The Auron MacIntyre Show - May 20, 2026


Ezra Klein Has a Crisis of Faith | 5⧸20⧸26

Hosted by
Mentioned
The Dave Rubin and Bishop Barron Interview Was Bizarre | 5 ⧸18⧸26 Why Libertarians Fall for the AI Trap | 5⧸21⧸26

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 19 minutes

Words per minute

170.18

Word count

13,534

Sentence count

336

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

41

sentences flagged

Hate speech

29

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Oren McIntyre Show, host Oren McInnes talks about the need to understand the crisis of liberal ideas and why we need to look at them through the lens of history to understand why they re so difficult to grasp.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 It's the family and friends event at Shoppers Drug Mart.
00:00:04 Get 20% off almost all regular priced merchandise.
00:00:07 Two days only.
00:00:08 Tuesday, May 26th and Wednesday, May 27th.
00:00:11 Open your PC Optimum app to get your coupon.
00:00:16 Hey everybody, how's it going?
00:00:18 Thanks for joining me this afternoon.
00:00:20 I am Oren McIntyre.
00:00:22 Before we get started today, I just want to remind you
00:00:24 that one of the ways we keep the lights on around here
00:00:26 is of course subscriptions to Blaze TV.
00:00:28 So if you want to support what I'm doing on the show and you also want to get access to all your favorite Blaze TV hosts, you need to head to blazetv.com slash Oren to get $20 off your subscription today.
00:00:41 That's blazetv.com slash Oren to get $20 off today.
00:00:47 All right, guys.
00:00:48 So I was watching Ezra Klein.
00:00:51 Not something I do all that often, but I thought the title of the video was interesting.
00:00:57 It was talking about how liberalism was in some form of crisis, and we needed to understand it at a historical level.
00:01:05 We need to put liberalism in its historical context so we can better grasp why liberalism is currently in the situation that it's in.
00:01:14 Now, in case you don't know, Ezra Klein is a New York Times columnist, is pretty much everything you'd expect.
00:01:22 And it was interesting for me, though, when they talked about the the history of liberalism, because normally when you're talking to a liberal, they're not even aware that there is history.
00:01:34 You know, they they know that there was World War Two and slavery and Jim Crow and the civil rights movement.
00:01:40 And that was about it. Like that's about as much as as any liberal will grasp when it comes to history, because history is very, very dangerous to the left.
00:01:49 progressives have to be very wary about actual investigations into history. Because if you read
00:01:56 enough history, if you look deep enough into the past, you start to discover that the worldview
00:02:01 that has been carefully curated by the liberal left is just radically incorrect. And even the
00:02:08 worldview that has been curated by much of mainstream conservatism is very incorrect.
00:02:13 And when you look at history, you'll see that there are these very, very different forces
00:02:18 acting upon humans, very different belief systems, radically different from what we think of today.
00:02:26 And if you look deep enough into the past, you will slowly start to discover that much of what
00:02:32 we think of as history, much of what we try to understand as like our political lineage
00:02:37 is completely incorrect. And so I was interested to see what would these two liberals think about
00:02:44 this like uh what what would two people who are trying to understand history and liberalism and
00:02:50 tradition what would that look like would they would they glaze over different parts would they
00:02:55 make things up and it turns out that really Ezra Klein is having a crisis of faith in this discussion
00:03:01 he understands that at the root uh he believes in something that is very different from previous
00:03:08 versions of liberalism and he wants to like tie this together because he thinks ultimately like
00:03:13 this is an issue but also he hates most of the history like both of these people really hate
00:03:20 uh the the history that they're discussing so he has this woman on i think it's like helena
00:03:25 rosenbaum or something like that and they're supposed to go over her book because she's a
00:03:30 historian and we we want to understand what's going on in the past with liberalism and uh you
00:03:36 know the whole podcast is always like it's like an hour an hour and a half there's no way i could
00:03:42 cover it all in one of my episodes so i cut it down but but as always i encourage you to go listen
00:03:47 to the whole thing at the very least you can kind of get inside the mind of the new york times
00:03:52 liberal which i think is actually rather valuable uh that's one thing the left doesn't have a theory
00:03:57 of mind for the right they don't understand how we think they don't understand what we value
00:04:01 it doesn't make sense to them on a fundamental level and they're not particularly interested
00:04:05 in understanding that they don't have to they live in a world that is ruled by progressivism
00:04:10 and leftism and so conservatives are just swept away as some kind of silly uh you know thing out
00:04:15 of time but ultimately i think it's important for us to understand what they are thinking how they
00:04:22 are processing this because it reveals to us the inner workings of the people who are you know
00:04:27 frankly coordinating against us on a regular basis and if we can grasp you know where these
00:04:32 tensions are then we might find different weaknesses that can be exploited different
00:04:36 strategic moments, maybe even if you find the right liberal arguments that could ultimately
00:04:41 compel them to change their mind, though I wouldn't bet on that too often. I'm not a big
00:04:46 marketplace of ideas guy, but people do change their mind. I've certainly changed my mind on
00:04:49 arguments. So it's always worth having that particular trick in your bag in case the person
00:04:54 you're discussing these things with actually does have a hope of kind of learning something and
00:05:00 changing that said let's go ahead and dive into uh this video and i'll stop and i'll explain as we
00:05:07 go so we live in this moment when illiberalism is winning when illiberalism is in power i don't
00:05:14 think anybody really argues that what so we start off with trump is being and mean and bad and he's
00:05:22 an authoritarian and he's illiberal now that'll be very interesting because of course in many ways
00:05:27 Trump is a very liberal president. He is somebody who is relatively socially liberal when it comes
00:05:33 to, you know, conservative standards. Yes, he's talked about abortion some and, you know, he has
00:05:40 won some victories there. You know, he will kind of make certain noises about Christianity, but
00:05:46 he's not a doctrinaire Christian. He's certainly not a faithful Christian, certainly not someone
00:05:50 who seems overly interested in that kind of stuff. So, you know, Trump is the first guy to
00:05:56 like wave the lgbtq flag at the republican convention so we're not talking about a guy
00:06:01 who's like deeply uh you know convicted when it comes to like conservative uh right-wing or
00:06:07 reactionary morality and even when you look at the different measures that trump is taking
00:06:12 ezra klein only sees them as illiberal because he disagrees with them when joe biden was doing
00:06:18 this stuff when joe biden's locking up j6ers locking up abortion protesters you know uh you 0.54
00:06:24 know locking away his possible you know only real political challenger in Donald Trump or 0.51
00:06:29 attempting to uh through ridiculous government prosecutions Ezra Klein has nothing to say he
00:06:34 has nothing to say about that fact are those authoritarian actions well if Donald Trump does
00:06:40 them of course they are but if Joe Biden doesn't he's a liberal he's a liberal in good standing
00:06:45 so Ezra Klein doesn't really care about the the terrible authoritarianism of Donald Trump
00:06:51 it in fact only impacts him because it's his enemy when his ally is doing it when his friends
00:06:56 are doing it it's fine he's not going to bring anything up he's certainly not going to say
00:07:00 this is some kind of indication that we're becoming illiberal okay the war in iran you
00:07:04 say that's illiberal well obviously hillary clinton was celebrating celebrating the death
00:07:09 of momar qaddafi again like i i think that ezra klein is very very careful with when he finds
00:07:15 problems with use of government force against people who disagree but yeah obviously that's
00:07:21 exactly what we'd expect has surprised me about it is how weak liberalism has felt in response
00:07:27 i'm a liberal i'm a like a professional liberal one involved in liberal politics
00:07:32 and i don't think at this moment i could tell you what liberalism's vision is so i mean this part
00:07:40 is honest so this part is interesting and and this is why i did find the episode interesting
00:07:44 if not ridiculous like most of it as you'll see is ridiculous but editor klein recognizes that
00:07:49 there is like a floundering of liberalism and we'll get to why here in a second you know this
00:07:55 is a guy who came up with the abundance uh discussion we're going to make everything
00:07:59 abundant and you know people will then have material stuff and that's going to fix our
00:08:03 that's our vision of of liberalism which you know i mean in a lot of ways it's just like
00:08:08 half-hearted capitalism you know kind of just conceding that fact uh but really he understands
00:08:14 that liberalism has become very hollow. It seems at some level to have burned out a lot of its
00:08:19 kind of passion in 2020 and the George Floyd riots. It felt like while liberalism was triumphant
00:08:28 in a way, like we can control these streets, we can lock these people down, we can close the
00:08:33 churches, we can really censor all of our opponents on the internet. At the same time,
00:08:39 It seemed to have reached this culmination and this euphoric moment, and then it didn't go anywhere. It didn't do anything. It didn't unlock what comes next. And so this is very concerning to Ezra Klein because, of course, in his mind, liberalism means progress. It means we should always be moving towards some end, right?
00:08:57 And so if there is no continued vision for where we should be going, liberalism is going to flounder, which I think is true.
00:09:06 Like, liberalism is an eternal revolution.
00:09:09 And so if we're not finding something new to kind of revolt over, if there's no next version of the revolution, liberalism kind of falls on its face.
00:09:19 Who its leaders are.
00:09:20 In some way, I feel liberalism never really recovered from the Obama era when it had this grand victory in electing America's first black president, when it had this thoughtful, deliberate and frankly, quite popular liberal leader.
00:09:37 And then it ended in Donald Trump twice.
00:09:41 Yeah, I mean, and this is kind of it, right?
00:09:43 Like they think of this idea of progress.
00:09:46 Once you achieve the thing, we elected a black man to the White House. There you go. We're just only going to become more leftist, more progressive from here. That's just how history works. The arc of history is long, but it bends towards liberalism, except it doesn't because Donald Trump disproves that.
00:10:07 Right. Like after Obama, where did the American people go? Did they find someone even more liberal than Obama? Did they find someone at least tangentially as liberal as Obama? No, they went to someone like Donald Trump, who's a direct repudiation of that.
00:10:21 There had been no permanent victory of liberalism achieved there. There was this desire to run away from much of what had been done in the name of liberalism. And there's not some holy moment that once Jesus Obama was elected into the White House and a black man finally sat in the big chair, it didn't bring about any of the things that liberals wanted at the end of the day, or at least not sufficiently because it is the eternal revolution, right?
00:10:50 And so if you run into this moment where Trump gets elected and then after Joe Biden, who is a disaster in all kinds of levels, I think at this point, there's probably very few liberals that want to own the Obama or rather the Biden presidency, even though they were all championing it up until the very end. 0.53
00:11:08 At this point, then Trump reenters. And so what does that say? What does that mean about the momentum of the left?
00:11:15 You know, we now because of the Trump administration's kind of current internal struggles, struggles with its own base, kind of distractions with foreign wars and these things, we forget like how devastating a loss the liberals took when Trump was elected, that how much they were completely demoralized by that, how much they were spiraling.
00:11:37 And so Ezra Klein recognizes that, yeah, you might currently have some outbursts from Antifa, some momentum because Trump hasn't been doing so well, inflation, Epstein, all this stuff. But ultimately, there is still a break in the liberal narrative by Trump's election. People did want the mass deportations. They did want the things that Trump was ultimately offering.
00:12:01 They wanted to see him back in the White House, despite all of the propaganda that had been spewed about him.
00:12:07 So what does that mean? 0.67
00:12:07 What does it mean for the left when Hispanic men vote for the guy who's hawking mass deportation?
00:12:14 Like, how does that fit into Ezra Klein's worldview?
00:12:16 It doesn't.
00:12:17 And so there's a real crisis there.
00:12:19 But Donald Trump is not working out.
00:12:22 He is not making people want more of what he is.
00:12:25 but if he's going to be beaten if illiberal political forces are going to turn back
00:12:31 i think you're going to need a liberalism that is aspirational again
00:12:36 again i think there's a little wish casting there i i know the trump administration again has had
00:12:41 some rough patches and uh you know it's got a certain level of internal crisis at the moment
00:12:46 but ultimately i don't think there's a full repudiation of what donald trump offered in fact
00:12:52 If anything, I would say the main argument that people who are currently angry with Donald Trump make is that he didn't do enough.
00:13:00 He didn't follow through, right?
00:13:02 He hasn't had enough deportations. 0.61
00:13:04 He didn't release the Epstein files when he was supposed to. 0.52
00:13:07 He didn't take some of the actions that they were hoping he would.
00:13:11 Now, of course, there are leftists that just always hate Trump.
00:13:14 But for that kind of centrist coalition, the Maha guys, the libertarians that came over, and then much of the new right, those kind of things, if there's any disagreement with Trump, it's not on Trump going too far, being too Trump.
00:13:29 Their argument is Trump is not Trump enough.
00:13:31 Trump did not continue through with what we thought he was going to do.
00:13:35 So I think Klein is kind of hoping that it's a wholesale, you know, rejection of Trump and his promises, when in fact, I think it is simply, if anything, a current desire to see more of what Trump promised and see it fulfilled.
00:13:50 liberalism has moral imagination again a liberalism that stands for more than not this
00:13:56 and so i've been on this sort of esoteric personal quest reading all these books in the liberal canon
00:14:04 reading all these histories of liberalism trying to think through like what in this very very long
00:14:10 tradition is valuable for us right now being liberal really was not just all right so this
00:14:16 the author that he brings on uh yeah i cut the whole intro because they go on and on about all
00:14:21 the books she's written that kind of thing not super useful but she wrote this book about the
00:14:24 history of liberalism uh and that's that's what he's diving into here about um believing in a
00:14:31 certain or working towards a certain political design it wasn't just about a constitutional
00:14:35 form it wasn't just about individual rights it was actually more about moral development and about
00:14:41 certain character development that they felt was so very important and that a good constitution
00:14:51 should promote. And many of them thought that, yes, rights are important, but they're important
00:14:57 because they allow us to actually accomplish our obligations. They're very much concerned with
00:15:07 establishing a good morally good regime so what this historian does is like really gross and ugly 0.98
00:15:18 and dumb uh but it's gonna it's gonna work on the new york times people because they don't they 0.97
00:15:22 don't know any history liberals don't know history they don't they have no clue there's no context 0.99
00:15:26 for anything she's saying so they're just going to nod along as your client is like completely
00:15:30 blown away yeah liberalism really was in the ancient world having civic virtue and achieve
00:15:36 like that is not what liberalism is it's not what liberalism means what they're doing is they're
00:15:41 going to take liberalism and they're going to expand it to mean any positive pro-social virtue
00:15:47 so everything that is like be a good person how you know contribute to your community build up
00:15:54 you know a well of this like social capital that's all liberalism now none of the people
00:16:01 in the ancient world thought anything like that like that's complete bastardization of what they
00:16:06 thought in any way shape or form though there is some truth here which is important so she's going
00:16:12 back and she's talking about ancient societies you know the greeks the romans the ones that we
00:16:17 think of as foundational to many of our western uh understandings of the world she won't say that
00:16:22 of course because they're not going to talk about the western tradition they're not going to
00:16:26 delineate that as a specific important different tradition because of course they would just want
00:16:31 to globalize this they're all they're all just global communists at the end of the day and so
00:16:35 like that that's what they're really looking for and so they're not gonna like pull out why this
00:16:41 tradition looks different than other traditions they're not going to explore that they're just
00:16:46 going to kind of be like well this is a thing that happened in the ancients but the the point
00:16:51 here at least stands, it's true that to the degree you cared about liberty in the ancient
00:16:59 world, when you're looking at the Greeks or the Romans and their city states, the reason you
00:17:03 would talk about liberty, the liberty is to do the right thing. It's to live as God wanted or
00:17:10 the gods wanted, depending on the society. It's to be a good citizen. It's to have the freedom
00:17:16 to cultivate a high level of moral character so they were oriented towards a collective
00:17:23 understanding of the good and this is something that's going to be really really hard for klein
00:17:29 and rosenbaum to like ultimately a rosenplatt i keep i keep forgetting what her last name was
00:17:34 um but but uh it's gonna be really hard for them to grasp because they don't believe that you
00:17:40 should have like a cohesive society they think and they go and they go on to this at length in
00:17:47 the full podcast again i don't have the whole thing in here because it's just too long but in
00:17:51 the full podcast they go on at length about how important it is to have like this radical diversity
00:17:57 where you uh you know put up with everything you put up with different religions and viewpoints and
00:18:02 and and people from you know all these other countries and everything and they never get to
00:18:07 the fact that like the reason the ancients were able to orient themselves towards this virtue
00:18:12 is that they had a relatively uh you know homogeneous society they had a relatively
00:18:19 cohesive understanding of who they are what they believe they have the same religion they came from
00:18:25 the same lineage they came from the same traditions and this allowed them to then understand what
00:18:31 liberty meant inside their tradition and this is going to be again the failing of these guys over
00:18:37 and over again they're going to talk about like the roots of western civilization they're going
00:18:42 to color them as liberal even though again like nothing in the roman or greek uh you know
00:18:50 understanding uh was anything close to like progressive liberalism much less even classical 1.00
00:18:56 liberalism like we're talking about societies where you know oftentimes women had little to
00:19:00 no rights certainly couldn't vote uh only a certain percentage of the population could vote at all
00:19:05 uh you know the slavery patriarchy all kinds of stuff you know all these hierarchies that left
00:19:12 hate these are rampant and heavily baked in to the understanding of what the good was like if
00:19:18 you're talking about the ancients and their pursuit of virtue inside society they're going to be
00:19:23 pursuing like how to own the most slaves and build cool things with them and like you know like like
00:19:30 like how to marry your daughter off for political and social advantage like these are all things
00:19:36 that they would think of as virtuous things are orienting themselves towards like and and there's
00:19:42 just no acknowledge of the there's no acknowledgement of that anywhere except to say that they hate it
00:19:47 even though they're like trying to tie things to this history so i decided to trace the word and
00:19:55 the meaning of the word all the way back to ancient Rome, which is liberal in ancient Rome.
00:20:01 The root of the word is liber, right? And the word liber, yes, it means free, but it also means
00:20:07 generous, which I thought was so very, very interesting. So if liberal were really the
00:20:12 qualities of freedom, lovingness, and generosity expected of a citizen, liberalitas was the noun
00:20:20 that went went with it um so this was an attitude that was expected of citizens in rome when you are
00:20:28 devoted to the commonwealth to the common good well so again just this this one two step of like
00:20:35 well liberalism was being generous with your money and then liberty is freedom these are not the same
00:20:42 thing right so you know there there there's not some like obvious correlation but of course we
00:20:47 want to make a just so story where the Rome, the Romans, when they talk about liberty, they had
00:20:52 the idea of basically the democratic party in 20, you know, 2005, like that's, these are the same
00:20:59 thing, whether or not at all, again, the Roman version of liberty would have meant the ability
00:21:05 to live towards virtue. Yes. But what virtues, right? It's not that the liberty itself is the
00:21:12 virtue it's that it you know you it's a virtue but it's not the overall identity of the virtues
00:21:19 it's one among many and they all orient towards you towards a vision of the good that both of
00:21:24 these people would find absolutely abysmal and so trying to root the history of her political
00:21:30 ideology in ancient robe is just so radically and comically a historical that it's amazing that like
00:21:37 like i again i know these people are biased i know they're ignorant but it's just wild how like no
00:21:43 one sat down like you really want to you want to try to make that move like she obviously published
00:21:48 a book doing this so i don't know if she she knows what she's doing is a lie she should she's
00:21:53 a historian but what does the left-wing historian do with all that inconvenient knowledge i don't
00:21:58 know one thing that was a bit of an epiphany reading a book for me i think a lot of things
00:22:04 are missing in modern liberalism. My interest in doing this episode and more that I think are going
00:22:08 to come is trying to figure out why liberalism feels so exhausted at a moment that it is so
00:22:14 needed, and why so many of the books I read about it, some of the defenses I read of it,
00:22:20 are so arid. They have no blood in them. But one thing that was interesting here
00:22:29 was this idea that liberalism is built on a virtue,
00:22:33 not a political philosophy, right, liberality.
00:22:37 And as you just mentioned,
00:22:38 that the old definitions of it,
00:22:40 and you have Cicero and John Locke and John Donne,
00:22:44 but they have some kind of intersection
00:22:46 between generosity and freedom,
00:22:48 but not freedom like we think of it now.
00:22:52 So what did freedom mean in this context?
00:22:55 so again this has some value like i think this is important even for conservatives to understand
00:23:02 that like freedom and liberality meant very different things in the ancient world
00:23:07 but that's not what ezra klein's doing here he wants to connect this directly to his political
00:23:12 ideology he doesn't want to understand and let history inform his definition of liberalism he
00:23:18 wants to find a way to like retroactively impose his understanding of politics into like roman
00:23:27 traditions and understandings of liberty and virtue and freedom i think it's wise to ask what
00:23:34 were these things for i think it's good to understand liberty as a virtue and not a political
00:23:38 ideology but for klein he just wants that because he wants to hope that this will somehow connect
00:23:43 things and again he's right to say that liberalism is failing because it's not connected to its
00:23:48 history because it's not connected to its roots. It's not connected to its ultimate understanding
00:23:55 historically, but he can't do that. He can't connect the tradition because he hates the
00:23:59 tradition. He hates the things that the Romans and the founding fathers and many of the other
00:24:04 people they're going to cite here ultimately believed. And you're going to see that through
00:24:08 line throughout here. He desperately wants to connect liberalism back to a deeper tradition,
00:24:13 But he is so hateful. He is so dismissive. He and his guests sneer so often at the people who
00:24:21 built the tradition he's trying to revere that it's impossible. And he's going to run into this
00:24:25 problem repeatedly. It's really about having the freedom to voluntarily become the person that you
00:24:31 should be. And this has dropped out of our conversation. We think of liberalism so much,
00:24:36 as you said, being about individual rights and maximizing our choices. A good system of
00:24:42 government would help you, give you the capacity to make those good choices.
00:24:49 So again, this is correct. This is actually the way that freedom and liberty were understood in
00:24:58 the ancient world. But this is radically different than current liberalism, and that matters quite a
00:25:03 bit. Now, they're going to say they want to reground it in this idea of being civic-minded,
00:25:07 not being so individualistic. But of course, that's what defines everything that they think
00:25:12 about as what civic mindedness is. Being civic minded is creating the most tolerance, creating
00:25:19 the most opportunity for people to go do things individually by the state, helping them out with
00:25:23 things, giving them money, you know, giving them advantages, giving them a hand up. That's what
00:25:28 they think of as liberalism. So they can't look at this. It's a lot of stolen valor. They're trying
00:25:35 to run back to the Romans and the Greeks and say, oh, no, their definition of liberalism is part of
00:25:41 our grand tradition no it's not it's not at all like you do not understand virtue in this way
00:25:46 in any like it's not even close and so once again they're going to try to keep trying to connect
00:25:52 things to this tradition but they're going to hate everything about it they're going to revile
00:25:57 its outcomes on a regular basis while still trying to steal back some of that history
00:26:03 thinking that somehow that's going to revivify liberalism in the modern era that evolved over
00:26:09 times. So in the medieval period, it became Christianized, and it's behaving freely the
00:26:15 way God wants you to behave in a generous, charitable way. There's Cicero and Seneca,
00:26:23 and these are well-known names that have had tremendous influence.
00:26:27 What do they say? What is their vision of liberality?
00:26:29 So that liberality is about reciprocity, exchange, behaving, gift-giving, and reciprocity
00:26:37 is is uh fundamental you need to know uh you need to be good to one another um very much about what
00:26:46 they would call you know citizenly or i call citizenly virtues things that make a commonwealth
00:26:52 work and and and adhere you know stay to get together that is not now again there's some
00:27:00 truth to this but she's never going to mention that when cicero or any of these other people
00:27:06 are talking about liberalism as a virtue, they always mean to your people. They mean to the
00:27:12 people of your city, your culture, your tribe. That's what he's talking about. If you tried to
00:27:19 explain to Cicero that you as a Roman should be generous to any given barbarian outside the gates,
00:27:28 any given people that you've conquered, that would make no sense to him. It would not make
00:27:33 sense it's not a it's not a generalized virtue a universal understanding of interaction it's a very
00:27:40 specific again restricted understanding in this tradition and that's what makes it work by the way
00:27:49 because cicero would immediately understand that if you were that generous and receive and you
00:27:55 reciprocated all the time to anyone you met outside of your people your tribe your civilization
00:28:01 it would bring you to ruin. And so, yes, like they saw this as some level of virtue.
00:28:09 They'll remember like true charity is a Christian virtue that didn't make a lot of sense to Romans
00:28:14 either. Right. But to the extent that you had this level of generosity and reciprocity, 0.77
00:28:20 it was within your tribe. It was within your city. This idea of like universal tolerance,
00:28:26 universally giving money to people, you know, having the state take it from them and then just 0.93
00:28:31 hand it out to a bunch of illegal immigrants. None of this would have been virtuous to the 1.00
00:28:36 ancient Romans. In fact, it would have been a absolute scandal. It would have been seen as
00:28:41 horribly, horribly corrupt. And yet she's, you know, acting as if this is the same thing.
00:28:47 So he said the word liberal at some point. So it's the same thing too. I don't try to
00:28:53 idealize you know these these thinkers either because you know you had slavery in rome which
00:28:58 is uh so they're talking about a small group a small group an elite so again they're they're
00:29:06 they're never going to make it more than 10 seconds into discussing the kind of different
00:29:11 virtues and the different traditions that they want to connect liberalism to without immediately
00:29:17 attacking the very people that they want to build this on so they they simultaneously want to do
00:29:23 like this build on the shoulder of giants thing and then cut them off at the knees right oh well
00:29:30 we're we're following the tradition of cicero we're following the tradition of the ancient romans
00:29:35 who were awful and had slaves and were terrible people and were elitist and they didn't let women
00:29:40 do this and they treated barbarians like this and like they're gonna do this over and over again
00:29:46 and so they're so desperate to connect liberalism back to this root they understand the hollowness
00:29:52 they understand that it's lost its blood they understand that it's lost its uh its virality
00:29:58 but ultimately they can't because they hate everything that came before them and they don't
00:30:04 understand how that like constant destruction of the past has completely unmoored their liberalism
00:30:10 from anything that could be seen as virtuous why are why is everyone individualistic uh maybe
00:30:16 because you told them to hate their ancestors like why wouldn't why would they behave for the
00:30:21 common good when the common good was built by people who were racist and sexist and all of
00:30:27 these things right it makes no sense but they they want to they want to do both they want to have a
00:30:32 society that coheres around a central identity and a shared set of beliefs and values is is civic
00:30:38 minded and oriented but they want people to hate every single thing that came before them that
00:30:42 would motivate them to engage in this civic minded behavior i i think this is quite important and
00:30:50 it's something threaded through your book. You write at some point that this idea of being a
00:30:55 liberal, which comes way before liberalism as a political philosophy, is designed by and for the
00:31:00 free, wealthy, and well-connected men who are in a position to give and receive benefits in ancient
00:31:04 Rome. And some other things that emerge as the book goes on, one thing it makes clear is that
00:31:11 if today your problem with liberalism and liberals is you find them to be a bunch of smug,
00:31:17 condescending elites that problem goes way back that's always been braided into the the issue here
00:31:24 um and that there was like uh like it was a set of virtues that was associated with like the noble
00:31:29 born and set them apart in a way that would make them the ideal citizens so again calling this
00:31:37 liberalism is ridiculous ahistorical junk history nonsense ezra klein is trying to take the word
00:31:46 liberal and turn it into the ideology of liberalism he wants to take the virtue and he wants to say 0.99
00:31:53 the virtue is the ideology garbage like none of these people were liberals none of them were even 0.98
00:31:59 close to liberals these people would have been the most reactionary retrograde insane people 0.94
00:32:05 to guys like Ezra Klein right like Ezra Klein would be absolutely like jaw on the floor destroyed
00:32:13 by seeing the way that the people he is now revering as the founders of liberalism behaved,
00:32:19 how they would have thought of someone like Ezra Klein, right? So ridiculous. But there is, 0.98
00:32:25 again, truth here. And this is the problem. They are going back to ancient virtue and ancient
00:32:30 cultivation and certain attitudes. And that is valuable. Like, I want to do this too. I talk
00:32:35 about this. I think this is valuable. Something conservatives need to understand as much as
00:32:39 liberals but ultimately he points out here that liberalism his idea this ideology of liberalism
00:32:46 really the cultivation of virtue this understanding of like you should have this intense uh uh program
00:32:54 to encourage a specific way that you should live and and cultivate these different aspects of human
00:33:00 behavior that are pro-social which is not liberalism that is not what liberal ideology is but that is a
00:33:06 real thing that was a real thing and he says well this was for the aristocracy and so there's a long
00:33:10 history of this behavior being for aristocrats there are people who should lead and they should
00:33:16 behave in this way why yes there is that's true the nobility were expected to cultivate these
00:33:22 things to be worthy of leadership by having these attributes that's correct but there's a hidden
00:33:29 nugget in there that's really important ezra that means that this style this aristocratic
00:33:34 understanding, which he would hate if it was forced on the United States today. That is for
00:33:41 a certain set of elite people that is hierarchical. This way of understanding the world that you want
00:33:48 to connect to modern liberalism is an anathema to modern liberalism because it was built around
00:33:55 the idea that a hierarchical structure of people ruled because they were worthy, because they were
00:34:00 brought up in a certain way and conducted themselves in that virtue in that orientation
00:34:05 towards the good that that would be a complete heretical statement for Ezra Klein so he he notes
00:34:13 that yes this thing he wants to call liberalism is attached to the elites the entire time but he
00:34:20 never thinks about the implications there maybe it's not for the masses maybe you can't do it at
00:34:26 scale maybe there's a reason throughout history that this approach always had to focus on a small
00:34:32 noble set that being able to cultivate that level of virtue could only be done
00:34:38 in a certain particular type of people who are worthy to lead that doesn't mean you didn't have
00:34:44 a general expectation of behavior but it was understood that there were only so many and
00:34:49 again it certainly would be understood that this had to happen inside your city your tribe your
00:34:53 people. It certainly would not be this idea that you can universalize it to any and anyone who
00:34:59 wants to walk in to Rome can just become a Roman by following these virtues. That would make no
00:35:05 sense to the Romans. This was always an ideology. It's not even an ideology. For him, it's an
00:35:11 ideology. This was always a tradition that was cultivated inside a specific, particular people.
00:35:20 but Andrew Klein doesn't want to believe that
00:35:22 so he's not going to bring that up he's not going to
00:35:24 notice that he keeps hitting on
00:35:26 that fact he's going to completely
00:35:28 ignore that fact
00:35:29 and continue to talk as if this is just something
00:35:32 that was always available to everyone
00:35:34 or should have always been available to everyone
00:35:36 and that feels to me actually like a quite
00:35:38 profound
00:35:39 tension at the heart of
00:35:42 the project
00:35:44 yeah absolutely
00:35:45 you know they don't even always live up
00:35:48 to the ideal
00:35:49 But they had that ideal and they talked about it. And they designed an educational system, a liberal arts education that was supposed to cultivate these virtues, this liberality in elite boys. But there was a lot expected of the elite as well.
00:36:13 so again hatred of these people well they weren't perfect they didn't do all the things that we
00:36:18 modern progressives know are the right thing to do so again hatred for the virtue but also a
00:36:24 recognition that there had to be this cultivation but again you notice that she says these liberal
00:36:31 virtues no liberalism was one of the virtues it was not the entire set of virtues they're trying
00:36:42 to take every virtue and put it under generosity. They're trying to turn it into an ideology again
00:36:50 and again. They're trying to fuse it to a political identity. But this is a complete rewriting of
00:36:56 history. It is a radical modern frame for a historical phenomenon that simply did not exist
00:37:04 in that day. There is nothing about the Roman understanding of virtue that was in its totality
00:37:11 liberal that is just incorrect at every level but they keep insinuating that it was however
00:37:18 they are going to talk about a you know the cultivation of that virtue through a liberal
00:37:24 education which was again they wouldn't have called it a liberal education this is an ideological
00:37:30 understanding however they did understand the romans that you did have to cultivate
00:37:35 a certain set of virtues not liberality not liberalism as a system but you did have to
00:37:41 cultivate a set of virtues amongst liberalism being one that you ultimately needed to have the
00:37:48 elites follow and much was expected of them they didn't they didn't just cultivate these virtues
00:37:53 and have their position and that was it no like there was a lot of expectation if you were going
00:37:58 to hold this power hold this wealth hold this position in society you had to meet very high
00:38:04 expectations you know so i i don't think it was just mere you know hypocrisy and that um they're
00:38:11 an elite but they had obligations is what are the habits what is a kind of education what is a form
00:38:17 of personal development needed to instill the virtues that will be necessary to hold together
00:38:25 complex societies what so that was good phrasing this is this this is the correct frame right
00:38:34 what are the virtues that you need to cultivate to hold together society possibly even complex
00:38:39 societies he didn't say the liberal virtues this time though that's what he means but again that
00:38:46 would be the correct framing is to say there are a whole set of virtues in which generosity is one
00:38:51 that you need to ultimately bind a society together to make it function and you should
00:38:57 look to cultivate those as a society there should be a civilization wide effort to find worthy
00:39:03 people to elevate this but again while klein at moments hits on truth hits on the correct
00:39:09 understanding the correct frame most of the time he's subverting it into an ideological understanding
00:39:14 is needed to hold together a country or even a city is not easy. I actually think this helps
00:39:23 explain one reason liberals have always been so shocked and repulsed by Donald Trump himself,
00:39:33 not just Trumpism or the Republican Party, but him, which is quite deep in the liberal theory
00:39:40 and inheritance, I'm not even sure people totally realize
00:39:42 that they have absorbed,
00:39:44 is the sense that to make a country work,
00:39:46 people have to behave in a certain way towards each other.
00:39:48 And the ways in which he flouts the rules of behavior,
00:39:53 the ways in which he acts towards others.
00:39:55 Mm, mm, you hear that? 0.99
00:39:58 That incredibly female indignation, mm. 0.83
00:40:01 Their people are almost separate from anything he believes, 1.00
00:40:05 like a profound challenge to what liberalism,
00:40:08 what liberalism believes of how you make a society work i think in many ways he is proving that there
00:40:14 was something um important in that but but this question so of course they hate trump right like
00:40:22 that's that's the whole mission here is to hate trump and they say okay well trump is crass and
00:40:28 the way he treats people talks to people that that offends my liberal sensibilities and that's why
00:40:33 he's so terrible like apart from anything he believes or does just his mannerisms are illiberal
00:40:38 And that's the problem, because he's so, you know, caustic. He's so not careful with his language. He does not feel aristocratic. All right. So fair, like Trump is brash. He is bold. Many people love that about Trump. But it's it's fair to say that Trump does not act like normal politicians. He does not carry himself with an air of decorum. He says what he means. He gets right to it. He's very uncareful with his language. Right now, again, a lot of people like that.
00:41:06 a lot of people hate it but they're pretending like trump is somehow unique in this way which
00:41:11 is of course not the case at all look at the left right now was jasmine crockett aristocratic
00:41:18 is aoc aristocratic careful with her language cautious about how she treats people or addresses
00:41:26 people ilhan omar are these people careful with their language no they're around saying 1.00
00:41:33 white people are stupid they're they're you know we should eliminate whiteness uh we know the the 1.00
00:41:38 patriarchy is evil uh you know red state americans are stupid and ugly uh they're all racist they 1.00
00:41:44 all this stuff right like that's how they live their lives yeah they run around uh you know 1.00
00:41:49 using like ridiculous vernacular uh you know assaulting people verbally like all this stuff
00:41:55 and and it's like oh but trump came up with this no like again you can feel how you want about 0.88
00:42:00 Trump's behavior, his mannerisms, but pretend like it's a one-sided deal, like Trump is some
00:42:06 kind of unique force and the right has embraced this crude, completely illiberal, completely
00:42:12 unvirtuous guy who up there is in no way aristocratic. Well, you have too. You have
00:42:20 embraced and celebrate that behavior. So at the very least, you could say this is a general
00:42:25 breakdown for our society but trying to point to trump as if he is somehow uniquely an avatar of
00:42:31 this is insane of how do you instill in a society the virtues necessary to make a society work
00:42:39 understanding that as an actually hard problem yeah i think there's juice in that today yeah
00:42:44 no absolutely and um the the fact that they're elitists i mean i think it was i think you
00:42:50 mentioned that liberals throughout their history have tended to be elitist, but they demanded a
00:42:57 lot. There were a lot of obligations and they took that extremely seriously. There's a section
00:43:02 in my book where I talk about Lincoln and how much he was admired by liberals who are very
00:43:09 worried about this problem of elites, you know, perhaps not being able to show people how to
00:43:16 behave and to be the kind of leaders that a liberal society needs. And they thought, you know,
00:43:21 at that point, they thought maybe a liberal democracy would fail. There was no real example
00:43:26 of it lasting. You know, would the American example, this exceptional example, actually
00:43:32 work? And Lincoln showed that he could, and he did it in this beautiful way that kind of
00:43:39 made people optimistic about liberal democracy. He
00:43:46 what i'm sorry i'm sorry what are you talking about abraham lincoln saved liberal democracy
00:43:55 by having the bloodiest war in american history on american soil he saved liberal democracy
00:44:04 by putting the south under military occupation by suspending the constitution by having the
00:44:13 constitution basically rewritten at gunpoint the idea that abraham lincoln was this you know
00:44:21 completely liberal leader who inspired people to to really re-embrace liberal democracy no he shot
00:44:28 people who disagreed with him like that was the plan again you can feel how you want about that
00:44:33 you can say ultimately that kept the union together uh slavery and whatever right but like
00:44:38 this is again radically a historical you're just gonna gloss over the entire civil war
00:44:45 the suspension of habeas corpus the burning of the south the military occupation of reconstruction
00:44:52 and we're gonna say that abraham lincoln saved liberal democracy the 14th amendment
00:44:58 basically destroying states rights
00:45:00 bringing in birthright citizenship as we now understand but yeah lincoln saved liberal
00:45:08 democracy now again you could still think he's a great president you could still think he did
00:45:12 the right thing but he was not liberal in any of those senses he did not resolve political
00:45:18 differences by having discussions in the marketplace of ideas yeah he had famous debates
00:45:24 and when that didn't work he shot people again okay fine like that's that's the way of the world
00:45:30 I'm not going to sit here and ultimately be like, I can't believe someone conquered someone else.
00:45:35 But that's what happened. 0.72
00:45:36 Lincoln conquered the South.
00:45:38 The end.
00:45:39 It was not liberal.
00:45:40 There's nothing liberal about it.
00:45:41 What are you on about?
00:45:43 Was not a demagogue.
00:45:45 He did not talk down to people.
00:45:47 He raised them up.
00:45:48 He engaged in moral uplift.
00:45:50 And they recognized that.
00:45:52 And it showed that a liberal democracy could survive if it had a leader like this.
00:45:56 They also recognized that those kinds of leaders are very hard to find.
00:46:00 What is liberal in the liberal arts?
00:46:02 The purpose of the liberal arts education is really to form leaders, to form freedom-loving and moral leaders and giving them the tools, rhetoric and history and some science for sure.
00:46:16 But it's supposed to train citizens, really, through engagement with the classics.
00:46:21 In the early times, there was a lot of emphasis on being able to speak in public.
00:46:26 So, again, all of this is true.
00:46:28 they wouldn't have thought of this as a liberal arts education but again like you know we're
00:46:33 taking all of the modern ideology and we're forcing it down onto history we can't actually
00:46:38 treat history as it was we have to view it through the lens of our modern ideology we're trying to
00:46:44 ultimately justify even though we hate all of the historical figures and we gotta stop every few
00:46:49 minutes to remind you about that but she says here well they read the classics okay well guess who's
00:46:54 really against reading the classics right now liberals we're banning the classics we're 0.61
00:47:00 replacing with books by like a black woman from the 1980s the the past is too white remember 0.93
00:47:07 the the authors of the past are too european too white too male we have to get rid of all of those
00:47:15 books even when we go back to something like the odyssey or the iliad we need new translations by 0.98
00:47:21 radical feminists and those are the ones we're going to follow because even the past can't be 0.55
00:47:27 authentic it must be re-viewed through this liberal feminist modern lens so even in even if 1.00
00:47:36 we're going to grant her that this was a liberal education which it was not but even if we're going
00:47:40 to grant that like incredibly modern premise she rejects it the left rejects it they're adamantly
00:47:46 against it get rid of shakespeare bring me more poetry from you know sub-saharan africa that's
00:47:54 liberalism today has nothing to do with looking at the classics and why do you look at the classics
00:47:59 by the way why are the classics important oh because they teach you about your people
00:48:04 your history the beliefs of your tribe your descendant that you're descended from
00:48:11 it's your tradition and they never bring that in they want to they want to link things to the
00:48:19 liberal tradition but they don't want to actually engage in it because the people of the past are
00:48:24 dirty and racist and believe in hierarchy and patriarchy and all these things like um to speak
00:48:29 in a convincing way in public and this is all really to convince people to become citizens 0.88
00:48:36 and to do the right thing it sounds terribly idealistic and i don't always want to again
00:48:40 idealize them or say these people were were perfect in every way far from it but the ideas
00:48:46 were pretty beautiful and i think we could we could uh learn something from them at what again
00:48:51 gotta stop gotta stop every 10 minutes or so and say actually remember yeah these people were we're
00:48:58 we're talking about the history we're trying to connect it to the tradition but all the people 0.98
00:49:02 in the tradition were terrible people they were all racist they were all evil they were all sexist 1.00
00:49:07 They were all transphobic. They didn't peer into the future and see the trans surgery and know that in their heart men could become women. So we have to decry them, even though we're trying to connect this. And again, that's the beauty of this whole exercise. 0.99
00:49:21 ezra klein desperately sees a weakness in liberalism he desperately sees a failure of
00:49:28 liberalism but he is committed to the modern practice of burning your ancestors at the stake
00:49:34 and so he hates these people and so does she even though they're the very people they're trying to 0.93
00:49:40 stand on top of again we're trying to build on the shoulders of giants while chopping them off at the
00:49:44 knees point in your view did the strand of liberal thinking that was about the cultivation
00:49:52 and disciplining of the self oh drop out definitely it happened during uh the the cold war let's say
00:50:01 i mean this is uh and it's that's pretty recent in in the history that i describe in my book right
00:50:07 but this idea of disciplining the self or the we're talking about the collectivity about your
00:50:12 duties about um any government or state making and getting involved in forming citizens a public
00:50:20 education system that forms citizens started to have a a scary kind of ring to it when you've
00:50:26 seen fascism and communism and i liberals uh wanted to show like oh we're not that we're not
00:50:35 going in that direction uh this is so important and so revealing okay so this is the post-war
00:50:41 consensus that's what they're talking about this is basically the liberal inverted version of rr
00:50:48 reno's return of the strong gods when reno explains that after the cold war everyone was
00:50:53 so worried about these ideas of collectivity and fascism and all these and communism and all these
00:50:57 things that you had to banish the idea of having a national identity of having a history of having
00:51:03 a shared faith of having a shared identity you had to scatter everybody to the wind because you
00:51:08 didn't want to look like those other forms of government you didn't want to summon the ideas
00:51:12 of a mustache man from the 1930s that was what was so important that you had to stop and so it was
00:51:20 important to after the cold war become radical individualists if we can't collectivize behind
00:51:26 some kind of shared identity as americans because that'll make us look too much like nazis well then
00:51:31 the only other option is to become as radically individual as possible and that's what they're
00:51:36 doing here again they want this fruit of having a cohesive social identity but they want to destroy
00:51:44 everything that makes it real they want to destroy the roots the foundation that allows for that
00:51:52 collective understanding of the good that you can orient people towards that you can train them
00:51:56 towards but they they want to destroy everything that makes it real and so they're desperately
00:52:02 trying to construct the like edifice of a cohesive society on just this foundation of sand that are
00:52:11 really rubble that they destroyed they want to take a sledgehammer to this collective identity
00:52:16 tradition understanding but they ultimately want the fruits of it and so they they're desperate to
00:52:23 solve this problem but they have cut themselves off from all possible solutions they want virtue
00:52:30 they want a society oriented towards the good but they also want to destroy everything that
00:52:36 would drive people to understand why they should care about their neighbor why they should care
00:52:41 about the collective continuance of their society they want the tradition but they want to destroy
00:52:47 everything that came before them in the tradition it's insane it's it's fatal but it's fascinating
00:52:54 to watch because they don't get it ezra klein is never going to grasp this he can't grasp it if he
00:52:59 grasp it, it would destroy his worldview. I'm sure that's the same with her here.
00:53:03 We are not about the state forming citizens. We are about individual rights, about property
00:53:11 rights in particular. And I think that really gave probably the impetus to something that was
00:53:17 probably happening already. There's a real feeling among the religious that liberals look down on
00:53:22 them, you know, among evangelical Christians and others that they won't even, that they try to use
00:53:27 a state to change their behavior that, you know, you can't even refuse to bake a cake for a couple
00:53:35 that is getting married of the same sex. And so there is this critique of liberalism that you see
00:53:42 throughout the ages, which is that liberals are tolerant of everything but what they consider to
00:53:47 be the intolerant. And if they consider you to be intolerant, backwards, bigoted, then they will
00:53:52 bring the full force of the state if they control it down upon your head and it creates backlashes
00:53:59 but it is this very hard problem like this paradox of tolerance how do you tolerate people who don't
00:54:05 want to be tolerant how do you then not become intolerant yeah can you trace a bit of that
00:54:10 so they're just walking right into carl schmidt's critique of liberalism that liberalism for all of
00:54:19 its words about tolerance and multiculturalism and the toleration of the other, the acceptance
00:54:30 of others, for all of their words about neutrality and letting people be individuals and having
00:54:36 rights and doing what they want to do. Ultimately, behind all of that, liberalism has a worldview.
00:54:41 It has an interest. It has a friend-enemy distinction. It has people who it believes
00:54:46 should be in society the way that society should operate. So there are no neutral institutions.
00:54:52 There is no liberal society that allows people to be tolerant and free. It never exists. It's
00:54:59 simply a ruse. It's a guise. It's a layer of deception over the actual ideology that is
00:55:06 operating underneath, the actual belief system, the set of interests that are operating underneath.
00:55:10 And so when you buy into this idea that liberalism is somehow navigating these interests, you're blinding yourself to the fact that ultimately liberalism has its own interests, that the people behind it are the ones that are deciding where should we go and what we should do.
00:55:25 and they will drop the hammer on you the minute you fall afoul of that so it can never resolve
00:55:30 this problem liberalism can never ever fix this because it's not true liberalism is never about
00:55:37 diversity it's never about tolerance it's never about respect for others and klein acknowledges 0.68
00:55:42 this we can't have these evangelicals out there not baking gay cakes not in our tolerant society 0.86
00:55:49 that's intolerant because we don't tolerate christians in our tolerant society we only 0.99
00:55:53 tolerate homosexuals sodomy is the only thing we tolerate not not adherence to the word of god 0.99
00:56:00 that's liberalism to klein because that's his real religion that's his actual set of beliefs 0.99
00:56:07 that is his true political theology but he needs to hide it behind this veneer of liberalism again
00:56:13 carl schmidt tears this to shreds it in in uh you know uh his books it's it's fascinating to watch
00:56:21 I don't know if they ever solved that problem.
00:56:23 They were very, I mean, one has to, if you really try to understand the world from their
00:56:30 perspective, you know, it was really hard to be a liberal most of the time.
00:56:34 There were such formidable obstacles, such strong enemies, and such intolerance of their
00:56:41 views.
00:56:42 It was really serious stuff to think of the Catholic Church coming back into power, the
00:56:49 counter revolutionaries you know what what would happen to you so do you tolerate them do you allow
00:56:55 them to use the free press to uh to uh attack constitutional government at what point do you
00:57:04 censor we struggle with this today um and and they certainly did then there is interest so again
00:57:11 there is no answer to this they have no answer oh well yeah if people start writing stuff you
00:57:17 disagree with you censor them end of story that's the solution i guess we're struggling with a
00:57:25 little bit like but ultimately it's so hard to be a liberal and that you know if you let these
00:57:29 people get into power they're going to crush everything so again even when they go back
00:57:32 historically they just make the same justifications for what they did during covet what they do as
00:57:37 soon as they get back into power again today it's that they would become radically intolerant of
00:57:43 anyone who is not their version of tolerance there is no such thing as liberalism that's what they're
00:57:49 revealing liberalism is a lie it is a ruse it is an impossible way for society to operate if you
00:57:56 want a cohesive understanding of the good you must draw lines you must gatekeep you must decide what
00:58:02 is good and you must ban what is bad you must encourage the good and you must discourage the
00:58:08 bad that's what it looks like to have a cohesive society to achieve the things that they want
00:58:13 You must do these things. You must draw these lines, these batteries. You must be intolerant. So the liberalism that they so extol must behave as an intolerant force to create what the real society is, which is just this radical progressive leftism. It's not tolerant in any way, shape, or form.
00:58:30 Interesting argumentation over how much to think of the American founders as inside the American liberal tradition, as in tension with what later becomes a liberal tradition, right?
00:58:40 They're obviously claimed by all sides here.
00:58:42 How do you think about the founding and with its profound internal contradictions around freedom and human bondage?
00:58:51 I've become more and more interested in American political thought and institutions and history. Unfortunately, because of the way disciplines and concentrations work, I'm more of an expert on European history. But what I've read about the founding and about the founding fathers and what was going on there just fills me with enormous respect and gratitude.
00:59:15 so this is funny because like she starts by saying i don't really know much about the american
00:59:21 founding because i'm an academic and because of disciplines i only know my discipline which is
00:59:27 true it's kind of weird when i talk to uh college professors they're very very smart they're
00:59:33 oftentimes brilliant but they're very narrow like they're siloed they don't have anything outside of
00:59:38 their specialization so when you try to bring in broader topics even when it comes to political
00:59:43 theory of philosophy they they've only read democracy in america and they know it like the
00:59:48 bible they know it the the back of their hand they could quote it chapter and verse but if you ask
00:59:53 them how it interacts with anything else they're just like oh i don't know it's not my specialization
00:59:56 so she for some reason ezra klein brought on a woman who specializes entirely in european
01:00:03 understandings of history so she doesn't know anything about the american founding but she's
01:00:07 trying to talk about american liberalism and again this is the problem is they don't treat it as it's
01:00:13 own discrete tradition they try to universalize it whatever is true about liberalism in you know
01:00:19 germany or france has to be true in america well no actually not at all liberalism is very different
01:00:26 in fact question if they're even related in in you know totally but like she only knows the
01:00:33 european side and so she's just like fumbling around i think i like the founders i think i'm
01:00:37 supposed to say this and you'll see where it goes in a second and i think you know you know for for
01:00:42 the wonderful work that they did, being both thinkers and actors. And Frankl and Jefferson
01:00:49 came to Paris and were very much interested also in French matters and vice versa. The American
01:00:56 Constitution influenced early liberals because, you know, they thought it was an amazing, amazing
01:01:03 document. And maybe that's the thing that's so wonderful is to see exactly those things coming
01:01:12 together the ideas and the practices coming together in the in the founding fathers to
01:01:17 produce this amazing document that's a very glittering answer but but i think a critic of
01:01:22 liberalism would say that what good is your liberalism if it can include slavery in its
01:01:30 founding constitution or in more of the european case what good is your liberalism if it is so
01:01:35 interwoven with colonialism and i mean there were many you know people who certainly believed in
01:01:42 many liberal ideas we're talking about here who made space for both of those practices within
01:01:47 their liberalism right um well i don't mean to again idealize these um out of proportion these
01:01:55 people these are early liberals and liberals whoops whoops sorry sorry i didn't mean to praise
01:02:01 the founding fathers my mistake fine immediately goes to it right oh i see you said there was
01:02:08 something good about the american founding fathers will have you considered slavery gotcha
01:02:14 remember we're never allowed to go more than 10 minutes without saying how evil and racist and 1.00
01:02:20 stupid and patriarchal and sexist and homophobic everyone before us was because we're trying to 1.00
01:02:26 connect liberalism to a tradition but we hate every single person in that tradition and think 1.00
01:02:31 they were evil and to be fair this is not just a liberal thing it's not just a leftist thing it's
01:02:37 not just a progressive thing this is what a lot of conservatives believe this is what joel barry
01:02:42 believes he can't stop calling the founders racist when he's confronted with their words
01:02:46 because like he believes the same thing yeah there were some good ideas in the past but the founders
01:02:51 were a bunch of like evil racists and only once their beliefs were perfected by martin luther
01:02:57 king jr did we actually have real american values the constitution was actually always pointing
01:03:04 towards martin luther king jr the the founders were not honorable wise men who knew exactly what
01:03:11 they were talking about no they were flawed racist and yeah maybe they wrote down some nice stuff but
01:03:18 ultimately like their values had could not be realized until the the deified civil rights
01:03:25 movement brought them into the modern day that's what so many conservatives believe what they'll
01:03:32 say out loud and there's not a lot of space between them and Ezra Klein here and uh Helena
01:03:38 I believe her name is like the only difference is that uh the the conservatives will remember
01:03:43 that they're supposed to say but like George Washington's a good guy somewhere in between
01:03:47 that right like the only difference is that the hatred rip dripping from Ezra Klein is a little 1.00
01:03:52 more obvious as we're like conservatives are supposed to be like well they were just stupid 1.00
01:03:57 and ignorant and in the past and wrong but as we're like Ezra Klein and liberals can be like 1.00
01:04:01 oh, no, they were evil. Right. But otherwise, they have the same story. It's the same progressive 0.99
01:04:06 story. Many conservatives are just progressives in this sense. They've never been perfect. They
01:04:11 often suffer from the same prejudices, the prejudices of their time. There are
01:04:17 exclusions. But how did they grapple with this? I mean, we've talked a lot about freedom here.
01:04:22 How did they grapple with this? How did they grapple with this? I think there were,
01:04:28 I mean, other people can speak more intelligently about the U.S. Constitution and the slavery within the document and say that this is really a question also of compromise.
01:04:37 It's a horrible thing to imagine, but I think there was debates going on there and politics going on that are unseemly today.
01:04:45 And you have John Stuart Mill seeing absolutely atrocious things about how despotism is okay when you're dealing with barbarians or something, talking about British imperialism in India.
01:04:59 You have Tocqueville, who was okay, apparently, with burning silos in Algeria.
01:05:06 That's awful stuff.
01:05:09 But at the same time, these people were then from within, this was not a liberal position, I would say. This is, as many people were saying, you are betraying your own principles. And conservatives were also for, perhaps even more so for colonialism, imperialism.
01:05:28 I'm it's horrible to say, but racism was rampant. Sexism was rampant. If anyone was against it, if we can, we don't you know, they were liberals. It was kind of they thought that Napoleon would.
01:05:43 so again she's trapped here because she wants to revere some aspects of liberalism but then she
01:05:51 notes that these titans of liberalism you know people who i think of as radically liberal like
01:05:58 john stewart mill or a guy who's certainly championed democracy in america alexis de
01:06:03 toqueville these people when it came down to it they seem to value liberalism for their people
01:06:12 but they didn't care about liberalism in India or you know North Africa it's like yeah what does
01:06:20 that mean oh it means liberalism even in the you know tradition you're trying to connect it to was
01:06:27 always particular to its people whether you're John Stuart Mill or you're Alexis de Tocqueville
01:06:35 you thought liberalism applied to your people not everyone not to the Indians not to the people
01:06:42 of Algeria. You're actually fine with treating them differently because that's how everyone
01:06:48 understood the world. It was not a universal understanding or application of liberalism,
01:06:53 but they don't grasp that. They don't think that's, they think they can remove that element
01:06:58 of liberalism and keep the rest and keep it functional, but you can't because all the things
01:07:03 that you were talking about, about cultivating virtue and having a civic mindedness, they require
01:07:08 an idea of exclusive community. You can't be generous to everyone. You cannot be mindful of
01:07:18 orienting yourself towards the good of everyone because their goods are different and in conflict.
01:07:24 The world is not one universal place with one universal good. It is a place with many different
01:07:29 cultures and peoples with different goods and different needs, and many of them are directly
01:07:33 in conflict with each other but liberalism doesn't address this unless you understand it
01:07:39 as something that only applies to the people around you my buddy carl benjamin has a great
01:07:45 phrase liberalism is the sharia law of the british it is the way they live their lives
01:07:51 is what they believe and when you apply it just to them it seems to work but when you try to
01:07:58 universalize it when you try to take it to all these other nations and peoples who are no way
01:08:02 connected you know it seems to work in other places that are connected to the anglos but when
01:08:07 you take it to a bunch of people who aren't in any way anglo don't have the history don't have
01:08:10 the tradition liberalism doesn't seem to work there which is why liberalism was always elite
01:08:15 and always bound by an identity a people a place a country a nation instead of being applied to
01:08:24 everyone even its greatest champions did not see liberalism in this way and ezra klein and his
01:08:31 guests keep running into this problem over and over and over again and they just hand wave it
01:08:36 because they can't deal with it because if they did it would collapse their entire worldview 0.94
01:08:40 yeah there's a world where liberalism works it's where it applies to like a bunch of anglos or
01:08:47 maybe people descended from anglos who have that culture and have that tradition and have that
01:08:52 understanding maybe there's even like a french version but it only applies to the french it's
01:08:57 not universal you can't just put it on everyone and that's why all these liberal heroes keep
01:09:01 falling short for you because they understood something about liberalism that you don't it's 1.00
01:09:06 not that they were stupid or that they were wrong or they were you know ignorant it's that you are 1.00
01:09:11 you want to cut history off at the knees and then you want to build on it and it fails every single 1.00
01:09:17 time come and save the revolution so there was a lot of hope that this charismatic figure
01:09:22 who claimed to want to save the revolution,
01:09:26 was making all the right noises.
01:09:28 He was going to bring peace to France.
01:09:30 He was going to bring back order.
01:09:31 He was going to protect all these things liberals had fought for so hard.
01:09:35 And then instead, he became this despot and a demagogue.
01:09:40 And he used wars, you know,
01:09:46 to divert attention to what he was doing at home.
01:09:50 He gave gifts to people. He lined the pockets of his friends. He flattered people, gave them power, but at the same time that he amassed power in his own hands.
01:10:07 This was profoundly demoralizing to the early liberals that I'm talking about who had this lofty notion of what a freer, better, more moral, more humane world would look like.
01:10:21 And look what it derailed into.
01:10:25 So what did they learn from that?
01:10:26 They learned that you needed certain safeguards in place.
01:10:29 This is really when you get like liberalism as a constitutional way of thinking, balance of power, separations of powers, individual rights, freedom, how important freedom of press is, how important freedom of religion is.
01:10:46 Napoleon used religion, you know, to buttress his power.
01:10:51 So all of these constitutional ideas really came together then.
01:10:56 and they so they want to complain about napoleon and they want to complain about napoleon because
01:11:01 obviously they want him to be trump like you'll see even more clearly in just a minute here why
01:11:06 that's true but the complaint but again the point she's making here is wildly a historical
01:11:11 she is not a historian or if she is and this is what passes for his uh history departments
01:11:17 in the united states then it's time to throw the entire university system into the blender
01:11:21 like just burn it down salt the earth be done with it raise them to the ground salt the earth
01:11:26 it's over okay so the french invented separations of powers now in liberalism after napoleon
01:11:35 no not even close not even close baron de montesquieu was writing about separation of
01:11:43 powers 100 like at least 100 years before this happened it was in the constitution because
01:11:48 baron de montesquieu was writing about it right like that's the point that the french were already
01:11:56 seeing this but and you know where baron montesquieu got this you already saw the separation
01:12:01 powers you know why he idealized this idea these restrictions on government because he was admiring
01:12:06 the british government which put some of their power in the king and some of the power in
01:12:10 parliament and some of the power you know you know in the church and all these places and that these
01:12:14 things seem to balance each other like that's what he was excited about so the idea that the
01:12:20 french didn't know about this before napoleon came to power is insane ahistorical entirely
01:12:27 but also it excludes once again the idea that these things already existed
01:12:33 in the english government and that's where moscue was drawing them from
01:12:38 they were bound to a specific tradition he was admiring a specific tradition
01:12:44 from a specific people so once again she is entirely rewriting history ignoring the founding
01:12:51 of america the fact that a frenchman had already wrote about these ideas and that's where americans
01:12:56 got the idea for the constitution in the first place the idea that those ideas came from the
01:13:01 british who had been practicing them for a long time but again we can't contextualize any of this
01:13:07 we can't tell any real history and again ezra klein is just nodding along because he doesn't 1.00
01:13:12 know anything about history these people are idiots or they're liars maybe they know all 1.00
01:13:19 these things maybe klein knows all these things maybe she knows all these things maybe they're 1.00
01:13:23 all just putting on the show for their readers and they know they're idiots but either way the 0.99
01:13:29 point is this is supposed to be a discussion about the historical tradition of liberalism 0.99
01:13:33 and at no point has there been any real history here
01:13:37 outside of the whole virtue is oriented towards the good stuff you know that i i praised at the 0.77
01:13:43 beginning i was glad that they got into other than that this has just been a farce it's ridiculous
01:13:48 you know it happened again and again over the course of the 19th century that you have these
01:13:54 very clever charismatic figures who could speak directly to the people i understand you i represent
01:14:02 you it i don't need these we don't need these representative institutions we don't i because i
01:14:08 speaks directly to you i am you sort of i mean that's what a demagogue does and that's what
01:14:12 populism is right is that you don't need the intermediaries so of course we hate populism
01:14:19 right we love democracy but we hate populism why oh well are they the same thing no no no
01:14:25 populism is very different populism is when the leader speaks to the people and goes around all
01:14:30 these mediating institutions. Oh, you mean all the things that will manipulate and control the
01:14:35 process in your favor. That's why you hate Trump. That's why you hate the idea of populism,
01:14:39 because it's going to bypass all those institutions of control that you have set up in your favor to
01:14:45 make sure that your elite class rules. And that's why you hate populism. That's why you hate the
01:14:50 idea of right-wing populism, especially, because that's going to allow people to circumvent
01:14:56 all of the ideology all of the indoctrination all of the legalese everything else that you've
01:15:02 wrapped your system of control in and it's going to allow them to directly address the problems
01:15:07 of the people and there's nothing worse for liberal rule than the people actually getting
01:15:13 someone who cares about them actually getting somebody who wants to do something for the people
01:15:17 that's the worst possible thing all right guys i'm going to stop there like i said this is an
01:15:22 hour long plus conversation so if you want to watch the whole thing for context by all means
01:15:27 please do so it's over on the new york times uh or or i think ezra klein's youtube channel that
01:15:32 kind of thing uh so you can go check that out i do think it's a fascinating look into the mind
01:15:37 of the liberal these people trying to reconstruct this alternative history that justifies what
01:15:41 they're trying to do uh but i understand i watched it so you don't have to you don't have to do that
01:15:47 but again if you if you want to grasp it and get the full context by all means please do
01:15:51 let's head over to the questions of the people here
01:15:54 shrink this down
01:15:57 Ezra is uh Arthur in California says Ezra is the master of
01:16:03 sophist rhetoric for liberalism all of this hides his true desire for a blue
01:16:09 Caesar again I don't know him that well honestly
01:16:12 don't spend a lot of time thinking or you know listening to Ezra Klein
01:16:15 but I from his behavior here I think that's probably
01:16:19 probably correct
01:16:21 Wild Speaker says, liberalism has no blood in it anymore. The old problem of Thumos rears its
01:16:26 ugly head. Fukuyama is after Locke's, the most incorrect man to ever live award. Yeah,
01:16:33 very, very true. I mean, at least Locke was right about atheists, right? So he at least had that 1.00
01:16:38 going for him. Sir Blank says, USA liberalism in 2026, USSR communism in 1989. Yeah, I do think
01:16:48 that there's ultimately like something they're trying to avoid here that liberalism has you know
01:16:52 this very particular gradient that gets you to something that they don't want to admit uh and
01:16:57 that's why they're sitting around saying oh i don't understand why has this destroyed all these
01:17:00 identities uh well because marx told you that's what liberalism would do that's why he liked that
01:17:05 stage on its way to communism liberalism is a necessary agent of dissolving identities both
01:17:12 national and relational uh you know familial uh religious so that ultimately communism can
01:17:20 globalize that's what marx said about liberalism and so he loved that stage of liberalism he just
01:17:25 didn't want to get stuck there and they don't understand that or they don't want to understand
01:17:29 that and they don't understand why it is dissolved everything that they are trying to now put
01:17:34 liberalism back on it's dissolved that foundation uh blue gray says liberalism is when you can do
01:17:40 whatever you want as long as you're liberal and agree with me yes perfectly said perfectly
01:17:44 encapsulated uh weirdy curb says i remember when obama was elected all of my friends were talking
01:17:51 about the probability of his assassination because racist funny how that panned out yeah of course 0.96
01:17:56 right like that that was the idea is america's full of these racists and they're going to shoot 0.99
01:18:00 him immediately but of course it's donald trump that gets shot up because liberals are the violent 1.00
01:18:03 insane uh you know evil people and so they want to murder there are people who disagree with them 0.97
01:18:08 politically and conservatives didn't do any of that uh and a name i can't say uh says the gop 0.55
01:18:15 must fall or one the gop must fall to free the chud uh that's a lot of very online internet uh
01:18:22 there's a story i can't get into right now about this guy chud the builder i don't even i never
01:18:27 heard of him before i'd stopped it popped out and he i guess went up and uh you know said the
01:18:34 no-no word to black people and they got angry and he defended himself, I guess. Again, I don't
01:18:40 really know enough about it, so I can't speak intelligently about it. But I guess if you want
01:18:45 to understand that more, you can go check that out. All right, guys, I'm going to go ahead and
01:18:50 wrap this up. Once again, I want to thank everyone for coming by. It's always a pleasure to speak
01:18:55 with you. Fantastic audience today. Great questions. If it's your first time on this
01:18:59 channel, make sure that you are subscribing. You're clicking the like, the bell, the notification,
01:19:03 all that stuff it all helps out with the algorithm it all makes sure that you can see the content and
01:19:08 it grows the channel if you would like to get these broadcasts as podcasts you need to subscribe
01:19:11 to or macintyre show on your favorite podcast platform and when you do if you leave the rating
01:19:15 or review that helps with the algorithm there and of course my book the total state is out in
01:19:19 paperback now it's got a new chapter so if you're waiting for the paperback or you're waiting for
01:19:23 that new chapter it is available on amazon as we speak you can go ahead and pick that up thank you
01:19:28 everybody for watching and as always I will talk to you next time.