The Ben Shapiro Show - September 30, 2026


The Clancy Defense Lawyer May Have Broken the Constitution

Hosted by
Mentioned
Britain Caught an Iranian-Backed Plot — and Released Them on Bail Elon, Dario, Zuck, and Karp Walk Into the White House

Episode Stats


Length

17 minutes

Words per minute

169.4

Word count

2,894

Sentence count

229

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

6

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcripts from "The Ben Shapiro Show" are sourced from the Knowledge Fight Interactive Search Tool. Explore them interactively here.
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 So, I remember Jack Smith.
00:00:01 He was the special counsel appointed to go after President Trump, and then all of his cases blew up when President Trump won the 2024 election.
00:00:07 He was in Congress yesterday.
00:00:08 It didn't go great for him.
00:00:09 There was a hearing that happened in the United States Senate.
00:00:12 The hearing was directed at Jack Smith.
00:00:14 Jack Smith, of course, was the special counsel who was appointed under the Biden administration to look into President Trump on a wide variety of counts, ranging from the Mar a Lago raid to allegations that he had involved himself in election corruption.
00:00:35 He was the one going after Trump for 2020 election interference.
00:00:40 And then he had to dismiss the action after Trump won the 2024 election.
00:00:46 So he was called before Congress.
00:00:47 And the reason he was called before Congress is because, in the process of pursuing all of these alleged crimes, he proceeded to basically draw information on pretty much everybody on the right.
00:00:58 Subpoena, like basic donor information, for example, go after GOP organizations.
00:01:04 So, Jack Smith, first, he claimed not to know that the RNC and TPUSA were subpoenaed.
00:01:09 Did your team subpoena records concerning the Republican National Committee?
00:01:16 We subpoenaed a number of records.
00:01:18 That's a yes or no question.
00:01:22 I do not have, I just want to be clear with you, Senator, I do not have a recollection of every subpoena.
00:01:27 We did subpoena numerous records.
00:01:29 Did your team subpoena the RNC?
00:01:31 I would have to look at those records, but we did subpoena.
00:01:33 You're testifying you don't remember?
00:01:34 Yes, no, or I don't remember.
00:01:36 There's your three options.
00:01:38 It is very possible.
00:01:39 I do not have a recollection of the RNC.
00:01:40 Did your team subpoena Turning Point USA?
00:01:45 Again, I would have to look at the.
00:01:46 Do you have any idea who you subpoenaed?
00:01:48 Can you name?
00:01:49 All right, let me help you.
00:01:52 Did your team subpoena the Conservative Partnership Institute?
00:01:56 That I do remember, yes.
00:01:57 Okay, good.
00:01:58 We found one.
00:02:00 Okay, we should point out at this point that Senators Graham Hawley, Ron Johnson, Marsha Blackburn, Bill Hagerty, Dan Sullivan, Tommy Tuberville, Cynthia Lummis, Ted Cruz, and Representative Mike Kelly all had their phone calls and toll records subpoenaed.
00:02:14 In the middle of this investigation, and Senators Grassley, Lee, Cornyn, and Hawley, Graham, and Johnson all had their text messages subpoenaed between late 2020 and early 2021.
00:02:24 Ted Cruz highlighted the subpoenas targeting GOP organizations.
00:02:29 Every name on it is a Republican.
00:02:32 Is it your view?
00:02:33 Is it a crime to be a Republican?
00:02:35 Absolutely not, sir.
00:02:37 Is it a crime to write a check to Republicans?
00:02:40 It is not, and I'm happy to explain why we issued these subpoenas if you'd like.
00:02:46 Sure, briefly.
00:02:48 We had to conduct an investigation about whether any person or entity violated the law with respect to the attempt to block the peaceful transfer of power.
00:02:58 To make that decision, yes, I understand.
00:03:00 And you use that as an excuse to engage in a massive fishing expedition targeting over 400 Republicans, and it was disgraceful.
00:03:07 Okay, so, you know, Jack Smith, again, it was a fishing expedition.
00:03:13 It was, in fact, a fishing expedition.
00:03:15 Josh Howley also went after Jack Smith.
00:03:19 Again, Jack Smith went too far.
00:03:20 His charges were never truly substantiated.
00:03:23 The charges themselves were incredibly vague and poorly drawn.
00:03:25 We covered it extensively at the time.
00:03:27 Here is Josh Hawley going after Jack Smith.
00:03:30 But you use your ability and the powers of your office to lie to the court, to lie to Congress, to lie to the American people, to lie to the House.
00:03:42 It's the worst abuse of prosecutorial power in the history of the United States.
00:03:46 And all I have to say is I'm glad you failed.
00:03:48 I don't know what our democracy would be like.
00:03:50 If you had succeeded in your effort to interfere in the workings of a presidential election, if it were up to me, I'd charge you with perjury.
00:03:59 But you should certainly be disbarred.
00:04:03 And I can only pray that nothing like this will ever happen again in the United States of America.
00:04:07 Now, Jack Smith claimed that he had not coordinated in any way with the Biden administration.
00:04:11 And Senator John Kennedy of Louisiana was like, Are you trying to joke us right now?
00:04:17 Like, are we really supposed to believe that?
00:04:20 Attorney General Garland could have countermanded that decision.
00:04:23 But I made that decision.
00:04:25 On my own, consulting with my staff and reviewing the incredibly strong evidence that we had accumulated.
00:04:31 In fact, President Biden andor his White House staff told General Garland to prosecute the president, didn't they?
00:04:42 Again, I have no idea about that.
00:04:44 What my job was was to.
00:04:45 I don't know anything about that.
00:04:47 Do you believe in the tooth fairy?
00:04:51 I do not.
00:04:52 How about the Easter Bunny?
00:04:56 I no longer believe in the Easter Bunny.
00:04:58 Do you think Jimmy Hoffa died of natural causes?
00:05:02 I do not.
00:05:05 Well, you know, is this going to do any damage seriously to Jack Smith?
00:05:10 Probably not.
00:05:10 They weren't going to catch him in a perjury trap.
00:05:12 It was amusing, by the way, that Cory Booker then put on his angry eyes, right?
00:05:17 He's Mr. Potato Head, and he popped in the angry eyes.
00:05:19 And then he talked, how dare the Republicans do this before an election?
00:05:24 I don't know.
00:05:24 How dare Democrats try to.
00:05:26 Basically, prosecute the former presidents of the United States into the ground before an election.
00:05:33 And I'd say this to my ranking member here every person who they bring through to be confirmed for a position, asked over and over again, did Donald Trump win the 2020 election, refuses to say the truth.
00:05:49 This is an eight year attempt to lie to the American people.
00:05:52 And this is their closing argument, everybody.
00:05:55 Right before an election, this is what they want to spend their time on.
00:06:00 Perpetrating a lie.
00:06:03 Yeah.
00:06:04 Perpetrating lies on law enforcement auspices about your political opponents, that's kind of a Democrat thing, actually.
00:06:11 By the way, President Trump has, of course, maintained that the 2020 election was fraudulent.
00:06:17 Calchie Markets disagree.
00:06:19 The Calchie Markets, again, they're sponsors.
00:06:22 Most people believe that there will be no court ruling that the 2020 election was fraudulent, like a 10% chance at any point that there will be some sort of Ruling that the 2020 election was fraudulent.
00:06:33 Again, not a gigantic surprise there.
00:06:35 Okay.
00:06:36 Meanwhile, in other legal issues in the headlines.
00:06:40 So, we talked at length yesterday about this Cornell University alleged gang rape case.
00:06:44 And I pointed out that the evidence there was unbelievably scanty, that the original police complaint that was filed by the unnamed Jane Doe in this particular situation did not even allege a lack of consent.
00:06:57 And that's sort of a problem.
00:06:58 Well, that has not stopped Hollywood from going to bat against Cornell University for supposedly not doing enough.
00:07:04 So, Mariska Hargete, who's been synonymous with tackling sex crime stories because she played a sex crime police officer on Lawn Order SVU, used her Instagram story to rail against the Cornell Seven.
00:07:17 That's what they're calling the men who engaged in this by reposting the following statements Dear men and boys, if your friends tell you they're gang raping someone, call the effing police. 0.75
00:07:25 Yes, I think we should ruin the futures of adult men who drug and gang rape a woman. 0.56
00:07:29 Thanks for asking. 0.96
00:07:30 57 men were in that frat group chat.
00:07:32 57, not one of them stopped it.
00:07:35 Meanwhile, heated rivalry star Hudson Wilson said, arrest them, F them, and F Cornell too, and good place in She Hulk actor Jamila Jamil. 0.99
00:07:43 She said, I think the likes of the Cornell Seven shouldn't be allowed penises anymore. 0.98
00:07:47 They use them as weapons, so now they have to be confiscated. 0.95
00:07:49 I think jail time, legal castration, and removal of the shaft seems like the bare minimum.
00:07:54 Now, normally, when you're calling for that sort of treatment, you have to identify a crime.
00:08:02 I know this is crazy talk.
00:08:04 But as I say, the reason that the left is so exercised about this particular case is because they know deep in their heart that something terrible happened here.
00:08:11 The terrible thing that happened here is that people consented to acts that are inherently degrading.
00:08:17 The woman in this particular case degraded herself.
00:08:20 The men treated her in unbelievably degrading ways.
00:08:22 It's all a bunch of truly scummy behavior, obviously.
00:08:27 But the evidence that this was like a gang rape is, at least the contemporaneous evidence, non existent.
00:08:33 I don't mean like it's scanty.
00:08:35 It's not even scanty, it is non existent.
00:08:35 I'm going to revise that.
00:08:38 According to CBS News, CBS News New York investigative reporter Maza Saidi received new screenshots from a source.
00:08:45 The source says they showed text between the former student identified as Jane Doe and one of the defendants accused of rape in the lawsuit.
00:08:51 The messages were sent just two days after the alleged assault.
00:08:54 The man started by apologizing for how things went down.
00:08:56 He said his memory is kind of fuzzy and that he and another man feel bad for being too intoxicated to shut it down and kick people out before it got way out of hand.
00:09:03 The woman in the text chain replied that her memory is super clouded too and said they had all been heavily intoxicated.
00:09:08 She also wrote, None of the sexual stuff was illegal.
00:09:15 Admission against interest?
00:09:16 Anyone?
00:09:17 None of the sexual stuff was illegal.
00:09:20 She said she liked being with him and another man.
00:09:23 Later, she suggested they smoke together again, but like leave out the extra 5 billion men and ketamine.
00:09:32 That sounds like some terrible decision making and, again, incredibly degrading behavior.
00:09:37 And like everyone had some regrets about the behavior.
00:09:39 Does that sound like illegality?
00:09:41 Quote None of the sexual stuff was illegal.
00:09:46 Rare win, by the way, for Sonny Hostin.
00:09:48 Okay, like this is the only time in human history in which you're going to hear me agree with Sonny Hostin.
00:09:53 So here's Sonny Hostin on The View.
00:09:55 Pointing out that by legal standards, she consented.
00:09:59 She allowed other boys and consented to other boys snorting ketamine off of her body.
00:10:06 And under New York law, voluntary intoxication or drug use that merely impairs judgment does not legally constitute an inability to consent to sexual activity, right?
00:10:16 So that means if you voluntarily ingest drugs, you voluntarily take alcohol, you can agree to have threesomes, which In her statement, she agreed to have two separate threesomes.
00:10:31 One boy did walk in, one young man did walk in and say, everybody out.
00:10:35 So there was one person that did that.
00:10:38 And according to her statement, three of the young men did not touch her.
00:10:43 And so I say all that.
00:10:45 The thing I wonder, Sonny, is what you're saying.
00:10:46 But I say all that to say the pictures of these young men who have not been charged, not been adjudicated, are being plastered all over the internet.
00:10:57 I think people are reporting this story inaccurately.
00:11:00 I think they're reporting it unfairly.
00:11:02 And while this is something that we have to take very seriously, there is no way, according to her statement in 2024, that any prosecutor would have brought the case.
00:11:13 Again, Sonny Hostin happens to be correct.
00:11:16 And by the way, if we're going to redefine intoxicated sex as rape, I don't know where that ends precisely.
00:11:23 Like, truly, I really don't know where that ends.
00:11:25 If you voluntarily have a couple of drinks and then have sex, and this is now considered rape, How do you draw that legal standard?
00:11:33 At what level of legal intoxication?
00:11:35 You have to take a blood test?
00:11:36 How does that work precisely?
00:11:38 And this is all a mess, and it's a mess because no one has the moral language to just condemn bad behavior without trying to buttonhole that into some sort of legal charge.
00:11:47 Okay, speaking of legal issues, the juror, the holdout juror, Michael Desronville, who is the holdout juror in the Lindsey Clancy trial, he did an interview with Fox in which he explained his perspective.
00:12:07 He says, Listen, I don't want to be the center of the story.
00:12:10 I just want the focus put back on the kids who were murdered by Lindsey Clancy.
00:12:15 Here he was.
00:12:15 Again, he sounds like a class act.
00:12:17 Whether you agree with him or disagree with him, I don't see any evidence that this person is some sort of intransigent, evil person, which is how the entire media have attempted to play him.
00:12:26 Hi, my name is Michael Peggy Desronville, also known as the Lone Jour.
00:12:32 I know the whole focus has been on me, but we want to reel everything back and put the focus on the three angels that are at hand the ones that can't speak for themselves, the ones that can't defend themselves, and the ones that can't fight the battles.
00:12:49 And those are Cora, Dawson, and Callan.
00:12:54 This guy is supposed to be a bad guy.
00:12:56 And he was demonized by the attorney for the defense.
00:13:03 And here was Kevin Reddington, who is the attorney for Lindsey Clancy, blaming that juror for having robbed the jury of seven weeks.
00:13:12 I think the biggest misconception is that this individual is referred to as the holdout juror.
00:13:17 He, in fact, is the obstructionist juror.
00:13:20 And every motion that has been filed is legitimate, it's all based on sound law facts.
00:13:27 Jury questions, and I'm doing what I should do representing Lindsay.
00:13:31 Okay, again, the lawyer for Desranville, again, Edward Paltic, he says that Reddington going after the juror is a violation of the Sixth Amendment.
00:13:41 And he is right.
00:13:42 I mean, the fact that Reddington has behaved horribly throughout this entire trial.
00:13:46 I find it richly ironic that after Kevin Reddington outed Michael and stood on the courthouse steps and said, Michael has.
00:13:59 An agenda.
00:14:00 Michael robbed the other jurors.
00:14:02 I find it richly ironic that now all of a sudden he's calling him John Doe after the damage was already done.
00:14:10 And the question now is do we want to have a Constitution?
00:14:13 Do we want to have a Sixth Amendment?
00:14:15 Do we want jurors to feel safe when they show up to perform their civic duty?
00:14:21 Because we're not going to have a criminal justice system if jurors are afraid of reprisals.
00:14:28 And what Kevin Reddington is doing here, he is setting a nightmarish precedent.
00:14:35 And what would happen next time if it's the district attorney that didn't get his way because of a holdout juror?
00:14:43 What are we going to have now?
00:14:44 The prosecution doing this?
00:14:47 Because the tables always turn, things always change.
00:14:50 It's the principle that matters here.
00:14:52 And we're consistent about that.
00:14:55 Kevin Reddington isn't.
00:14:57 Again, whatever you think of the actual verdict here, whatever you think of the actual verdict, the reality is that the treatment of this juror is insane, truly crazy.
00:15:05 As the New York Post points out, Kevin Reddington likely violated the Constitution by revealing Michael P. Desranville's identity and then accusing him of being an obstructionist for not agreeing with others who felt the mom should be cleared for murdering her three young kids she strangled with exercise bans.
00:15:18 Desranville, a devout Catholic and Haitian immigrant, was thrown into the limelight when he was revealed to be the man who defied his 11 co jurors who had concluded Clancy was innocent of killing her three children by reason of insanity.
00:15:30 Now, again, the fact that this has turned into some sort of referendum on the juror. Is truly crazy.
00:15:36 It is wild.
00:15:37 And Reddington is out of his mind.
00:15:38 I mean, Reddington is now arguing renewed motion for required finding not guilty, asking the judge to find the evidence presented at trial was legally insufficient for a rational jury to find Clancy guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.
00:15:51 So, again, that's a long shot.
00:15:52 Basically, he's arguing that there is no possible way a jury could have come up with this verdict.
00:15:59 And then he says, Is there evidence Lindsay killed her kids?
00:16:02 I feel like there is definitely evidence that Lindsay Clancy killed her kids.
00:16:05 I'm pretty sure.
00:16:06 Case further indicates that the evidence must.
00:16:10 Not just be some record evidence.
00:16:14 It has to be reliable and it has to be sufficient that would allow a rational juror to make a determination beyond a reasonable doubt.
00:16:27 Not just that there's some record evidence that touches on each element of the offense.
00:16:33 So I asked the court to hearken back to the evidence that was presented and ask yourself where's the evidence that she did this?
00:16:42 Where is the evidence that she did this?
00:16:46 Where's the evidence that she did it? 0.72
00:16:47 I mean, like that she did it.
00:16:49 That would be the evidence.
00:16:52 But it is amazing how the headline always obscures the actual story.
00:16:55 What an amazing video you just watched.
00:16:57 Wasn't that amazing?
00:16:58 Well, you know, if you think so, head on over to dailywire.comslash subscribe to watch the full show ad free or check out this crazy story here.