The Auron MacIntyre Show - May 18, 2026


The Dave Rubin and Bishop Barron Interview Was Bizarre | 5 ⧸18⧸26

Hosted by
Mentioned
Will AI Data Centers Destroy America? | Chase Davis | 5⧸15⧸26 Ezra Klein Has a Crisis of Faith | 5⧸20⧸26

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 30 minutes

Words per minute

180.97

Word count

16,463

Sentence count

457

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

78

sentences flagged

Hate speech

96

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

A conversation between Dave Rubin and Bishop Barron is a perfect example of the kind of conversation that can only be described as "friendly" between two people who have very different ideas but have a very similar vision and a common enemy.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hey everybody, how's it going? Thanks for joining me this afternoon. I am Oren McIntyre.
00:00:05 Before we get started today, I just want to remind you that one of the ways we keep the
00:00:08 lights on around here is, of course, Blaze TV. So if you want to support what I'm doing
00:00:13 on the show and you want to get access to all your favorite Blaze TV hosts, you need
00:00:17 to head to blazetv.com slash Oren to get $20 off your subscription today. That's blazetv.com
00:00:24 slash Oren to get $20 off today.
00:00:27 all right guys there was a really interesting and well frankly bizarre conversation that went
00:00:35 on a few days ago between dave rubin and bishop barron you're probably familiar with both of
00:00:41 these individuals but in case you aren't dave rubin is this guy who used to be a very progressive
00:00:47 comedian he was on the young turks he was on left-wing uh talk radio and over time he decided
00:00:55 that he didn't like wokeness he didn't like the direction that the left was going and he became
00:01:00 this figure that embodied a kind of movement heading into 2015 2016 that was talking a lot
00:01:08 about free speech the problems of woke cancellation the inability of people to talk make fun of
00:01:14 things have fun anymore the way that education and all these other areas entertainment were being
00:01:20 dominated by wokeness and leftism. And at this time, he was far from alone. There was the emergence
00:01:27 of what was eventually labeled by Barry Weiss as the intellectual dark web, which is like this
00:01:35 collection of mostly leftists, but a few kind of conservatives. You had Joe Rogan as kind of the
00:01:42 host that was bringing these people on. And you had Jordan Peterson, who was a big one. You had
00:01:47 sam harris uh you had the the weinstein brothers brett and eric uh you had of course dave rubin
00:01:55 and all of these people were coming out ben shapiro they were coming out against this kind
00:02:01 of left-wing woke dominance that we were seeing in the culture the hysteria seemed to be kind of
00:02:06 sweeping the nation and dave rubin's show that he started after kind of leaving the young turks
00:02:13 striking out on his own on YouTube became a hub for these different kind of anti-woke
00:02:19 individuals. And at this time, I found the movement fascinating. 2015, 2016, Oren McIntyre
00:02:26 thought it was wild that kind of all these people who had previously been on the left,
00:02:31 some of them in my mind, very far to left, though for them, they didn't think of themselves that
00:02:35 way. But many of these people who had been kind of very progressive were starting to understand the
00:02:41 problems that their own worldview was presenting to the types of lives they've wanted to live
00:02:47 and Dave Rubin was exploring this aspect of his his kind of intellectual approach as well as
00:02:55 interviewing all these other people who were going on the same journey and so you know I
00:03:00 first discovered this when they had Sargon Avakad, Carl Benjamin on the show which was
00:03:07 interesting because at that time Carl very much thought of himself as a liberal in good standing
00:03:13 so he he felt very similar to a guy like Dave Rubin though Carl has moved very radically much
00:03:19 to his credit on something like that and this is where I discovered all kinds of other people
00:03:23 Stephen Crowder and you had Candace Owens back when she was a leftist who was running a
00:03:31 doxing website trying to destroy conservatives you just had this whole kind of who's who of
00:03:37 people who would slowly come up and come to dominate much of the conservative media environment
00:03:42 for the next decade. And they were all kind of flowing through Dave Rubin's show. Now,
00:03:47 the interesting thing is that Dave Rubin had many conversations with people who were far more
00:03:53 religious than him. You had guys like, of course, Jordan Peterson, who himself wasn't a Christian,
00:03:58 but certainly respected the Bible, respected many parts of Christianity, thought it was very
00:04:04 important. And then he even brought in legitimately Christian people like Bishop Barron. Bishop Barron
00:04:09 is a guy who, you know, I think seems very friendly. He's often portrayed as this very
00:04:15 conservative Catholic figure and was having good conversations with many people who had previously
00:04:23 been on the left about the value of Christianity. Many of these people, along with their discovery
00:04:28 that the left had gone too far, were also learning that having stripped out every aspect of
00:04:33 Christianity was not the best move. You still had very angry people like Sam Harris who hated
00:04:39 Christianity, but several of these leftist figures were, if not adopting Christianity itself,
00:04:44 at least open to the idea that Christianity had some form of value. And so they entered into this
00:04:52 dialogue. So I understand why this relationship was formed, why this has been kind of a friendly
00:04:58 dialogue over what's basically been a decade now i haven't checked in on dave rubin in a long time
00:05:04 and the reasons for that are plentiful one i moved well beyond the dave rubin phase i moved well
00:05:11 beyond this conservative enamored with the idea that leftists might start listening to us again
00:05:17 talking to us again seeing some problems with their own movement again i recognize that actually
00:05:22 that's not really what's happening we'll get much more into that in a second but the other reason
00:05:27 is that Dave Rubin ended up blocking me on Twitter. And I bet you can guess exactly the day
00:05:32 that Dave Rubin blocked me on Twitter and has never unblocked me. And the reason is because
00:05:38 I pointed out that actually all these conservatives celebrating Dave Rubin's new
00:05:45 children that he purchased with his gay husband, that was not really very conservative. Actually,
00:05:53 that was the opposite of conservatism at the time it was pretty popular to applaud Dave for
00:05:58 you know trying to be a family man doing his best to kind of emulate a family in some way
00:06:04 you know ironically Dave Rubin got a lot of his start a lot of his attention because he was
00:06:12 decrying the trans movement the idea that men could not become women and it was ridiculous to
00:06:17 say that the these genders were interchangeable that these biological sexes could be altered by 0.87
00:06:23 some kind of physical surgery he was pointing out the damage it was doing the ridiculous nature of 0.53
00:06:28 it but dave rubin was basically creating a trans family dave rubin is not a mother the man he is 0.88
00:06:36 married to which is not marriage there is no such thing as gay marriage that does not exist
00:06:41 but he did not acknowledge that he was literally making the same argument for homosexuals that he
00:06:51 was arguing against for trans people that somehow his partner who he calls a husband even though
00:06:58 they cannot be married because two men can't be married for the same exact reason that men cannot
00:07:04 become women because that's not what marriage is that is a distortion a complete rewriting 0.67
00:07:09 of the definition but dave could never put that together because like ultimately his homosexuality 0.62
00:07:15 was more important than truth and so just like any trans person he was ignoring reality so he 0.86
00:07:22 could continue to live the delusional lifestyle he wanted to live however dave saw the problems 0.94
00:07:27 with the left and so he was trying to ape the conservative lifestyle without giving up
00:07:32 the the sin the the thing that he was fighting god against that he was fighting against reality with
00:07:39 so the fact that he was out there buying children and you know marrying some guy
00:07:45 and then being held up as a conservative uh you know pundit some some thought leader some
00:07:52 important figure on the right i thought that was insane and simply by pointing that out i got a
00:07:57 nice block from dave so i really haven't been familiar with like what he's talking about i
00:08:02 haven't seen anything from him in many many years however he popped up on bishop baron and i thought
00:08:08 was very interesting because i thought to myself well the attitudes on surrogacy have changed pretty
00:08:14 radically on the right uh you know at the time when dave rubin was buying children uh like you
00:08:20 know two boys just weird you know just pointing that out just always boys always boys for some
00:08:26 reason um but when they were purchasing boys uh that was celebrated again by many conservatives
00:08:32 over time that position has uh changed quite radically you know there are several people
00:08:38 myself included in the blaze who speak out very forcefully against surrogacy uh because of its
00:08:45 monstrous nature and we'll get into that as well as we talk about this uh but you know because of
00:08:50 that shift i wondered if bishop baron was going to confront dave about the fact that despite being 0.90
00:08:57 part of the conservative movement for 10 years he's still gay he's still gay married he still
00:09:04 owns children that are not his and has in no way as at least as far as i understand it repented in
00:09:10 any sense of the of any of these facts he has not addressed the contradictions i wondered well will
00:09:17 this Catholic bishop, this guy whose job literally is to tell a man the truth about sin, will he
00:09:23 confront him about that? So I watched this whole thing. I think it's like an hour and a half-ish.
00:09:30 And I obviously cannot play the whole thing here, hour and a half, you know, longer than the program
00:09:35 itself. I had to cut out some choice things that I want to observe here. But I encourage you to go
00:09:41 watch the whole thing if you want the full context. As always, I never want you to think I'm just
00:09:45 clipping people out of context to own them or anything please go watch the whole thing so you
00:09:50 can understand why i'm approaching the way i did a lot of what they did in this was just to repeat
00:09:56 talking points from 2015 and among the many things that stunned me when i was watching it that was
00:10:02 probably the most amazing to me it's like this was a little time capsule like like a like somebody
00:10:08 cryogenically froze the world in 2015 and nothing changed nothing happened uh dave gave exactly the
00:10:16 same stories exactly the same talking points exactly the same uh you know kind of uh wrote
00:10:23 memorized explanations that he had back when i watched his stuff over a deck or i guess about
00:10:30 a decade ago at this point and i just thought that was insane because like i have changed
00:10:34 radically from that time and i i would think that since dave started a journey at that time
00:10:40 he would have journeyed further or at the very least bishop baron might confront him for not
00:10:45 have journey very far instead like i said what i saw was two men who seemed absolutely bamboozled
00:10:53 that basically like this center-left utopia that they kind of wanted like this this kind of
00:11:01 bill clinton-esque liberalism that they wanted didn't didn't materialize after they went on
00:11:07 their their little journeys together and so i want to play these clips i want to go over them i'll
00:11:11 stop and comment it as i said um but but i just think it's really interesting uh that so little
00:11:18 has changed for these men and they have thought so little through kind of why the world is currently
00:11:24 the way it is and not the way they envisioned it would be but that said let's jump in and i'll i'll
00:11:28 stop it and explain when I think there's something important.
00:11:31 But I often say that, you know, defending my classical liberal beliefs has become a
00:11:35 conservative position.
00:11:36 Makes you a conservative.
00:11:37 So, right.
00:11:38 And that's the thing.
00:11:39 And I think maybe that's why I find common cause with so many people that people think
00:11:41 I wouldn't because in a weird way, the liberals need the conservatives to guard the door.
00:11:49 Liberals are very good at, you know, we can have our differences and we can hopefully
00:11:56 we can build institutions.
00:11:57 I mean, that's what classical liberals really did in this country, but they're not good at ever saying, OK, guys, enough's enough.
00:12:04 And because of that, that's why the progressives were basically able to take over liberalism.
00:12:09 Right. So. First, it's bizarre again to see Dave just using the same line from 2015, like my my becoming being a liberal suddenly became conservative.
00:12:20 And that's why I'm over here. I don't like this for a couple of reasons.
00:12:24 one did dave change or not right like the idea that he's supposed to be explaining i think is
00:12:32 that he actually had a legitimate change and to be fair to dave i want to give give the man at
00:12:37 least some do here i think he did change on a number of issues i think he had genuinely pretty
00:12:43 radically progressive beliefs and he came something to more like a center left or barely maybe into
00:12:51 a little bit of conservatism. That's a change. That's a pretty significant change, but we're
00:12:56 not acknowledging that change. We're just saying, well, no, the whole world changed and I just stood
00:13:01 still. And this is always my problem with kind of the IDW types. They take up this Ronald Reagan. 0.99
00:13:07 I didn't leave the left, the left left me. Well, okay. So you're saying you're still leftist
00:13:13 that you didn't learn anything. And the danger of that is always, I didn't need to change.
00:13:18 everybody else needs to change and understand that my world review was correct all the time 0.94
00:13:23 and it's only because those liberals got a little too wacky a little too crazy
00:13:27 that ultimately i kind of had to i had to side with the conservatives but i didn't move
00:13:32 everybody moved around me and to be fair there's some truth to that but but that reveals something
00:13:38 right it reveals something about the world that if the liberals are keep getting crazier
00:13:44 and the right keeps moving to catch up to where you are now you're admitting that the right is
00:13:51 becoming more leftist that the or at least the conservatives are becoming more leftist which
00:13:58 you know if you watch this channel at all you know Cthulhu swims slowly but he always swims
00:14:03 to the left this is like a core understanding of neo-reaction a lot of what we talk about here
00:14:07 conquest laws so like yes I agree with all this but Dave does not grapple with the implications
00:14:13 of the fact that conservatives moved
00:14:15 far enough left for him to become
00:14:17 a conservative he just acts
00:14:19 like that's like the rational thing to do
00:14:21 it never it
00:14:23 he's never intellectually curious about why
00:14:25 that movement has occurred
00:14:27 okay something
00:14:29 happened because before we went
00:14:31 on camera to talk about William F. Buckley
00:14:33 but what I really admire about
00:14:35 Buckley is that he was a great
00:14:37 friend with someone like John Kenneth Galbraith
00:14:40 yes with whom he had profound
00:14:41 disagreements about politics economics everything but it's lovely to watch the two of them talk
00:14:46 because they're around the same age they obviously like each other they're friends and they were
00:14:51 disagreeing vehemently but you knew they went out for dinner afterwards you knew they had a drink
00:14:55 together you knew that they would get together happily so i left this in because this is going
00:15:01 to prefigure some stuff that we're going to talk about later here but i just want to i'll outline
00:15:06 it and then when we get to the meat of it we'll drill down deeper but you'll notice that there
00:15:11 answer here is, well, what I really like is conversation. I like that we can sit down and
00:15:16 two people who disagree are able to talk things out. And look, man, I like to do that whenever
00:15:20 possible. I'm somebody who enjoys a good conversation with someone I disagree with.
00:15:23 I find intellectual exploration, sparring, the exchanging ideas. I do think that that's good.
00:15:30 Does that make me a liberal? Maybe. I think Benjamin Boyce would say it makes me a liberal.
00:15:34 But that said, you'll notice that they bring up William F. Buckley specifically here and say,
00:15:40 well, that's the great thing about William F. Buckley. Yes, he was considered like the big
00:15:44 leader of the right, the conservatives at the time, but he was able to sit down and talk with
00:15:48 people who didn't agree with him. Later on, they're going to note that actually the great
00:15:54 thing about Buckley is that he was a gatekeeper, that he pushed people out of the right. He's not
00:16:00 even, they're not even going to deny that this is what happened. There are some people who try to
00:16:03 deny that Buckley was pushing out the old right, pushing out the actual right wing to create this
00:16:08 new neoconservative consensus, but they're going to acknowledge it and they're going to say that's
00:16:14 a good thing. So we end up at the scenario where, well, Buckley is good because he could have
00:16:20 conversations with anyone, but also Buckley is good because he wouldn't have conversations with
00:16:25 people who are right way. So when we say Buckley is good for having conversations, what we mean is
00:16:31 Buckley was good for having conversations only with people to his left. You're allowed to disagree
00:16:37 with conservatives and it's good to have conversations with people who disagree with
00:16:40 conservatives as long as they're to your left if they're to your right oh no no no so it's not some
00:16:46 universal principle it's not some idea that oh well it's good to have these conversations and
00:16:50 rational discussion and and the marketplace of ideas no no it's no we want a very carefully
00:16:55 curated garden in which leftists are the only people we're in dialogue with and that's really
00:17:03 interesting but like i said this is just the foreshadowing we'll get to that more depth when
00:17:07 they get to it um or go way back you know another hero of mine gk chesterton famously debated with
00:17:13 atheists across england you know and uh george bernard shaw but they were great friends they
00:17:20 went to the pub afterwards and they they literally danced on the tables something happened let's stay
00:17:26 with that for a second because we've talked about how the left went crazy so wokeism is kind of like
00:17:31 liberalism run amok, right? But we're witnessing now, as you've been saying, the elements of the
00:17:36 right going crazy and losing the narrative and turning to forms of anti-Semitism and turning
00:17:42 to all kinds of crazy. So this is going to be the only thing they mention. They're going to say the
00:17:48 right has gone crazy. The right has gone off the rails. It's lost the plot. And the only thing
00:17:56 they're going to mention is anti-semitism i i think you need more right like and we'll get into
00:18:03 all the anti-semitism accusations too but if you're telling me the right has gone crazy then
00:18:08 why can't you list anything else like i i believe there are things that bishop bear disagrees with
00:18:13 the right on for instance if i remember correctly bishop baron specifically called out the
00:18:20 deportations as being cruel and that the trump administration needed to tone him down now this
00:18:25 isn't surprising the catholic church is terrible on immigration the last couple popes just want to 1.00
00:18:30 get as many third worlders into the west as possible as many hostile muslims as many like 0.98
00:18:36 just people who you know hindus as many people who aren't christian and aren't american need to 0.97
00:18:41 be in america that's like the mission of the catholic church at this point and so it's not
00:18:46 surprising that a catholic bishop holds the same position of the pope that like yeah we really
00:18:51 should not be deporting people certainly shouldn't be doing mass deportations certainly shouldn't be
00:18:56 doing any things that are actually required to physically remove people who are breaking the law
00:19:00 and shouldn't be here he doesn't mention of course that like a lot of these people that the trump
00:19:04 administration has been targeting are like violent felons rapists drug dealers none of that matters 0.66
00:19:09 what matters is they made him you know feel bad in the fuzzy wuzzies and so like this conservative
00:19:15 catholic bishop in theory actually is pretty much for open borders and against the trump
00:19:20 administration but they don't bring that up they just bring up anti-semitism because like that's
00:19:27 the only thing they actually care about which we'll see as we go on in the world and and i think
00:19:31 you're right and say that charlie kirk was very helpful in keeping that together keeping it sane
00:19:36 yeah what happened on the right why why is the right splintering the crazy way that it is right
00:19:42 well again i would connect it to that commentary by jordan on drill rogan's show about what will
00:19:46 happen one day so we shouldn't we shouldn't sit here and be shocked by it i think so i will say
00:19:52 this um i i agree we should not be shocked that the right has changed over the years because we
00:20:00 saw that it wasn't working and jordan peterson did warn that if you continue to push the limits
00:20:05 if you continue to do this woke radical leftism you will see an equal and opposite reaction on
00:20:10 the right now the question that you have to ask yourself is always well what's worse right because
00:20:17 what's being presented here and what is so often presented by many conservatives sadly and
00:20:23 especially these like you know former leftists classical liberal uh you know uh types what
00:20:31 they're always kind of putting forward is the idea that you have to be careful with your wokeness
00:20:36 It's not because the wokeness itself is necessarily the worst thing, not because leftism run amok is the worst thing, not because the kind of people who would shoot Charlie Kirk in the neck are the worst thing.
00:20:46 The thing you have to watch out for is the reaction.
00:20:48 It's the reaction of the right that is actually dangerous.
00:20:52 That's the thing we're really trying to avoid.
00:20:53 The only reason not to go too far left is because eventually it will create the far right.
00:20:59 But the question is, at some point, is moving far to the right the correct response?
00:21:06 Like if the politicians in your country keep leaving the borders open, getting people killed, having drugs brought in, child trafficking, if they're supporting all of these insane things, endless foreign wars, if they're destroying the middle class, if they're going to war with white Christian males in America and trying to destroy their lives.
00:21:26 Like, at some point, isn't there a reasonable reaction that is further to the right than what we have?
00:21:32 Doesn't that make sense?
00:21:34 If the current conservative paradigm is not resolving these issues, never makes any progress, constantly gives up and destroys itself, then don't we need something else?
00:21:46 But no, that's the danger.
00:21:48 That's always the danger.
00:21:49 There's never a justifiable reaction, only a dangerous reaction.
00:21:54 because ultimately these guys want leftism they're they're leftists they're both leftists
00:22:00 as we'll get to you'll you'll see but that's their worst nightmare is not that the current regime the
00:22:07 current paradigm would be dangerous to americans that it would attack white people that it would
00:22:12 attack christians that would try to destroy the foundations of america no the danger is
00:22:17 that the right might react and that's that's the most dangerous thing in the world what we should
00:22:22 be shocked by is what i just referenced which is we should be shocked how it went on steroids once
00:22:27 charlie died that there was you know we had this weird moment if you remember those those few that
00:22:32 week after charlie was assassinated i happened to be in new york city on i was going for a 9-11
00:22:38 uh event so i was in new york city and i did all these 9-11 events and i did a whole bunch of stuff
00:22:44 on fox that day about charlie i was supposed to be there again for 9-11 but they ended up bringing
00:22:48 me in for all this Charlie stuff. And I remember thinking, and I was in New York City for 9-11.
00:22:53 I was there for it. My dad saw the second plane hit from his office. I can tell you all sorts
00:22:57 of stories about that. But I remember thinking that day, in a weird way, this feels bigger than
00:23:04 9-11. And I know that that is, in some sense, a crazy statement to make. But it felt certainly in
00:23:11 the moment, in the immediacy of it, it kind of felt right. But if you look at now what has
00:23:15 happened over the last eight months with a certain set of people. And if you want to name names,
00:23:19 we can name names. I don't even think it's necessary in some sense. People know who we're
00:23:22 talking about. Charlie wanted to keep MAGA alive and Charlie loved freedom. What was the shirt?
00:23:31 What did it say on his shirt? It said freedom. It said freedom. Freedom incorporates a lot of
00:23:38 different things. Yeah, it does incorporate a lot of different things. And that was what Charlie
00:23:43 wanted and that i think that it's not really overstating in any way that charlie kirk was
00:23:50 a key figure if not the key figure in holding the maga coalition together and keeping the disparate
00:23:57 parts uh together coalition politics are always volatile and if you don't have a guy who can
00:24:04 drive that you know someone like trump who has the dynamism and then someone like charlie who
00:24:09 has the relatability and the ability to network and kind of make you make these people sit down
00:24:16 together and work together if you don't have it coalition politics can break apart very very
00:24:20 quickly however you'll notice dave does the illusion of and some people on the right we
00:24:25 don't need to name names and fine you know you don't have to but we know who he's you know we
00:24:29 know who he's talking about we know he's talking about you know charlie kurt or sorry um tucker
00:24:34 Carlson, Candace Owens, you know, these kind of people, but also like Marjorie Taylor Green
00:24:39 and all these other people. And the funny thing is that he says, you know, Charlie was all about
00:24:47 freedom. He was about sitting down and having these discussions and working these things out.
00:24:51 But of course, that's not how Dave feels about any of those people, right? Like Charlie Kirk
00:24:56 fought to keep Tucker Carlson on stage, despite his criticisms of Israel. Charlie Kirk fought
00:25:04 to bring Dave Smith in and have a debate with a guy like Josh Hammer, despite all the flack he
00:25:10 was catching from big Jewish donors, pro-Israel donors. That's what Charlie Kirk was fighting
00:25:15 for, and Dave doesn't agree with that at all, and neither does Bishop Barron. For all their talk
00:25:19 about liberalism and the need for William F. Beckley to sit down and talk to these leftists
00:25:24 and even the communists that G.K. Chesterton was debating, and they'd go down drinking later,
00:25:29 they don't believe any of that stuff. They'll debate communists all day, they'll debate atheists.
00:25:34 But you know who they won't? 0.78
00:25:36 Truck people who question Israel.
00:25:40 That's actually where they stop.
00:25:43 They talk to, I don't know, 0.89
00:25:45 a guy who pretends to be gay married while purchasing children 0.72
00:25:49 before they talk to somebody who disagrees with Israel. 0.65
00:25:54 It's kind of telling, right?
00:25:55 Like, oh, we need free debate.
00:25:57 We need these open lines of communication with the left.
00:26:00 But not if they don't like one country, not if they think that that country has a little too much influence, not if they think ultimately we shouldn't go to war on behalf of that country.
00:26:11 No, no, no.
00:26:13 Those people, we can't talk to them, even though they're like the most mainstream of conservatives.
00:26:18 Tucker Carlson was the most recognizable and probably still is the most recognizable right wing pundit, maybe after Charlie Kirk in the world.
00:26:26 and yet off limits can't talk to him he defined mainstream conservative for decades
00:26:35 but tucker carlson is off limits in a way that a radical communist is not why
00:26:42 israel that's it that's it that's the entire reason they don't give a single other one
00:26:49 there could be other ones i know they disagree on other things they don't even bother to bring
00:26:54 anything else up. That's all they got. Right. A lot of different things that maybe the secular
00:27:00 lib coming into this movement feels differently about than the Christian conservative,
00:27:06 but can they exist in the same country? Yes. And it's America. And America is basically the only
00:27:11 place they can do that. And if we give that up, we give everything away. Again, Dave believes
00:27:18 that the atheist liberal should be able to coexist
00:27:22 in a country with the Christian conservative,
00:27:26 but not with somebody who is a Christian conservative
00:27:29 who doesn't like that we're sending billions of dollars to Israel.
00:27:35 Charlie Kirk didn't believe this.
00:27:37 Charlie Kirk clearly and repeatedly
00:27:40 said that our connection with Israel was unhealthy,
00:27:44 that we needed to start thinking about it in different ways,
00:27:48 i think he still loved israel i'm not one of these people who's like charlie kirk was completely
00:27:52 turning on israel and hated hated benjamin netanyahu and was you know planning to like
00:27:57 you know denounce israel i i from what i see i don't think that's true i do think he was
00:28:02 rethinking his conservatism i think he was becoming far more of a nationalist and a true
00:28:08 american first nationalist in that sense i think that he wanted to see some changes in the way we
00:28:14 interacted with israel but i still think he was a dispensationalist i still think he was a zionist
00:28:18 i still think he held many pro-israel attitudes but charlie kirk while holding all of those
00:28:24 attitudes was able to talk to tucker carlson was able to talk to dave smith
00:28:28 why why is he able to do that but dave rubin is it why does dave rubin get to draw that line where
00:28:36 charlie kirk didn't especially while he's sitting here lionizing charlie kirk if you really believed
00:28:41 Charlie Kirk's values, practice what you preach. Go talk to Tucker. Go talk to Dave Smith. I got
00:28:49 a feeling Dave will talk to you. If you will, I'll host you. No problem. But you're not going to do
00:28:55 that because you don't really believe in Charlie Kirk's message. Charlie Kirk was pro-Israel,
00:29:01 but he actually believed in free speech and putting America first. So he was willing to
00:29:07 have these conversations willing to hear these opposing voices willing to be swayed by many of
00:29:12 these arguments and dave rubin won't hear any of them he won't talk to any of these people they're 0.99
00:29:18 unnameable why why are they unnameable but a radical leftist who wants white people dead you 0.64
00:29:24 can have a conversation with them what is that i think we know so it was literally on his chest
00:29:32 when he died so i don't think anyone thought it would have broken down so quickly but now i'll
00:29:36 give you i'm not a black pill guy i'm a white pill guy i always consider myself a world-weary
00:29:40 optimist but but i have to be an optimist as i as i suspect you are because how how else could
00:29:45 we do this for something like this for a living how could we sit here and talk about things if
00:29:49 we didn't think we could angle them to be a little bit better the white pill on this
00:29:53 is that when the left was going crazy 10 years ago and obviously i was right in the middle of that
00:29:58 there were almost no liberals willing to stand up against it yeah there were a couple sam harris
00:30:04 Bill Maher, Jordan, although he wasn't liberal truly, but he was kind of right there. There were
00:30:09 a few people willing to stand up against it. What I have seen on the right in this past
00:30:15 eight months or so since Charlie's death is extraordinary. The right is fighting. The right
00:30:21 is saying there are some things that are not acceptable and ushering in ancient hatreds that
00:30:27 we should have left a long time ago and the worst ideas of all time. No, we're not going to do it.
00:30:34 So, again, I want to make I'll just do the disclaimer because, you know, we shouldn't have to say this, but I will just because it's important and I want to make sure everything's in context.
00:30:46 You should not have ethnic hatred for other people, as especially as Christians.
00:30:50 You should not do that.
00:30:52 That doesn't mean that, you know, everybody needs to come to the United States.
00:30:56 Everybody's to live here.
00:30:57 you have to live around everybody, but you should not be harboring ethnic hatred towards anyone,
00:31:02 including Jewish people, in your heart. It's unhealthy for you. It's a sin. You shouldn't
00:31:07 do it as a Christian. Bad practice. That said, at no point has any of these, either of these 1.00
00:31:14 gentlemen, entertained the idea that there are any legitimate criticisms of Israel. And by the way,
00:31:20 again, we've lionized Charlie Kirk, but this is what Charlie Kirk believed. He believed there
00:31:24 were legitimate criticisms of israel again he supported israel he loved israel he loved jewish
00:31:31 people he didn't want to see anti-semitism but that did not keep him from having real
00:31:36 serious critiques of israel that seem to be growing day by day other than his personal
00:31:42 relationship with charlie kirk if charlie kirk were someone else and was someone else was spouting
00:31:48 Charlie Kirk's positions, Dave Rubin would call him an anti-Semite. He would. He would.
00:31:56 If Charlie's words about Jewish donors threatening him, if Charlie's words about needing to decouple 0.55
00:32:02 from Israel because this isn't healthy, that we're being driven to war by the Israeli lobby,
00:32:07 if those were just disembodied comments, in fact, I would love, if anybody can get Dave Rubin on an
00:32:12 interview or something, I would love to see this. Hey, Dave, I just want to read you these statements.
00:32:17 this is what Candace Owen just said
00:32:19 we should be careful
00:32:21 we should probably stop giving money to Israel 1.00
00:32:23 we should be careful about being driven into war 0.74
00:32:25 by Israeli interests and foreign interests 0.84
00:32:27 Jewish donors
00:32:29 will attack you if you question 0.71
00:32:31 Israel and they'll withdraw your funds
00:32:33 can you believe Candace Owen said that 1.00
00:32:35 and he'd be like yeah what an anti-Semitic
00:32:37 actually these are Charlie Kirk's words 0.98
00:32:38 I would love to see
00:32:41 that play out
00:32:42 but he never entertains that there are any
00:32:45 legitimate
00:32:45 questions about Israel and our relationship with it. It's impossible. You have to be an anti-Semite
00:32:52 or you have to be 100% blindly pro-Israel. Those are the only options. And they will never present 0.88
00:32:58 another option during this discussion. And that's in no way a mistake. That is a tactical frame.
00:33:04 Okay. The people who are trying to manipulate us in the United States want you to either have to
00:33:13 be an anti-Semite or extremely pro-Israel. They want you to have to be a hater of Jewish people
00:33:18 or someone who unquestionably supports the secular government of Benjamin Netanyahu.
00:33:25 Those are your only two options. Because if there's a third sane reasonable option
00:33:30 that pretty much everyone would agree on if it was available, well, then the support for Israel
00:33:36 would probably erode. So you need the radical hateful people. Now, again, there are hateful 0.67
00:33:42 people out there and you just shouldn't engage with it i'm not i'm not pretending that there
00:33:46 isn't hatred for jews out there i'm not pretending that that isn't bad but it is very clear that this
00:33:52 binary dynamic is intentional that that is what has to be the case for this whole thing to continue
00:34:00 to operate and i think it's a very very bad faith the fight on the right that did not happen on the
00:34:06 left and and i believe that the right will beat this thing i think the polling absolutely indicates
00:34:11 that yeah trump clearly actually the polling shows that israel's reputation is collapsing
00:34:18 like especially among young conservatives the swings are drastic so yeah you might still have
00:34:27 israel being popular with kind of the boomers and some of the gen xers in conservatism but
00:34:32 everybody under that everybody millennial under and even a lot of the gen xers are saying yeah
00:34:38 i'm done with this like actually just put america first so the polls don't reflect this like
00:34:42 currently trump's most hardcore supporters the people who are you know like very diehard maga
00:34:49 they still are with him on most things but if you poll individually on support for israel
00:34:56 it's not looking good so actually i think dave is being a little uh optimistic for his uh possible
00:35:03 victory in the long term really has chosen the right side of this so to speak so i think there's
00:35:08 a much better chance the right will survive this and not become exactly what the life has become
00:35:15 that's interesting see a bit in that context about anti-semitism because we reference buckley
00:35:20 already and you know as everyone points out back in the 50s buckley made this decision
00:35:25 to kind of extricate from his movement the john birch society anti-semitic elements and he said
00:35:31 again i've had people from the john birch society on it's kind of funny um this is a a silly history
00:35:38 but also as as i said our previous comments foreshadowed where this was going to go the
00:35:44 the amazing thing that they loved about umf buckley is he would just talk to these radical
00:35:48 communists he would talk to these insane leftists these radical progressives who ultimately probably
00:35:54 supported like violent terrorism as many of them did but he could have a beer with them at the end 0.90
00:35:59 of the day he could sit down and have these conversations but but i'm glad he purged all
00:36:04 these people who weren't big on israel and the john birch society because it was anti-communist
00:36:09 hey why why would william f buckley purge one of the most anti-communist organizations in the
00:36:18 united states that's that's a good question to ask yourself why why would the leader of the
00:36:22 conservative movement uh purge the most anti-communist people in the movement i wonder
00:36:29 what that means i wonder what the motivation there could be i'll let you stew on that one
00:36:34 for a little bit uh so their whole their whole praise of buckley was his openness is willing
00:36:39 to debate is willing to discuss but again as i said before except only with people to his left
00:36:44 never with people to his right they praise him for cutting them out of the conversation they
00:36:50 praise him for setting that boundary that gatekeeper now again you can feel however you
00:36:54 want about gatekeeping i think there is some level gatekeeping that's necessary to all movements
00:36:58 but it's very clear who they think has to be gatekept not the leftists not the progressives
00:37:03 not the communists not the abortionists definitely not the gay marriage guys no no no destroying 0.67
00:37:09 marriage murdering children uh you know subverting the entire country into communism we can have 0.75
00:37:15 conversations with those folks uh but i don't want to send four billion dollars to israel nope 0.58
00:37:21 no talking to you no sir out of bounds no discussion that direction cthulhu swims
00:37:27 slowly but he always swims to the left look that the movement i'm advocating here kind of classical
00:37:35 conservatism should not include those elements and it was a very important decision you made
00:37:39 a lot of people critiqued him and said i'm done with you and you become you know a radical yourself
00:37:45 and but buckley stuck with his guns it was the right decision um the anti-semitism on i mean
00:37:51 both the left and the right to be honest about it but um what's the right move now would it be for
00:37:56 people i was on the sensible right to say i look do what buckley did you're not in the this is just
00:38:02 not appropriate well the left we can do the left version because it's very easy quickly i mean the
00:38:06 left basically jews are thought of as white but even sort of extra white and successful right and
00:38:13 And successful and all those things.
00:38:15 And it also, what really doesn't make sense is the Jews are, the Jews in some sense, if 0.83
00:38:19 you were to look at one group, are the ultimate minority because they're.
00:38:23 So it's really interesting here. 0.99
00:38:25 Dave Rubin says that the reason that the left hates the Jews is because they're white. 0.89
00:38:30 And to be fair, this is a pretty common line. 0.96
00:38:32 It's not just exclusive to Dave Rubin.
00:38:36 And, you know, there's some truth to this. 0.98
00:38:38 Like many of the arguments used against Israel are those used against Western whites, right? 0.87
00:38:44 Like, oh, you know, they are colonialists and they are occupiers and they're, you know, all these things, right?
00:38:52 And so you can see the flow of the argument there.
00:38:55 And again, I think there is some logic behind it.
00:38:58 But you'll notice that Dave never addresses, and most people who bring this up never address, what that means. 0.95
00:39:06 oh the left only hates jews because they're white uh so they actually hate his white people
00:39:13 so they're not anti-semitic they're anti-white right like that that's the logical follow 0.99
00:39:21 right like stay with me here if if the left hates jews because jews are white
00:39:28 then the left isn't anti-semitic it's it's anti-white and so the real problem is not
00:39:36 anti-semitism it's anti-whiteness but dave is never going to do that because it's it's all
00:39:43 about ethnic narcissism right like it's all well no my people well if your people are being attacked
00:39:49 because they're thought of as being part of a wider collective white identity it isn't the
00:39:54 attack on whiteness and not Judaism per se, if you're receiving the same attack that Western
00:39:59 whites are receiving for being colonialist, you know, expansionist powers and all that stuff, 0.54
00:40:04 aren't you being attacked as a white person and not as a Jew? 0.92
00:40:09 But no, it's all about, it's all about Jewishness. It's the victimhood of the Jewish people. That's 0.99
00:40:16 the issue. So even though he's admitting that Jewish people are being seen as white and being
00:40:21 attacked as white he does not address it as anti-whiteness he addresses it as anti-semitism
00:40:26 now i guess it could be anti-semitism inside of anti-whiteness you could say like okay well
00:40:32 there's like a you know like a venn diagram here or something or you know there's layers that's
00:40:38 fine like it's jewishness is part of a set of whiteness but we'll see at the end of this
00:40:43 interview he doesn't actually believe that uh but uh in his argument now the argument is one
00:40:49 that says the left is opposing jews because they are white but he will not then follow the logic
00:40:55 because that removes like the thing he actually cares about he doesn't care about the state of
00:41:04 how whites are treated he cares about how jews are treated apparently exclusively they're still
00:41:10 here the jews are still here after thousands of years right the all you know people always talk
00:41:15 about oh there's all these countries that kick the jews out as if it's the minority's fault
00:41:18 well most of those empires and countries don't exist anymore so you might want to think about
00:41:23 what happens when you start turning on the jews because it's not that you're turning on the
00:41:27 i mean most empires through history don't exist anymore that that's how it works like
00:41:34 there aren't a lot of continuous empires left from like i don't know the 1500s or the 1200s
00:41:41 something so just saying like all those empires fell well i guess like because all empires fall 0.93
00:41:49 i mean if you want to link it to kicking jewish people out of their country i okay but like i
00:41:55 think historically that just doesn't track again if we understand that all nations and empires
00:42:01 rise and fall but that that's just a nitpick about history jews only you're usually turning
00:42:07 on all of the good principles that allow for minorities and other people to exist in your 0.65
00:42:13 nations and that's not good for nations on the other side um so again if you take this if you
00:42:21 take this argument and just remove the element of judaism from it the argument here is like well
00:42:28 you need principles that allow minorities to exist inside your society i mean there might be an
00:42:37 argument for that but like isn't that just kind of a multiculturalism aren't you just kind of
00:42:42 making the argument for multiculturalism and if you exclude multiculturalism then it doesn't work
00:42:48 i don't know again like when you inject you know the history of the jews and everything into it
00:42:54 okay now you understand the emotional charge but if if you extract that and you just look at the
00:42:59 raw argument it seems like he's just arguing for like this kind of globalist multiculturalism like
00:43:05 You have to have principles that ensure the continued flourishing of minorities in your
00:43:10 society.
00:43:11 Now, I do think that Western societies have actually been very good for minorities, but 0.89
00:43:15 there's a reason why, and I think it's because of the people in the West.
00:43:19 I think that actually the values and customs and traditions and populations of the West
00:43:24 have been more welcoming to minorities and treated them better because of the character
00:43:30 of those people, the character of the Westerners, the Europeans who occupy those lands. If you
00:43:38 reduce the number of Europeans who believe that thing, the Christians, the people who have that 0.84
00:43:43 culture, that tradition, if you remove the people who have that tradition from the land and you 0.98
00:43:47 replace them with all these minorities that are so much better off in those places, you lose that 1.00
00:43:51 tolerance, actually. That's a problem that we are going to address, I suppose. 1.00
00:43:56 So it's very obvious why they don't fit. And then to the backdrop of October 7th, that they've created just the grandest of all lies related to the founding of Israel and the connection that the Jewish people have to that land. And that, I mean, we could do a quick history lesson. In some sense, it's boring, but like that a state of Palestine never existed for a people known as Palestinians. 0.99
00:44:17 and the coin, people always show you the coin of Palestine
00:44:20 and it quite literally, it's the British mandate of Palestine,
00:44:23 not a country, which is why it didn't have a prime minister
00:44:25 and that in Hebrew, it says the land of Israel on it
00:44:28 and all of these things.
00:44:29 But because they marched through the institutions,
00:44:32 they taught people this incredible lie
00:44:34 that somehow the Jews, Jesus, where was Jesus born?
00:44:39 Where did the story of Hanukkah take place?
00:44:41 It's Judea and Samaria, which is now,
00:44:43 now unfortunately, people call it the West Bank.
00:44:46 it's just the west bank of the jordan river um so ilhan omar or so this is one of those scenarios
00:44:55 where a guy who doesn't know much about history insults other people for not knowing much about
00:44:59 history so yes like obviously you know the original founding of israel was based on god
00:45:09 granting the holy land to the Jewish people at that time. Now, the land has been called Palestine
00:45:17 for a very long time, pretty much since, you know, especially since the Jews were expelled
00:45:22 by the Romans. The Jews were occupied in that land for, again, centuries. Like, you know, the Israeli
00:45:30 occupation by Romans and other forces were constant. You know, the story of the Bible
00:45:36 is are the hebrews uh you know kind of being conquered taken out of israel having israel 0.63
00:45:42 taken from them for them disobeying god returning back to israel rebuilding things betraying god
00:45:48 again getting thrown back out of israel like this is not new this is like this is not something that
00:45:53 just happened out of nowhere and certainly since the roman uh expulsion uh created the larger
00:46:00 diaspora that has been the case and yeah there have been sephardic jews living in that land for
00:46:05 long time but there have been many other peoples including the palestinians living there and saying
00:46:10 like well because they didn't have an independent government they weren't real okay so because king
00:46:16 herod was actually just a pawn of the romans israel wasn't real at that time under roman
00:46:22 occupation is that what we're going with that anytime the jews were kicked out of the land
00:46:27 they no longer had a right to that land like that doesn't make any sense like again i have no problem
00:46:34 with israel existing as a state as long as they can defend their borders because that's what
00:46:39 actually creates a state if you with your own sovereignty can fight off your enemies
00:46:44 and and and hold you know the the land cohesively through force that's what actually creates the
00:46:51 right to exist and everything else is just noise everything else is just you know oh well this that
00:46:57 sorry like obviously that's not the case and if dave is going with like well the scripture says 0.97
00:47:05 that they have access to land well dave you don't believe in the scriptures because you're gay
00:47:08 married and you bought kids like so the bible's only right when it's promising people of your 0.86
00:47:15 genetic lineage land in the middle east but you can ignore all the stuff about marrying men and
00:47:21 you know buying children from their mothers that doesn't make any sense but for dave like
00:47:28 it's it's a useful tool it's useful in that time in that place so he just pretends like the history
00:47:36 of you know that the area he is now referring to doesn't exist that there's like this again
00:47:42 he accuses other people of having this weird twisted history but his is completely discombobulated
00:47:47 Yeah, there wasn't, under the mandate of British Palestine, an independent Palestinian government. But then the British handed Israel to Jewish people through the Balfour Declaration. Why was it more legitimate when the Balfour Declaration and less legitimate when it was British mandate Palestine?
00:48:08 Why does not having a separate government at that one moment create that?
00:48:12 And anyway, this is a misunderstanding of much of Arab culture, much of Muslim culture when it comes to the nation state.
00:48:20 The nation state is a Western construction.
00:48:22 Many Muslims don't really have that. 1.00
00:48:25 They go from kind of the tribal level to the caliphate level. 1.00
00:48:28 It's tribes or empires.
00:48:29 And because we're kind of Western and we got used to this nation state idea, we're like, oh, well, that's the only thing that grants legitimacy. 0.59
00:48:35 Now, again, Israel fought and won a war, and so they own the land. The end. Like, I'm not here to, you know, create some alternative argument for Israel not being a valid country. It is. But not for any of the reasons that Dave is mentioning, because he doesn't want to mention, like, the ones that really matter, the ones where you shoot people. 0.82
00:48:56 Dita Talib or even AOC, they'll, on Hanukkah, they'll wish Jews a happy Hanukkah. And then 0.90
00:49:02 by the next day, they don't want any Jews living in the place that Hanukkah took place. It was 0.96
00:49:07 literally the Jews defending their land against, okay, against the Greeks. Okay. So that just 0.81
00:49:12 doesn't work. It just, none of it works. There's so many lies and the intersexual calculator
00:49:16 doesn't work for the left. Now on the right, on the right, I think there's a couple of things
00:49:20 happening. One is that on the right, there is, there is, I think you can be a principled
00:49:25 isolationist i'm just talking about a pure political sense you can be an absolute isolationist
00:49:30 america should be more basically like sweden or something or switzerland which switzerland
00:49:34 and we're just not going to have anything to do with the rest of the world and we're anti-war
00:49:38 and all those things i think that's a perfectly fine position i suppose so but i don't think it's
00:49:42 the most mature position i don't think it really equates with reality in some sense just saying
00:49:46 you're anti-war doesn't get you no war and in some sense it probably gets you a really bad war
00:49:52 on your shores because obviously there are bad guys out there. So Dave says one thing that's
00:49:57 true here and one thing that's false. So I'll go with the thing he said that's true first that I
00:50:01 agree with. I am not like constitutionally anti-war. And I don't mean like the written
00:50:07 constitution. I mean, I don't think that it is a bedrock principle that like we should just never
00:50:13 go to war. Like war is a reality. It's a human reality. States have to defend themselves. And
00:50:19 sometimes they have to go beyond defending themselves to secure resources or other other
00:50:23 you know disagreements like sometimes that's necessary and so i'm not a pacifist i'm not a
00:50:29 completely anti-war guy so i'll agree with them there like if you if you're this like total
00:50:34 pacifist total anti-war completely and actually anti-isolationist i do think that's a naive
00:50:41 worldview that said what dave is explaining is a worldview that was held by george washington
00:50:48 that George Washington expressed as a founding father, maybe the most important founding father,
00:50:54 the first president of our country, that you should not make alliances with foreign countries
00:51:00 like, I don't know, Israel, and you should not make them a favored nation. You should not have 0.95
00:51:05 nations that you hate. That's what George Washington also said. You shouldn't hate Israel,
00:51:08 but you also shouldn't love it. It's just a foreign country. You should do trade with it, 1.00
00:51:12 and that's about it. That was the American foreign policy ideal under George Washington.
00:51:18 That's what he warned everyone that they should do.
00:51:21 But Dave would now hold that position as some kind of immature isolationist position while
00:51:28 claiming to care about the founding and the principles in America and the beauty and all
00:51:31 these things.
00:51:32 So he's chastising people for holding the principles that he then says we should uphold
00:51:37 later on because he doesn't know the principles or he only wants the updated liberal version
00:51:42 of those principles while pretending to be a conservative.
00:51:44 But I think some sense of that leads to, oh, Israel's in the Middle East, and there's always wars in the Middle East, so there's some weird isolationist connection to that.
00:51:54 Then there's some weird things that you can probably speak to better than I can related to replacement theology and things of this nature.
00:52:02 I've never once had any issue with any of my Christian friends or my Catholic friends
00:52:10 or any denomination thereof related to being Jewish and that.
00:52:15 Like, it's always, you know, my best friends to this day.
00:52:18 He talks about it here for a second.
00:52:19 When we're trying to roast a lamb, we would put a lifelong friendship that hopefully will
00:52:23 take us into our 90s.
00:52:25 So I think there's some weird religious stuff happening there.
00:52:29 And then I think there's just something that is baked in unfair.
00:52:32 So, uh, he talks about the idea that there's some kind of theological issue he doesn't get
00:52:41 very clearly, right? But he is talking to a theologian. So he could have asked,
00:52:45 because here's the thing. If Bishop Barron is an actual Catholic, like if he actually believes in
00:52:51 Catholic doctrine, he believes in the replacement theology that Dave Rubin is talking about. 0.54
00:52:58 so dispensationalism is the idea that the jews have like this separate deal with god and they
00:53:07 have this separate history that they get to move along the separate track and again this is not all
00:53:13 dispensationalists there's a lot of nuance here i've done entire episodes on dispensationalism
00:53:17 if you need to go back watch those but there i should say there's a subset of dispensationalists
00:53:21 who entirely believe that like basically jews have their own deal with god and that covenant's
00:53:26 not broken and they just do their own thing but the actual belief of the church proper for basically
00:53:34 its entire history until dispensationalism kind of came up in the 1800s was the idea that the church
00:53:42 was the new israel now they don't call it replacement theology because they're not replacing
00:53:48 israel because jews can be part of the new israel too that's the beautiful thing if you go to
00:53:54 Galatians and actually read the Bible, I believe it's chapter three, it talks about how the Jews
00:54:01 and the Gentiles were grafted in. They are a new church. They are the new Israel. There is neither
00:54:07 Greek nor Jew. There's neither Jew nor Gentile. They are all one in Christ. So there are no more 1.00
00:54:17 jews because everyone is israel under christ you're not replacing the jews the jews get to 0.78
00:54:25 be part of the new israel if they accept christ they fulfill that and they stop being jews and
00:54:32 they start becoming christians that's what bishop baron as a catholic should believe
00:54:39 but you'll notice that the professional public theologian does not stop dave rubin to explain
00:54:46 that here that's the doctrine of his church that's what he believes but he doesn't care
00:54:53 because the problem is not properly articulating the doctrines of the catholic church
00:54:58 or christianity proper up until the 1850s or whatever the most important thing is being
00:55:06 angry at anti-semitism he's a he's a catholic bishop he can he can explain the problem right
00:55:13 here and he just doesn't do it why there's only one answer he doesn't want to interrupt the flow
00:55:21 of bagging on anti-semitism he's not going to give the anti-semites the ammunition of like well
00:55:27 actually this is christian doctrine and actually this is correct and this is what i believe like
00:55:32 he could say that and still say hey you shouldn't hate jewish people they should be they should all
00:55:36 become christians we should all be grafted in like you could just stop and say that but he doesn't
00:55:40 because it's not about actually sharing those ideas he doesn't want to differ with dave here
00:55:46 just like he's never going to bring up dave's gay marriage his fake marriage he's never going to
00:55:51 bring up dave's human trafficking his purchase of children his use of surrogacy because he's not
00:55:58 really having a conversation where they are allowed to disagree this is just all of us
00:56:04 nodding together so this conversation this grand conversation of liberals and conservatives
00:56:09 sitting down and having this conversation and understanding things. It's not happening.
00:56:14 These are two liberals agreeing with each other to the point where Bishop Barron doesn't even
00:56:18 correct Dave on his Catholic doctrine. Fortunately, which is that, you know, Jews just celebrated 1.00
00:56:25 Passover as Christians were celebrating Easter. And Passover is the story of bondage to freedom, 1.00
00:56:32 right? And within that story, if you sit at the Passover table, no matter what Haggadah you're
00:56:38 reading they talk about how in every age someone will come someone will rise up to destroy us
00:56:44 it's baked into the code in some sense this is so unhealthy man this is so unhealthy okay so this is
00:56:52 and you know roseanne barr has talked about this there's been many people who have who have kind
00:56:57 of admitted what dave is admitting now that deep down in like these gatherings like the thing that
00:57:04 is taught to many jews in the west in america there's other places is that the people around
00:57:09 you ultimately want to kill you that like someone is going to like rise up every generation and try 0.99
00:57:14 to eliminate you now you can understand after the holocaust and many other pogroms that jewish 0.97
00:57:20 people have had their wariness to i guess some level of this but if you teach every young jewish 0.97
00:57:28 person that the whole world is going to rise up and try to kill them at any given moment that this 0.70
00:57:32 is baked in you heard those words and guys like josh hammer have said this that europeans have 0.96
00:57:38 anti-semitism in their dna and clearly this is something that's being taught to young jewish
00:57:44 people so they grow up with this idea everyone is coming to kill you this is just a natural cycle 0.91
00:57:51 of history this is like built in to the europeans or the west they're just going to come and murder
00:57:56 you and you have to be prepared for this and so he says the same anti-semitism on the right is
00:58:00 just unavoidable because like that's just how western people are that's how christians are 0.99
00:58:06 that's how white people are they're just so one of them is going to pop up and try to murder you 0.92
00:58:09 that's not healthy man that's a terrible thing to treat people to teach people now again you 0.98
00:58:16 shouldn't have ethnic hatred in your heart you should i guess watch out for a rise of hatred
00:58:21 for any given group so when they're attacking say white people you should be aware that that's
00:58:26 probably because then they want to eventually hurt white people if they're attacking jewish 0.93
00:58:28 people eventually they want to hurt jewish people that's fine it's fine to be aware of that
00:58:32 but if you taught if if people in the west taught their children if white europeans taught their 0.96
00:58:39 children everybody else is trying to kill you there's just it's baked into everybody else's 0.73
00:58:44 dna that it's baked into the code that they're going to come for you in the night and try to
00:58:48 kill you i mean geez man that's a terrible way to live and you can see how that could produce some
00:58:54 really, really bad incentives. And Jews are the canary in the coal mine. So if you're going to, 1.00
00:59:01 let's put it this way, here's the simplest way, and then I'll stop. If you're on the side of the
00:59:06 Jew haters right now, or what is now becoming really anti-American too, that's the weird thing. 0.97
00:59:11 It would be like, it would be one thing if you, okay, you just hate Jews. Well, as long as you're 0.95
00:59:14 not attacking them, I'm fine with, you can hate whoever you want, but it usually doesn't just
00:59:18 stop with that, right? But now they're connecting it to deep anti-American stuff and kind of pro-Iran
00:59:23 and pro-Russia and a whole bunch of other things but this is what I would say if now this is again
00:59:28 I think that Dave's framing is a little silly here but I'll say this there is a strain on
00:59:37 some of these people who oppose Israel to again take it too far get into actual hatred of Jewish
00:59:45 people again any hatred of any ethnicity not good for your soul but also to then see because other
00:59:53 people are acting against those interests, they must be on your side. And that's bad, right? Like
00:59:58 you shouldn't suddenly become pro-Russia or something, you know, side with some Muslim
01:00:05 country or something because you think that Israel has undue influence in the United States. That's
01:00:10 the wrong reaction. The right reaction is to say, I want all foreign influence out of the United 0.98
01:00:13 States. I don't want Russian influence. I don't want Chinese influence. I don't want Ukrainian 0.96
01:00:17 influence. I don't want Qatari influence. I don't want Israeli influence. That's the correct 0.99
01:00:21 response it's to be pro your country not to then trade israel for some other country that should
01:00:27 have foreign influence and so dave is talking about that phenomenon and i do think it's bad
01:00:31 because it's just morally bad strategically bad also because it gives fuel to comments like dave
01:00:37 is making now because there is some level of truth to this however what then you know dave
01:00:43 then applies is like oh well then they must be pro iran and this is what we get is then it's oh
01:00:49 well if you oppose the war with iran for any reason you must be pro-iranian you must you must 0.68
01:00:54 love the mullahs you must love islam you know sharia law because you don't want us to constantly 0.99
01:00:59 go to war in the middle east and that's ugly and stupid but that's what it's supposed to be 0.99
01:01:04 dave wants this thought terminating cliche so you shouldn't go out and support other countries over 0.99
01:01:09 america like that's just true that should be a baseline understanding especially as like a
01:01:14 nationalists, America first, terrible idea. However, on top of the principle, you shouldn't
01:01:19 do it strategically because then it gives guys like Dave Rubin, this stupid rhetorical point 0.86
01:01:23 that like, it shouldn't make any sense, but because there's a certain level of this in 0.89
01:01:28 existence, he does get to stand on this footing. So don't make the mistake of giving a guy like
01:01:32 Dave Rubin, this platform, you know, that this handhold, because he will then use it and people 1.00
01:01:38 will listen you think that if you can remove jews from public life altogether or you can 0.99
01:01:44 we can do some pogroms or whatever you want to do and that america will be better or safer on 0.94
01:01:50 the other side it's crazy well yeah it's crazy because you said the most extreme insane thing
01:01:57 right like there are plenty of people who just want us to stop sending money to israel and stop
01:02:03 fighting on behalf of Israel and that's all they want they don't wish Israel any ill will they
01:02:09 don't want to like see Jewish people purged out wiped out they're not calling for pogroms but he
01:02:16 again couches this as this is the only option either you're entirely on board with all the
01:02:22 influence that Israel has in the United States with everything we do for Israel or you want to 0.99
01:02:27 murder all the Jews those are the only two options it's dishonest it's ugly but it's effective 0.66
01:02:33 again because that binary setup that binary frame is critical you can't just be a good 0.99
01:02:38 person who loves america and says israel best of luck but you don't get our money anymore we're not
01:02:42 sending any troops over there fight your own wars that's not possible you can't have that moral 0.64
01:02:48 position it's either complete extreme jew hatred or whatever israel says goes it's not because of 0.74
01:02:55 what the jews will do to you it's because there's something there's something tied to the fabric of
01:03:02 reality related to all that the story of the jews is the story of it's the story of man in a way 0.98
01:03:10 and then okay so there's something tied to the fabric of reality
01:03:15 jews are the story of mankind all right that's a little um
01:03:23 ethnocentric don't you think like don't get me wrong i think everyone should
01:03:29 have a healthy respect and love
01:03:31 for themselves, their culture, their heritage.
01:03:33 They should have
01:03:34 a pride in their identity.
01:03:37 I think it's even healthy for most
01:03:39 people that believe at some level that their
01:03:41 country has a special relationship
01:03:43 with God. I actually do think that's
01:03:45 pretty healthy for people to
01:03:47 understand. But there
01:03:48 is something else to be like, no, the
01:03:51 actual laws of the universe
01:03:52 are that people are going to hate and try to 0.98
01:03:55 destroy Jews, and then that'll 1.00
01:03:57 destroy them because Jews are like 0.99
01:03:59 the center of the story of mankind like that's kind of weird like sorry that's that's a little 0.99
01:04:05 strange i would have known bill maher as a comedian back in the 80s merv griffin show
01:04:09 on johnny carson show right so i knew him and then he begins his kind of career as a political
01:04:14 commentator but he first really came on my radar as a great critic of religion and i hated him i
01:04:19 thought you know that religious movie he just took the you know the worst examples of fundamentalism
01:04:23 and said well that's really it was a little heavy-handed he never talked to like a serious
01:04:27 religious person yeah it was a lot of caricaturing so he just sort of turned me off but i had the
01:04:32 romans called the gaudium de stilo when you have kind of a joy in someone's style you know there
01:04:36 was something about mara that i enjoyed watching so i kept watching him and he eventually dropped
01:04:41 religion he stopped talking about religion and he started talking about wokeism and i kept saying
01:04:48 yeah yeah yeah that's it yes and i'm like applauding with the crowd so if you watch
01:04:55 watch a show at all or you've followed me on twitter you know how i feel about the conservative 0.99
01:05:00 worship of bill maher oh bill maher he hates my guts he said i'm stupid he hates white people 0.99
01:05:06 he hates christians but but he said one thing men can't become women wow what a brave guy we love 1.00
01:05:14 bill maher he's the best what a champion for freedom like i'm i hate this stuff it's so stupid 1.00
01:05:20 It's so dumb. And that's just what we're engaging with here. Yes. Bill Maher spent his entire career 1.00
01:05:27 like crapping on me, hating my religion, calling it stupid, encouraging people to turn away from 1.00
01:05:33 Christ, to abandon God, to embrace hedonism at every level, to, to hate, you know, my culture, 1.00
01:05:39 my people, but you know what? He doesn't like that transgender stuff so much. Sometimes maybe 1.00
01:05:45 actually he's usually not that based on it, but one time he did say something. And so now
01:05:50 oh boy that's it buddy you're on my side remember these are the guys who said william f buckley
01:05:55 needed to purge everybody they disagreed with from the right but bill maher the angry anti-christian
01:06:05 atheist who has consistently attacked insulted slandered conservatives the right white people
01:06:13 christians for years on end the minute he talks about wokeness back in you're good man don't worry
01:06:19 you're not one of those bad john birch society guys who hated communism you're one of the good 0.98
01:06:23 people who just supports gay marriage and legalizing every drug and prostitute prostitution 0.99
01:06:28 and hates christians and yeah you're one of those good ones like what are we doing here 0.98
01:06:33 so mar to me is a fascinating figure because boy he's one of the only classical liberals as you say 0.66
01:06:40 who really called out the kookiness of the left um bill is right about most of the issues i would
01:06:47 Bill is not right about most of the issues and again this is what infuriates me what Dave Rubin
01:06:54 means is Dave is still a leftist when he says Bill is right on most of the issues he means I
01:07:01 am basically still a leftist because I can still see a guy like Bill Maher who like adamantly hates
01:07:07 the right on every level and be like yeah that guy's pretty close he's basically here no he's
01:07:14 not on every critical issue except what opposing anti-semitism right that's the one like other than
01:07:22 that bill maher is not right yes he'll he'll slap the left on the wrist in a monologue like once
01:07:28 every you know month or two to get the the clicks and the plays and the adulation from the right 1.00
01:07:34 he's wrong on everything he's wrong on everything he's garbage he's a terrible human being he hates 1.00
01:07:40 me he hates mine he hates my religion he hates my god but yeah i guess he's willingly right on 1.00
01:07:46 all the issues right roughly let's say you absolutely disagree with him on abortion and
01:07:51 actually i'm closer to your position on abortion than i am with bill but let's say so if you're
01:07:56 bishop bearing sitting at this table i'm sorry this is immoral there's no other way to say this 0.98
01:08:01 this is immoral bishop bearing is sitting across the table from a man who literally is gay married 0.61
01:08:07 has as i understand a contract that was very standard in uh you know the these different um 0.95
01:08:15 uh uh these different uh surrogacy contracts that says if there's something wrong with the baby we
01:08:21 can force the mother to abort it and he's like well no i'm pretty close to your position i mean
01:08:29 maybe he's changed his mind since he bought his kids but at the very least bishop parents should
01:08:34 say something here look i get it i've done interviews with people i just wanted to understand
01:08:39 i've i've interviewed guys like alexander dugan and i have not gone at them hammer and tong even
01:08:45 though i disagree with them severely on certain things because i wanted to get to understand what
01:08:50 was going on with them i wanted to get the maximum time for them to explain what was happening and
01:08:55 what they believe so maybe that's what he's doing here and fine if that's the case but i just i don't
01:09:01 no man in a moment like this when when you know this guy is publicly representing very like
01:09:07 obviously this position and you don't bring it up at all he's roughly right about what america is
01:09:13 and free speech and things like that what the conclusion i've come to is that donald trump at
01:09:18 a political level is the best guy to accomplish that that there's nothing left in the democrat
01:09:23 party to accomplish those things if you care about free speech if you care about capitalism
01:09:28 if you care about law and order, et cetera, et cetera, there's nothing left for you.
01:09:32 Yes, you have you and John Fetterman, and it's a lonely boat, and good luck.
01:09:36 However, there is something to be said for somebody that stakes out that position and says,
01:09:41 I will not move. Now, if he voted, I don't know if he even voted, but if he voted for Kamala,
01:09:48 I would think, boy, that's... He said he did, I think. Yeah, did he say he did? I know he didn't
01:09:54 vote for trump so okay so they're converting so they're confirming that bill maher has learned
01:09:59 nothing he's learned nothing oh he's anti-woke who would he vote for kamala harris kamala harris
01:10:07 the avatar of woke the dei uh like candidate for president he voted for her for all the oh well
01:10:19 he's learned and he's basically right on all the issues and oh man you know ultimately isn't he
01:10:25 doing what's important no not in any way shape or form and you're admitting it but but we still love
01:10:32 him can't talk to the john birch society can't talk to anybody who's got questions about israel
01:10:37 and our relationship with them fine with a guy who votes kamala harris because we need open borders
01:10:43 and trans kids but he's anti-woke maybe sometimes in one monologue three minutes at a time every 0.99
01:10:49 month it's pathetic it's so pathetic so to me that i just don't understand how you could take 0.99
01:10:55 all your positions that you're right about and then vote for someone who's antithetical to all 0.99
01:10:59 of those things because it's tribal dave because his beliefs mean nothing at the end of the but
01:11:06 anyway whatever but but that's a small piece actually in a way the position where he gets
01:11:11 up there every Friday night on that show, brings on people who he agrees and disagrees with as we
01:11:16 talk about, and then says, I'm here and I did not change. I do think that is admirable. And,
01:11:23 you know, if you sat down with him and you debated abortion for two hours, I don't think you would
01:11:29 change his opinion, but I don't think either one of you would leave angry. Yeah. And I think that
01:11:34 that's, well, that clearly is the theme that we keep coming back to here. Right. And I admire that
01:11:39 about him very much that he does have people and he often complains because democrats don't come
01:11:43 on my show republicans come on my show can i tell you something so so again i know i've hit on this
01:11:48 several times but the fact that they just keep walking into this insane contradiction and
01:11:53 hypocrisy it blows my mind they have repeatedly over and over again talked about how great it is
01:11:59 that william f buckley and these other conservative gatekeepers would not talk to anybody who had any 0.97
01:12:06 questions about israel but it's great that you can talk to somebody who loves baby murder
01:12:13 which one is worse i'm sorry like look again ethnic hatred bad don't engage in ethnic hatred 0.54
01:12:20 but what is worse an anti-semite who mutters to himself under his breath on his front porch
01:12:27 or someone who's like actively involved in supporting the murder of children 0.71
01:12:32 like which one is worse again you shouldn't hate jewish people you certainly shouldn't
01:12:37 take acts of violence out against them but if someone like just holds these beliefs somewhere 0.54
01:12:42 in the abstract while another person is like actively facilitating the murder of children
01:12:49 which one of these people is more rapport morally repugnant which one is not worthy of having a
01:12:55 discussion with because for dave and bishop barron the only real sin the only unforgivable sin the 0.75
01:13:01 only untouchable sin the one which you cannot have a discussion with is opposing israel baby
01:13:07 murder yeah go have go have a two-hour conversation with bill maher you won't change his mind but you
01:13:13 know you won't be angry at him maybe you should be you certainly be angry at him than people who
01:13:19 aren't a big fan of our relationship with israel but we're never gonna we're never gonna i guess
01:13:25 understand that we're never gonna grasp this um when i did club random which is about two or three
01:13:29 years ago. I said to him something that I now realize I did light a little fire in him. I said
01:13:36 to him, Bill, this is before he had sort of made amends with Trump and everything, before the last
01:13:40 election. I said, Bill, tell me this. If you went to a Trump rally, I can tell you what would happen.
01:13:45 You go to a Trump rally and people would love it. They would be like, holy cow, Bill Maher's here.
01:13:49 They'd be like, I disagree with him on some stuff and he's a little wacky on abortion. Abortion would
01:13:53 probably be the big one. But they'd be like, it's Bill Maher. How cool. It's great. It's great. I
01:13:57 said bill what would it be like if you showed up to an aoc rally yeah you would be hated and i i can
01:14:03 send you the clip his eyes like this because he suddenly was like you're right yeah you're right
01:14:09 and that so that's the interesting thing where your voting habits okay his voting habits are
01:14:14 one thing but the idea set is something else so so the fact that he came to this realization with
01:14:23 dave and dave thinks he he got through to bill mar on this and then bill mar turns around and
01:14:28 votes exactly the opposite way and and dave's like well that's not what matters the idea set
01:14:32 is what matters what does that even mean does the idea set not inform the vote and if not why not
01:14:38 dave you want to be a little more specific why is bill mar gonna vote for kamala harris for the rest
01:14:43 of his life despite you proving to him that left hates him and conservatives would welcome in what
01:14:50 does that mean oh it means bill myers hatred of conservatives christians americans is more powerful
01:14:58 than the actual rational understanding that conservatives would be kinder and more welcoming
01:15:04 and build more of the society he wants he hates religion and the right so much that even with that
01:15:11 realization he will vote left and then dave pretends that doesn't mean anything no it means
01:15:15 everything, Dave. It means everything. And I think as the years go by, he will just find common cause
01:15:22 with people. You know what? It's very similar to Richard Dawkins, who's obviously a hugely well
01:15:25 known atheist. He's now very appreciative. He spent his life trying to basically destroy
01:15:29 Christianity, but now appreciates Christian culture. Well, because he realizes that Islam 0.99
01:15:34 as it encroaches on the West is now a much bigger issue. So suddenly he's very appreciative of living 1.00
01:15:40 in a Christian culture. So whether he can grapple with that or what he's going to say on his death
01:15:44 bed or whatever well the question is can you get a christian culture without without christianity
01:15:48 am i would say no ultimately no i would say no and enjoying the fruits of something that he's
01:15:52 trying to destroy right the plant you know well this was again a fair criticism of dawkins when
01:15:58 i've made personally bishop barron's on good footing here nothing nothing to disagree with
01:16:02 always the debate and in some sense this is what separates maybe the classical liberal from the
01:16:06 conservative did it all start with the enlightenment or was there something beneath that
01:16:10 that's what jordan and sam harris debated for years i've come closer obviously to the
01:16:14 to see that's a good question i think you know that's my philosopher's hat on that's a really
01:16:18 interesting question because i would say the best of the enlightenment is a fruit of christianity
01:16:23 yes the worst of the enlightenment is a distortion of it and so there should not be a conflict
01:16:28 between christianity and the enlightenment in the french revolution there was indeed because i mean
01:16:32 that became a radicalized and became deeply anti-clerical anti-religious so this is where
01:16:38 we kind of do a little one one two step here right so yes it's true that the enlightenment
01:16:44 had different impacts in different areas and there's a reason for that but this is also the
01:16:49 problem with like just lumping the enlightenment into one thing uh which of course it wasn't like
01:16:53 you know the difference between rock lock and russo matters even if you know they they might
01:16:58 agree on too many things for our uh you know for our comfort ultimately they did they are different
01:17:05 And they come up with very different systems and different results.
01:17:07 And so the American revolution is very,
01:17:09 very different from the French revolution.
01:17:12 But there is a certain level of secularization that occurs under the
01:17:15 enlightenment and Bishop Barrett is a Catholic.
01:17:19 Like, again, if any, if anyone's going to,
01:17:22 you could understand like why a Protestant might say this at some level,
01:17:25 but even then I think Protestants shouldn't probably say this,
01:17:28 but why is he standing for the enlightenment?
01:17:30 Like he's a Catholic.
01:17:32 They, they don't believe this and not supposed to, 0.73
01:17:35 Like, what's he talking about here?
01:17:36 Our revolution, thank God, was not.
01:17:38 Even though you had, you know, deists like Jefferson and Ben Franklin, but you know, a lot of very committed Christians who gave rise to the American experiment.
01:17:47 And it's not by its nature anti-clerical or anti-religious. 0.53
01:17:51 That's the ominous.
01:17:52 I was on this Religious Liberty Commission.
01:17:55 We just finished our work.
01:17:56 But that's the basic assumption of it, is that the American commitment to religious liberty is a Christian idea.
01:18:02 it's not it's not you know opposed to christianity or trying to limit christianity it comes up out of
01:18:07 the heart of christianity so end of sermon on that wasn't someone removed from the religious
01:18:12 liberty commission that he just mentioned because they didn't support israel like wasn't there a
01:18:17 catholic woman who was ultimately like removed for it for not being sufficiently supportive of
01:18:22 the state of israel like i i'm pretty sure i'm remembering that correctly i could be wrong i
01:18:27 could be wrong but i think that's the case and if so that's a very interesting comment to make
01:18:31 after saying like we need to be able to sit down and talk to people and have these conversations
01:18:35 and yeah i i could i could hang out with bill maher and talk about baby murder all day uh but
01:18:41 if a catholic who isn't big on israel gets removed from the religious liberty commission well
01:18:46 i don't have much to say about that i don't know man yeah um well i would say bill as time goes on
01:18:52 i think he realizes that more and more it's also why during covid most of the people that i found
01:18:58 were kind of sane during COVID happened to be religious because they believed in something
01:19:03 else beyond what Anthony Fauci was telling them every day.
01:19:06 Did you notice this?
01:19:07 It struck me in 2020.
01:19:09 So the great civil rights movement, right, of the 50s and 60s didn't just have religious
01:19:14 people in it.
01:19:15 It was led by religious people, most notably King, but many others too.
01:19:19 It was led by deeply biblical people.
01:19:23 Martin Luther King was not deeply biblical.
01:19:25 He did not believe in the divinity of Jesus Christ.
01:19:28 He cheated on his wife constantly.
01:19:31 He was deeply unfaithful. 0.88
01:19:32 He's been accused of enabling rape, possibly committing rape himself.
01:19:38 Like, this is not true.
01:19:40 Like, this is pop history.
01:19:42 This is in no way true.
01:19:44 And again, he's a man of the cloth.
01:19:46 Like, he should be telling the truth here, or at least he should be availing himself of the truth, learning about this.
01:19:52 Rabbi Heschel.
01:19:53 you know most of the white people the white quote-unquote people that king was marching with 0.70
01:19:58 were jews actually okay so so dave rubin previously is like well they hate they hate jews because 0.94
01:20:14 they're white and they that's why the left hates jews because they see them as white 0.92
01:20:17 and then he takes the time to be like actually the people marching in the civil rights movement 0.93
01:20:23 the ones that made the civil rights movement good,
01:20:25 because they're contrasting it with, you know,
01:20:28 2020 and George Floyd and the BLM riots.
01:20:31 He said, what makes those riots that happened in the 60s,
01:20:34 and there were lots of riots in the civil rights movement,
01:20:37 what makes those riots good and these riots bad 0.85
01:20:39 is there were Christians leading them. 1.00
01:20:42 Which Christians?
01:20:43 Well, Martin Luther King,
01:20:44 who didn't really believe in Christian doctrine.
01:20:46 Okay.
01:20:47 And who else was there?
01:20:48 Oh, religious people, white people. 0.75
01:20:50 Well, actually they were Jews.
01:20:52 It was the Jewish people.
01:20:53 okay um just dave contradicting himself a lot here can't can't seem to hold are jewish people
01:21:01 white or not is is that good or bad and what the civil rights movement i guess is good but
01:21:07 the marching for civil rights now is bad what they don't recognize is of course
01:21:10 that the civil rights movement became wokeness wokeness is the natural evolution of the civil
01:21:16 rights movement it is it is intellectually tied again i've done entire episodes on this i'm not
01:21:22 going to go back and break it all down right now but like this is the natural culmination of the
01:21:27 civil rights movement all you want is the last version of liberalism all you want is the slightly
01:21:32 less radical version of liberalism the one you told was non-violent even though there were plenty
01:21:36 of race riots in the 50s and 60s and 70s but you're you're pretending because you don't know
01:21:42 history after you insulted people for not knowing history again it's absurd yes and so it was led by
01:21:47 religious people 2020 riots religious people were conspicuous by their absence because the woke
01:21:54 revolution doesn't like religion the civil rights movement came from religion it came from that
01:22:01 narrative you just read no civil rights became the religion and that's what bishop barron is
01:22:08 not confronting and dave rubin's definitely not confronting they hate religion because the civil
01:22:14 rights movement became the religion and it can't have other competing religions wokeness is just
01:22:20 the final religious manifestation of civil rights which seems to be the religion that both of these
01:22:26 men actually seem to primarily put before other very important beliefs that's the problem that's
01:22:36 the issue first well because woke is a cult not a religion no right that's the difference right
01:22:42 Right. But it struck me as a very interesting difference. The hostility to religion, which has been part of the university culture for too long, too, that came out of that whole wokest mentality. Religion's on the side of the oppressor and all that. Okay, let me ask this question.
01:22:57 Yeah.
01:23:00 How do you explain Bernie Sanders? Now, here's what I mean.
01:23:04 I'd rather do deep existential stuff. This is pretty thin, but okay.
01:23:08 No, but no, I think it's related to it though,
01:23:10 because I come from a very strong democratic family.
01:23:14 So I'm a Chicago Catholic.
01:23:16 That meant Mayor Daley.
01:23:18 And it meant, you know, like my dad loved politics.
01:23:21 Franklin Roosevelt, Harry S. Truman,
01:23:24 Adlai Stevenson, John F. Kennedy.
01:23:26 Those were his political heroes.
01:23:28 I grew up, one of my earliest political memories
01:23:30 is the Republican convention 1972
01:23:34 and my father lustily booing Richard Nixon, right?
01:23:38 So I left on that last part because it really ties the whole thing together.
01:23:41 It really just brings it all home.
01:23:44 Bishop Barron isn't conservative.
01:23:46 He's not right wing.
01:23:48 He's a leftist.
01:23:49 He grew up a leftist.
01:23:50 He still holds most of those beliefs.
01:23:52 Just like Dave Rubin.
01:23:54 This is not a conversation between two conservatives.
01:23:58 This is not a conversation between two classical liberals.
01:24:00 It was a conversation between two former leftists who find themselves now as, I guess, centrist because the left got so insane that they couldn't stay there anymore.
01:24:16 But that's all they want.
01:24:18 They just want us to go back to being good leftists.
01:24:21 They just want the last version of leftism.
01:24:23 it's still just the international
01:24:25 or the
01:24:26 intellectual dark web
01:24:30 from 10 years ago
01:24:31 nothing has changed
01:24:33 nothing has changed these men have learned nothing
01:24:35 and again that's what struck me about this whole thing
01:24:38 is just what a frozen
01:24:40 time capsule what a snapshot it is
01:24:42 of
01:24:44 2015-2016
01:24:45 and they have just not advanced at all
01:24:47 and they're befuddled about the world around them
01:24:50 because they never really actually
01:24:52 changed anything
01:24:53 They never really thought through where their beliefs are and where they were
01:24:58 going, what the natural end of them was.
01:25:00 But that said, guys, again, long thing.
01:25:03 Took me like almost an hour and a half to get through just the clips I pulled
01:25:06 up there.
01:25:06 But feel free to go back and watch the whole thing.
01:25:08 Never want to take people out of context.
01:25:10 Never want you to think I'm misrepresenting it.
01:25:12 But a lot of what I cut out was just more of this like, oh, yeah,
01:25:15 the left is a little crazy.
01:25:16 Got a little crazy there.
01:25:17 Can't you believe?
01:25:18 I can't believe the left got crazy like that.
01:25:20 We should talk about free speech.
01:25:21 like it's just a lot of rehashing that over and over again but by all means please feel free to
01:25:27 go back and watch the original that said let's go to the questions of the people here
01:25:33 manny youd says i remember the intellectual dark web days man how much things have changed since
01:25:41 back then the idea that people are still stuck in 2016 mindset like dave rubin is wild and sad yeah
01:25:46 Like I said, you know, people like Jordan Peterson, look, Jordan Peterson, far from
01:25:51 perfect, but he changed over time.
01:25:54 You had guys like Brett Weinstein, who I think changed like very credibly, probably like
01:25:58 the most change out of the people in the actual dark web.
01:26:01 You have guys who are adjacent to it, like Carl Benjamin, who changed radically.
01:26:05 These are all people I think are worthy of our respect.
01:26:07 And so it's just amazing to watch those guys take those those journeys and then watch Dave
01:26:11 Rubin and Bishop Barrett sit there and like reheat these talking points from 10 years
01:26:15 ago.
01:26:16 sean wineland says conservatism is just progressivism driving the speed limit yeah i
01:26:21 believe that's michael malice and one of the truest things ever said many says being right
01:26:27 wing has been functionally illegal since september 2nd 1945 all in fear of an ideology long since
01:26:34 dead and defunct this is why we can't have a homeland because the fear of a dead idea yes
01:26:39 i've talked about this i think um that uh r.r reno's return of the strong gods is one of the
01:26:44 better books, you know, describing this phenomenon. If you haven't read it, you should definitely
01:26:48 read it. Or if you don't have time, you could at least watch the episode I did on it a little bit
01:26:52 ago. Well, actually a couple of years ago at this point. David Dundon says, sorry, Rube,
01:27:00 center dissolved. Incoherencies, contradictions, lies, too obvious, too few benefits, too many
01:27:05 grievous harms. IEW equals mouths without a constituency nation for me, not for the ending.
01:27:14 yep i think that's a pretty good summation there man i think that's basically exactly where we got
01:27:19 to and why this is just ringing so hollow both these guys are surprised that both sides have
01:27:24 gone very different directions i'm not surprised at all because i understood that what they were
01:27:28 selling at the beginning well i didn't understand it right at the beginning but i quickly learned
01:27:32 that it was insufficient it was a good starting place i don't blame anyone for going through this
01:27:37 phase i went through it too but you have to be an adult it's like uh it's like reading ayn rand
01:27:41 right like every 16 year old thinks ian rand is an absolute genius and then you become an adult
01:27:46 and you move out of it unless you're libertarian wild speaker says all these i didn't leave the 0.78
01:27:51 left left left me types were always foolish allies to rely on they willfully admit that they are
01:27:57 still left-wing yeah again i i wrote a article early on when i was the blaze recorded a video
01:28:01 about it called the neocon cycle i think this is a big part of it i think it's very dangerous to
01:28:06 put people like this in charge of a movement to see them as the center of any of this movement
01:28:10 uh and so i think it's just very foolish you know if you're someone who is moving away from the left 0.92
01:28:14 that's great i'll talk to you i'll encourage you but i'm not putting you in charge of anything and 0.72
01:28:18 you definitely go you don't get to tell me what conservatives should be doing what right wingers
01:28:22 should believe manny youd says communism kills the body but liberalism rots the soul so true sir
01:28:29 so true dorito world order says can we get your take on the christopher nolan uh blackwashing
01:28:36 trans watching the odyssey love the guys movies but seems like you've jumped the shark yep i'm
01:28:41 i feel exactly the same way huge christopher nolan fan uh memento was like the first like
01:28:46 really artsy complicated movie ever saw uh blew my mind love the prestige love inception uh love
01:28:54 the batman movies uh just fantastic uh even liked interstellar even though i thought it got uh weird
01:29:00 and and kind of boring in places uh but his last few movies uh i mean he had oppenheimer which is
01:29:06 solid uh but like um you know tenant was was not great and then now this uh you know i'm just not
01:29:13 going to go see it is the short answer to that like sorry i love nolan i love his movies i i'm
01:29:18 not i'm not going to go out there try to lead the boycott on this i don't know if we're going to
01:29:21 shut down you know one of the biggest filmmakers in hollywood uh but i i'm not going to see it
01:29:27 because it just it disgraces the material and i don't want to be a part of that weirdy curve says 0.80
01:29:32 the buckleyites made their cowardice a vice very much so very much so and wild speaker says we
01:29:40 must invent time travel so we can uh make john locke sit uh clockwork orange style to watch 0.53
01:29:46 modern day surrogacy videos in order to prevent liberalism yeah yeah to be fair at least at least
01:29:52 locke said you can't trust atheists right so he would have been right about bill maher um but yeah
01:29:56 I think if, if Locke knew the, ultimately the, um, you know, kind of fruit of his ideology, 0.94
01:30:03 he would have just been like, you know what?
01:30:04 Fillmore's right.
01:30:05 Divine right of Kings.
01:30:06 Uh, you know, stick, stick with the monarchy.
01:30:09 Never, never turn this stuff loose.
01:30:11 I think that that's probably true.
01:30:13 If we could go back and actually show them where everything went.
01:30:16 All right, guys, that said, thank you so much for watching.
01:30:18 It's always a pleasure.
01:30:19 I appreciate everyone coming by watching live.
01:30:22 Great having a discussion with you.
01:30:23 and of course if it's your first time on this channel you need to click subscribe the bell
01:30:28 the the notification like the video all that stuff helps people see the video more gets it up in the
01:30:33 algorithm if you want to uh get these broadcasts as podcasts you need to subscribe to the or mac
01:30:38 entire show on your favorite podcast platform and if you do leave a rating or review there that
01:30:42 helps with the algorithm and of course i have my book the total state it is out in its second
01:30:46 printing paperback got an extra chapter now so if you've been waiting for the paperback or for the
01:30:51 extra chapter now's your time pull the trigger go on amazon pick up the total state thank you
01:30:55 everybody for watching and as always i will talk to you next time