Another mass shooting rocks Colorado, Joe Biden continues to lock kids in cages while keeping the border open, and Democrats aren t done yet, calling for the end of the filibuster and adding states. This is the Ben Shapiro Show, and it is sponsored by ExpressVPN. If you haven t gotten a VPN yet, you should get one, because you re gonna need one a lot. ExpressVPN is the fastest and most trusted VPN on the market, which is why they are rated the VPN by CNET and Wired, and Wired by the New York Times. That s super simple, you click one button on your phone now, and you re good to go. Go check them out right now! It s super easy, you just have to tap one button, now you are safe to go, and go check out their super simple and trusted VPN. You ll get an extra 3 months free with that one-year package, and get access to all of ExpressVPN s features, including the features mentioned in the show. That s awesome! Want to learn more about ExpressVPN? Check out their awesome features and features? Subscribe to the ExpressVPN app! And don t forget to rate, review and subscribe to the show on Apple Podcasts! and become a supporter of the show, Ben Shapiro's Workplace! Ben Shapiro is on the . and Ben Shapiro s on The Ben Shapiro Podcast on The Show on The FiveThirtyEight Podcasts on PODCAST is on The SixThirtyEight on Social Media! On The Other Side of the FiveThirty One Podcast And Ben Shapiro on The Fifth Third Radio On Social Media is On The Fifth Centurio Also On The Five Fifty Cent Radio On The Other Side Of The Crew On The Third Sheets On The Same Podcast And On The Sixth Third And The Other Third , On This Is That And On This And The Third And So Much And On And On That And So And So On And And So & So And And And The Others Out On That And And And Finally Finally Finally On And Finally On And Finally Finally Finally On ... The Other On This Finally On This And The And This And So Finally And His Story Thank You And The Rest And Finally And That And The And And His And The Final And So
00:00:20.000Visit ExpressVPN.com slash Ben, which is as good a time as any to remind you that you actually should get ExpressVPN because here is the reality.
00:00:28.000Big tech, they are not out to protect your best interests.
00:00:32.000And by the way, to use that data against you, in the case that they don't like what you are doing at some point, turning on incognito or private mode in Chrome or Safari, that's actually not enough.
00:00:41.000It doesn't matter how often you clear that browsing history, your ISP, internet service provider, can see every single website you've ever visited.
00:00:46.000They can sell your data to advertisers, which is why I use ExpressVPN to keep my online data secure and private.
00:00:52.000ExpressVPN makes sure your ISP and third-party trackers can't see your online activity and location.
00:00:56.000It does that by rerouting your connection through a secure encrypted server.
00:01:00.000In fact, ExpressVPN protects all your data, regardless of whether you use incognito mode.
00:01:04.000ExpressVPN has you covered with easy-to-use apps for computers and mobile devices so you can use the internet with confidence.
00:01:09.000All you have to do, tap one button, now you are protected.
00:01:12.000ExpressVPN is also the fastest and most trusted VPN on the market, which is why they are rated the number one VPN by CNET and Wired.
00:01:18.000So, protect your online activity today with the VPN I trust to keep me private.
00:01:22.000Visit expressvpn.com slash ben and get an extra three months free.
00:01:25.000with that one-year package. That's expressvpn.com slash ben to learn more. It's super easy. You click one button on your phone. Now you're good to go. It's super simple. Go check them out right now. Expressvpn.com slash ben to learn more. All righty. So big news of the day is another horrific mass shooting. This time in Colorado where 10 people were killed at a Colorado supermarket. According to the Associated Press, a shooting at a Colorado supermarket killed 10 people on Monday, including a police officer who was the first to respond to the scene, according to authorities.
00:01:53.000They didn't reveal his name or any details about the shooting.
00:01:55.000At an evening news conference where Boulder Police Chief Maris Harreld fought back tears, Investigators had just begun sorting through evidence and witness interviews and didn't have details on a motive for the shooting at the King Soopers store in Boulder, which is about 25 miles northwest of Denver, home to the University of Colorado, according to Boulder County District Attorney Michael Dougherty.
00:02:13.000He said this is a tragedy and a nightmare for Boulder County.
00:02:16.000These were people going about their day doing their shopping.
00:02:18.000I promise the victims and the people of the state of Colorado we will secure justice.
00:02:22.000The attack was, according to the Associated Press, the seventh mass killing this year in the United States, following the March 16th shooting that left eight people dead at three Atlanta-area massage businesses, according to a database compiled by the Associated Press, USA Today, and Northwestern University.
00:02:35.000And of course, it all depends on how you define mass shooting, because some definitions are like three people or more, some definitions are five people or more.
00:02:43.000It follows a lull in mass killings during the pandemic in 2020, which had the smallest number of such attacks in more than a decade.
00:02:48.000Which is mainly because people were locked inside their houses so people couldn't congregate, which meant it was more difficult to pull off a mass shooting.
00:02:54.000This database tracks mass killings and defined as four or more dead, not including the shooter.
00:02:59.000One of the reasons, by the way, that a lot of these statistical databases like to separate off mass shootings with four or more dead is because if they include three or more dead, then the numbers rise dramatically and the racial composition of the shooters goes dramatically differently.
00:03:12.000Because it turns out there are a lot of gangland shootings that involve people who are killing two, three people.
00:03:18.000And so the numbers change pretty radically.
00:03:20.000You'll notice that mass shootings are always the excuse for gun control, but the deadly violence that happens in Chicago every single weekend, that is never the excuse for gun control.
00:03:28.000Because again, this plays into the broader media narrative, which is that the big problem in America is white supremacy and America's systems of violence.
00:03:36.000The slain officer was identified as Eric Talley, 51, who'd been with Boulder Police since 2010, according to Herald.
00:03:41.000He went to the store after a call about shots fired, someone carrying a rifle.
00:03:44.000He was, by all accounts, one of the outstanding officers of the Boulder Police Department.
00:03:48.000His life was cut too short, it's already said, of Talley.
00:03:50.000Identities of the other nine victims were not disclosed Monday night, as police were still notifying their family members.
00:03:57.000Attorney for Colorado, pledged the full weight of federal law enforcement to support the investigation.
00:04:02.000Officers did escort a shirtless man with blood running down his leg out of the store in handcuffs.
00:04:06.000Authorities would not say if he was, in fact, the suspect.
00:04:09.000Officials have not said whether the suspect is the person who was taken from the shooting scenes at Foothills Hospital in Boulder, and the hospital is not releasing any more information.
00:04:16.000Dean Schiller told the AP he had just left the supermarket when he heard gunshots and saw three people lying face down, two in the parking lot, one near the doorway.
00:04:22.000He said he couldn't tell if they were breathing.
00:04:24.000There was also video live-streamed on YouTube.
00:04:26.000Which showed one person on the floor inside the store and two more outside on the ground.
00:04:30.000And you can hear gunshots at the beginning of the video.
00:04:33.000At one point, authorities said over the loudspeaker, the building was surrounded and you need to surrender.
00:04:38.000Sarah Moonshadow told the Denver Post, two shots rang out just after she and her son, Nicholas Edwards, had finished buying strawberries.
00:04:43.000She said she told her son to get down and then we just ran.
00:04:46.000It's obviously just another horrific mass shooting.
00:04:50.000And the media typically in these situations responds by suggesting, of course, that people who don't agree with their basic policy prescriptions are somehow unsympathetic to the victims in these sorts of situations.
00:05:02.000Because you know that the next political move here, forever and always, will be a federal call for gun control.
00:05:08.000Joe Biden has been looking for an excuse to push gun control for a little while here now.
00:05:12.000He's been talking about gun control consistently for the last 10, 15 years.
00:05:16.000He used to be somebody who's a little looser on gun control.
00:05:18.000Now he is somebody who's much tighter on gun control.
00:05:19.000He's been pushing for an assault weapons ban, all of the 1994 assault weapons ban that really had no impact on mass shootings in the United States.
00:05:25.000He's been looking for that for quite a while.
00:05:27.000So this will be used politically as a hook in order to push forward the gun control agenda.
00:05:35.000And the media are gonna foster this by suggesting, of course, that if you don't agree with Joe Biden's agenda, it's because you don't care about the people who were killed.
00:05:42.000It's a cheap political trick that is played during every tragedy.
00:05:45.000That if you don't agree with my policy prescription, it's because you don't care about the people who have died or the people who have been victimized in any particular way.
00:05:52.000And you can see the media already ramping up for this, right?
00:05:56.000That if you say that the gun control measures that are likely to be pushed by the federal government are extraordinarily unlikely to prevent mass shootings.
00:06:04.000In fact, virtually every gun control policy that's been pushed By the federal government has had no impact on mass shootings.
00:06:10.000The number of guns in circulation in the United States has risen dramatically over the course of the last 15 to 20 years.
00:06:15.000The number of people who have been killed in mass shootings year on year has actually been going down.
00:06:19.000But that does not matter to the folks who push gun control.
00:06:23.000And so their idea is you are unsympathetic to victims.
00:06:26.000This has been a thing ever since I told Piers Morgan not to do it on CNN.
00:06:30.000The reality is that you can be deeply sympathetic to people who have been harmed in any sort of crime and still recognize that bad policy does not solve the problem.
00:06:42.000OK, but you can see that the media already setting the predicate.
00:06:44.000So here on CNN was one of the reporters saying that this is just the way America is.
00:06:51.000Realistically speaking, America does have more absolute numbers of mass shootings than other countries.
00:06:57.000But there are mass shootings in Australia.
00:06:58.000There have been mass shootings in Norway.
00:07:00.000If you were to look at the number of deaths per million from mass shootings, it's actually higher in some civilized countries than it is in the United States.
00:07:05.000Nonetheless, again, the predicate here is that America is unique, that this problem is easily solved by a simple policy change, which, of course, it is not.
00:07:13.000And the media are going to suggest that if you oppose that policy change, it's because you don't care about what just happened in Boulder, Colorado.
00:07:18.000Here was CNN jumping on that within probably an hour of the shooting breaking.
00:07:22.000A larger story here that may not be addressed today, but is one that we have to address in light of what happened in Atlanta, which is, are we facing a spring and summer of mass casualty events as we come out, as people congregate?
00:07:37.000And that is something that the Biden White House will have to address as well.
00:07:51.000Okay, so again, the level of incredulity, I believe that's Allison Camerata over on CNN, the level of incredulity there, the notion that you are, how can it be that we as Americans are going, we as Americans aren't doing anything?
00:08:07.000In fact, as of yesterday, as far as I'm aware, there were some 330 million Americans who didn't engage in a mass shooting.
00:08:14.000It's not as though everybody went out in the streets and started shooting guns in the air and then turned the guns on their fellow citizens.
00:08:19.000There are 300 million guns in the United States.
00:08:22.000There are over 100 million long guns in the United States.
00:08:25.000Virtually none of them were used in a mass shooting yesterday.
00:08:28.000But there was one used by somebody who was evil.
00:09:03.000Did you engage in a mass shooting yesterday?
00:09:04.000or no reason. We have a moral imperative to be better than this. I don't even know what that last part means. A moral imperative to be better than what?
00:09:10.000Nobody is saying that what happened in Colorado is decent, good, or should be something that we ignore. Who is saying that?
00:09:18.000Better than what? Did you engage in a mass shooting yesterday? I didn't. This notion that all Americans are somehow okay or blasé about 10 fellow Americans being shot to death in a supermarket, including a police officer, and some of their blasé about that.
00:09:36.000I don't believe that Casey Hunt is more sympathetic than you are, or than I am.
00:09:40.000I don't believe that Casey Hunt is a deeper wellspring of emotion than you are, or than other normal Americans are.
00:09:47.000I think all Americans are rightly outraged at the act of evil that we saw yesterday in Boulder, Colorado.
00:09:53.000But again, the media are setting the groundwork, and the groundwork is that when Joe Biden comes out and makes an emotional pitch for gun control, if you don't believe that that gun control is truly Well calibrated toward reducing risk and preserving rights, then this means that you just don't care, right?
00:10:08.000You're not better than this, in the words of Casey Hunt.
00:10:16.000But this is the same game that our media play, and it really is kind of an emotionally manipulative game.
00:10:21.000That if you don't agree with what they want, it means you're a bad person.
00:10:25.000That is the subtle argument that is being made here.
00:10:27.000It's not a particularly subtle argument in reality.
00:10:29.000Some people are less subtle even than that.
00:10:31.000Mary L. Trump, who is famous only because her last name is Trump, and has made a bajillion dollars off of writing a book about how much she doesn't like Donald Trump.
00:10:38.000So Mary L. Trump tweeted out, The NRA is a terrorist organization and should be treated as such.
00:10:45.000Do we have any evidence that this particular person was an NRA member?
00:10:49.000Or that the NRA fostered his behavior?
00:10:51.000Or that the NRA trained him for this behavior?
00:10:54.000And by the way, what exactly is that suggestion?
00:10:55.000If the NRA is a terrorist organization, then presumably we should round up all the members and put them in Gitmo.
00:11:00.000If the NRA is a terrorist organization, what?
00:11:01.000We're going to go around... Does Joe Biden now have the capacity to just drone American citizens who happen to believe in the Second Amendment?
00:11:09.000So little of this is rooted in anything remotely resembling a policy debate.
00:11:15.000If you want to make a case for specific pieces of legislation that would mitigate mass shootings, or shootings at all, while actually preserving Americans' fundamental right to defend themselves and defend their property and defend their rights, then bring it forth!
00:11:32.000Barack Obama used to admit this all the time.
00:11:33.000He used to say, sure, the legislation we're now bringing forward on gun control wouldn't have stopped this shooting, but it might stop other shootings.
00:11:41.000OK, well, if it wouldn't stop this shooting, then why are you talking about this piece of legislation on the back of this particular act of evil?
00:11:49.000They recognize the game before it's being played because I promise you this is going to be the narrative over the course of the next couple of weeks as Joe Biden immediately shifts into gun control mode.
00:11:57.000He's immediately going to shift into gun control mode.
00:11:59.000The media are going to shift along with him because they don't want to talk about what's happening on the border because that, of course, is a Biden-fostered crisis.
00:12:05.000And so they're immediately going to shift with Joe Biden into gun control talk.
00:12:09.000And the implication is going to be those evil obstructionist Republicans, if only they would just go along with the gun control agenda, then all of this would stop.
00:12:17.000And if they don't go along with it, it's because they wish to normalize, in the words of Casey Hunt, what just happened in Colorado.
00:12:22.000Again, no one is normalizing acts of evil.
00:12:25.000That is not something that any fellow American is doing.
00:12:27.000And if you're imputing to fellow Americans that they literally don't care about people getting shot in a supermarket in Colorado, we shouldn't share the same country.
00:12:33.000If you truly believe That your fellow Americans do not care about innocents being gunned down in a supermarket?
00:12:39.000Then you're living next to people who are evil.
00:12:41.000And you shouldn't be sharing a town with them.
00:12:43.000You shouldn't be sharing a church with them.
00:12:44.000You shouldn't be sharing a country with them.
00:12:47.000But that is the underlying emotional play that is being made here by your delightful mainstream media.
00:12:52.000Alrighty, in just a second, we're gonna get to the situation on the border, which continues to just marinate and get worse day after day.
00:14:01.000Head on over to policygenius.com to get started.
00:14:04.000PolicyGenius, when it comes to insurance, it's nice and quite important to get it right.
00:14:08.000Okay, so, Meanwhile, the situation on the border continues to get worse and worse, and this is driven explicitly at this point by Joe Biden's terrible policy.
00:14:17.000According to Axios, the Biden administration kept a Trump-era policy known as Title 42 as a tool to quickly turn back adults and families who illegally crossed the southern border.
00:14:25.000But according to new Department of Homeland Security data leaked to Axios, it has not been used at all for families.
00:14:45.000But DHS now says that if you arrive as a family, they're not going to do that.
00:14:49.000In fact, the data shows an average of just 13% of nearly 13,000 family members attempting to cross the U.S.-Mexico border were returned to Mexico between March 14th and March 21st using the public health order, which essentially says the U.S.
00:15:01.000can close the border to non-essential travel because of the COVID virus.
00:15:05.000It's a sign of how the administration is struggling to keep up with the migration surge and has recently been hamstrung by Mexico's inability to take in more families the U.S.
00:15:22.000The same administration that tells you that Florida is terrible because it's wide open and COVID's gonna spread and we're all gonna die and keep masking up, they're not even using the coronavirus pandemic to reject people at the border that we have not tested for COVID.
00:15:35.000That's how ridiculous and incoherent this administration's policy is.
00:15:39.000The other 87% won't remain in the U.S.
00:15:42.000indefinitely according to Axios, but they will be allowed into the U.S.
00:15:45.000to go through immigration proceedings, which means they will stay in the U.S.
00:15:51.000The DHS spokesperson said, well, you know, one week of stats doesn't reflect the full picture.
00:15:55.000Our policy remains that families are expelled, and in situations where expulsion is not possible, they are placed into removal proceedings.
00:16:02.000White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki says the process of deporting those families sometimes, quote, takes a minute to ensure there's proper transportation and steps in place to do that.
00:16:09.000No, what's happening right now is that you guys have decided that you are just going to let a ton of people in.
00:16:16.000And Joe Biden has incentivized all of this.
00:17:03.000Yes, we desperately in Florida need the help of Kamala Harris, an incompetent senator who couldn't get 0% in a California primary before she was plucked out of obscurity, thanks to the fact that Joe Biden wanted a black female for his vice president.
00:17:54.000You wonder why the Democratic Party needs to wheel around a not fully sentient, not fully alive human as President of the United States, because all that stands between Kamala Harris, a terrible, awkward, horrific politician in the presidency, is that old man.
00:18:09.000That's why they have to just keep pretending that everything is fine in Biden-land, because here is the thing.
00:18:14.000Kamala Harris, as the face of this policy, looks very, very different, not because of race or gender, but just because she's terrible at this, than Joe Biden does.
00:18:21.000Okay, in any case, the situation on the border, again, continues to be bad.
00:18:24.000The media were barred from these migrant facilities, where we now have a multiple of people who are being kept and housed.
00:18:32.000But footage did leak from inside the migrant facilities.
00:18:35.000Project Veritas got a hold of some of the footage.
00:19:42.000According to the Biden administration, not a crisis.
00:19:44.000And also, everybody should keep coming, but also they should stay away, because it's awkward right now.
00:19:47.000But also, the media shouldn't be allowed in, because if they see those pictures, then it might be bad for the administration.
00:19:53.000Even CNN, finally catching on, they say, um, yeah, it turns out that we now have migrant children who are essentially staying in jail cells.
00:20:33.000Because I feel like they're not racing so much.
00:20:35.000And I feel like if they wanted to make sure that kids were not along the border, they would reject families at the border, which apparently they're not doing.
00:20:41.000Because it turns out families generally have kids, but they're not rejecting the families.
00:20:46.000They've fostered this border crisis, and every single person knows it.
00:20:50.000In fact, NBC's Steve Gutierrez said that migrants say they are now being encouraged by the Biden administration.
00:20:57.000We have spoken with several migrants over the last several days, Andrea, both on this side of the border and over in Mexico, in Matamoros, Mexico, that said that they were encouraged by the change in administration.
00:21:09.000Many of them didn't know the specifics of President Biden's border policies, but what they did know is that he was not President Trump, and some of them did feel that now would be the time to come to the border.
00:22:06.000The Biden administration kept talking about transparency, and we're not getting any transparency here with what is happening at the border, that we have to get those images from a congressman who won't say where he got those images.
00:22:18.000It's very frustrating for not just journalists, but for the American public who want to know what's going on inside those facilities, those disturbing images.
00:22:28.000Jake Tapper of CNN now calling it out.
00:22:31.000Today we saw this rare look inside these facilities, since the Biden administration has not granted news media access to the facility, citing COVID restrictions, despite the president's promise in his inaugural address to always level with you.
00:22:45.000Blocking access to the news media is not leveling with the American people, Mr. President.
00:22:49.000Yeah, they're not leveling with the American people.
00:22:51.000They're refusing to release statistics.
00:22:53.000And by the way, who are you going to believe, the administration or your own eyes?
00:22:56.000Jen Psaki said literally yesterday that as these pictures were emerging of these kids sleeping directly next to each other, and adults, by the way, sleeping directly next to each other in large numbers inside what looked like essentially plastic bubbles, she said, don't worry, we're following all the CDC guidelines.
00:23:16.000If they need to be quarantined, they are quarantined.
00:23:18.000We also follow CDC guidelines to ensure that they are kept safe.
00:23:22.000One of the reasons that it took us some time to have some of these facilities or some of the shelters open to larger groups of kids is because we wanted to follow those CDC guidelines.
00:23:33.000But where else in the country would it be okay to have 400 people in a space for 260 during the pandemic?
00:23:41.000Well, again, Peter, we're closely following the CDC guidelines.
00:23:50.000You have said that kids cannot be in schools.
00:23:53.000Kids can't be in schools if they are three feet or less apart.
00:23:58.000But you are keeping these kids inches from one another, and it's totally fine.
00:24:02.000Which suggests this is not really about COVID on the one hand, and also they just don't want to do anything about the immigration problem.
00:24:07.000According to the Washington Post, over the last three weeks, the average number of teenagers and children crossing into the United States without parents has topped 550 per day.
00:24:15.000Border officials are on pace to take in more than 17,000 minors this month, which would be an all-time high.
00:24:24.000Biden has had a markedly different approach than his predecessors to an influx of homelands that Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas said was on pace to be the largest in the last 20 years.
00:24:35.000So far, they're just adding capacity to shelters and other facilities to absorb the influx, declining to implement policies that would send minors back because the administration considers the policies morally unacceptable, which means they want this to happen.
00:25:33.000According to the New York Times, it's going to start with a giant infrastructure plan that might be financed in part through tax increases on corporations and the rich.
00:25:40.000Yeah, that's not going to have any impact.
00:25:41.000You're going to take all the corporations that have to rehire everybody right now, and you are going to tax them in order to pay for roads that largely should be done through the state and local level.
00:25:51.000After months of internal debate, Biden's advisors are expected to present the spending proposal to the president and congressional leaders this week, as well as begin outreach to industry and labor groups. Industry and labor groups are the key here. When you wonder why Biden wants to spend trillions of dollars on this stuff, it's because he wants to quote, quote, create good union jobs.
00:26:06.000The goal is to pay off big labor, because the most corrupt open bargain in American politics is that our Democratic friends, they pay off the unions.
00:26:13.000The unions then take that money and pour it back into campaigns so that Democrats can be elected to pay off the unions.
00:26:18.000It's the most open corruption in American politics, and it's been going on for decades.
00:26:23.000Administration officials caution the details remain in flux, but the enormous scope of the proposal highlights the aggressive approach the Biden administration wants to take as it tries to harness the power of the federal government to make the economy more equitable, address climate change, and improve American manufacturing and high-technology industries in an escalating battle with China.
00:26:41.000I always love when the New York Times quote-unquote reporting reports they want to make the economy more equitable.
00:26:48.000It is a word that means whatever the Biden administration wants it to mean.
00:26:52.000What it really means is that they don't care about growth rates, they care about redistribution of income.
00:26:56.000And when they say they're going to address climate change, question, what policy here is calibrated to addressing climate change?
00:27:03.000If the United States were to go carbon neutral right now, it would lower the climate by estimates about 0.2 degrees Celsius by the end of the century.
00:27:13.000So what in the world is he talking about?
00:27:16.000The $1.9 trillion economic aid package Biden signed into law this month includes money to help vulnerable people and businesses survive the pandemic downturn, but it does little to advance the longer-term economic agenda.
00:27:27.000The economic agenda is completely tied in to the billions of dollars, hundreds of billions of dollars in that package that are designed at creating a new welfare net for people without any requirements as to their behavior.
00:27:39.000According to Seth Hanlon, Senior Fellow at the Center for American Progress, President Biden's plan represents a stunning shift in priorities addressing many of the nation's most pressing challenges.
00:27:48.000The plan is super wide-ranging, reflecting the fact we've under-invested in so many areas.
00:27:52.000Under-invested in so many areas, we are spending $4 trillion a year before the pandemic.
00:27:57.000Last year, we spent something like $7 trillion, and that doesn't count the Fed spending, which was another several trillion dollars.
00:28:03.000And now, we've already got the $4 trillion budget that's gonna pass this year.
00:28:06.000Plus another $2 trillion package, and you want to add another $3 trillion on top of that.
00:28:09.000So you're talking about $9-10 trillion blown into the economy by the Biden administration this year.
00:28:14.000You think that's not going to lead to runaway inflation?
00:28:34.000It has happened in multiple economies.
00:28:35.000And pretending that what goes up does not come down cannot be the hallmark of your economic policy if you actually care about growth, which apparently they don't.
00:28:43.000Right now, the White House officials say they want to focus on the infrastructure stuff.
00:28:48.000That plan would spend heavily on clean energy deployment and the development of other high-growth industries of the future, like 5G telecommunications.
00:28:55.000It includes money for rural broadband.
00:28:57.000Advanced training for millions of workers, by the way.
00:28:59.000These advanced training programs, I wish they were successful.
00:29:01.000I wish it were just as easy for somebody losing a job to get trained for another job and stick them in a government program.
00:29:16.000If by affordable you mean that we're going to subsidize government housing in a time when the economy is going to be booming, then good luck with that.
00:29:24.000Officials have discussed offsetting some or all of the infrastructure spending by raising taxes on corporations, including increasing the 21% corporate income tax rate and a variety of measures to force multinational corporations to pay more tax in the United States on income they earn abroad.
00:29:39.000So they're gonna punish corporations for success, even as they attempt to rehire Americans who've been put out of work by the pandemic.
00:29:46.000We were at 3.5% unemployment before the pandemic, and your goal is now to reach, is now to quote-unquote, build back better by completely shifting the basis of the United States economy that had been at historic highs before the pandemic.
00:30:12.000And by the way, it's going to bleed down into lower tax brackets.
00:30:14.000According to the New York Times, one question is how to apply Mr. Biden's campaign promise that no one earning less than $400,000 a year would pay more in federal taxes under the plan.
00:30:22.000Currently, the top marginal income tax rate starts at just about $500,000 for individuals and about $600,000 for couples.
00:30:29.000Biden proposed raising that rate during the campaign.
00:30:34.000They've debated whether to lower the income threshold for the top marginal tax rate to tax all individual income above $400,000 at 40% in order to raise more revenue for his spending plans, and they're going to raise a bunch of taxes that do impact people making less money than that, because when you tax corporations, you're inherently taxing a bunch of people who make less than $400,000 a year.
00:30:52.000But don't worry, it doesn't stop there.
00:30:53.000The Democrats are now pushing forward on their plans to kill the filibuster.
00:30:57.000Which would, in essence, mean ramming through every radical policy proposal you could imagine.
00:31:14.000It's why I look so svelte and wonderful.
00:31:16.000Hey, Noom doesn't just help you lose weight.
00:31:19.000It helps you know why you lose weight, what sort of habits you need to change in order to lose the weight.
00:31:24.000Based in science, built by psychologists, Noom doesn't give you rules.
00:31:26.000Instead, teaches you how to think so you can accomplish your personal health goals, stick with them long-term, and get healthy for good.
00:31:32.000Based in psychology, Noom teaches you why you make the decisions you do and gives you the tools to replace your habits with healthier habits.
00:31:38.000Noom's cognitive behavioral approach means you're not just improving your health, you're gaining the knowledge and habits you need to stay healthy in the first place.
00:31:43.000Everybody's busy, so Noom doesn't demand a lot of your time.
00:32:04.000Sign up for your trial today at Noom, N-O-O-M dot com slash Shapiro.
00:32:08.000If you're ready to learn how to live healthier, sign up for Noom today at N-O-O-M dot com slash Shapiro.
00:32:13.000Alrighty, in just one second, we're gonna get to the Democrats attempting to kill the filibuster.
00:32:18.000First, if you haven't heard by now, but honestly, if you listen to this show, you would have heard, Candace Owens has a brand new talk show with us exclusively at DailyWire.com.
00:32:26.000The full show might be available to DailyWire members only, but Candace is also a podcast you can listen to on Apple, Spotify, anywhere else.
00:33:24.000But now the case by Democrats is basically that the legislative filibuster is a racist tool, which is weird because Barack Obama used it repeatedly when he was a senator.
00:33:31.000The Democrats used it repeatedly to shut down, for example, a police reform bill from the black Senator Tim Scott from South Carolina, who happens to be a Republican.
00:33:38.000So filibusters are only racist, apparently, when Republicans use them.
00:33:42.000Here is Secretary Clinton making the case.
00:33:45.000I think we need to bring back a real legislative process.
00:33:48.000If you thought you had to actually stand up and vote on something, you'd actually work to get an amendment to change it.
00:33:55.000As opposed to saying, I don't even have to think about it, I'm just going to show up and I'm going to be part of a filibuster.
00:34:01.000That doesn't inspire cooperation, it just keeps people in their separate camps.
00:34:07.000I think it's going to take a little bit of change in order to get to where people have to work together.
00:34:12.000And surprisingly, in my own mind, I think, you know, getting rid of the filibuster will actually have that result.
00:34:18.000That's the dumbest thing I've ever heard.
00:34:19.000So now she's saying that getting rid of the filibuster will create bipartisanship.
00:34:35.000They could just do it with a simple majority.
00:34:38.000They could do it with 50 votes plus Kamala Harris.
00:34:40.000So, what in the world is she talking about?
00:34:42.000The case that Democrats usually make is that the filibuster is racist, even though it has been a piece of procedure that has been in place and used by both parties for centuries at this point.
00:34:52.000Nonetheless, Erwin Chemerinsky is now calling, the professor formerly of USC, he is now calling for Vice President Kamala Harris to simply declare the filibuster unconstitutional.
00:35:03.000He says, in 1957, Vice President Richard Nixon, sitting as presiding officer of the Senate, issued two advisory opinions, holding that a crucial provision of the Senate's filibuster rule, requiring two-thirds vote to amend it, was unconstitutional.
00:35:14.000Nixon's constitutional determination was reaffirmed by subsequent VPs Hubert Humphrey and Nelson Rockefeller.
00:35:19.000In fact, it was this ruling that allowed both the Democratic-controlled Senate in 2013 and the Republican-controlled Senate in 2017, by simple majority vote, to eliminate filibusters for all executive and judicial nominees.
00:35:29.000Harris possesses the same exact power.
00:35:32.000Which essentially establishes a 60-vote supermajority rule, the filibuster.
00:35:36.000She could say it's unconstitutional because it denies states equal suffrage in the Senate in violation of Article 5 of the Constitution, which is absurd.
00:35:43.000Okay, the Senate can come up with its own procedures.
00:35:46.000The notion that the Senate, that the states are denied equal suffrage because you need a supermajority to pass things, you could bring the same exact complaint against the other areas requiring supermajority consent, including, for example, impeachment.
00:36:00.000It takes two-thirds of the Senate in order to greenlight an impeachment.
00:36:05.000Is the Constitution itself unconstitutional?
00:36:10.000Everyone agrees the text of the Constitution does not allow for simply giving California more senators than Wyoming, says Erwin Chemerinsky, nor can the Senate's lack of representative fairness be cured by adopting internal Senate voting rules.
00:36:20.000But that doesn't mean the Senate has authority to create even more unfairness than already exists.
00:36:25.000In fact, Article 1 of the Constitution doesn't allow a broad 60-vote supermajority rule.
00:36:32.000The Senate has the ability to make its own rules.
00:36:34.000Now, would it be a good idea for Kamala Harris to simply overthrow the filibuster in a time of high political polarization and division in the United States?
00:36:41.000It would be about the dumbest thing she could do.
00:36:43.000If she did that, I will tell you what the predictable result of all of this is going to be, as Democrats surge forth with a more and more radical program with fewer and fewer people supporting it.
00:36:50.000What this is going to look like, as opposed to a bipartisan compromise, what this is going to look like is states beginning to say, you passed it, now enforce it.
00:36:59.000If you really want to pass it, you can try to enforce it, but we're not helping you.
00:37:05.000We're just going to become sanctuary states where people actually still have constitutionally guaranteed freedoms.
00:37:10.000Doesn't mean we're going to use armed opposition to stop the feds from doing things.
00:37:14.000It does mean that you are going to have to enforce this sucker yourself.
00:37:17.000That is what you're going to start getting very, very quickly.
00:37:20.000Meanwhile, the Democrats really want to get rid of the filibuster because, number one, they want to completely destroy the system of voting in the United States by violating, by the way, the Constitution.
00:37:28.000So they want to get rid of the filibuster so they can violate the Constitution by federalizing all voting procedures which were not delegated to the federal government under the Constitution of the United States.
00:37:38.000It is a horribly written bill that dramatically increases the possibility of voter fraud and dramatically undermines the ability of anybody to believe in the voting system of the United States.
00:37:46.000And this is coming from somebody who doesn't believe that the last election was decided by voter fraud and irregularity.
00:37:50.000You want to make sure that every future election is in doubt?
00:38:09.000And they need to do that so they can add states.
00:38:12.000So they can completely overthrow the bargain that the states currently have by adding with a simple majority vote states like the District of Columbia.
00:38:58.000And I don't just mean police brutality and hate crimes and food apartheid systems and transportation deserts and unequal access to healthcare.
00:40:13.000Because it has long been held, since like the foundation of the country, that the District of Columbia should not be under the auspices of any state.
00:40:21.000Because if you have a state, that means the seat of the federal government is now in hock to the states.
00:40:28.000It can't be a racial issue because at the time, no black people could vote, okay?
00:40:32.000At the foundations of this country, black Americans were stopped from voting by racist policy.
00:40:38.000So the notion that the Federal District of Columbia was prevented from being a state because white people were afraid of black people gaining power is an absurdity, historically speaking, and it also happens to contravene the explicitly stated intent of making the Federal District of Columbia federal in the first place.
00:40:53.000Federalist 43, James Madison, fully explains why the District of Columbia is a federal district.
00:40:59.000He says, if it were not, then the federal government would then be in hock to the state.
00:41:07.000It would create a dependence on the members of the general government on the state, comprehending the seat of government for protection in the exercise of their duty.
00:41:13.000Might bring on the national councils an imputation of awe or influence equally dishonorable to the government and dissatisfactory to the other members of the Confederacy.
00:41:22.000would be seen to be running the federal government, as opposed to the federal government being D.C.
00:41:27.000This consideration has the more weight as the gradual accumulation of public improvements at the stationary residence of the government would be both too great a public pledge to be left in the hands of a single state and create so many obstacles to a removal of the government as still further to abridge its necessary independence.
00:41:41.000The extent of the federal district is sufficiently circumscribed to satisfy every jealousy of an opposite nature.
00:41:47.000Again, this goes all the way back to the foundation of the country.
00:41:49.000The notion that this is racially based is ridiculous on its face, but again, it's not about any of that.
00:41:53.000It's about America's bad unless you give me what I want.
00:42:02.000This kind of language about the country that allows for immigrants to the United States to become members of Congress regularly, it is quite an astonishing thing.
00:42:13.000I mean, Rashida Tlaib is one of the great beneficiaries of America's systems of freedom and meritocracy.
00:42:18.000And yet, here she is saying that America's racist because D.C.
00:42:24.000statehood, which is overwhelmingly supported by the people of Washington, these representatives and their dark money backers over the Heritage Foundation, that's right, are telling over 700,000 Americans to sit down, shut up, and enjoy this authoritarian system implemented by a bunch of elites who thought it was okay to enslave people for their selfish monetary gain hundreds of years ago.
00:42:47.000It is shameful that anyone would claim to support democracy and freedom and oppose statehood.
00:42:53.000You can't even support democracy and freedom and oppose D.C.
00:43:15.000And they're going to do so by killing the filibuster.
00:43:18.000They're going to do so by changing the voting rules.
00:43:19.000They're going to do so by incentivizing illegal immigration.
00:43:22.000And they're going to do so by cowing you into silence by leveraging the power that they have institutionally in order to shut you up.
00:43:29.000That is the future of the country over the next few years.
00:43:31.000There's only one thing you can do to stop that, and that is don't shut up and don't acquiesce to their ridiculous suggestion that if you disagree with them, this makes you somehow morally deficient, which is an absurdity on its face.
00:43:41.000Because I'll tell you what, this agenda is morally deficient.
00:43:44.000Alrighty, we will be back here later today with an additional hour of The Ben Shapiro Show coming up soon.
00:43:48.000The Matt Wall Show airing at 1.30 p.m.