The Auron MacIntyre Show - November 16, 2026


My Journey from Normie to Monarchist ... And Back Again | 11⧸16⧸26

The GOP Train Wreck Gets Worse | 11⧸13⧸26

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 9 minutes

Words per minute

183.4

Word count

12,690

Sentence count

385

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

28

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Hey everybody, how's it going? Thanks for joining me this afternoon. I am Oren McIntyre.
00:00:14 We've obviously had an interesting few weeks. There's been a lot going on, but I wanted to
00:00:20 dive back into some theory today. I wanted to get out of the day-to-day grind and talk
00:00:25 a little bit about how we got here, not just here in this specific political moment, but
00:00:33 how many of us have journeyed through the different eras of politics that we're looking
00:00:39 at today. A lot of people have had different ideas, different approaches. That's certainly
00:00:44 been true of me. I've made some pretty big shifts along the way. I thought it'd be interesting to
00:00:49 just kind of dissect that intellectual journey because I think it tells us a lot about where
00:00:54 we've been and where we're going. I think a lot of people, you know, kind of go along this path
00:00:59 at one point or another. And so I thought it might be helpful if I broke down how I went through it
00:01:03 and how I responded and ultimately the conclusions that I've come to. So you can perhaps apply that
00:01:09 to yourself as well. So today I want to talk to you about the idea of American monarchy. Ultimately,
00:01:16 is this something that we should be investing in? Is this the solution to our problems? Is this some
00:01:21 crackpot theory that's been made up by kind of a synonymous, you know, internet political
00:01:28 philosophers. Are there any legs to this idea? Does it fit in our tradition? Does it actually
00:01:34 solve our problems? That's the kind of thing that I wanted to dive into today. So let's begin at
00:01:40 the beginning. Like a lot of people, I grew up as a talk radio conservative. I was one of those kids
00:01:46 who was obsessed with politics pretty early on because I'm very normal. So I remember listening
00:01:52 to the radio when I was 10 or 11 years old, hearing people talking about issues and ideas
00:01:59 and thinking that was fascinating, something that I wanted to hear more of. So I was somebody who
00:02:04 very early on was listening to political talk radio. Now, to be fair, I did not grow up in a
00:02:10 particularly political household. My parents were not super political. I mean, they were Republicans.
00:02:15 they were conservatives they talked about the issues of the day from time to time but you need
00:02:20 to understand this was not a household where fox news was on all the time or we always had the dial
00:02:24 turn to rush limbaugh in fact most of the time you know my dad was enjoying sports you know my mom
00:02:31 would sometimes listen in uh to the christian radio station dr dobson or uh you know those
00:02:37 kind of people but most of the time they just weren't really following politics it was kind of
00:02:43 me tuning in on my own but I did get really into political talk radio and later on especially when
00:02:49 I had jobs as like a courier in college I was driving all the time so I was listening to hours
00:02:53 and hours and hours of talk radio because well that was the best thing that was on you can only
00:02:57 listen to the same you know metal cds so many times I did start listening eventually to books
00:03:03 on tape but lots of conservative talk radio and so I had all the opinions that you would expect if
00:03:09 your diet was pretty steady uh dennis prager and michael medbed and sean hannity and those kind of
00:03:16 guys i did have a neil bortz or two in there you know still kind of cringy libertarian in some ways
00:03:20 but at least a little variation michael savage actually pretty good time but ultimately i had
00:03:27 a lot of the neoconservative mainstream political uh ideas that you'd expect from somebody who
00:03:32 tuned into this type of talk radio and i talked i brought that understanding into college i
00:03:38 eventually got a degree in political science. I ended up working on a few campaigns. And, you know,
00:03:44 these were, again, all just kind of the standard beliefs. Everyone had the same beliefs. They all
00:03:48 kind of understood that this was the way things worked. There wasn't a lot of variation inside
00:03:53 the movement at the time. I had heard about people like Pat Buchanan, kind of a little bit,
00:03:58 Ron Paul, these kind of people, but had never really paid a lot of attention to what they were
00:04:02 saying. And so I can continue to have those basic beliefs through my time working in politics,
00:04:08 though eventually I stepped out of that and ended up working in teaching and I became a local
00:04:14 reporter. But the thing that really started to shift me a little bit was in 2015, we started
00:04:22 to see the emergence of Donald Trump and the European migrant crisis. That one really took me
00:04:28 by surprise. I hadn't really understood. I mean, I never really liked immigration. I always
00:04:34 understood that it was a bit of a problem. But I more or less had that, well, you know, as long
00:04:39 as they're American, as long as they want to assimilate, you know, we are ultimately a nation 0.70
00:04:45 of immigrants or some such nonsense. We should probably, you know, close the borders so that 1.00
00:04:49 we don't have all these illegals coming in. But I never really thought of immigration as a large 0.99
00:04:54 scale issue, even though I didn't really like what was going on. And I saw what happened in
00:05:00 the European migrant crisis and just the way that the governments completely did not care
00:05:06 about their people. They were ignoring the rapes and the murders and the assaults. They were
00:05:14 ignoring the way that these new immigrants were transforming their countries, building no-go 1.00
00:05:19 zones, for Islamic neighborhoods where police would not venture into. They were not enforcing 1.00
00:05:25 the law when these men would assault women, these kind of things. And even when the people would
00:05:31 cry out and say, hey, we're not really looking for this, they try to vote to change it, nothing
00:05:35 happened. And so this, along with the arrival of Donald Trump on the scene and his message of
00:05:40 putting America first, closing the border, building a wall, this all made a lot of sense to me. But I
00:05:45 was still pretty normie Republican. You know, Donald Trump was shaking up some of my ideas of
00:05:50 what was going on. I saw the way that the media treated him, especially later on when I was part
00:05:55 of the media. And I started to see kind of the backroom dealings about how ultimately the media
00:06:00 framed these stories. It started to shake up my narrative a little bit, but I still more or less
00:06:05 believed in the same old American democracy. I thought that that was kind of the way things
00:06:10 worked. Power, as described to me, made sense. So not a big change there at the time. The thing
00:06:17 that really shook my world beliefs to the core was 2020. I had been watching a little bit of
00:06:25 online politics. I had watched this guy, Sargon of Akkad, and then this other guy, Dave the
00:06:31 Distributist, came on, though he was just going by the Distributist at the time. And Dave Green
00:06:37 had talked about a lot of ideas that seemed to really challenge Sargon in ways that I had never
00:06:43 seen before. Sargon had always kind of been a liberal, but like a moderate liberal, the kind
00:06:47 of guy you felt like you could get along with maybe. And he was ultimately questioning some
00:06:53 of those beliefs, it seemed like. And Dave was really part of that. It seemed like he really
00:06:56 brought some issues that Sargon could not address in kind of his classically liberal worldview.
00:07:02 And so I started watching this guy. He had mentioned a few times this guy Minchus
00:07:07 Mullbug, and those videos had been interesting, but I just, in general, still held the same
00:07:12 beliefs that I had held previously with maybe a few tweaks here or there. Ultimately, when 2020
00:07:18 came, things got insane. Obviously, the lockdowns with COVID and everything else really shattered
00:07:26 my belief in the constitution, the bill of rights as some kind of sacred barrier that would protect
00:07:32 us at any time. Uh, you know, we, we closed the churches, we closed our businesses. Everybody
00:07:39 sat at home and did what the government told them to. Uh, they all kind of sat around hoping that
00:07:44 they wouldn't be forced to take what could be a dangerous vaccine in order to go to work,
00:07:48 but nobody did anything. You know, I'd heard my entire life from libertarians and conservatives
00:07:53 that the Second Amendment was going to protect us from this kind of tyranny.
00:07:58 And then it did nothing.
00:07:59 It did nothing at all.
00:08:00 Nobody did anything.
00:08:01 Everyone came up with excuses as to why ultimately we could not do this.
00:08:06 And so the lockdowns were a complete success.
00:08:09 You know, nobody fought back.
00:08:11 Nobody did anything significant.
00:08:13 You know, I was in Florida, so I got the best of it because at least Ron DeSantis eventually
00:08:17 kind of unwound some of this stuff.
00:08:19 but still the fact that we had even engaged in it seemed to just completely shake my faith in
00:08:24 the government and our system to the core and the fact that the vast majority of the country
00:08:28 continued to engage with it you know basically everybody but florida just really told me that
00:08:33 yeah okay there was some pushback available but the vast majority of people in the united states
00:08:38 simply didn't care they didn't care about the freedoms they didn't care about their rights
00:08:41 the constitution the bill of rights were something nice in theory and abstraction but in practice
00:08:46 They did nothing. They stopped nothing. Everybody would just do what the government told them. Everybody would conform. Nobody would rise up. Nobody would stand up. That became very clear. And then things got worse. Not only did we have the lockdowns, but then we saw the BLM riots.
00:09:01 The press obviously went out of their way on a regular basis to try to find some victim.
00:09:07 They cycled through many, many, many different people of color who were getting abused by the police until they finally found George Floyd.
00:09:16 And that video ignited a lot of stuff.
00:09:17 And we suddenly had these violent protests everywhere.
00:09:20 People were burning stuff down.
00:09:22 And, you know, you saw these people and they were out in the middle of the street clustered together.
00:09:27 you know a lot of them wearing masks not because they thought it would stop the covid but because
00:09:31 they wanted to cover their face so they wouldn't get in trouble and the police did nothing they
00:09:35 let them burn they let them loot uh the the corporations uh the government in many cases
00:09:41 sided with uh the looters and the rioters uh again once again nobody actually cared about
00:09:46 the pandemic the it was this gave you know the obvious lie to the idea that the pandemic was
00:09:52 ever real that anyone ever cared about it that lockdowns were ever motivated by public health
00:09:57 uh and again no one did anything no one went out there and stopped anything uh you ultimately just
00:10:04 watched all these people rip your town apart uh the the few people who resisted ended up getting
00:10:08 you know stabbed or shot and for the most part the government punished no one there was no mass
00:10:14 arrests of rioters there's no installation of law and order by the government the people didn't rise
00:10:20 up and protect themselves it's just nothing happened i mean i think you guys remember that
00:10:24 couple i think it was in georgia been so long i forgot their name but it's the man and the woman
00:10:28 who stood there and tried to protect their homes from the mob uh and ultimately those two were
00:10:33 vilified they like lost everything you know people were threatening death threats and all this stuff
00:10:38 they almost faced criminal charges uh for just trying to protect their home so you know even if
00:10:43 you had guns and you tried to protect yourself the second amendment meant nothing because uh the the
00:10:47 government didn't care about your second amendment rights uh no one was coming to fight for them
00:10:51 Ultimately, if you tried to defend yourself with a gun, you were going to get destroyed, even if you successfully stop, buddy.
00:10:57 And they didn't even have to stop anyone.
00:10:58 They didn't even fire a shot.
00:10:59 But it didn't matter.
00:11:00 Just the fact that they stood up with guns meant that they had to be destroyed.
00:11:04 And so, you know, it just became very clear that none of this mattered.
00:11:09 And then we got, of course, to the 2020 elections where we, you know, randomly just went ahead and changed all of the rules for how elections work because of COVID.
00:11:17 and the results seemed very very very suspect so now we had lockdowns no one did anything
00:11:26 riots no one did anything if you tried you were threatened with criminal prosecution you were
00:11:31 destroyed in public you you had everything taken away from you and then we had elections that
00:11:37 ultimately seemed fraudulent and that you could change the rules for in a moment's notice
00:11:41 And so when you end up in a scenario like that, you start looking around and you say, oh, well, I need to figure out why this is happening.
00:11:49 I mean, I guess for a lot of people, they didn't.
00:11:51 The vast majority of people just moved on.
00:11:53 Whatever.
00:11:53 I guess, you know, they just didn't care.
00:11:56 But for me, this was a huge issue, especially because, you know, I had studied politics.
00:11:59 I'd worked in politics.
00:12:01 I wasn't like a political genius, but I knew enough to know this was not how things were supposed to work.
00:12:06 I was familiar enough with the documents and the philosophy and everything behind it to say, hey, you know, ultimately there's an issue here.
00:12:14 And so I decided I wanted to understand more, especially after I watched, you know, the J6 protests and the consequences of that. 1.00
00:12:23 What happened to the J6ers? It's like, oh, there really is just no chance that the people will overthrow the government. 0.99
00:12:30 Like even these people who walked into the Capitol weren't even armed.
00:12:34 like they obviously were not involved in an insurrection there's no chance they were going
00:12:38 to overthrow the government that day but it didn't matter like they still all had their lives
00:12:42 destroyed they all their constitutional rights were thrown in the shredder they were locked up
00:12:46 in solitary confinement for months and months years and years with no trial it was just very
00:12:52 clear what was happening here uh you know the entire political system was a lie that was that
00:12:56 was just very obvious so i needed to understand what was happening and like i said you know this
00:13:01 guy, David Stributis, who I thought was pretty insightful, kept referencing this guy,
00:13:05 Minchus Molebug. We'd later learn his name to be Curtis Yarvin when he started writing
00:13:10 under his real name. And so I just decided, okay, well, I guess I'll dive in and try to
00:13:15 understand what's happening with this guy. And Curtis Yarvin was a revelation at the time.
00:13:20 This was a guy who had an entire alternative way of looking at politics. He understood American
00:13:25 history differently. He understood constitutions and power differently. His entire story about what
00:13:32 America is and where it came from and where it was going was radically different. And so I dove
00:13:37 into his work. And not only did I dive into his work, I went spread out to the larger, what was
00:13:42 called the NRX, neoreaction sphere at the time. Guys like Nick Land, Spandrel, Jim's blog, a lot
00:13:50 of other guys. And they were all kind of writing in this vein. Some had different focuses. Land's
00:13:55 work was definitely very different from mold bugs, but was in dialogue with it and ultimately was
00:14:00 still pointing out a lot of the problems with primarily democracy. The one thing that most
00:14:07 of these guys had in common was that they thought democracy was a failed system, if it even existed
00:14:12 at all. It was mostly a sham. It was mostly a lie. Democracy was in no way reflective of popular
00:14:19 sovereignty or the will of the people. It was the carefully managed product of intellectual,
00:14:24 cultural, and economic elites who went out of their way to shape public opinion through things
00:14:29 like the university, the media, all of these different avenues of narrative shaping inside
00:14:35 the United States and the wider Western world. They tend to call this the cathedral.
00:14:40 You also saw a very interesting defense of monarchy. Nick Land appropriates a lot of this
00:14:47 from Hans-Hermann Hoppe, who himself appropriated it from Bertrand de Juvenal.
00:14:51 And so I realized I needed to start reading well beyond just these NRX guys. They were interesting, but I needed to have the underlying stuff, the basis on which all this was built. So I started going out and reading the original sources. I started reading Hans Hermann Hoppe. I went and read Bertrand de Juvenal. I went and read guys like Vilfredo Pareto and Robert Michels and Gaetano Mosca, the founders of Elite Theory.
00:15:20 I read James Burnham. I read his Machiavellians. I read his his managerial revolution. And all of a sudden, you know, the the world around me made a lot more sense. I could see that we hadn't had a real democracy or more importantly, a real republic in a very long time.
00:15:39 and so all of the excuses that I heard from my mainstream political sources those talk radio guys
00:15:46 that I used to listen to I mean there was still some truth in there but ultimately a lot of it
00:15:51 was based on a framework that was just a lie that did not exist when you talk about how well it's
00:15:56 the will of the people you should care about well no not if you actually understand how politics
00:16:00 works oh well you know the government's supposed to work for us not not us working for them well
00:16:06 know. That's actually not how politics works. Again, if you pay any attention to the actual
00:16:10 theory, the actual events on the ground, that's just not true in the slightest.
00:16:16 And so all of these kind of platitudes that I had ingested from the normal conservative movement,
00:16:23 they were falling away. Now, as you feel that structure fall away, it's very easy to then
00:16:30 adapt solutions without investigating them too thoroughly so a lot of smart guys like
00:16:37 Nick Land and Curtis Yarvin and you know Hoppe didn't embrace monarchism but he certainly
00:16:45 made a good case for it the same with Bertrand de Juvenal all these guys seem to make the point
00:16:50 that even if you didn't think monarchy was the best system it was certainly better than democracy
00:16:54 as we understood it now and so that really ended up with my thought at the time
00:17:00 so i started to look at monarchy and in a lot of ways it seemed to solve a lot of our problems
00:17:08 you know land and papa made the really good case that you have this investment in the people that
00:17:16 ultimately uh the the the difference in the difference in time preferences a lot low time
00:17:23 preference versus high time preference was a big deal that democracy was inherently a high time
00:17:29 preference form of government because the cycles were so short elections were always coming the
00:17:33 people always wanted more and the best way to win was to offer them more what was there and so
00:17:38 democracy just kind of eats itself constantly by having to deliver to the people what they want 0.96
00:17:44 no matter how stupid that is and only staying on top only staying in power if you're willing to 0.97
00:17:48 burn what is good now later for you know what benefits you now as where monarchy is something 0.99
00:17:54 that generally invests you in low time preference because the monarch is going to be in power no
00:17:59 matter what unless there's some kind of military revolution and so ultimately he cares over time
00:18:06 what happens the continuity of the civilization matters to him not only because he's going to
00:18:10 rule over it for 10 15 20 maybe even 30 years but because it's going to go to his children and his
00:18:16 grandchildren that inheritance basically creates the incentives of owning property you know this
00:18:21 is where papa's libertarian roots come in where all of really nrx's libertarian roots come in
00:18:27 where the idea of property rights making you a better decision maker really comes to fruition
00:18:34 you know if you look at who owns a democracy well it's definitely not the people it's a run it's a
00:18:40 set of elites that have to constantly win elections and so their time preference is very high they're
00:18:46 they're again willing to burn the future for their current power but the monarch because it's
00:18:51 shifted because they don't have to fight for power all the time they're going to be more likely to
00:18:55 take care of the country you know the classic analogy is the rental car versus the car you own
00:19:00 you have a rental car you're not taking it to get the oil change you're not careful about slamming
00:19:04 on the brakes you don't worry about accelerating or any of these things because ultimately you're
00:19:09 going to return that car after a couple days and you're never going to see it again so who cares
00:19:14 how you treat it if you own a car well you know that matters especially if you had to work hard
00:19:19 invest in it then ultimately you're going to take good care of it you're going to get the oil changed
00:19:22 you're going to be careful baby those brakes you're going to clean the car on a regular basis
00:19:26 same is just true of a country if you're going to own that country in perpetuity if it's not going
00:19:30 to be yours for two or four years but it's going to be yours for 10 20 30 years the life of your
00:19:35 life the life of your children your grandchildren all of a sudden the fact that you're handing down
00:19:40 that country, just like if you handed down a car to your child, you want it to be in good working
00:19:44 order. You don't want to hand your child your car if you've been beating the brakes off it and never
00:19:49 changed the oil and it's not safe. Same thing's true with the country. You're going to invest
00:19:54 more if you know that that's going to be handed off. There's also all kinds of other incentives
00:19:59 that don't work inside democracy. I've talked about them at length. I'm not going to go into
00:20:05 my full attack on democracy here as a system. But ultimately, the point is, monarchy looked like
00:20:13 it solved a lot of those issues. It solved the problem of democracy turning politics into this
00:20:20 constant partisan war that the elites are encouraged to aggravate all the time. It removes
00:20:28 the incentives of the elites to constantly manipulate the public into voting for them by
00:20:34 just hard coding propaganda into every single interaction. It reduces the incentive to create
00:20:41 a total state where politics permeates absolutely everything because, well, politics is contained
00:20:46 basically just to the king and the people who are working for him. No one else has to worry about
00:20:52 politics. Politics has been more or less solved in that scenario. And so you don't have this
00:20:57 constant battle for power which creates this incentive for people to kind of divide society
00:21:03 and so it felt like monarchy had a lot of great explanations for what was going on and how we
00:21:10 could fix it and it made perfect sense you know this was a a tried and true uh you know version
00:21:16 of government and the more i looked at history the more i learned the more i learned that
00:21:20 kings were not these like all-powerful you know god kings that i thought had existed previously
00:21:26 that were usually depicted in media and that kind of thing that usually kings had to constantly
00:21:32 battle for the right to rule they usually had to curry favor with their lords uh with their
00:21:38 bannermen their their barons their dukes uh that they were usually just one of of many elites as
00:21:44 opposed to like the singular elite that command everything and so in many ways uh monarchies had
00:21:50 been much smaller governments and this was really Bertrand de Juvenal's argument one that I still
00:21:55 find to be the most compelling if you haven't read on power just go do that now like I don't
00:22:00 know how many times I have to tell you this but if you need to read like one book on political
00:22:04 philosophy that's not like classic Plato Aristotle that kind of stuff go read on power go do it like
00:22:10 it's it's it's along with the Machiavellians one of the most important political texts you can read
00:22:16 so just go do that but Bertrand de Juvenal's argument was that the creation of democracies
00:22:22 that this idea of the rule of the people
00:22:26 had ultimately grown the size of government,
00:22:27 not constrained it.
00:22:28 That monarchies had been
00:22:29 far more limited governments in the past
00:22:32 and it was the creation
00:22:34 of these popular sovereignty-based systems
00:22:37 that really allowed the government to explode.
00:22:40 That they were really more of the product
00:22:41 of James Burnham's managerial revolution
00:22:46 and that the reason that you saw democracies
00:22:50 or liberal democracies
00:22:52 overtake monarchies was that they were better at centralizing power they were better at
00:22:57 centralizing production and consumption which was necessary in a modern post-industrial
00:23:03 revolution society and so this all just came together to make monarchy look like the solution
00:23:09 and was I a monarchist you know probably at some level I definitely thought that there was a lot
00:23:16 of merits I was definitely not hostile to this idea anymore and it looked like the solution a
00:23:22 lot of the problems so I would say that I yeah in a lot of ways I had become a monarchist I thought
00:23:26 that this was kind of the only way forward that we could address that you know that we could use
00:23:31 to address what was going on so I got to this point of thinking monarchy might be the solution
00:23:41 to our problems but did I stay there right like that's the big question well like I said I was
00:23:45 reading a lot of these different sources I was getting deep down into kind of all the different
00:23:51 layers that had contributed to these bodies of work that i wanted to understand better
00:23:54 but one of the things that i read in this was joseph de maestra now joseph de maestra was a
00:24:01 pretty big fan of monarchy in general uh certainly uh was a big fan big fan of authority he wrote
00:24:08 an entire book about the pope's temporal authority uh and how he derives it uh so you know joseph
00:24:13 de maestra is not scared of centralized power or centralized government or authoritarianism as many
00:24:19 people would would call it but the one thing that joseph de maestra said that really stuck with me
00:24:25 more than anything more than any of the monarchy stuff was that joseph de maestra said that
00:24:30 ultimately no people writes their own constitution which i thought was fascinating he said and and
00:24:39 this is great because you know he's writing this back in the time where people were not shy about
00:24:43 the reality of god and the divine order so he didn't have to hedge his bets on this he didn't
00:24:47 to have to come up with some kind of secular explanation in the way that i think a curtis
00:24:53 yarvin or others who had been fighting for monarchy had to for joseph de maestra constitutions were
00:24:59 written on the hearts of people by god god created us and he also created us as nations something
00:25:06 that a lot of christians want you to forget at this point oh we're all one nation we're all one
00:25:10 people under christ that's not true actually we're all brothers and sisters in christ right
00:25:16 but there's god still established in the nations you'll find the nations all the way up into
00:25:21 revelation and in those nations he made us different you know he shattered the tower of
00:25:26 babel for a reason he didn't want all of man working together he didn't want us all unified 0.85
00:25:30 and so each nation each people is different and distinct that doesn't make other nations or
00:25:38 people's evil or bad or less valuable than your own but it does mean that their ways are different
00:25:45 And it's okay for you to have a specific way and understand it and prefer that way.
00:25:50 And you don't need to be ashamed of that.
00:25:52 And you don't have to impose your way on everybody else.
00:25:54 But that's just the reality of human nature.
00:25:57 You know, we are different peoples.
00:25:58 We have different backgrounds, heritages, faiths, beliefs, traditions, folkways.
00:26:04 We live in different regions with different needs and desires.
00:26:08 And so ultimately, these things are going to be different.
00:26:11 And so we don't construct our governments from first principles. That's what Joseph de Maestro really tore apart for me was this idea that the founders got together and created the constitution from thin air. They just kind of thought a priori, okay, well, these are the best things, and so we're going to do those best things, and this will create the best government.
00:26:32 No, no, no. That's not what constitutions are. Constitutions are an instantiation of the way
00:26:38 of being a people. That way of being emanates from the people themselves. Americans were living
00:26:44 as Americans for hundreds of years before the constitution was written. Americans as a people
00:26:52 had existed for a long time before it was ever written down on a piece of paper. So the constitution
00:26:57 didn't make America, Americans made the Constitution. And that frame shift really
00:27:04 is important. That flip really blew my mind, completely shattered what I believed previously.
00:27:11 And so when I look at that, yes, I understand the values of monarchy, but I also have to say
00:27:18 myself, well, maybe then monarchy isn't like the one solution, actually. Maybe the problem is not
00:27:26 so much about systems right like that's the big thing about curtis yarvin and so many of the nrx
00:27:31 guys they were twiddling around with systems as if humans were just like some kind of hardware on
00:27:38 which you could run their software and so if you had the system aligned correctly if you created
00:27:43 the right incentives the right structure of government that's what would solve everything
00:27:47 And it's ironic because in many ways, this is the same failure that so many people commit with the Constitution itself, right?
00:27:59 Like normie conservatives, me as a talk radio conservative, I thought to myself, well, the reason America is great is because our founders created this incredible new form of government that was just so balanced.
00:28:12 It was so well done with all of these different checks and balances and, you know, the separation of powers and the restraints on the government and all of these different things.
00:28:23 What an amazing system.
00:28:24 And it's because they created this Rube Goldberg machine, like this new invention, this piece of political technology.
00:28:31 That's why America became great.
00:28:32 That's why we dominated.
00:28:34 That was the thing.
00:28:35 But that's not it.
00:28:36 That's not it at all.
00:28:37 that's not that's a huge mistake to believe that the constitution created americans and because
00:28:43 we'd set up the constitution this beautiful and infallible way that's why america became what it
00:28:48 was and of course curtis yarvin and these other guys saw that but their answer was just to come
00:28:54 up with another system a different system that would solve all of the problems and that system
00:29:00 would be more monarchical now it was updated curtis yarvin's monarchy wasn't just a a altar
00:29:06 enthroned monarchy from you know the 1400s or something he wanted a ceo to be king he wanted
00:29:12 the ability to be stakeholders and a board there's going to be this like crypto thing that
00:29:15 locked behind uh you know the the nukes uh or locked the nukes behind this wall and you had
00:29:20 to get the code from the board and then the that ceo would be in charge but he would have to
00:29:26 answer to these people and that you know there's all these extra layers but ultimately it was just
00:29:33 another system it was just another system that was being designed that would like perfect humans
00:29:39 and you could just you know kind of put it on everybody right but that's not the case and even
00:29:45 though guys like Joseph de Maestra favored monarchy the fact that he understood that this would not
00:29:53 work for everybody that different peoples were going to be governed differently in accordance
00:29:56 with what they believed and who they were and what God had frankly shaped them to be well that
00:30:02 meant that maybe monarchy wasn't just automatically right for America. Maybe that wasn't just the
00:30:07 system that solves everything. Maybe what we needed was not just a solution through systems.
00:30:13 Maybe we needed to contemplate something else. So when I'm looking at this, I'm also looking at the
00:30:20 fact that Joseph de Maestra said that over time, the constitutions of people change. That what's
00:30:27 right for the people in one era may not be right for the other. That God has put us on a path
00:30:32 that we develop these things over time.
00:30:35 And so just because you write a constitution in 1776,
00:30:39 it doesn't mean you're the same people in 2026.
00:30:43 And so maybe the constitution changes when the people change.
00:30:47 So just because you had one system right at one time,
00:30:52 maybe it's not the same at the other.
00:30:54 Now, I've also, of course, read a lot of other guys.
00:30:58 I've read a lot of the classic philosophers,
00:30:59 but I've spent a lot of time rereading a lot of my philosophers.
00:31:03 I've made rereading guys like Machiavelli and Aristotle every year just part of what I do.
00:31:09 I don't let a year go by where I haven't reread at least one book from Machiavelli and one book from Aristotle.
00:31:14 I just make sure I always do that.
00:31:19 And again, when you're reading great works, these things accumulate knowledge to you over time.
00:31:24 you know, if you've done any kind of scholarship, any kind of study, and again, I'm just some guy
00:31:28 with a bachelor's degree from a party school in Florida. But if you've done any of this kind of
00:31:34 scholarship over time, even if you're an amateur, you see the different aspects. There's so much
00:31:40 wisdom. It's so dense and the wisdom is so eternal that it's easy to glance over it as you're
00:31:47 focusing on one part or another. And so every time you reread a book like that, new things stand
00:31:52 out. You have new context. You're interacting with other thinkers, other ideas, other events
00:31:57 around you. And so you're understanding that you're pulling from those kind of changes over
00:32:04 time. And the thing about Aristotle is, of course, he understands that every government
00:32:12 kind of falls into one of three categories, right? It's the rule of the one, the rule of the few,
00:32:20 and the rule of the many. But for Aristotle, there are differences in these governments. He has
00:32:26 preferences in the systems, but ultimately he says every one of these systems has a good or a bad
00:32:32 version. You have democracy or you have a polity. You have a tyranny or you have a monarchy. You
00:32:41 have an oligarchy or you have an aristocracy. And what's the difference? What's the difference
00:32:46 between a tyranny and a monarchy? What's the difference between an aristocracy and an oligarchy?
00:32:52 Well, it's still all the same. It's still rule by one, rule by a few, or rule by many. The difference
00:32:57 is virtue. The difference is the virtue of the leaders. Are the leaders running the country in
00:33:05 their own interests, the nation in its own interests, or are they running it in the interests
00:33:10 of the greater good? And any one of these governments can be run for the interest of
00:33:15 the people in charge or for the greater good monarchies could be run for just the good of the
00:33:20 king that's a tyrant or it could be run for the entire good of the people that's a monarch
00:33:26 you could have the rule of the few be run for just the rich that's an oligarchy or the rich
00:33:35 could understand their role as leaders as people who have a noblesse oblige to the people that
00:33:42 they're ruling that's an aristocracy an aristocracy is a rule of a few that is done in the name of the
00:33:48 people well not maybe the name of the people is the wrong phrasing it's ruled for the common good
00:33:54 for the overall good of the nation you can have a democracy which is where the people just vote
00:34:00 themselves what they want all the time what we're seeing now or you could have a polity where the
00:34:05 people understand that they are trying to keep a greater good you know they're not just voting
00:34:11 themselves everything they want all the time and so while there are strengths and weaknesses to one
00:34:15 the few and the many ultimately you can have a good version of any one of these and so ultimately
00:34:22 it matters not just what system you have but what virtue the people possess and what kind of system
00:34:33 you have is going to be determined by what virtue your people possess so for instance Aristotle says
00:34:40 that if there's really only one virtuous man or one man who's so much higher in virtue on a regular
00:34:46 basis there's or there's like a line of these guys then you're going to end up with a monarchy
00:34:51 you're you're if you're if your nation your people is only really capable of producing like one
00:34:55 singularly virtuous and impressive individual well naturally that person's going to rule 0.95
00:35:02 So if it produces a whole class, a whole set of families, you know, kind of a whole set of gins that have virtue more than the average, well, then you're going to see more of an aristocracy, right? 0.98
00:35:17 Like you're going to see that the virtue is distributed.
00:35:20 They're less likely to just follow one guy.
00:35:22 The power is going to be more distributed, though still very limited to that class or that set of families that really maintain that virtue.
00:35:29 And finally, if the virtue of the people is high enough, they're going to want to have self-rule.
00:35:37 They're going to want to, at least at some level, be able to choose what's going on because they're just as virtuous as the leaders.
00:35:46 And so there's no reason that they shouldn't be able to take stock of what's going on there.
00:35:51 But you'll notice that never is Aristotle talking about freedom being the ultimate good.
00:35:59 In fact, he talks repeatedly about how democracy is a system driven by the desire for freedom over the common good and how that's deleterious.
00:36:08 so the the people who are virtuous even in a polity the good version of rule of the many
00:36:15 those people are still always fighting for the overall good not just their own good
00:36:21 they're they have that power because they are so virtuous that they don't need
00:36:26 aristocracy or a monarchy over them because they are capable of making all these choices now again
00:36:33 it is not about doing whatever you want again aristotle very important aristotle's very clear
00:36:38 that if you're just doing what you want if you if your desire to have power so that you can be
00:36:44 free and do whatever you want well then you're not virtuous at all and you're not you're not
00:36:49 ready for rule of the many that's a bad idea for you so the idea of just letting the people rule
00:36:55 because they need to be free because everybody needs to be equal that's bad that's the bad
00:37:01 version of rule by the many. But when everybody is so virtuous that you just don't need very much
00:37:06 government, well, then you might have a good rule by the many. And so you start to understand
00:37:17 that it's not just about the system. It's about the virtue of the people. And the virtue of the
00:37:24 people is far more likely to decide on the system rather than the system determining the virtue of
00:37:30 people. And that's really important because a lot of conservatives have this backwards. Guys like
00:37:34 Jeremy Boring and Joel Berry have made this argument that in order to be virtuous, you must
00:37:39 be free. But that's just not true. And it's especially like just unbiblical. If you look
00:37:45 at the Bible, in the Bible, there are instructions for how slaves should behave, how they can be
00:37:50 virtuous. And so it's very clear that the Bible believes that there is virtuous behavior that
00:37:57 slaves who are not free, who are literally owned human beings, that they can be virtuous.
00:38:03 And so there's no restriction on virtue simply due to freedom. Now, the good news is that if
00:38:10 you have enough virtuous people in your society, your society can be more free because it doesn't
00:38:15 need as many rules. It doesn't need that centralized power. It doesn't need the rule
00:38:20 of one great man or a handful of great families because you have virtue spread out over enough
00:38:26 of the population that they don't need that kind of thing. But there's nothing built in that says
00:38:31 that's true. And it's not a systems issue. It's not like you just drop a constitution on people
00:38:35 and they become virtuous. It's just not true. It's not like you give them liberty, you give them
00:38:41 freedom, which are not the same thing, by the way, but you give them those things and they just
00:38:45 become more virtuous. That's not true at all. In fact, in many cases, if you grant freedom to
00:38:51 someone who's not virtuous, you're just giving them license. If you give freedom to a drug addict
00:38:56 to do heroin you don't make them liberated you make them slaves they just become a slave to
00:39:02 themselves and their desires but they are slaves nonetheless and so a society full of people who
00:39:09 would use their freedom in that way will eventually end up with a monarch they'll end up with a
00:39:15 singular individual who's going to rule over them and that's not because a constitution said one
00:39:20 thing or a piece of paper said the other we set up rules in a certain way that's because that's
00:39:25 how human beings behave and organize. This is the real political science that Aristotle was doing.
00:39:33 And so before we ask ourselves, is our system tweaked exactly the right way?
00:39:38 Did we get the right bill of rights, the right constitution? Do we get enough articles? Did we
00:39:44 separate our powers properly? Did we check and balance our government? We have to ask ourselves
00:39:48 about the virtue of the people. That's actually what determines what our government is going to
00:39:53 end up being it's also a lot about scale and this is the other one that no one wants to talk about
00:39:58 because uh aristotle is very clear that you can only have uh you know that that governments can
00:40:06 only be so big especially when they're governments where people are elected he says look if people
00:40:11 are if you're electing your leaders and your government is so big that you don't even know
00:40:14 anything about the leaders you don't there's so much going on that you don't even know who these
00:40:18 people are you don't know their character well then how are you going to elect them and funny
00:40:22 funny enough, he also says, and if your country gets too big, how are you going to know that 0.96
00:40:26 foreigners haven't snuck in and taken over the rights of citizens and are manipulating your 0.87
00:40:30 government like we see today? And so it turns out that the type of government you have is not just 0.99
00:40:38 based on virtue, but it's also based on scale. There are certain types of governments we simply
00:40:43 cannot operate at a certain scale. And so we have to make choices between growing our government,
00:40:50 growing our people growing our country and keeping the type of government that we want to keep
00:40:57 we might not be able to do both and so when we're looking at our systems we need to understand that
00:41:04 they matter it's not like there aren't bad systems it's not like you can't make a bad
00:41:08 constitution or bad rules or bad laws but ultimately the paper the the you know the
00:41:14 The very clever scaffolding we set out for our political life, that is not going to matter as much as the virtue and the scale of what we're trying to do here.
00:41:25 And so after, you know, kind of going through this journey of starting as a normie Republican, believing in all of the stuff, you know, Constitution, Bill of Rights, Popular Sovereignty, the whole nine yards, I come back around, you know, to this position.
00:41:42 I'm in monarchy. I'm thinking, okay, this is the solution to the problem. But as I'm looking at
00:41:46 these ancient thinkers, I realize, whether it's Joseph de Maestro or Aristotle, that there's just
00:41:52 a lot more to this than slapping monarchy or republic or democracy or whatever on the side.
00:41:59 That actually this is a far more complicated thing and that ancient thinkers have really
00:42:04 delved into this and that we need to pull that wisdom. And of course, one of the big things that
00:42:09 i believe in because of aristotle is virtue ethics and tradition i also you know when i look at
00:42:15 someone like alistair mcintyre who might be able to guess i'm a big fan of i think about the fact
00:42:22 that tradition is so critical and the continuity of tradition is so critical and so if i'm someone
00:42:26 who's going to be defending tradition if i'm going to be defending the traditional understanding
00:42:32 of a kind of continuity and what people are well i should probably look at my own tradition i should
00:42:38 Look at my own founding fathers.
00:42:41 And so, you know, I went back.
00:42:42 Now, I've read the Federalist Papers and other stuff.
00:42:44 But, you know, again, when you're reading through these things and you're really looking
00:42:48 at them, what you can see, what you're perceiving can change.
00:42:53 So, when I'm looking at the Federalist Papers, when I'm looking at the letters of people
00:43:01 like hamilton or madison or jefferson or you know any of these guys i recognize that uh there's a lot
00:43:10 of interesting thought put into the system we ended up with and what it's based on and when
00:43:19 you look at the actual founders and what they really believed it's very very very different
00:43:24 than talk radio conservatism and i'm sorry i like i i know this is going to hurt a lot of people but
00:43:30 the talk radio hosts have been feeding you just lies about america for decades and decades i don't
00:43:35 think they're intentional i think a lot of those people really believe that that's what the founders
00:43:40 meant but most of what they're doing is playing a game of telephone with the founder they heard
00:43:45 from somebody else who heard their teacher told them another you know thinker or another radio
00:43:51 host or another writer told them a television told them a movie told them that this is what
00:43:55 founders believed and so they're repeating a copy of a copy of a copy of a copy of what the founders
00:44:00 believed but if you actually look at what the founders believed it's pretty radical compared to
00:44:07 today and we know this for a fact because again for a while there on uh on twitter uh there were
00:44:13 a number of people who made a game of quoting uh the founding fathers to people like joel barry and
00:44:18 james lindsey and insurrection barbie and they called these founders racists my buddy dave green
00:44:24 did this to joel barry on in a debate on benjamin uh boyce's uh youtube channel he just said okay
00:44:30 here's what they believed are you going to call them a racist and inevitably barry had to be like
00:44:35 yeah because because when you actually look at what the founders believe it's very very different
00:44:40 go check out the immigration act of 1790 it tells you that only white men of good character should
00:44:45 be coming to the united states now you believe that or not but like ultimately that's what the
00:44:50 founders believe that's what your founding generation passed into law i've heard a lot of
00:44:54 people try to be like well that was the most inclusive thing up to that point blah blah blah
00:44:58 yeah whatever man like make up whatever you need to but like that's what they really believe now
00:45:02 you could say well we need to leave that behind whatever but understand what you're saying
00:45:06 ultimately is uh the founders were wrong and we need to change what they did we're progressing
00:45:12 beyond them we're progressives we're going to change what the founders did now of course the
00:45:16 founders also wrote a constitution with slavery i don't really want black people to be enslaved i
00:45:21 don't think that's a good move so yeah in some ways i guess i'm progressive too right like
00:45:25 ultimately i think that some aspects of the constitution had to shift over time but then
00:45:31 if i paid attention to guys like joseph de maestra i would know that the constitutions always change
00:45:36 over time that the people always change over time but if we're going to claim the authority of the
00:45:41 founders if we're going to claim the authority of the tradition we need to be honest about what they
00:45:44 really said what they really believe. And what the founders believed is very radically different.
00:45:48 But interestingly, when you look at the founders, a lot of them worry about immigration from
00:45:52 Europe, specifically Catholic countries, because they say, oh, well, these people are going to be
00:45:57 monarchists. They're not used to living in free societies like we are. Now, you know, all these
00:46:03 guys had just come from England, which had a monarch, but obviously it was kind of a different
00:46:07 system. England had a much longer tradition of restraining its monarchs than many Europeans.
00:46:12 but you know if i'm taking the founder seriously i have to take seriously the fact that they were 0.68
00:46:17 obviously saying we should limit immigration even of white people from europe if they might be more
00:46:23 likely to believe in monarchy so that's part of our tradition that's what our people believe now
00:46:28 this could be a little complicated because for instance alexander alexander hamilton one of the
00:46:34 presidents to be lifelong basically an elected monarchy so even inside the american system there
00:46:39 was kind of a understanding that you could have monarchical aspects without being a a true uh
00:46:45 you know centralized uh monarchy that the mixed government was not something americans came up
00:46:51 with mixed government goes all the way back to polybius and aristotle the mixed regime was often
00:46:58 thought of as being one of the best if not the best by many of the ancients so the idea that
00:47:04 you'd have aspects of monarchy and democracy and oligarchy or aristocracy all mixed together
00:47:09 that was already a firm part of the political tradition well before americans wrote a
00:47:15 constitution so the idea that we just kind of thought that up that's just not true that's been
00:47:20 a part of political theory since really its beginning its inception so sorry we didn't we
00:47:25 didn't invent checks and balances or separation of powers guys i hate to break that to you but
00:47:29 this stuff was already well understood way back when the ancient greeks were writing
00:47:34 now again the constitution changes over time and people's change over time you know polybius
00:47:43 talked about the cycle of regimes uh you look at someone like oswald spangler talking about
00:47:48 the cycles of civilization i'm a big believer that there is truth to this that our kind of
00:47:53 people and our systems naturally change and flow over time and that you know i don't know if there's
00:47:59 a hard cycle of regimes that we always go in fact aristotle argues that there isn't that there
00:48:04 you know he gives alternate examples where the regimes did not cycle the way that it was expected
00:48:09 that was predicted by this theory but i do think there is ultimately truth that we are always kind
00:48:14 of moving through different forms of government and so it's probably unlikely that america is
00:48:19 going to continue its same form of government for its entire existence and a lot of people act as
00:48:24 if that's the end of america but i mean you know france isn't over because it went from a monarchy
00:48:29 to a republic you might say you know it's better as one or another but ultimately france still
00:48:36 exists the romans went from being a monarchy to a republic to an empire with a king again
00:48:45 you know so you know these things are real you know this is obviously the case where you could
00:48:51 go from a monarchy to, well, really an aristocracy and then a republic and then a monarchy again
00:49:01 with an emperor. You can go through the whole cycle and still be Roman, right? So just because
00:49:06 your government changes, that doesn't mean you have to change. And so I guess I'll bring this
00:49:10 home by saying this. It could be ultimately that America does get a monarch. In fact, I think the
00:49:18 very likely outcome is that we're probably heading towards authoritarianism of one type
00:49:23 or the other. It's going to be right-wing authoritarianism or left-wing authoritarianism.
00:49:27 But from the indicators I'm looking at, from all the political theory I've read, 0.91
00:49:33 when you create a multicultural empire, the only thing that really holds it together
00:49:39 is strong authoritarian government. You really need that central galvanizing figure that kind 0.87
00:49:47 of cuts through all the disagreements puts all the different people in their place and allows
00:49:52 these things to work you look at something like a Lee Kuan Yew in Singapore and when he when 0.87
00:49:56 Singapore was starting out it was just this backward third world uh you know nation without 0.95
00:50:02 indoor plumbing and in a few decades Lee Kuan Yew just pulled off this miracle and he was very
00:50:09 explicit as to how he did it he said there's no way the democracy was going to work in Singapore 1.00
00:50:14 because there's just too many ethnicities, too many cultures, too many religions, 0.98
00:50:17 and everyone's just going to vote with their religion or their race.
00:50:20 And so you needed a strong hand.
00:50:22 You needed a man of iron to run Singapore.
00:50:25 The future belongs to those who can kind of bind those groups together.
00:50:31 And unfortunately, I think that might be true in the United States.
00:50:33 But I do want to be clear.
00:50:34 I don't know if that makes it desirable.
00:50:37 I wouldn't describe myself as a monarchist at this point.
00:50:41 I'm not wishing for a king
00:50:44 in fact I think in many ways
00:50:45 it kind of directly
00:50:47 contradicts our tradition
00:50:49 our heritage
00:50:50 I think that at one time America was a country
00:50:53 that was virtuous enough
00:50:55 for the many to rule
00:50:56 we didn't need a centralized government
00:50:59 we didn't need a monarch
00:51:00 we didn't need even an aristocracy
00:51:02 though in retrospect it might have been better to
00:51:04 make our aristocracy a little more formal
00:51:07 the wasps kind of shirked that responsibility 0.99
00:51:09 we destroyed the aristocracy in the south
00:51:11 the civil war and we've just never had a ruling class that we understood properly as such since
00:51:16 but the point is at one point america was capable of individual self-rule and that was not a mistake
00:51:22 it was not a whoopsie the the the founding fathers didn't make a mistake by creating a government
00:51:28 where the people really did have a lot of power again they didn't have all the power we actually
00:51:34 restricted a large amount of democracy the founders actually decried democracy repeatedly
00:51:38 You find everybody from Benjamin Franklin to Alexander Hamilton saying democracy is a huge mistake. It's the worst of all governments. It's dangerous. But ultimately, they did understand that the people should have more power than in previous governments because they were virtuous enough to actually do that.
00:51:57 so we have to make some decisions if we believe that republicanism really is the true constitution
00:52:09 of our people truly the way that we should be governed well then we have some pretty radical
00:52:14 changes to make and this is the point of this talk right here this is the point if you want
00:52:20 to return america to being a real constitutional republic not the you know basically secular
00:52:27 secularly religious atheistic uh oligarchy we have today marating masquerading as a democracy
00:52:34 but a real republic like when you know when you always hear people say oh we're not a democracy
00:52:39 we're a republic no you're not you don't even know what a republic is you have no clue what a
00:52:44 republic is and uh even if you did like the democracy that we have today looks nothing like
00:52:50 it. But if we want a real republic, we would need a revolution in this country as dramatic
00:52:57 as if we were going to get a monarch, maybe even more, actually. Yeah, I'm actually going to hold
00:53:03 to that right here. Becoming a republic again would be harder than becoming a monarchy for
00:53:09 the United States. It would be more of a revolution. More of a revolution is necessary
00:53:14 for america to become a virtuous constitutional republic again than to become an empire under an
00:53:23 emperor and i'm going to explain why the reason is that if we were going to really become a republic
00:53:31 we would need to match the requirements of what people like aristotle or machiavelli or the
00:53:38 founders said about a republic okay so what is a republic in their eyes what's a real republic
00:53:44 first the franchise is limited
00:53:49 to the people who fight yeah that's right good old service guarantees citizenship
00:53:56 bacchiavelli said that republics need to have virtue and can only be defended by their own
00:54:05 citizens. They should not
00:54:08 have mercenaries. They should not
00:54:10 have professional standing armies.
00:54:11 They should be defended by militias
00:54:14 of their own people who have the right of
00:54:16 representation. Aristotle
00:54:18 said that the citizen is he who
00:54:20 is armed. He says this multiple times in the politics.
00:54:22 Citizenship belongs to those who 0.54
00:54:24 have arms and are willing to fight
00:54:25 to protect the country.
00:54:27 The founders structured
00:54:29 our country to
00:54:31 more or less only have
00:54:33 the guys who were going to be fighting for the country
00:54:35 voting at the time he needed to be a land-owning white guy that was you know kind of the requirement
00:54:42 and most of those people were the people who were part of the militia
00:54:45 if you look at the federalist papers you can see hamilton saying hey you need to turn over
00:54:54 militias to uh to the federal government i know you have the state militias but we need you to
00:54:59 fight up on behalf of the federal government because if you don't then the federal government
00:55:02 we need a standing army and we all know the standing armies are the doom of republic
00:55:05 by the way Machiavelli said that that's a very was a very common understanding standing army
00:55:13 was the doom of a republic so first and foremost we'd have to reduce the franchise down to
00:55:20 men who own land and will fight for the country and I've never been in the military so to be
00:55:27 clearer that's going to exclude me right there i'm not telling i'm not telling you anything to
00:55:31 flatter myself here these are just the cold hard facts of what all great thinkers thought
00:55:36 a republic had to be structured around so you're going to need to drastically reduce the franchise
00:55:43 you have to get rid of this idea that everybody who comes in as a citizen birthright citizenship
00:55:48 is out of there the idea that everybody comes in and they and they can or everybody who's born here
00:55:54 gets a vote gets to say nope that's done you also need to drastically shrink the size of the country
00:56:02 which is probably not going to happen which is why we're not again this is this is why i'm saying
00:56:07 it was would be much harder for america to become a republic again than it would be for it to become
00:56:15 a monarchy or some kind of authoritarian rule over an empire you would need to shrink the country
00:56:22 down the country is too big to function as a republic it was never supposed to be this way
00:56:28 we were supposed to be a collection of 13 states and by states they meant countries
00:56:31 the word state in america just means like regions we govern but they originally states because they
00:56:37 had their own authority they had their own governments they had their own constitutions
00:56:40 and so we were never meant to be a continent spanning empire that operated as a republic
00:56:48 You simply can't do that. It doesn't work. For all the reasons I've already explained.
00:56:55 Washington made it clear that you didn't want to involve yourself with foreigners, foreign alliances, foreign wars, because you needed to, a republic needed to be free of foreign influence.
00:57:06 And if you have favored countries, extended alliances, if you're fighting wars all the time, that was going to invite foreign influence into the country.
00:57:12 so we need to purge all of those relationships and get rid of our status as the world police
00:57:19 and shrink down he washington said that foreign influence is the death of republics
00:57:26 so in order to become a republic again we would need to limit voting to a militia we would have
00:57:36 to replace standing armies with militias we would need to shrink the country down significantly we
00:57:42 We need to withdraw from foreign commitments and end any alliances and stop being the world's police.
00:57:49 And the hardest one, this is the last one, we'd have to become virtuous again.
00:57:54 We would need the majority of people in America to be so virtuous that they could govern themselves and participate in the government.
00:58:01 And we're just so far away from that, it's almost comical.
00:58:04 the door dash generation 1.00
00:58:07 the LGBTQ 1.00
00:58:08 month generation 0.95
00:58:11 say I'm transing my kid generation 1.00
00:58:14 the most decadent 1.00
00:58:16 generations in history
00:58:18 they're not going to suddenly acquire
00:58:20 enough virtue to completely
00:58:22 govern themselves that's just not going to happen
00:58:24 and so
00:58:26 we'd need just all kinds
00:58:28 of stuff I mean we'd also need mass deportations
00:58:30 both to shrink the size 1.00
00:58:32 of the country and to purge foreign influence
00:58:34 if you're lobbying for some other country in my country you need to go that must be your real
00:58:40 homeland so all of these things would be required to return us to a virtuous republic that said i
00:58:49 think that's the ideal i think that the that if we could if it's possible that would be the best
00:58:55 i'm doubtful that it's possible that's the problem so am i a monarchist no i don't think so
00:59:02 i think america was born as a republic and if it could return to a public a republic it should
00:59:08 my only concern is i don't think that's possible i think that we've driven out the elements and
00:59:14 altered our society so much and lied to ourself about what america is that as i've said becoming
00:59:19 a republic again would require a more radical revolution than simply becoming an authoritarian
00:59:26 empire. And we're probably getting that. So in a practical sense, I have made peace with the fact
00:59:33 that that's probably where we're going. I will tell people that ultimately, if this is where
00:59:38 you're going, you want it to work your way, and you should be the one in power, and you should
00:59:41 be the one making the rules. But this is not what I wish for my people. It's not what I wish for my
00:59:45 country. I'm not against monarchy to my bones. I'm not one of those people who has a
00:59:55 revulsion to the idea of monarchy i think it's just another system and it might be eventually
01:00:00 the right system for us if we end up going that direction i just don't think it should be the
01:00:04 goal i think the goal ultimately the best goal would be a restoration of our republican roots
01:00:10 and a republican understanding i'm just very doubtful that that can happen so i'm far from
01:00:15 a monarchist but i'm also a realist in that if we end up with a monarchy we could do worse
01:00:20 people have done much worse and if a monarchy is what we need to set us back on the road towards
01:00:27 becoming a virtuous people so that we can once again perhaps one day return to a republican
01:00:33 government well then maybe that's what we need but i wouldn't say that that is the best form of
01:00:39 government or the only form of government or the form of government i support i support the american
01:00:43 people i'm done with ideology that's really what it's about and what we all need to be heading
01:00:49 towards at the end of the day i'm done with being this or that i'm done with the isms or the odds
01:00:55 i'm for the american people and they're good and if what's good for the american people what's
01:01:01 natural the american people is a republic and we can create one and maintain it we can keep it
01:01:06 well then we should do that but we shouldn't delude ourselves that we did keep a republic
01:01:11 we don't have one you haven't had one for a long time if you're in the sound of my voice if you're
01:01:16 hearing me talk right now you have never ever lived in a constitutional republic you have never
01:01:21 ever lived in a constitutional republic and anyone telling you otherwise is delusional
01:01:26 maybe that's what we should have but it's not we have now you don't even know what that looks like
01:01:32 so i think if we can create that we should but if we can't then we need to be open to the fact
01:01:41 that constitutions change and the cycle of regimes is real and so we might just end up in a moment
01:01:46 where ultimately a strong man is going to be what's necessary i'm not going to pretend like
01:01:51 that's the end of the world either whatever is good for the american people that's what i support
01:01:58 and that's what we need and that's where you should be focused to enough with the isms enough
01:02:03 with those you know the systems if we want to fix this thing we need virtue
01:02:08 hopefully you know we get virtue for everybody but if we only produce one
01:02:13 truly virtuous man maybe he'll end up being the king
01:02:16 but we really need virtue more than anything and that's what we should be fighting for not systems
01:02:22 not strategies not uh some some kind of abstract political ideology virtue that's what we need
01:02:31 everything else flows downhill from there all right guys let's take a look at the questions
01:02:38 of the people real quick. Alex Roberts says, I'm worried no presently existing elites are capable
01:02:46 or worthy of being a king. Very true. Absolutely. Right. Again, we, you have to have at least one
01:02:52 super virtuous person for them to embody that. And I want to be clear. A lot of people, when
01:02:57 they hear virtuous, they just think of like, you know, maybe some of the fruits of the spirit or
01:03:01 something. And those are all great. Don't get me wrong. I'm a Christian, but we also need martial
01:03:05 virtue you need the virtues of leadership right so we're not just talking about you know some of
01:03:11 the virtues people think of you know kindness generosity those are good excellent you know
01:03:15 but like ultimately we need those those virtues those hard virtues the man of steel that kind of
01:03:21 virtue as well and i think you're right man it might be the case that we just don't have somebody
01:03:25 like that right now and if we don't then we certainly shouldn't be elevating anyone
01:03:28 the only thing worse the only thing worse than a bad democracy is a bad king which is what
01:03:36 ultimately aristotle says right the best form of government is a benevolent king and the worst
01:03:42 form of government is a tyrant so on the spectrum the very best is a rule of one and the very worst
01:03:48 is a rule of one so you know we should be careful about elevating people who can't get the job done
01:03:54 eric uh with a last name i couldn't hope to pronounce but thank you very much
01:04:01 oran i've uh discovered an apple super chat receipt that my uh that my state illinois has
01:04:08 begun taxing 56 on a 4.99 super chat this is super chiseling by the left in action
01:04:14 cyger cheers uh i didn't even know such a thing as possible that's incredible if there is actually
01:04:20 attacks on super chats uh if so i am very sorry uh but thank you uh but ultimately uh that's insane
01:04:27 man but yeah thanks for supporting the show manny youd says the system is no system is perfect
01:04:33 politics is the art of the possible and there will always be trade-offs and we must not mistake
01:04:37 political theory for political reality great stream today well thank you very much man all of that is
01:04:41 very true we need to live in the real world right i love talking about political theory i will
01:04:45 continue to talk about political theory but i'm not the guy telling you the political theory at
01:04:49 the end of the day gets this done i think it matters i'm not talking about because i don't
01:04:52 think it matters but i think ultimately it is action and organization that's my show uh last
01:04:58 week talking about you know kind of the end build things do things in the real world get out there
01:05:04 organize get connected to your community get connected to people make that stuff happen right
01:05:09 like that's what we need we need the virtue the virtue matters first and the political theory
01:05:14 might help us understand what the situations we're in or how to fix them but it's the doing
01:05:18 it's the being virtuous it's the building those things that's what actually matters
01:05:22 freelancer you says virtue is in short supply virtue is true strength and my opinion is that
01:05:31 if i'm not strong i will not and cannot expect to uh to find it around me uh well let's see my
01:05:37 opinion is that if i'm not strong i will not and cannot expect to find it around me okay so yeah
01:05:42 that makes sense so you need to be first you need to have the strength first if you can't master
01:05:48 yourself you shouldn't be expecting it from others and that's right you know i then you know you have
01:05:53 to get the log out of your own eye before you can get the speck out of your brother's eye and so you
01:05:59 have to become virtuous first you have to become worthy first uh and what does that look like it
01:06:05 looks like taking care of yourself it looks like making sure that you're building your own personal
01:06:09 wealth, your own connections, you're starting a family, you're involved in church, you're
01:06:13 worshiping God, you're spiritually centered, you're morally correct, you're doing for others,
01:06:18 you're also leading in your community, you're looking for these positions. Guys, I promise you,
01:06:24 there's like a thousand positions around you that just no one will take the time to fill.
01:06:30 Who's running your local Kiwanis? Who's running your Rotary Club? Who's running your local
01:06:36 fraternal organizations? Who's signing up for water management boards? Who's running for seats
01:06:44 that no one cares about in your government? Who's willing to become the secretary of your local
01:06:51 Republican executive committee? The answer is not a lot of people, actually, for the most part,
01:06:56 but people are not fighting for those positions. So you can step into those positions of leadership.
01:07:01 who's organizing ministries at your church who's leading those bible studies who's taking all the
01:07:09 guys at the church to the range so that they learn to defend themselves defend their families
01:07:15 and hopefully go out and you know have some dinner afterwards and talk about what they would do if
01:07:20 things went sideways these are all things that you can do you can be that person the world is
01:07:26 desperate for people who will organize people in real life right now. And that can be you.
01:07:30 And that will build virtue. People will see you as a leader. And by the way,
01:07:35 if you're looking for a spouse, if you're looking, you're like, Oh, I don't know how to build a
01:07:38 family, become a leader. I promise you women will notice women. Women will notice and value a man
01:07:44 who doesn't just blame everybody else. Who doesn't just take all their free time and blow it
01:07:49 on Netflix or video games or watching football, but actually goes out there and build something.
01:07:54 And I'm not saying you can't play a video game or watch football.
01:07:57 I'm just saying if that's the majority of your activity time,
01:08:00 if you can't name three different organizations you're associated with and one
01:08:05 leadership position you hold in them, you're playing too many video games.
01:08:09 You're watching too much TV.
01:08:12 You're enjoying too much football.
01:08:13 Again, I'm not saying you can't enjoy those things,
01:08:15 but if you can't name three groups you're a part of and one leadership position
01:08:20 you hold in one of those groups, you're wasting your time.
01:08:23 you're not building virtue so go do that instead all right guys thank you for coming by and
01:08:30 watching it's been fantastic speaking to you today if it's the first time on this channel
01:08:35 please go ahead and subscribe click the bell notifications all that stuff so you know when
01:08:39 we go live if you want to uh get these broadcasts as podcasts you can just subscribe to the or
01:08:44 mcintyre show on your favorite podcast platform when you do leave a rating or review it really
01:08:48 helps with the algorithm magic if you want to get some of my deeper insights into all of this
01:08:53 political philosophy and the journey that I made to get where I am now, you can pick up my book,
01:08:57 The Total State. It's available in hardback, paperback, audio book, a digital book. It's
01:09:02 all over at Amazon. And of course, I really appreciate you guys stopping by and enjoying
01:09:07 the show. Thanks for watching. And as always, I'll talk to you next time.