The Auron MacIntyre Show - August 17, 2026


The Left's Newest Martyr Is Another Fraud | Guest: J. Burden | 8⧸17⧸26

Topics
Hosted by
Guests
Mentioned
Did America Become a Communist Country? | Guest: J. Wargo | 8⧸14⧸26 Lindsay Clancy and the Question of Female Agency | 8⧸19⧸26

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 15 minutes

Words per minute

170.95

Word count

12,926

Sentence count

340

Harmful content

Toxicity

39

sentences flagged

Hate speech

28

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 hey everybody how's it going thanks for joining me this afternoon i've got a great stream with
00:00:13 a great guest that i think you're really going to enjoy so this guy jason our day blew up all
00:00:20 of a sudden apparently he was like the youngest black professor to ever be at cambridge he was
00:00:25 this phenom this rising star he had all these achievements uh even had simon and schuster
00:00:31 writing a book about him i think they're actually still going through with that you'll see why that
00:00:35 might be awkward here in a second but what was found out by our day or found out about people
00:00:41 by our day is that it turned out a lot of his work was plagiarized and if you look back at
00:00:46 uh the rest of his life not only was his work plagiarized but it seems like he was
00:00:50 just a completely obsessive liar constantly spinning stories about his achievements
00:00:55 it's very clear that he was only placed in this situation because of the color of his skin 0.88
00:01:01 now after he has apparently ended his life due to the shame of this moment the media is trying to
00:01:08 turn him into a victim there are many people out there now saying that he was lynched in public
00:01:14 because he was a black man we're going to talk about that today and joining me of course is
00:01:20 jay burden thanks for coming on man yeah aaron thanks for having me on i'm looking forward to
00:01:24 it of course so obviously we know that academia is a place that is teaming with progressives who
00:01:32 desperately want to hit certain quotas uh if you've spent any time in college if you've thought
00:01:38 about a career in academia or any way or i mean let's just be honest if you thought about a career
00:01:42 at any company in the united states you know that hitting certain diversity goals is is key and if
00:01:49 you're a white guy out there you're probably going to be at the bottom of the stack when it comes to
00:01:53 resumes even if you have equal ability or even better ability than many people you're competing 1.00
00:01:57 against so it's no surprise that in many situations we see the ardor artificial elevation of minorities 0.81
00:02:04 in these situations of course we know that harvard was caught like massively rigging uh their uh
00:02:12 intake when it comes to applicants. They were weighting the scores of black applicants radically
00:02:17 more, basically giving them hundreds and hundreds of free points worth on the SAT comparatively when
00:02:24 it came to white or Asian students. So we know admissions are rigged. You can tell from the
00:02:29 people who are put in charge. We, of course, had Chris Rufo, known for getting Claudine Gay 0.97
00:02:35 canceled at Harvard due to the fact that she was a plagiarist. And so it's not surprising. I bet
00:02:40 you that even just in general in academia, plagiarism is anywhere, is everywhere. But it's
00:02:46 not surprising that a guy like Jason Arday ends up in the position he's in, right? This is the
00:02:50 culture that has been created in the university system. We always elevate the minority. We always
00:02:57 elevate those who check off these DEI requirements, no matter what their accomplishments. But what we
00:03:05 haven't really seen is the consequences of that on the individuals themselves we've seen the
00:03:11 consequences from a you know lack of capable people in these positions but normally a lot
00:03:16 of these people just kind of walk away they bounce back they go somewhere else apparently
00:03:21 our day was so shaken by this i mean we still don't know for sure he's just been found dead
00:03:25 but the assumption seems to be that this was a case of uh suicide and so ultimately uh we're
00:03:32 seeing a scenario where this guy raised a lot of attention by the way he went out over this and a
00:03:39 lot of people are trying to turn him into the victim at every point i guess we shouldn't be
00:03:44 shocked by this but the man was caught completely manufacturing this stuff and not only did he
00:03:49 manufacture this he went after people and tried to get them fired or thrown in jail for noticing
00:03:54 his lies like he has a history of trying to get litigious about accusations of his dishonesty so
00:04:01 So I guess, are you surprised that this is the tack that these people ultimately took?
00:04:07 No, of course not.
00:04:10 We're all aware of the fact that there is no objective sense of standards coming from the regime.
00:04:18 There are different rules for different people.
00:04:20 For instance, we've been talking quite a bit about this idea of pulling yourself up by your bootstraps.
00:04:25 You need to be personally accountable.
00:04:28 And, well, that is the message towards you and I are.
00:04:31 That's what we are told to do. But if you are a patron of the regime, seemingly you never have
00:04:37 to take responsibility. You can not only be elevated to an incredibly high position if you
00:04:43 flatter progressive sensibilities, but even when you are found out for lying and you take your own
00:04:49 life, which let's be clear, you should not do, but it again is blamed on the other, the external
00:04:58 records, white supremacy, this sort of dark matter that seems to explain all unexplainable
00:05:05 political realities, the thing that has to be there to balance the equation from the progressive
00:05:12 point of view. So even then, in a situation where he presumably has died by his own hand,
00:05:17 that still cannot be his fault. People like Jason Arday occupy a completely different political
00:05:24 social reality than you or I do. If we were caught lying, of course we would lose our jobs. We would
00:05:30 be expunged. That's even assuming we could get a job at Cambridge, which is a secondary point.
00:05:36 But we see that even in death, he has been turned into a sainted figure. And I think it bears
00:05:45 repeating that the fact that he was hired in the first place reflects very, very poorly upon this
00:05:50 institution. Because I'll be honest, I don't follow British academic scandals particularly
00:05:57 closely. This wasn't on my radar until fairly recently. But when I was doing research on
00:06:02 what this guy had claimed to do, these aren't the sort of little lies, a little exaggeration
00:06:09 to make a story more interesting. Each one of these is something that would be exceptional
00:06:15 in its own right and exceptional bordering on impossible. One, of course, you have his
00:06:22 idea that he did not know how to read until he was 11 or 12. He was, or sorry, he was nonverbal
00:06:29 until he was 11 or 12. He couldn't read until he was 18. You're like, I mean, I guess there
00:06:33 are people like that. Very few of them become Cambridge professors, but I guess it's at least
00:06:39 mathematically possible, right? It could have happened. But when you compile the idea that
00:06:44 he's supposed to have run 600 miles in 10 days, that he's supposed to have worked at colleges
00:06:50 that you could very easily check to see if he's worked at, claiming to have written a
00:06:54 book that never came out, to have worked in Africa, all of these things that are easily
00:07:00 verifiable, like this wouldn't fly if you were trying to get a job at Walmart, let alone
00:07:06 allegedly the most prestigious academic institution in the nation, if not the world.
00:07:10 yeah so this is an incredible list you brought up you brought up some of the things that he's
00:07:17 lied about uh but i just wanted to bring up this you know someone had compiled all of the things
00:07:22 he said because it is you know when people say oh well he lied a little bit on his resume oh well
00:07:27 everybody lies on their resume or okay well we get he was woke and so they they elevated him
00:07:32 uh and he probably did some of the plagiarism thing but ultimately you know how bad could it
00:07:37 be no i want people to grasp like the totality of how pathological this guy is so as you say
00:07:43 he claimed he was diagnosed as with autism as a child that he was not able to speak until 11
00:07:51 that he didn't learn to read until he was 18 but he still managed to acquire multiple degrees he
00:07:59 claimed to have had a career as apparently a a pro snooker player which is like a very very
00:08:07 random thing to lie about he lied about being on uh on uh tv shows that he could not have been on
00:08:15 because he was not old enough to exist when they were on television uh he lied about running 30
00:08:22 marathons in 35 days the last nine being on a broken leg right like
00:08:30 as you say if that if that was true by itself just that story all by itself you could make an
00:08:39 entire movie about the incredible heroic effort done here uh you know and of course as you say
00:08:45 you know he claimed about writing books that never came out he claimed to have attended schools and
00:08:51 acquired master's degrees from them when there was no record of him even being there this guy 0.90
00:08:56 is a complete pathological liar like he is not just some guy who fudged a little bit to get into 0.97
00:09:04 Cambridge and got the benefits of the DEI regime this is a man who lied every time his mouth was 1.00
00:09:10 open and there's no way that the people at Cambridge did not know this man was a liar
00:09:17 like there's no way you hear all of these stories like we all have this friend right jay you've got
00:09:23 to have this friend where you know he comes in and every time you meet him he's got a new
00:09:27 wild story about the most ridiculous thing he's ever done he's claimed to achieve all these things 0.98
00:09:32 you know we all know this guy and everyone in the group knows that person is a liar they they 0.94
00:09:38 acknowledge who they are and those lies are almost never as grandiose as the ones being told by
00:09:45 jason here and so you have this scenario where everyone had to have been in on the fact that
00:09:51 this guy was a complete fraud i mean his academic work was in sociology and guess what you'll never
00:09:58 guess the area of study he focused on racism and he went around and interviewed people about 0.74
00:10:04 experiencing racism and then gave commentary on it that was his academic work so this guy was in
00:10:09 a nonsense discipline literally owned he had a degree in race communism and worked teaching
00:10:15 race communism and uh you know was was just pathologically lying about it so everybody is
00:10:21 in on this again simon and schuster prepared to write a book about this man's life taking these
00:10:27 claims at face value obviously like we are talking about a problem that is just built in the system
00:10:36 top to bottom i mean this is emperor's new clothes level of stuff right like he is naked completely
00:10:43 but because he is a black man everyone is required to pretend he is actually wearing
00:10:48 fine clothes and no one is allowed to step out now the guy who ultimately revealed his uh you know
00:10:56 his plagiarism was a guy named nathan kofnes uh now that's significant for a few reasons one uh
00:11:04 Nathan Kofnes is an academic who is famous for his enthusiastic embrace of race realism,
00:11:10 the idea that races are different genetically and have different talents and intelligences.
00:11:15 And so that gives people the stick to say, well, this is this is racism because the guy
00:11:22 who uncovered the the, you know, the level of fraud here, that guy is himself racist.
00:11:28 And so therefore, everything is tainted by this tree and we can put all this together
00:11:33 There's some kind of grand conspiracy against our day.
00:11:36 The other reason I just bring that up is because ultimately, I don't like Nathan Coughness.
00:11:42 He's been really, really crappy to friends of mine, mutual friends of ours like Dave Green.
00:11:46 I don't think he's a good person. 0.53
00:11:48 I think he's actually quite petty and not good at all, clearly willing to attack and lie about people.
00:11:55 But ultimately, this is not Nathan Coughness' fault.
00:11:59 He's not responsible for what happened here.
00:12:01 in this case at least he did nothing wrong and whatever you feel about his views or his personal
00:12:07 uh you know conduct the plagiarism was real real enough for cambridge to take it to take it finally
00:12:13 seriously after it being outed but ultimately they're going to try to they're trying to use
00:12:18 that you know reference point coughness as uh kind of the the key issue because if we actually
00:12:25 take a look at academia especially the promotion of minorities in academia you're going to quickly
00:12:31 find that all of these people are propped up for the most part that if you know because we know
00:12:36 that the admissions have been artificial and the elevation of these people is artificial and so if
00:12:41 Jason Arday is found to be illegitimate as a scholar well this doesn't just indict Cambridge
00:12:47 or you know the people who are in charge of his ascension or even the people who participate in
00:12:53 it it indicts the entire system because the entire system is arrayed to produce exactly this outcome
00:12:59 And if it turns out to be fake beginning to end, and this is endemic throughout the system, well, you have a real problem on your hands.
00:13:09 Well, definitely. And look, we understand this, that the regime has an ability to hollow out an institution, to make it into a skin suit, as someone once said. 0.83
00:13:21 And it's so clear this is what's happened to higher levels of education, really to all education.
00:13:26 This is no longer a system for producing and educating the best and brightest.
00:13:35 It is a patronage network.
00:13:37 Certainly, this guy received more accolades for, shall we say, somewhat mediocre scholarship
00:13:43 than many other competent, capable people.
00:13:47 You get a lot of money from a book deal for Simon & Schuster.
00:13:50 It's a lucrative thing, let alone, of course, the social prestige of being this sort of
00:13:55 cultural figure. We understand there are any number of these sort of court academics who get
00:14:01 to run around and charge lots of money for speaking engagements. It is a patronage network.
00:14:07 It is not really an institute of higher education. Sure, you can go, and if you match up to certain
00:14:13 criteria, some of which are academic, many of which are not, you will get a gold star.
00:14:18 But is that why that institution was created, to hand out gold stars? I mean, kind of,
00:14:24 from a certain perspective, always, you know, having a degree from Cambridge, at least previously,
00:14:28 was something that had a certain amount of social status attributed to it. But functionally, it was
00:14:34 to, well, educate people, people who would be doing important things. And the liberal mind has
00:14:42 this sort of completely backwards understanding of institutions and also of place. And we will
00:14:48 oftentimes point out the fallacy of the magic dirt, the idea that you can take someone from
00:14:54 anywhere, stick them on American soil, and they become just as American as apple pie.
00:14:59 We are running the exact same experiment with the same results in education. The idea that if
00:15:05 someone walks through the doors, if they're handed the paper, the magic paper, they will become
00:15:10 exactly the same sort of person as the graduating class of Cambridge from 1926 or 1916,
00:15:20 let's be honest, 1616, right? That you can magically transform the sort of person produced
00:15:27 by an institution. And that has been an abject, complete, and total failure because they're no
00:15:33 longer searching for greatness, searching for exceptional individuals. They're using it to,
00:15:40 well, launder their feelings through education. It sure would be nice if we had more people like
00:15:48 this in prestigious positions. Well, I know what we'll do. We will simply give them prestige,
00:15:54 regardless of if they deserve it or not. And well, sure, Jason Arday is perhaps the most
00:15:59 egregious recent example. There are many more like him, many more that weren't quite as blatant
00:16:05 with their lives. And sure, we can talk about how that's unfair, how that's immoral, and it
00:16:10 certainly is. But also, we have to understand that things like higher education ideally serve
00:16:16 a purpose in a society. They are there for a reason, to cultivate an elite. And if your elite
00:16:22 is, well, no longer elite, they're basically confidence men. They're hucksters. They're the
00:16:27 kind of guys who, in a more just society, would be trying to sell you fake Rolexes instead of,
00:16:33 oh i don't know being professors with book deals from simon and schuster it shows that there's
00:16:37 something deeply wrong that institution no longer performs its required service
00:16:43 yeah i think that is an incredibly important point uh as we have said many times on this channel
00:16:52 uh the idea of the political formula is really important to understanding power and regime
00:16:59 gitano mosca said that all regimes need a political formula that's not just a noble lie
00:17:06 but something that everyone buys into the rulers and the rule that explains why the people who are
00:17:12 in charge are in charge and if you don't have that then you can use brute force for a while
00:17:17 but your power is going to become brittle and eventually it's going to break down
00:17:20 now in the west largely but especially in the united states our political formula has been
00:17:26 liberal meritocracy uh we used to have situations where people are in charge because of how they
00:17:33 were born you know they had the right bloodline or they were uh worthy aristocrats owned property
00:17:39 something you know there's some contingency on which uh you know that they have inherited
00:17:44 their power uh but we wanted to say that we broke away from that that our our civilization is
00:17:50 different. And that instead of birth or wealth or some other happy accident ultimately gifting
00:17:57 the hierarchy power, instead, everyone in the hierarchy has earned that power through
00:18:04 meritocracy. And the thing that conveys that legitimacy, how do we know a meritocratic guy
00:18:10 from some prole who shouldn't be ruling because he's doing plumbing or HVAC repair? Oh, well,
00:18:16 because they went through college. College makes you elite. Once you have a college degree,
00:18:21 especially the right type of college degree, you have transcended into a different class,
00:18:26 which makes you more eligible to rule. You have a right to rule, especially if you gain certain
00:18:33 status inside those circles. And so it's your professionalism to be competent, to compete at
00:18:41 the highest levels to be selected for this is what legitimizes the rule of our elites well
00:18:48 if you decide that actually our elites don't look right you know our elites are kind of male and
00:18:55 kind of pale and uh they have this nasty habit of all kind of coming from the same areas and the
00:19:01 same uh stock and uh you know having the same beliefs well then you need to you need to do 1.00
00:19:06 things to artificially mix that up as you're saying here and so you change those requirements
00:19:13 not that they were ever 100 objective but now you have to lean harder on the scale and of course the
00:19:19 more people demand representation and of course more and more people do because you keep importing 0.97
00:19:23 more and more foreigners the more representation that is demanded the heavier you have to lean on 0.98
00:19:29 the scale until eventually you are basically entirely weighting the scales in favor of people 0.99
00:19:36 who in no way shape or form actually competed in a meritocratic system and instead are crafting the
00:19:41 elite in basically what is a hereditary manner you're you're going through and selecting people
00:19:47 because of the color of their skin because those type of people deserve to be elevated into the
00:19:52 elite and to help to hold power and so you're entirely undermining not just your mission of
00:19:58 educating people yeah that's long in the dust right but what you're really undermining is your
00:20:03 entire political formula you're revealing the lie that the competent people are in charge the
00:20:10 adults are in the room but the people at the top of the hierarchy are there because they earned it
00:20:14 they were selected for their merit that is clearly not the case and it's getting to the point where
00:20:21 basically no one believes this at this point you went through obviously all the DEI campus stuff
00:20:27 everybody saw the great awokening and what happened there but then of course we also saw
00:20:32 what happened during the covid and the lockdowns and at that point it became clear that all of
00:20:38 these professionals you know whether they're in some frivolous thing like uh you know sociology
00:20:43 or if they are in hard sciences like medicine they will still lie to you to protect the system
00:20:50 they will still manipulate everything shamelessly they have no fealty to truth they have no
00:20:55 fealty to their uh you know their area of study or their expertise uh their expertise is
00:21:01 functionally useless because when the question of should i choose what is true due to my expertise
00:21:06 or should i choose what is politically popular because of the system elevated me almost all of
00:21:11 them will choose the latter and when you know that the institution is not producing people of quality
00:21:17 and the people that it is producing are willing to throw all of their expertise and findings away
00:21:22 you've basically blown up the entire substructure of your power base like there's nothing left
00:21:30 to rest that power upon. And so when you've kind of manufactured the situation, I mean,
00:21:36 the universities still matter because they convey, you know, they credential people and that conveys
00:21:44 a level of status at this point still. But no one is fooling themselves into thinking that
00:21:49 these institutions really carry any significant academic weight anymore. And so, I mean,
00:21:54 will this hurt universities yes at some level but the real thing is everyone is just kind of
00:22:00 watching the shambling corpse of academia continue forward because nobody knows what else to do in
00:22:06 order to credential people and you know reorder the hierarchy to like repair our political formula
00:22:13 like this this is a fatal wound to our political formula and there seems to be little to no effort
00:22:18 to actually heal it it seems like we're just going to keep going until the wheels fall off
00:22:22 well and one i do think it's funny that they have effectively re-engineered a hereditary monarchy
00:22:31 or hereditary aristocracy from first principles now i would say your great grandpa was pretty
00:22:38 good at riding a horse and killing people with a sword is slightly better maybe not ideal of a
00:22:43 basis for picking your elites than you know an arbitrary concentration of melanin but you know 0.88
00:22:49 I get it. I'm a little bit out there as far as politics goes. But also, this core problem that
00:22:55 the political formula is falling apart, that it has been mortally wounded, is why you and I spend
00:23:02 so much time arguing with a certain stripe of conservative, a certain stripe of conservative
00:23:10 who loves these institutions, and rightfully so. At one time, they were great, but cannot recognize
00:23:18 the political reality has shifted, that you simply cannot act as if these institutions,
00:23:26 these features of whether politics or culture are still healthy because they are not.
00:23:31 And they want to pretend as if they are, pretend as if we can still rely on market forces to
00:23:37 correct this. And I understand the appeal, right? I too have an attachment to these pieces of
00:23:44 American culture, these pieces of American society. But at a certain point, the project is
00:23:49 recognizing what is, looking at it dispassionately and saying, well, this problem must be fixed.
00:23:57 How can it be fixed? Instead of sort of wish casting, projecting what you wish were the case
00:24:04 onto a seemingly fatally wounded system and by extension political formula.
00:24:12 well i want to take a look at the reaction because as we mentioned uh the effort has
00:24:18 been launched to turn this guy into a martyr to turn him into a victim uh you can imagine the 0.91
00:24:24 you know the media is ridiculous on this but i want to show you the most ridiculous of all which 0.85
00:24:29 you could probably expect is going to be ibram x kindy share this real quick 0.95
00:24:35 so kendy uh is obviously himself just a race a race communist right like that's that's his only
00:24:44 his only function uh nobody takes him serious as seriously as an academic uh he exists to write 0.68
00:24:51 books about why white people are bad and everybody else is good and while you should be punished for
00:24:57 the color of your skin and so unsurprisingly we have uh his posts here on twitter and he says
00:25:03 the death of jason arday hit so close to home and i had no words yesterday but i both woke up with
00:25:09 words yes stunning and brave uh to be a prominent anti-racist black scholar is to know that you're
00:25:17 a target almost totally surrounded by resentments you know that at any point the attacks can come
00:25:24 like lynch mob and if you die from the attacks the media still calls the attacks on you
00:25:29 accusations to wash their hands of your blood your lynchers announced your death as if they
00:25:36 had no role in your lynching my latest in the emancipator only with time to delve deep into
00:25:43 what i'm sure is a enlightening uh read there so a couple amazing things about this statement
00:25:50 first uh the idea that a black race academic is the most targeted person on a college campus
00:25:59 might be the most provably 0.88
00:26:01 insane thing that anyone has ever
00:26:03 said out loud. Obviously
00:26:05 these are people who have special
00:26:07 plot armor. They are only in
00:26:09 their positions because of
00:26:11 their race. They were elevated specifically
00:26:13 because that's a desirable trait
00:26:15 the university wants to have.
00:26:18 So they automatically have
00:26:19 advantages at every level.
00:26:21 The university wants to hire them. They do not
00:26:23 want to fire them. They want to ignore all
00:26:25 complaints about them as we learned that
00:26:27 jason already had multiple complaints against him and they the people who did so were threatened
00:26:32 uh because they brought legitimate concerns against the guy but on top of this uh we literally
00:26:39 just saw carly charlie kirk assassinated on a university campus that's what being a target
00:26:45 actually looks like that's what being lynched in public on a campus for your politics actually
00:26:52 looks like we also can come up with a thousand examples from peak woke like charles murray
00:26:57 being chased off by a crowd of you know savage uh college students uh you know people in his
00:27:03 entourage getting uh wounded by these people hurt by these people uh the fact that there's a violent
00:27:09 response to a guy who has a book of statistics uh is is insane but this is a common occurrence
00:27:16 on the left so trying to play the big victim in this moment is obviously wild on top of this
00:27:22 the use of lynching is hilarious uh this guy again we don't know for sure but very likely
00:27:29 ended his own life um i will not make any jokes as to how that might have happened uh that said
00:27:36 uh ultimately you have a scenario where you're trying to turn a self-inflicted wound into
00:27:43 something that is going to ruin the lives of everybody else who pointed out he shouldn't be
00:27:48 there that ultimately at some level uh it is the people who noticed the lie noticed the grip
00:27:54 noticed that this guy was taking advantage of a system that was built for him and to hurt everyone
00:28:01 else around him those people are the problem and so what you know he wants to make clear here is
00:28:07 if you notice that a a minority is abusing the system abusing a privilege is ultimately doing
00:28:16 poor work or stealing other people's work well then you you are someone who is the same as a
00:28:21 racist who lynched someone back in i don't know 1870 or something the implication here is simply
00:28:27 noticing the bias in the system and calling out bad behavior is itself a act of deadly physical
00:28:34 violence well of course i don't know if you're aware or on but uh robin williams he was lynched
00:28:42 Kurt Cobain was lynched, Cleopatra, Anne Hero, any number of people apparently I thought just
00:28:49 killed themselves, they were actually lynched. And look, this is deliberately emotive language.
00:28:54 He knows exactly what he's doing here, right? He is taking something that many people have
00:28:58 a visceral reaction to and, well, using that to cover up something that is personally embarrassing
00:29:03 to him. I don't pretend to have a lot of knowledge of Mr. Kinsey's academic work,
00:29:10 but certainly right he has been accused of not having the highest standards but also it is
00:29:17 embarrassing to his narrative that someone like him right running sort of the same grift got exposed
00:29:24 as a massive fraud and well took the coward's way out and that's a very uncomfortable situation to
00:29:29 be in that oh wait hey this guy who was basically saying all the same same things that i did turned
00:29:35 out to be a massive fraud and had no reason to be in his position well that could be uncomfortable
00:29:40 or actually, wait, no, I can blame everyone else.
00:29:43 It's actually, it's not me.
00:29:44 It's not what I think.
00:29:45 It's not any position I have ever taken
00:29:48 that has led to this result.
00:29:49 Some might say inevitably, it's actually you.
00:29:52 It's your fault.
00:29:54 You noticed. 0.99
00:29:55 And by noticing, you killed him. 0.96
00:29:58 Well, obviously that's laughable. 0.55
00:30:00 I mean, sure, some progressives did make the argument
00:30:03 that you shouldn't call the cops on someone
00:30:05 breaking into your house or stealing your car
00:30:07 because if they're harmed, that's your responsibility.
00:30:09 but well most normal people don't think that way they're like no obviously it was his fault
00:30:17 on two levels both that he got himself into a situation where he became a public laughingstock
00:30:23 and also in all likelihood to be fair we don't have a coroner's report but if he did check out
00:30:31 himself, quite literally, that's on him. The sui in suicide means you do it yourself.
00:30:39 Not that, again, a bunch of people killed you. There's a different term for that.
00:30:45 Lynching certainly is one, murder is another. These are different concepts.
00:30:49 And obviously, this isn't an argument. This isn't a syllogism. This isn't set out with perfect
00:30:54 logical consistency, it's an emotional attack. It's designed to push away the focus from an
00:31:02 uncomfortable reality to an arena that people like Kendi are more than capable of operating in,
00:31:08 which is basically being a huckster, right? Using someone's good nature, someone's natural aversion
00:31:15 to vigilante killings, horrific photos of people who've been killed, and using that to, ironically
00:31:22 enough, whitewash what would be a very clear case of, well, fraud, of lying. And again,
00:31:32 in a just society, this guy would be exactly that, a confidence man, a huckster, right?
00:31:39 You can imagine him selling fake deeds 200 years ago or whatever. But the fact that he has not only
00:31:46 been pushed to such a high level, but is being defended again by the same class of people,
00:31:52 Elites like Kendi, who have access to institutions, who have access to honors that you or I don't, and let's be honest, probably couldn't, even if we were saying the exact same things that he were, for fairly obvious reasons. 0.85
00:32:06 And so look, you and I are examining this statement, not simply to point out that it's not well thought out, that it's stupid, that it doesn't make sense, but to expose a tactic.
00:32:16 This one is particularly easy to identify because it's such a ridiculous situation, but this exact same tactic of deliberately using hyper emotive language, of deliberately using something that causes most people to recoil, to associate with very bad things, to cover up something that's, well, much less clear cut. 0.86
00:32:39 that isn't what you've seen in hollywood it's actually just a guy being embarrassed for
00:32:45 something that he did wrong very publicly wrong you know the amazing thing is that at some point 0.86
00:32:54 he probably could have just landed on his feet you know claudine gay is not you know eating tuna
00:32:59 fish sandwiches uh you know home alone i believe she's still employed in academia today uh so
00:33:05 really the fact that he went to this radical step uh is kind of its own uh story maybe he knew that
00:33:13 things were worse for him maybe he knew his lies went deeper or maybe the shame was just too much
00:33:18 but remember that even if he had actually paid a a professional and social price for this it
00:33:26 probably would not have been permanent it probably wouldn't even been that prominent and he probably
00:33:29 would have landed back on his feet working in academia somewhere else just a year or two later
00:33:34 uh so that that is an indictment of the system itself and i don't want to beat this to death
00:33:40 because i think we've pretty much covered this as thoroughly as possible there's only you know
00:33:44 you can't do a whole hour of what a hypocrite these people are but ultimately uh well i guess 0.71
00:33:49 you can there are plenty of i was about to say aaron you can make yourself very rich doing 0.73
00:33:54 exactly that very true uh but but i guess i'll just tie this up in a bow saying that ultimately
00:34:00 uh the reason that uh kindy is freaking out the reason that academia is scrambling the reason the
00:34:06 media is trying to cover this is it true there this truly is an indictment of the entire institution
00:34:10 to the core there is no world in which uh jason uh um i've got his last name our day our day thank
00:34:20 you i was trying to say aldi and that's not right that's a grocery store uh but uh there's no way
00:34:25 that he is some singular figure okay there's it's not like oh well you randomly search and find uh
00:34:32 you know plagiarism and then you search our day and you find plagiarism there's you could probably
00:34:37 unravel the entire academic establishment and certainly probably most of the diversity hires
00:34:42 with this tool and they are desperately trying to cover and and trying to shame anyone who might
00:34:49 try to look into any of this because if it continues this really could like completely
00:34:54 unspool the idea of academia it strikes at the very core of their beliefs the core structure
00:35:00 again of their twisted version of our political formula and if they don't scare everyone away
00:35:05 from asking more questions about what's going on here well there's no way they can actually defend
00:35:10 the structure of what they have uh that said uh the other thing i wanted to discuss today
00:35:15 was jeremy boring uh jeremy boring has been on a tear of the last few weeks apparently uh you
00:35:23 he started his own podcast and at first you know whatever but it seems like the podcast has
00:35:28 basically just become a platform for bringing every kind of classical lib uh lol cow that he
00:35:35 can onto the platform to tell us all about the dangers of the woke right and the evils of power
00:35:40 and how young people are all nazis and you know we we've gone through all this stuff a million
00:35:45 times you guys are very familiar with this line of reasoning from james lindsey or joel barry or 0.74
00:35:50 all of these clowns that just really want to make sure that the right loses forever and that you know
00:35:56 that is your goal your noble goal as a conservative is to hand your country over to third world 0.99
00:36:01 barbarians and like you know twisted demented leftists like that that's the only honorable 0.88
00:36:07 thing that you can do we've all heard this rhetoric before now i also don't want to belabor this too 0.89
00:36:12 long because i didn't do a full episode i could you could have done a full episode on this but
00:36:16 the funny thing is i already did uh so um jeremy boring talked about uh carl schmidt because of
00:36:24 course carl schmidt while really being one of many many figures that we have talked about
00:36:29 intellectually when it comes to the new right uh he has the advantage of being a nazi at some point
00:36:35 in his life and so therefore uh there is a a feeling that you can use carl schmidt as if he
00:36:42 is the foundation of everything the new right
00:36:44 has ever talked about which he obviously is
00:36:46 not in any way shape or form but because
00:36:48 he has been referenced by people like
00:36:50 myself in my book ultimately you
00:36:52 can use his association with
00:36:54 the third right to smear and destroy
00:36:56 any effort to like I don't know
00:36:58 have an actual political movement
00:37:00 have a real American identity
00:37:01 secure power and win things and make life
00:37:04 better for Americans Carl Schmidt is
00:37:06 the key to stopping this and so
00:37:08 Jeremy Boring
00:37:08 talked about the friend enemy distinction
00:37:11 now as i said i have already uh i've already done a full episode i've done multiple episodes on the
00:37:18 friend enemy distinction specifically but i did a full episode with um a philosopher with michael
00:37:25 millerman discussing specifically how people misunderstand the friend enemy distinction
00:37:30 so if we do here is too short for you there is an entire hour-long podcast explaining in detail
00:37:37 why jeremy boring is wrong but i want to take just this two minute clip that he had that he put out
00:37:43 himself this is you'll see it's his edited reel he thought this was a clever thing to say out loud
00:37:47 uh and it would prove that all these people are evil and they shouldn't be able to speak in public 0.53
00:37:52 because uh you know mid-century germans were bad bring this up real quick 0.65
00:37:59 there's mr boring let's hear him out there's a political thinker who's become fashionable in
00:38:07 certain corners in recent years his name is carl schmidt a german jurist whose 1932 book
00:38:12 the concept of the political has become the basis for a new pattern of post-liberal right-wing
00:38:17 thought so first and foremost uh his book has become central it's the it's the inspiration for
00:38:25 a pattern of thought um first no like again carl schmidt is one guy uh who i who to be fair had a
00:38:35 lot of brilliant observations his work matters that's why it's been by the way taught uh by
00:38:40 progressives in you know uh legal theory for for decades and decades and decades uh this guy is not
00:38:47 just some obscure academic uh you know who was in the third reich that uh that the new right picked
00:38:53 up and dusted off this is a respected scholar uh you know yes like he had bad associations so did
00:39:00 heidegger but guess what there's still entire philosophy courses dedicated to him so did plato
00:39:04 tyrant of syracuse over there by the way we still teach plato uh aristotle you know tutored alexander
00:39:10 the great who killed millions of people still still considered a very important you know
00:39:16 philosopher so it turns out we are actually allowed to study people who may have not always
00:39:21 had the best friends while they were alive that said uh the uh idea that carl schmidt is like the
00:39:27 foundation of a post-liberal order uh is just absolutely ludicrous again he is one of many
00:39:34 many thinkers who have been referenced he's not even referenced that often uh but he is the most
00:39:39 dangerous one he's the one that could be most easily uh used in propaganda against the new
00:39:45 right and so that's why jeremy picks him out here even though he has no idea what carl schmidt has
00:39:50 really ever said well and i mean to that point while we're even just constraining ourselves to
00:39:56 the idea of legal theory. The idea that you and I are personally responsible for the political
00:40:03 associations of Machiavelli or Demestra, that we should be forced to denounce the Gelfs because
00:40:10 Machiavelli is from Florentine, which was on one side of that issue from hundreds of years ago.
00:40:17 It's absurd. Again, much like Kendi, this is masquerading as an argument, but functionally,
00:40:24 it's an underhanded rhetorical tactic, which is you are in some way associated with this thing
00:40:30 that I don't like, so you are exactly the same. And this is a common strategy among these,
00:40:37 what would you even call them? Liberal conservatives, IDW types, whatever. You know,
00:40:43 the sort of people kind of congregating around figures like, well, Barry, Lindsay, Boring,
00:40:48 etc. That circle, whatever you want to call them, is that they assume or at least they act as if a
00:40:55 bibliography and a genealogy are the same thing. That if you read or reference someone, you are
00:41:01 ultimately descended or derived from them in the same way that you are from your family.
00:41:06 There's a continuity there. I, for example, will reference Foucault all the time on issues of legal
00:41:13 theory. Now, Aron, I am not a French pedophile. I don't really have a lot in common with people
00:41:20 who like Foucault, but well, if you are interested in this subject, you have to be familiar with
00:41:28 what other people have said. You have to be a part of the conversation. This is actually a
00:41:34 very fundamental part of capital L liberal thought. If you've ever seen the famous painting
00:41:41 in the Vatican, the school of Athens with all of the different philosophers, what are they doing?
00:41:46 They're talking. It is a great conversation. Ideas are bouncing off each other. And you cannot
00:41:52 simply put blinders on and say, well, I don't want to talk about that. So I just will pretend
00:41:59 like it doesn't exist. And if you have touched it, even if you reject it, or even if you take
00:42:05 some things and leave others, I don't know the sort of things adults do when they encounter ideas,
00:42:10 you are tainted. You have become irrevocably ruined by your association with a guy who lived
00:42:17 in Germany in the 1930s. And this is particularly absurd when you look at figures like, I don't know,
00:42:23 Ernst Younger, a man who is incredibly popular in philosophy departments, who is sort of a
00:42:29 sensation of the 1960s for a number of different reasons, a very diverse thinker. But guess what
00:42:36 army he served in. The same one, because he was German. Again, the idea that simply by being
00:42:45 vaguely associated with a guy who had certain political affiliations, you are responsible or
00:42:51 you are the same thing is absurd. This is not an argument. This is not what anyone actually thinks.
00:42:57 It is simply a way to, much like Kendi, distract from a very real issue. In this case, it is not
00:43:05 the same issue as Jason Arday. But the issue is that the political formula is broken. It's not
00:43:13 working. And so when people are looking for other political formulas, when they're looking for other
00:43:19 things that explain the situation that we're in, people look to Schmidt and they say, oh,
00:43:24 that theory of power makes more sense than the ones we're taught in public school.
00:43:30 I wonder if that could be scaled. I wonder if we can use that idea.
00:43:33 And the conservative comes in to say, no, no, no. If you do that, you're literally Hitler.
00:43:39 It's not helpful. It's not really an argument. Well, and I'm almost exhausted making this point,
00:43:47 but nevertheless, I will persist. These people, of course, call guys like you and I the woke right.
00:43:55 This idea that we're the mirror image of the woke left. They are literally playing guilt
00:44:01 by association games in
00:44:03 academic circles
00:44:04 to smear and cancel people
00:44:07 like that's the goal
00:44:08 is to say well there is a guy
00:44:11 here who has said this thing
00:44:13 and because he was at one point
00:44:15 a part of this organization and you referenced
00:44:17 his academic work at one point
00:44:18 therefore by the transit of property
00:44:21 you believe everything that
00:44:23 a Austrian painter
00:44:24 put into practice in
00:44:27 mid-century Germany like that's
00:44:29 very obviously what's going on here
00:44:31 It is the most woke tactic you can imagine.
00:44:34 And the fact that this has been pointed out to them a trillion times and they're still doing it means they know what they're doing.
00:44:41 They know they're deploying woke tactics.
00:44:43 They know they're using exactly the left's cancellation strategy and guilt by association.
00:44:48 Jeremy Boring is perfectly, perfectly aware of what he is doing.
00:44:52 He knows that he is using leftist tactics to slander people and get them canceled, but he does not care.
00:44:58 Because for Jeremy, the specific political distinction that determines all actions
00:45:05 is that of friend and enemy.
00:45:09 Schmidt argued for what he called the autonomy of the political.
00:45:14 Politics is severed from the moral order and put in its own category,
00:45:17 answerable to nothing above it.
00:45:20 And inside that category sits what Schmidt called the friend-enemy distinction.
00:45:24 All of politics reduced to rewarding friends and punishing enemies.
00:45:28 okay so again entire video on why this is wrong exists we're not going to be able to do the
00:45:36 the full hour here but the nuggets here for for people to make nuggets of this discussion uh first
00:45:44 uh the friend enemy distinction does not say you can just do whatever you want to your enemy
00:45:50 and give everything you want to your friends in fact these are entirely separate statements
00:45:56 I have talked about how politics is about rewarding your friends and punishing your enemies.
00:46:02 That part is true.
00:46:04 That said, this is not what the friend-enemy distinction says.
00:46:08 This is not Carl Schmitt's implication.
00:46:10 He did not say that there is no morality in politics or that all morality is completely subservient to politics.
00:46:19 That is not what Carl Schmitt said.
00:46:21 uh also uh what jeremy boring is doing is taking a set of memes that he has seen online and mixing
00:46:30 them together and vomiting them out as some kind of criticism of carl schmidt now to be fair i have
00:46:38 made some of those memes uh but as with all memes the memes are half a joke because that's what
00:46:45 memes are they're not meant to convey highly sophisticated ideas right they are a quick
00:46:52 reaction on twitter in fact i stopped using those memes specifically because i was so tired of
00:46:58 people you know misconstruing or mixing this up that i just don't use anymore because i don't
00:47:03 think it's helpful even though i think they were good memes and they were funny like ultimately
00:47:06 people took these memes i guess very very seriously and tried to pretend like they were
00:47:11 conveying the entirety of a complex academic idea. And Jeremy is not responding to the things
00:47:17 Carl Schmitt wrote. He does not know what Carl Schmitt said. He has not spent time studying or
00:47:22 understanding or analyzing the text. Jeremy Boring is just vomiting back the things that he saw on
00:47:28 the internet that he thinks will look like an actual refutation of what's going on.
00:47:34 Oh, a hundred percent. And the very frustrating thing about this is that, look, memes are useful,
00:47:43 right? It's helpful to convey an idea quickly in a snappy way, but we understand this with
00:47:49 any form of philosophy, right? I'm sure in a previous era you saw, you know, libertarian
00:47:55 memes and yeah, sure. We can make fun of libertarians for all the appropriate reasons,
00:48:00 But there is a big gap between some deep fried image of a snake with glowing laser eyes and actually reading Hoppe. There's a distinction there. And oftentimes in defending this posture, people like Boring and others will say, oh, you're just like the communist who said, oh, have you read Marx? That's the line of attack.
00:48:23 Like, oh, are you saying I need to spend hours and years studying this in order to have an opinion?
00:48:30 No, but if you are making a specific claim, Schmitt says this, Marx says this, that is not based in fact, asking, are you even sure what you're talking about is reasonable.
00:48:44 Like, you can disagree with Schmitt in a way that indicates you have read Schmitt.
00:48:50 That's entirely possible.
00:48:51 There are areas in which I disagree with Schmidt. You have to at least wrestle with his ideas,
00:48:57 but there's nothing that says you must follow him like scripture. But at a certain level,
00:49:01 if you're making factually incorrect statements, if you were just mischaracterizing the man on such
00:49:09 an egregious level that it seems as if you have really no familiarity with his work, asking,
00:49:14 have you read Schmidt, is entirely reasonable. It seems like what almost anyone would say.
00:49:20 yeah that's exactly right i don't expect podcast hosts to read all the philosophy okay i get it
00:49:27 like that that's kind of what i try to do uh but you know that's why you know i'm doing something
00:49:33 slightly different i do not expect your average comedian or podcast host to have gone through and
00:49:39 done the academic research that's not the question here if jeremy boring just said i don't think
00:49:44 carl schmidt's right about this and moved on that would be fine just like if he said i think carl
00:49:48 marx is wrong about economics that's okay you don't have to read das kapital man i'll give you
00:49:52 that one i think the evidence is kind of in on on that being something where you don't have to read
00:49:57 that seriously however if you said that the labor theory of value is the theory that if you you know
00:50:05 throw cats at a wall at some point eventually you will produce a chevy corvette okay well now
00:50:16 you've made a very specific claim about the theory in question and whether or not it works
00:50:22 and it probably doesn't but if you're going to make a specific claim on the labor theory value
00:50:27 you need to know what it is and so jeremy boring here is not just saying you know what i don't
00:50:32 think i like the style of politics that you know uh that that is promoted by carl schmidt and even
00:50:39 though i don't know his work that well i think i can surmise that this is like not the best thing
00:50:43 that that would be one assertion that would be reasonable instead he is specifically referencing
00:50:49 a theory he does not know has not read does not understand and saying that this theory is the
00:50:56 basis for everything i don't like about people i want to cancel which means he is using that theory
00:51:02 as a reason to remove people from the conservative movement even though he doesn't know the basic
00:51:09 words in the actual theory. That's the problem. You don't have to read every guy. You don't have
00:51:14 to read the theory. It's okay. But if you're going to specifically state your claim on the idea that
00:51:21 the theory here is the reason people should be canceled, you have to at least know what the
00:51:25 theory is. That's just a prerequisite. Now, just as it's not wrong to have family loyalties and
00:51:31 natural affections for your own people, it's not wrong to recognize friends and enemies in politics.
00:51:36 I certainly have enemies, and I spend a considerable amount of time fighting them.
00:51:40 That isn't what Schmidt is selling.
00:51:42 Schmidt takes the one true thing and makes it the only thing.
00:51:45 Rewarding friends and punishing enemies stops being a piece of politics
00:51:48 and becomes the entire point of politics, the highest good,
00:51:52 the thing every other consideration bows to, which is exactly what it is.
00:51:56 So again, this is not the friend-enemy distinction.
00:51:59 Like, this is not even close to the friend-enemy distinction.
00:52:02 Again, whole video on this, hour long.
00:52:05 But to break this down as quickly as possible, Carl Schmitt is not giving you a prescriptive idea here.
00:52:13 He's giving you a descriptive idea.
00:52:15 He is noticing the way that politics and political coalitions form, not telling you, here's how you should then behave.
00:52:23 However, even in that, his point is that the friend and enemy coalition is existential.
00:52:29 that politics is about working ultimately to protect a central identity of a group and the
00:52:37 people who get to determine what that identity is are sovereign they are the people who are
00:52:43 actually defining the group as such the political realm as such it is not the idea that nothing else
00:52:49 matters that there is no morality that there's nothing above this but it is explaining that
00:52:54 this is the ultimate delineation in politics and until you recognize this right and this is and to
00:53:01 be clear this is just the hobbesian line okay carl schmidt is just in a lot of ways taking things
00:53:06 from thomas hobbes you can disagree with thomas hobbes but if you reference thomas hobbes no one's
00:53:11 going to lose their mind carl schmidt is not saying anything like radically different from
00:53:16 hobbes or demastra here he is simply bringing it into a modern context which is why by the way i
00:53:22 I use more Demeister than I've ever used Schmidt.
00:53:24 But again, Demeister was not a national socialist.
00:53:27 So Jeremy Boring can't use Demeister to attack me or you or Matt Walsh, who for some reason has suddenly been brought into this.
00:53:37 And so ultimately, that is the whole motivation.
00:53:41 Not that there's anything insightful about what he just kind of blurted out in reference to the friend-enemy distinction.
00:53:47 well and the deep irony is that that basic formulation uh is not from schmidt
00:53:55 you can find it going back to the socratic dialogues or the it's a pretty old idea in
00:54:03 plato yeah yeah like again you can like or dislike schmidt but saying that one he is the unique
00:54:11 originator of this formulation and then therefore can be used as a stick to beat everyone who
00:54:16 you know mentions it it's clearly not honest this is also setting aside and i realize aaron you and
00:54:23 i have an immense capacity to nerd out about political theory and i'm going to consciously
00:54:27 resist that they're playing really fast and loose here with what politics is and if we're talking
00:54:33 about daily politics the kind of tax rate stuff versus existential politics right the politics
00:54:40 that says it's a zero-sum game.
00:54:43 If I win, you don't get to live how you want to live.
00:54:46 It is a risk to you and your way of life.
00:54:49 That is obviously not a distinction
00:54:52 that Mr. Boring seems to be getting into
00:54:54 in this two-minute clip,
00:54:55 but that is important
00:54:56 because he is deliberately producing
00:55:00 a line of reasoning intended
00:55:05 for existential politics
00:55:07 and applying it to the least consequential things
00:55:10 possible like oh isn't this ridiculous if you you know treated your you know local pta a lot or
00:55:16 local pta meetings like you know a battle or meeting with genghis khan like yes of course
00:55:22 these are different orders of like this is radically different completely different scale
00:55:27 again to make it look ridiculous does the person want next to me want a three percent increase in
00:55:35 property taxes is a very different question than does the person next to me want to steal my child 0.96
00:55:40 mutilate their genitals and ultimately make sure I never see them again if I disagree with that
00:55:45 action right like those are fundamentally different questions and calling them all politics is 0.99
00:55:52 basically what Jeremy Boring is doing here and pretending that all of them should be treated
00:55:55 exactly the same is the sleight of hand as you point out that he is utilizing how it works in
00:56:00 an honor culture where loyalty to the tribe outranks truth outranks justice outranks everything
00:56:05 Schmidt didn't invent anything of course all he did was take the oldest and most basic arrangement
00:56:10 on earth, laundered it through a German law faculty, and then sold it back to the West as
00:56:14 some sort of sophisticated political theory. The friend-enemy distinction is just a permission
00:56:19 structure. It's the logic that tells a nation that its enemies are owed nothing. And once a
00:56:23 people believes that, well then there's no atrocity that can't be justified. Schmidt himself, it should
00:56:28 be noted, was a card-carrying Nazi. And that's the grim world that Candace and Tucker and Hassan 0.72
00:56:33 Piker and all the rest of them are driving us toward. They get there by different means, but
00:56:37 they all get to the same place see you either believe in objective truth you believe in an
00:56:42 impartial system you believe in the primacy of justice over tribe and over wealth and over might
00:56:46 or you so uh candace owens notable political philosophy enjoyer uh we can confirm that
00:56:55 obviously jeremy boring uh implying that she is only doing what she's doing because
00:57:00 she has discovered carl schmidt okay um couple problems here uh so the idea that uh you can just
00:57:11 do any that this is permission structure uh funny enough one of the most famous carl schmidt quotes
00:57:17 is literally about how saying that he who uses the word humanity cheats because that person is
00:57:24 looking for a permission structure to do whatever they want to the people they don't like by
00:57:30 declaring someone inhuman or maybe even a nazi you have permission to treat someone however the
00:57:38 way because they are a enemy of humanity meaning they are no longer human that was carl schmidt's
00:57:43 point who literally made the opposite argument that you need to be very careful about how you
00:57:50 utilize language because it could in fact allow you to treat anyone any way you want with no
00:57:57 concern for morality or truth, that's actually insane. You're literally saying the exact opposite
00:58:04 of what Carl Schmitt said. You are lying. Jeremy Boring is a liar, though I doubt Jeremy Boring
00:58:09 knows he's lying because I doubt he has read that passage. I doubt he has read Carl Schmitt.
00:58:14 I doubt he has any informed opinion about what Carl Schmitt actually said in his work. That said,
00:58:21 also this is just clearly clearly nothing but an attempt to tie everybody into the same
00:58:29 gaggle of people he hates everybody who is associated with this i mean jeremy boring
00:58:35 doesn't believe candace owens has read carl schmidt he doesn't believe hasan piker or tucker
00:58:39 carlson are driven by carl schmidt so why is he tying them in here well you see jeremy boring
00:58:45 is creating a friend and enemy distinction he is trying to put everybody who he disagrees with
00:58:52 in the untouchable out group and they are nazis and we know what we can do with a nazi you can 0.98
00:58:58 punch a nazi charlotte crook was assassinated because he was a nazi so i want to be really 0.91
00:59:03 clear here jeremy boring is creating a permission structure where violence can be done to people who 0.84
00:59:09 disagree with him politically jeremy boring is doing what he thinks carl schmidt was doing
00:59:14 with a friend-enemy distinction. Can we also acknowledge, and I'm not trying to
00:59:21 derail this stream, but given the comments, Auron, you and I heard from Jeremy Boring about
00:59:30 certain other nations, the irony of saying, can you believe in a tribal system that holds that
00:59:39 there's nothing wrong you can possibly do to your enemies and you have no responsibility to your
00:59:44 political enemies. Oh, also, we need to support this war halfway across the earth. You're like,
00:59:50 all right, dude, come on, man. Like, come on. I understand there are certain people who object to
00:59:57 the moral framing of Schmitt. But when these critics themselves embody their own stereotypes
01:00:05 of Schmittian politics, it becomes impossible to point out. It's not like you and I are cutting
01:00:12 this guy into a million different pieces, you know, stitching together different quotes to
01:00:16 make him look bad. Just watch it. It is clear, not only does he have no idea what he's talking about,
01:00:23 but he has no real principles. The principles that he himself is lauding as better than Schmitt,
01:00:31 that he is lauding as the ultimate kind of pinnacle of objective morality, he makes no
01:00:38 attempt to stick to. He has his own, ironically enough, Schmidian exception, something for which
01:00:45 his stated principles will bend. And so, again, you can look at Schmitt and say there are things
01:00:51 I dislike or I like about him. But when you are criticizing him, inaccurately, I might add,
01:00:58 while embodying his exact political framing, I'm sorry if I don't take you seriously. 0.94
01:01:03 It's ridiculous. It's genuinely a ridiculous situation. 0.94
01:01:06 well and at the end here he basically is appealing to liberalism right he says look you need to not
01:01:12 care about tribe you need to not care about identity what you need to care about is objective
01:01:16 standards objective values objective morals institutions that's what matters that's what
01:01:23 makes you american or whatever is that you ultimately embrace this stuff that's what we
01:01:27 believe unless you're a country in the middle east in which case you don't get validated by
01:01:35 your institutions you aren't actually upholding to this objective way you should treat people
01:01:40 you are allowed to define yourself as an ethno state and you are allowed to prefer your tribe
01:01:46 against others as you point out jeremy boring has a literal state of exception to these principles
01:01:53 those principles of jeremy apply to you as an american conservative they do not apply to
01:02:00 nations in the middle east that he has decided have this special exception it is the literal
01:02:06 schmidtian political miracle that intercedes on the behalf of those who you have deemed above
01:02:14 these principles so it's incredible that he appeals to exactly this idea of liberalism but
01:02:21 as you point out 10 seconds later he would have to turn around and say actually there's a particular
01:02:26 exception because for some reason Israel is just different than everyone else well and it's this
01:02:31 very tactical framing because figures like boring and others have criticized the woke left they have
01:02:38 to when addressing us adopt this framing that all of our institutions are perfectly liberal that
01:02:45 they're working exactly as designed but look at our first story look at you know Jason or day
01:02:51 however we say his name I'm sorry I don't know how to pronounce really anyone's name
01:02:55 But you look at that and you're like, oh, well, I thought that we didn't advance people on the basis of their tribe. I thought that we didn't make decisions based off of, one might say, some sort of line in the stand distinction.
01:03:11 And well, if we already are, functionally, like look at our institutions, well, what
01:03:20 leg are we standing on here?
01:03:21 It would be better if we weren't.
01:03:23 I mean, sure, in an abstract sense, maybe if that's even possible.
01:03:28 But functionally, our enemies to the left are Schmittian.
01:03:33 They understand that is how power works. 0.98
01:03:36 They are operating on those terms.
01:03:39 It's sort of like, you know, a sport or whatever.
01:03:42 You know, once we figured out the way to do a long jump is that weird back arch thing.
01:03:46 Well, if you want to do it the old way, just kind of running and hopping, there's no way
01:03:51 you're going to the Olympics.
01:03:52 You were using the wrong technology.
01:03:55 You're using the wrong method.
01:03:56 And so at a certain point, if you want to win, if you want to protect your way of life,
01:04:03 you have to adopt to the war that you're fighting, not the war you wish you were fighting.
01:04:08 And many people make fun of generals in the First World War, sending cavalry charges at machine gun nests, and then adopt that exact same mechanism when we're talking about politics.
01:04:21 And again, Aron, you and I are not the ideologues here.
01:04:25 You and I are not the lunatics possessed by theory, desperate to make reality conform to our high-minded series of ideals.
01:04:33 We're interested in results.
01:04:35 we're interested in saving this country and saving a culture. And if you're committed to that goal,
01:04:41 well, you're going to look for every available tool. And if one presents itself, well, that's
01:04:46 how we do this. I think it's very important to recognize that these conservatives are the
01:04:51 ideologues. They are the ones trying to contort reality to meet their professed principles,
01:04:57 not us. And they love to revert to classic conservative critiques of left-wing radicals.
01:05:04 They say, oh, you're utopian. Oh, you're an ideologue. Oh, you have all this theory,
01:05:09 but it doesn't turn out in real life. And they're trying to use that exact same tactic on people
01:05:14 who it clearly does not apply to. Yeah, obviously this is a losing strategy.
01:05:21 I think everybody sees this. I mean, at this point, honestly, I think that
01:05:26 the Jeremy Boring show is becoming a public service because it's just a parade of people
01:05:33 that are going to lay out why the previous tactics have failed entirely and destroy the
01:05:39 reputations of people who ultimately embrace this again when you we've roped you know guys
01:05:44 like matt walsh and john doyle into this at this point i mean you're you're just basically building
01:05:49 a coalition against you you know it's a do you want to be losers forever because that's what
01:05:54 jeremy boring is selling you he's selling you that we it's your duty to lose that you are as 0.95
01:05:59 a conservative or a beautiful loser and that just doesn't it doesn't work anymore so i think at this
01:06:04 point uh it's just very helpful because he's just gonna have a bunch of people on to all tell you
01:06:09 why you should lose forever and why your homeland should be sold out and why you should never have
01:06:14 a family or a home and it's all your fault and uh what you want to eat burritos like that that's 0.51
01:06:18 going to be the tone going forward uh and there's you know just the fact that all of this is
01:06:24 overlapped with a bunch of people who are basically never trump uh you know uh one desperately needed
01:06:29 a war in the Middle East. I mean, there are too many points of obvious overlap to think that any
01:06:34 one of these is an isolated incident. They all move together in the same direction for the same
01:06:39 reason. That said, we have a pile of super chats that we need to get to. So Mr. Burden, before we
01:06:44 get to the voice of the people, where can everyone find your work? Yeah. So you can find me on the
01:06:51 Jay Burden show, anywhere you listen to podcasts, but on an episode every single day. And I will say
01:06:57 I'm actually quite grateful to Mr. Boring because his shows are effectively a subsidy for me.
01:07:04 These are, it's low hanging fruit and I am not too proud to, to take it. I've done, I think,
01:07:11 two episodes on Jeremy Boring and I'll be honest, I might be doing a third. So point is Jay Burden
01:07:18 show anywhere you listen to podcasts. And again, Aaron, thank you so much for having me.
01:07:21 yeah if you if you want to get a steady stream of uh you know replying to jeremy boring then
01:07:28 jay burton has you covered he is he is your source he's he is dealing it out all right uh
01:07:34 let's see here cherry coke says uh cherry coke nixon says how many our days have been scammed
01:07:39 into elite institutions how many are involved in stem and put lives at risk at the altar of
01:07:44 wokeness well the good news is probably not so many of the latter uh most of those guys don't
01:07:48 actually make it into stem fields that said i'm sure there are some that are and it's incredibly
01:07:53 dangerous and you're right like this is just uh this is the competency crisis right like we all
01:07:58 know that the elites who have been manufactured are faulty and they will uh ultimately not be
01:08:04 able to do the job hold the system together uh you know forge a civilization that we need
01:08:08 uh and so this is an incredibly dangerous situation um that's why it has to be fixed
01:08:13 we can't just turn a blind eye to this we can't just say oh well ultimately it's not a big deal
01:08:17 it's just some sociologist no like this is where we actually manufacture credentials we decide that
01:08:23 people have the right to rule uh this is where we decide who should be in charge of the our
01:08:27 civilization and if we don't fix this it's going to have a catastrophic effect it already is starting
01:08:32 he also says gigantic public vigil for our day today in england over 150k raised for his funeral
01:08:40 just uh just so far uh gold you know floyd like golden casket in the works no more likely probably
01:08:47 the buying of a home and a car. But yeah, the fact that I think I saw last I saw it was almost
01:08:52 $200,000 for a guy killing himself. By the way, he left the wife and kids behind. So this is not
01:08:58 a victimless crime. Yeah. So, I mean, this is in no way a victimless crime. Hopefully that's where
01:09:05 the money goes to. I mean, it's not their fault that, you know, this guy did what he did. Hopefully
01:09:11 it's not going to some grifting to, you know, some other family members or some people who
01:09:15 want to get rich off of it but the fact that it's raised that much is insane
01:09:18 uh ian briggs says yarvin spoke about the genetic heresy and how it rec how its recognition
01:09:27 requires regime collapse kofnis is trying to prove him wrong do you think researchers like
01:09:32 him can succeed um so the problem with this is we already have the evidence the bell curve was
01:09:42 written a long time ago kids uh this was kind of the the mistake the alt-right made when they showed
01:09:47 up on the scene they had a bunch of data and they had been told that winning arguments is how you
01:09:52 win the marketplace of ideas so if you've got the data and you've got the arguments well then how
01:09:58 are people going to ultimately argue with the fact that there are differences in populations
01:10:02 genetically and that produces different results in fields like academia and the answer that everyone 0.99
01:10:08 brought to that argument was you're a racist and we should kill you and turns out that's actually 0.96
01:10:14 a really good argument uh and so even though uh there's not a lot of i mean i really don't ever 0.98
01:10:22 see anyone bring any scientific data to refute charles murray's thesis or anything else in you
01:10:28 know this uh the iq debate or the genetic debate um i think yarvin's right that if you undermine
01:10:35 that belief structure ultimately that would collapse the entire system but that's why they
01:10:39 don't care like they don't care what the research says they don't care what the science says they
01:10:44 don't care what the studies say and i think this is the problem that kaufnes as a self has run into 0.56
01:10:48 he's just an incredibly disagreeable human and has made an enemy out of everyone who should be
01:10:53 on his side because like the fact that he's pursued this doggedly is mainly racked up to
01:11:00 the fact that he just is impossible incapable of reading social views uh and so you end up in the
01:11:06 scenario where you could be right about something and still lose uh which you know is something i
01:11:10 try to teach libertarians all the time you don't you you you being right is not sufficient and you
01:11:15 need to have that drilled in your head uh sean wyland says the emperor wears no clothes exactly
01:11:23 exactly uh uh marcos it says dei complex delinda est yes let's hope so uh mark uh marcos says also
01:11:37 quick we must voluntarily repudiate and condemn the entirety of the roman republic lest we be 0.70
01:11:42 branded uh branded uh clodians or are associated with catiline yes uh the cancel culture all the 0.78
01:11:49 way back to rome uh weirdy curb says it amazes me they think that the one ring meme lands uh yeah
01:11:58 i just did a little screed about this on uh twitter but uh guys like james inzi were running
01:12:03 around doing the you know it's the one ring and it's power and you're the woke right if you want
01:12:07 to grab the ring uh and uh you know just briefly um guys the lord of the rings is a story about a
01:12:14 man who destroys the world uh or or you know makes the world worse because he refuses to take
01:12:19 state power and only when he finally learns to take his rightful place as the literal king
01:12:25 in the book return of the king is the is is the land healed uh jr tolkien was a supporter
01:12:32 francisco franco he is in every way shape or form what james lindsey would call the woke right so
01:12:37 james lindsey trying to use a meme from lord of the rings to denounce exactly the kind of thing
01:12:42 that well tolkien was talking about in the lord of the rings let's never say that the left can't
01:12:49 you know stop owning themselves well exactly and one this is from many of the same people who 0.99
01:12:56 rightfully made fun of lefties for calling trump voldemort 10 years ago you're like oh you idiot 0.99
01:13:03 you've taken a minor plot point or a character from a fiction novel and turned it into political 0.99
01:13:08 theory no wait nope here we are again doing exactly the same thing i will not get into a
01:13:14 detailed rant on the politics of lord of the rings but like let us be known that reading is
01:13:21 so impossibly wrong again right like the whole point of it is we need a king
01:13:29 a king selected by right of blood to set everything to right like that is the conclusion
01:13:36 complete with the magical sword to rule and everything like just like we are it's not being
01:13:41 subtle here um but yeah no i actually i did i believe do a whole episode with middle earth
01:13:46 mixer on this topic so once again if you want to see us rant about the politics of middle earth
01:13:50 for an hour uh you can do that as well uh marcos says uh has jeremy ever heard of lucius cornelius
01:13:58 Sulla. No, I imagine he has not.
01:14:00 But we are a fan of making
01:14:02 lists around here. 0.94
01:14:05 Cyberchud
01:14:06 says, I hope you both will do the right
01:14:08 thing and disavow NASA for their association
01:14:10 with Operation Paperclip.
01:14:12 Yeah, that's exactly the same comparison I actually
01:14:14 make in my book when I talk about Schmidt.
01:14:16 Obviously, you know, because 0.97
01:14:18 a bunch of Nazi scientists got us 0.88
01:14:20 to the moon, we don't disavow 0.84
01:14:22 our ability to get to the moon. In fact,
01:14:24 we still think of it as quite a bit of pride.
01:14:26 the fact that they came up with the theories and the science to do that does not actually taint
01:14:30 that um same can be true schmidt you can correctly think his associations were very bad but still
01:14:37 recognize that when he's right about theory he's right about theory and the use of correct theory
01:14:42 is ultimately still the way to go truth is truth even if it's spoken by someone who doesn't have
01:14:47 the best intentions and spartan says uh an unwinnable war for jeremy's friends and twenty
01:14:55 dollar burritos for his enemies yes yes well done all right guys we're gonna go ahead and wrap this
01:15:01 up as always a pleasure speaking with jay bird make sure you're checking out all of his fine
01:15:05 material if it's your first time on this show you need to go ahead and click subscribe bell
01:15:11 notifications leave a comment all that stuff that lets youtube know you want to watch the show
01:15:14 we're also streaming on twitch now so if that's a place you normally enjoy your streams you can
01:15:19 find us there as well as rumble and uh twitter uh live streaming to all those platforms if you
01:15:24 want to get your broadcast as podcasts, you need to subscribe to The Orr McIntyre Show on your
01:15:28 favorite podcast platform. And when you do, leave a rating or review. It really helps with the
01:15:32 algorithm magic. Thank you, everybody, for watching. As always, I will talk to you next time.