The Israel-Iran War Did Not Take Place | Guest: The Prudentialist | 6⧸25⧸25
Episode Stats
Length
1 hour and 7 minutes
Summary
The Iran-Israel conflict seems to be in a cease-fire for the moment, which is a good thing. But what does that mean for the future of peace in the Middle East? And what does it mean for America's relationship with Israel and Iran?
Transcript
00:00:03.400
Get a big cash purchase discount of up to $12,300
00:00:07.180
on the 2025 GMC Sierra 1500 and the 2025 Sierra HD.
00:00:13.180
With Sierra 1500's premium interior and advanced tech
00:00:16.520
or Sierra HD's impressive power and capability,
00:00:19.380
you'll have everything you need to get from work to play
00:00:23.860
Hurry in, employee pricing is on for a limited time.
00:00:36.400
Before we get started, I want to tell you a little bit
00:00:41.520
You've heard us talking about this and for good reason.
00:00:44.040
Share the Arrows is one of the most powerful women's events
00:00:47.420
happening this year and it's hosted by Blaze TV's own
00:00:54.760
and it's where women in your life who have been craving
00:00:57.720
real encouragement and biblical truth can get together.
00:01:00.580
Your wife, your daughter, your sister, this is for her.
00:01:03.520
It's a full day of worship, teaching, and powerful conversations.
00:01:09.500
and this is a chance to push pause, learn in truth,
00:01:17.580
Tickets and details are available at sharethearrows.com
00:01:27.780
that over the last few days, pretty much every show
00:01:30.940
in the news sphere has been about the Iran-Israel war
00:01:39.960
There are many people who do that and they do that well
00:01:44.820
but in my view, a lot of times when you're trying
00:01:48.160
to do accurate analysis, being right on top of the issue
00:01:51.200
is really detrimental, it's very easy to get caught up
00:01:54.080
in the emotion, it's very easy to have your understanding
00:01:58.160
overridden by whatever event is currently getting splashed
00:02:03.880
what is increasingly true is the information we're receiving
00:02:10.760
and immediately gets corrected or rewritten in real time
00:02:13.700
and this makes it very difficult to look at any given event
00:02:16.680
and immediately give your analysis because if you do,
00:02:21.600
or intentionally false information that really makes it difficult
00:02:27.060
and again, that's not an accident, that's in many cases
00:02:29.820
what the participants involved in the conflict want
00:02:34.060
So I'm gonna talk a little bit about what we know
00:02:41.160
and joining me today is one of our favorite returning guests,
00:02:46.780
Thanks for having me on, Oren, it's always a pleasure.
00:02:49.580
So I guess we'll kind of start at the beginning.
00:03:01.600
something that we were particularly concerned at.
00:03:06.140
the desperate need to get rid of Iran's nuclear capacity
00:03:30.020
are very concerned that Trump would be the war candidate
00:03:36.140
the invasion of Iraq and Afghanistan being mistakes
00:03:52.640
So, yeah, this is, it seems very out of the blue
00:04:16.320
because I think for the majority of Trump supporters,
00:04:28.660
But they know that many of these geopolitical issues
00:04:31.860
have been used to try to distract from the fact
00:04:44.640
And the only thing that consistently gets acted upon
00:04:52.400
Again, not pretending that a nuclear weapon in Iran
00:05:21.660
but again, it feels like the timeline went from
00:05:25.600
for at least years to we have to worry about this immediately.
00:05:36.680
the attempt by Democrats to obviously spread those
00:05:39.560
It looked for a minute like we were really pushing
00:05:41.940
towards a new summer of love along immigration grounds
00:05:57.980
because, of course, a lot of people have pointed out
00:06:00.800
that Netanyahu is in a very perilous place domestically.
00:06:06.480
when we're looking at the nature of this conflict.
00:06:08.800
This is a guy who has been in power for a long time,
00:06:12.160
but has increasingly found his political future
00:06:18.100
he was just a few votes away from possibly losing power
00:06:24.600
this feels a little bit like Caesar deciding he has to march
00:06:27.720
because otherwise he's going to face criminal prosecution.
00:06:31.100
This became Bibi Netanyahu's most important thing.
00:07:00.920
And I think that for both Trump as well as Netanyahu,
00:07:36.280
and step over these activist district court judges.
00:08:26.920
There's a very strong lobbying presence as well.
01:00:17.600
from the pakistan and india uh exchange right i guess they didn't go to full-blown war so
01:00:22.600
maybe it prevents a certain level of war uh but uh we we you know obviously we're basically in a
01:00:29.220
proxy war with russia right now and no one has launched any nukes uh and so i think that there
01:00:34.520
there is a very strange uh substrata of war where like basically you can do this much war without
01:00:40.560
triggering nuclear deterrence but but not no higher so there's i guess nuclear deterrence
01:00:45.460
sets a ceiling on the intensity of war but does not prevent conflict overall but prudential this
01:00:51.140
is probably a better question for you yeah and i i think the other thing really too to consider that
01:00:55.460
and this goes back to that uh these debates between scott sagan and and kenneth waltz was well what are
01:01:01.780
your capabilities to have second strike capability what is the current rate or production of your
01:01:07.920
nuclear arsenal what does your government look like in terms of competence and diplomacy these are
01:01:12.280
things that all kind of get considered and i mean as oran had pointed out like you know you can only
01:01:17.880
have so much war and as we saw during the biden administration there were conversations that
01:01:22.260
happened between the defense secretary lloyd austin and the biden government alongside with
01:01:27.040
ukrainians and the russians so when the ukrainians did something that seemed like escalatory there were
01:01:32.220
always calls to washington about like hey did you authorize this did you approve it in the same way
01:01:36.460
that we've kind of watched um iran and america say like you people should evacuate before i bomb this
01:01:42.400
place and people like to reduce this to kayfabe or theater but it's also sort of this strategic
01:01:47.580
diplomatic out that people are giving themselves to avoid it like conflict obviously has still
01:01:52.200
happened i mean uh yes nuclear weapons have maybe reduced um some of the large-scale conflicts that we
01:01:57.880
have been grown worried about maybe during the fears of the cold war and all the world war three
01:02:02.120
concerned but at the same time we also have to seriously consider well what is pakistan's second
01:02:07.640
strike capability or what would iran's second strike capability look like because if you can't do
01:02:12.680
it and your attacks with nuclear weapons would just be inviting suicide because you can't intercept or
01:02:17.540
retaliate it kind of limits things but at the same time the biggest thing that from what i've read
01:02:22.320
and what i've witnessed is is that it's really concerning when governments especially diplomats and
01:02:27.660
security officials stop talking to each other and once those lines of communications are
01:02:31.820
off then the security dilemma gets really uneasy and really high and that's when people get worried
01:02:37.040
but i i think at the end of the day when it comes to this stuff uh iran still wants to pursue a nuclear
01:02:42.560
weapon and they probably will because they know that you get treated differently on on the world stage
01:02:49.460
kmax mcdonald says is it fair to say israel mostly took over american foreign policy when the cold war ended i
01:02:58.420
don't feel it was quite as talked about until the 1990s in george w bush pat buchanan and ron paul
01:03:05.040
were its only critics then oh well i wouldn't say it's only critics there were there were several others
01:03:11.000
uh very notably uh you had um russell kirk who got canceled for uh saying that some american politicians
01:03:18.440
forget that the capital of america is not tel aviv uh that said i think america probably has had
01:03:24.940
its own foreign policy interests of course and has acted in in accordance with those but it's
01:03:31.220
undeniable especially in this particular case that israel had a significant influence like i said
01:03:36.140
no one was talking about whether or not we needed to end israel or iran's nuclear capacity just a few
01:03:43.280
weeks ago that was not the focus of the government it immediately became the focus it became the focus
01:03:47.940
for one singular reason israel launched an attack in iran you can feel that they were justified you can say
01:03:53.700
that that's the right thing you can do you can even say the united states should have been more
01:03:56.440
concerned and involved with that but what you can't do is say that the priority stack didn't get
01:04:01.180
shuffled simply because israel made a unilateral uh decision to make an attack on iran you can't call
01:04:09.120
that not influence like you can say the influence is good you can say the influence is bad but don't
01:04:14.280
don't tell me that you know an issue that literally did not exist for the vast majority of americans
01:04:19.620
a couple weeks ago suddenly becomes the most important issue in the world because israel takes
01:04:24.480
action and that has nothing to do with some level of influence with israel i think that's pretty
01:04:29.340
obvious yeah and as you mentioned oran it wasn't just those two that had criticized about it there is
01:04:34.120
a laundry list of people who have been criticized uh for for making very obvious observations about that
01:04:39.380
kind of influence from sam francis to the late and great joe soberan to um of course ron paul and pat
01:04:46.640
buchanan who had gotten in trouble even when he talked about you know these things in in 2011
01:04:51.240
uh in 2012 when he had put out his book about the suicide of superpower um so i mean yeah clearly
01:04:56.900
there's influence there you can debate the the value or the worth or how much influence that it has but
01:05:01.380
it is a certain faction that or a certain degree of influence that has a very pro-interventionist
01:05:06.780
um faction in there and i mean you can see that from everyone from lindsey graham in the senate to
01:05:11.740
randy fine in the house of representatives uh it does clearly illustrate some of the
01:05:15.920
problems that america has not just with say like you know the israel foreign policy but even inside
01:05:21.040
uh other countries too or when it comes to say like somalia with ilhan omar and others like that
01:05:26.760
there is a fundamental problem it's not just with say like israeli influence it is a blanket problem
01:05:31.740
of dual citizens influencing the united states government let's not forget that just a few weeks
01:05:37.640
ago the president of mexico literally told her citizens in the united states to continue riots so that
01:05:44.280
they could affect american foreign policy or american domestic policy so yeah the greater mexico
01:05:49.720
doctrine in which the literal president of that country recognizes that illegal immigrants are here
01:05:56.060
to serve her interests and she commands them to act on the behalf of her nation yeah it's it's not just
01:06:02.480
israel having an effect on the united states this is why you know again we go to samuel huntington
01:06:08.420
talking about the influence that diasporas have you know he points that armenia is often called you
01:06:14.260
know the the other the other israel lobby because of its level of influence because of the large
01:06:19.380
armenian diaspora in certain key cities in the united states so that you know whether it be somalia or
01:06:24.760
mexico or israel or armenia or any of these nations uh having a large population or an influential
01:06:31.060
population in key areas of the united states is going to allow you to influence the united states which is
01:06:36.320
why a number of founding fathers warned us about special relationships with foreign countries
01:06:41.600
because this is exactly the incentive that it sets up all right guys we're going to go ahead and wrap
01:06:47.320
this up again once again i want to thank everybody for coming by as always it is a pleasure to talk
01:06:52.500
with the prudentialist and you should be perusing his internet wares if it's your first time on this
01:06:57.740
channel please make sure to subscribe on youtube click the bell notification so you know when we go live
01:07:02.180
if you want to get these broadcasts as podcasts you need to subscribe to the or mcintyre show on your
01:07:06.340
favorite podcast network and if you want to support the show remember you can always sign up for the
01:07:10.100
blaze or you can head over to shop blaze media click on the uh or mcintyre collection to pick up some
01:07:15.440
merch for the show thank you everybody for watching and as always i will talk to you next time