The Candice Malcolm Show - August 20, 2025


Carney doubles down on Trudeau-era gun grab

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Poilievre CRUSHES byelection with 80% win How can we fix Canada’s failing healthcare system? Let’s look to Japan

Episode Stats


Length

53 minutes

Words per minute

174.04

Word count

9,264

Sentence count

621

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The Canadian Taxpayers Federation and the Toronto Police Association are joined by an expert on gun control to discuss the federal government's plan to confiscate private property from legal, law-abiding firearms owners. They also speak with Toronto Police Chief Bill Blair.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to The Candace Malcolm Show. My name is Chris Sims. I'm the Alberta Director for the
00:00:07 Canadian Taxpayers Federation. And when I say we have a special show for you, boy, do I mean it.
00:00:14 We're going to get right into the gun issue here in Canada. And I'm not talking about the gang
00:00:20 bangers on the streets of Toronto who are causing mayhem, ruining lives with illegal handguns.
00:00:26 I am talking about the federal government's confiscation of private property from legal,
00:00:34 law-abiding firearms owners. We're going to be speaking with an expert on this. We're also
00:00:41 going to be speaking with the Toronto Police Association, who is rightly speaking up and
00:00:46 saying, hey, we do have a gun problem on the streets of Toronto, but it's not the duck hunters in 0.99
00:00:52 Manitoba who are the problem. It's not the sports shooters in London, Ontario, who are trying to go
00:00:58 out to the range, who are causing the problem. It's the criminals who are committing the crime here.
00:01:04 The reason why we need to dive into this now is because it seems like the federal liberal government
00:01:10 is deciding to go ahead now with its confiscation rollout of lawfully obtained firearms.
00:01:20 What that means is, if you had legally obtained a certain kind of firearm, okay, before May of 2020,
00:01:29 unless you surrender that firearm over to the state somehow, you will instantly become a criminal.
00:01:36 So the language we're now hearing from Ottawa goes something like this. Yeah, we know we've been
00:01:42 kicking this around for the past five years. Yeah, we know that we've actually ruined several
00:01:47 normal gun businesses. And yeah, we think that now that we're going to be dangling some form of
00:01:54 monetary compensation at cost to taxpayers, by the way, we're actually going to have more people
00:02:01 happy about this, happy to surrender their private property to the government. Now, this is the thing.
00:02:08 I'm a firearms owner, okay? It's easy to say, oh, well, I'm not going to do it. I'm not going to
00:02:14 comply. That's not who people are within the law-abiding firearms community. Folks who are
00:02:21 legally owning guns in Canada are usually big sticklers for rules. That's because we have to
00:02:29 go through major screening when we want to legally own a firearm in Canada. Even if you just want to
00:02:36 have a regular rifle or a shotgun in Canada, like, you know, more than two and a half million-ish people
00:02:41 do in Canada, if you want to go do that, you have to get a firearms license. And there, they do big
00:02:48 background checks. They phone all of your ex-boyfriends and girlfriends. You have to have an
00:02:53 instructor sign off on everything you do. There's storage rules. There's transportation rules. There's
00:02:59 all sorts of stuff that goes along with being a legal law-abiding firearms owner. So yeah, unless you
00:03:05 comply with the government, you're going to be instantly a criminal. What an unfair situation
00:03:11 for so many firearms owners in Canada. Now, when we're talking about the cost to taxpayers,
00:03:17 this is already going to cost over a billion dollars with a B. We do not have the money for this.
00:03:25 Just picture it. Picture not just the compensation amounts that they're going to try to be offering
00:03:30 to people eventually. Picture the man hours, the people hours, as Prime Minister Justin Trudeau would
00:03:36 probably call it, of the law enforcement that is going to be required to what? Go door to door?
00:03:43 Say, now it's time to surrender your firearms? Or even somebody who's carefully approaching the
00:03:49 police station saying, um, I think I need to do this now. It's in my car. There's hours and hours and
00:03:55 hours of paperwork, right? So this is going to cause a big messy problem. And we wanted to highlight it
00:04:02 on this special show. So this is the Candace Malcolm show. It's on Juno News. You aren't going to hear
00:04:08 this level of expertise in detail on the mainstream media. And I'll tell you why. One, it's just sometimes
00:04:16 that they don't know. They see a movie like Rambo and they hear some politicians say assault style
00:04:22 weapons. And they picture some full auto machine gun, some person spraying bullets by holding their
00:04:30 trigger finger down. Those guns are not legal in Canada. They have not been legal in Canada since the
00:04:36 1970s. Okay. So there's a lot of bad information coming out of the mainstream media on this. A lot of
00:04:45 ignorance, a lot of water carrying that is happening right now for the Liberal government. That is why it's super
00:04:52 important for people to subscribe. Okay. Go to Juno News, subscribe to this show. Okay. Tell your
00:04:59 friends, especially if you're within the legal firearms community and you're at the range, tell
00:05:05 them about the show. Share this show online. Okay. I wanted to play you a clip which perfectly
00:05:13 illustrates the situation we're in. I'm laughing because otherwise I'll cry. Okay. I'm going to set
00:05:19 this up. The person who's asking the question is Andrew Lawton. You might remember him from such shows
00:05:25 as right here, at least the previous incarnation of this show. Andrew Lawton had his own show on
00:05:32 True North for years and years. He is now an elected member of parliament and he stood up in the house of
00:05:38 commons back when it was sitting, you know, for like 73 minutes after the election. And he asked the public
00:05:44 safety minister about the legal law-abiding right to own a firearm in Canada. And he kind of quizzed him
00:05:53 and he kind of failed. So let's listen.
00:05:56 Does the minister know what an RPAL is?
00:06:00 The Honourable Minister.
00:06:01 I do not.
00:06:02 Member.
00:06:05 Does the minister know what the CFSC is?
00:06:09 The Honourable Minister.
00:06:10 I do not. No.
00:06:12 Member.
00:06:13 I'll stipulate, Chair, that is the Canadian's firearm safety course that all gun owners in Canada have
00:06:17 to do to get their firearms license. Has the minister ever done the Canadian firearm safety course?
00:06:22 The Honourable Minister.
00:06:24 Speaker, is it my third week on the job? No, I have not.
00:06:27 The Honourable Member.
00:06:28 Does the minister know what safety classes and safety demands are expected of law-abiding Canadian
00:06:33 gun owners?
00:06:34 The Honourable Minister.
00:06:36 This is not about law-abiding gun owners, Mr. Speaker.
00:06:39 The Honourable Member.
00:06:40 How can the minister make that claim when he doesn't know the basic fundamentals of law-abiding
00:06:44 gun ownership in this country, Chair?
00:06:49 Did you hear what the minister said there at the very end? That is the most important part.
00:06:53 Now, it would be nice if the public safety minister, who is going to be the person in charge of
00:06:59 confiscating people's firearms, would know what an RPAL is. So that's a restricted license.
00:07:07 That's if you're able to own a handgun, not a shotgun or a rifle. That's what an RPAL is. It would be nice if he actually even had such a license.
00:07:15 But at the very basis of him saying this is not about legal gun owners in Canada, yeah, it is.
00:07:26 That's why we're having this conversation. If the federal government were trying to crack down
00:07:32 on criminals and gangbangers who are using gun, like, this conversation would be over.
00:07:39 This show wouldn't exist. None of these advocacy organizations, including the Taxpayers Federation,
00:07:44 including the CCFR, would be upset about this at all. It would be, okay, fine, you go do your
00:07:50 government thing and make people safe. But that isn't what is happening here. What is happening here
00:07:55 is something that the mainstream media is trying to euphemistically call a buyback program.
00:08:03 That's incorrect, just on its face, just verbally, okay, using words, because the firearms owners in
00:08:11 question did not purchase their firearms from the government. They legally acquired their firearms
00:08:18 from lawful firearms sellers. Usually a private company of some now have gone bankrupt due to this
00:08:27 confiscation. And that's exactly what this is. This is a confiscation program. And it is a
00:08:34 confiscation program that we do not have the money for. I'll give you a perfect example to explain why
00:08:40 we don't have the money for this and why the Taxpayers Federation is fighting this. Folks might remember
00:08:47 something called the Long Gun Registry, okay, way back in the mists of time, when then Liberal Prime Minister
00:08:54 Jean Chrétien was around, okay, remember when they had a balanced budget, that was magical. Okay, so they had a
00:09:00 long gun registry. And they wanted literally like duck hunters, okay, and ranchers, because ranchers need to keep
00:09:08 long guns on their property to take care of pests and stuff and threats to their livestock. They had a long gun
00:09:13 registry where you would have to register your long gun with the government. They estimated it was going
00:09:18 to cost taxpayers around $2 million with an M. By the time the smoke cleared, it cost us around $2 billion.
00:09:28 So times a thousand. So this is a huge problem. It is a problem of cost. And it's a problem of private
00:09:36 property. How are people trying to push back on this? How are people trying to convince Prime Minister
00:09:45 Mark Carney, who says he's a pragmatist, to look at the numbers, look at the spreadsheet, and walk away
00:09:52 from this? Because ultimately, this is the previous guy's mess. Mark Carney in good conscience can say,
00:09:59 you know what, guys, this doesn't make sense. We don't have the money for this. My administration as Prime
00:10:05 Minister is not going ahead with this. We're dropping it. We're going to focus on actually making the
00:10:11 streets safer and not blowing money going after law-abiding people. Who's in this fight? How can
00:10:18 we convince the government to do the right thing? Let's find out. Joining me now is Rod Giltaka. He is
00:10:24 the CEO and Executive Director for the Canadian Coalition for Firearms Rights. You've probably seen
00:10:31 their stickers on the backs of pickup trucks. I know it is super popular around Southern Alberta
00:10:37 here where I live in Lethbridge. They are a major advocacy organization for the legal ownership of
00:10:43 firearms in Canada. If you have not checked them out yet, I strongly encourage you to do so. After
00:10:50 this chat, I bet you, you just can't resist after listening to Rod. Thank you so much for joining us
00:10:54 today. Thanks, Chris. So, and I meant that. I've been listening to some of your earlier podcast
00:11:00 appearances and you're very passionate, very knowledgeable when it comes to the rights of
00:11:05 firearms owners here in Canada. Last I was looking, there was around two and a half million of us
00:11:11 here in Canada. Are those the latest numbers you have too? Yeah, somewhere around there, just slightly
00:11:16 under two and a half million for all licenses, both restricted and unrestricted. So what he means,
00:11:22 and I'm going to keep on translating for folks who aren't gun owners. I am a firearms owner in Canada.
00:11:28 I was raised on hunted meat. I see them as a tool, the same as one would have, say, a snowblower or a
00:11:34 chainsaw or a pickup truck. You have to use them responsibly, but I think that they're an essential
00:11:39 element of Canadian culture, frankly, especially Western Canadian culture. Now, when we're getting
00:11:44 into what's happening here, this is not going to affect all firearms owners. It is going to affect
00:11:51 firearms owners who own specific kinds of guns. And I wanted to reiterate, a lot of folks in the
00:11:57 media keep calling this thing a buyback. It is not a buyback. I did not purchase my gun from the
00:12:04 government. This is a confiscation of private property, which was legally obtained. And now
00:12:11 they've changed the rules. Do we have an estimation as to how many people, how many gun owners this is
00:12:17 affecting this rolling confiscation that it sounds like the federal government wants to go ahead with?
00:12:23 Investing is all about the future. So what do you think is going to happen?
00:12:27 Bitcoin is sort of inevitable at this point.
00:12:29 I think it would come down to precious metals.
00:12:32 I hope we don't go cashless.
00:12:34 I would say land is a safe investment.
00:12:37 Technology, companies.
00:12:38 Solar energy.
00:12:39 Robotic pollinators might be a thing. 1.00
00:12:41 A wrestler to face a robot. That will have to happen. 0.76
00:12:44 So whatever you think is going to happen in the future, you can invest in it at Wealthsimple.
00:12:50 Start now at Wealthsimple.com.
00:12:53 Well, it's funny. The federal government says this affects somewhere around 140,000 firearms,
00:12:58 which is absolutely ridiculous. Nobody believes that for a second. There are somewhere around 90,000
00:13:05 AR-15s. AR-15s are registered. They're restricted firearms. So the government knows who has them and
00:13:12 how many there are. And so for them to say after all of these successive bans and all of the bans via
00:13:19 variant status from the RCMP, that somehow the total number of affected firearms is 140,000 is
00:13:27 ridiculous. It's probably nobody knows for sure because the overwhelming majority of these firearms
00:13:32 are unregistered. The government doesn't know who has them or where they are or how many there are.
00:13:38 But we think there should be somewhere maybe between half a million, 800,000, maybe up to
00:13:44 over a million. So it's a lot of guns. Based on my experience and the family I have, that
00:13:50 feels about right. Right. You start thinking about who among my family has certain kinds of firearms
00:13:56 legally obtained. And then you kind of work out the ratio. That feels about right. Now, the Canadian 0.58
00:14:02 Taxpayers Federation, we're right there with you. So we are fighting against this gun confiscation.
00:14:07 Last we checked, this current push to confiscate people's private property is going to cost taxpayers
00:14:15 more than a billion dollars. That's with a B. And for folks who are saying, oh, well,
00:14:20 their government's going to come in under budget. That's never happened. And I can only I can point
00:14:27 back to, of course, the long gun registry that they tried to do. Back then, they said it was going to
00:14:32 cost around two million with an M. After the smoke all cleared, they were getting close to two billion
00:14:39 with a B by the time they were done. And it didn't make Canadians safer. We are going to get into the
00:14:46 whole safety issue. We've got actually a spokesperson for the Toronto Police Association. So somebody who's
00:14:52 in connection with the boys and girls in blue right on the front line. So we're going to get into the
00:14:55 element that this doesn't make Canadians safer. What I wanted to focus in on with you, Rod, is how
00:15:01 undemocratic and really unfair this is to have your lawfully purchased private property seized by the
00:15:10 state at great expense to you. Keep in mind, the government doesn't have a magical money pot.
00:15:15 They're blowing taxpayers money to do this, to set up these registries, to set up all the administration,
00:15:21 to try to get the police, you know, who are already strapped for time and people to try to go pick up
00:15:27 these, these firearms. And there's also the element of, of sellers. Do you guys get into that at all?
00:15:34 I, I personally interviewed a gun seller, wonderful lady, mom of like five kids up in Prince George. 0.59
00:15:40 She had to shut down her business because she had so many stranded assets sitting on the shelf. Are you
00:15:45 guys in contact with the actual retailers too?
00:15:47 We are. So many, we have a business member program and so we are in touch with a lot of people and we
00:15:53 have longstanding relationships in the retail space as well. But yeah, they, they've had to hold on to
00:16:00 all of this property that was, that was banned by, you know, via OIC, Order and Council by Fiat, basically
00:16:08 for over half a decade. Now, some people probably were sitting on a hundred thousand dollars worth of
00:16:14 inventory. Many businesses use a line of credit to fund their inventory. So you can only imagine
00:16:20 the situation that some of these retailers were, were in. And just going back to something you said
00:16:25 about the, about the long gun registry costing $2 billion instead of $2 million, you know, that's
00:16:32 only a thousand times over. So that's actually a pretty reasonable budget underestimate for the
00:16:37 government. But I think, I think one of the most important things for people to remember is this
00:16:42 won't cost 750 million, like the government, the highest estimate the government thought it'll
00:16:48 probably cost two to $8 billion. And the situation we're in now that's borrowed money. So it will be
00:16:56 borrowing two to $8 billion at interest. And again, not to step too much into, into your topic,
00:17:03 but I think people forget right now, Canada is paying $4 billion a month, just an interest on
00:17:09 the national debt. That's before anything. That's before policing. That's before employment insurance.
00:17:16 That's before pension. That's nothing. That's 4 billion a month. So this is just going to add to
00:17:21 that, which is even more of a slap in the face to hardworking Canadians.
00:17:25 Man after my own heart. Yeah. To put it this way. Okay. What he just said is exactly true. Okay.
00:17:32 The interest just on the federal debt. We're not counting the provincial debts. Just the federal
00:17:37 government's debt is a billion dollars a week. So picture everybody gathering around on a Saturday
00:17:43 night. And instead of watching hockey, we burn down a hospital, build it up brand new. Wait,
00:17:49 don't send anybody in yet. Burn it down instead. That's how much we are spending on the interest on 0.51
00:17:55 the debt. So exactly to your point, Rod, that the federal government is now thinking that we're
00:18:00 going to borrow more money to go out and confiscate and compensate these law abiding firearms owners.
00:18:09 Now, I know a lot of the viewers of the Candace Malcolm show will be, will have their pal. Okay.
00:18:14 They will have firearms licenses, but if you can speak to their brother-in-law and their sisters and
00:18:21 people who perhaps aren't in what I would call the gun world, the law abiding gun world,
00:18:26 can you explain to them why this is important? Why should non firearms owners, which there are many
00:18:34 in Canada care about the fact that tons of people are getting their property seized by the government?
00:18:40 It's not so much that they have to care about it. They have to transfer the same set of values that
00:18:47 they do for everything else in our society over to people that lawfully own firearms.
00:18:51 So in Canada, there's a very strict system that is in place to regulate legal firearms.
00:18:58 You need a license. You need to prove competency by taking a course. You need to have extensive
00:19:03 background checks. You get a background check every 24 hours. Handguns are registered so the
00:19:08 government knows where they are, where they're being stored. You can only shoot them at an approved 1.00
00:19:12 shooting range. You can't shoot them out in the bush. Same thing with some long guns, 0.99
00:19:16 like AR-15s, all this stuff is very, very tightly regulated. And I think what a lot of people miss
00:19:22 is civilian firearm, private firearm ownership is a feature of free societies where you are not a
00:19:30 slave. You are a citizen. You are entrusted with a variety of responsibilities, just like you are
00:19:35 entrusted with a driver's license. We do not ban cars. I don't like, there's so many analogies floating
00:19:42 around all the time, right? I've heard them all and I've heard them ad nauseum. So it's,
00:19:45 you know, but we'll just use this one for now. I'm, I guess I'm talking to myself to not get
00:19:49 annoyed with them, but you know, everyone is entrusted with a, with a driver's license and
00:19:55 there's no criminal background check required, but yet the odd person drives drunk, wipes an
00:20:00 entire family out. And that's, and that's real. But the, the first reaction of the government or
00:20:06 the public isn't like, you know, obviously people shouldn't own cars or they should only go to and
00:20:12 from specific places with permission of the government. Of course not. They're like, these
00:20:15 people broke the rules, throw them in jail, give them a lifetime, uh, driving ban. When there was
00:20:21 a van attack in Toronto and the, if the van attack was a multiple victim public shooting of which we've
00:20:28 had very few in Canadian history, thank God, you know, you would think that, um, that people would
00:20:35 be up in arms. Like, why can you take $80 down to the van rental place with just a driver's license
00:20:41 and drive away with a van? Nobody said that ever. Nobody even, it never even crossed anyone's mind
00:20:47 to increase the restrictions on renting vans. But for some reason it's guns. And the reason for that is
00:20:54 not everyone sees value in firearms. So if I were to, to, to forward one important message,
00:21:00 firearms are incredibly important to the people that, that own them. You can have firearms in
00:21:05 Canada for hunting, sports shooting, collecting. You can pass them down. There are a variety of
00:21:10 different things. And Canadian gun culture is a beneficial, super positive culture. So people
00:21:17 sports shoot with these guns, hunting is a way of life. And then it's people that are like, well,
00:21:22 it's a hobby and it's not. And I'll tell you why, because these are not, you know, if you think of
00:21:28 a golf club as a hobby, but at the worst moment in your life, when no one's there to help you,
00:21:34 this tool, this sport shooting or hunting tool can save your life. So this makes them extremely,
00:21:40 extremely valuable property people. So we are qualified to own them. We are tightly regulated,
00:21:47 right? All the people get criminal record checks every day. There's, we have storage requirements.
00:21:52 These are laws. We have transportation requirements and licensed gun owners do not represent a 0.96
00:21:57 disproportionate risk to public safety. And then the other side, sorry for going on,
00:22:01 but this is important. And it takes more than a couple of soundbites to explain it.
00:22:05 When you're talking about bans or further restrictions or buybacks as were confiscation
00:22:09 programs, you're not just taking guns from people that didn't do anything to deserve it.
00:22:14 You're destroying the shooting clubs. You're running up the national debt. You're destroying a culture that
00:22:20 is older than Canada itself. And that represents billions in real estate and billions in property
00:22:27 improvements and taking away the central hub, the community hub in a community that that's at least
00:22:34 2.5 million people strong. So there's a, there are many moving parts. It's not so it's, it's not a
00:22:40 simple situation and it is devastating to the people that again, haven't done anything to deserve it.
00:22:45 It's bad policy. Amen. I have a few more questions I want to get into here. And some of them are kind
00:22:51 of specific. So bear with me audience. Can you explain in the best of your ability, what kinds of
00:22:59 firearms the current federal liberal government is trying to ban? Because I want to stress, this may
00:23:05 sound silly for those of us who understand firearms culture. So folks just bear with me. In Canada,
00:23:13 the machine gun that you will see on like a Rambo movie or something where the person just holds
00:23:20 down the trigger and sprays bullets, those have been big time illegal since before I was born.
00:23:26 Okay. In the early seventies. So the full auto thing, like that, that is not accepted in Canada.
00:23:34 Those are not what the government is banning. When people say, oh, they're banning semi-automatics.
00:23:41 Okay. What a semi-automatic means in normal people talk is if you've got your firearm up, it's squeeze,
00:23:49 bang, squeeze, bang. You have to pull the trigger every time. There's no holding your finger down
00:23:56 and spraying rounds at people. So like, this is where I do think there's a big education gap
00:24:02 between the folks who understand normal, safe, law-abiding firearms ownerships with all of our
00:24:09 trigger locks and our gun safes and all of our background checks. Okay. When you go even just
00:24:14 for your regular PAL. Okay. Your regular, you know, non-restricted, if you want to own a rifle or a
00:24:19 shotgun, they phone your ex-boyfriends and girlfriends. Okay. Like they do a really
00:24:26 thorough background check to make sure things are all in the up and up. So all that said,
00:24:31 can you please describe for people what kinds and styles, I think is the better term of firearms,
00:24:38 the federal government is trying to confiscate?
00:24:40 So the most important thing is assault weapons don't, they don't exist in Canada. The only people
00:24:46 that have assault weapons, as you're describing full autos, right? Hold, hold the trigger and the 0.51
00:24:51 firearm continues to discharge bullets, right? Those, uh, it was actually the late seventies that
00:24:57 those were banned. And it was a long time ago. We definitely agree on that. And the only people that
00:25:04 have those are movie armorers and museums basically, and the police and the military, of course. And then a
00:25:09 handful of people that had a specific status, like I, even, even me, I'm, I'm too young to have gotten
00:25:17 a prohibited firearms license. So really important. I, I, I have so much experience with the legacy
00:25:26 media in Canada, um, showing stories about the so-called buyback and the bill C-71 and bill C-21 and
00:25:34 all these different, all this different legislation and orders in council. And then while they're talking
00:25:39 about these measures, they show full autos in the United States being, being discharged. Like when you
00:25:45 say education gap, it truly is propaganda. And of course it's wildly frustrating. So these guns that are,
00:25:51 that are being banned are a wide variety of guns. So you have regular semi-autos that look like machine
00:25:56 guns, but just, just aren't. And these are guns that have been tested by the RCMP to make sure that they
00:26:03 couldn't be easily converted to full autos. Okay. These are tried and true guns that we've had for
00:26:08 decades upon decades in Canada. Then, um, hunting rifles and target shooting rifles that are too
00:26:14 powerful. So they say over 10,000 jewels. Um, but basically you look and they're like, you know,
00:26:20 big game African hunting rifles. So there's a wide variety of different firearms that fall under their
00:26:26 assault style, um, you know, ban. And some of them are even single shot rifles, many bolt actions.
00:26:34 There are all, even some shotguns are too dangerous to own. So it is, they continue to call them assault
00:26:40 weapons and they even can, they tried to call them assault style weapons. Like anyway, I don't know if
00:26:47 any, a lot of people bought into that, but there, there are no assault weapons in Canada. So these are
00:26:52 firearms that are held by people like me that I use for target shooting or training or recreational
00:26:58 shooting or what have you. And, um, yeah, it's, it is an absolute mess and it's, it's,
00:27:03 it's government overreach in the extreme. Some of it, I'm glad you described it with
00:27:08 the mainstream media. That's why I belabored the point of like, this is, this is not, you know,
00:27:13 I love me a Stallone flick, but this is not a Stallone flick that's happening here in Canada,
00:27:18 not from law abiding firearms owners. Anyway. Um, I wanted to get into exactly what you guys are
00:27:23 fighting and what you guys are proposing. Cause you mentioned the old, you know, I would say,
00:27:28 you know, more restricted firearms licenses in some cases, uh, way back in the day, again,
00:27:35 before I was born, thank you. Um, there were some of those firearms that were then grandfathered in.
00:27:41 Okay. Are, is that what your organization is looking at with some of these versions of the
00:27:48 firearms, which are mostly cosmetic? I will point out like they're, they're finding ones that have
00:27:53 like the removable, you know, stock, so you can shorten it, which a lot of women use by the way, 1.00
00:27:57 cause it makes it easier for shorter arms. Right. Um, they're removing, uh, taking away the guns that
00:28:02 are, you know, painted black. Okay. But the, the wood grain version is okay. Like a lot of this is
00:28:08 cosmetic. So what is the CCFR doing as far as negotiating with the federal government? Are,
00:28:15 are you guys looking at like a grandfathering in to try to get the government to back off on this?
00:28:22 Well, the government is marching forward with their buyback and we have information that they,
00:28:26 they are. And I, we really, we released a video, uh, I don't know, about a week and a half ago.
00:28:33 And basically where the situation that gun owners are in is we've been fighting this,
00:28:38 since May 1st, 2020, we sued the government in the largest lawsuit in the history
00:28:44 of Canada for, on behalf of gun owners. Uh, we took the government to federal court.
00:28:48 We cross-examined every witness. We fought every intervener. We filed three injunctions.
00:28:54 We went toe to toe and put $3 million into that. That's never been possible for gun owners before. 0.68
00:29:00 So that's great. We lost. We went to the court of appeal. We fought them again. We lost again,
00:29:05 and we are still fighting it because we've, uh, made an application to go to the Supreme Court of
00:29:10 Canada. So we'll see whether or not that's accepted. So we're continuing to fight this
00:29:13 to have it completely repealed, but I don't know. I don't want to be too cynical. I just,
00:29:20 the courts are a funny bunch. Let's, uh, let's just put it, uh, put it that way. We also participated at
00:29:26 an unprecedented level in the last election. The last election was for everything. Yeah.
00:29:33 If the conservative conservatives would have won, all of this would have been being unwound as we
00:29:39 speak. So unfortunately the, uh, CCF are still alone, but we were actually the fifth largest
00:29:46 third-party advertiser in the entire country, including unions and, you know, all the rest of
00:29:50 that stuff. So we took a real swing at them during the election. Now they're moving forward
00:29:54 with their buyback because they won again. I wish more people had jumped in, um, not to be too
00:30:00 self-serving, but more people had jumped in during the election. Maybe we wouldn't be having this
00:30:05 conversation, but as a last ditch effort to total confiscation over the span of one year,
00:30:11 we said, Hey government, there's an opportunity for you not to spend all this money for you to
00:30:16 leave all the good people alone, right? Maybe divert that money into dealing with firearm-related
00:30:20 violence, which has never been higher by issuing grandfathering. Now grandfathering means that,
00:30:26 uh, gun owners that have these types of firearms can continue to own them. No new
00:30:30 ones can come into the country and that we could buy and sell between us. So we could move these
00:30:35 firearms around with people who have the same license status. So that would cost the government
00:30:39 nothing. Taxpayers would save a unimaginable amount of money. Gun owners could be not victimized, 0.84
00:30:47 at least at, at the extent that they would for, with immediate confiscation, which is what the
00:30:51 government is rolling out. And then that's also to us, the most important delay tactic. We need to
00:30:57 keep physical possession of these firearms so that there's something to roll back. Should there be
00:31:03 another election sitting around waiting for total confiscation is not an option. A lot of people love
00:31:11 that and people love to do nothing because it's the easiest thing to do. So if you sit around and do
00:31:15 nothing, you're going to get nothing. So I guess we'll see what happens. That's why we rolled out a
00:31:20 suggestion of grandfathering and grandfathering has now been rejected. They want to go forward with their
00:31:25 multi-billion dollar program to take guns from me whilst people get shot in the street with illegal
00:31:31 guns. To that point, so they've officially rejected your offer of grandfathering? Well,
00:31:38 we got a notification from the prime minister's office. We read your document very carefully.
00:31:43 I'm sure they read it very carefully. It was a six page document, so I don't know how much effort that
00:31:49 would require. They forwarded it to the minister of public safety, which we had sent it to anyway.
00:31:55 We sent it to every liberal MP. We sent it to every liberal staffer that we had information for,
00:32:01 of course, the prime minister and all the cabinet ministers that mattered. But they know how to do
00:32:06 this. They've done grandfathering before. So in a way, it's good and bad, right? For them to turn away
00:32:14 from that shows they only want to take firearms from licensed gun owners. They are not concerned
00:32:22 about criminals that are shooting houses and drive-by shootings and all the rest of them
00:32:26 kicking doors in. They're not concerned about that. Only licensed gun owners. So I don't want to
00:32:31 fall down the rabbit hole, but think about that for a second. They're willing to spend billions of
00:32:36 dollars in deficit spending. They're willing to make people like me absolutely furious, like turn their
00:32:43 lives upside down. And when they have a viable alternative. But no, they're going to go forward
00:32:51 with it. So there's a lot going on with this. And I don't want to get too inflammatory about it,
00:32:56 but I think people should just think about that and see where this government is going.
00:33:00 We are going to be speaking with a spokesperson for the Toronto Police Association, who I will point out
00:33:06 as a group are being brave by speaking up about this. Usually police are hesitant to wade into things
00:33:13 like this. They're pretty stoic in my experience, but they're actually speaking up. Basically to
00:33:19 to summarize what they're saying is, hey, it's not the sport shooters and the hunters and the law
00:33:24 abiding firearms owners that we're having trouble with here on the streets of Toronto.
00:33:28 It's the gangbangers with the illegal guns, which are often smuggled across the border. I know that is
00:33:34 no surprise to any rational person who's listening right now. But it's really important, I think,
00:33:40 to have a respected law enforcement organization like the Toronto Police Association speak up
00:33:46 on an issue like this. Are you hearing from other police officer groups saying, hey,
00:33:52 yeah, we have a gun problem in Canada, but it's not with the duck hunters?
00:33:56 Yeah, of course. I mean, even the National Police Federation had put out a statement. That's the union
00:34:02 that represents all of the frontline police officers of the RCMP, which is one, I think,
00:34:07 one of the biggest police agencies on the planet because the national force, obviously. But even
00:34:12 there, these are frontline people. These are the people that have to deal with people wielding
00:34:17 firearms in a criminal manner. And even they are like, just leave the license gun owners alone.
00:34:24 But the government isn't listening to police. They only listen to police when the police are saying
00:34:29 something that works for them. When the police are saying something that goes against their politics or
00:34:34 their ideological pursuits, then it's like, well, we don't listen to police. So, you know, good for
00:34:40 Toronto Police for standing up, good for the National Police Federation and the countless other police
00:34:45 forces. Although there are some that have signed agreements with the federal government for money,
00:34:51 for funding to roll out this confiscation program, Winnipeg Police being one of them. And I think there's one
00:34:57 in Eastern Canada as well. I think the OPP are looking at it too. I guess we'll see. But you got to
00:35:03 wonder what's going on with these police forces that are signing on to this. It is, it's pretty monstrous.
00:35:10 It's for the record, Alberta Premier Daniel Smith has instructed,
00:35:15 saying her province isn't going to be putting taxpayers' money into this.
00:35:18 So that was nice to hear. Rod, that's all the time we have. Where can people find your work? If they
00:35:25 want to tune into your show, if they want to jump on board the advocacy train, if they want to speak
00:35:30 up for law-abiding firearms owners, because you may not own a firearm today, it may not affect you today,
00:35:36 but it could be your gas-powered car next week, okay, if we let this go through. Rod, where can people
00:35:42 find your work? Well, of course, they can go to CCFR.ca. You can also see our podcast, the CCFR
00:35:49 radio podcast on YouTube and all the other social media platforms. We also have a nationally broadcast
00:35:53 television show on Wild TV going into our fifth season called CCFR radio on the air. So you can
00:35:59 find us through all that and the socials. Rod, thank you so much for joining us today.
00:36:04 I appreciate it. Thanks, Chris. Good luck. Once again, that is Rod Giltaka. He is with the
00:36:10 Canadian Coalition for Firearms Rights, the CCFR. You've probably seen their big logos. It's kind
00:36:16 of like half of a maple leaf and half of a long gun on the other side. Again, they are an advocacy
00:36:22 organization that are fighting for the rights of legal law-abiding firearms owners. The Canadian
00:36:28 Taxpayers Federation, we are also in this fight from, of course, the financial angle, because as he
00:36:34 pointed out with the debt, we do not have the money to spend on things like this, okay? We
00:36:40 cannot afford to be paying for a huge amount of compensation for the confiscation of firearms.
00:36:46 And we also can't be affording how much it is going to cost. Just imagine how much this is going
00:36:53 to cost police, police to do this. Imagine them having to go door to door, all of these man hours,
00:37:01 door to door, to legal law-abiding firearms owners saying, knock, knock, who's there? The police,
00:37:06 we're here to confiscate your property. Or even if people are safely coming up to the police station
00:37:12 saying, here, I'm here to, you know, allow the state to take away my property. I've got it in the car.
00:37:20 You have no idea how many hours and hours and hours of police time that accrues. Now multiply that by
00:37:28 however many thousands and thousands and thousands of people are going to be stuck in that situation.
00:37:33 And we have un-money. To exactly what Rod was talking about, okay? This is not trying to combat
00:37:41 the actual street-level gang crime that people are seeing with handguns, which are illegally brought
00:37:48 over often from across the border in the United States. We hear time and time again from police
00:37:54 organizations saying, um, yeah, we have a gun problem. But we don't have a gun problem with the normal
00:38:00 law-abiding firearms owners who are out there as sport shooters and hunters. How much of a problem
00:38:08 is this? Who is speaking up on this on behalf of the police? Let's find out. Joining me now is Clayton
00:38:15 Campbell. He is the president of the Toronto Police Association. Basically what that is, is the union
00:38:21 representing the frontline guys and gals in blue on the streets of Toronto who work as police officers.
00:38:28 So sir, Mr. Campbell, thank you so much for joining the show today. I know it really matters when
00:38:34 associations like yours speak up on this stuff. Yeah. Thanks. Thanks for having me. And it's great
00:38:39 to speak to an audience outside of Ontario. So thanks for the invitation. We really appreciate it. Now,
00:38:46 the reason why we invited you on the show is because I saw your statement posted on X and we can probably
00:38:52 pull it up here just to kind of summarize. You're basically saying here, if I put on my glasses,
00:38:58 in the city of Toronto, which is the focal point for a lot of the conversation around gun violence,
00:39:03 it will have little to zero impact on firearm crime. We're seeing in the city. It is a small
00:39:10 number of gangs or organized crime members involved in firearm violence in the city, and it is not legal
00:39:17 gun owners. Now, of course you're referencing there, the so-called buyback program that is being
00:39:23 rolled out by the federal government. As a law abiding firearms owner, I would describe it more
00:39:28 as a confiscation rollout. But for argument's sake, let's call it the buyback. Why did you feel it was
00:39:34 important to speak up against this form of the buyback? Yeah. I mean, since I've taken this role and
00:39:42 you mentioned, I'm so fortunate I get to represent about 8,600 members. They're police officers,
00:39:48 special constables, dispatchers, IT people all across the great men and women that keep Toronto
00:39:55 safe each and every day. And the firearm issue in the city of Toronto is really the focal point
00:40:01 when it comes across all of Canada. And so it's important to talk about the things that actually
00:40:06 work and the things that don't work. And what we find in the city of Toronto is that last year,
00:40:12 our great men and women seized about 700 illegal guns in the city. About 90% of those were sourced
00:40:20 to the United States illegally from the United States. The other 10% were probably from the US,
00:40:26 but very difficult to source everything if you're a gun owner, serial numbers scratched off,
00:40:32 things of that sort. So what we found, it is not legal gun owners. It's certainly not hunters or
00:40:38 target shooters. They're involved in crimes in the city of Toronto. It's a small number of thugs,
00:40:44 criminal gangs, organized crime that are involved in terrorizing our great city. And really, we thought
00:40:52 that that's a waste of resources to spend that amount of money on this gun buyback program. And we
00:40:57 can think of many ways it could be spent that would actually keep the city of Toronto safe.
00:41:02 You know, as a firearms owner, and I've got law enforcement in my family, I'm just trying to
00:41:08 picture what that would look like. Trying to get Toronto police or any other police team,
00:41:15 trying to confiscate the otherwise legal property of law abiding gun owners. Just, you know, the man
00:41:23 hours or the people hours involved in this of, you know, would you have to go door to door?
00:41:30 It'd be tough, right? I mean, these are a lot of the times they're unrestricted firearms. So we don't,
00:41:35 we don't know where they are. And really just a waste of resources, in my opinion. In the city of
00:41:41 Toronto, we've seen luckily an increase of investment in public safety. Well, we've seen
00:41:46 the city of Toronto and our police services board, that's the employer for all of our members,
00:41:51 start to reinvest in the city of Toronto and in public safety, after many years of defunding the
00:41:57 police. So we're starting to head it in the right direction. But we're not there yet. We still take a
00:42:02 long time to get the radio calls. We're still short staffed in many areas of the service. So it would
00:42:07 really be a ridiculous use of resources. And what we really need to focus on in the city,
00:42:14 and I think the federal government does, is on the legal use of firearms by bad guys,
00:42:21 not law abiding citizens. And I think a lot of the time, it's just a lack of understanding
00:42:26 from people that maybe don't possess firearms. They hear something like, we're going to ban guns. And
00:42:32 someone that doesn't have any interaction with guns, would think, okay, then just no one's going
00:42:37 to have guns, and no one's going to get shot. The reality of it is, only the bad guys don't follow
00:42:41 the rules. And what you're going to be doing is really punishing law abiding citizens, instead of
00:42:45 focusing on the bad guys, they're causing the violence in our city. Yeah, it's not typically the
00:42:51 criminals who are getting the government bat signal saying, Oh, what I'm doing is illegal. Let me go turn
00:42:56 in my legal guns anyway. Well, yeah, exactly. They're already in possession of an illegal gun.
00:43:02 I can't think of a time when a legal gun in the city has been used in a crime. I can't think of one.
00:43:07 We have hundreds of shootings in this city. We're a large city. We just had an eight-year-old,
00:43:13 it was just a horrible story, shot and killed while he was sleeping in his bed, eight years old. So sad.
00:43:20 And I know when our investigators identify and arrest who was involved in that,
00:43:24 this is not some legal gun owner. It certainly isn't somebody target practicing at one o'clock
00:43:29 in the morning in a park. These are going to be thugs. These are going to be gang members involved
00:43:34 in illegal use of firearms, not legal firearm owners. That was just a terrible story. It's just
00:43:40 like your worst nightmare as a parent, right? You put your child to bed. It's hard to even really
00:43:44 articulate. To your point, I'm just going to go out on a limb here. You mentioned the person likely
00:43:51 responsible. It's also likely that they're already known to police, right? It's also likely that that
00:43:57 person already has a rap sheet. And frankly, you know, as a taxpayer, a lot of people forget,
00:44:04 we already have a lot of these resources there. Like the laws are supposed to be on the books. The bad
00:44:09 guys are supposed to stay away from the good guys. Can you expand on that a little bit? Like what would
00:44:15 actually help the frontline police keep people more safe in places like Toronto and not have something
00:44:22 like this cumbersome government heavy buyback program against law abiding normal firearms owners?
00:44:30 What tools do you guys need? You know, it's pretty basic stuff. It is we need changes to the criminal
00:44:37 code to keep repeat violent offenders in custody. And we're not talking about people involved in a theft or
00:44:44 people involved in making a mistake as a youth or something like that. We're talking about gang
00:44:48 members involved in violent carjackings, firearm offenses, home invasions, murders, shootings.
00:44:55 They need to be kept in custody and they need to be punished. They need to be kept in jail.
00:45:00 And one thing I've said many times to the media is that I can guarantee you one thing. If that gang
00:45:06 member involved in that illegal firearm offense was in custody, they wouldn't have shot that second
00:45:11 person. And I think we need to really put victims first. We need to focus on those bad guys.
00:45:16 And there needs to be some minor changes, really small changes to the criminal code to keep them
00:45:20 in custody. We lobbied for, I've been at the police union for seven years. We lobbied the previous
00:45:28 Liberal government every single year. And all we saw was changes that actually made it harder to keep
00:45:34 bad guys in custody. An election has been held. We have a different, could be a different Liberal
00:45:40 government. So we're going to see what they do as far as bail. But we need some minor changes to
00:45:46 the criminal code. We're very lucky in Ontario. We have a super supportive provincial government,
00:45:51 a conservative government led by Premier Doug Ford, who is very supportive of public safety
00:45:56 and our members. And we're hoping in the fall, we'll see some changes to the criminal code to keep
00:46:02 these thugs in jail. I have to stress as a spokesperson for the Taxpayers Federation, I need to repeat,
00:46:09 all of this money is being spent anyway, like the police are being paid, you know, the prisons are
00:46:14 being run, all of this stuff is already on the books, it's all at taxpayers expense. But the cost
00:46:19 of the time of the rotating in and out and in and out and in and out, and having the same group of
00:46:25 people, in some cases, just a small handful of people causing 1000s of crimes over and over again,
00:46:33 is a huge strain on the public purse. And this whole buyback program thing, we've had experts
00:46:39 speaking from even universities, guesstimating that this is going to cost more than a billion dollars
00:46:45 with a B. And again, to your point, you're going to have you're going to have police officers being
00:46:50 tasked maybe going door to door. And I just have this picture in my head, even if they don't have to
00:46:54 go door to door, say you have a law abiding firearms owner, show up at the police station,
00:47:00 walk into the foyer saying, Hey, guys, I have something in my trunk, like the amount of paperwork
00:47:06 that that would incur, correct? Yeah. And I mean, I, we support, and you look in city of Toronto,
00:47:13 our mayor is in it from the NDP party, we have a federal liberal party, we have the conservative
00:47:20 provincial party, we work with anybody, we base our arguments on truth and evidence. And we know
00:47:28 that the gun buyback program is going to have essentially zero impact on the crime in Toronto.
00:47:33 There's lots of better ways that we can invest taxpayers money. Clearly, there's a problem at
00:47:39 the border when we're seeing 90% of the illegal firearm seized source to the US, clearly a problem
00:47:45 there. And we can definitely use the resources to hunt down these, these criminals, check on those
00:47:52 that are in bail. And like you mentioned, it's a revolving door in and out of custody, it's the
00:47:58 same individuals, and it's very expensive to continue to arrest them. The legal costs behind
00:48:03 it, the court costs behind it, you know, it's simple, if you shoot an illegal firearm in the streets
00:48:08 of Toronto, just put them in jail. We don't need that in the city of Toronto, and just leave the legal gun
00:48:14 owners alone and put the bad guys in jail. That's really our message. Yeah.
00:48:18 Lastly, and I don't want you to have to get too political on this or speculate, but we have heard
00:48:23 Prime Minister Mark Carney in his own words, describe himself as a pragmatist. As a long time political
00:48:30 analyst, I've been in the game for a long time. It's frankly easy for the new person to say, you know
00:48:34 what, that was the previous guy's plan. That was the previous government, I'm coming in fresh,
00:48:39 I'm the pragmatist, I'm going to drop this, this and this. Are you hopeful that this could be dropped,
00:48:46 that they could start focusing more on keeping bad guys in jail, on strengthening the border, reducing
00:48:52 the amount of illegal guns coming across the border and flooding places like Toronto? Are you, are you
00:48:57 hopeful? Well, we try, right? We took an unprecedented step. We did support the federal conservatives in the
00:49:04 last election. It was purely around their public safety platform. They've been talking about bail
00:49:09 reform for a long time and we were very supportive of it. I'll say we at least heard in the throne
00:49:16 speech conversation around bail. So my job is to advocate on behalf of the members that I represent
00:49:24 and also really the citizens of Toronto to make sure they're safe. So we're speaking with conservative
00:49:29 MPs and liberal MPs right now. We had a meeting yesterday with a conservative MP talking about
00:49:34 some changes to the criminal code. We're going to be meeting with Sean Frazier, the Minister of Justice.
00:49:40 So we have to continue to advocate whoever is in power to try and bring forward some reforms that
00:49:46 are going to keep the citizens safe. And a gun buy back program isn't going to do that. And we can,
00:49:51 like I said, think of many areas we'd rather redirect those funds to actually keep the citizens of
00:49:58 Toronto safe. I know we're out of time and I know that many of our viewers are really happy to hear
00:50:03 what you're saying here. Is there any way for them to support what you're saying or to spread
00:50:08 that message to make sure that their elected officials hear what you're saying? Yeah, I mean,
00:50:13 we live in a democracy, right? So we can hold the politicians accountable, let them know
00:50:19 really what they're believing in. And I think one of the challenges is a lack of understanding for
00:50:24 people that are not involved in firearms, not involved in law enforcement. And when they hear,
00:50:30 like I mentioned earlier, we're just going to ban guns, they think, okay, then we're going to have
00:50:35 no guns. It's really the reality of it is that it's the criminals that are already in possession
00:50:41 of illegal guns when they don't have a license. So I think it's really important to educate
00:50:47 everybody. You know, look, most people living in an urban environment in the City of Toronto
00:50:51 have never shot a gun or been a hunter or a target shot. So we can't really blame them for
00:50:55 not understanding. So I think there needs to be an education piece. And that's what I'm trying to do
00:51:00 based on evidence and things that are actually going to work in listening to the over 8,000 members
00:51:05 that are out there every day keeping the citizens of Toronto safe. Clayton Campbell, President of the
00:51:11 Toronto Police Association, representing the frontline police officers and peace officers there in Toronto.
00:51:17 Thank you so much for your time today. You're welcome. Thanks again for having me.
00:51:21 You bet. Once again, you just heard it from him. That was a really important interview.
00:51:27 So I have some homework for folks. Can you please share this story? Share this video. It's not often,
00:51:33 okay, speaking from experience as a longtime court reporter, it's not often that you hear representatives
00:51:40 of the police speak up on something like this, because they're just there to do their job. They're
00:51:46 there to follow their orders. They're there to enforce the law. It takes a lot for them to say,
00:51:51 you know what, this is really not working here, folks. We need to make some changes here. And you just
00:51:56 heard directly from a spokesperson who represents, you know, a huge number of police officers on Canada's,
00:52:04 the streets of Canada's biggest city, that we do have a gun problem in Canada, but it is illegal guns
00:52:11 coming from the United States. And that if we're going to spend taxpayers' money fixing what is
00:52:17 actually the gun problem, it shouldn't be going after confiscating normal law-abiding firearms
00:52:23 owners' property. We should direct those resources into actual street-level crime prevention,
00:52:30 and thickening that border to make sure that guns like these are not coming into the country
00:52:36 in the first place. So it's really important for you right now to head over to Juneau News,
00:52:41 become a subscriber if you're not one already, and most importantly, share this story. Send this video
00:52:49 to your MP, to your MLA, to your family and friends. Make sure they know that the police themselves are
00:52:57 saying this current gun confiscation thing is not going to work. Thank you so much for watching.