00:11:48I think he's actually quite petty and not good at all, clearly willing to attack and lie about people.
00:11:55But ultimately, this is not Nathan Coughness' fault.
00:11:59He's not responsible for what happened here.
00:12:01in this case at least he did nothing wrong and whatever you feel about his views or his personal
00:12:07uh you know conduct the plagiarism was real real enough for cambridge to take it to take it finally
00:12:13seriously after it being outed but ultimately they're going to try to they're trying to use
00:12:18that you know reference point coughness as uh kind of the the key issue because if we actually
00:12:25take a look at academia especially the promotion of minorities in academia you're going to quickly
00:12:31find that all of these people are propped up for the most part that if you know because we know
00:12:36that the admissions have been artificial and the elevation of these people is artificial and so if
00:12:41Jason Arday is found to be illegitimate as a scholar well this doesn't just indict Cambridge
00:12:47or you know the people who are in charge of his ascension or even the people who participate in
00:12:53it it indicts the entire system because the entire system is arrayed to produce exactly this outcome
00:12:59And if it turns out to be fake beginning to end, and this is endemic throughout the system, well, you have a real problem on your hands.
00:13:09Well, definitely. And look, we understand this, that the regime has an ability to hollow out an institution, to make it into a skin suit, as someone once said.0.83
00:13:21And it's so clear this is what's happened to higher levels of education, really to all education.
00:13:26This is no longer a system for producing and educating the best and brightest.
00:30:00I mean, sure, some progressives did make the argument
00:30:03that you shouldn't call the cops on someone
00:30:05breaking into your house or stealing your car
00:30:07because if they're harmed, that's your responsibility.
00:30:09but well most normal people don't think that way they're like no obviously it was his fault
00:30:17on two levels both that he got himself into a situation where he became a public laughingstock
00:30:23and also in all likelihood to be fair we don't have a coroner's report but if he did check out
00:30:31himself, quite literally, that's on him. The sui in suicide means you do it yourself.
00:30:39Not that, again, a bunch of people killed you. There's a different term for that.
00:30:45Lynching certainly is one, murder is another. These are different concepts.
00:30:49And obviously, this isn't an argument. This isn't a syllogism. This isn't set out with perfect
00:30:54logical consistency, it's an emotional attack. It's designed to push away the focus from an
00:31:02uncomfortable reality to an arena that people like Kendi are more than capable of operating in,
00:31:08which is basically being a huckster, right? Using someone's good nature, someone's natural aversion
00:31:15to vigilante killings, horrific photos of people who've been killed, and using that to, ironically
00:31:22enough, whitewash what would be a very clear case of, well, fraud, of lying. And again,
00:31:32in a just society, this guy would be exactly that, a confidence man, a huckster, right?
00:31:39You can imagine him selling fake deeds 200 years ago or whatever. But the fact that he has not only
00:31:46been pushed to such a high level, but is being defended again by the same class of people,
00:31:52Elites like Kendi, who have access to institutions, who have access to honors that you or I don't, and let's be honest, probably couldn't, even if we were saying the exact same things that he were, for fairly obvious reasons.0.85
00:32:06And so look, you and I are examining this statement, not simply to point out that it's not well thought out, that it's stupid, that it doesn't make sense, but to expose a tactic.
00:32:16This one is particularly easy to identify because it's such a ridiculous situation, but this exact same tactic of deliberately using hyper emotive language, of deliberately using something that causes most people to recoil, to associate with very bad things, to cover up something that's, well, much less clear cut.0.86
00:32:39that isn't what you've seen in hollywood it's actually just a guy being embarrassed for
00:32:45something that he did wrong very publicly wrong you know the amazing thing is that at some point0.86
00:32:54he probably could have just landed on his feet you know claudine gay is not you know eating tuna
00:32:59fish sandwiches uh you know home alone i believe she's still employed in academia today uh so
00:33:05really the fact that he went to this radical step uh is kind of its own uh story maybe he knew that
00:33:13things were worse for him maybe he knew his lies went deeper or maybe the shame was just too much
00:33:18but remember that even if he had actually paid a a professional and social price for this it
00:33:26probably would not have been permanent it probably wouldn't even been that prominent and he probably
00:33:29would have landed back on his feet working in academia somewhere else just a year or two later
00:33:34uh so that that is an indictment of the system itself and i don't want to beat this to death
00:33:40because i think we've pretty much covered this as thoroughly as possible there's only you know
00:33:44you can't do a whole hour of what a hypocrite these people are but ultimately uh well i guess0.71
00:33:49you can there are plenty of i was about to say aaron you can make yourself very rich doing0.73
00:33:54exactly that very true uh but but i guess i'll just tie this up in a bow saying that ultimately
00:34:00uh the reason that uh kindy is freaking out the reason that academia is scrambling the reason the
00:34:06media is trying to cover this is it true there this truly is an indictment of the entire institution
00:34:10to the core there is no world in which uh jason uh um i've got his last name our day our day thank
00:34:20you i was trying to say aldi and that's not right that's a grocery store uh but uh there's no way
00:34:25that he is some singular figure okay there's it's not like oh well you randomly search and find uh
00:34:32you know plagiarism and then you search our day and you find plagiarism there's you could probably
00:34:37unravel the entire academic establishment and certainly probably most of the diversity hires
00:34:42with this tool and they are desperately trying to cover and and trying to shame anyone who might
00:34:49try to look into any of this because if it continues this really could like completely
00:34:54unspool the idea of academia it strikes at the very core of their beliefs the core structure
00:35:00again of their twisted version of our political formula and if they don't scare everyone away
00:35:05from asking more questions about what's going on here well there's no way they can actually defend
00:35:10the structure of what they have uh that said uh the other thing i wanted to discuss today
00:35:15was jeremy boring uh jeremy boring has been on a tear of the last few weeks apparently uh you
00:35:23he started his own podcast and at first you know whatever but it seems like the podcast has
00:35:28basically just become a platform for bringing every kind of classical lib uh lol cow that he
00:35:35can onto the platform to tell us all about the dangers of the woke right and the evils of power
00:35:40and how young people are all nazis and you know we we've gone through all this stuff a million
00:35:45times you guys are very familiar with this line of reasoning from james lindsey or joel barry or0.74
00:35:50all of these clowns that just really want to make sure that the right loses forever and that you know
00:35:56that is your goal your noble goal as a conservative is to hand your country over to third world0.99
00:36:01barbarians and like you know twisted demented leftists like that that's the only honorable0.88
00:36:07thing that you can do we've all heard this rhetoric before now i also don't want to belabor this too0.89
00:36:12long because i didn't do a full episode i could you could have done a full episode on this but
00:36:16the funny thing is i already did uh so um jeremy boring talked about uh carl schmidt because of
00:36:24course carl schmidt while really being one of many many figures that we have talked about
00:36:29intellectually when it comes to the new right uh he has the advantage of being a nazi at some point
00:36:35in his life and so therefore uh there is a a feeling that you can use carl schmidt as if he
00:36:42is the foundation of everything the new right
00:36:44has ever talked about which he obviously is
00:46:21uh also uh what jeremy boring is doing is taking a set of memes that he has seen online and mixing
00:46:30them together and vomiting them out as some kind of criticism of carl schmidt now to be fair i have
00:46:38made some of those memes uh but as with all memes the memes are half a joke because that's what
00:46:45memes are they're not meant to convey highly sophisticated ideas right they are a quick
00:46:52reaction on twitter in fact i stopped using those memes specifically because i was so tired of
00:46:58people you know misconstruing or mixing this up that i just don't use anymore because i don't
00:47:03think it's helpful even though i think they were good memes and they were funny like ultimately
00:47:06people took these memes i guess very very seriously and tried to pretend like they were
00:47:11conveying the entirety of a complex academic idea. And Jeremy is not responding to the things
00:47:17Carl Schmitt wrote. He does not know what Carl Schmitt said. He has not spent time studying or
00:47:22understanding or analyzing the text. Jeremy Boring is just vomiting back the things that he saw on
00:47:28the internet that he thinks will look like an actual refutation of what's going on.
00:47:34Oh, a hundred percent. And the very frustrating thing about this is that, look, memes are useful,
00:47:43right? It's helpful to convey an idea quickly in a snappy way, but we understand this with
00:47:49any form of philosophy, right? I'm sure in a previous era you saw, you know, libertarian
00:47:55memes and yeah, sure. We can make fun of libertarians for all the appropriate reasons,
00:48:00But there is a big gap between some deep fried image of a snake with glowing laser eyes and actually reading Hoppe. There's a distinction there. And oftentimes in defending this posture, people like Boring and others will say, oh, you're just like the communist who said, oh, have you read Marx? That's the line of attack.
00:48:23Like, oh, are you saying I need to spend hours and years studying this in order to have an opinion?
00:48:30No, but if you are making a specific claim, Schmitt says this, Marx says this, that is not based in fact, asking, are you even sure what you're talking about is reasonable.
00:48:44Like, you can disagree with Schmitt in a way that indicates you have read Schmitt.
00:55:07and applying it to the least consequential things
00:55:10possible like oh isn't this ridiculous if you you know treated your you know local pta a lot or
00:55:16local pta meetings like you know a battle or meeting with genghis khan like yes of course
00:55:22these are different orders of like this is radically different completely different scale
00:55:27again to make it look ridiculous does the person want next to me want a three percent increase in
00:55:35property taxes is a very different question than does the person next to me want to steal my child0.96
00:55:40mutilate their genitals and ultimately make sure I never see them again if I disagree with that
00:55:45action right like those are fundamentally different questions and calling them all politics is0.99
00:55:52basically what Jeremy Boring is doing here and pretending that all of them should be treated
00:55:55exactly the same is the sleight of hand as you point out that he is utilizing how it works in
00:56:00an honor culture where loyalty to the tribe outranks truth outranks justice outranks everything
00:56:05Schmidt didn't invent anything of course all he did was take the oldest and most basic arrangement
00:56:10on earth, laundered it through a German law faculty, and then sold it back to the West as
00:56:14some sort of sophisticated political theory. The friend-enemy distinction is just a permission
00:56:19structure. It's the logic that tells a nation that its enemies are owed nothing. And once a
00:56:23people believes that, well then there's no atrocity that can't be justified. Schmidt himself, it should
00:56:28be noted, was a card-carrying Nazi. And that's the grim world that Candace and Tucker and Hassan0.72
00:56:33Piker and all the rest of them are driving us toward. They get there by different means, but
00:56:37they all get to the same place see you either believe in objective truth you believe in an
00:56:42impartial system you believe in the primacy of justice over tribe and over wealth and over might
00:56:46or you so uh candace owens notable political philosophy enjoyer uh we can confirm that
00:56:55obviously jeremy boring uh implying that she is only doing what she's doing because
00:57:00she has discovered carl schmidt okay um couple problems here uh so the idea that uh you can just
00:57:11do any that this is permission structure uh funny enough one of the most famous carl schmidt quotes
00:57:17is literally about how saying that he who uses the word humanity cheats because that person is
00:57:24looking for a permission structure to do whatever they want to the people they don't like by
00:57:30declaring someone inhuman or maybe even a nazi you have permission to treat someone however the
00:57:38way because they are a enemy of humanity meaning they are no longer human that was carl schmidt's
00:57:43point who literally made the opposite argument that you need to be very careful about how you
00:57:50utilize language because it could in fact allow you to treat anyone any way you want with no
00:57:57concern for morality or truth, that's actually insane. You're literally saying the exact opposite
00:58:04of what Carl Schmitt said. You are lying. Jeremy Boring is a liar, though I doubt Jeremy Boring
00:58:09knows he's lying because I doubt he has read that passage. I doubt he has read Carl Schmitt.
00:58:14I doubt he has any informed opinion about what Carl Schmitt actually said in his work. That said,
00:58:21also this is just clearly clearly nothing but an attempt to tie everybody into the same
00:58:29gaggle of people he hates everybody who is associated with this i mean jeremy boring
00:58:35doesn't believe candace owens has read carl schmidt he doesn't believe hasan piker or tucker
00:58:39carlson are driven by carl schmidt so why is he tying them in here well you see jeremy boring
00:58:45is creating a friend and enemy distinction he is trying to put everybody who he disagrees with
00:58:52in the untouchable out group and they are nazis and we know what we can do with a nazi you can0.98
00:58:58punch a nazi charlotte crook was assassinated because he was a nazi so i want to be really0.91
00:59:03clear here jeremy boring is creating a permission structure where violence can be done to people who0.84
00:59:09disagree with him politically jeremy boring is doing what he thinks carl schmidt was doing
00:59:14with a friend-enemy distinction. Can we also acknowledge, and I'm not trying to
00:59:21derail this stream, but given the comments, Auron, you and I heard from Jeremy Boring about
00:59:30certain other nations, the irony of saying, can you believe in a tribal system that holds that
00:59:39there's nothing wrong you can possibly do to your enemies and you have no responsibility to your
00:59:44political enemies. Oh, also, we need to support this war halfway across the earth. You're like,
00:59:50all right, dude, come on, man. Like, come on. I understand there are certain people who object to
00:59:57the moral framing of Schmitt. But when these critics themselves embody their own stereotypes
01:00:05of Schmittian politics, it becomes impossible to point out. It's not like you and I are cutting
01:00:12this guy into a million different pieces, you know, stitching together different quotes to
01:00:16make him look bad. Just watch it. It is clear, not only does he have no idea what he's talking about,
01:00:23but he has no real principles. The principles that he himself is lauding as better than Schmitt,
01:00:31that he is lauding as the ultimate kind of pinnacle of objective morality, he makes no
01:00:38attempt to stick to. He has his own, ironically enough, Schmidian exception, something for which
01:00:45his stated principles will bend. And so, again, you can look at Schmitt and say there are things
01:00:51I dislike or I like about him. But when you are criticizing him, inaccurately, I might add,
01:00:58while embodying his exact political framing, I'm sorry if I don't take you seriously.0.94
01:01:03It's ridiculous. It's genuinely a ridiculous situation.0.94
01:01:06well and at the end here he basically is appealing to liberalism right he says look you need to not
01:01:12care about tribe you need to not care about identity what you need to care about is objective
01:01:16standards objective values objective morals institutions that's what matters that's what
01:01:23makes you american or whatever is that you ultimately embrace this stuff that's what we
01:01:27believe unless you're a country in the middle east in which case you don't get validated by
01:01:35your institutions you aren't actually upholding to this objective way you should treat people
01:01:40you are allowed to define yourself as an ethno state and you are allowed to prefer your tribe
01:01:46against others as you point out jeremy boring has a literal state of exception to these principles
01:01:53those principles of jeremy apply to you as an american conservative they do not apply to
01:02:00nations in the middle east that he has decided have this special exception it is the literal
01:02:06schmidtian political miracle that intercedes on the behalf of those who you have deemed above
01:02:14these principles so it's incredible that he appeals to exactly this idea of liberalism but
01:02:21as you point out 10 seconds later he would have to turn around and say actually there's a particular
01:02:26exception because for some reason Israel is just different than everyone else well and it's this
01:02:31very tactical framing because figures like boring and others have criticized the woke left they have
01:02:38to when addressing us adopt this framing that all of our institutions are perfectly liberal that
01:02:45they're working exactly as designed but look at our first story look at you know Jason or day
01:02:51however we say his name I'm sorry I don't know how to pronounce really anyone's name
01:02:55But you look at that and you're like, oh, well, I thought that we didn't advance people on the basis of their tribe. I thought that we didn't make decisions based off of, one might say, some sort of line in the stand distinction.
01:03:11And well, if we already are, functionally, like look at our institutions, well, what
01:03:56And so at a certain point, if you want to win, if you want to protect your way of life,
01:04:03you have to adopt to the war that you're fighting, not the war you wish you were fighting.
01:04:08And many people make fun of generals in the First World War, sending cavalry charges at machine gun nests, and then adopt that exact same mechanism when we're talking about politics.
01:04:21And again, Aron, you and I are not the ideologues here.
01:04:25You and I are not the lunatics possessed by theory, desperate to make reality conform to our high-minded series of ideals.