Scotland has a new hate crime law that criminalizes stirring up hatred relating to race, age, disability, religion, sexual orientation, gender identity, or being intersex. The Scottish government argues that this does not infringe on freedom of speech, and that it does not contravene Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which protects ideas that offend, shock, or disturb. According to proponents of the law, you have to be really threatening and abusive, and there has to be a reasonable assumption from others that that is the case. The problem is, of course, that all of these terms are discretionary. When you have a law where the terms are so broadly defined that they are basically at the discretion of whomever is in charge of the government, then you really have no protections in terms of rights at all. And here is the problem: it's all discretionary, and the only protection you have is that which is discretionary, which is that it's not written in any statute at all, it's discretionary. And that's why you can't complain about it, and you can only complain about something that is actually intended to be abusive or threatening or abusive, unless you actually intend to stir up hatred against someone else. And if you do intend to do so, you're not the target of hatred, are you? You are the target? You're a victim of hatred? And you have nothing to worry about? . Well, if you are a victim, then what do you want to do about it? Is this abusive, threatening or threatening behaviour intended to hurt someone else? or is it intended to make you feel hurt? ? Or is that you want someone else to feel hurt, offended, or disturbed? Or do you just want to be offended by something that you feel offended, disturbed, or offended? Do you want the law to protect you from being offended, offended or disturbed by something you're offended, then this is your right to free speech? Well then you need to do something about it or are you a racist, sexist, homophobic, prejudiced, homophobic or transphobic, anti-racist, or homophobic, etc.? Is that what you should be doing it, or is that really a problem you want it to be protected from the law? This is a question that needs to be dealt with, or should it be handled in a fair and just a matter of course?
00:00:00.000Well, folks, bad ideas that start in Europe eventually end up here in the United States.
00:00:04.000And the latest bad idea in Europe is that hate speech should be criminalized.
00:00:08.000This is something that is being pushed by the European Union.
00:00:11.000It's also been pushed now by Scotland.
00:00:13.000Scotland has a brand new hate crime law, which has come into force, according to the BBC, this brand new hate crime law essentially
00:00:21.000criminalizes, quote, stirring up hatred relating to age, disability, religion,
00:00:26.000sexual orientation, transgender identity, or being intersex. The maximum penalty is a
00:00:30.000prison sentence of seven years. Apparently, you're an offender if you behave in a manner that, quote,
00:00:35.000a reasonable person would consider to be threatening or abusive.
00:00:39.000Now, the claim of the Scottish government is that this does not infringe on free speech
00:00:44.000because, after all, Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights protects, quote,
00:00:49.000ideas that offend, shock, or disturb a According to proponents of the law, quote, you have to be really threatening and really abusive, and there has to be reasonable assumption from others that that is the case.
00:00:58.000The problem, of course, Is that when it comes to things like gender identity, the entire case that is made by advocates is that you simply saying, man is not woman, is in fact not only harassment but deadly harassment.
00:01:10.000That it is a threat, that it is a form of abuse, because that transgender person is going to kill themselves if that person is called by their original sex or their original name.
00:01:21.000This is obviously incredibly dangerous stuff.
00:01:24.000The fact that Scotland has gone forth in this manner is pretty astonishing.
00:01:27.000The current First Minister of Scotland is a person named Humza Yousaf, and here he was explaining the law yesterday.
00:01:36.000The only concern you should have when it comes to the new stirring up of hatred, the new stirring up offences, is if your behaviour is threatening or abusive, and intends to stir up hatred.
00:01:45.000And by the way, even if that is the case, there are some defences, such as the reasonable person defence, and so on and so forth.
00:01:51.000So unless your behaviour is threatening or abusive, and intends to stir up hatred, then you have nothing to worry about in terms of the new offences being created.
00:01:57.000If your behaviour is threatening or abusive, and does intend to stir up hatred against Jews, or Muslims, or disabled people, or gay people, then I think the law should protect those people who are the victims of that potential hatred.
00:02:12.000Okay, the problem is, of course, that all of these are terms of art.
00:02:16.000I mean, go on X for like five minutes and you will be hit with certainly a lot of speech that is quote-unquote abusive, where people are mean to one another.
00:02:24.000And again, the over-sensitivity, the desire for victimhood is so strong these days that obviously anybody could use this law and file a police report.
00:02:35.000When you have a law where the terms are so broadly defined that they are basically at the discretion of whomever is in charge of the government, then you really have no protections in terms of rights at all.
00:02:46.000This is the member of the SNP, which is the Scottish government.
00:02:51.000Describe the act as ambitious, while also insisting it would not necessarily criminalize anything that was not already criminal.
00:02:57.000Asked whether misgendering someone or making a comment about their religion could be a crime, the minister replied, quote, This will be up to Police Scotland.
00:03:04.000If you say something on social media, for example, it would be up to Police Scotland to determine.
00:03:09.000The superintendent of the Association of Scottish Police superintendents, they said there was a potential for huge uplift in complaints about social media posts, of course.
00:03:19.000Now, again, the fact that the Scottish police are now going to have to dedicate an entire team to track down the purveyors of evil social media posts that say that boys are not girls and the like, that demonstrates what a violation of free speech this is.
00:03:30.000Now, the person who should probably be most worried would be the First Minister of Scotland, who back in February 2023 was just ripping on white people.
00:04:42.000Almost every trade union in this country headed by people who are white.
00:04:46.000In the Scottish Government, every Director General is white.
00:04:52.000Wow, that seems like a little bit abusive.
00:04:54.000I mean, just saying white over and over because white is apparently a term of derision to the First Minister in Scotland.
00:05:01.000We'll get to more on this in just one moment.
00:05:02.000First, $20 barely gets you anything these days.
00:05:04.000You can't even fill your gas tank or get a burger and fries for less than $20.
00:05:07.000But do you know what $20 will get you?
00:05:09.000From the cell phone company I use, PureTalk, you can get unlimited talk, text, and plenty of 5G data for just $20 a month.
00:05:15.000PureTalk gives you the same quality of service as your current cell phone provider, but for half the cost.
00:05:19.000The average family saves almost $1,000 a year, all with no contracts and no activation fees.
00:05:24.000You can switch to PeerTalk and keep the phone and phone number you currently use, or you can take advantage of their great deals on the latest iPhones and Androids.
00:05:32.000customer service team can help you join PeerTalk in as little as 10 minutes.
00:05:36.000Choose to spend your hard-earned money with a wireless company that shares your values, supports our military and veterans, creates American jobs, and refuses to advertise on those fake news networks.
00:05:45.000So stop spending a ridiculous amount of money on your phone plan.
00:05:47.000Go to puretalk.com slash Shapiro right now.
00:05:48.000My listeners can get an additional 50% off their very first month of coverage.
00:05:55.000Again, start saving money on your phone plan today with people who actually like you.
00:05:58.000Go to puretalk.com slash Shapiro and start saving.
00:06:02.000Well, yesterday, this got hot, not just because the law actually passed in Scotland, but also because J.K.
00:06:07.000Rowling, who is, in fact, Scottish, she issued a fiery condemnation of the law.
00:06:13.000And then she issued a series of social media posts on April Fool's Day in which she labeled a bunch of trans women women and then said, April Fool's.
00:06:20.000Obviously, the people mentioned in the above tweets aren't women at all, but men, every last one of them.
00:06:24.000And then she dared the Scottish government to arrest her.
00:06:27.000She said, freedom of speech and belief are at an end in Scotland if the accurate description of biological sex is deemed criminal.
00:06:32.000I'm currently out of the country, but if what I've written here qualifies as new offense under the terms of the new act, I look forward to being arrested when I return to the birthplace of the Scottish Enlightenment.
00:06:40.000And then she signed off with the hashtag, arrest me.
00:06:44.000The prime minister of the UK, Rishi Sunak, he said, people should not be criminalized for stating simple facts on biology.
00:06:49.000We believe in free speech in this country and conservatives will always protect it.
00:06:53.000A government source told the UK Daily Mail, quote, the SNP is taking Scotland down a very dangerous path with potential for seriously chilling effects on free speech.
00:07:00.000We are clear that biological sex matters and gender critical beliefs are protected in British law, and that will not change while conservatives are in government.
00:07:08.000Hamza Youssef, for his part, says he is very, very proud of the act.
00:07:13.000Now, Rowling was reported to the North Rumbria police last month.
00:07:16.000Of course, Rowling is the author of the Harry Potter series for calling a trans TV broadcaster named India Willoughby a man.
00:07:22.000I love that the Daily Mail has to put that in quotations because obviously it's so crazy to call, you know, a biological man a man.
00:07:28.000Police later said that the complaint did not meet the criminal threshold.
00:07:31.000In her social media post, the author listed 10 high-profile trans people and denied their claims to be women, including double rapist Isla Bryson, 31, who was initially jailed for eight years at a women's prison before being moved to a male prison following a widespread backlash.
00:07:45.000Rowling said in passing the Scottish Hate Crime Act, Scottish lawmakers seem to have placed higher value on the feelings of men performing their idea of femaleness, however misogynistically or opportunistically, than on the rights and freedoms of actual women and girls.
00:07:55.000The new legislation is wide open to abuse by activists who wish to silence those of us speaking out about the dangers of eliminating women's and girls' single-sex spaces.
00:08:03.000The nonsense made of crime data, if violent and sexual assaults committed by men are recorded as female crimes, the grotesque unfairness of allowing males to compete in female sports, the injustice of women's jobs, honors, and opportunities being taken by trans-identified men, and the reality and immutability of biological sex.
00:08:18.000Rowling writes, for several years now, Scottish women have been pressured by the government and members of the police force to deny the evidence of their eyes and ears, repudiate biological facts, and embrace a neo-religious concept of gender that is unprovable and untestable.
00:08:30.000The redefinition of woman, to include every man who declares himself one, has already had serious consequences for women's and girls' rights and safety in Scotland, with the strongest impact felt as ever by the most vulnerable, including female prisoners and rape survivors.
00:08:43.000She concluded, It is impossible to accurately describe or tackle the
00:08:46.000reality of violence and sexual violence committed against women and girls,
00:08:48.000or address the current assault on women's and girls' rights unless we are allowed to call a man a man.
00:08:55.000Rowling, who is using her extraordinary power in order to stump for truth.
00:09:00.000Now, why should we be worried about this sort of stuff coming across the water to the United States?
00:09:05.000I mean, after all, we have a First Amendment, don't we?
00:09:06.000Well, the answer is that if, in fact, there were a left-wing majority on the Supreme Court, there is very little doubt that, quote-unquote, anti-discrimination law, which applies in a wide variety of jurisdictions across the United States, would, in fact, be applied to crack down on free speech.
00:09:22.000That it would not, in fact, be considered free speech to engage in quote-unquote discrimination in a place of business, for example.
00:09:28.000And by discrimination, that might mean that you said that a man was a man.
00:09:33.000That would be verboten under anti-discrimination law in places like New York and California.
00:09:38.000And again, the Supreme Court right now has a majority of conservatives on it.
00:09:42.000But, if there were in fact an activist Supreme Court left-wing majority, they would undoubtedly curb the First Amendment so as to mirror the law in places not only like Scotland, but also in places like Canada.
00:09:54.000The entire West has decided that the First Amendment that frees speech principles Not only are in play, but absolutely should be thrown out in favor of the sensitivities of quote-unquote victimized groups.
00:10:08.000Now all of this is the wages of a new paganism, of a new pagan ideology that has decided that basic Western values like free speech and freedom of religion, like property rights, all these things the West has been characterized by for centuries at this point, that all of those things are inherently bad and inherently discriminatory.
00:10:27.000And that pagan ideology has gained root.
00:10:30.000Well, it's gained root because all of this, free speech, freedom of religion, all of these things are rooted originally in Judeo-Christian values.
00:10:40.000The idea of freedom of religion is rooted in the Peace of Westphalia, which again arose from conflict between Protestants and Christians during the Thirty Years' War.
00:10:49.000The idea of freedom of speech is an enlightenment concept that relies on the idea of freedom of mind.
00:10:55.000And that freedom of mind is reliant on a notion that we have as human beings, a core obligation to seek a higher truth.
00:11:02.000And that core obligation to seek a higher truth requires us to have discussions with one another, to investigate and to pursue.
00:11:11.000All of these things are outgrowths of Judeo-Christianity.
00:11:15.000The author, Tom Holland, wrote a book called Dominion.
00:11:18.000He's pointed out that pretty much everything in the West is an outgrowth, uniquely, of Christian ideals.
00:11:24.000Well, the problem is that the West has cut itself off from the roots of its own ideology.
00:11:29.000There's a philosopher named Will Herberg, who was writing about Judaism, but this certainly applies to Christianity.
00:11:36.000What he wrote is quote the moral principles of Western civilization are in fact all derived from the tradition rooted in scripture and a vital meaning only in the context of that tradition.
00:11:45.000The attempt made in recent decades by secularist thinkers to disengage these values from their religious context in the assurance that they could live a life of their own as a quote unquote humanistic ethic as resulted in what one writer has called our cut flower culture.
00:11:58.000Cut flowers retain their original beauty and fragrance, but only so long as they retain the vitality that they've drawn from their now-severed roots.
00:12:03.000After that is exhausted, they wither and die.
00:12:05.000So, with freedom, brotherhood, justice, and personal dignity, the values that form the moral foundation of our civilization.
00:12:11.000Without the life-giving power of the faith out of which they've sprung, they possess neither meaning nor vitality.
00:12:15.000Morality ungrounded in God is indeed a house built upon sin, unable to stand up against the vagaries of impulse and the brutal pressures of power and self-interest.
00:12:24.000We live in a cut flower culture, as Herberg put it.
00:12:27.000We live in a culture that is living off of the exhaust, off of the fumes that are left in the tank from millennia of Christian civilization and before that, Judaic civilization.
00:12:41.000As we have cut ourselves off from those roots, we are flowers that are still in the vase, but they are withering and they are withering quite quickly.
00:12:48.000We'll get to more on this in just a moment.
00:13:47.000One of the people who's now acknowledging this is Richard Dawkins.
00:13:50.000Richard Dawkins has for a very long time been the most famous atheist on planet Earth.
00:13:53.000Obviously, he's written extensively about why Christianity and Judaism and Islam and all religions are wrong.
00:14:00.000He's written about the so-called God delusion, this idea that a belief in a higher power is in fact a delusion, but he simultaneously called himself a cultural Christian.
00:14:08.000So here he was on LBC talking about his views of cultural Christianity.
00:14:16.000Well, I must say I was slightly horrified to hear that Ramadan is being promoted instead.
00:14:20.000I do think that we are culturally a Christian country.
00:14:28.000But there's a distinction between being a believing Christian and being a cultural Christian.
00:14:32.000And so, you know, I love hymns and Christmas carols and I sort of feel at home in the Christian ethos.
00:14:41.000I feel that we are a Christian country in that sense.
00:14:45.000It's true that statistically the number of people who actually believe in Christianity is going down, and I'm happy with that.
00:14:54.000But I would not be happy if, for example, we lost all our cathedrals and our beautiful parish churches.
00:15:02.000So I count myself a cultural Christian.
00:15:04.000I think it would matter, certainly if we substituted any alternative religion, that would be truly dreadful.
00:15:13.000Okay, but we have substituted an alternative religion, and that religion is paganism, because the reality is that when you cut off a civilization from its Judeo-Christian roots, what you end up with is a paganistic replacement for that religion.
00:15:24.000Humanism devolves into paganism pretty quickly, because all of the central premises of humanism, things like reliance on human reason, Make an argument for human reason as an independent force.
00:15:34.000You cannot from an evolutionarily biological perspective.
00:15:52.000You can't make the case for higher concepts like justice or freedom.
00:15:56.000If you are operating from a non-God based universe, You might be able to live that way individually.
00:16:02.000You can be like Richard Dawkins and be an atheist and be a cultural Christian.
00:16:06.000But you cannot separate the church building that he is praising there off from what goes on inside the church.
00:16:13.000The church building is an outward manifestation of the soul that is the church.
00:16:19.000The same thing is true of our civilization.
00:16:21.000Our civilization is built in a particular way on particular Frameworks and foundations.
00:16:26.000And when you destroy those foundations and frameworks, what you end up with is secularist pursuit of values that ends up undermining itself and eating itself.
00:16:36.000The reason that postmodernism is a natural outgrowth is because it is a natural decay.
00:16:41.000You go from a thriving civilization, an Enlightenment civilization that was in fact rooted in Judeo-Christian values.
00:16:47.000This is why, for example, when it comes to capitalism, Adam Smith wrote Theory of Moral Sentiments before he wrote Wealth of Nations.
00:16:53.000Theory of Moral Sentiments is an entire book about virtue, A necessity thereof.
00:16:58.000And then he wrote Wealth of Nations, which was predicated on the idea that when you have a civilization that does in fact promote virtue, capitalism can thrive.
00:17:05.000The same thing is true of things like free speech.
00:17:07.000These all exist on deeper foundations.
00:17:09.000Those deeper foundations are religious in nature.
00:17:11.000Trying to separate those off, pretending that they are the natural state of the world, is historically ignorant.
00:17:18.000The Enlightenment rests on Christian bases.
00:17:21.000Pretending that it does not means that you end up severing the two and an enlightenment severed from its Christian bases ends in terror.
00:17:28.000It actually ends in gulags and death camps.
00:17:31.000This is the point that Nietzsche was making near the end of the 19th century.
00:17:35.000He was making the case that when you kill God, you don't in fact end up with a higher secular humanism.
00:17:40.000You end up with a pagan pursuit of power.
00:17:44.000You end up with the pursuit of the ubermensch because you live in a cold, Meaningless universe in which will is the only thing that matters.
00:18:17.000Those ideas are natural outgrowths of severing natural law.
00:18:22.000That's a natural outgrowth of suggesting that the universe is in fact not ruled by a creator who created a human nature and that that human nature has natural consequences like property rights or should have those natural consequences.
00:18:36.000That the freedom of the mind that is guaranteed by Genesis 1.27 where it says we're all made in the image of God meaning that we are creative and capable of will.
00:18:44.000And when you cut that off, you end up with everything is just power dynamics and power relations.
00:18:49.000As a civilization, you cut yourself off from your roots, and what you end up with is Scotland passing laws suggesting that you cannot speak freely on matters of whether a man is a woman or not.
00:18:59.000And whoever is in power gets to cudgel the other side.
00:19:24.000That our civilization rests on Christian foundations.
00:19:27.000And the answer is, yes, of course he is right about that.
00:19:30.000The second question we should ask is, then why are we destroying those Christian foundations?
00:19:36.000If the church building exists, but there's nobody inside, how long do you expect the civilization to thrive?
00:19:42.000If the civilization built on the Bible discards the Bible, how long do you expect that civilization to continue along the lines it has previously continued?
00:19:53.000And the argument by Dawkins and other atheists presumably will be, yes, but all that's untrue.
00:19:58.000Those would be necessary myths, but they're necessary myths, but they're myths.
00:20:03.000So first of all, I would ask, how are you defining truth?
00:20:06.000Because according to, again, folks like Richard Dawkins, and again, I like a lot of Richard Dawkins' work, it's really interesting, but according to folks like Richard Dawkins, when he says, we can't believe the Bible because it's not true, My question is, what in evolutionary biology suggests that truth is of any paramount value?
00:20:22.000If, in fact, he's a specialist in adaptation and the necessity of adaptation, then he should be a believer in the Bible simply on the adaptability basis of it.
00:20:33.000He should be a Christian because it is useful to be a Christian.
00:21:31.000The guys with that catchy jingle, you know, 1-877-CARS-FOR-KIDS.
00:21:35.000If you're tired of looking at that old car in your driveway or hearing your spouse complain about it, why not let Cars4Kids take care of it for you?
00:21:46.000The whole process only takes two minutes.
00:21:47.000Cars4Kids will schedule a pickup at a time that's convenient for you.
00:21:50.000If you don't have a car, you can still help.
00:21:52.000Cars4Kids accepts non-cash donations of school supplies, clothing, sports equipment, and more The hell of items that's just sitting in the closet of the garage collecting dust.
00:21:59.000Donate it today, make a better tomorrow for a kid in need.
00:22:02.000Call now or visit cars4kids.org slash ben to get that ball rolling.
00:22:06.000That's cars with a K, the number four, cars4kids.org slash ben.
00:22:12.000Number two, why exactly shouldn't it be true?
00:22:16.000If it has proved, if it has proved that Western civilization is in fact the highest form of civilization that man has experienced, And it is rooted in Christian and Judaic values.
00:22:38.000And maybe it seems that while people like Richard Dawkins can individually reject the premises of the Bible while accepting the conclusions, maybe it turns out that the vast majority of the population cannot and should not.
00:22:50.000Maybe it turns out that we need more Christians going to church, and we need more Jews going to synagogue.
00:22:55.000Maybe that's actually really important with civilization.
00:22:57.000Otherwise, you end up in the muck that we currently find ourselves.
00:23:01.000What I would say to Richard Dawkins is, if you like the Christmas carols, someone needs to believe in Christ to sing them.
00:23:06.000If you like the churches, somebody has to go to church to actually maintain the church.
00:23:11.000If you like the civilization in which you live, somebody's got to maintain those biblical roots.
00:23:15.000Somebody's got to go to the garden and cultivate and guard it.
00:23:20.000And when you don't, what you end up with is the American White House.
00:23:22.000So the Biden White House obviously spent the weekend suggesting that Easter was of secondary importance.
00:23:27.000Trans Day of Visibility was, of course, of primary importance.
00:23:31.000Pretty much all the members of the cabinet spoke on this, including the Secretary of Education.
00:23:34.000It's very important that our Secretary of Education here in the United States speak to young Americans while wearing a Pride Progress flag pin.
00:23:41.000It is amazing how quickly All of the left-wing progressive memes make themselves absolute necessities in the Democratic Party.
00:23:54.000And then, like two years ago, they started promoting the Pride Progress flag, which is this ugly triangle coming in, and it only had the trans colors.
00:24:02.000And then George Floyd died, and then they added the brown and the black.
00:24:06.000Well now, by the way, there is a second triangle that's coming in from the other side.
00:24:10.000So a flanking maneuver by various intersectional identity groups.
00:24:14.000Pretty soon the rainbow is going to be completely crowded out.
00:24:16.000But celebrating Trans Day of Visibility was our Secretary of Education, while speaking
00:24:20.000to small children, he's wearing this Pride Progress flag pin instead of an American flag
00:24:43.000We also know it's not an easy time to be you.
00:24:47.000Today, we at the Department of Education want you to know that your school, your community, and your country are better because you're a part of it.
00:25:20.000On this Transgender Day of Visibility, we must continue To make focused and ongoing efforts to end inequities, eliminate the impacts of injustice, and improve access to care for everyone.
00:25:34.000Today, of all days, I stand proud and visible with my fellow transgender Americans.
00:25:56.000Here's Corrine Jean-Pierre, however, denying that Trans Day of Visibility had been purposefully timed for Easter.
00:26:03.000I do want to say a couple of things because I think it's important here.
00:26:06.000As you just stated in your questions, what we've been hearing out there, a lot of misinformation done on purpose.
00:26:13.000And as a Christian who celebrates Easter with family, President Biden stands for bringing people together and upholding the dignity and freedoms of every American.
00:26:24.000Now, sadly, and it's not surprising, right?
00:26:26.000It is actually unsurprising that politicians are seeking to divide and weaken our country with cruel, hateful and dishonest rhetoric.
00:26:34.000It is dishonest what we have heard the past 24 hours.
00:26:37.000It is untrue what we heard over the weekend.
00:26:58.000Okay, just for the record, Trans Day of Visibility was invented by, again, people with a particular agenda in 2009.
00:27:07.000In 2009, the White House did not memorialize Trans Day of Visibility until Joe Biden was President of the United States.
00:27:14.000So it's like four years old, according to the White House.
00:27:18.000The very first proclamation about Trans Day of Visibility was 2021.
00:27:20.000So you're telling me that Easter, which has been around for, I don't know, a couple thousand years, Trans Day of Visibility could not be, it could not be moved on the calendar.
00:27:29.000It was just too vital that it be on Easter.
00:27:32.000By the way, I will point out that the White House held the Easter egg roll on Monday.
00:27:44.000March 31st is the day it's going to happen.
00:27:47.000It's really important it happen that day.
00:27:51.000The reality is again, a substitute value system has now been put before the American people and before the West, and that substitute value system is a complete replacement of the Christian value system that predominated in the West for thousands of years, even in the post-Christian era.
00:28:07.000That post-Christian system was based on the values of Christianity.
00:28:11.000And to pretend otherwise is to ignore all of Western history.
00:28:17.000First, Grand Canyon University is a private Christian university in beautiful Phoenix, Arizona.
00:28:21.000GCU believes our creator has endowed us with certain unalienable rights.
00:28:25.000Life, liberty, the pursuit of happiness.
00:28:26.000GCU equips you to serve others in ways that promote your flourishing, creating a ripple effect of transformation for generations to come.
00:28:32.000Whether you're pursuing a bachelor's, master's, or doctoral degree, Grand Canyon University's online, on-campus, and hybrid learning environments are designed to help you achieve your degree.
00:28:40.000GCU has over 330 academic programs as of September 2023.
00:28:45.000Find your purpose today at Grand Canyon University.
00:28:52.000Okay, meanwhile, a couple of big updates from the situation in Israel.
00:28:57.000So update number one, which actually is the biggest news in the region.
00:29:01.000Iran's top commander in Syria was killed in an airstrike by Israel.
00:29:04.000So Iran's Revolutionary Guard Corps has been fomenting terror all over the region.
00:29:09.000Iran has terror proxies in Lebanon, in Syria, in Gaza, in the West Bank.
00:29:15.000In Yemen, in Iraq, and they've been activating every single one of these terror proxies against various Israeli targets.
00:29:22.000And in particular, there is a Syrian nexus in which weapons are shipped from Iran through Syria and into Lebanon, or down to Gaza, or into the West Bank.
00:29:31.000And so, Israel, on Monday, carried out an airstrike on a building next to Iran's embassy in Damascus, and it killed seven members of Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, including the top Iranian commander in Syria.
00:29:43.000This would be the new equivalent of Qasem Soleimani, who is the top commander of the terror wing of the Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps, who was killed by airstrike by the Trump administration.
00:29:53.000Apparently, the strike in the Damascus area municipality of Mezzeh hit a building that was adjacent to an Iranian embassy, according to the footage.
00:30:01.000This, of course, was a very significant strike.
00:30:03.000It basically decapitates the top levels of the IRGC.
00:30:08.000Other officers killed included other top officers at the IRGC.
00:30:13.000Iran, of course, is mouthing off, suggesting that they're now going to escalate.
00:30:16.000But the reality is that Iran has been activating its proxies all over the region, of course, harassing shipping in the Red Sea, such that most shipping is now avoiding the Red Sea entirely, adding to your costs at the grocery store.
00:30:26.000They've been activating Hezbollah to fire anti-tank missiles into Israel literally every night, killing Israelis and keeping some 60,000 Israelis from their homes in the north of Israel.
00:30:36.000As the editorial board of the Wall Street Journal pointed out, Iran paid the first real price Monday for its proxy warfare in the Middle East after Israel killed the leading Iranians, sowing chaos in the region.
00:30:44.000The most significant assassination since Soleimani is how the missile strike in Damascus is being reported in Israel.
00:30:50.000Monday's strike killed General Mohammad Reza Zahedi, Iran's top Quds Force commander in Lebanon and Syria, as well as his deputy commander and his chief of general staff.
00:30:57.000They were also meeting with the Palestinian Islamic Jihad, which is one of the three governing groups in the West Bank.
00:31:03.000Where the United States keeps pushing for a Palestinian state.
00:31:06.000And the United States is funding both sides in this war right now, so your taxpayer dollars at work.
00:31:12.000As regional chief of the Quds Force, the Wall Street Journal points out, Zahedi was point man in Iran's war on Israel.
00:31:16.000He was the boss of Hezbollah, the Iranian proxy that has fired more than 3,500 rockets unprovoked on Israel's north since October 7th.
00:31:23.000The attack was carried out with precision on a building next to Iran's embassy.
00:31:28.000Monday's strike is in contrast to the U.S.
00:31:29.000response after Iranian proxies killed three Americans near the Syrian border in January.
00:31:33.000The Biden administration leaked news of its retaliation in advance, giving Iranian commanders in Syria time enough to get out of the way.
00:31:40.000Israel instead decided that they were going to actually decapitate the Iranian Revolutionary Guard terror regime.
00:31:45.000So, good, obviously, for the Israelis.
00:31:49.000That is not receiving nearly the amount of coverage this morning as a horrific circumstance in which the Israeli Defense Forces apparently accidentally struck and killed a World Central Kitchen truck that was attempting to facilitate aid into the Gaza Strip.
00:32:02.000The group is called World Central Kitchen, and it is headed by a celebrity chef named Jose Andres.
00:32:09.000And they've been working with the Israeli government, with their facilitation of the Israeli government, to ship aid into the Gaza Strip.
00:32:15.000Apparently, a targeted Israeli strike accidentally killed Australian, British, Palestinian, Polish, and U.S.
00:32:23.000The Israeli military, unlike every other country in the region where something deeply terrible happens and no investigation takes place because that's actually the intent, Israel is launching a full-scale investigation into this particular incident.
00:32:37.000WCK has been working to unload food brought to Gaza by sea from Cyprus.
00:32:42.000The White House was, quote, heartbroken, according to U.S.
00:32:44.000National Security Council spokesperson Adrian Watson, stressing relief workers must be protected as they deliver aid that is desperately needed.
00:32:51.000Obviously, this is a friendly fire incident.
00:32:54.000Unfortunately, that sort of incident is really common in wartime.
00:32:58.000About a fifth of all Israeli soldiers who have been killed in Gaza have been killed in friendly fire incidents.
00:33:02.000The most famous incident thereof was the killing of three Israeli hostages who were held by Hamas, and then Israel accidentally killed its own hostages in a friendly fire incident.
00:33:12.000The IDF spokesperson, Admiral Daniel Hagari, said in an English-language video,
00:33:17.000quote, we've been reviewing the incident at the highest levels to understand the circumstances
00:33:19.000of what happened and how it happened. For the last few months, the IDF has been working closely with
00:33:23.000the World Central Kitchen to assist them in fulfilling their noble mission of helping bring
00:33:27.000food and humanitarian aid to the people of Gaza. The work of WCK is critical. They are on the
00:33:30.000front lines of humanity. He promised that we will get to the bottom of this and we will share our
00:33:34.000findings transparently. The IDF said the strike was a serious incident that never should have
00:33:40.000have happened and there will be a probe and they will release all the facts.
00:33:42.000Again, demonstrating once again, this is how democracies handle their problems.
00:33:45.000They air them in public and they do full-scale investigations.
00:33:49.000Nonetheless, this is being used as a rationale for now promoting a ceasefire against Hamas, which is weird since Hamas would kill aid workers without any sort of investigation.
00:33:58.000They've been killing aid workers for legitimately months at this point.
00:34:02.000A lot of focus being put on the fact that there was an American citizen among the killed and that is horrific and terrible.
00:34:07.000Also, there are currently American citizens who are being held by Hamas in terror tunnels right now.
00:34:11.000You don't know their names because the media don't care about that and they don't cover it.
00:34:15.000So this terrible incident will undoubtedly be spun as sort of case number one for why Israel is bad, despite the fact that, again, it was number one, an accident by all available information, and two, Israel will do a full investigation into it.
00:34:28.000Meanwhile, Hamas will continue to hold Americans in terror tunnels on purpose and pursue the murder of aid workers on purpose, and the rest of the world will declare that there must be a ceasefire against Hamas.
00:34:39.000The media coverage of these sorts of situations is always incredibly ugly and it's pretty obvious exactly what the media are attempting to do with that sort of coverage.
00:35:39.000Meanwhile, the other big piece of news from Israel is that Israel has now passed a law barring the distribution of Al Jazeera in Israel.
00:35:46.000Al Jazeera is, of course, the Qatari-funded propaganda network on behalf of terror regimes all around the world, including Hamas.
00:35:52.000They have promoted pretty much every myth promoted by Hamas since the beginning of the war.
00:35:56.000Many of the Al Jazeera quote-unquote reporters were canning glove with Hamas in the Gaza Strip.
00:36:00.000The Knesset in Israel approved on Monday the so-called Al Jazeera law, which gave the government temporary powers to prevent foreign news networks from operating in Israel if they're deemed by the security services To be harming national security, this sort of stuff is fairly common across the world during times of war.
00:36:13.000During World War II, der Sturmer was not distributed inside the United States, to the best of my knowledge, because, again, foreign propaganda that is being run by actual enemies of whatever is the administration in power, not just the administration, the entire country.
00:36:27.000Those sorts of things happen fairly regularly during wartime.
00:36:32.000The United States is expressing concern over the legislation.
00:36:34.000White House Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre had comment, of course.
00:36:38.000So as it relates to and I think you're speaking specifically at least the reports that we've seen is about Al Jazeera specifically but it doesn't matter whichever right journalist more broadly but to those particular report we've seen the reports and certainly I'm going to refer to Israel for what they may or may not be considering but If it is true, if it is true, a move like this is concerning.
00:37:04.000We believe in the freedom of the press.
00:37:07.000It is critically important, and the United States supports the critically important work journalists around the world do.
00:37:14.000And that includes those who are reporting in the conflict in Gaza.
00:37:19.000So we believe that work is important, the freedom of the press is important, and if those reports are true, it is concerning to us.
00:37:27.000Okay, there's only one problem, which of course is that Al Jazeera operates in the interests of Hamas.
00:37:32.000Former Representative Ileana Ros-Lettinen has explained in a report prepared for Congress that the network, quote, repeatedly undermines U.S.
00:37:37.000interests in the region by supporting extremist groups like the Muslim Brotherhood, Hamas, Al-Qaeda, and the Al-Nusra Front.
00:37:42.000Moreover, Qatar uses its state-owned, state-funded, state-directed, state-controlled Al Jazeera media network to project this vision to the United States public.
00:37:49.000Al Jazeera has effectively acted as a mouthpiece for Hamas.
00:37:53.000In a report for Memory, the Middle Eastern Research Institute, since October 7th, Al Jazeera has been airing official military announcements and threats by Hamas spokespeople, as well as by other terror organizations on an almost daily basis.
00:38:06.000They've made false allegations about rape, for example, at Shifa Hospital, which they then had to back off.
00:38:12.000I noticed that Karine Jean-Pierre does not have anything like this to say about Ukraine, where Vladimir Zelensky has shut down many opposing media outlets in the middle of a war.
00:38:22.000Again, the disparate treatment is rather fascinating.
00:38:25.000The reason, of course, is because the Democrats are very scared of their left flank.
00:38:29.000They are scared of people like Pramila Jayapal, the progressive nutjob from Washington State, who is suggesting that the crisis in Gaza is, quote-unquote, breaking their coalition.
00:38:36.000Which, again, is strange, because the United States really is not involved very much in what is going on over there, other than continuing aid to an American Democratic ally against a terror group.
00:38:47.000This particular issue on Gaza is breaking our coalition.
00:38:53.000We need that fragile coalition to come back together.
00:38:57.000But this is a moral issue for people, and so there's not a lot of time to fix it.
00:39:01.000The worse it gets in Gaza, the harder it gets to bring people back in.
00:39:07.000Okay, well, I mean, it's really not that Biden's going to lose the progressives.
00:39:10.000They're all going to vote for him against Donald Trump.
00:39:11.000The real problem, of course, is that he's going to lose the moderates, but his math is all bollocksed up.
00:39:16.000Meanwhile, speaking of Ukraine, according to the New York Times, Speaker Mike Johnson has begun publicly laying out potential conditions for extending a fresh round of American military assistance to Ukraine.
00:39:25.000The strongest indication yet that he plans to push through the House of Package, many Republicans view as toxic and have tried to block.
00:39:30.000His terms may include tying the aid for Kiev to a measure that would force Biden to reverse a moratorium on new permits for liquefied natural gas export facilities, something the Republicans would see as a political victory against the Democratic president's climate change agenda.
00:39:44.000Johnson said Sunday in an interview on Fox News, when we return after this work period, we'll be moving a product, but it's going to have some important innovations.
00:39:50.000Apparently, one of the possibilities is to push the aid to Ukraine as a loan.
00:39:56.000Now, the reality is that Johnson is stuck between a rock and a hard place with his own caucus.
00:40:00.000Because there's obviously a hard core of people inside the Republican caucus, maybe 10 to 15 Republicans at most, who are unwilling to facilitate any aid to Ukraine, who apparently are perfectly willing to watch Russia march into Kiev.
00:40:12.000Which is a strange take if you believe that America's interests are paramount in the world.
00:40:17.000If you believe America first, and I do believe that American interests come first, I don't see how it's quite in America's interest to allow Russia to march directly into Kiev thanks to shortage of weaponry in Ukraine.
00:40:27.000That does not seem to make a lot of sense to me on a sort of realpolitik level, putting aside all of the rhetoric.
00:40:33.000Nonetheless, Johnson has a problem on his hands because the Republican majority is very narrow and because Kevin McCarthy, in order to become Speaker, instituted a set of rules whereby one member of the House Republican caucus can challenge the Speaker and then effectively force a vote of no confidence on the Speaker of the House.
00:40:52.000It essentially allows a group of 10 Republicans to overrule the other 205, 210 Republicans who are in the House.
00:41:00.000It's really stupid and it needs to stop.
00:41:03.000The reality is that the process of legislation is a job of sausage making.
00:41:08.000And the sausage gets made in really ugly ways.
00:41:11.000But the job of the legislator is to make the sausage.
00:41:14.000The job of the legislature is, in fact, to make the best of a bad situation.
00:41:18.000It's always choices between bad alternative policies.
00:41:22.000And when you see people posturing on your television, members of Congress posturing on your television, with a purist position on the issues, we should recognize at this point that the Republicans don't even control two branches of the elected government.
00:41:52.000I do not understand the case being made that somehow Russia is the positive force in this vision of what happens to Ukraine next.
00:42:01.000Vladimir Putin is in fact a murderous dictator who has anti-American intentions that he is spreading all across the globe ranging from the Middle East to Africa to in fact Central Eastern Europe.
00:42:11.000The real politic case for Vladimir Putin's victory in Ukraine has never been made.
00:42:14.000There have been a lot of critiques of the Ukrainians.
00:42:19.000But none of that explains exactly why it would be in America's interest to watch Ukraine completely collapse and watch Vladimir Putin win the war.
00:42:27.000The fact that this is even a going theory in the Republican Party is somewhat strange to me because, again, I don't, like, if someone can explain the logic, I'd be perfectly willing to hear it.
00:42:36.000I've heard a lot of propagandistic talking points that make no actual sense.
00:42:40.000We'll get some more on this in just a moment.
00:42:42.000First, do you know what the real March madness is?
00:42:44.000It's the struggle to find quality, affordable American meat at the grocery store, which is why my team has all of their meat delivered from Good Ranchers.
00:42:50.000As the number one American meat delivery service in the United States, Good Ranchers brings 100% American beef, chicken, pork, and wild-caught seafood right to your door, relieving you from grocery store chaos and parking nightmares.
00:43:01.000When you go to the store, you end up parking a mile away, getting a cart with only one non-squeaky wheel, and then settling for that low-quality, overpriced cut in styrofoam packages.
00:43:10.000Stop the meat madness with GoodRanchers.com.
00:43:12.000You can be confident in the quality and affordability of every single cut.
00:43:15.000Right now, Good Ranchers is offering you free jumbo chicken wings for a year with any subscription.
00:43:20.000Make delicious dinners, game time favorites, grill out staples with two pounds of free wings included in every box when you subscribe.
00:43:26.000Every piece of their chicken comes from an NAE program that guarantees it's never been given antibiotics or added hormones.
00:43:32.000Claim your $150 value of free wings plus that additional $20 off with Code Shapiro at GoodRanchers.com today.
00:43:44.000Meanwhile, things are getting hot about abortion in Florida, according to the Wall Street Journal.
00:43:49.000The Florida Supreme Court ruled on Monday that the state's ban on abortion after six weeks of pregnancy can, in fact, be implemented.
00:43:54.000The justice also cleared the way for voters to expand the right to abortion in November.
00:43:58.000That, of course, is going to be a hotly fought issue, even in the state of Florida, because the state of Florida moved from the Roe vs. Wade standard, which was effectively abortion on demand until late term, up to six weeks, which is a pretty hefty move.
00:44:13.000The state of Florida is very conservative, but that isn't to say that conservative states haven't taken the wrong position on this before.
00:44:17.000Obviously, we've seen the state of Kansas, which is a very conservative state, take the full pro-abortion position as opposed to things like a heartbeat bill.
00:44:25.000In a 4-3 decision, the court approved the language for a ballot measure that would protect abortion access in the state through fetal viability or more than halfway through a typical pregnancy.
00:44:34.000If passed, the measure would effectively restore Roe v. Wade.
00:44:37.000In a 6-1 decision, the court also ruled that a privacy provision of the state's constitution does not protect access to abortion.
00:44:43.000Currently, abortion in Florida was legal through 15 weeks of pregnancy after Roe v. Wade was overturned, and then it was moved back to six weeks.
00:44:51.000I'm sure the Democrats in the state of Florida are very excited about this fight because Democrats, of course, have been running on the abortion issue since the overturning of Roe vs. Wade.
00:44:59.000The Florida Supreme Court justices ruled the meaning of the abortion ballot measure was sufficiently clear.
00:45:04.000The measure allows health care providers to determine whether a fetus is considered viable.
00:45:20.000It'll be a really interesting political example of how much abortion can damage Republicans if Democrats are able to not only win that referendum, but also then win additional seats in the legislature or do better than expected in the next gubernatorial race on the basis of policies like that.
00:45:36.000It'll be good evidence for one position or the other when it comes to abortion in red states like Florida.
00:45:43.000Whether, in fact, pro-lifers should be taking a more gradualist and incrementalist approach to protecting life in order to ensure the future viability of such legislation.
00:45:52.000Meaning, if you push it from 15 to 12, and then two years from now you push it from 12 to 10, and then two years from then you push it from 10 to 8, is that going to be better than simply pushing from 15 to 6?
00:46:12.000At the same time, if the legislation ends up backfiring and leading to a full-scale legalization of abortion in the state of Florida, for example, Many more unborn kids will die because of that than would have been the case if you took a more gradualist approach.
00:46:26.000So it'll be fascinating to see, again, what the politics are in a deep-red state like Florida.
00:46:30.000If history is any indicator, the abortion issue has not gone Republicans' way in Michigan.
00:46:34.000It has not gone Republicans' way in Kansas.
00:46:37.000So this will be a fascinating test case.
00:46:41.000In what is the most delightful entertainment story of the day, Shakira, remember Shakira?
00:46:46.000She's the hips don't lie lady, correct?
00:46:47.000Okay, so, uh, Shakira apparently did an interview with Allure magazine and shared her less than glowing take on Barbie.
00:46:56.000She said, quote, my sons absolutely hated it, referring to her sons who are 11 and 9.
00:47:00.000She said they felt it was emasculating and I agreed to a certain extent.
00:47:04.000She said, I like pop culture when it attempts to empower women without robbing men of their possibility to be men, to also protect and provide.
00:47:11.000I believe in giving women all the tools and the trust that we can do it all without losing our essence, without losing our femininity.
00:47:16.000I think men have a purpose in society and women have another purpose as well.
00:47:35.000I feel like maybe her sons watched a particular 43-minute critique of the Barbie movie in which many Barbie dolls were burned right at the beginning.
00:47:46.000But enjoying the fact that Shakira is now receiving massive blowback, it's good to know that it wasn't just me.
00:47:52.000So Shakira also taking it on the chin for mentioning that Barbie is an emasculating movie that treats men as throwaway things that are completely useless in a civilized society.
00:48:02.000Oliver Stone has also received criticism.
00:48:05.000He criticized Ryan Gosling for not focusing on more serious films, yet Ryan Gosling is wasting his time if he's doing that bleep for money.
00:48:27.000We'll see if Shakira backs off the point.
00:48:28.000But, by the way, Shakira's take on femininity is exactly right.
00:48:32.000Now femininity is something that belongs to women and masculinity is something that belongs to men.
00:48:37.000That doesn't mean that women can't do masculine things or men can't do effeminate things.
00:48:40.000It does mean that men are required in our society and actually it is very good for men to be involved in society for women.
00:48:49.000One of the most hilarious social media phenomena that we've seen lately is a bunch of feminists who are realizing they like it when men pay for dinner.
00:48:57.000Well, yes, of course you like it when men pay for dinner, because it demonstrates willingness to provide, which is an essentially masculine characteristic.
00:49:04.000When you rob men of their duty in life, it turns out that men don't just disappear, they become toxic.
00:49:10.000When you rob men of mission, they redirect those aggressive energies into all the wrong places.
00:49:17.000There's a great book by George Gilder, sort of a philosopher-economist called Men and Marriage, all about this.
00:49:22.000And his suggestion is that basically men are robber thieves who act aggressively until they are civilized by women, and all those aggressive energies are channeled in the direction of building.
00:49:32.000So either men are going to destroy or men are going to build.
00:49:34.000When you shut men out of the building apparatus, particularly in terms of building a family, When you don't channel men's aggressive instincts toward protection of wife and hearth and home, you end up with aggressively very bad men.
00:49:47.000You end up with no men, you end up with really bad men.
00:49:49.000Half population, still gonna end up being men.
00:49:52.000The only question is whether those men are going to be channeling their energies in a positive and good direction or whether they're gonna be following WWE light figures who are boasting about their muscles, shirtless while driving Lamborghinis around and running sex rings.
00:50:31.000It means that it is actually a duty of women to allow men to be men, just as it is a duty of men to allow women to be women, just as it is a fact that it is a form of appropriation for men to pretend to be women and take on all these supposedly female characteristics, and it's a mockery.
00:50:46.000When women do the same with regard to masculinity, that is also bad.
00:50:55.000And the single best articulation of this comes in the book of Genesis.
00:50:58.000When God creates woman, he creates woman and says that she is ezer kenegdo, okay, which is the, that's the language in Hebrew.
00:51:04.000Ezer kenegdo means a helper, kenegdo, against him.
00:51:09.000In other words, men and women are not meant to be perfectly equivalent.
00:51:13.000Men and women are meant to be complementary.
00:51:15.000They are meant to bounce off each other.
00:51:16.000They are meant to work in both cooperation and opposition to one another.
00:51:19.000And when you get rid of that dynamic, which is what Barbie seeks to do, the Barbie movie is all about how men and women actually be better off not really living together.
00:51:29.000And Ken shouldn't be dominating Barbie.
00:51:30.000And apparently, according to Greta Gerwig's theory of life, those are the two choices.
00:51:34.000The two choices are effectively either men are marginalized or men are aggressively predominant.
00:51:42.000But the reality is that it's the beauty of the relationship between men and women that creates civilization.
00:51:46.000When you have a civilization like ours, to go back to the theme at the beginning of today's show, a civilization like ours that is built on anti-biblical principles, what you end up with is relationships falling apart, men who act like aggressive bandits, women who are completely unmoored from the thing that makes them women, Which, by the way, does have to do with childbearing and rearing.
00:52:11.000Which is why, again, we have the most prosperous and free society in the history of humanity, and we have extraordinarily high depression rates in the West.