Zombie Constitution ｜ 8⧸31⧸23
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
155.00487
Summary
Sovereign Citizens are a loose collection of individuals who believe that they can evade the authority of the police by claiming exemption from the legal code. There s no central text explaining the Sovereign Citizen ideology, but one branch holds that America s first governing document, the Articles of Confederation, was never legally dissolved, meaning that those who claim sovereign citizenship are not subject to the law as currently enforced under the Constitution. Though it s never stopped a single arrest, devotees of this doctrine will confidently state their case as they resist detainment.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
We hope you're enjoying your Air Canada flight.
00:00:10.720
Fast-free Wi-Fi means I can make dinner reservations before we land.
00:00:25.260
Wi-Fi available to Airplane members on Equipped Flight.
00:00:30.620
If you want a good laugh, you can enter the phrase
00:00:32.580
Sovereign Citizen into your favorite video search engine
00:00:35.300
and find endless hours of delusional people being arrested by the police.
00:00:40.000
Sovereign Citizens are a loose collection of individuals
00:00:42.700
who believe that they can evade the authority of the police
00:00:48.680
There's no central text explaining the Sovereign Citizen ideology,
00:00:52.460
but one branch holds that America's first governing document,
00:00:55.560
the Articles of Confederation, was never legally dissolved,
00:00:58.960
meaning that those who claim sovereign citizenship
00:01:01.640
are not subject to the law as currently enforced under the Constitution.
00:01:08.720
devotees of this doctrine will confidently state their case as they resist detainment,
00:01:12.760
treating the legal assertion as a magic spell meant to halt a police officer in his tracks.
00:01:17.080
While delusional people attempting to argue their way out of an arrest can create a hilarious spectacle,
00:01:22.880
the phenomenon can also teach an important lesson about placing one's faith
00:01:27.100
in a document that no longer has the authority to restrict power.
00:01:30.440
A surprising number of people, even those who consider themselves well-informed and patriotic,
00:01:36.320
don't know that the Articles of Confederation served as America's first governing document.
00:01:41.000
The Articles governed the young American nation from 1777 until 1789,
00:01:50.940
This original legal framework created a very weak central government
00:01:54.440
that treated the individual states more like independent nations
00:01:57.780
that happened to work together on certain key issues.
00:02:01.220
The central government found it difficult to raise taxes,
00:02:04.160
settle disputes, negotiate trade, and handle monetary policy under the Articles.
00:02:09.420
After the nation's leaders had trouble putting down a tax rebellion
00:02:15.020
they decided to form a new government that could wield power more effectively.
00:02:19.200
The Articles were designed to be very difficult to change,
00:02:21.820
requiring unanimous consent from all 13 states.
00:02:25.760
The Constitutional Convention began work to replace the Articles in 1787,
00:02:30.480
but no vote to alter or dissolve the original document was taken.
00:02:34.720
Instead, the new Constitution created its own rules for how it would be ratified,
00:02:39.180
requiring only nine of the 13 states to agree to the document.
00:02:43.500
Technically, the sovereign citizens are correct
00:02:46.080
that the Articles were never legally dissolved,
00:02:48.540
but this has never stopped any of them from going to jail.
00:02:52.800
The point is not that the sovereign citizen crowd is right.
00:03:01.640
the Constitutional Convention's replacement of the Articles was illegal,
00:03:07.300
The Constitution is the key governing document throughout American history.
00:03:11.780
It's the foundation on which the majority of law has been placed,
00:03:16.280
and the values enshrined in its words have become the critical, binding narrative of the nation.
00:03:28.560
Debating the legitimacy of its ratification hundreds of years later is irrelevant.
00:03:34.220
The Constitution became the functional law of the land
00:03:37.520
and shaped every aspect of America as we know it today.
00:03:42.000
Trying to argue that fact to get out of an arrest will get you nowhere,
00:03:45.860
and people will simply laugh as you're thrown into the back of a police cruiser.
00:03:50.040
The formal letter of the law is less important than how it's enforced and followed.
00:03:55.520
Making arguments based on the technicalities of a document that fell into irrelevance long ago
00:04:08.600
Christopher Caldwell traces the development of civil rights law in the United States.
00:04:14.020
Caldwell asserts that America has developed a secondary informal Constitution
00:04:18.240
that runs parallel to the document that formally rules the nation.
00:04:22.080
He believes that the civil rights movement began as a well-intentioned effort by most Americans
00:04:27.440
to deliver on the promise of racial equality in law,
00:04:30.920
answering the legitimate grievances of those who had been treated unjustly.
00:04:37.700
and when legislation proved difficult to pass through the normal channels,
00:04:41.780
politicians and activists were willing to use courts,
00:04:44.780
executive orders, and other tools to circumvent the traditional democratic process.
00:04:49.320
A patchwork of legal decisions slowly merged with dictates from the federal bureaucracy
00:04:54.560
and sweeping legislation to create a Byzantine network of rights and regulations
00:04:58.840
generated by new interpretations of previous constitutional amendments.
00:05:03.380
The rapid success of the civil rights movement was unprecedented,
00:05:07.640
and other activist groups sought to use the same strategy to their advantage.
00:05:11.760
The rights of other racial minorities, women, the disabled,
00:05:16.360
and gay and eventually even trans individuals all became civil rights,
00:05:20.620
granting them access to the second constitution.
00:05:23.720
The slow and exhausting work of changing public opinion
00:05:27.120
and passing constitutional amendments could be circumvented
00:05:29.960
by placing the concerns of your group in the fast lane.
00:05:33.120
When does fast grocery delivery through Instacart matter most?
00:05:37.120
When your famous grainy mustard potato salad isn't so famous without the grainy mustard.
00:05:41.960
When the barbecue's lit, but there's nothing to grill.
00:05:44.620
When the in-laws decide that, actually, they will stay for dinner.
00:05:48.340
Instacart has all your groceries covered this summer.
00:05:50.920
So download the app and get delivery in as fast as 60 minutes.
00:05:54.220
Plus, enjoy $0 delivery fees on your first three orders.
00:06:03.920
This development didn't go unnoticed by political parties,
00:06:10.200
The only common factor that seemed to bind its wildly diverse constituents together
00:06:18.100
An emergency program that was initially conceived
00:06:20.880
to right the historical wrongs visited on a small and specific percentage of the population
00:06:29.300
The majority of the population now had access to the second constitution.
00:06:33.120
Creating a new minority of second-class citizens who were relegated to only the rights
00:06:41.480
Even these legacy constitutional rights quickly became subordinate to the new civil rights.
00:06:47.780
Christians have quickly discovered that freedom of religion has proven a very flimsy shield
00:06:52.780
as the FBI targets them for protesting the sexual indoctrination of their children.
00:06:57.220
Every previous norm can and must be discarded in pursuit of the utopia offered by the second constitution.
00:07:05.140
The regime will now enthusiastically arrest Donald Trump, their primary political opponent,
00:07:14.080
Democracy is no longer a process by which leaders are chosen,
00:07:17.800
but a sacred affirmation of the new paradigm assembled under the second constitution.
00:07:22.840
The current American conservative has an uncomfortable amount in common with the sovereign citizen crowd.
00:07:30.400
The conservative remembers and cherishes the freedoms that were enshrined in the original constitution
00:07:35.800
and believes that their presence in that founding text should defend those rights in perpetuity.
00:07:41.840
Unfortunately, those rights were not vigorously defended by previous generations,
00:07:46.080
and the document that was supposed to protect them has been subordinated to a new order with its own priorities.
00:07:53.040
Conservatives will impotently recite sections of the Bill of Rights to government officials
00:07:57.260
who care about nothing but the power to advance their own agenda.
00:08:01.480
For these progressives, the constitution is a dead letter,
00:08:04.560
a forgotten relic with no power to constrain their actions or limit their utopian ambitions.
00:08:10.360
The good news is that while the constitution is regularly abused and ignored,
00:08:15.060
its fate need not be the same as the Articles of Confederation.
00:08:19.760
The constitution has been central to formal law for most of the nation's history,
00:08:24.700
and its values still echo in the hearts of many.
00:08:28.320
Ultimately, it's not the words on a piece of paper that make a nation,
00:08:32.400
but the people who cherish and pass on those traditions.
00:08:36.640
Constitutions are not dusty and dry legal pronouncements,
00:08:40.240
but the formal inculcation of the traditions and folkways that exist
00:08:47.620
If the people stop carrying forward the spirit, tradition, and values of the country,
00:08:56.000
Those that oppose the current progressive tide must step away from a form of zombie constitutionalism
00:09:01.320
that expects the document to shamble forward and protect itself.
00:09:07.160
Freedom is never more than one generation away from extinction,
00:09:11.180
but too many generations have been convinced that those freedoms must become subservient
00:09:18.460
Quoting constitutional amendments to woke revolutionaries
00:09:21.680
will never shame them into honoring values they do not share.
00:09:25.460
If those on the right want to see their freedoms returned,
00:09:34.460
but in every aspect of culture, religion, and education.
00:09:38.700
The Founding Fathers told us that the Constitution is only fit to govern a moral and religious people
00:09:44.640
who are willing to actively protect their way of life.
00:09:50.940
and not the quoting of constitutional protections,
00:09:53.840
that can ultimately rescue the American spirit.
00:10:17.460
If you'd like to follow me on Twitter, or Substack, or Gab,
00:10:22.440
if you'd like to watch these videos on Rumble or Odyssey,
00:10:25.100
the links to do all that are down below in the description.