00:00:46We are all supposed to be demoralized and upset.
00:00:49And we're all supposed to believe and claim that no one anymore has any shot at getting ahead in America, that the American dream is dead, that we need something brand new, by which most people mean some idea that was tried centuries ago, four centuries.
00:01:03And then fail like over and over and over.
00:01:05And most of those bad ideas revolve around a very, very basic failed idea that people are addicted to that there ought to be a special cadre of elite people who direct the economy toward their specific ends, that your individual freedoms are actually destructive, that you ought to have your choices circumscribed so that they can build whatever it is they want to build.
00:01:26For Hassan Piker, total economic leveling in poverty.
00:01:30For Zorhan Mamdani, third world ascendancy in American weakness.
00:01:33For Tucker Carlson, an agrarian feudal state.0.95
00:01:35For the Muslim Brotherhood, Dar al Islam.0.79
00:01:37So, today I want to talk about what the American dream actually is and what it actually is not.0.97
00:01:43So, you're constantly hearing the American dream is the house and the white picket fence and the dog and the 2.2 children.
00:01:59That process says that there is a relationship between cause and effect, that you, if you make good, virtuous, smart decisions, if you perform dutiful and smart things throughout your life, You will end up better off than you did.
00:04:11You need to know what a good decision looks like, what a moral decision looks like.
00:04:14Those are all the preconditions for the American dream.
00:04:17And free markets, free minds, equal justice before law, social virtue.
00:04:23Those are the things, those are the preconditions.
00:04:25And when you have that, and then you have a government that protects those things and protects the process, that's when the American dream happens.
00:04:33The process not only protects and promotes freedom, it also happens to have the happy effect of promoting insane, unprecedented human prosperity.
00:04:40Because it turns out the best way for innovation and competition to happen is to access the diverse knowledge and opinions of all humanity, that free people innovate, free people compete, free people are able to access each other's knowledge levels, they're able to aggregate those knowledge levels.
00:04:58And we are much better off that no single human being knows more than the rest of humanity.
00:05:06And that's true when it comes to prioritization as well.
00:05:09Free markets mean that everyone can prioritize what they want on a material level.
00:05:13You get to make your own decisions about what makes your life better.
00:05:17You get to decide whether you wish to trade your labor for X number of dollars or whether you wish to trade X number of dollars for a lottery ticket or for a share of stock, right?
00:06:49There are people who lie to you and they say the process doesn't work.
00:06:52Now, the process doesn't work as well as it should, thanks to the impositions of people like Hassan Piker on the left or Tucker Carlson on the right.
00:07:00Statists inhibit the process, but the process still works and it works really, really well.
00:07:05We'll get some more on this in just one second.
00:07:08First, when it comes to your upward mobility, one thing that people do need is access to capital, right?
00:07:22Cardiff offers business owners up to $500,000 in application that takes less than five minutes with no impact on personal credit and the potential to get approved in minutes and same day funding.
00:07:30If you want bank rates without the bank delays, you need to check out cardiff.co slash Shapiro for up to $500,000 in same day funding.
00:07:47Cardiff has the key that unlocks this problem.
00:07:51If you've been in business for at least a year and are pulling at least $20,000 a month in revenue, apply now for up to $500,000 in same day business funding at cardiff.co slash Shapiro.
00:08:20And what they found, inflation adjusted, is that 93% of kids who grew up in the bottom quintile were better off than their parents were by the time they reached their 30s.
00:09:24It's why it's important for young men to get married, particularly.
00:09:27Because income trajectory goes steeply up.
00:09:30When you're a single dude, you are perfectly happy to live in kind of a crappy apartment with a box for a chair and a futon for a bed and eat ramen every night.
00:09:56But, but, There's a different view of the American dream, and this is the perverse view of the American dream, and it actually destroys the American dream.
00:10:04That different view of the American dream is that the American dream is a set of outcomes, right?
00:10:10That the American dream isn't that if you make good, smart, virtuous decisions, you will live better than your parents did and your kids will live better than you.
00:10:17That actually the American dream is the house with the white picket fence, or two kids and a dog, or a nicotine factory in India.
00:10:25Now, listen, I may want all those things except for the factory, and you might too.
00:10:29But when the government, which is at the end of the day, all the government is, is a big gun pointed at people.
00:10:38And sometimes you need it, but you shouldn't use it that much.
00:10:42When you use that gigantic gun pointed at people, directed at achieving certain ends, not protecting the process, but achieving the ends, you end up actually destroying the process.
00:10:53And by the way, never achieving the ends to boot.
00:11:17This bizarre discussion about the price of burritos.
00:11:19Now, again, I want to start off with a basic, with this sort of basic primer.
00:11:23For those who missed it, Andrew Colvitt, who's one of the guys who helps run TPUSA, put out a tweet where he was saying that some 20 year old was complaining about $20 burritos and this is the problem with America.
00:11:34And As usual, the conversation sort of degraded into the dumbest form of itself because two things can simultaneously be true.
00:11:59And other people saying, guys, there is some virtue to making responsible decisions with your money.
00:12:04And if you're 20 and you're having trouble making the rent, Going out for dinner to buy a $20 burrito is probably not the wisest expenditure of cash.
00:12:11In any case, let's be real about how food inflation works.
00:12:15Free markets create better and cheaper burritos, to use the burrito as an example.
00:12:20Because again, the byproduct of human choice and widely disseminated knowledge and innovation and free competition is better and cheaper burritos.
00:12:31Now, here are some things that do not create better and cheaper burritos tariffs that are meant to protect the American working man.
00:12:37If you increase the price of the inputs, the burrito price goes up.
00:12:41Or let's say lower interest rates that are designed to make credit easier for the American family.
00:15:03And then eventually, it turns out those people can't pay their bills, and then the housing market collapses.
00:15:08And then people stop building because the housing market collapsed.
00:15:11That is the story of the real estate collapse of 2007, 2008, and the subsequent drop off in the building of new units, which is what happened in the aftermath of 2007, 2008.
00:15:20Add on top of that other government policies designed to achieve affordable housing, like, for example, rent control.
00:15:50So it turns out that using the government to achieve the kind of housing that you desire ends up making housing more expensive and less affordable.
00:15:58In other words, when you inhibit the process of the American dream, again, the American dream is very simple free markets, free minds, equal justice before law, social virtue, government's there just to protect those things.
00:16:09When you start using the government to achieve the end, you end up achieving the opposite.
00:16:14This is also, by the way, true for college education, right?
00:16:16People are correctly complaining about college debt.
00:16:21How do you think it happened that so many Americans, a huge percentage of Americans, have gigantic college debt?
00:16:27The answer is we artificially increased demand through government subsidy and we did not do anything about the supply.
00:16:35And in fact, we started supplying crap degrees that are worth nothing to people just because we had this dumb idea that because people who went to college earned more, therefore everyone should go to college and then they will all earn more.0.53
00:20:02If he thought it would achieve his ends, he would call for full scale nationalization of industries with Lord Carlson at the helm, a petty tyrant ruling America from his flannel, all in the name of your spiritual welfare.
00:20:18This is why Tucker constantly does this routine where he says that America is like the post Soviet Russian oligarchy, which, by the way, is kind of hilarious since he loves the post Soviet Russian oligarchy.
00:20:27He goes over there to talk about how wonderful their bread is, how we need feudalism.
00:20:31But again, don't expect any sort of internal consistency from this rather addled human.
00:20:38As I hear your big picture description of this transition through which we're moving, the first thought that comes to mind is boy, that sounds a little bit like what happened after the Soviet Union collapsed in the summer of 1991.
00:20:52And all of a sudden, Russians woke up 10 years later and all state industries were owned by a small group of people.0.97
00:21:12You're experiencing false consciousness put in your head by whomever.
00:21:17Again, in the end, all these people are quite happy for you to be poorer, for you to be less free, so long as they can build whatever utopia they want to build.
00:21:26So, again, on the left, that takes a bunch of forms.
00:21:27For Zorhan Mamdani, it's a third worldist utopia in which America is really brought to heel.
00:21:33For Hassan Piker, it's a complete leveling.0.71
00:21:36For the Muslim Brotherhood and Islamists, It is Dar al Islam, presumably.0.91
00:21:41On the right, this takes the form of what is now called post liberalism.0.96
00:21:45Post liberalism basically argues that individualism, and that includes individualism and free markets, saps us of our virtue.
00:21:52What we actually need is a top down state run by oligarchs so that we can have virtue again.
00:21:57This is a bad idea, and it was tried for many centuries, and it was horrible.
00:22:01It turns out that one of the premises of the American founding is that virtue is a thing that you should pursue in your church and in your community and on an individual level.
00:22:12And that government has a role protecting people from insidious infectious problems.
00:22:35If you are told that you are not in control of your own destiny, that your decisions don't matter, if people keep telling you over and over and over, That you can't do anything about your life, but you deserve everything.
00:24:41The worst thing about it is not just its inattention to the fortunes of actual Americans, it's hostility, it's hatred of Americans.
00:24:52Because there's no other way to describe the kind of feelings that could get you to give a lecture like the one Ben Shapiro gave.
00:25:00I feel like if I say that we all ought to be grateful, me, you, all of us ought to be grateful for America, I don't know if that's hostility to Americans.
00:25:06It feels more like love of Americans because it turns out that the greatest country in the history of the world is the place that you are currently living.
00:25:12It is an amazing place and it has all these problems.
00:25:14The problems we've talked about, mostly statist interventions like the ones that Tucker promotes.1.00
00:25:19But if you're ungrateful for America, you're either an idiot or malevolent.1.00
00:25:30Obviously, I believe in an educational system in which traditional virtue is upheld.
00:25:36It is also true that when the law says you cannot handle your own choices and freedoms, when the law says that basically all your freedoms and choices are bad for you, the law then teaches you to be a child and dependent and incapable.
00:25:51And this is what the post liberals are now arguing for ingratitude, because if you're ungrateful for the freedoms, if you're ungrateful for the process, if you say the process is rigged and crap, and what you actually need is someone telling you what to do, how virtue ought to be constituted, what you ought to do with your money, what decisions you ought to make with your life, how you ought to bring up your kids.
00:26:08If you have people who are saying that to you, That somehow individual rights that undergird capitalism destroy your spiritual fulfillment.
00:26:18There's a reason that Max Faber talked about the Protestant work ethic.
00:26:22It is indeed an Anglo American Protestant tradition that leads to the rise of free markets.
00:26:29You do not need to be poor or poorer in order to reach spiritual fulfillment.
00:26:34People who argue that you do typically just want an excuse for making you poor.
00:26:38Here's what I want I want for you to be wealthy and also to go to church.
00:26:42These two things are not mutually exclusive at all.
00:26:45Most of the biblical prophets were wealthy.
00:26:48Why are we, who says that Americans can't have both?
00:26:51Who says we can't have both prosperity and virtue?
00:26:56The very same people who are telling you that I'm somehow feeding you goy slop are sitting in mansions across from Hunter Biden and Andrew Tate and claiming they have the high ground on virtue and they're totally full of it.
00:27:06So I do have a theory about some of these folks.0.95
00:27:09I don't like to go into motivations, but we can look at personal histories.
00:27:13I have a theory about some of these folks.
00:27:16That many, many, many of the people who say the American dream is dead and that the American dream isn't a process, it's a set of ends that they alone can achieve if you give them power, never actually lived within the American process.
00:27:27They never were part of the American process.
00:27:29Hassan Piker didn't live the American dream.
00:27:35Zarn Mamdani did not live the American dream.
00:27:38Zarn Mamdani grew up alternatively in a mansion in Uganda or in a series of hoity toity areas of the United States with his Columbia University father.
00:27:49And his mom, who made documentaries for Disney.
00:27:50Bernie Sanders didn't live the American process.
00:27:53The dude's been living essentially rent free off the back of taxpayers his entire life.
00:28:41Can you imagine four or 500,000 American 18 year olds plucked at random from cities across the country in a field this summer, this month, August, 57 years after Woodstock?
00:28:54Can you imagine what they would look like with their shirts off?0.83
00:28:57Which is not to make fun of their lumpy physiques.
00:29:14So maybe the last thing they need is to be lectured by people who are clearly the beneficiaries of unearned privilege, like Ben Shapiro, who somehow got into Harvard Law School despite a middling IQ.
00:29:40Put aside the fact that he's using Woodstock as an example of American happiness, which is a bunch of young drug addled people banging in the mud, which is weird.
00:29:48And his weird imaginings of people with their shirts off.
00:29:54I'm just going to point out the reason I got into Harvard Law is because I had a 3.85 GPA from UCLA and a 176.
00:30:03On my LSAT and a published book and a syndicated column at age 17.
00:31:10First, the window to reach a woman facing an unexpected pregnancy has now gotten incredibly, incredibly small.
00:31:15Today, she can order the abortion pill online from her phone without ever walking into a clinic, sometimes before she's spoken to anyone who can remind her that she's not alone and that there's help and there is another option.0.86
00:31:25This is why the work preborn does really, really matters.
00:31:29At preborn network clinics, women are met with compassion, practical support, and a free ultrasound.0.76
00:32:28Until 1995, until I was 11 years old, my parents and I and my three younger sisters lived in a two bedroom, 1100 square foot house in Burbank, California with one bathroom for six people.
00:32:41It was a great life because America's awesome.
00:32:53My mom started off as a secretary at a small television company.
00:32:58And my father played piano on Monday and Tuesday nights at a restaurant called Michelli's.
00:33:04I spent most of my childhood Monday and Tuesday nights at Michelli's, hanging out with the waiters and the bartender while I waited for my mom to finish work so she could pick us up from the restaurant.
00:33:37Okay, so we moved into, I finally had my own room.0.99
00:33:40And that was, you know, basically for the rest of my childhood in North Hollywood.
00:33:45We're on scholarship at a local private school.
00:33:47But the reality is that sort of my own sort of educational history was public school through grade four, skipping grade three, private school five and six.
00:33:54We couldn't afford private school for seven and eight.
00:33:56So I went back to public school for seven and eight.
00:33:59And then private school again for 10, 11, 12, because I skipped ninth grade and I was on scholarship.
00:34:03Because my parents were by this point middle class to probably upper middle class.
00:34:08Because again, they made responsible decisions and their life progressed.
00:34:12And then I got into UCLA, a state school that does not cost tons of money.
00:34:18And then I got a 3.85 GPA and a 176 on my LSAT.
00:34:53He is not someone who got better and stronger and more powerful because he made smart, wise, and virtuous decisions.
00:35:01That is not the story of Tucker Carlson's life, just as it is not the story of Hassan Piker's life or Zorhan Mamdani's life.
00:35:07Or sheet of Tlaib or El Hanau, like this is not their life.
00:35:11Hey, here's what Tucker Carlson's childhood was like Tucker Carlson grew up silver spoon rich in a frozen food empire.
00:35:22He went to a Swiss boarding school for high school.
00:35:27He, according to Jason Zengerly in his book about Tucker Carlson, although Carlson found religion in high school, he continued to drink and smoke and began doing drugs, marijuana, acid, cocaine, even ether.
00:35:41He went to St. George's, which wasn't Exeter or Andover, but it still sent a smattering of graduates each year to Harvard, Princeton, and Yale.
00:35:49His grades and test scores were nowhere near good enough to get into any of those schools.
00:35:54His academic record at St. George's was sufficiently poor, he had a difficult time at gaining admission to any prestigious university, not just those in the Ivy League.
00:36:03So he got into Trinity College because his then girlfriend Susie's dad, who was the headmaster of St. George's, helped grease the wheels to get him in.
00:36:17When Patel, Neil Patel, with whom he became business partners later, and most of Carlson's other friends received their Trinity diplomas, Carlson was not among them.
00:36:30Then Carlson's daddy called up his friends at the Heritage Foundation, where he landed a $14,000 a year internship fact checking a quarterly journal at Heritage Foundation, and the rest is history.
00:36:41Okay, so again, I'm happy for Tucker that he is richer than he once was.
00:36:45But I think the reason why he despises the American dream as process is because he never lived that process.
00:38:34Well, you know, if you think so, head on over to dailywire.comslash subscribe to watch the full show ad free or check out this crazy story here.