Permanent Revolution and the Total State ｜ 4⧸14⧸23
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
148.68025
Summary
Always and everywhere, power seeks to expand its reach and centralize control. In order to consolidate control, the state must erode the influence of all competing power centers and leave itself as the only authority on which its subjects can rely.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
We hope you're enjoying your Air Canada flight.
00:00:10.720
Fast-free Wi-Fi means I can make dinner reservations before we land.
00:00:25.260
Wi-Fi available to Airplane members on Equipped Flight.
00:00:30.720
Always and everywhere, power seeks to expand its reach and centralize control.
00:00:36.460
In order to consolidate control, the state must erode the influence of all competing power centers
00:00:42.220
and leave itself as the only authority on which its subjects can rely.
00:00:50.160
and any state that seeks to gain total control over its population
00:00:56.500
by removing any form of stability provided by an alternative social institution
00:01:01.980
that could allow the subject to ignore the will of the government.
00:01:05.980
The naked destruction of these competing centers of power by the state
00:01:12.280
So any government undertaking that task must have a justifying narrative
00:01:16.820
to obfuscate the fact that it's seizing authority from its rivals.
00:01:20.480
The revolution has proven to be the most powerful justifying narrative of the modern era,
00:01:26.960
allowing one power center to destroy its rivals in the name of the people.
00:01:30.900
If a state seeks total control of its population,
00:01:34.620
the creation of a permanent revolution provides a never-ending justification
00:01:38.960
for the expansion and centralization of authority.
00:01:45.560
nations tend to see a wider distribution of political power.
00:01:51.040
they don't have the authority, wealth, or bureaucratic structure
00:01:54.240
necessary to wield control over every part of their domain.
00:01:58.700
New governments tend to be very dependent on regional authorities
00:02:04.700
because they couldn't hope to replace the function of those centers of power.
00:02:08.680
Community members are dependent on their families,
00:02:23.540
or in the more modern figures of the mayor, sheriff, and county commissioner.
00:02:28.960
The local populations count on these regional institutions and leaders,
00:02:33.420
not the central state, for their direct safety and security.
00:02:37.100
This dependence generates power for these local aristocrats and institutions,
00:02:41.980
and the fact that the younger central government must rely on them
00:02:51.420
that restricts the power or growth of government.
00:02:54.540
It's the existence of competing centers of power
00:02:57.420
and political interests that holds a central government in check.
00:03:01.700
When the government relies on other social authorities
00:03:06.880
it's required to negotiate with those competing centers of power.
00:03:11.020
Because those competing power centers are local or regional,
00:03:14.940
their political interests are far more likely to be tied
00:03:21.000
This means that as long as those competing power centers
00:03:25.640
the central government will always face natural limitations on its power,
00:03:29.400
because it can't ignore the competing regional interests
00:03:35.080
If a state seeks to expand and centralize control,
00:03:44.740
The authority of competing spheres of power must be collapsed
00:03:55.480
as those competing regional powers have earned the loyalty
00:03:59.320
of the communities that have long depended on them.
00:04:02.820
That loyalty grants the regional powers independence,
00:04:06.100
something that is unacceptable to a state seeking total control.
00:04:10.220
If the state is to remove these rival power centers,
00:04:13.460
then the loyal base that grants them independence
00:04:20.060
the political theorist Bertrand de Juvenal explains
00:04:22.820
that the most effective way to undermine established regional powers
00:04:27.200
that are competing for authority with the state
00:04:29.340
is to offer their wealth and power to the disenfranchised.
00:04:33.640
Communities that have benefited from their long-standing relationship
00:04:41.460
and pledge their allegiance to the central government.
00:04:46.140
or those that have traditionally been denied the benefit
00:04:53.380
Emperors and kings who wish to increase their power
00:04:58.920
would often use new populations acquired through conquests
00:05:08.380
The titles might have changed in the modern world,
00:05:13.700
This juvenilian model of high-low versus middle
00:05:17.160
continues today in the eternal revolution of the total state.
00:05:20.820
The eternal revolution in explicitly communist countries
00:05:30.540
to wipe out all traditional governing institutions
00:05:33.500
and redistribute some of the spoils seized from the ruling class
00:05:37.380
while taking the corresponding authority for themselves.
00:05:40.920
Neither the power nor the material wealth that is seized is enough,
00:05:47.900
those who were capable of assembling some level of personal wealth
00:05:56.420
because the power of the ruling party was built
00:06:04.420
if their narrative justification for control is to be maintained.
00:06:08.160
Even if the Communist Party has been in total control for decades,
00:06:13.320
the state must continue to find new anti-revolutionary forces
00:06:22.580
Western nations believed that they had escaped the ravenous hunger
00:06:25.980
of the eternal revolution and emerged victorious.
00:06:29.540
But instead, the centralization of power simply took a different form.
00:06:33.520
So you've always been picky about your produce.
00:06:36.660
But now you find yourself checking every label to make sure it's Canadian.
00:06:41.900
At Sobeys, we always pick guaranteed fresh Canadian produce first.
00:06:51.360
Instead of forming a revolution around the collective nation,
00:06:54.720
the governments of Western nations built their justifying narrative
00:07:00.520
Civil rights and human rights became the new civic religion of Western nations,
00:07:06.680
and the pursuit of these rights could justify any expansion in government authority.
00:07:11.940
The autonomy of states and local governments could be abolished
00:07:17.780
as could the property rights of both businesses and individuals.
00:07:22.260
Confiscatory tax rates could be justified by redistributive practices,
00:07:26.360
and the need to deliver standardized government services in the areas of education,
00:07:31.320
child care, and housing in order to level the playing field.
00:07:35.220
Open borders ensured a steady flow of new arrivals,
00:07:38.600
who would always be, by definition, less enfranchised,
00:07:42.180
and would require the regular intervention of an ever-expanding state
00:07:48.700
American revolutionaries used these policies to target their own kulaks,
00:07:52.980
the middle class, who were the backbone of regional autonomy and independence.
00:07:58.120
The middle class and the institutions that they built
00:08:00.820
served as an alternative power center that enabled local communities
00:08:04.580
to flourish without dependence on the central state,
00:08:07.960
and the middle must always be destroyed by the revolution in the name of the people.
00:08:13.700
With individual liberty as its justifying narrative,
00:08:16.680
the eternal revolution in western nations had to find increasingly obscure minorities
00:08:22.320
in whose name it could demand additional power.
00:08:25.800
One of the reasons our media and government seem so bent on manufacturing
00:08:32.140
is the incredible amount of revolutionary energy that they generate.
00:08:36.740
If the very truth of biology itself must be altered in the quest for individual liberation,
00:08:42.120
the state will need virtually unlimited power to engineer a society
00:08:46.320
in which this wholly artificially constructed identity can exist and thrive.
00:08:52.540
The justifying narrative may be collective or individualistic,
00:08:56.800
but the dynamic of high and low versus middle remains the same.
00:09:03.280
Where will it end in the destruction of all other command
00:09:07.740
for the benefit of one alone, that of the state?
00:09:11.520
In each man's absolute freedom from every family and social authority,
00:09:16.260
a freedom the price of which is complete submission to the state.
00:09:20.780
In the complete equality as between themselves of all citizens,
00:09:25.460
paid for by their equal abasement before the power of their absolute master,
00:09:30.960
In the disappearance of every constraint which does not emanate from the state,
00:09:36.340
and in the denial of every preeminence which is not approved by the state.
00:09:40.980
In a word, it ends in the atomization of society,
00:09:44.560
and in the rupture of every private tie linking man and man,
00:09:48.740
whose only bond is now their common bondage to the state.
00:09:53.280
The extremes of individualism and socialism meet.
00:10:00.960
The state in America has already destroyed the majority of its competing power centers.
00:10:06.080
Regional governments have lost most of the independence granted by the constitution,
00:10:11.360
and while some brave governors, mayors, and sheriffs continue to resist the dictates of the central government,
00:10:20.880
The church, once a powerful bulwark against state power,
00:10:26.700
and many denominations have now shamefully devoted themselves to worshiping the new gods of the total state.
00:10:32.680
Each of these competing power centers has been eroded in the name of individual liberty,
00:10:37.800
and as each one has fallen, the authority of the state has grown.
00:10:42.080
The family is always the final barrier to the total state.
00:10:46.080
It's the most organic bond of dependence human beings form,
00:10:50.240
and one of the few remaining institutions exercising authority beyond the reach of the government.
00:10:55.200
This is why every totalitarian government seeks to turn the child against his parents.
00:11:01.100
If it can break the most fundamental of all bonds,
00:11:04.640
then there are truly no limits to the state's power.
00:11:09.680
The institution has been redefined and undermined in almost every conceivable way,
00:11:14.860
all in the name of individual rights for the disenfranchised.
00:11:18.080
The revolution has now taken aim at the children themselves,
00:11:22.560
pushing artificial sexual identities onto them at an increasingly younger age
00:11:27.240
and promising to liberate them from the authority of parents who would deny them that identity.
00:11:33.120
Of course, no child is ever liberated by this process.
00:11:36.720
They're only taken from the protective authority of their parents
00:11:40.020
and made complete wards of a state that seeks to use them in a never-ending quest for power.
00:11:45.460
The good news is that many are starting to understand
00:11:49.700
that the relentless quest for individual liberation has failed us,
00:11:54.320
and that bonds of community, not unfettered liberty,
00:12:01.180
In order to break the cycle of revolution and the growth of the state that accompanies it,
00:12:05.780
we must once again bind ourselves together in institutions capable of providing what the state cannot.
00:12:12.040
Community, meaning, purpose, and a culture that nourishes the spirit
00:12:17.020
can only come from the organic bonds formed by those who share folkways and traditions,
00:12:22.920
who become dependent on each other instead of the state.
00:12:29.500
that can resist the modern state and its eternal revolution.
00:12:38.960
If you enjoyed this video, go ahead and click like,
00:12:41.400
and if you haven't subscribed yet, now is a great time to do so.
00:12:44.860
If you'd like to get these broadcasts as podcasts,
00:12:47.880
make sure to go ahead and subscribe to The Oren McIntyre Show on your favorite podcast platform.
00:12:52.800
And when you do, make sure to go ahead and leave a rating or a review
00:12:55.880
that really helps with all the algorithm magic.
00:12:57.780
If you'd like to watch these episodes on Rumble or Odyssey,
00:13:01.760
if you'd like to follow me on Substack or Twitter or Gab,
00:13:05.120
the links to do all of that are down below in the description.
00:13:08.460
Of course, you can also read all of my columns over at The Blaze,
00:13:12.360
and you can watch all of these episodes on Blaze TV.