women.
00:45:33.560
Women are just more jealous at losing friends in general, not acquaintances, but friends.
1.00
00:45:39.000
You can amplify men's jealousy by saying, Hey, he's your teammate and friend, and he's
00:45:47.900
The idea of men prefer large, loose kind of club networks.
00:45:52.960
Another guy coming in, being a friend, even a best friend, like that's, that'd be, Hey,
00:46:00.420
But if that guy, if your best friend decided, I'm going to go, I don't know, join the other
00:46:05.820
team or something that's more, that's like, you've betrayed us.
00:46:14.100
And I should say thinking about jealousy or friendship, jealousy this way is totally
00:46:19.180
different than how most people have thought about it so far in developmental psych or other
00:46:24.280
more traditional areas of psychology or sociology.
00:46:27.440
Some work suggests that feeling jealousy at all is a symptom of internalizing Western
00:46:34.080
capitalistic ideals where you see people as things.
00:46:39.340
Other work seems to suggest that, yeah, okay, young people feel jealous when their friends
00:46:45.620
But if they're normally developing, they grow out of that because no one friend can fulfill
00:46:52.040
So if you do feel jealousy in adulthood, when your friends make other friends, you've developed
00:46:58.760
And still other work seems to suggest, you know, you just don't understand friendship
00:47:06.020
You must have low self-esteem if you're jealous when your friends make new friends.
00:47:09.960
Our functional and evolutionary look at it is just this emotion is beneficial.
00:47:15.840
And on average, people that felt jealousy when their friends made new close friends
00:47:20.180
and acted accordingly in sort of positive ways to maintain their friendship probably did
00:47:26.660
better than people that didn't feel that jealousy at all.
00:47:30.140
So if you started feeling friendship jealousy, you start doing the, hey, I'm going to invite
00:47:35.080
Like you try to be more proactive to nurture that friendship.
00:47:39.340
We created a list of sort of 44 items that we call friend guarding behavior.
00:47:45.700
So everything from punching the interloper to being really vigilant, maybe, you know,
00:47:52.260
you sort of stalk your existing friend on social media and see if they're hanging out
00:47:57.780
But in between, there are these behaviors that are probably more characteristic of adults,
00:48:06.420
Let's make sure we spend some time together and, you know, invest in this friendship.
00:48:10.700
That can be a way that people guard their friendships and their friends against defection.
00:48:16.040
But then this could go like, uh, malade, not malade, like maybe antisocial, not pro-social.
00:48:21.940
It's like, well, you start telling your best friend, I've heard this about her, you know,
00:48:25.940
gossiping and starting rumors and things like that.
00:48:28.300
So, I mean, in that sense, that kind of gossip or exclusion is antisocial or aggressive toward
00:48:38.060
the person that you're negatively gossiping about or excluding.
00:48:41.620
It might still be an effective form of friend guarding though.
00:48:46.000
And to recap, women feel more friendship jealousy than men do on average.
00:48:52.800
The one exception, and again, this is a small effect, is that men tended to be comparatively
00:48:58.420
more jealous when their acquaintances made new acquaintances.
00:49:03.920
So, I mean, it could just be, again, about the numbers, right?
00:49:07.340
So, men are using their networks to benefit them in ways that women aren't necessarily.
00:49:12.620
And so, the loss of a network member for a man might be more costly than an acquaintance
00:49:20.360
Well, Jamie, this has been a great conversation.
00:49:23.260
Where can people go to learn more about your work?
00:49:25.680
So, they can visit my lab website, the Social Minds Lab at UCLA.
00:49:33.020
And very soon, they will be able to hear about some of our research or maybe even see some
00:49:38.500
public-facing talks at the UCLA Center for Friendship Research if they're in the LA area.
00:49:51.300
You can find more information about our work at our website, kremslab.com.
00:49:54.660
Also, check out our show notes at aom.is slash krems, where you can find links to resources,
00:50:06.920
Well, that wraps up another edition of the AOM Podcast.
00:50:09.500
Make sure to check out our website at artofmanliness.com, where you can find our podcast archives,
00:50:12.980
as well as thousands of articles that we've written over the years about pretty much anything
00:50:16.880
And if you haven't done this already, I'd appreciate you taking one minute to get a
00:50:23.380
Please consider sharing the show with a friend or family member who would think you'd
00:50:26.940
As always, thank you for the continued support.
00:50:28.740
And until next time, it's Brett McKay, reminding you to not listen to the AOM Podcast, but put what