The Candice Malcolm Show - December 14, 2021


Canada’s insignificant role on the world stage

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
True North’s Investigative Reporting EXPOSES Critical Race Theory in Canada Canada just banned clinical therapy for children thinking of transitioning

Episode Stats


Length

30 minutes

Words per minute

170.78

Word count

5,252

Sentence count

197

Harmful content

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, Candice is joined by Conservative MP Garnett Genis to discuss the government's new bill to ban conversion therapy in Canada, and why he thinks it's a bad idea. They also discuss why the Conservative Party stopped opposing the bill and voted in favour of it.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 In 2015, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau told the world that Canada is back. Well, in the six years
00:00:06 since, he has embarrassed the country over and over again, and Canada is more significant than
00:00:10 ever. I'm Candice Malcolm, and this is The Candice Malcolm Show.
00:00:17 Hi, everyone. Thank you so much for tuning into the show. And as we get closer to Christmas,
00:00:22 we'd like to take a step back and take a broader look at the country, look at some of the deeper
00:00:27 themes as the news cycle slows down a little. And we are doing that today. I'm delighted to be joined
00:00:32 by a member of Parliament, a Conservative Member of Parliament, Garnett Genis. Garnett is the MP for
00:00:37 Sherwood Park, Fort Saskatchewan. He was first elected in 2015, has been re-elected with more
00:00:42 than 50% of the vote in every election since. In Parliament, he has been a vocal proponent for
00:00:48 Alberta's interest in Ottawa, fighting back against the carbon tax and advocating for more Canadian
00:00:52 oil and gas. Garnett currently serves as the Conservative Critic for International Development.
00:00:58 In his time as an elected official, he has prompted a return to Canada's principled foreign policy,
00:01:03 and has gained a reputation for being a tireless advocate for human rights and religious freedoms,
00:01:08 both domestically and abroad. So, Garnett, thank you so much for joining us today.
00:01:12 Well, thank you, Candice. It's great to be with you and have this conversation.
00:01:15 So, I want to talk about foreign policy, and we will get there. But before, there's just one
00:01:20 question that I really want to ask you about a recent bill that received unanimous consent
00:01:26 and passed without a vote in the House of Commons. And I'm talking about the government's bill on what
00:01:31 they call conversion therapy. So, I know that you ran a campaign on this topic. You said everyone,
00:01:37 in theory, opposes the idea of conversion therapy. I think that the name of the bill was called
00:01:43 conversion therapy because it elicits such a negative response when people hear about it.
00:01:47 They think of a sort of outdated, cruel practice. And yet, your criticism of it was that the bill was
00:01:54 too broad and too vague. And because of the vagueness and the broadness of the wording,
00:01:59 it could actually have a negative impact on freedom of speech. It could ban just normal conversations
00:02:05 between teenagers and their parents, between qualified therapists, between members of their church.
00:02:11 If someone seeks on their own, you know, freely seeks to go get counseling, that could actually
00:02:17 be banned by this law. And yet, you know, when it came through the House of Commons,
00:02:22 all of the Conservatives voted in favor of it. This is after twice opposing the bill. And from best
00:02:28 I can tell, it hadn't been rewritten, and those definitions hadn't been changed. So,
00:02:32 I want to ask you your opinion on this bill, and why is it that the Conservatives stopped opposing this bill?
00:02:37 Sure. Well, I guess a little bit of the context. I think, you know, in general terms, you describe
00:02:48 my position on this issue well. I'm opposed to conversion therapy. I support efforts to ban 1.00
00:02:56 conversion therapy. I think when we legislate, we need to look at the definitions that are given
00:03:03 to that terminology. If you ban something that everybody agrees should be banned, and yet you
00:03:08 define it in a way that is incorrect in terms of the way people conceive of the definition,
00:03:16 then you've ended up banning something other than the thing you set out to ban. I use the analogy in
00:03:22 the House. If you say, we're going to ban hard drugs, I'm with you. If you call coffee a hard drug
00:03:29 through an error of the definition, then I'm going to be not with you. So,
00:03:35 this is something that, you know, that I think it's a pretty clear thing to point out to say,
00:03:41 hey, like, let's analyze the bill. Let's look at the definition used in it. And in particular,
00:03:47 in the last parliament, I spoke about the need to fix the definition in then Bill C-6, because
00:03:53 the issue was that the definition included, it was broad enough to include even private
00:04:02 conversations, not involving a therapist or official person of any, or just a conversation.
00:04:08 And it was broad enough that it defined as conversion therapy, any effort to reduce sexual
00:04:15 attraction or behavior. So I think a reasonable inference from that is that like a conversation
00:04:21 in which a mentor tells a young person that they should modify their sexual behavior in some way,
00:04:28 that that would be construed under the definition as being conversion therapy. And that's obviously
00:04:33 not what conversion therapy is. When people who, I mean, many people aren't aware of this,
00:04:37 but when people who are aware of conversion therapy, they understand that to mean acts of violence,
00:04:43 coercion, degrading someone efforts to sort of compel a change in sexual orientation, it's, you know,
00:04:53 those are methods that were sort of experimented with at times in the past. And look, they're wrong,
00:05:00 they're degrading, they're evil, and also they don't achieve the stated objective. So it's a bit of a
00:05:08 language trick on the government's part to say, you know, you know, if you, if you, if you are,
00:05:14 if you're in favor, if you're against this bill, then you're in favor of conversion therapy, allegedly,
00:05:19 but then demanding a lack of scrutiny around the definition. You know, Candace, you asked some
00:05:25 questions about, about process, just, I'll just share with folks that, you know, we're gonna, we're gonna be
00:05:30 talking a lot about foreign policy, I was in Europe for NATO and OSCE meetings last week. And I'm sure
00:05:39 we'll get to just the, the emerging security concerns in, in Eastern Europe as a, as a result of
00:05:46 the aggressive posture that Russia was taking, I was, I was invited to be part of, of a parliamentary
00:05:53 delegation that was present for those meetings. And to be honest, I would not have expected
00:06:00 the process that was followed before I, before I went on the trip. I, I didn't expect to be,
00:06:07 to be missing votes. And so I've had some conversations with colleagues about, you know,
00:06:13 how, how this unfolded, but I, I can't really speak to the process piece, because those were
00:06:18 things that I either wasn't involved in, or to the extent that I know about them, I know about them
00:06:23 because of, because of private conversations I've had with other colleagues.
00:06:26 Well, it's interesting, because you said that it's a word trick, and it's with a definition,
00:06:31 the media bought right into it. So the whole idea was, oh, there's these 63 conservative MPs
00:06:36 who support this harmful practice called conversion therapy, even though you ran a campaign that was
00:06:42 pretty clear, called change, fix the definition that said that you were opposed to literal conversion
00:06:47 therapy, but you were not in favor of this bill because of the wording. So we saw a lot of dishonesty
00:06:52 across the board. And I think for a lot of conservatives, it was just strange to see
00:06:57 you guys abandon a bill that you had previously, abandon opposing a bill that you previously had a
00:07:02 really strong opposition to, and then just sort of, you know, having this, I guess, feel good moment,
00:07:07 not over where everyone agrees, which is not really what you want in your parliament, you want
00:07:11 opposition, but yeah, let's move on. So why don't you tell us a little bit about what, what you're
00:07:15 working on with regards to NATO and the aggression of the Russian government towards Ukraine?
00:07:20 Well, so last week, I was in Latvia for a couple days on the sidelines at the NATO summit that was
00:07:31 happening there. And then I was in Stockholm, where the OSCE summit was, and a lot of interesting
00:07:39 conversations with respect to the situation in Eastern Europe. I think it's important for more
00:07:45 people to know just about the, the important leadership role that Canada is playing as part
00:07:51 of our NATO mission in Latvia. And this is something that obviously has the support of,
00:07:56 of all parties being, being an active participant in NATO, being part of that NATO, NATO forward presence.
00:08:02 And, you know, if you, if you go to Holland, there's a lot of, there's a lot of gratitude,
00:08:08 of course, to Canada for the role we play to liberation during the Second World War. In Latvia,
00:08:14 there, there's a lot of recognition of Canada as well, for the fact that we're leading a battle
00:08:18 group there and, you know, full, full credit to our, our armed forces for the incredible work they do
00:08:24 around the world. Sometimes not with the level of resources from, from government that, you know,
00:08:31 certainly we've, we've talked in the past about, about increasing our, our, our, our defense
00:08:38 engagement and moving towards that, that NATO target of 2% of GDP. So, so, so there's a lot
00:08:47 of awareness of the fact that there's a Russian military buildup, increasing Russian military
00:08:52 activities and, you know, concern about what steps may be, may be taken next by Russia. And I don't think
00:09:00 that'll be a new information by, to, to many people, but I just think we need to, we need to
00:09:06 really take seriously the possibility that, that the Putin regime are planning something and we need
00:09:13 to reflect on, on our and NATO's level of, of readiness to respond. So, so maybe you can walk us
00:09:21 through a little bit more details because I think maybe some viewers don't know what, what specifically
00:09:26 is Canada's involvement when it comes to the operation you're talking about in Latvia? How
00:09:30 many troops do we have there and what specifically is the Trudeau government doing with, with regards to,
00:09:38 you know, the, the, the aggression that we might be seeing from Russia?
00:09:40 Yeah. Yeah. So, so there's a, there's a mission in enhanced forward presence. The idea of, of having
00:09:48 more NATO countries present providing a level of, of reassurance in, in NATO countries that are,
00:09:57 that are sort of geographically closer to, to Russia. So Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, and, and Poland. And
00:10:06 there is a, there are various countries involved in, in each of those missions. And there is a country
00:10:15 that is leading each, each battle group. So, you know, the UK, the US, Germany, or the other,
00:10:22 other nations leading battle groups and Canada's leading the battle group in, in, in Latvia. So,
00:10:29 we're, we're, we're present there. We're, we're, we're part of, of leading that mission. And there's,
00:10:35 there's many other countries that are involved and that we're, we're cooperating with. And I mean,
00:10:40 I think there's, there's a lot of benefits to that, that operation and the obvious one in terms of
00:10:44 demonstrating our, our readiness and our solidarity with NATO members. But, but it's, look, it's, it's also a
00:10:51 great opportunity for, for our, you know, various NATO countries to work together. And I think, I think
00:10:59 the battle group in Latvia is actually the largest in terms of the number of countries that are, that
00:11:03 are represented. So, so it's, it was interesting to hear in the briefing, just about that, that breadth
00:11:10 being something that the Canadian Armed Forces is able to do really well, which is, which is
00:11:15 collaboration with other NATO partners and, and building that large multi, multinational force.
00:11:23 You know, I, I think the, the, the concern around action that Russia would take, I should say that
00:11:30 the Putin regime would take would be specifically into Ukraine. And in, in the sort of side meetings I
00:11:38 was a part of, there's a lot of discussion about this question of, of, of NATO enlargement, because you
00:11:44 have, you have, you have Ukraine, you have Georgia countries that, that, that the Putin regime is, is
00:11:52 interfering in, in various ways, and that don't have that kind of security blanket of being part of,
00:12:00 part of NATO. On the one hand, Russia complains about the enlargement of, of NATO, but on the other hand,
00:12:06 they don't, you know, they, they, they take advantage of, of, of countries that are not covered by that security
00:12:17 blanket, and they're more likely to, to intervene and interfere there. So, this is, this is a concern,
00:12:23 obviously, and I think we have to think seriously about what kind of response we would, we would, we would
00:12:29 undertake if we see the kind of Russian aggression that a lot of people are talking about as being a realistic
00:12:34 possibility. You know, probably it would be, it would be further aggression in Ukraine beyond, 0.87
00:12:40 of course, the ongoing occupation and, and, and issues that are happening there.
00:12:45 So, one of the things that previous Harper government was known for was sort of a refusal to
00:12:50 bow down to other countries, especially bad actors and adversarial nations. We saw Harper,
00:12:56 one, stand up directly to Vladimir Putin. He stood up to the Iranian regime by kicking out their diplomats,
00:13:03 and he, he even stood up to the United Nations. Justin Trudeau, you couldn't have a more stark
00:13:07 difference between that and Justin Trudeau. Justin Trudeau said that he admired China's
00:13:12 dictatorship. He shook hands with Iran's foreign minister just days after Iran shot down a civilian
00:13:18 airline flight 752, murdering scores of Canadians, including students and children.
00:13:26 You know, during your time as an elected official and MP Garnett, have you seen Canada's reputation
00:13:34 change on the world stage? I know Justin Trudeau liked to say that he was bringing Canada back,
00:13:39 that the foreign policy diplomats were all, you know, applauding when he, when he was elected and
00:13:44 first entered the foreign affairs building. But, but, but, but on the ground out in these missions that you go on
00:13:51 and, and, and working with our allies, have you seen a change in, in Canada's reputation? And what,
00:13:57 what, how, how, how has Canada's reputation changed? You know, thanks. That's a, that's a really important
00:14:03 question. And, and look, as a, as a member of the loyal opposition, I'm obviously a proud Canadian,
00:14:10 and I want to see Canada do well. And I'm particularly proud of our, our armed forces and the courage that
00:14:16 the women and men in uniform show as, as part of the various missions that we're, we're a part of and,
00:14:21 and sometimes not getting the political support that they, that they should have. You talked about
00:14:27 Stephen Harper. I think one thing that, that really came out to me talking to various people in, in
00:14:34 Eastern Europe was, was sort of thinking about that trajectory of Putin aggression, that the, the kind of,
00:14:43 there were, there were various human rights issues and aggressive actions taken within the, the
00:14:49 territory of Russia itself. One critical step, I believe in 2008, I might be off a little bit, 0.55
00:14:56 but I believe in 2008 where Russia invaded Georgia. And this, this is, has perhaps lessened the conscience
00:15:07 of people in Canada. We have a closer relationship with Ukraine. But I think there's, there's a consensus now
00:15:13 that basically there was a, there was a lack of meaningful response to, to that act of Russian
00:15:20 aggression in, in Georgia. And there was sort of a perception in the Putin regime that they could,
00:15:26 could get away with that. In 2014, in the context of Russian aggression in Ukraine, there was a much
00:15:36 stronger, if anything sort of stronger than expected response from the international community in terms of
00:15:41 showing support for Ukraine. That response on Ukraine was substantially, I would argue, driven by
00:15:50 Stephen Harper's leadership within the, the G7. And Canada's firm, just refusal to accept a return to
00:16:01 sort of 19th century so-called great power politics in which big countries can bite off chunks of small
00:16:07 countries at will. We, we have to assert the, the principles of international law, the, the sovereignty
00:16:16 of states, the principle of self-determination against this kind of, this kind of might makes right
00:16:22 narrative. And Canada did that boldly, decisively. And, you know, Stephen Harper being well-respected,
00:16:32 the senior member of the G7 was, was, was, was able to maybe say things that Europeans or Americans at
00:16:40 the time were unwilling to say, but ultimately to pull that consensus towards us. So I think when you
00:16:48 are a, you know, when you're, when you're somewhere in between a super tower, pardon me, when you're
00:16:54 somewhere in between a super power and, and, and, and very small, when you're kind of a, at that, at that
00:17:00 middle level as Canada is part of many international organizations, you know, you, the degree to which
00:17:06 you're listened to really depends on the strength and credibility of your, of your leadership. The U.S.,
00:17:14 people have to listen to the U.S. regardless of what they think of the present of the day because of
00:17:18 its, its, its size and, and geopolitical importance. Canada is the sort of country where, where we have
00:17:26 an opportunity to be heard, but it's not inevitable that we will be heard or that we will be, we will
00:17:32 be listened to. And I think what I, what I see, and you can, I can see this quite clearly from the Biden
00:17:37 administration, its posture towards the Trudeau government is, you know, doing all the kind of nice
00:17:44 things and photo ops, but, but not really taking our concerns seriously, not really responding to
00:17:51 them. And, and, and I, I think Canadians have this perception of our, of our prime minister as
00:17:58 kind of in it for the image and, and not being that serious about the substance. And I think, look,
00:18:05 Canada as a country still has a great reputation around the world. But it is very hard to imagine
00:18:11 Justin Trudeau playing the same kind of leadership role today as Stephen Harper did on, on Ukraine.
00:18:20 That, that leadership required a willingness, yes, to work within multilateral frame frameworks,
00:18:25 but to lead and to be the first out of the gate and to, and to pull other countries towards us in
00:18:30 terms of the process of building consensus. I, I don't think, I don't think we are, we are likely to
00:18:36 see that kind of leadership from Justin Trudeau. We, we certainly haven't in the past.
00:18:41 It's been interesting. You talk about Russia. You can look at maybe China and other,
00:18:45 another important geo-strategic challenge that, that Canada faces. And obviously the Trudeau
00:18:50 government came in promising this, this golden age of, of relations between Canada and China.
00:18:58 And, and now what we've seen is, is like a shift in some of the rhetoric, right? The, the liberals,
00:19:04 the liberals are adopting some of the language of conservative foreign policy in, in some of their,
00:19:11 the way they try to frame what they're doing, but we're not seeing it in the substance. We're,
00:19:15 we're seeing a shift in posture, but not a shift in substance of our foreign policy. And that's,
00:19:19 that's a big concern.
00:19:20 Well, I do want to get to China, but before we do just quickly, there, there was an announcement
00:19:25 not too long ago of a new submarine deal between the UK, the US and Australia. And when I saw that
00:19:31 news Garnett and I, and I read the details to me, it was like, okay, we used to have this agreement
00:19:35 called the five eyes and it was, it was Canada in that mix and New Zealand as well. And here we have
00:19:40 this new, you know, groundbreaking technology and this, this, you know, next generation deal that,
00:19:46 that Canada was just completely left out of. So I'm wondering if you could comment on that
00:19:51 specifically and why Justin Trudeau, why under, under Justin Trudeau's leadership, Canada wasn't
00:19:56 involved in those discussions you talked about, not meeting our 2% NATO requirement that, that seemed
00:20:03 to be perhaps an opportunity to at least push it in that direction. If we were to make investments in,
00:20:08 in the submarine technology, icebreakers in the North, what, why isn't Canada involved in these conversations?
00:20:14 Well, I think it's a, it's an important question and it's a question we've asked. So we have an
00:20:22 opportunity as, as members of parliament to submit something called order paper questions, which is,
00:20:26 you know, people are thinking of questions in parliament, they think of the cut and thrust of
00:20:30 question period, which is obviously one, one great opportunity, but we also submit written questions,
00:20:34 which are, which are, are usually kind of detailed requests for information. And it's, it's,
00:20:40 it's harder for the government to, to avoid providing, providing answers to those. So, so,
00:20:46 although they, they still find ways of doing so. So, so I've submitted a, a question specifically on
00:20:52 AUKUS, the, the UK, US, Australia deal asking, was Canada part of discussions?
00:21:00 Was Canada invited to join? Would Canada be interested in joining? And I'm, I'm hopeful that,
00:21:07 that within the deadline of that question, the question, the response will have to be submitted
00:21:10 when parliament returns in January, at that point, we'll be able to see what the, what the response is.
00:21:16 But, but look, I mean, obviously this raises some, some red flags when we see kind of within the
00:21:26 Five Eyes, some members of the Five Eyes establishing agreements, which, I mean, they're, they're, they're
00:21:32 going to be some aspects of, of, for instance, US-Australia cooperation that are going to focus
00:21:37 on specific theaters where we're, where we're less present, but there's, there's a lot of elements of
00:21:42 the AUKUS deal, some of which I think would be, would be very relevant to, to Canada. And shortly
00:21:49 after that, I think people, people noticed the, the, the interaction between, between President Biden
00:21:58 and the Prime Minister of Australia, in which he said, the US has no more reliable friend and ally
00:22:03 than Australia, which I think, you know, from a Canadian perspective, is sort of like seeing your
00:22:08 spouse out for dinner with somebody else. You know, Biden has described his relationship with Canada
00:22:13 as the easiest relationship. So it's, it, it is interesting, you know, Trudeau has, has sat across
00:22:20 from three different American presidents. And I think a lot of people were willing to give him a
00:22:25 pass on certain things with Trump because they, they perceive Trump as a, as a, as a tough customer.
00:22:29 But when, when you have two, two democratic presidents and still really a failure to achieve
00:22:37 results and, and seeming gaps in terms of ability to cooperate, you start to wonder, you know, maybe,
00:22:44 maybe, maybe our current leadership is missing something in terms of, of effective engagement of
00:22:49 our allies. Well, so, so our relationship with the US, I mean, you, you shouldn't be seen as being easy
00:22:55 if you're, if you're Canada, you should bargain, you should still make demands, whether it be pipelines
00:23:01 or, you know, exemptions to meet in the USA tariffs. That, that, that should be an easier
00:23:06 relationship because we have so much in common and we share so many mutual values. So, so, so compare
00:23:12 that with, you know, seeing Trudeau have very few results with our greatest partner and ally, the US,
00:23:19 and then juxtapose that with, with China, where you have an adversarial regime, you have a
00:23:24 a terrible offender of human rights, you have, you know, a country that is, is acting more and more
00:23:30 belligerent on the world stage. And yet, you know, we have Trudeau failing to negotiate a trade deal,
00:23:37 a waffling, waffling on Huawei and, and, and how, how we're going to deal with them, not really standing
00:23:43 up in the way that many wanted to see with the two Michaels who are arbitrarily arrested. In the US,
00:23:49 we see both Democrats and Republicans in agreement about China's aggression and the need to build up 0.87
00:23:56 their own domestic economy so that they're less reliant on imports from China. Canada doesn't
00:24:02 seem to have an appetite to, to implement some of the same trade restrictions against China. So I'm
00:24:08 wondering if you could comment both on the foreign policy side with China and how Trudeau deals with
00:24:13 them and how, how we ought to deal with them in a different, different way. And then also address
00:24:18 the issue of trade and, and whether we are too reliant on, upon China, whether we ought to be building
00:24:25 up more of our own domestic or at least North American manufacturing base so that we're not
00:24:29 relying on, on China in the future. Yeah. So I, I think on, on the trade piece, it's maybe important to
00:24:35 distinguish between the question of, of trade in general and the question of strategic dependency.
00:24:41 Um, you know, trade, you know, you can, you can engage in commerce, um, without being in a position
00:24:47 of, of, um, of strategic vulnerability, where there are things that you are going to need at critical
00:24:53 times and, uh, and that access could be managed by, um, by an authoritarian political actor for their
00:25:01 own strategic, strategic reasons. Right. So we saw that a little bit with COVID with the, with the vaccines,
00:25:06 as well as with PP and E that we were reliant on China and they, they didn't really seem to, to care
00:25:10 and they didn't really seem to be reciprocal in, in terms of following through on agreements that we
00:25:14 had with them. Yeah, certainly it became evident through the study we did at the special committee
00:25:19 on Canada-China relations in the, in the last parliament that, uh, that there were political
00:25:24 decisions aimed at Canada in response to, to political factors. And, uh, there is, there are, there are many
00:25:30 advantages to focusing on, on, uh, expanding free trade among free nations, rule of law nations where,
00:25:36 um, you know, where, where, uh, contracts are, are formally enforceable and, um, and there can't be
00:25:43 threats made against, uh, judges, business people and, and, and, and so forth. Um, it doesn't mean we,
00:25:49 we can't and shouldn't trade with countries that, uh, that don't share our values. I mean, I think there 0.63
00:25:54 are, there are good arguments for both the economic benefits, but also the potential just engagement that can,
00:25:59 can flow from that. But, uh, separate from the question of trade in general, we, we have to be
00:26:06 attentive to this question of, of strategic dependency, uh, that, that came through the, the
00:26:11 pandemic and, um, and, uh, you know, we, we see it in other issues as well. I know during, during a
00:26:18 recent trip to Eastern Europe, a lot of, um, a lot of people are, are interested there in questions
00:26:23 around energy security, right? And, and we, we should, should think about the role that Canada can play,
00:26:28 uh, as a, as a, an exporter of energy resources in, uh, in supporting energy security, because that's
00:26:34 another, uh, one of those, uh, those strategic, strategic, uh, commodities and points of strategic
00:26:40 vulnerability for certain, uh, for certain like, like-minded countries. Um, on the sort of relationship
00:26:47 with, with, uh, with China in general, um, how we kind of relate to the Chinese government, I think
00:26:53 for a long time, the Trudeau government has just been very naive. Uh, they've, they sort of assumed
00:26:58 that if you're, if you're treating someone in a certain way that they will, uh, reciprocate that,
00:27:03 uh, uh, that, that treatment. And, um, we've seen in, in response to, I think, very effective
00:27:10 work in the last parliament, again, through the special committee on, on Canada-China relations,
00:27:14 being a, being a big part of it. Um, the, many, many, many of the government's failures on this
00:27:21 and, and, and failures in perception have been exposed and that has forced certain changes in
00:27:28 tone and language. Uh, the, um, uh, the, two U.S. administrations actually have recognized the
00:27:36 Uyghur genocide. Canada's parliament has recognized the Uyghur genocide. Uh, the government has,
00:27:41 has failed to provide that recognition, um, in terms of our own domestic security, right? Uh,
00:27:48 we haven't, we have not, uh, recognized yet that the, the security threat posed by, by Huawei,
00:27:54 the government says its decision with respect to Huawei is still, uh, still pending. So, um,
00:28:00 there are these, there are these key issues of substance, uh, protecting our own security,
00:28:04 defending our own interests, standing with our allies on issues of human rights where Canada, uh,
00:28:09 needs to step up and, and has not stepped up yet. Um, and I would say just protecting our own
00:28:15 security is in, in this context is, is a particularly urgent priority. Uh, the biggest security threat
00:28:21 facing Canada right now is foreign state back interference in our country. Uh, the, the sort 0.96
00:28:26 of silent invasion, uh, that one, one Australian writer, uh, described where, um, where the institutions of,
00:28:34 of, of, uh, uh, of, of a foreign state, you know, rather than, rather than rolling up, uh, with,
00:28:39 with tanks and flags on the beach, uh, are seeking to, uh, to, to bring institutions in other country,
00:28:47 on countries under their control. And, um, and, and we really need to wise up about this and respond
00:28:53 to it more effectively. Well, there, there have been, uh, there's been several books written about,
00:28:58 uh, Chinese spies and infiltration into Canada. Uh, we saw it, uh, flare up not too long ago in
00:29:04 Vancouver when, um, there were, you know, high school kids fighting over, um, you know, the
00:29:10 invasion of, um, or the, the changes of law in Hong Kong that will give China more autonomy. We see,
00:29:15 uh, pro China rallies in, in Vancouver frequently. So, uh, unfortunate stuff is definitely happening in
00:29:21 Canada. Well, Garnett, I really appreciate your time, really appreciate all your, uh, expertise and,
00:29:25 and shedding light on all of these issues to help us, uh, get a better understanding of what's
00:29:29 happening, uh, you know, inside Canada's, uh, foreign policy, um, area. So, so we really
00:29:35 appreciate you coming on the show and, um, wishing you a very Merry Christmas to you and your family.
00:29:40 Well, thank you so much. Merry Christmas to you. And I'll maybe just say in conclusion that
00:29:44 these foreign and security policy issues, um, they're not often top of mind for Canadians. Um,
00:29:50 but when something goes wrong in the world, uh, they can, they can move from low down the list
00:29:55 to the top of the list very, very quickly in terms of their significance and their impact.
00:29:59 So, uh, obviously, uh, you know, conservatives are working hard to hold the government accountable
00:30:03 on the economy, on inflation, uh, on, uh, on justice issues, on domestic freedoms issues.
00:30:09 Uh, but these, but these foreign, foreign affairs and, uh, and security issues, uh, they,
00:30:14 they have the potential to have a very significant impact, uh, on our, on our lives. And it's important
00:30:19 for us to be vigilant and asking the government questions about, about what their, their plans
00:30:24 are. So again, Merry Christmas to you and thanks for the opportunity.
00:30:26 All right. Thank you so much, Garnas, Janet, MP for the Conservative Party. I'm
00:30:31 Candice Malcolm, and this is the Candice Malcolm Show.