The Blueprint: Canada's Conservative Podcast - June 30, 2026


Uncertainty. That is what the current government has left Canadians with.

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Canadian airports should be secure. Not a playground for organized crime. Bill C-9 wasn’t about fighting hate.

Episode Stats


Length

22 minutes

Words per minute

164.38

Word count

3,721

Sentence count

275

Harmful content

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The Cowichan decision by the B.C. Supreme Court in August 2025 elevated Aboriginal title over private property in British Columbia. This has ramifications across the province and beyond. In this episode, we speak with Teiko Van Papta, MP for Langley-Fraser Heights and the Head of the Task Force on Property Rights, about the implications of the ruling.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hello and welcome once again to The Blueprint. This is Canada's Conservative Podcast. I'm
00:00:13 your host, Jamie Schmael, Member of Parliament for Halliburton Corps at the Lakes with new
00:00:16 content for you every single Tuesday, 1.30pm Eastern Time, even throughout the summer.
00:00:21 So don't forget to like, comment, subscribe and share this program because on today's
00:00:25 show. We are talking about the Cowichan decision out in British Columbia. This has ramifications
00:00:31 elsewhere, potentially, so that's why we bring it to your attention. And to get more information,
00:00:36 we bring on the one and only Teiko Van Papta, the Member of Parliament for Langley Township,
00:00:42 Fraser Heights, also the head of the task force on property rights. Thanks for coming on the show.
00:00:47 Good. Thanks, Jimmy, for the invitation. Good to be here.
00:00:49 I appreciate you coming on the show because this is such a complex topic that has kind of engulfed British Columbia, I want to say politics, but also kitchen table talk for many.
00:01:02 Maybe you can give us like the 30-second elevator pitch.
00:01:08 I don't know, not so much a pitch, but an idea for the person tuning in in Nova Scotia, Ontario.
00:01:15 What is the Cowichan decision?
00:01:17 And what has kind of got people engaged in this topic out in British Columbia?
00:01:22 Well, the Cowichan decision, decision of the B.C. Supreme Court in August 2025, so about a year ago,
00:01:30 For the first time in Canadian history, a Canadian court declared Aboriginal title over private lands.
00:01:37 It's never happened before.
00:01:39 People woke up the next morning finding out that their titles were subject to Aboriginal title,
00:01:44 and people are wondering, what does that mean?
00:01:48 Before I got into politics, I was a real estate development lawyer,
00:01:52 and the whole industry banks on title indefeasibility,
00:01:56 and today that is being called into question.
00:01:59 I never expected to see that happen because in Canada, private property rights has always been secure.
00:02:06 At least we thought it was. Today, it is less secure than it was a year ago.
00:02:10 And that's what the issue is.
00:02:13 When Justice Young of the B.C. Supreme Court says that sections 23 and 25 of the B.C. Land Title Act do not apply,
00:02:21 That is the underpinning of private property ownership in that province, which then, to your comment, elevated Aboriginal rights and title that the Cowichan tribe was claiming around the city of Richmond.
00:02:35 So there are businesses and homeowners that are affected by this.
00:02:38 That's right.
00:02:39 And including First Nations themselves.
00:02:42 There are two First Nations that are saying, hang on a second, we have interest in this area as well.
00:02:49 Absolutely true. 0.61
00:02:50 So by saying that Section 23 and 25 of the BC Land Title Act don't apply to Aboriginal title, Justice Young was really saying that where the two compete, Aboriginal title comes out on top.
00:03:04 It is a senior and prior interest.
00:03:07 And we did not expect that to happen.
00:03:12 It was argued that Aboriginal title and fee-simple title cannot coexist on the same land at the same time.
00:03:18 She discounted that argument by saying, oh, I think they can coexist because, and she pointed to a decision, sorry, an agreement that had been entered into with the Haida Gwaii Nation up in northern British Columbia, where both the provincial government and the federal government were parties.
00:03:39 And that agreement says that aboriginal title, if he's simple title, can coexist.
00:03:45 And legal experts are saying that is impossible.
00:03:48 Because the Aboriginal title is very similar to fee-simple title. 0.79
00:03:52 It gives the holder of it the right to exclusive possession of the land, 0.89
00:03:58 the right to profit from the land, the right to decide what to do with the land,
00:04:02 just like fee-simple.
00:04:04 So how can the two coexist?
00:04:05 We say that it does not work.
00:04:08 So what we have in Alberta, Saskatchewan, Manitoba, parts of Ontario,
00:04:15 moving eastward from British Columbia,
00:04:17 we have a lot of treaties, numbered or otherwise modern.
00:04:21 The treaties are engaged,
00:04:23 which acts as kind of a finality to the process
00:04:26 in a lot of cases.
00:04:27 British Columbia really doesn't have any of that going on.
00:04:31 You have overlapping claims.
00:04:34 You have a bunch, you know,
00:04:36 we have over 200 nations in that province.
00:04:40 And that is, I think, a major piece of this puzzle, too,
00:04:45 is that those negotiations were not held way back when
00:04:50 that could have kind of add some certainty
00:04:53 to this process that we're dealing with now.
00:04:54 Yes, exactly true.
00:04:56 So early on in British Columbia's history
00:04:58 when it was a colony, but before it became a province,
00:05:01 James Douglas was the governor
00:05:04 and he entered into some treaties
00:05:06 in the southern part of Vancouver Island
00:05:09 because Victoria was sort of the center of the universe
00:05:13 for the colony.
00:05:15 but he didn't enter into treaties like for other parts, right?
00:05:20 On the mainland, for example.
00:05:23 And British Columbia then entered into Confederation in 1871
00:05:27 in that state of ambiguity when it came to indigenous claims.
00:05:32 Unlike Alberta and Saskatchewan,
00:05:34 and by the way, the northeastern part of British Columbia as well,
00:05:38 east of the Rockies, entered into what we call the Number Treaties.
00:05:41 And so there's a much higher degree of certainty in that part of Canada and in British Columbia.
00:05:48 We are suffering, continuing to suffer from the indecision and the lack of action on the part of James Douglas and successor governors and the province of British Columbia after it became a province.
00:06:03 And so today, 2026, we're still sorting out the mess.
00:06:06 So we, as an opposition and a party, do agree that treaties, for the most part,
00:06:11 are the way forward in a lot of cases.
00:06:13 To add some finality to this, to have both sides hopefully walk away happy at the process.
00:06:20 Let's queue up Cut One.
00:06:21 We have our leader, Pierre Polyev, talking about what we'd like to see
00:06:25 with the British Columbia government in their negotiating process,
00:06:28 but also the government of Canada, and on how we can, as a party, support future treaties.
00:06:34 Play Cut One.
00:06:35 I think there are four steps that need to happen immediately.
00:06:38 One, we need the federal government, Mark Carney, to change his mind and reverse the directive,
00:06:44 making it clear that the federal government's position is that fee-simple property takes priority over all other claims.
00:06:49 Two, we need to ensure that all future agreements that the government signs with First Nations
00:06:54 clearly and explicitly lay out that fee-simple private property is protected and has seniority over all other title.
00:07:01 Three, the Prime Minister must announce a full and comprehensive plan to protect private property rights across British Columbia.
00:07:08 It's been almost a year since this ruling.
00:07:10 And four, we need to convene a parliamentary committee that will immediately begin study on how we can take political, legal, and constitutional steps necessary to protect people's homes and land.
00:07:21 There's a good-looking guy over the leader's shoulder.
00:07:23 I don't know if you noticed Takeo, but I just want to point that out.
00:07:27 What was directed, number one, the leader, his point?
00:07:30 Number one, when he was talking about the directive,
00:07:34 explain that to us.
00:07:36 Directive 14, what is that?
00:07:37 Right, so the Attorney General, as always,
00:07:40 would give directives to litigation counsel,
00:07:44 and in this case to litigation counsel
00:07:47 involved in Aboriginal title claims.
00:07:49 And early in this litigation,
00:07:53 now the Couching case goes back 10 years.
00:07:55 Yeah, one of the longest court cases in Canada.
00:07:58 Exactly, right.
00:07:59 And early in the process, the federal Crown lawyers argued for extinguishment.
00:08:06 Okay, I'm going to ask you to define that in a second, but keep going.
00:08:08 Don't lose your thought.
00:08:09 And then in 2018, so a couple of years into the litigation, the Attorney General,
00:08:14 it was Jody Wilson-Raybould at the time, changed the directives, added directive number 14,
00:08:19 which says, do not use extinguishment as an argument.
00:08:22 And that really is the most powerful tool for the government to have used to protect private property rights.
00:08:31 So I'll explain what extinguishment is.
00:08:33 Yeah, while you're doing that, maybe we can pop up the graphic of the city of Richmond mayor talking about protection.
00:08:38 So what is extinguishment?
00:08:39 So extinguishment is the legal principle that says that the government of Canada or the government of British Columbia
00:08:47 has the sovereign authority and power to extinguish Aboriginal title.
00:08:52 But the law says that they need to do that clearly, not just by innuendo or by regulation
00:08:59 or something like that. 1.00
00:09:00 It needs to be a clear intent on the part of the government to extinguish Aboriginal
00:09:04 title to the extent that there is Aboriginal title over a specific piece of land. 0.87
00:09:09 The argument is that by the Crown granting fee simple parcels to individuals, that act
00:09:17 alone was a clear and definitive intent expressed by the government to extinguish any aboriginal
00:09:26 title that might be over those lands, because the two cannot coexist.
00:09:29 The two cannot coexist.
00:09:30 All right, cut two.
00:09:32 We have the prime minister in question period trying his past, I think, to explain the government's
00:09:39 position on this, which doesn't make much sense.
00:09:41 Play cut two.
00:09:42 Private property rights are fundamental, and this government, indeed, this House, will always protect them.
00:09:50 This government fundamentally disagrees with the B.C. Supreme Court's decision on Cowichan.
00:09:56 We immediately appealed that decision alongside the government of B.C., the city of Richmond, and other First Nations.
00:10:04 We will always advance viable legal arguments to protect private property.
00:10:10 federal agreements including agreements about aboriginal title have always and will always
00:10:17 protect private property no modern treaty negotiated agreement or federal approach
00:10:21 you're out of the time there okay so the government in 2018 said uh you know we're
00:10:28 not going to stick up for private property we're not going to continue that argument
00:10:31 now the government's saying well we do stand up for private property rights but
00:10:36 the directive still exists. Now that it's gone to appeal, the government can't argue something
00:10:46 that it didn't argue the first time, right? Does it use it or lose it, as some of our colleagues
00:10:50 have said. So what does that statement mean to you when you heard that? Well, it's very unclear
00:10:56 what it means to me. Very complicated. You know, when the Prime Minister uses the adjective
00:11:01 To viable arguments, you go, so what does viable mean?
00:11:04 I guess extinguishment is not viable because you didn't argue it and that directive is
00:11:08 still there not to use it.
00:11:10 And you also make the point, Jamie, that an argument that was not used at trial cannot
00:11:18 be raised on appeal.
00:11:20 Now, it's interesting whether or not a B.C. Court of Appeal is going to consider the extinguishment
00:11:27 argument. They may, because Richmond, being one of the defendants, did argue it.
00:11:33 Yes, that's right. The only one that stood up for private property.
00:11:38 The only one who stood up for private property rights. And I asked some legal experts, I said,
00:11:43 so why wouldn't the judge have listened to and been convinced by the arguments advanced by the
00:11:48 city of Richmond? And the answer was, well, you know, the judge would have looked at the federal
00:11:54 crown and the provincial crown has said, are you arguing for extinguishment? No. Pretty easy to
00:12:00 discount an argument from a city government, which is not crown. It's like a private enterprise. It's
00:12:07 a creature of the provincial government. So again, we have another misstep by,
00:12:13 we'll let the province deal with the provincial team deal with it, but the province messed up too,
00:12:17 the federal government messed up too. They had the same directive. Yeah, they had the same
00:12:21 directive. So this was all avoidable. Again, the short-sightedness, unfortunately, by this federal
00:12:27 government gets us to the point we are at now, and now they're in a bit of a box. But one of the
00:12:33 largest property owners in the affected area, let's put up the graphic here, they want a bit of
00:12:38 clarification here. Why don't you tell us a bit about that? Because not too long ago, you sat in
00:12:43 Victoria, BC in a courtroom that heard about this. So why don't you give us your thoughts on that?
00:12:49 Yeah, so Montrose Properties is the largest private land owner that has land within that 800-acre jurisdiction.
00:12:57 They have some land on the other side of the street as well.
00:13:00 They're a significant land developing company.
00:13:03 And they had a project on the subject lands that was shovel-ready, according to Ken Lowe, the proprietor, the CEO.
00:13:13 He said it was shovel-ready.
00:13:14 They had bank financing in place.
00:13:16 They had zoning approvals.
00:13:18 they were going to put up a warehouse, a significant warehouse. They had anchor tenants
00:13:24 for the warehouse. And the anchor tenants also had their bank financing in place for
00:13:29 tenant improvements. And then the decision came down and the banks said, we need to re-look
00:13:35 at it. They pulled their funding. The project is, if it's not dead, it's on hold. And so
00:13:42 Montrose, it's pretty unusual for somebody to say, oh, sue me too, right? Please join
00:13:47 into your lawsuit, right?
00:13:48 I want to be a defendant.
00:13:50 But Montrose makes a very valid point
00:13:53 that if a court is going to make a decision
00:13:55 that is going to affect our rights
00:13:57 to be able to use our land,
00:13:59 absolutely, we want to be part of that lawsuit.
00:14:01 We want to argue the points
00:14:03 in favor of protecting private property rights
00:14:06 that neither the federal AG
00:14:07 nor the provincial AG advanced
00:14:09 because of this directive
00:14:11 that was telling them not to.
00:14:13 Yeah, unbelievable.
00:14:14 Now the private property owner has to defend themselves at the last second here
00:14:20 when the province and the feds just walked away from it.
00:14:24 They had the ability to do it and didn't.
00:14:26 It is just incredible how we got to this point.
00:14:30 Now we have a decision, not a decision, but a Supreme Court.
00:14:36 Can I call it a decision? Is that the correct wording?
00:14:39 I think it's a decision.
00:14:40 Decision not to do something.
00:14:42 Yeah, decision not to do something.
00:14:44 I wanted to get the correct terms.
00:14:45 You're the lawyer.
00:14:46 I'm not.
00:14:48 So there's a case under British Columbia.
00:14:49 I'll let you talk about this because I'm the host.
00:14:51 You're the guest.
00:14:52 Tell us what was going on in New Brunswick and what the Supreme Court did and how it could potentially affect what's happening in British Columbia.
00:15:02 Yeah, thanks for raising that.
00:15:03 So at the same time that the Cowichan case was proceeding in British Columbia, there was another case, similar facts, differences, of course.
00:15:14 But called Walastakui, if I'm pronouncing that correctly, that's the name of an Indian First Nation who was claiming Aboriginal title over a large piece of land.
00:15:24 Almost half the province.
00:15:25 Almost half the province, right, of New Brunswick.
00:15:28 And they named the Attorney General of Canada as the defendant, rightfully so, and the Attorney General of New Brunswick.
00:15:34 But they also named some private landowners, including Irving, the big Irving company, who has significant land holdings there for forestry purposes.
00:15:45 Now, the private landowners, before the trial, the trial hasn't even started yet.
00:15:50 So as a preliminary application, these private landowners made an application to the judge saying that we are not proper defendants in this case because we are private landowners.
00:16:02 and this court will never declare
00:16:05 aboriginal title over private lands.
00:16:09 The court agreed and said,
00:16:11 you don't need to be defendants
00:16:12 because we would never do that. 0.99
00:16:14 We would never grant aboriginal title
00:16:17 over fee simple lands.
00:16:19 In the words of one of the judges
00:16:20 who set the new grants for the Court of Appeal,
00:16:22 he said, that would be the death knell of reconciliation.
00:16:26 Right, yes, because reconciliation
00:16:27 is both teams coming together, both sides,
00:16:29 both groups, whoever you want to call it.
00:16:31 Not to push them further apart.
00:16:32 And that's exactly what they saw would be happening.
00:16:35 It is what is happening in British Columbia.
00:16:36 That's right.
00:16:37 So the last degree plaintiffs applied for leave to appeal, permission to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada.
00:16:47 We don't have an automatic right to, nobody has an automatic right to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada.
00:16:51 They have a very busy agenda.
00:16:53 And they, you know, so an application has to be made.
00:16:56 Lawyers go get gowned up.
00:16:57 They go in front of the judges and they make the case why this case should be appealed.
00:17:04 And the judges listen to it.
00:17:06 And after giving it some appropriate thought, they said, leave to appeal denied.
00:17:12 That's all they say.
00:17:13 Why?
00:17:14 We don't know.
00:17:15 We don't know what's going on in their minds.
00:17:17 But legal experts say, you know what?
00:17:19 It's the Supreme Court by denying leave to appeal on Woloskoe, if I say that correctly, 1.00
00:17:25 is signalling that the New Brunswick Court got it correct. 0.97
00:17:31 And by extension of the logic,
00:17:35 the British Columbia Court got it wrong.
00:17:37 Yeah.
00:17:38 But the clarification, too, is that you in British Columbia,
00:17:42 you, I'm saying as a British Columbia member of parliament,
00:17:44 have this piece of provincial legislation called DRIPA,
00:17:47 the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous People,
00:17:49 where New Brunswick doesn't, which complicates that.
00:17:53 But I think you're right.
00:17:54 I do agree, this sends a message, I think, will resonate.
00:17:59 I think it sends a message, clearly.
00:18:00 And they call the wiser on it, yeah.
00:18:01 Yeah, no, everybody in the Cowichan case in BC is appealing.
00:18:05 Yeah, yes.
00:18:06 Federal government, provincial government, Richmond, everybody is appealing.
00:18:09 Musqueam.
00:18:09 Musqueam, Tawasim, because they're unhappy, and the Cowichan are also unhappy,
00:18:13 because they had actually claimed Aboriginal title over 1,800 acres, about 7 square kilometers,
00:18:18 and the judge gave them only 800 acres. 0.68
00:18:22 So they're going, we needed more than that.
00:18:24 So everybody is equally unhappy.
00:18:27 It's going to end up at the Court of Appeal,
00:18:29 B.C. Court of Appeal.
00:18:30 And without the guidance from the Supreme Court of Canada,
00:18:34 I think the Court of Appeal will look very closely
00:18:37 at the reasoning in the New Brunswick Court of Appeal.
00:18:40 They're not bound by it,
00:18:42 but they will give it significant weight,
00:18:45 particularly since the Supreme Court of Canada
00:18:46 decided that they didn't have to hear the appeal.
00:18:49 And I think that would be the prudent thing to do.
00:18:51 I think that reasonable, that makes total sense.
00:18:53 It makes total sense, however.
00:18:55 However, there's always an option.
00:18:56 Yeah, yeah, exactly, right?
00:18:58 So lawyers like to make things complicated, right?
00:19:00 So, I mean, you raised the issue of DREPA, right?
00:19:03 This is British Columbia legislation
00:19:05 where BC incorporated the United Nations Declaration
00:19:10 on the Rights of Indigenous People.
00:19:11 It was never intended to be law, right?
00:19:13 It's just sort of a guiding principle.
00:19:15 British Columbia decided to make it part of their law.
00:19:17 This is backfiring on them badly, right?
00:19:19 That's maybe for another day.
00:19:20 But, you know, there are enough differences between British Columbia and New Brunswick to, you know, for me to say that an outcome from the B.C. Court of Appeal on the couch and appeal is uncertain.
00:19:33 We don't know where it's going.
00:19:34 This may end up at the Supreme Court of Canada yet.
00:19:36 Which is such a shame because B.C. has so much potential and they've done very, it's a beautiful province to live, but so much confusion and tension with homeowners and business owners around Richmond.
00:19:49 You see businesses getting a little, you know, hesitant about investing.
00:19:55 It's so unfortunate because there is so much more potential British Columbia has as a province to really kickstart the Canadian economy and get things rolling.
00:20:04 That's the last thing we need, to be honest, more uncertainty.
00:20:07 The real estate industry is really struggling these days, you know, because of other provincial and federal legislation and also municipal rules and development cost charges and everything.
00:20:18 It's become very complicated, and then you throw in this additional uncertainty about indefeasibility of title.
00:20:25 It's worrisome.
00:20:25 Yeah, they have an NDP government.
00:20:28 That pretty much says it all in British Columbia.
00:20:30 Takeout, we're over time a bit, but I hope that our listeners and viewers found this information helpful.
00:20:36 I know it's a lot of legal terms, but I think we did our best to try to summarize it as quick as possible
00:20:42 and give people an idea of what's going on and the latest development.
00:20:46 So the guests always get the last word here.
00:20:49 The floor is yours.
00:20:50 Good.
00:20:51 Well, thank you, Jamie.
00:20:51 Thank you for the invitation.
00:20:53 This is a very important topic.
00:20:55 I was just at a roundtable or a town hall meeting this morning
00:20:58 with people right from across the country.
00:21:01 And a lot of them go, what's all this going on in British Columbia?
00:21:04 And as one person said, yeah, this is a scary movie coming to a theater near you.
00:21:10 This is not just a BC issue.
00:21:12 If indefeasibility of title can be questioned in British Columbia, it can happen in other parts of the country as well.
00:21:19 Yeah, well, let's hope common sense prevails.
00:21:22 Like you said, the Supreme Court did make a pretty remarkable step, in my opinion, to kind of put some water on this fire and calm people down.
00:21:32 But reconciliation, right?
00:21:34 It's about bringing people together.
00:21:36 I think the government of British Columbia, the federal government here, has not been doing that.
00:21:40 And it's unfortunate.
00:21:41 It really is.
00:21:43 Takeo, thank you so much for coming on the show.
00:21:45 Takeo Van Popp to the Member of Parliament for Langley Township, Fraser Heights.
00:21:49 We once again thank him for his time.
00:21:51 Thank you for yours.
00:21:52 I hope you found this information very helpful.
00:21:54 But we also ask that you get it out to your friends and neighbours who may not understand exactly what is happening in British Columbia with the Cowichan decision.
00:22:02 So please like, comment, share and subscribe to this program.
00:22:06 and you can download it, good stuff,
00:22:09 on platforms like CastBox, iTunes, Google Play, and Spotify.
00:22:12 You name it, it is out there.
00:22:14 We have new content for you every single Tuesday,
00:22:17 1.30 p.m. Eastern time, even throughout the summer.
00:22:19 So until then, remember, low taxes, less government,
00:22:22 more freedom, that's the blueprint.
00:22:36 You