The Candice Malcolm Show - May 29, 2025


Candice Malcolm DEBUNKS CTV's Alberta separation lies

Hosted by
Mentioned
Poilievre SHREDS Liberal slogans + Canadians lose jobs to temporary workers $486 BILLION?! Carney’s First Budget BLOWS Past Expectations

Episode Stats


Length

11 minutes

Words per minute

182.49

Word count

2,121

Sentence count

2

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of Fake News Friday, host Candice Malcolm Gladwell and her producer read past the headlines to debunk the idea that 29% of Alberta s voters want the province to become independent of Canada. Is there any economic reason why this is a good idea?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 okay folks we used to do a segment on the candace malcolm show called fake news friday it was our
00:00:07 favorite segment and one of the things i used to do is read through a legacy media news article
00:00:14 and just point out all the flaws we haven't done in a while and so my producer handed me this story
00:00:18 we decided that we would read past the headlines and show you the genesis of fake news so here is
00:00:24 the article that we are talking about 29 of albertans support the idea of separation from
00:00:28 canada leger polls you might recognize this one i've used it a couple of times on my show but i've
00:00:32 never really dug into it and when you dig into it you realize just how absurd it is okay so it starts
00:00:37 off with that leger poll it says leger poll suggests 29 of albertans want the province to become a
00:00:42 country independent of canada 1 000 people were surveyed over three days earlier this month 43
00:00:47 percent of respondents say economic reasons such as taxation and federal policies are the reasons
00:00:53 they support independence and then other people who have participated 67 percent were opposed
00:00:57 well five percent didn't know and so the author wants to sort of zoom in on those 43 percent of
00:01:03 respondents who want to separate who say the reason that they want to separate is because of economic
00:01:07 reasons this is a drastic departure by the way from quebec right quebec wants to separate because of
00:01:12 language reasons and cultural reasons whereas in alberta it really is the financial reasons right we all
00:01:17 know this that equalization means that albertans get raked by the federal government that albertans
00:01:22 send their taxation dollars over to big government provinces like quebec atlantic canada and sometimes
00:01:29 even ontario for them to provide lavish social services that alberta themselves don't even have
00:01:35 and so yes fundamentally it is an economic complaint that they have and so this ctv reporter wants to
00:01:41 sort of debunk that idea so here she says with nearly a third respondent supporting idea economist
00:01:46 mosch lander says it's emotion behind the numbers and not economics then she quotes this individual
00:01:52 mosch lander saying there's no mainstream economist who says this will work they're not even saying it
00:01:58 could work launder told ctv news edmonton launder says decades of messaging in alberta against ottawa
00:02:05 has become an issue causing people to consider separating from canada they've just bought into
00:02:10 the narrative and they've decided that well i guess we just got to get rid of the problem rather than
00:02:16 recognizing that maybe it's the messaging or even the messenger that's the issue okay did you get
00:02:22 that so the whole idea is that it doesn't make any economic sense says this economist and it's just
00:02:27 propaganda so if you have any inclination towards alberta independence if you think that alberta is
00:02:32 like i said getting raked over equalization it's just because of messaging and the messenger okay
00:02:38 let's just stop for a second let's pause for a second who is this economist mosch lander let's just do
00:02:43 a simple google search it leads us to saying he is a lecturer at concordia university in montreal so
00:02:50 this is a professor based in quebec saying to albertans if you believe in this idea it's because
00:02:56 you've been fed propaganda and saying definitively that there is no economic case that there's no
00:03:02 mainstream economist who says this will work says the montreal lecturer at concordia university
00:03:09 according to his linkedin page prior to being a lecturer at the university of concordia he was a
00:03:16 bureaucrat in the alberta legislature so he was a government bureaucrat economist in edmonton working
00:03:23 for the provincial government and then he went over and became a professor in montreal i just love the
00:03:28 definitiveness no mainstream economist says this will work well let's just try another simple google search
00:03:33 i'll go over to chat gpt ai search engine just type this in provide a list of economists who say
00:03:40 alberta could thrive independently and lo and behold here we go now not saying that any of these
00:03:46 economists support alberta separation or say that it's a good idea but these are all people who have
00:03:52 written about it and say it could work so first you have jack men's probably canada's preeminent
00:03:56 economist and financial thinker we had him on the show a few weeks ago the episode did really really
00:04:02 well jack men's is like the gold standard of economists in canada and here it says you know
00:04:08 right on chat gpt it says jack men's a respected economist at the university of calgary school of public
00:04:12 policy men's has highlighted alberta's entrepreneurial spirit and economic resilience he suggests that
00:04:18 with appropriate policy framework alberta could navigate future challenges here it is folks in the
00:04:22 cbc of all places back in 2018 albexit why this economist thinks alberta could separate from canada
00:04:30 and again creme de la creme economist jack men's saying that it could work so um ctv maybe you
00:04:37 should just google it next time uh another list of people uh from chat gpt here uh joseph du set who
00:04:43 is the dean of the alberta school of business he's emphasized alberta's competitive advantages
00:04:48 including his energy resources educated workforce he notes that while diversification is essential the
00:04:54 province's existing strength provide a solid foundation for economic growth next you have neil
00:04:58 valdo's president of the prestigious fraser institute valdo's has contributed to research
00:05:02 outlining policy frameworks aimed at fostering growth and prosperity in alberta while not advocating
00:05:06 for independence his work discusses strategies for enhancing the province's economic performance
00:05:12 so there you have it folks one search and we can entirely debunk this ctv article and so it's
00:05:18 interesting the next thing that this reporter goes on to is this bit that we covered on the show with
00:05:23 brett wilson where she goes to arlene dickinson who is a kind of you know she's a businesswoman 1.00
00:05:29 respected businesswoman and entrepreneur but she came out swinging against danielle smith premier of
00:05:34 alberta saying it's wholly un-canadian for her to even be entertaining a referendum a democratic-led
00:05:40 referendum and so we have these quotes from arlene dickinson saying it's totally unfair okay so just
00:05:46 from a news perspective right journalism school you're told to cover both this is disruptors
00:05:51 no hype no hot takes just clear thinking real trade-offs and practical insight with a focus
00:05:57 on what matters for canada every episode we talk to the people shaping what comes next in business
00:06:04 policy technology and the real economy i'm john stackhouse polo disruptors and never miss an episode
00:06:11 besides the story so far this reporter has interviewed two people one an economist saying
00:06:17 that no economist could ever say that this could work which we easily debunk and then the second one
00:06:22 is a political activist on the political left saying that it's un-canadian to have a referendum
00:06:27 and a democratically led initiative which canada's constitution actually allows for
00:06:32 and a supreme court decision in the 90s allows for this for quebec so you know we might not like it
00:06:37 but it's part of the discussion so you have two people both saying that this is not good and wrong
00:06:42 where's the balance here folks where's the balance here uh finally i'll just read the end of this
00:06:48 article so she says a sense of fairness tegan hill director of alberta policy with the fraser
00:06:52 institute says albertans are rightfully frustrated they have made and continue to make an outsized
00:06:57 contribution to the federation to the rest of canada to the tune of 245 billion dollars hill told ctv at
00:07:03 the same time they continue to face federal policies that damage and restrict their key industry the
00:07:08 energy sector and so to be fair this person is not in any way advocating for alberta separatism but
00:07:13 she's just pointing out that yes alberta doesn't really get a fair shake economically and there are
00:07:19 policies that block alberta's growth and so they specifically mention the proposed emissions camp
00:07:24 as well as bill c69 which we call the no pipelines bill okay so this is a totally biased news story
00:07:31 right this whole idea she says she tries to debunk the economic ability of alberta to separate then
00:07:38 she talks about the sort of emotional side of it from this dragon's den lady and then she kind of just
00:07:43 tries to round it off by having someone from the fraser institute talk about like the legitimate
00:07:48 criticisms here and this is this is kind of how they bake the news this is what they do they they come
00:07:55 out and they say it's not viable and then that line an economist saying it's not viable gets repeated
00:08:00 and it shows up in other google searches and other ai searches and then all of a sudden people have
00:08:04 this impression that it would just not be economically viable for alberta to separate let's just click on
00:08:09 this journalist for a second miriam valdez carletti now i don't mean to necessarily pick on her but i'm
00:08:15 just using this as an example of sort of what we're up against right so let me just read a bit from her
00:08:21 bio it says miriam valdez carletti joined ctv news edmonton in march 2023 she has a passion for
00:08:26 reporting on human interest stories and issues affecting bipoc communities bipoc communities
00:08:32 that means black indigenous and people of color so in her intro sentence in her bio it says that she
00:08:40 has a passion for reporting on stories affecting basically anybody who isn't white bipoc basically 0.92
00:08:47 just means every single person in canada who is not would not be considered white as a people of color
00:08:52 such a vague term it kind of implies everybody so imagine like in her bio like the thing that she
00:08:59 says about herself is i really love telling stories about people who are not white i like covering the
00:09:05 news about all the people in canada who are not white like in what world is that okay in what world 0.73
00:09:10 is it okay to just have like a totally racist line in your bio and that's like who you are and that
00:09:15 represents who you are and the news team is like oh that's really important that's great yeah
00:09:18 definitely include that bit about how you love telling stories about people who are not white just
00:09:23 reading a bit more into her bio it says she was a bachelor of journalism from toronto metropolitan
00:09:28 university um what what is that oh right the university that was so woke that they changed their name
00:09:34 because they didn't want to be named after ryerson egerton ryerson who had in some way been some
00:09:40 tangentially connected to residential schools and so they decided to rename the university the only
00:09:45 problem is ryerson university journalism program has a bit of cachet right everybody kind of knows
00:09:50 that ryerson had a good journalism program like back in the day and so she writes that she went to
00:09:56 toronto metropolitan university because she has the correct woke opinion politically correct version
00:10:01 of the university but then she puts in parentheses formerly ryerson university so she gets the prestige
00:10:06 you see that so she wants to be connected to the school even though she wants to distance herself
00:10:10 from the school because she probably hates the legacy and this is what we're up against in the legacy
00:10:15 media right you have woke reporters pushing a woke worldview and distorting the news distorting what
00:10:21 is right news right this is an opinion piece this is not someone saying this is an op-ed this is my
00:10:25 opinion i believe that there's no economic case for a better separate this is a news story that tries
00:10:31 to purport to be fact-based and totally removed from any kind of bias and yet they're like just declaring
00:10:40 that this isn't an economically viable thing all right folks thanks so much for tuning in
00:10:46 you're watching juno news canada's fastest growing independent news network our team works day and night
00:10:56 to bring you nationwide coverage of the issues that matter honest reporting of the stories that put
00:11:04 canadians first from far and wide juno is doing the work to turn the dial in the right direction
00:11:13 bringing you the news from the field and in the studio wherever it takes us we get the job done
00:11:21 for you for canada subscribe today and help us replace the cbc go to juno news.com to join the fight