The Candice Malcolm Show - January 07, 2022


As if we needed another reason to Defund the CBC

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Trudeau lashes out and blames Canadians for his failures Is Justin Trudeau losing his grip on reality?

Episode Stats


Length

33 minutes

Words per minute

200.98

Word count

6,660

Sentence count

328

Harmful content

Misogyny

12

sentences flagged

Toxicity

9

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

A CBC journalist quits the state broadcaster in rage and spills the beans about just how far down the woke left rabbit hole the CBC has gone. As if we need another reason to defund the CBC, it's Fake News Friday with Harrison Faulkner!

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 A CBC journalist quits the state broadcaster in rage and spills the beans about just how
00:00:05 far down the woke left rabbit hole the CBC has gone as if we need another reason to defund the
00:00:10 CBC. It's Fake News Friday. I'm Candace Malcolm and this is The Candace Malcolm Show.
00:00:18 Hi everyone. Thank you so much for tuning in. This is our favorite show of the week here at
00:00:22 The Candace Malcolm Show because it gives us the opportunity to reflect on all of the craziness
00:00:27 and all of the nonsense that is put out in the Canadian media by the legacy media here in the
00:00:32 country and this story in particular. So this came out on January 3rd and we wanted to cover it right
00:00:37 away. This is one of those stories that was so big, it was so hot, it was all over social media that we
00:00:41 wanted to cover right away but we had discipline and we decided to save it for Fake News Friday
00:00:45 because it is the perfect example of the kinds of themes and the kinds of things that we talk about
00:00:50 here on Fake News Friday at The Candace Malcolm Show and I'm excited today because I have a special
00:00:55 guest joining me on the program today to help sort of understand and break through some of the
00:01:00 stories and that is Harrison Faulkner. Harrison Faulkner is a producer and a journalist here at
00:01:05 True North. He started out as an intern. He is a student over at Ryerson University in the journalism
00:01:10 program and he jumped on board with True North. So first, welcome to the show, Harrison. Thanks for
00:01:15 joining us. Thanks for having me, Candace. Fake News Friday is my favorite segment and I think we've got
00:01:20 quite a few examples to get into with this one. Exactly and well for you, Harrison, I mean you're
00:01:25 young and you're sort of fresh out of journalism school or I think you're still enrolled over there,
00:01:30 you're almost done, but you sort of see the dynamic of the, I mean Ryerson is sort of one of the most
00:01:37 well-regarded journalism schools in the country. It's right in downtown Toronto so it's sort of like
00:01:42 the woke epicenter of the country and so you know you're coming out of that environment and I'm sure a lot
00:01:48 of the things that we see, the problems that we see at the CBC, you know, you've lived through it and
00:01:53 you know exactly what it's like inside, you know, not that Ryerson is a media company, but the sort
00:02:00 of your professors and the mindset and the attitudes I think that you learn I'm sure is very similar.
00:02:06 Yeah, well one of the things that I'm not sure many readers of the CBC know or readers of the
00:02:10 legacy media know is that a lot of these writers and journalists actually teach classes or they spend some
00:02:16 time actually working in these journalism schools and so I kind of got a bit of a glimpse into where
00:02:22 things were headed with the CBC and some of these legacy media outlets and it really only led me more
00:02:29 and more to outlets like True North because really I just, there was no prospect of me ever working in
00:02:34 one of these newsrooms. It's far too biased, far too woke and they've completely abandoned any
00:02:40 journalistic principles that they once had. So yeah, I mean I got a front row seat to really the
00:02:47 journalist factory, the CBC factory at some of these journalism schools and I got to tell you it's
00:02:53 pretty freaky knowing what's coming down the pike. If it's bad now it's going to get a lot worse in
00:02:58 about five or ten years. Right, well speaking of a front row view, I feel like that's what Canadians got
00:03:05 this week with this sub stack. So I'm gonna go through this a little bit because it's just so
00:03:09 interesting and so much of this, so what happened is Tara Henley, a long-time journalist over at the
00:03:15 CBC, she's a TV producer, radio producer, occasional on-air columnist, she describes herself as a journalist
00:03:21 of 20 years covering everything from hip-hop to news to food to current affairs and she basically just had
00:03:28 enough. She said enough is enough, I don't want to work at the CBC anymore and she kind of did this
00:03:33 expose or this open letter just explaining all of the problems that had gone on on CBC. It very
00:03:39 quickly went viral and really gives us an inside view of what is going on and what is wrong over
00:03:45 the state broadcaster. So I'm just going to go ahead and read a lot. I think it's so good and I'm
00:03:49 shamelessly just going to like read most of this article because I really find it eye-opening. So
00:03:54 the article here is called Speaking Freely, Why I Resigned from the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation
00:03:59 is over on Substack which is a sort of opportunity for a journalist or a writer to kind of own their
00:04:06 own platform, to have their own blog where people subscribe and they send out newsletters. So it kind
00:04:10 of gives journalists the opportunity to kind of be entrepreneurial and do their own thing rather than
00:04:15 working for a big sort of corporate legacy media outlet and it's become really popular for sort of
00:04:21 dissenting thinkers, not necessarily conservatives but people who just don't go along with the sort of
00:04:26 woke mantra dogma that exists on the political left and in legacy media. So here we go. She writes,
00:04:34 For months now I've been getting complaints about the CBC where I work as a TV and radio producer and
00:04:39 occasional on-air columnist for much of the past decade. People want to know why, for example,
00:04:43 non-binary Filipinos concerned of lack of LGBT terms in Tagalog is an editorial priority for the CBC
00:04:50 while local issues of broad concern go unreported. Or why are pop culture radio shows coverage of the
00:04:56 Dave Chappelle Netflix special failed to include any of the legions of fans or comics that did not
00:05:00 find it offensive? Or why exactly taxpayers should be funding articles that scold Canadians for using
00:05:06 words such as brainstorm and lame? Everyone asks the same thing. What is going on at the CBC? I agree
00:05:13 with all this. I think I remember each of those stories and the idea that something different is
00:05:18 going on at the CBC is interesting because from my perspective this has kind of always been the case.
00:05:23 They've always been promoting a far-left worldview. They've always been coming up with really obscure
00:05:27 stories. And the point of most of their journalism is to kind of scold Canadians and blame Canadians
00:05:32 and tell Canadians that we're the problem and that we're racist. So the idea that this is something
00:05:37 that's new, that's happened in the last couple of months or over the last two years, I kind of
00:05:42 disagree. I think it's been happening for much longer. But my point aside, I'll keep reading here.
00:05:46 She writes,
00:05:47 When I started at the National Public Broadcaster in 2013, the network produced some of the best
00:05:52 journalism in the country. By the time I resigned last month, it embodied some of the worst trends
00:05:56 in the mainstream media. In a short period of time, the CBC went from being a trusted news source
00:06:00 to churning out clickbait that reads like a parody of a student press. Again, I would probably refute
00:06:05 the idea that it was ever a trusted source of news, or at least in my lifetime or the, you know,
00:06:10 15 years since I've been a journalist. I don't think the CBC was ever trusted, but maybe in the eyes of
00:06:16 more sort of centrist, middle-of-the-road Canadians that used to be trusted, whereas clearly what
00:06:21 she's talking about here is that they've abandoned the center and they've really gone to the fringe.
00:06:25 Far left, I'll keep reading here. She says,
00:06:28 Those of us on the inside know just how swiftly and how dramatically the politics of the state
00:06:32 broadcaster have shifted. It used to be that I was one of the furthest to the left in any newsroom,
00:06:38 occasionally causing strain in a story meeting with my views on issues like the housing crisis.
00:06:41 I'm now easily the most conservative, frequently sparking tension by questioning identity politics.
00:06:47 This happened in the span of about 18 months. My own politics did not change. I like how she
00:06:51 openly admits that she's a leftist. You know, journalists are supposed to be non-biased,
00:06:56 especially at the state broadcaster. I'm sure that they all sort of claim that they're neutral
00:06:59 and that they're not on the political spectrum. You know, at least she openly admits that she is a
00:07:04 leftist and that she used to try to push the stories. To the left, interesting that she says that she
00:07:09 hasn't changed her views and she's now considered conservative. I know that this is a lot of the
00:07:14 feelings of people who are sort of like old school liberals. They believe in things like,
00:07:18 you know, individual liberty and democracy. And these are the kind of things that the new left
00:07:25 has sort of abandoned. And so leaving a lot of liberals feeling like they're conservative.
00:07:29 I'll keep reading here.
00:07:31 To work at the CBC in the current climate is to embrace cognitive dissidence and to abandon
00:07:36 journalistic integrity. It is to sign on enthusiastically to the radical political
00:07:40 agenda that originated on Ivy League campuses in the United States and spread through American
00:07:44 social media platforms that monetize outrage and stoke societal divisions. It is to pretend that
00:07:50 the woke worldview is near universal, even if it is far from popular with those you know and speak to
00:07:55 and interview and read. To work at the CBC now is to accept the idea that race is the most 0.86
00:08:00 significant thing about a person and that some races are more relevant to the public conversation than
00:08:05 others. It is in my newsroom to fill out racial profile forms for every guest you book. Unbelievable.
00:08:12 And to actively book more people from some races and less of others. It's wild that this stuff is
00:08:18 actually going on at the CBC. The CBC, by the way, has sort of denied that this stuff does take place.
00:08:23 But I know a lot of outlets, including True North, are trying to get their hands on what those racial
00:08:28 profile forms look like and what they actually say, because I have no doubt that they do that kind of thing
00:08:32 over at the CBC. I'll continue. It says, to work at the CBC is to submit to job interviews that are
00:08:38 not about qualifications or experience, but instead demand the parroting of orthodoxies,
00:08:43 the demonstration of fealty to dogma. It is to become less adversarial to governments and corporations
00:08:49 and more hostile to ordinary people with ideas that Twitter doesn't like. I like how she just openly
00:08:54 says that they're not adversarial to government. You know, the whole idea is that they're holding the
00:08:58 government to account. That is the role of a political journalist. And yet we know because
00:09:02 Trudeau funds them. Trudeau pays their bills and they are subservient. They bow down to Justin Trudeau.
00:09:09 They do not hold him accountable. They are not adversarial or hostile to them. Instead, like she says,
00:09:14 they're hostile and adversarial to just regular old Canadians who might have views that are falling
00:09:19 out of fashion. She goes on to say, it is to endlessly document microaggressions, but pay little
00:09:25 attention to evictions, to spotlight companies' political platitudes, but have little interest
00:09:30 in wages or working conditions. It is to allow sweeping societal changes like lockdowns, vaccine
00:09:35 mandates, and school closures to roll out with little debate, to see billionaires amass extraordinary
00:09:40 wealth, and bureaucrats amass enormous power with little scrutiny, and to watch the most vulnerable
00:09:46 among us die of drug overdoses with little comment. Now, this is interesting because this is the kind of
00:09:50 stuff that True North covers, and we're like the only ones that are out there, you know, keeping track of
00:09:55 how many people are dying in Canada from opioid overdoses. You know, we're the ones that are sort
00:10:00 of raising these questions. The CBC should be, and it's interesting to see that at least one journalist
00:10:04 in the CBC or formerly acknowledges that and sees that too. Almost done here, she writes,
00:10:11 it is to consent the idea that a growing list of subjects are off the table, that dialogue itself
00:10:15 can be harmful, that the big issues of our time are already settled. How many times have we heard over
00:10:20 the last decade that the science has settled and that debate is over? We'll go on here. She writes,
00:10:25 it is to capitulate to certainty, to shut down critical thinking, to stamp out curiosity,
00:10:30 to keep one's mouth shut, to not ask questions, to not rock the boat. This while the world burns.
00:10:37 How could good journalism possibly be done under such conditions? How could any of this possibly be
00:10:42 healthy for society? All of this raises larger questions about the direction that North America
00:10:46 is headed. Questions about this new moment we are living through, and its impact on the body politic,
00:10:51 on class divisions, on economic inequality, on education, on mental health, on literature,
00:10:56 and comedy, on science, on liberalism, and democracy. These questions keep me up at night.
00:11:02 I can no longer push them down. I will no longer hold back. This subsect is an attempt to find some
00:11:07 answers, and then she just goes on to lay out what she plans to do and what she plans to write,
00:11:12 and invites people to go ahead and share. So pretty powerful stuff there. I mean, I don't know if any
00:11:17 of it per se surprises me other than the fact that they fill out racial profiling forms and that
00:11:22 they're told to book guests more from one race or another. But Harrison, what is your reaction to
00:11:28 this pretty scathing letter about all the problems over at the CBC? Yeah, I mean, this is really like a
00:11:35 bombshell that I think a lot of people in, especially in conservative media or right-leaning media,
00:11:40 like you said, Candace, we all kind of knew what was being said here. We already knew a lot of this.
00:11:45 It's not that surprising for us, but it really got a lot of traction around, I mean, Fox News picked
00:11:50 it up. A lot of big American blogs picked it up. And this really, I think a lot of Canadians were
00:11:56 waiting to hear this and waiting to see something like this, and clearly it ruffled some feathers.
00:12:00 And, you know, one quote from that article that really got my attention was this line about how in
00:12:06 a short period of time the CBC went from being a trusted source of news to turning out clickbait
00:12:11 that reads like a parody of the student press. Now, as we talked about at the beginning, I haven't,
00:12:15 you know, I'm still in journalism school, and some of the articles I read out of our student
00:12:20 newspapers, I mean, yeah, they're pretty bad, but they're actually a lot better than what you see
00:12:25 on the front page of the CBC. And it kind of makes you scratch your head and think, first of all,
00:12:29 where do they find these people to write these articles? And really kind of where, how has the
00:12:34 CBC gotten to this low of a level? It's really, it's really too bad, but, you know, it's important
00:12:40 to remember that all of us pay for the CBC. So anytime you see a really, a really awful story, you
00:12:44 know, that's your money that went to that. And I think that that's part of why this, this article
00:12:49 from, this article from Tara Henley really, really, you know, made a lot of news. But yeah, I want to,
00:12:55 I want to bring up Andrew Lawton's tweet, our colleague Andrew Lawton, who kind of went,
00:13:00 went at Aaron O'Toole, who of course jumped on this the moment it was published. Aaron O'Toole,
00:13:04 as many of you would know, famously in the leadership election, said that he would
00:13:08 cut English television by 50% and then privatize CBC English TV within his first mandate. So he came
00:13:16 out strong in the leadership election, but by, by the time it came around for the general election,
00:13:21 Aaron O'Toole's stance on the CBC had totally softened. It basically had been brought down
00:13:26 all the way into basically a review of their mandate. So he went from being full on in support
00:13:31 of defunding to just wanting to review them, not rock the boat, make sure the CBC still gave them a
00:13:37 positive, still gave him a positive headline here and there. And clearly none of that has worked.
00:13:41 But O'Toole tweeted that he would like to sit down with Tara Henley and to talk about what can be
00:13:46 done to fix the CBC. And Andrew responded on Twitter and said, during the leadership race,
00:13:52 Aaron O'Toole pledged to unequivocally defund and privatize CBC. During the election,
00:13:57 he pledged to review possible changes to its business model. Now he wants to fix it. So clearly
00:14:01 the, the line from O'Toole, the line from the conservative party has softened on the CBC.
00:14:07 But I think that, I think it's a miscalculation. I think most people
00:14:10 now are ready to see some serious reform to CBC, ready to see some serious change.
00:14:16 It clearly needs it. But of course, not all the response to Tara Henley's articles have been
00:14:22 positive. There have been, there has been some pushback. One article that I think needs to be
00:14:27 brought to the attention of our audience is this hit piece on Henley from Gawker. So Gawker was
00:14:33 basically destroyed in 2016 by Peter Thiel. He bankrupted them and basically wiped them off the,
00:14:38 off the block. And Hulk Hogan, right? Wasn't it Hulk Hogan that they had like published some
00:14:42 stuff about him and he teamed up with Peter Thiel was like a, like a private donor. And they just,
00:14:48 I mean, this is a terrible website, right? It's just like low, low quality clickbait, full on gossip,
00:14:55 like the most salacious kind of things. And yeah, it disappeared. Now all of a sudden it's back to
00:15:00 defend, to defend the CBC and the woke, the woke leftist takeover over there. And it's just like this
00:15:06 terrible junkie site and yet another, you know, leftist squawking voice. I don't, I don't really
00:15:11 understand the business model here, but. Yeah. And so like you, I kind of thought that Gawker had
00:15:16 been, you know, fully erased. Like I thought, I thought Gawker didn't exist. And then we saw this
00:15:20 article. So I did a bit of research. It turns out they, they came back in the summer of this past
00:15:24 summer in 2021, they were relaunched. And so I guess they were relaunched to write articles like this,
00:15:29 which frankly is, is a total joke. So they basically go after Henley for say,
00:15:33 for basically accusing her of, of trying to imitate writers like Glenn Greenwald and Barry
00:15:37 Weiss, who are kind of just, you know, leaving their legacy media jobs and going, searching for
00:15:44 a cheap buck by calling out, you know, legacy media for being too woke and too liberal and just kind
00:15:49 of jumping on this substat grift. It's, it's, it's so ridiculous to call it a grift though. I mean, 0.93
00:15:54 it's like, okay. So someone like Barry Weiss was a columnist at the New York times, the most
00:15:59 prestigious American newspaper. And, you know, she, she, she's kind of like the description we 0.93
00:16:04 were talking about earlier, a liberal, you know, she's by no means on the right in any way. She's 0.99
00:16:08 not conservative. The only position that she might have that would be considered conservative is that 0.73
00:16:11 she's pretty pro Israel, but, but you know, everything else is like she, she, she gave up a
00:16:17 very prestigious position at the New York times as an editor to go completely independent. It's a huge
00:16:22 risk. I don't know how much money she makes from, from a substat, but, but asking people who enjoy 0.83
00:16:28 your work and who read your stuff to, to, to fund you as opposed to going through some big
00:16:33 corporation. I mean, to me, that's honorable. It's like an entrepreneur doing their thing.
00:16:37 And so, and so to just like the way that Gawker does it, just dismiss it as a grift and say that,
00:16:41 you know, they're just trying to make money. It's like, it's probably the opposite. My, my guess is
00:16:46 that most of these names and including Tara here, she's probably making less money, quite a bit less 0.50
00:16:52 money doing her own thing and trying to solicit individual donations versus working at, 0.93
00:16:58 you know, a plush fancy news outlet, like the CBC or the New York times that you, you know,
00:17:04 you get paid really well over there. Yeah. And, and, you know, Gawker is an alternative media site
00:17:08 and you'd think maybe they'd be interested in, well, maybe not propping up these old legacy media
00:17:13 outlets like the CBC and New York times. But I mean, when you read this article, you see exactly
00:17:18 where they're, where they're coming from and you kind of understand, well, actually it doesn't
00:17:21 surprise, shouldn't surprise anyone that they're defending CBC. So a couple of quotes I just have to
00:17:26 bring up. So in, in Tara Henley's Substack article, she, she talked about two CBC headlines,
00:17:31 which I think we've covered on this show before, because they're just so ridiculous. And again, 0.86
00:17:37 it's important to remind everyone listening that when you read these CBC headlines, just know that
00:17:41 your money went to the funding of this, of this journalism. So obviously she, she brings up this
00:17:46 non-binary Filipinos article about how basically it's a question. It's how non-binary Filipinos
00:17:53 reconcile their identities with their language's lack of LGBT terms. So I think everyone can
00:17:58 understand that that is a ridiculous headline, frankly, not something that, you know, should be 0.86
00:18:02 written about in the CBC. But the way Gawker attacks Henley's, you know, sort of interpretation
00:18:08 of this article is just crazy. So they basically call this, they say this in describing this Filipino
00:18:15 article, it is by all standards, a normal and well-reported piece of journalism about language and
00:18:21 colonialism. So, I mean, that is just, that is straight out of the CBC newsroom. That's basically
00:18:26 the way any CBC author would write about this article. And then the second article is about how,
00:18:32 you know, it's racist or it's, it's, it's offensive to basically use modern basic words in,
00:18:40 in the English language. So the CBC published a, published a story, which we covered, which goes
00:18:44 through, you know, words like blackmail. So apparently using that is racist and it comes from a point of
00:18:50 privilege, I guess. And then the, the Gawker article basically said it was wrong to criticize
00:18:56 this, this article because it doesn't scold anybody, but instead provides, but instead provides
00:19:03 context about the evolving meaning of certain words in public discourse. That's so stupid. I mean, 1.00
00:19:08 it's, it obviously, the whole point of the article was to scold Canadians. I mean, it just really,
00:19:13 really like scraping the bottom of the barrel there to defend Terry Hanley. And, and they didn't go
00:19:18 after that. The Gawker article didn't defend the CBC against all these accusations that they're not
00:19:23 focusing on the important issues of her time. I, to me, the most powerful part of Tara Henley's
00:19:28 article and, and, and sub-stack column there was, she was talking about the big questions of her time.
00:19:33 And she was talking about how the way that the, the woke left, even though they, they tend, they,
00:19:37 they pretend to be striving for justice and peace and all these things. It's like, you know,
00:19:44 they're, they're, they're obsessed with race. They're focused on these really niche issues that
00:19:47 don't impact and don't really affect Canadians. And meanwhile, they're ignoring these huge,
00:19:51 huge, you know, growth of government, amassing a power among corporations and, and governments,
00:19:57 without question, you know, really huge societal changes, ignoring them all, ignoring the plight of
00:20:02 the, the, the, the lowest among us, the, the people who are struggling and addicted to drugs,
00:20:08 you know, that stuff gets said. So, so just really kind of a pathetic little response by, 0.95
00:20:15 by Gawker there. But I, you know, Jonathan Kaye over on Twitter has done a really good job.
00:20:20 He's, he's with Colette. He's done a good job of collecting the, the sort of mainstream legacy
00:20:26 media's response to Tara Henley's piece, because you would kind of think that people would applaud
00:20:32 her for her bravery of coming out, that they would recognize that some of the trends that she talked
00:20:37 about, even if we don't agree with everything that she wrote, we would agree that some of the trends
00:20:40 that she talked about were serious and deserved our attention. So instead you see a Toronto star
00:20:46 columnist replying. So Jesse Brown over at Candleland said that he was going to have Tara on his show.
00:20:51 And she just responded by saying, I hope you're joking as if like, how dare you give this person
00:20:56 a further platform? Uh, we, we had other people, uh, straight out accusing her of being a racist 0.99
00:21:03 and a bigot. So this is an individual who's a former correspondent for the Globe and Mail. He wrote
00:21:09 reading the anti-CBC rant by Tara Henley a second time. I found it even more one-sided, superficial,
00:21:14 and wrongheaded feeding into people's anti-CBC prejudices. I love the idea that, that, that if you
00:21:22 don't like CBC, it's because you're prejudiced. It's like the CBC is now like a protected group or
00:21:26 something like that. Um, there are more here. This is an individual who is a, a former journalist,
00:21:32 he says, and a, um, author for Harper Collins. And he wrote, it's very lucrative to write an
00:21:38 anti-woke substack. Racism has all the money and it needs content creators. Again, just not true. 0.93
00:21:44 There's no way that Tara Henley is going to make more money from a substack than she got paid from 1.00
00:21:48 the CBC. Remember they get $1.2 billion a year from the government. Um, I, I don't know how much
00:21:55 Tara Henley is going to raise from her substack, but my guess is it won't be anywhere near a normal
00:21:59 salary for a high paid journalist over at the CBC. This is an executive and administrator over at the
00:22:06 University of British Columbia, UBC. He just makes a point that she is making a conscious decision to
00:22:11 quote, monetize their own racism. So, uh, again, the taking, taking Tara Henley's substack and 0.97
00:22:18 concluding that she's a racist and a bigot, and the whole purpose of it is to monetize off her racism 0.95
00:22:24 bigotry. And that there's a huge audience, uh, for racists in Canada really just shows you how much 0.97
00:22:29 the typical woke leftist hates Canadians. Like the, the whole problem with the CBC, you see it echoing
00:22:35 out, um, on, on, on Twitter here. And John Kay did a really, really good job of that. Well, Harrison,
00:22:42 I want to move on to another story here because this, this one, this one is like the definition of
00:22:46 fake news. The CBC, uh, not surprising another story from the CBC, the CBC basically just invented
00:22:52 a news story here that had no bearing to reality and they were completely caught out
00:22:57 on it. So I'm talking about this poll that they did. They ran a story saying basically flat out
00:23:03 that Canadians don't want to live in Alberta, Alberta bound. Only half of Canadians say they'd
00:23:09 feel comfortable making the move. This is just so ridiculous. So basically the CBC commissioned a poll 0.99
00:23:14 where they only asked Canadians if they would want to live in Alberta. They didn't ask them about
00:23:20 other, other provinces. So the whole point of this article was to attack Alberta, to say that
00:23:25 Canadians don't like Alberta and that most Canadians wouldn't feel comfortable. I'm going to read a
00:23:29 little bit about it because it's just so, it's such a farce. So Alberta bound, only half of Canadians
00:23:34 say they'd feel comfortable making the move. New poll suggests many wouldn't feel at home and worry
00:23:39 climate change mitigation isn't a priority. Okay. This is the start of this article. Cowboys,
00:23:45 nodding oil pump jacks on the prairie landscape, conservative politics. You could fill a Ford
00:23:50 F-150 pickup truck with stereotypes about Alberta, but a new national poll suggests Canadians' views
00:23:56 of Alberta are a lot more complex than the cliches. And so then they talk about how they did this poll
00:24:01 of 1,500 people and they found that 53% don't think Albertans care enough about climate change. So
00:24:09 they're kind of making the point that Canadians don't want to live in Alberta. That's basically the
00:24:14 whole point of this article, kind of saying Alberta is different. We don't like Alberta. 0.99
00:24:18 Most Canadians wouldn't want to live there, wouldn't feel comfortable living here. I mean,
00:24:23 not only is like the whole purpose of this article so transparently, clearly just a attack on Alberta
00:24:29 for no reason, just to say like, look at them, they're different. We hate them. But it's not true.
00:24:33 It's not true. The facts and the statistics in Canada are basically the complete opposite. They're
00:24:38 the complete opposite. I mean, a simple search on Google, if you, if you literally just type in on
00:24:42 Google, what Canadian province has the highest net migration? Meaning what is a province the most
00:24:47 Canadians move to from other provinces? The answer is Alberta. Over the past five decades, Alberta has
00:24:53 had the highest net increase from interprovincial migration from any province. This is a report
00:24:58 from our friends over at the Fraser Institute. And just look at this graph. Okay. The first graph
00:25:02 right here looks at net migration in Canada over the last 40 years from 1970. So, so over the last 45
00:25:09 years. And as you can see, the province where most people have left is Quebec. Of the, of the 45 years
00:25:16 that they, that they kept track out of 43 of them, Quebec has had more people leave the province each
00:25:22 year than come. You can see all the way down. Alberta is the lowest, the least number of people leave
00:25:28 Alberta each year on net. They've had fewer years where more people have, have, have left the province
00:25:33 than come. Next graph right here is even more clear. This is the net cumulative interprovincial
00:25:38 migration. As you can see, almost half a million Canadians have left the province of Quebec over
00:25:44 the last five, four and a half, five decades and gone to other provinces. You can see very clearly here
00:25:50 that Manitoba, Saskatchewan, Newfoundland, New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, and yes, even Ontario have
00:25:55 all had net loss of, of residents. People from those provinces have left the two main beneficiary
00:26:02 provinces, the two places in this country where the most people want to live, British Columbia and
00:26:06 Alberta. More people want to live in Alberta. More people have moved to Alberta. There have been
00:26:11 over a million people moved to those two provinces. More than half, 600,000 have been going to Alberta.
00:26:18 So CBC cooks up this completely fake idea that people don't want to live in Alberta. Meanwhile,
00:26:23 the data, the statistics, the facts back up the exact opposite, that in reality, the choices that people
00:26:29 actually make in this country are to move to Alberta, to vote with their feet, to go to the place where
00:26:35 there is opportunity, where there is freedom, where Alberta is a great place to live. I lived there for
00:26:40 four years during university and I lived in Calgary a little bit later on for a while. It's a great,
00:26:45 wonderful, beautiful place to live and that's what the facts show. But there's CBC over there making
00:26:51 the exact opposite point. Rightly so, they were called out. Jason Kenney, the premier of Alberta,
00:26:56 called it a drive-by smear. He said that he accused CBC correctly of treating the province as a
00:27:03 convenient sort of punching bag. He wondered where the research was on Canadians' attitudes towards
00:27:09 Quebec and Ontario. Well, feeling shameful and being called out, the CBC did what they should have done
00:27:15 the first time. They went back and they redid the survey. They asked all Canadians where they would live
00:27:21 and what did they find. Well, pretty much exactly what the facts show, which is that Canadians say that the place
00:27:27 that they would most like to live is British Columbia as well as Atlantic Canada, probably because the
00:27:32 weather is more temperate and housing prices maybe in eastern Canada would be part of the draw.
00:27:37 Interestingly, that people say that they would want to live in Atlantic Canada, where again, the facts
00:27:41 show the opposite, that people leave Atlantic Canada every year because there's just not a lot of jobs and
00:27:46 not a lot of economic opportunity. But the third place province tied with Ontario right there
00:27:53 is Alberta. More Canadians say that they would feel comfortable living in Alberta. Interestingly,
00:27:59 Quebec was at the very, very bottom of that list. So almost half of Canadians say that they would want
00:28:03 to live in Alberta, whereas only 24% of Canadians say they'd feel comfortable living in Quebec, probably
00:28:10 largely because of the language issue, but still the exact opposite of what the CBC said. So this is a
00:28:15 perfect example of fake news of CBC sitting around saying, let's cook up a news story to demonize
00:28:21 Alberta to make them feel awful, to show how out of step they are on this one issue of climate
00:28:28 change. Meanwhile, forgetting all of the other facts about the situation, all of the nuance, all of the
00:28:33 real world statistics that show literally the opposite. Again, this is why this is why CBC can't be
00:28:40 trusted. What do you think of this one, Harrison?
00:28:43 Yeah, well, there's so much wrong with this, this article, Candace. I mean, I don't always agree with Jason
00:28:48 Kenny, but his characterization of this article is spot on. It's a, it's a smear job. You can just
00:28:53 picture the activists in Toronto sitting around in the newsroom, kind of thinking about how they can,
00:28:58 how they can tweak the data, uh, leave important facts out about Alberta, about the migration,
00:29:04 interprovincial migration of Canadians, and just find every way possible to politicize their news.
00:29:10 Because of course this was, this was characterized as a news piece, uh, to, to find ways to politicize
00:29:14 the news and just tarnish, uh, tarnish a whole swath of Canadians. Um, many of whom don't fit the,
00:29:22 the, uh, the stereotypes that the CBC put in at the beginning of that article. And,
00:29:26 you know, this is, this is a classic problem. I think part of this is, is the bias of omission.
00:29:31 Leaving data out can be just as bad as, as cooking up fake information. Sometimes the, the idea that,
00:29:37 that the CBC would just completely, I mean, they must've done the research themselves. They must've
00:29:43 known that actually the facts tell a different story than this poll they commissioned.
00:29:46 Well, I thought it was interesting, Harrison, that the author of the piece, I went to look up who,
00:29:51 who wrote it, because you kind of assume it might, might be some junior guy writing in Toronto or
00:29:55 something, someone who's never set foot in Alberta. Contrere, uh, this was written by a 20-year
00:30:00 professional reporter, producer over at the CBC, who is also, uh, of course, teaching journalism at
00:30:08 Mount Royal University. So he's in Albertan. He lives in Calgary. He, he, he's been at the CBC
00:30:13 for 20 years. And of course he's, he's a journalism prof as well. Uh, what, what, what shoddy
00:30:18 journalism. And, and I feel sorry for these students who are paying good money to get a
00:30:22 journalism degree over at Mount Royal University being taught, uh, by this kind of individual here.
00:30:26 Yeah. I mean, seriously, it's just, it's just ridiculous. Um, and frankly, this is, this is 0.95
00:30:32 something that always needs to be reminded. And I mean, Albertans pay for their province
00:30:37 to be tarnished and to be written about like this, uh, in the CBC. And I just think, you
00:30:42 know, if you ever needed more of an example of, of the CBC's bias, their, their ability
00:30:48 to spin things just perfectly to fit their ideology, uh, this is, this is, this is it. This must
00:30:53 be the one that, that basically shows to every Canadian, um, you know, the data does not, does
00:30:59 not basically match what they're trying to say. And, you know, of course the CBC would
00:31:03 never try and offend the sensibilities of the front of the Quebecers in Canada. Um, you
00:31:08 know, they would never try and, uh, paint, paint Ontario to be, you know, some desirable
00:31:13 place on equal level as Alberta. Of course, their whole view of the West of the West in
00:31:17 this country is a negative one. Uh, and they'll try and do everything they can in their news
00:31:23 to tarnish Albertans. Uh, and I, I, I, I mean, I think it's partially why no one even, no
00:31:29 one listens to the CBC. They're so irrelevant. Uh, they're grasping for anything they can.
00:31:34 Um, it really, it's, it's a shame to see it because at the end of the day, it is, it is
00:31:38 causing, it's, it's a, it's a negative to Canada. It's not doing us anything positive to have a public
00:31:43 broadcaster write these articles about the country. And it just makes you wonder what their real
00:31:47 goal is. Why would they do this? Their whole, their whole job should be to promote Canada,
00:31:51 to make it a better place, not to try and divide it, uh, regionally.
00:31:54 And, and I thought it was funny because when you read the opening of that story, like, oh,
00:31:58 these, you know, these, these conservatives driving F1, uh, Ford pickup trucks, it's like,
00:32:03 if you, if you drive like an hour outside of any city in Canada, that's what it's like. It's not like,
00:32:09 you know, Alberta is completely different, um, than rural parts of British Columbia, Ontario,
00:32:14 Newfoundland, like any, any rural part of the country has similar characteristics and a similar
00:32:19 culture. And, and this idea that Alberta is just a stark different place, it's, it's, it's untrue.
00:32:24 For any Canadian who has spent time in, in, in Alberta or in any sort of place outside of urban
00:32:31 center, to me, it just shows again, how out of touch. When I read it, I really did think it was
00:32:35 written by some downtown Toronto woke intern and not a 20 year veteran, um, living in Calgary. Well,
00:32:42 Harrison, thank you so much for joining the program. It's been fun to have you on and thank you to the
00:32:46 audience for listening. Look, it's clear that the CBC pushes a divisive race obsessed woke worldview.
00:32:52 It invents fake news meant to divide the country and pit Canadians against each other, all the while
00:32:59 milking us, taking our money and wasting it away. It's time to defund the CBC. It's fake news Friday.
00:33:06 I'm Candace Malcolm, and this is the Candace Malcolm show.