The Super Bowl Now Plays Like America’s Divorce Proceedings | 2⧸12⧸26
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
160.6283
Summary
The Super Bowl is a country at war with itself. This year s Super Bowl looks like a country in war with each other. The broadcast opened with two national anthems, the familiar Francis Scott Key standard and the newer Black National Anthem. The halftime show only sharpened that divide.
Transcript
00:00:00.420
Got PC Optimum points? Visit Shopper's Drug Mart for the bonus redemption event and get more for your points.
00:00:06.400
Friday, February 13th to Wednesday, February 18th. Valid in-store and online.
00:00:13.760
The Seattle Seahawks trampled the New England Patriots in Super Bowl 60, but the post-game chatter barely touched football.
00:00:21.400
Fans and pundits argued about anthems, halftime, commercials, and what the whole spectacle said about America.
00:00:27.720
For better or worse, the Super Bowl serves as the premier civic liturgy of the American Empire,
00:00:33.740
a night when strangers share the same screen and offices share the same small talk.
00:00:39.200
When that ritual becomes another front in the culture war, the country loses one more place to breathe.
00:00:45.940
Look, families fight, politics, they intrude, and resentments pile up, but holidays still force a pause.
00:00:53.600
Thanksgiving and Christmas push people back to the same table, reminding them that argument can't become the relationship.
00:01:02.160
When even the ritual itself turns into the argument, when Thanksgiving and Christmas are no longer about gratitude or celebrating the birth of Christ,
00:01:10.380
but rather who can win a political debate, the family slides from conflict towards a rupture.
00:01:18.200
Shared ceremonies don't solve deep disagreements, but they do keep disagreements from becoming total separation.
00:01:26.400
Americans rarely stop living their separate lives to watch the same thing at the same time.
00:01:36.740
Even big films and best-selling books now fall into ideological silos.
00:01:41.860
The Super Bowl remains one of the few national events that still compels common attention.
00:01:47.000
People who even hate sports tune in for the ads so they can follow the conversation at work the next day.
00:01:53.860
A shared celebration, however frivolous, still binds people who otherwise share little else in common.
00:02:00.920
This year's Super Bowl looks like a country at war with itself.
00:02:04.940
The broadcast opened with two national anthems.
00:02:08.000
The familiar Francis Scott Key standard and the newer Black national anthem that appears at more NFL events each season.
00:02:15.140
The league has leaned hard into woke activism, from corporate rituals to social campaigns,
00:02:21.060
and it rarely hides the moral it wants viewers to absorb.
00:02:28.080
Two constituencies begin to behave like two different nations.
00:02:36.240
The NFL chose Bad Bunny, a Puerto Rican artist who performs almost entirely in Spanish,
00:02:43.720
The stage recreated a bodega, complete with an EBT welcome neon sign.
00:02:51.700
The performance leaned into sexual provocation, with dancers simulating sex acts,
00:02:56.200
and two gay guys grinding on each other for shock and applause.
00:03:00.380
The show ended with performers hoisting foreign flags,
00:03:04.100
a tableau that read less like cultural flair and more like a victory lap,
00:03:10.740
A large portion of the audience just wasn't buying what the league was selling.
00:03:15.200
Ratings suggest that many viewers turned off the Super Bowl during the set.
00:03:19.600
Some did so out of prudishness, others did it out of irritation with the message,
00:03:24.640
If you look at the live crowd, they couldn't have seemed more bored about what was going on.
00:03:29.060
Either way, the halftime show didn't function as a shared moment,
00:03:34.520
Turning Point USA offered a competing halftime show featuring country artists singing about America and Jesus Christ.
00:03:40.740
The stream broke records and reportedly became YouTube's largest live stream.
00:03:48.180
but the very need for it should worry anyone who wants a coherent nation.
00:03:53.100
Instead of one shared celebration, Americans built parallel ceremonies,
00:03:57.580
then congratulated themselves for avoiding each other.
00:04:22.320
So whatever you think is going to happen in the future,
00:04:33.020
One spot from a mortgage lender portrayed a family of color moving into a mostly white neighborhood
00:04:38.060
and encountering casual racism until they instruct the residents on diversity and inclusion.
00:04:46.000
Another strange commercial backed by Patriots owner and Jewish billionaire Robert Kraft
00:04:54.620
It showed a Jewish student harassed in a school hallway as classmates, all white of course,
00:05:04.360
The boy reaches his locker where a black student offers solidarity
00:05:08.160
based on their shared experience of being hated by whites.
00:05:11.360
The ad then unveils a blue square social media campaign modeled on the black square campaign
00:05:21.640
NFL owners didn't back away from the woke script.
00:05:26.680
The next day I went to my barber and he described the shift in real time.
00:05:32.760
For most of his life, the Monday after the Super Bowl brought lively chatter about the best
00:05:38.480
This year, customers wanted to talk about politics.
00:05:41.360
They explained about the anthem, the halftime show, the messaging, the moral scolding.
00:05:48.480
Friendly banter about the MVP and next season's prospects gave way to arguments about what kind
00:05:56.040
That entire conversation really captured the larger problem.
00:06:00.280
Conservatives and liberals increasingly inhabit different worlds.
00:06:04.140
They share geography, but they don't share a premise.
00:06:09.180
They don't share the same media diet, the same moral language, or the same sense of what counts
00:06:15.820
When they occupy the same room, they talk past each other.
00:06:22.200
The old civic fracture ran along a map, north and south.
00:06:26.900
The new fracture runs through families, workplaces, churches, and neighborhoods.
00:06:31.540
The country didn't divide into north and south.
00:06:34.880
It divided into competing moral nations layered on top of the same territory.
00:06:39.920
Each tribe builds its own institutions, its own entertainment, and its own narrative, while
00:06:48.440
No stable regime can endure that kind of division indefinitely.
00:06:52.880
One side will eventually impose dominance on the other, with power used to punish dissent and
00:07:01.540
Or, the country will choose some form of national divorce, formal or informal, with communities
00:07:16.000
A shared civic ritual lets people practice unity without requiring uniformity.
00:07:22.720
Americans once used the game as a harmless excuse to share food, laugh at ads, and pretend,
00:07:28.820
at least for a night, that they still belonged to one people.
00:07:33.540
This year, the country used the game more to rehearse separation.
00:07:37.760
A nation that can't share a football game probably can't share much else for very long.
00:07:48.320
If you enjoyed this video, go ahead and click like.
00:07:50.640
And if you haven't clicked subscribe, now is a great time to do so.
00:07:54.420
If you'd like to get these broadcasts as podcasts, you need to subscribe to The Orr McIntyre Show
00:08:06.400
And if you are listening on the podcast, but you haven't subscribed on something like YouTube,
00:08:11.580
guys, I would really appreciate if you'd take the time to do that.
00:08:14.340
The podcast keeps growing, but YouTube is really trying to tank my numbers,
00:08:18.080
and so it would be fantastic if you'd help out by making sure you're subscribed in both places.
00:08:23.280
If you'd like to follow me on Twitter or Gab or Substack or Instagram,
00:08:28.000
if you'd like to get this show on Rumble or Odyssey,
00:08:31.320
the links to do all of that are down below in the description.
00:08:34.900
And of course, you can read all of my columns and watch all of my episodes over at The Blaze.
00:08:40.080
Thanks for watching, and as always, I'll talk to you next time.