The Candice Malcolm Show - April 14, 2022


Can Canada become a global power? (ft. Irvin Studin)

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Justin Trudeau is determined to censor the internet (Feat. Ezra Levant) How will Trudeau’s internet censorship bills impact True North? (Ft. JJ McCullough)

Episode Stats


Length

38 minutes

Words per minute

177.87

Word count

6,763

Sentence count

388

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

19

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Ervin Studen is the founder and editor-in-chief of Global Brief Magazine, one of the leading international policy thinkers in Canada. He has been a public policy professor and has worked for Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, as well as an Australian Prime Minister. He holds a Bachelor degree from York University, a Master s degree from Oxford University, and a PhD from Osgoode Law School.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Can Canada become a global superpower? Only if we learn to think for ourselves.
00:00:04 I'm Candice Malcolm, and this is The Candice Malcolm Show.
00:00:17 Hi, everyone. Thank you so much for tuning into the podcast. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau
00:00:21 and his deputy, Chrystia Freeland, have a rather small view of Canada when it comes to our role
00:00:26 in the world and on the world stage. They love to repeat their silly little talking point that
00:00:29 Canada is back when the Liberals returned to power in 2015. To them, Liberals are the only ones that
00:00:35 can represent Canada on the world stage. Their perverse ideology that puts internationalism
00:00:40 ahead of Canada's own national interest rules the day. They believe in something called stakeholder
00:00:45 capitalism, where companies as well as governments aren't focused on things like innovation, jobs,
00:00:50 growth, taking care of the population, taking care of the people who work for the companies.
00:00:54 No, no. Instead, they focus on social justice, climate change, mass redistribution of wealth,
00:00:59 and something called equity. The more woke, the better, according to them. Canada is one of the
00:01:03 only countries in the world, one of the only countries in the history of the world to routinely
00:01:07 sacrifice its own national interest in order to virtue signal. We tie one hand behind our back
00:01:14 economically, refusing to develop our own natural resources. And rather than focusing on a grand
00:01:19 vision for Canada, rather than focusing on big national projects, we instead focus on little small
00:01:24 things like gender ideology, climate alarmism, censoring the internet, and recently stoking
00:01:29 division over the issue of COVID. Back in 2017, in a speech that was much applauded by the legacy
00:01:35 media, then foreign minister and World Economic Forum executive Christia Freeland gave a speech
00:01:41 calling Canada a middle power. That's how they see us, an irrelevant third-line role player,
00:01:47 not a superpower, not a relevant figure on the world stage. Well, my guest today has a much,
00:01:52 much bigger vision for Canada. His latest book is called Canada Must Think for Itself,
00:01:57 10 Theses for a Country's Survival and Success in the 21st Century. And in it, he lays out his
00:02:02 vision. So I'm very pleased today to be joined once again by Dr. Ervin Studen. Ervin is the founder
00:02:07 and editor-in-chief of Global Brief Magazine, one of the leading international policy thinkers in Canada.
00:02:12 He has been a public policy professor and has worked for Canadian Prime Minister as well as an
00:02:16 Australian Prime Minister. He holds a bachelor degree from York University. He's a Rhodes Scholar
00:02:21 with master's degrees from Oxford University as well as London School of Economics and a PhD from
00:02:27 Osgoode Law School. So last month, we had Ervin on the show to discuss Canada's post-COVID recovery
00:02:33 strategy. It was a great interview. I really encourage you to go check that out. And we also
00:02:37 talked a little bit about Canada's role in the conflict between Russia and Ukraine. So Ervin,
00:02:42 welcome back to the show. It's great to have you.
00:02:45 It's great to be back. I enjoy your work.
00:02:46 Thank you. So tell us a little bit about what differentiates yourself and your vision for
00:02:52 Canada from the current government and people like Chrystia Freeland who call us a middle power. 0.93
00:02:58 Well, I offer 10 theses for people to consider, not on a discrete basis, but altogether in terms of
00:03:07 our ability to really survive, which is not obvious, and succeed in this century coming out of the
00:03:14 pandemic. Now, the starting point, of course, for the book is my worry about the very survival of
00:03:20 the country before success. And that is counterintuitive to us in Canada, at least it was
00:03:25 before the pandemic, the idea that Canada may not survive in the coming decades. And one just needs
00:03:30 to do a calculation, which I do in the book, about the average lifespan of modern states. And they tend to
00:03:35 be 60 years old or younger, after which they collapse through one of two forces or two forces
00:03:44 combined. One is domestic collapse, constitutional collapse. The second is external collapse, war or
00:03:51 something like a pandemic. And God forbid you should have two of them combined, you'll collapse that much
00:03:55 faster. Now, Canada is well over 150 years old. That means we're pressing our luck on the logic of
00:04:02 things. That means beyond luck, we'll have to be very hard working. Underpinning that hard work is
00:04:08 thinking, we just can't work. And we can't just say we're thinking because we're educated, really has
00:04:12 to be combined in a strategic framework. And that's the overall spirit of the book, I offer the
00:04:18 architecture of our exit from the pandemic, and how we can really survive given the wicked domestic and
00:04:24 external circumstances, and then really flourish as a major country this century.
00:04:28 I remember there's a very famous essay written by Francis Fukuyama in the 90s called The End of
00:04:33 History. And the idea was that everyone will come to the position of Western liberal democracy. And
00:04:39 that's kind of the end point. And there won't be much left in terms of disputes and those kind of
00:04:45 things. So I think people have that mindset. It's a very influential essay. And people just think,
00:04:51 you know, Canada is a stable country, we're a Western liberal democracy, we've got it figured out.
00:04:54 And now it's just about kind of managing what we have and not letting it go. They don't really
00:05:00 think of Canada in terms of having threats, having enemies, that they're being existential threats to
00:05:05 our country, aside from perhaps secession movements, separation movements. Whereas even then,
00:05:11 the idea of Quebec would leave and Canada would continue to be a functional country. But you see
00:05:17 things a little different that we do have threats, that there are potentials that could end Canada as
00:05:23 we know it. So maybe you can walk us through what what you think the biggest threats are to our
00:05:27 country. Thank you very much for painting it. Thus, that is a famous essay. And my father, who's an
00:05:34 immigrant to this country, used to say Canada is a country where you need to invent problems.
00:05:39 So one of the differences between my thinking, to go back to your first question, thinking of the
00:05:43 current government, indeed of recent governments, is that is that I start analytically rather than saying
00:05:48 I have a good idea for Canada. And the analytical point needs to say what are our existential problems
00:05:54 and challenges? What are the problems then to us succeeding over and above existence? The existential
00:06:00 consequences are wicked. Coming out of the pandemic, we have, as I mentioned in our last interview, which I
00:06:06 enjoyed, seven or eight systems crises, really wicked systems crises that we need to manage concurrently,
00:06:14 and they're existential in nature, if any of the systems really collapse outright. I mean, we're
00:06:18 talking about mass, not just death, but the collapse of the country. Domestically, we have four national
00:06:24 unity problems, which any of which could collapse the country in the coming decades. First, the Quebec 0.55
00:06:30 question, which is alive and well and could turn at any point. It's an ongoing thing to manage, but it is
00:06:36 quite sharp coming out of the pandemic, because Quebec has had a very different psychological pandemic
00:06:42 than the rest of the country. But for certainty, if Quebec should ever leave, whatever one feels about
00:06:47 that question. I love Quebec. If Quebec ever leaves, that's the end of the country. That's the end of
00:06:52 the country. The second pressure point is the Western question, which is less existential and more affecting
00:07:00 our ability to succeed and thrive as a country, but is a wicked question, which I'll address, I think,
00:07:05 in my remarks in the keynote at Civitas in Calgary. The Indigenous question makes it very difficult to 0.99
00:07:12 govern the country coming out of the pandemic. And the final one is that we have these internal
00:07:16 borders pockmarking the country physically, psychologically, and in regulatory terms coming
00:07:22 out of the pandemic, such that New Brunswick could close off one day, say only New Brunswickers welcome. 0.99
00:07:27 The North could close off to the rest of the country. Well, we have a country that we don't,
00:07:30 and it takes a century and a half to smooth out this federation and only a couple of years to
00:07:36 collapse its internal cohesion, which before long could tend towards separatist movements and
00:07:41 disintegration. Externally, you mentioned Fukuyama's famous essay that liberal democracy had won,
00:07:48 but I think, in retrospect, Fukuyama was gravely mistaken, because if you ask who between Ronald
00:07:55 Reagan and Mikhail Gorbachev won the Cold War, my answer would be Deng Xiaoping won the Cold War, 0.50
00:08:01 that it was not the Soviet Union or the West democratically. For now, it's China and the Chinese 0.96
00:08:08 model that is central coming out of the pandemic, whether one likes it or not. It's irrelevant.
00:08:13 It's an objective fact. And in the way I paint our geography, China is very close to us on our
00:08:20 western borders. The geography between Shanghai and Whitehorse or Shanghai, where you're originally from,
00:08:28 Vancouver or Prince Rupert or Victoria or Shanghai or New Brunswick or Shenzhen,
00:08:33 then Yellowknife is smaller. The distance is physically smaller than that between Sydney and
00:08:40 Shanghai, Australia. So if the Australians say they're in Asia, which they have for the last 0.96
00:08:45 several decades, we're even more in Asia on the western border. Through our northern front,
00:08:50 the Arctic is melting. I'm not here to say we're going to reverse climate change. Climate change is
00:08:55 a reality at our north. So the north is opening up. The neighbor that we're exposed to all of a sudden
00:09:02 is the one that's at war with Ukraine, we imagine, to our east, but is immediately to our north.
00:09:08 That's Russia. We have America to the south, and we have Europe to the east. These are four new 0.98
00:09:15 wicked borders in their totality. ACRE, America, China, Russia, Europe. And I want to commend that to
00:09:21 all your listeners because it's a key part of my second thesis in the book. Our borders are ACRE. 0.51
00:09:26 These are all great powers. They're far bigger than us. They're far more energetic. And in their
00:09:31 combination, they could crush us or pull us apart very fast in 15 different combinations. So the
00:09:38 domestic pressures and the external threats combined mean that we're going to really have to up our game.
00:09:43 And that's where the thinking for ourselves happens. Because no one, as you'll appreciate,
00:09:48 Candice, no one around the world is saying, how can we do something for Canada? How do we help Canada
00:09:54 survive? Only we can think for ourselves. And it's not obvious that we're there. We're going to really
00:10:00 have to up our game and fight for our lives. And then I suggest later in the book, and we can get to
00:10:05 this, that in fighting for our lives, we will become a major power in our own right, if we make it.
00:10:11 Well, you definitely lay out the threats that we face. And in them could easily be opportunity,
00:10:17 I mean, to go back to the idea that Western separation is a threat, perhaps not an existential
00:10:23 threat. I would say that it's a more serious threat than any of the other ones. I mean,
00:10:29 well, I think also the Aboriginal one, because it undermines the very legitimacy of Canada by calling us a
00:10:37 colonial settler state and saying that Canada is illegitimate. I mean, I don't know how you can
00:10:42 really survive if you think that way. And it seems like many, many people in our institutions,
00:10:46 leading institutions, believe that Canada is illegitimate over this Aboriginal question.
00:10:51 When it comes to the West, though, the idea that we have this resource, this natural resource is
00:10:58 sitting there untapped, undeveloped, intentionally, purposefully, we have a leadership in this country
00:11:03 that does not want to develop our natural resources, because ideologically, it feels
00:11:08 that we have some other greater responsibility to the planet. No other country thinks that way,
00:11:16 no other power thinks that way. In some ways, I think Canada is very stuck. But when you look at
00:11:22 the North and conceptualizing Canada in the way that you do, I wonder if that could create more
00:11:29 opportunities to develop natural resources, more export paths to the North, to Russia, to China.
00:11:36 That way, do you see it as a potential opportunity? And how can we take advantage of that opportunity?
00:11:41 A hundred percent. It is the actual fourth thesis of the book. I start with our pressures,
00:11:47 our crises. Then I say that we have a dyad of futures, and none of them is that of a middle power.
00:11:55 A middle power is a slogan, but I prove in the book, I hope that middle powerdom is impossible for 0.98
00:12:01 Canada. It is either major power, I'm not even saying great power, major power amongst these major
00:12:07 powers at our borders by virtue of surviving, or a deep vassal state really crushed. And through all
00:12:15 these major powers playing across our territory, our information space, our geography, crushing us,
00:12:21 doing all the thinking on their terms. And in the end, because some of these major powers are either
00:12:26 cynical or in the United States case, not sufficiently wise to do all our thinking, we could live very
00:12:35 miserably. And I would argue in the book that we are tending towards the latter, whereas the preferable
00:12:41 is to be a major power. And in doing so, lifting our boat, but requiring huge thinking. So the thinking,
00:12:49 and you intimated very correctly, is that amongst these threats, there's real opportunity.
00:12:55 And the opportunity is through the north. And what I say is that this northern border,
00:13:03 the R, part the C, part the A, is the Arctic border. Now, in the south, in Vancouver, in Ottawa,
00:13:11 and Toronto, we imagine the Arctic as this frozen wasteland. But I want us to imagine the Arctic as
00:13:17 Toronto, Ottawa, Vancouver, just another border because it's opening up.
00:13:21 And that territory is as large as the entire European Union.
00:13:30 Yukon is as big as France. Northwest territory is as big as France, Germany, and Ukraine combined,
00:13:36 and none of it bigger than each of the other two. All told, the size of the European Union,
00:13:41 almost exactly. Do the calculation. What is the population for that territory? It is 115,000
00:13:49 strong for a territory that is opening up objectively. That's the size of Ajax, Ontario,
00:13:55 facing these giants at our border. Russia, 150 plus million people. China, a billion and a half.
00:14:02 The United States, 330 million. The European Union, 500 million. They're all at our borders, 0.99
00:14:07 and all of them touching the Arctic. So we need to up our energy, that is human energy first,
00:14:12 our demographic footprint, our political footprint, up towards the North, almost a shift away from the
00:14:19 South, which we imagine to be the existential game that's relevant. We need to up it. And instead of
00:14:27 imagining that we're going to war against Russia, China, or the United States, or the North, we embed
00:14:32 them in a framework that is of our own divination. We create the thinking. And that's why the second,
00:14:37 the fourth thesis called Canada becomes the center of the world through a city like Whitehorse,
00:14:43 Inuvik, or Yellowknife. We imagine they become the Singapore of the North. And so we imagine 10, 0.98
00:14:48 15 years from now, business people, businessmen and women taking regular flights from the North
00:14:54 to Shenzhen, to Shanghai, to St. Petersburg, to Oslo, to Chicago, just as we do through the South,
00:15:02 because it's opening up. And if we don't do the thinking, other powers will do it for us. But if we
00:15:06 do the thinking, we become filthy rich. And we also embed these countries in a framework of peace,
00:15:13 because the total market through the North is seven times larger than continental North America
00:15:19 alone. And we have geographic proximities that favor us. We just need to invest and do that thinking,
00:15:25 have the courage to build the framework where other countries are favored to have that courage.
00:15:31 They are the thinking countries, the term setting countries, like the United States, like China,
00:15:37 like Russia. These are countries that are hyper energetic, they're ready to build the framework,
00:15:41 and they're ready to vassalize us psychologically first. And I say we up our game, we will embed them
00:15:47 in our own framework. So we have to move fast, but we need to see our geography and the opportunity
00:15:51 first.
00:15:52 I remember when I was in high school, I was fortunate enough to go on an exchange program
00:15:56 to Europe. And so I was flying from Vancouver to Frankfurt. And, you know, at the time I was 16,
00:16:02 I imagined flying in an airplane all the way across Canada, all the way across the Atlantic,
00:16:06 and going to Europe. And I remember watching a little airplane on the screen. And at one point,
00:16:12 the pilots look out the window, you can see the Arctic ice caps. And it's like, oh, no, we didn't fly
00:16:16 across the continent. We flew over, right? And that's, that's how you get from the West Coast
00:16:20 over to Europe. And in a flight, we don't really conceptualize Canada that way. Why aren't there
00:16:26 flights that go through the North? Why, why, why don't we have more development up there? Why don't
00:16:29 we have airports? Why don't we have the basis of the infrastructure up there? And how, and how do we
00:16:34 get that built?
00:16:35 For the same reason that you articulate that the West is the most wicked of our national unity problems.
00:16:43 I concur. It's the first national unity problem I identified. The capital is in Ottawa. The capital
00:16:49 is in Ottawa originally because the strategic threat of Canada to go back to our genesis and
00:16:54 this idea of our borders was the United States. In 1867, Canada is created as the antithesis to the
00:17:02 American project. That is just a constitutional reality. It's particularly in the first paragraphs
00:17:07 of the Constitution. That is why all of the major cities and all the major economic activity
00:17:15 limb the southern border, not because it is warm. Anybody who's been to, to Winnipeg or Ottawa
00:17:21 at any particular time outside of summer knows that it's not, we're not there for meteorological
00:17:27 reasons. We're there because all the forts lined the southern border because the Americans were the 0.99
00:17:32 threat all the way to the west. The railroad went east-west and the cities followed and the
00:17:38 economic activity followed thereafter. And then the mythology of climate as the reason that we're
00:17:45 there because it's warm in the south and not in the north. And then the idea that the current
00:17:49 mythology that the Americans are enduring friends. Well, the Americans are our friend today, but in my
00:17:55 read of things, they are just another country and they are thinking in their own interests. And one
00:18:00 day that could turn against us, right? Even in annexation terms. And that should be understood,
00:18:06 including through the north. So now we understand the north is opening up in a way that was not true
00:18:10 over the last 150 years, just as China is relevant in a way that was equally untrue over the last 150
00:18:17 years. When Canada's created, China is just recovering from the opium war. So it's destabilized for
00:18:23 the entire modern existence of Canada. Now Russia and China are right at our borders, as I just
00:18:28 depicted. And so that border alignment, that border thinking needs to be shifted up from the American
00:18:34 axis up to that AC axis. And Ottawa is not there psychologically. Ottawa, as we discussed, I think,
00:18:44 in the last interview and even offline, has been self-isolating for two years. I mean, literally,
00:18:49 they've been zooming the entire country and imagining that they're governing through their
00:18:53 intellect, purely the second largest country in the world, not even understanding our geography,
00:18:59 neither intellectually nor in a felt way. And I want, I commend to all colleagues, all patriots of
00:19:05 Canada to feel our geography. It is huge. Canada, we must appreciate, that's why I reject the idea of us
00:19:12 us ever being a small country. If you, if you total the country, the geography of Canada, we are as
00:19:19 large as the Roman, Persian and Ottoman empires combined. That is the territory of Canada. That's
00:19:24 how big we are. We are, we are empire sized. We don't have an imperial mentality. Fair enough. I'm not
00:19:29 for that. But we need to think commensurately with our geography, because it is now opening up. And we
00:19:36 will be dominated on that geography, if we don't play at the right level. As it's opening up, Ottawa
00:19:41 needs to think, push its thinking up, up north. And in so doing, I also argue that they can address
00:19:47 in a very meaningful way, the Western problem, because much of the West is collected to the North
00:19:53 in psychological terms, particularly Yukon and parts of Northwest territories, Nunavut a little less.
00:19:58 And there is a huge energy proposition there. There's a huge scientific proposition. There's a
00:20:03 huge transport proposition. There's an environmental proposition. We have a new university that's just
00:20:10 come online through Yukon University. In 10 or 15 years, I'd like to see five major universities across
00:20:16 the North, literally in the Arctic, one of them offshore. I'd like to see 10 million people living
00:20:22 across the Arctic as it opens up by the end of the century. That's perfectly normal for a geography
00:20:27 that opens up. And we'll have some major cities. Just as a century ago, Vancouver was a village,
00:20:34 and Montreal was superior to Toronto. These things change. So we don't imagine that tomorrow everyone
00:20:40 will move to Toronto. I find it less attractive than other parts of Canada today anyways. But for
00:20:45 strategic reasons, we're going to have to shift our energy and get out there, get out there en masse and
00:20:51 see the country and build. One of the things that I took interest in, and this is really well
00:20:57 documented in the US, was migration during COVID. A lot of people in the US left sort of poorly
00:21:03 governed blue states, states governed by Republicans, places like California and New York that had really
00:21:09 restrictive COVID policies. And they were also dealing with wicked crime increases and just a
00:21:15 growth in the cost of living. A lot of families left those kind of places and went to so-called red
00:21:19 states, places that had lower taxes, that had more job opportunities, and that were incentivizing people 0.58
00:21:26 to come. I know both Florida and Texas saw huge increases in their population. At one point,
00:21:32 Florida was offering $1,000 bonuses to any police officer who wanted to move to that state. We didn't
00:21:37 see much of that in Canada, though. There wasn't really a lot of migration. There wasn't really a lot
00:21:42 of option when it came to, where can I go to escape restrictive COVID policies? Where can I go to raise a
00:21:48 family in a way that I can afford? I know a lot of people leave Toronto because they just cannot afford
00:21:53 a house. When I was reading your book and talking to you last time, thinking about the North, thinking
00:21:59 about all of this land that we have, and yet not a lot of people, I wonder if there could be some kind
00:22:05 of incentive for people, like in terms of a place where you can go and raise a family, you can afford a
00:22:12 single-family home, you can have a kind of more traditional, simplistic lifestyle if you were willing
00:22:18 to move up North. I wonder, have you seen any politician talking about this kind of stuff? Any
00:22:25 sort of grand idea of how to move people to places in this country where they can have a better lifestyle,
00:22:33 aside from everyone sort of congregating in and around places like Toronto and Vancouver?
00:22:38 Well, we had a collapse in thinking over the last two years. The collapse in thinking over the last
00:22:46 two years that you articulate is built on the general absence of real thinking in the years prior
00:22:54 because we weren't forced by circumstance, as I mentioned my father rightly said, until the pandemic
00:22:59 had Canada had to invent its problems. In a comparative sense, we had small public tragedies,
00:23:06 but we didn't have any war on our territory for the entire 20th century in any meaningful way.
00:23:13 And we didn't have the Quebec collapse in the mid-1990s or the early 80s that could have also
00:23:20 torn the country asunder. And all of the other continents of the world had it. So now it's our
00:23:24 turn. We are following the laws of history. So to think, a country that thinks also says,
00:23:31 how do we make sure that we have the right quantum of population, the right quality, and that people in
00:23:38 our country are happy and dynamic and also are mobile across the territory? By the way, when I talk
00:23:45 about people moving to the North, I don't just talk about foreigners necessarily. It could be Canadians
00:23:50 that see opportunity. And one of the things quietly, maybe even cunningly, that I have in the book is that
00:23:55 the North makes the demographic about which I'm most worried in Canada dream again. That's the young 1.00
00:24:01 people. When you talk about the North and the future of the country, as I see it, that excites
00:24:06 young people who have really suffered most over the last two years in Canada, in my view, unforgivably.
00:24:12 It's exciting. You see the entire world, it is close to us, and we have the wrong imagination,
00:24:18 the wrong imaginary from the South of the North. We imagine to be a frozen iceberg that's unlivable,
00:24:23 and it's exactly the opposite. It's to be built, it's to be tamed, it's to be connected to the rest
00:24:29 of the world. As I mentioned, the North connects us to a market of seven billion people, seven,
00:24:34 oh sorry, two billion people through the North, which is seven times larger than continental North
00:24:40 America, and four continents. So then I imagine a young person living in the North can live just as
00:24:46 as well as perhaps you did or I did growing up in the big cities of the South, with as much culture,
00:24:53 with as much mobility, but proximity. It would take an overnight trip to St. Petersburg or Shanghai or
00:24:59 Chicago or Oslo, as I mentioned. You want to go to London, or you go to another part of the North,
00:25:04 because I imagine the three territories connected. So easily you go from Whitehorse to
00:25:07 to Inuvik overnight, and you have a nice stay, you eat in a nice restaurant, you have some reindeer
00:25:15 for dinner, you take a course at the university in Northwest territories, and you go back home to a
00:25:25 nice lifestyle. Now the cost of living is high in the North, it's actually higher than in the South.
00:25:31 That has a lot to do with geographic distance, the fact that all the economic activity is imagined
00:25:38 to be in the South, but also through a lack of density of populations. We're going to need more
00:25:41 people in the North, more people actually will reduce the unit costs of housing and food in the North,
00:25:50 not the South, and also the unit costs of transportation, and make my life more interesting.
00:25:55 It also serves our interests for sovereignty purposes and for the opportunity, I suggest,
00:26:00 to have more people eventually move to the North. But as I say, it's not a painful proposition. I find
00:26:06 it very exciting once someone understands that it is opening up much like Canada did in the late 19th
00:26:14 and early 20th century for people who want to build life for themselves.
00:26:17 One of the things you hear about is that back then, the government was offering land plots,
00:26:23 like people were given plot of land or some kind of a bundle incentive to go live in the West to
00:26:30 develop Saskatchewan or given some farmland in Alberta. Could you see a program like that where
00:26:35 Canadians, maybe even First Nations Canadians are incentivized by being given land that they could
00:26:41 go develop? Or what other kinds of things can we do to get this plan in motion?
00:26:46 A hundred percent. And you began to hint at that when you said that over the last few years, we've
00:26:53 actually lost a lot of people, a lot of good people in Canada, and no one's keeping track.
00:26:57 And we're loath to get them back because they were psychologically, they've moved on. It's a big loss
00:27:01 for us. We've not had to work hard. And this is an area in which we're going to need to work hard
00:27:06 to get the right quantum and the right talent. And there needs to be a very deliberate choreography.
00:27:10 Choreography can't just be, just fill the place up. I'm not for that, even for the South. I'm for
00:27:14 very bespoke choreography. And that means business leaders, civil society leaders, and government
00:27:22 leaders getting on the phone, getting out into markets, into other countries, into other parts
00:27:28 of Canada, and recruiting actively. Make them offers that they cannot refuse because we want them.
00:27:34 Now, we also have a very intuitive but incorrect psychology in Canada in respect to recruitment.
00:27:40 We say, well, we'll come to the North when there's a job. And I say, no, we want the job makers,
00:27:46 in many cases. I remember being at a conference in the Middle East, and they were more curious about
00:27:52 the Arctic than we are in Southern Canada. And they said, well, if I look at that geography,
00:27:57 I think I could employ a thousand people within a year. And that's the type of person we want in
00:28:02 the North. We want the term setters. They come and we're, as perhaps I and someone else don't see
00:28:09 a job, a discrete job to be filled. They say, I'm going to employ a thousand people in the community
00:28:14 from across Canada and from across the North within a year and multiply that. These are term
00:28:20 setters that will help us make a term setting future. And you talk about the Indigenous population,
00:28:25 they are in many cases, the term setters that we'll need, or they're the ones that will want them.
00:28:30 There's some very, very energetic, ambitious, self-governing First Nations in the North that
00:28:35 are very practical, that are interested in talent. We just, in a very Canadian way, don't know how to
00:28:41 make offers. We don't know how to sell. And now we're going to have to learn to sell. Selling involves
00:28:47 the thinking that I command in the work and thinking goes hand in hand with the work that is needed to
00:28:52 build up that huge territory. Well, one of the things that I read in your book, and I've seen this argument
00:28:58 many times, and I instinctively reject it and disagree with it, is this idea that Canada should
00:29:03 deliberately grow its population to 100 million people. Whenever I hear that argument, I think of
00:29:09 people who just sort of want to wholesale bring other people, other cultures, and displace Canadians, or
00:29:14 sort of ignore the Canadian population, or is sometimes so condescending. It's like the idea is that
00:29:21 we need to bring other people in to civilize us and enlighten us on other cultures and other values. And it
00:29:26 seems that the people who lead these kinds of discussions almost have a dislike of the original
00:29:34 Canadian population. I'm wondering what your vision is and why we need to import people from around the
00:29:41 world in order to, why we need to get to 100 million and why we need to import people from around the
00:29:46 world to get there. A lot of the 100 million arguments over the last decade and a half start with my own
00:29:52 work. It started as an idea proposition, just a thought experiment. But now I mean it very much
00:29:57 in strategic terms. That is to say, on the current population of 38 million, we will be vassalized and
00:30:04 poor. And that is our current trajectory. So we can tweet as much as we want. We love Canada, we're
00:30:10 patriotic, we're democratic. But on the ground, we will become non vital in economic terms, politically
00:30:19 less connected. And you mentioned the connection between Ottawa and the West, which is also also
00:30:23 has to do in part with demography and non sovereign on our own territory and vassalized by other countries
00:30:30 that are larger and more energetic. So it is also an energy proposition, human sense, more people,
00:30:36 more energy, bigger companies, bigger markets, more transportation. I have, I think, a powerful table
00:30:42 in there, which I talk about the basic thing of, of high speed rail, we have, the Japanese created their 1.00
00:30:48 first high speed rail lines in the 1960s. Now, how many have we got in Canada in the year 2022? Still zero,
00:30:58 and zero for any foreseeable future, where even where, where high speed rail is already passe. And
00:31:03 there's nothing possible on that on current demography. But with larger demography, we can not just have
00:31:11 that we can have, we get larger capital markets, larger intellectual markets, better, a better
00:31:17 cultural space. But let's talk about the North. I mentioned that there are 115,000 people in the North
00:31:24 for a territory that we control for now, the size of the European Union. That is a strategic nonsense.
00:31:32 It is strategic nonsense, given that the surrounding market is, is 2 billion people, that the immediate
00:31:37 strategic neighbor for now a threat, I see before long, an opportunity, the Russians have 115 million 1.00
00:31:44 people. If you juxtapose, as I do in the, in the, in the book, the distribution of their population,
00:31:51 of their 150 million people, they have 2 million plus in on the, on the Arctic front, facing our 115,000.
00:32:00 And although they're larger, they're not that much larger to command such a disproportionate
00:32:05 superiority in ratio. So we're going to need many more people simply to govern ourselves in the North.
00:32:11 How many more? I'm actually indifferent between 80 million and 100 million and 120. Those are just
00:32:17 quanta to make people think it could be 70 million, but we're going to need about 10 million in the North
00:32:23 to govern ourselves, to manage this huge geography that's opening up. And 10 million in the North
00:32:28 means that we're going to need proportionately larger bases in the middle of the country. Now
00:32:33 we're talking about places like Thunder Bay, or even Churchill, Manitoba, further North,
00:32:39 and down to the current large metropolises where we imagine, whether we imagine,
00:32:44 whence we imagine everybody, whether we imagine everybody immigrating. We'll imagine that everyone's
00:32:48 going to come to the GTA. I don't want everyone to come to the GTA. I don't want more neighbors.
00:32:52 I want people to be properly distributed across the country through choreography. And I do want
00:32:58 to maintain the majority-minority equilibrium that you talk about. There needs to be a very bespoke 0.91
00:33:03 choreography. But we're not doing that. Even on the current immigration structure, it's very lazy. 0.64
00:33:09 It's quite laissez-faire. And it has no appreciation of our geography and our sovereignty needs and the
00:33:14 opportunities that I talk about.
00:33:16 Well, and it has no appreciation of the difficult work involved in integration, right? You talk about
00:33:24 a threat to Canada being that we could become a vassal state for all of these other more powerful
00:33:27 countries. It's like, if we just start importing people from those more powerful countries and don't
00:33:32 give them any guidance, don't give them any integration into our country and just say,
00:33:37 yeah, welcome to Canada. We don't really like ourselves. We don't have a lot of confidence.
00:33:40 We have this horrible history and we're humiliated by it. Come do whatever you want, basically.
00:33:44 And that's kind of the message delivered to newcomers. And I agree that it needs to be more
00:33:51 coordinated. It needs to be more deliberate if we're going to want to sustain the unity that we
00:33:57 have or at least build unity, continue towards being one country. So Irvin, just final question for you
00:34:06 here. You know, you spent a lot of time thinking about Canada. You kind of boiled it down here to 10
00:34:13 very succinct theses for the country. What is your grand vision for Canada? Where do you see Canada
00:34:19 in 2050? Where do you see Canada in 2100? And what do you hope for Canada?
00:34:26 In the last thesis, the 10th, my favorite, I paint 10 steps for Canada post-pandemic. By the way,
00:34:35 one of which would interest you personally, I talk about creating a special economic environmental
00:34:44 zone for the entire west and north of the country to really give us energy and to open our wings. I talk
00:34:50 about movement of assets in the country, both political and economic, more to the west and
00:34:56 to the north because of the China-Russia axis, which is underserviced. 2050, I hope I'm around and
00:35:04 vital. In 2100, I plan to be around and vital. I hope that Canada is around. It's not obvious.
00:35:10 Canada is my team, so I'm always fighting for it and I'm thinking about it. I'm grateful, but now I
00:35:17 realize that it's much more of the gratitude that is required for us to keep fighting. I imagine us
00:35:22 to be the second major country in the west in the year 2050, second only to the United States,
00:35:32 larger essentially in both demography and power and influence and self-belief than any Western
00:35:40 European country, any European country other than Russia, which by that point will have different
00:35:45 borders anyways. I also, however, imagine us to be connected very non-ideologically to all the
00:35:52 major countries in the world. This is an essential point. I'm very non-ideological in my strategizing
00:35:59 for Canada and must be so because if we're too dogmatic, we will get crushed. We can be dogmatic
00:36:04 on Twitter, but we need to be, I call it strategically promiscuous in our strategy. We need to have good
00:36:11 relationships with all these border countries because otherwise they will crush us. And that's 0.99
00:36:15 how a cunning, clever, calculating country that's at scale operates. So we'll have good relations,
00:36:22 not just with the United States, but with China, with Russia, with all the European countries. And then
00:36:28 after that, with India, with Africa, all to our advantage, first and foremost, and survival. And then I 0.72
00:36:35 hope, and this is my larger interest, in the service of humanity, which is the more interesting
00:36:40 condition. But first and foremost, we have to do it through Canada, which is, as I mentioned,
00:36:45 as I commend in the book, worth fighting for. Well, that's absolutely, I really encourage people to
00:36:53 go and check out your book. Where can they find your book right now, Irvin? Well, for the coming months,
00:36:58 it's going to be an e-book, so they can check it on the Global Brief site. They can purchase it there
00:37:03 on the Institute for 21st Century Questions, i21cq.com site. And I hope they love it. And
00:37:11 before long, we'll be in print as well. And I'll continue to talk about it. It's highly topical.
00:37:19 And as Irvin also mentioned, he's going to be giving a keynote address at our Civitas conference
00:37:24 this year. So if you're interested in coming out to Calgary and seeing that conference, checking it out,
00:37:29 go over to civitascanada.ca. You can find out more information about the organization,
00:37:34 about the conference, and you'll be able to come and see Irvin deliver that keynote address. So,
00:37:40 Irvin, thank you so much for your time. It's always so interesting to talk to you. Thanks for sending
00:37:43 me over a copy of your book. I really am enjoying it. I'm not quite done yet, but I'm enjoying working
00:37:48 my way through, and I look forward to seeing you in Calgary. Me too. See you soon. Thanks for your work.
00:37:52 All right. Thank you so much for tuning in. I'm Candice Malcolm, and this is The Candice Malcolm Show.
00:37:59 I'm Candice Malcolm.