Canadian Healthcare; Concerns and Solutions
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
181.40347
Summary
Another great program lined up for you and another great guest! Dr. Stephen Ellis returns to The Blueprints to talk about the growing shortage of doctors and nurses across Canada. Stephen is a friend of the show, a former family physician and a long-time critic for health in the House of Commons, and is now the Opposition Critic for Health in the Newfoundland and Labrador Parliament.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
hello and welcome once again to the blueprints this is canada's conservative podcast with new
00:00:13.900
content for you every single tuesday 1 30 p.m eastern time i'm your host jamie schmael member
00:00:19.000
of parliament for halliburton 4th links brock we ask that you like comment subscribe and share
00:00:23.040
this program you can also download and listen to it on platforms like cast box itunes google play
00:00:28.660
and spotify a message that is not always said in the mainstream media and something ears need to
00:00:34.480
hear eyes need to hear this show and we need your help to do that another great program lined up for
00:00:39.860
you and another great guest he's coming back on the show a friend of the show dr stephen ellis from
00:00:45.080
cumberland colchester member of parliament for that writing and also the critic for health
00:00:49.340
the shadow minister for health a good man thanks for coming back on well thanks very much jamie and
00:00:54.520
i wore my shirt today that has my name and writing on in case you forgot who i was so i thought that
00:00:59.640
was uh thought that was important to highlight that well i have my name behind me here in case you
00:01:04.800
forget who i am so it's all good we're going to talk about something i think that's well it is
00:01:09.540
affecting every every corner of the province and that is a shortage of physicians shortage of nurses
00:01:16.620
healthcare professionals uh you see emergency rooms closing in in in british columbia led by the
00:01:23.460
ndp you you see the same thing happen in liberal newfoundland labrador and yes in ontario provinces
00:01:29.740
uh as well with provincial governments of the the blue stripe so it it is happening everywhere uh you're
00:01:36.740
a doctor what what's going on there's it just seems to be a labor shortage and a whole bunch of things
00:01:42.600
why don't you give us your perspective yeah you know what i mean there's 6.5 million canadians
00:01:48.100
without access to primary care and of course that could either be a family doctor or a nurse
00:01:54.100
practitioner and that creates significant problems because of course the system that we have
00:01:59.560
you need to have access to a primary care provider so that you can access things like lab
00:02:06.480
diagnostic imaging x-ray ct mri etc ultrasound or access a specialist that's the canadian system that
00:02:14.960
we have so when you don't have access of course what happens is you end up going to the emergency
00:02:21.080
room the emergency rooms become overburdened people wait there a long time and uh and then of course bad
00:02:27.980
things can happen to them and we've seen that sadly here in nova scotia we've seen it but i think in
00:02:35.020
every province we've seen uh the tragic stories of people who have died in emergency rooms
00:02:40.640
and uh that of course cannot continue to happen uh related to that though is you know your question
00:02:49.000
off the top is what's going on and why does there appear to be a shortage you know certainly i think
00:02:54.820
that uh we all know that that times change uh i know that i was a family doctor for almost 25 years
00:03:02.380
and the person that i took over from i worked less than he did uh he was that uh ultimate family
00:03:11.440
physician so that jamie uh you know if you fell down at home and you said i think i broke my leg you
00:03:16.760
would call the doctor and and he would show up at your house uh and say oh no your leg's fine you know
00:03:23.120
get up and walk you know uh you're good uh you don't need anything pat you on the head
00:03:28.100
uh those times changed we we knew that very clearly uh for those emergency things we've
00:03:34.680
developed this incredible system across most of the country where if you have an emergency you can
00:03:39.840
call an ambulance if it's that style or you can go to the emergency room when you know you need
00:03:44.040
an intervention you know such as stitches or or a cast etc or if you need uh you know diagnostic
00:03:51.740
imaging so things have changed significantly from that style of medicine now excuse me
00:03:57.900
even further to understand that even from the style of medicine that i practiced which uh you
00:04:04.700
know i provided inpatient care a family medicine office emergency room i had a chronic pain clinic
00:04:11.340
that i was a part of uh nursing home visits etc we know that that place is a significant burden
00:04:18.200
upon health care providers and on their families as well and so that those not everybody now
00:04:25.340
don't get me wrong that's that's an unfair characterization but many folks who are going
00:04:30.860
into medicine have determined that that that is a lot to ask and and so medicine's now being practiced
00:04:36.760
even uh more differently if that's the correct english uh than than the way i practiced it so i think
00:04:43.860
that those are the things that are creating significant problems so we have as i mentioned emergency room
00:04:51.220
closings but we also have family physicians that are hard to find do we as you mentioned nurse
00:04:55.920
practitioners are coming in to try to to fill that gap and fix it and a lot of this is managed well pretty
00:05:00.960
much all of it's managed by the province but there is something the federal government can do and that's
00:05:05.240
something our leader has talked about and i know you've talked about it many times uh that's a blue seal
00:05:09.920
program tell us a bit about that so the blue seal program is really built upon this um knowledge that
00:05:18.220
there are physicians who have trained internationally who are who have come to canada under federal
00:05:25.740
programs which say hey you're a physician you should come to canada we'd love to have you here
00:05:30.900
but then there's no way for them or no easy way for them to access the possibility of becoming a doctor
00:05:38.800
who can work in canada and in some cases perhaps it's justified we we have standards that we have
00:05:45.900
established in canada for training and knowledge etc in other cases though it's not and even those
00:05:53.600
folks are finding it almost impossible to get a license to practice in canada of course if you don't
00:05:59.320
have a license you can't practice it doesn't matter what your training is so the blue seal program would
00:06:04.280
be really um built on the fact that it's related to if you can demonstrate that you have the knowledge
00:06:12.500
the cultural ability and the language ability to be a physician in canada then you should be a
00:06:18.420
physician in canada and on top of that we would also have a national licensing program so that if
00:06:26.100
you were a physician licensed to practice in i'm here in nova scotia if i were licensed in nova scotia
00:06:32.140
then i could practice anywhere in canada much i'll use the analogy for folks out there listening
00:06:37.420
of your driver's license you don't have to get a new driver's license when you move to british
00:06:42.520
columbia well eventually you do but certainly if you're visiting there you can drive with a nova
00:06:47.620
scotia driver's license so those are the ideas and i have to tell you i had a meeting with one of our
00:06:55.900
colleagues anna roberts who's riding as king von just north of gta and we met with around 25 physicians
00:07:03.840
who'd been here variably from 20 years to six months and none of them were able to gain licensure
00:07:11.440
here in canada and sadly one of the things that really stuck with me is two things one is um one of
00:07:19.120
the physicians who was a security guard his his children said to him dad why are you going to work
00:07:24.920
in this security guard outfit when we know you're a doctor that was heart-wrenching and the second part
00:07:30.820
of it was another physician who had been here he had uh many um cousins who were physicians back in
00:07:38.100
his home country and i can't remember which it was and i apologize for that uh but he said he said first
00:07:43.260
of all he told them not to come because internationally canada has become known as the graveyard for
00:07:49.420
physicians now isn't that a reputation to have oh wow yeah so so is it bureaucracy within these uh
00:07:57.880
provincial organizations these licensing bodies are just uh just slowed right down like that there was
00:08:03.980
this a problem before the pandemic or is this just grown worse throughout the the three years it's
00:08:09.640
just continued to grow worse uh you know and there's really no easy pathway for internationally trained
00:08:16.980
physicians to get work here and and gain licensure here in canada so those are the things that we want
00:08:22.620
to work with the provinces to remedy and we know and i've met with five of the provincial ministers
00:08:28.740
already and and certainly we know that there is significant interest in how we would make this happen
00:08:34.920
and uh and significant support and there's already been some work uh as hard as this is to believe but
00:08:41.760
even physicians trained in the united states uh didn't have easy access to come to nova scotia which now
00:08:48.860
uh the registrar here in nova scotia has rectified and we also know that the four atlantic provinces are
00:08:55.800
saying if you are licensed in one of the atlantic provinces then you can work in any of the atlantic
00:09:01.260
provinces uh so we do see some movement on this but what we really wanted and i think what really
00:09:06.800
what canadians expect is to have a homogeneous system across the country so that you know whatever's
00:09:14.460
happening in in nova scotia is the same in bc or alberta ontario and that's what i mean by
00:09:19.180
homogeneous it's the same and i think that's certainly as a canadian that's my expectation it
00:09:24.520
should be the same everywhere i think when you're when you're sick and you can't find a doctor you
00:09:29.040
don't really care where you know you obviously they have to hit standards and show that they're
00:09:34.860
disciplined and all that other stuff but at the same time i don't care if someone's been licensed in
00:09:39.200
nova scotia is practicing on ontario like this should be something that we we didn't leave
00:09:44.860
till 2023 to deal with i think no and i think many canadians are absolutely astonished when we
00:09:51.100
when we talk about this when they hear it as an issue they say well this doesn't make any sense and
00:09:55.740
and we know that uh as well as uh most of our listeners do that there is a red seal program out
00:10:01.360
there for carpenters electricians plumbers uh etc other trades people uh so that once you gain
00:10:08.040
that certification in in one province you can then of course practice anywhere in the country and
00:10:13.120
and that really is a sensible program that we would use uh to kind of build this upon so i think that
00:10:19.380
makes sense one of the things that i would highlight though is the inability for canadian citizens who've
00:10:26.100
chosen for whatever reason to be trained abroad ireland is somewhere they often train uh the caribbean is
00:10:32.400
somewhere they often train that even those canadian citizens who obviously are familiar with our
00:10:39.540
language and familiar with our culture are still unable to gain a spot back in canada and i i think
00:10:47.640
that's uh you know just a travesty for those young people who have this burning desire to be part of our
00:10:54.720
system and we have already established obviously that we have a significant need in our system
00:11:00.520
and as canadian citizens they can't gain licensure here in canada and that is something that uh that
00:11:07.480
a conservative government would rectify as well and i've heard a couple i have two uh stories that
00:11:12.600
i've heard in my time here of of uh canadians uh from my area going off to different countries
00:11:18.460
and getting trained getting their getting their license but unable to come back despite being a
00:11:24.640
canadian citizen despite growing up here uh not being able to actually uh practice despite a massive
00:11:31.100
physician shortage in every uh corner of this country i mean i mean it's just it's nonsensical uh
00:11:38.640
there was a story in the news the other day uh a female physician who had i think practiced in
00:11:45.760
australia for 10 years who was a canadian citizen who said hey i'll come back to canada
00:11:50.780
uh i don't think so nope no i don't think i mean you know this would be someone who is in the prime
00:11:57.440
of their career uh really at the height of knowledge and and i think any of our listeners are uh out there
00:12:04.920
that we would that they would also agree that you wouldn't think that the climate in australia from a
00:12:10.660
medical perspective is that different from canada so how could this individual have such a difficult
00:12:16.440
time coming back into her own country uh and to me that's inexcusable those are the things that we
00:12:23.200
need to change and those are the things that we need to make a significant priority for canadians
00:12:29.020
and you're right you can even argue it's a commonwealth country for crying out loud if there aren't you know
00:12:34.100
countries that you could really find common ground with it would be a commonwealth country
00:12:39.240
and and yet we can't seem to do that yeah you know um before i decided to do this job and was
00:12:46.820
fortunate enough to be elected that was one of the things that my wife and i had actually talked about
00:12:51.600
in our uh you know perhaps quote-unquote retirement plans um and and in my understanding the research
00:12:58.460
that i've done is that because i hold a license in canada that i could easily get a license in
00:13:03.780
australia so why would we not have that reciprocity if the australian government can recognize that the
00:13:10.420
training is the same the illnesses are generally the same then obviously there may be some difference
00:13:16.100
in in names of medications etc which is all learnable things um if the australians can recognize that
00:13:23.780
why can't the government this sadly this liberal government of canada cannot seem to recognize that
00:13:29.680
uh so that's a commitment that we would make as conservatives to say we'll change this i like
00:13:35.160
that planet i also we don't have to get into it now but just as a reminder to those watching and
00:13:40.160
listening there are actually significant trade barriers in our country where different provinces
00:13:45.300
can't trade their goods back and forth in some cases it's actually easier for some provinces to
00:13:51.020
do business with another country altogether than it is another canadian province and and it's these
00:13:56.340
these these these hurdles these these gatekeeping hurdles that need to be removed in order to allow
00:14:02.480
canada to be the freest nation in the world well and of course as we improve those things as a
00:14:09.120
conservative government well and we have businesses that want to come here and they want to make their
00:14:14.640
businesses bigger employ more people obviously when you have those economies of scale you can you can
00:14:19.940
pay your people more you can give them better benefits uh those are the things again that as our
00:14:26.200
leader pierre pauliev would say you get bigger more powerful paychecks uh that allows you to uh to
00:14:32.660
improve the life of not just yourself but your family and your community uh your business etc and and
00:14:38.300
everybody benefits from that uh to removing those barriers and those gatekeepers that uh that really
00:14:44.560
keep people and businesses under the thumb of the liberal government and and if you look at most of the stats the
00:14:53.240
the freest countries in the world they're usually the happiest countries in the world i you know the
00:14:58.920
the more the government clamps down the more government restricts your movements your choice
00:15:04.020
making and the list goes on the more unhappy the population gets and and so this is something that needs
00:15:10.500
to be repeated many times that in in when we make this the freest country in the world you will see
00:15:16.380
paychecks get bigger you will see attitudes change you will see that possibilities are almost endless
00:15:22.120
if you get the the gatekeepers out of the way you know what lots of people out there you know
00:15:29.440
will say well we already are free in canada and we are i mean we do have freedoms but there's this
00:15:35.980
there's this significant undercurrent of gatekeeping and red tape uh that doesn't need to exist that could
00:15:42.760
easily be eliminated uh and that would make everybody's lives significantly better i really
00:15:48.300
love the idea that uh uh that pierre poliev has to say i will incentivize municipalities who get out of
00:15:56.440
the way of building new houses and new apartment buildings etc and and to me that really makes sense
00:16:03.700
uh to say hey you know what you want to do this you want to do the right thing because people
00:16:08.300
need a place to live and of course housing in any way shape or form is exceedingly expensive now
00:16:15.240
uh that we will actually then incentivize municipalities who want to do the right thing
00:16:20.240
and help people find a decent place to live and with anything business it doesn't matter investments
00:16:25.400
it always it always takes the path of least resistance and there is reason for that right like
00:16:30.440
business moves very fast government does not and when those hurdles are in place investment goes
00:16:36.980
elsewhere like it's very easy for the most part to to invest all over the world in companies that are
00:16:42.800
doing business everywhere and and when when you have a investors trying to uh hear a pitch from a
00:16:50.580
project in canada but at a country a similar project in a in another country knowing that you can get
00:16:55.400
something off the ground faster and see a return on your investment and i know that's a dirty word for
00:17:00.960
for some on the left yes profit um you're going to probably take that if they're a limited dollar so
00:17:06.400
we need to ensure that canada is competitive once again and that we are making it while ensuring all
00:17:13.200
the checks and balances are in place making it a smooth and quick process either way yes or no on
00:17:19.100
any project absolutely you know and you know i always sum that up in my mind by saying canada needs
00:17:25.900
to have a favorable business environment we need to be business friendly that's how people go to work
00:17:31.760
every day that's how they have benefits that's how they feed their families and pay their bills
00:17:35.980
keep the lights on and in the winter keep the heat on those are the things that we need to change we need
00:17:42.700
good jobs that pay people well for doing the work that we ask them to do in this incredibly resource
00:17:50.560
natural resource rich country and we have people out there and we know uh that when we allow canadians
00:17:58.200
to work hard that they they can improve their own situation in life that they want to work hard that
00:18:02.960
they want their families to be one step ahead of where they were when when they were the same age and
00:18:09.280
that's what i've always wanted for my own family and i'm sure uh almost all of our viewers want the
00:18:14.920
same thing and that's the type of canada that we that we conservatives want to see and that we talk
00:18:20.580
about doc ellis i've kept you here long enough but i do appreciate your time as you know guests get the
00:18:25.240
last word but i don't know if you can top that but i i encourage you to try or or maybe not
00:18:30.100
well you know uh give a politician a microphone uh you know that being said uh we know very clearly
00:18:37.140
that there are immigrant physicians uh who've been trained internationally who are unable to practice
00:18:42.400
in canada that's one of the things that we want to change we want to ensure that the blue seal
00:18:47.180
program allows physicians who are licensed in in one province to work anywhere in this country
00:18:52.140
and we want to ensure that those canadian citizens who who have chosen to train abroad
00:18:57.060
will be able to come back and work in their chosen profession uh in their health care here in canada so
00:19:02.720
lots and lots of work to be done on health care that's a smattering of of one very small part of
00:19:08.660
the platform that you'll hear as we get closer and closer to election and it's my pleasure to be a part
00:19:13.980
of all that dr stephen ellis member of parliament for cumberland colchester in the beautiful province
00:19:19.340
of nova scotia also the shadow minister for health we appreciate your time the second episode this
00:19:24.420
summer love to have you on i appreciate you doing that appreciate your time as well please like
00:19:29.200
comments share and subscribe to this program you'll be notified of new episodes that pop up every single
00:19:34.340
tuesday at 1 30 p.m eastern time don't forget you can download it on platforms like cast box itunes
00:19:39.180
google play and spotify tell your friends they can do it too new content every single tuesday
00:19:44.420
without hesitation throughout the summer there will be something new to talk about and dr ellis's
00:19:50.540
second program this summer i love it i love it until next week remember low taxes less government