The Candice Malcolm Show - March 25, 2025


Election INTERFERENCE from Canada’s Deep State

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Kevin O’Leary: Carney is Trudeau 2.0 Mark Carney’s DISTURBING ties to Communist China

Episode Stats


Length

40 minutes

Words per minute

204.21

Word count

8,197

Sentence count

518

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

12

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Candice Malcolm Show, host Candice Malan is joined by Josh Udall, co-host of the Elevate podcast, to discuss a breaking news story from the Globe and Mail alleging that Indian agents were involved in helping Pierre Polyvorev win the Conservative leadership election in 2022.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hi, I'm Candice Malcolm and this is the Candice Malcolm Show. We have a great episode for
00:00:06 you today. Thank you so much for tuning in. Don't forget to like this video, share it,
00:00:10 leave it a comment and subscribe. So I am joined today for the entire episode by a podcaster,
00:00:17 one of my favorite podcasters in Canada. His name is Josh Udall. So Josh is an entrepreneur
00:00:21 based in Halifax and he co-hosts the Elevate podcast discussing business, marketing and
00:00:27 politics. Josh, thank you so much for joining the show. Thank you so much for having me. I'm
00:00:31 grateful to be here. Well, I love your podcast and it's great. Great to get to know you. I've never
00:00:36 had you on the show before. So I'm looking forward to our conversation. Likewise. So I'm very excited
00:00:40 to see what the magic can make happen today. Okay. So this is the big story. This is the sort of
00:00:47 the thing that was all over social media this morning, breaking news from the Globe and Mail
00:00:52 front page story that CSIS alleges that India organized support for Pierre Polyev's 2022
00:00:59 conservative leadership bid. And I have a lot of issues with this news article. I have a lot of
00:01:06 issues right down to the headline. So I am going to walk the audience through this story and then I'm
00:01:12 going to get you to comment and react, Josh. Okay. So let's just start off with this headline
00:01:17 that CSIS alleges that there was organized support. Let me just say, let me just clarify,
00:01:23 CSIS does not allege this. The story is based on an unnamed official within CSIS that leaked this
00:01:30 story to the Globe and Mail. They decided to leak it in the middle of an election campaign, right?
00:01:34 And they are making this allegation. So this is not coming from the head of CSIS. This isn't a press
00:01:39 conference or a report that has been put out by the government. This is, in my opinion, election
00:01:45 interference. They held this story. This is a report from 2022. They held it until a campaign,
00:01:51 until the election was underway. They want to derail the conservatives. They want to derail
00:01:55 Pierre Polyev, make him look illegitimate, make him look like somehow there's something nefarious going
00:02:00 on with his leadership of the party. It is all a deflection away from Mark Carney, away from what just
00:02:06 happened, the total mess and ridiculousness of the liberal race, where they had 400 members,
00:02:12 only 150 voted, 150,000 voted, where they disqualified two major candidates because they
00:02:19 didn't want Mark Carney to be challenged in any meaningful way, right? And so all of that is
00:02:23 happening. And then this story drops from the Globe and Mail. She's having the Globe and Mail for even
00:02:27 printing this stuff and being involved in it. So just allow me to go through the story because
00:02:33 it is really something. Okay. So here's how the story reads. Agents of India and their proxies
00:02:41 allegedly meddled in the 2022 election of Pierre Polyev as conservative leader, as part of a larger
00:02:47 effort to cozy up to politicians of all parties, according to a source with top secret clearance.
00:02:54 The source said that the Canadian Security Intelligence Service, CSIS, learned that Indian
00:02:59 agents were involved in raising money and organizing within the South Asian community for Mr. Polyev during
00:03:04 a leadership race, which he won handily. But the CSIS assessment did not indicate that this effort was
00:03:10 done in a sweeping and highly organized way, said the source. Mr. Polyev won on the first ballot
00:03:14 with 68%. Okay. So first of all, they admit right here that it didn't really have an impact.
00:03:22 Pierre Polyev won with a sweeping majority. We all know that Pierre Polyev is very popular within the
00:03:27 Conservative Party. And even though there were other, you know, high profile candidates, namely Jean Charest,
00:03:33 Lesley, Leslie Lewis, Roman Babber, there were other people that were, you know, and Patrick Brown,
00:03:39 who's the mayor of Mississauga, or sorry, of Brampton, you know, other high profile leaders, but Pierre is
00:03:44 so popular within the party, he won handily. And here that they're saying that the CSIS assessment did
00:03:49 not indicate that the effort was done in a sweeping way. So it sort of seems like random one-off things.
00:03:55 Let me just continue reading. It says, CSIS also did not have evidence that Mr. Polyev or members of
00:04:00 the inner circle were aware of the alleged actions of India's agents and their proxies,
00:04:05 said the source, who has national security clearance to see top secret reports. The Globe and Mail is not
00:04:11 identifying the source because they were not authorized to disclose classified information
00:04:16 publicly. Okay. So you have a whistleblower, allegedly, giving top secret information to the Globe and Mail in
00:04:25 the middle of an election. It says that this person has top secret clearance. So they're sharing
00:04:30 secret information from the government, sharing it with the Globe and Mail, which I believe is a crime,
00:04:36 or at least it should be, doing it in the campaign, and making it seem like Pierre Polyev did something
00:04:41 wrong, even though in the article itself, it admits that he didn't do anything wrong. He didn't know
00:04:45 about it. His team didn't know about it, and it didn't have an impact. So the big question out of
00:04:50 this story is why is it a story? Why did the Globe and Mail put this on the cover of their newspaper? Why are
00:04:56 they trying to push this as an election issue? Is there something wrong with Pierre Polyev's
00:05:01 leadership? Is it illegitimate in any way? No, of course not. But this is what the media does.
00:05:07 They whip up the narrative. They don't want to talk about Mark Carney. They don't want to talk about
00:05:11 his record or the liberal record and what it's done to Canada. They don't want to ask tough questions
00:05:16 of the prime minister. And instead, they go after the leader of the opposition for something that's
00:05:22 completely irrelevant. And in my mind, it's nothing. Look, it is a problem that there are
00:05:26 Indian agents that are acting in the South Asian community and doing this kind of thing. That is a 0.96
00:05:31 problem. But it's the government's problem. It is Trudeau's government and now Mark Carney's
00:05:36 government. It's their job to crack down on that, not Pierre Polyev, who even as a report
00:05:42 admits, didn't even know about it. So Josh, what do you make of the story and what do you make
00:05:47 of my interpretation of it? I think it's accurate from what you read there.
00:05:53 And really what's going to happen here is what they're feasting their eyes on right now is the
00:05:56 headline readers who are only really going to be doing that in this election. Right now, we have a
00:06:00 very short election. And what's going to happen, I've said this on my show, is things are going to be
00:06:05 pumped like crazy, like drinking information out of a fire hose. So people really aren't going to have
00:06:09 time to look at the article as you just did here. They're going to headline read. And the
00:06:13 narrative is going to be crafted that there goes Polyev again and his security clearance not
00:06:18 getting it. Look how irresponsible he is. And that's how exactly how this is going to go. And
00:06:22 that's the narrative that they're purposely trying to create through this. The only question I have
00:06:27 is if it had such a big impact, I'm wondering, Candace, do you hear anything about the Indian police
00:06:34 stations that have taken place in this country? Oh, no, no. Oh, sorry. That's China. My bad. That was 1.00
00:06:38 China. Oh, my bad. Yes. The country that has benefited the liberal party consistently,
00:06:43 including Parm Baines out in B.C. and who invited Mark Carney out that had Chinese paid for media in
00:06:49 the audience. Yes. We don't want to talk about that, though. It's going to be about the security
00:06:53 clearance for Pierre Polyev. No, that's exactly what this is. And they're trying to keep the
00:06:56 attention off them and how they've benefited from actual election interference that has really
00:07:01 inundated that party to this point. Well, it is so true. We had Sam Cooper,
00:07:05 the investigative journalist, on the show two weeks ago, and he had photographic evidence of
00:07:09 Justin Trudeau meeting with basically Chinese gangsters who were the kingpins in the drug and 0.96
00:07:15 fentanyl wars. And he has photos of them, Justin Trudeau, attending high-priced, high-dollar
00:07:21 fundraisers with them. So we know that this has happened. The Hogue report came out, and it didn't
00:07:27 blow the whistle on what we thought it would. It didn't really deliver much. But now, again,
00:07:31 bringing it up in the middle of an election campaign and trying to flip it to say, oh, no,
00:07:35 it's not about the Chinese and the liberals. It's really about India and the conservatives.
00:07:40 And I'm glad you brought up that security clearance thing, because this is sort of a favorite issue
00:07:45 of Mark Carney. He loves to talk about this fact that Pierre Polyev doesn't have his security
00:07:51 clearance. So while I'm at it, while we're talking about this ridiculous Global Mail story,
00:07:55 let's throw in this claim that Pierre Polyev hasn't bothered to get his security clearance.
00:08:01 Here is a clip of Mark Carney saying this exact thing.
00:08:06 Pierre Polyev hasn't ever bothered to get his security clearance. I've already, during this
00:08:13 leadership campaign, has filled out my forms. It wasn't that hard to do, I have to say,
00:08:18 and put them in. I fully expect to get it in the near future.
00:08:23 Okay, so he's saying at that point, he wasn't even the prime minister. He was running for liberal
00:08:27 leader, and yet he was already able to submit his forms. I don't know how he was able to do that.
00:08:31 He's not even a sitting member of parliament, but we'll move on from that. And he said it again,
00:08:36 when he was in London, England, the weekend, he became prime minister. He was speaking to press,
00:08:41 and he mentioned the same thing. Let's play that clip.
00:08:45 That the leader of the opposition cannot find it. And look, you look at the questions this evening,
00:08:50 you look at the nature of the discussions. Look at the nature of discussions I had
00:08:54 with the president of France, the prime minister of the United Kingdom.
00:08:59 The leader of the opposition would not be capable of having those discussions,
00:09:02 because the leader of opposition refuses to get his security clearance,
00:09:07 something that it took me a few weeks to get.
00:09:10 So again, he's mentioning that it took him a few weeks to get. He had just become prime minister
00:09:16 at that point. So clearly, he got his security clearance before he was even prime minister,
00:09:21 which is a little odd. But anyway, I want to address this idea that Pierre Polly hasn't gotten
00:09:26 his security clearance. Well, I don't even have to, because Carson Germain of the National Post
00:09:30 wrote an article about it. This is what the headline says.
00:09:33 Mark Carney, the conspiracy theory prime minister, liberal leader spreads baseless allegation
00:09:40 against Pierre Polly. This was March 10th, 2025. So let me just read from it.
00:09:45 It is true that Polly has declined to receive a security briefing, which would require passing
00:09:49 a clearance. But it has nothing to do with Donald Trump, as Carney seems to suggest.
00:09:53 It is in relation to Chinese interference in Canadian elections, a reality that current
00:09:58 prime minister Justin Trudeau spent months dismissing as a non-problem, despite the fact
00:10:02 that there is evidence such interference was done to benefit the Liberal Party. He goes
00:10:07 on, when the scope of Chinese meddling in elections became widely reported in late 2022 and early
00:10:12 23, Polly have said he would decline security briefings that would detail top secret intelligence
00:10:18 reports. But the reasoning was hardly nefarious. It was because receiving such briefings would
00:10:24 have circumscribed what Polly have could say about Chinese interference, a point which everyone
00:10:30 agrees. As a leader of the opposition, Polly have believed reasonably, I would say that any briefing
00:10:35 offered would be used as a way for the government to get him to stop criticizing it over lacks its
00:10:42 lax attitude to election security. So basically, just to sum that all up, Pierre Polly doesn't want
00:10:49 to get the security briefings, because if he did, it would limit what he can say publicly, just like
00:10:54 that leaker to the Globe and Mail did so against their security briefings, right? Again, you swear
00:10:59 an oath, you get the security briefings, you get the security clearance, and you're not supposed to
00:11:03 leak it to the media. Whoever did that didn't put their name out there because they're breaking the
00:11:07 rules. But Pierre Polly is saying, if they brief me, then I won't be able to talk about it anymore.
00:11:13 And I don't want that. The role of the opposition is to hold the prime minister to account to
00:11:17 criticize them. And you want me to get these briefings to shut me up, basically. And it's not just me that's
00:11:23 saying that it's not just the National Post. Thomas Mulcair, the former leader of the opposition with
00:11:27 the NDP, the left wing party, he was on CTV last summer in June, saying that he agrees with
00:11:34 Pollyev and that Pollyev is doing the right thing. Let's play that clip. I agree completely with the
00:11:40 call by Pierre Poyet. I think that Poyet was wise not to tie his own hands. He is the leader of the
00:11:46 official opposition. I have once, you know, occupied that role for several years as leader of the
00:11:51 opposition. I would never want to be hamstrung because I looked at a government document.
00:11:57 I would never want to be told that I can't ask all the questions I want of the government.
00:12:02 And I think that on this, Pollyev is completely right.
00:12:06 Pollyev is completely right. So what do you make of it all, Josh?
00:12:10 Well, you know, surprise, surprise. Of course he's right. It's because if you look at the details of
00:12:15 what's happening, he isn't doing anything wrong. And also to add to the point there is he only gets to
00:12:20 see what the government chooses that he gets to see anyway. So what is the benefit of doing it?
00:12:24 And I love that Malclair was able to be bipartisan enough to realize that this is this really is a
00:12:29 nothing burger. But then just shows as we go into this election, right, this is going to be one of
00:12:34 the greasiest elections that we'll have ever seen because there's so much at stake there. It really
00:12:39 is that literally the heart of Canada is at stake. Are we going to be given up to China? Are we going to 0.95
00:12:44 be taken over by the United States? Or are we actually going to stand around two feet and fight for our
00:12:47 country? Those are the questions that are being asked this election. And Canadians know it right
00:12:52 now. So I think right now what liberals are trying to do is, again, just smoke screen, delay, dip,
00:12:59 dodge, and making sure that they are not held to account to what their record's been in the last
00:13:03 10 years, no matter what the face has been on it. So they're just, you know, they're on the attack.
00:13:07 This is the offensive. This is what politics has come to in this country. You can hate it. You can love
00:13:12 it. Reality is it's the reality. So you can work with it.
00:13:15 And this is why I call it the deep state though, because like, why is CSIS involved in the liberal
00:13:20 campaign? Why is the Globe and Mail going along with it? Right? Like, obviously this is Mark Carney's
00:13:25 favorite talking point. Go after Pierre Polyev, say for some reason he won't get his security
00:13:29 clearance. The National Post calls it a conspiracy theory because there's no base, there's no basis
00:13:33 in it. So that they get a CSIS official and the Globe and Mail to help them orchestrate this as a
00:13:38 campaign issue. Look, it's a short election. I think it's only 38 days and every single day
00:13:44 matters. And what, you know, precious real estate on the front cover of the Globe and Mail or what,
00:13:51 you know, people in the country are talking about, again, rather than talking about Mark Carney,
00:13:56 rather than talking about the housing crisis, out of control, immigration, cost of living crisis,
00:14:01 out of control, crime, out of control, drug use. Rather than talking about any of the important
00:14:05 issues in the country, they've managed to orchestrate, you know, this is like wagging the
00:14:10 dog, right? Get a CSIS official to link this to the Globe and Mail, get the Globe and Mail to put
00:14:15 it on the front cover. Everybody will be talking about it. I guarantee wherever Pierre Polyev goes
00:14:19 today, he will be asked about this and they'll turn it into a scandal, right? Rather than talking
00:14:24 about the issues that matter, we're talking about a made up scandal, basically, that the National
00:14:28 Post has called a conspiracy theory, all to play into the hands of Mark Carney. And so I've made
00:14:33 this criticism so many times in the past, but this is what happens during an election campaign.
00:14:38 The media is bought and paid for by the Liberal Party and the Liberal Party gives the orders and
00:14:45 the legacy media goes along with it. Whatever the Liberals decide are going to be the talking points
00:14:50 of the day. This is the message event of the day. This is what we're going to be talking about today.
00:14:54 We're going to spend day three of the campaign talking about how somehow Pierre Polyev is involved
00:14:59 in foreign interference scandals and not the Liberals. Don't pay attention to the Liberals.
00:15:03 Just pay attention to the Conservatives. And they all go along with it. It's so frustrating.
00:15:07 Yeah, that's exactly it. You called it out for what it is. And it is scummy, if I'm being honest,
00:15:14 to see that this has randomly came out at this point in time. And as you said, it has been more
00:15:19 of a nothing burger and hasn't really informed us of really anything that's of consequence.
00:15:23 So why bring it up? Why bring it up now? And if there isn't some insider work that's
00:15:28 happening at this current time. And this is why people are getting upset at the current
00:15:34 establishment and the current way things operate is because they see the dirty games that are being
00:15:38 played. And it will continue. And it's about it's going to be on Polyev at this point to see how he's
00:15:43 going to react to it. Are you going to fall for the trap? Or are you going to be like, yeah, nice.
00:15:49 Answer that with this. Boom. Get out of my face. Now I'm going to talk about real policies that are
00:15:52 going to help Canadians. I think that's going to be the big thing he's going to have to do today.
00:15:55 Because you said you call it out perfectly there, Candace. This will be the number one thing he
00:15:59 gets brought up with today. And it's going to be on him to be the seasoned political official that
00:16:05 he is to get around it, focus how to fight through it and get the real information that people care
00:16:10 about in this country to Canadians. Well, I hope he does. OK, let's talk about Mark Carney and what
00:16:15 he has been doing out on the campaign trail. This has kind of become a little mini scandal,
00:16:19 this idea that he is refusing to go on TVA, the French language debate face to face. And he
00:16:28 originally said that he was going to do it. And then suddenly he says that he is not doing
00:16:32 it. So at a campaign stop out in Gander, Newfoundland, Mark Carney said he would accept Pierre Poilievre's
00:16:38 challenge to go on TVA's debate. Let's play that clip.
00:16:41 Bonjour, Monsieur Carney, c'est Fanny Olivier de Radio-Canada. Le chef conservateur Pierre
00:16:47 Poilievre vous met au défi de participer au face-à-face de TVA. Est-ce que vous allez
00:16:53 le faire?
00:16:54 Pourquoi pas.
00:16:55 Pourquoi pas?
00:16:56 Oui, pourquoi pas, oui.
00:16:58 So he says we, like of course I will. But then, despite saying that he would, this is
00:17:03 reported in the Toronto Sun, Carney now says that he won't take part in the TVA debate.
00:17:11 And that the top liberals face scrutiny for his French skills, particularly during the
00:17:15 liberal leadership race. There are some people online saying that it's something about how
00:17:20 they were charging the campaign, that they were charging people $75,000 to do this campaign.
00:17:27 And that's, that's the real reason. Because somehow the liberals are now morally opposed
00:17:31 to giving media money, even though they fund all the newspapers and they fund the CBC.
00:17:36 But this is a line too far and they're not willing to pay to be part of this debate. What
00:17:40 do you think, Josh?
00:17:41 Well, don't worry about it, liberals. I know you're broke. It's okay. But, you know,
00:17:45 Paul, you have extended an olive branch about 20 minutes ago saying, don't worry, liberals.
00:17:50 I'll cover it for you. The Conservative Party will cover the fee. Just come to the table
00:17:54 and have a conversation. But no, the real conversation, the reality is Mark Carney doesn't want
00:17:58 a debate in French. And I do, I think you're gonna have to correct me on this because this
00:18:03 is where it's been a little confusing. I know he's agreed to the opposite of the English
00:18:07 language debate and he has agreed to a French language debate. TVR, I believe was the additional,
00:18:11 it was like almost a third debate, a second. And I think that's something we just need to
00:18:15 clear up there where this isn't him trying to avoid a French language debate. This is him avoiding
00:18:21 trying to get wrecked again in a second French language debate.
00:18:24 Paul Yev, because he knows he would. He, I was talking to a friend who has a grandfather who lives
00:18:30 in Quebec. And she was asking him, who's a staunch liberal his whole life, and asked him,
00:18:36 what were your thoughts on Mark Carney's French? And he said, good luck in Quebec. That's all he said.
00:18:43 And that's kind of what we're going to be seeing here is this is, again, a play to making sure that
00:18:48 they minimize the amount of stage time he has with Paul Yev, especially in French, because Paul Yev,
00:18:52 from Alberta. I'm not a Francophone, but I've heard enough people from Quebec speak French.
00:18:58 And his nuances, his cadence, how he does that, you know, starts talking like he's got a down
00:19:05 path. You'd think he's a Francophone. The way he talks is actually kind of impressive. And it
00:19:09 almost freaks me out in some ways. But that is what they're trying to avoid at this point. So we'll
00:19:14 see what is happening. But this is all straight up just theater. And now they're going to be caught
00:19:20 up in this now. Because like, is it the $75,000? Well, that's been taken care of now. What's it?
00:19:25 What's the real issue now? Right? Yeah. And thanks for clarifying that. So he will do
00:19:29 the CBC Radio Canada French debate. But this is an initial one. And from again, I don't live in Quebec,
00:19:35 I don't know. But in Quebec culture and French culture, TVR is like the big network that everyone
00:19:40 cares a lot about. So even though he will be doing another one, a lot of people say, like, you know,
00:19:45 TVR is very important. And you have to do that one as well. And it's interesting because the
00:19:49 Liberals depend so much on having a strong Quebec in order to form a majority or in order to win
00:19:55 elections. Like, you know, that is their base. That is like their Alberta. And yet, you know,
00:20:01 it doesn't seem like Mark Carney is in a good position to relate to those people. He doesn't
00:20:06 seem to have a lot of respect or, you know, even interest in trying to like improve his French.
00:20:13 So I think that'll be one to watch, because if he allows, you know, Quebec to slip away, 0.65
00:20:19 I think I think it really says goodbye to his chances of becoming prime minister. What do you
00:20:22 think? Oh, well, I agree. Well, I have to say I Mr. Blanchett had me in stitches the way he reacted
00:20:29 to that. He's like, well, quite frankly, at this point, I don't know what he's not scared of at this
00:20:33 point. He's scared of the French language. He's scared to talk to Trump. What's next? You know,
00:20:39 and I think that is in particular really funny. But there's a position I actually highlighted in
00:20:44 my show this morning was the fact that how much the liberals hate Polyev. And that's mainly what
00:20:50 I think what we saw in Carney there in that interview. It was the fact that you were being
00:20:55 challenged by Polyev to do a debate in French and immediately was, of course, why not? Of course,
00:21:02 I'd do it. And then later, two hours later, actually, we're not going to be doing that here.
00:21:06 It was clearly he didn't want to look weak in the face of Polyev. It shows how much the 0.96
00:21:11 liberals hate Polyev and they don't want to look less than than him. And that's exactly what that
00:21:17 response was, was Carney's arrogance on full display for Canadians. Well, we have that clip
00:21:22 that you're talking about. So this is a clip of Pierre Polyev offering to pay the liberals to have
00:21:28 Mark Carney there speaking in Vaughn, Ontario this morning. And to your point, like this is just
00:21:33 humiliating. Like they really left this door open for Polyev to step up and do what he does best.
00:21:38 And I do think that he humiliates Mark Carney in this club, let's play it in hiding because he
00:21:44 believes that he's too weak to defend the lost liberal decade or explain why he thinks liberals
00:21:50 deserve a fourth term. Let's have a debate in French where we put us put together the choice,
00:21:57 either a fourth liberal term after costs and crime have gone up and our ergonomy has gone down under
00:22:06 the American thumb or putting Canada first for a change with a new conservative government that will
00:22:12 build the homes. I'll even pay Mr. Carney's fee so that he can show up. We'll take that excuse away from
00:22:20 him. Conservatives will even pay the fee to bring him out. He's not afraid. And by the way, if he is afraid
00:22:25 to have the debate, how is he going to have the courage to stand up against Donald Trump?
00:22:30 Some say the bubbles in an arrow truffle piece can take 34 seconds to melt in your mouth.
00:22:35 Sometimes the very amount you're stuck at the same red light. Rich, creamy,
00:22:40 chocolatey arrow truffle. Feel the arrow bubbles melt. It's mind bubbling.
00:22:46 I think he's just really playing into Polyev's strength there and allowing Polyev to take the issue.
00:22:52 What do you think? A hundred percent. That's exactly what's happening. I love that Polyev specifically 0.89
00:22:58 said, but we'll take that excuse away from him, you know, and it reminds me of my football coach back in
00:23:03 in high school. Our big thing was excuses are for losers. And that's exactly what this is, 0.97
00:23:10 is an excuse. And so we'll see what ends up happening moving forward. But you were right. Like,
00:23:15 you know, the struggle has been Quebec and it's Ontario for the conservatives traditionally.
00:23:19 And now it's just like, you're kind of like, there was a 40% support in Quebec right now for
00:23:23 the liberal party and you're starting to push them more to the blue side. That isn't the block blue.
00:23:27 It's the conservative blue. The more you're doing this type of stuff.
00:23:31 And, and on top of how bad his French really is, it's not going to serve him in Quebec. And we'll see,
00:23:37 we'll see what gets translated and what's good with the talk that happens in Quebec. Uh, you know,
00:23:43 we can think about the, one of the block representatives who since deleted his tweet,
00:23:47 but literally said that liberal party is a bigger threat to Canada than Donald Trump is. And
00:23:52 that sets some alarm bells off, especially for Mr. Gebo, who was not too heavy about it.
00:23:55 So I would tend to agree. I mean, who, who's destroyed our economy? It wasn't Donald Trump.
00:24:00 It was the liberals over the last 10 years and their radical policies, which seems that Mark
00:24:05 Carney is right on board continuing with the net zero and the carbon nonsense. I want to stay on policy
00:24:10 for a minute. Cause one thing that's happened is kind of interesting is that Mark Carney has
00:24:14 tacked right. He has abandoned a lot of the pet causes of the left wing. He is saying that he is
00:24:20 not going to have the carbon tax gotten rid of the carbon taxes. The first thing he did as prime
00:24:24 minister, I believe is sign a fake executive order. They're saying that, uh, he was going to get rid of
00:24:29 the carbon tax. Uh, and then he's also jumped on and copied peer poly of a policy when it comes to
00:24:34 giving an exemption, uh, to first time home buyers. And so I think because the liberals are
00:24:39 trying to steal the conservatives economic policies, it gives the conservatives more
00:24:45 opportunity to, you know, go even harder and, and hammer at home. So we saw Pierre Polyev announced
00:24:50 a 15%, uh, tax cut, uh, income tax cut, which could save families up to 2000 or $1,800 a year.
00:24:59 So speaking at a campaign stop in Brampton, Polyev pledged to drop the lowest personal income
00:25:04 bracket by 15%, bringing it from 15% to 12. Here is a clip of him saying that today. I'm announcing
00:25:13 that Canada first conservatives will cut income taxes by 15% for the average worker or $2,000 for
00:25:23 the average couple. This is a tax cut for seniors who are drawing their pension or retirement income.
00:25:30 They will pay on average 15% less. This is a tax cut for the workers behind me who will pay 15% less
00:25:38 on their income tax. This is a tax cut for the waitress, for the welder, for the barber. This is
00:25:45 a tax cut for everybody who has ever got up early in the morning and work hard to build our country.
00:25:51 This is a tax cut that will put Canada first.
00:25:54 So, uh, what do you think of this policy, Josh?
00:25:58 I think it's a, it's a good start. I think right now that's tax cuts are big right now. And so that
00:26:04 first income bracket going from 15% down to 12.75%, I think it was two and a quarter is what they're
00:26:11 essentially deducting. I think is a big cut. I think it's, that's a lot of money. You said yourself,
00:26:16 $1,800. Um, that's a good chunk of cash. I think we're looking at $125, $150 a month in savings for a family.
00:26:25 We'll take that then add on top of that, all the tax that are looking to take off the board. In
00:26:30 addition, the savings are going to keep increasing. So I think it's a good start. I would like to see
00:26:36 it continue to be pushed as they move forward, but I think it's a good place to start.
00:26:40 Yeah. I'm, I'm, I'm with you. I like any tax cut is good. I'm on board for it. I would like to see
00:26:43 Paulie have, it would be great if he just said like, let's bring in a flat tax or let's eliminate
00:26:48 income tax altogether. I mean, now is the time I think to throw things out there. This is something that
00:26:53 Trump did incredibly well was just saying, you know, we're going to get a mandate. We want a big
00:26:57 mandate. And these are all the things that we want to change and actually draw a very stark distinction
00:27:02 between yourself and the other side. And actually kind of reminds me again, I just remember this,
00:27:07 but during the campaign, remember Donald Trump came out and said that they were going to eliminate
00:27:11 taxes on tips. And then like a few days later, Democrat Kamala Harris said the same thing. It was like,
00:27:17 I don't know if she just heard him say, I was like, that's a good idea.
00:27:19 Or if they like planned intentionally to try to do that, to like neutralize the issue. But I think
00:27:24 that Pierre Paulie have obviously relates to working class people a lot better. He goes on these
00:27:29 tours. He goes, they call them meet and greets, but he goes and he meets thousands and thousands
00:27:33 of Canadians every day, shakes their hand and hears their concerns and talks to them. And so I think he
00:27:38 has a lot better idea of what would help and what issues are really facing Canadians versus Mark Carney,
00:27:45 who's, you know, in the C suite and obviously feels deeply uncomfortable when he's placed around
00:27:49 working class people, as we saw in Edmonton last week, where he came up with the, you know,
00:27:54 the fellows there and the hard hats. And you could tell that they just didn't want anything to do with
00:27:57 him. He didn't know how to even like approach them. And it was just like a super tense, awkward
00:28:03 encounter. Okay. I want to switch it over to Jagmeet Singh, because we've talked about this before.
00:28:08 Oh, sorry. Did you, you can, you can jump in there.
00:28:10 Yeah. One last point there too. I find this, you know, as much as the liberals and the media will
00:28:15 try to frame in a specific way, I'm starting to see this election as a big win for conservatives,
00:28:19 because we're starting to see the mere opposite of what we saw back in 2021 was Aaron O'Toole tried
00:28:23 to be left wing to try and went over the left wing moderates. And now what we're seeing is Carney's
00:28:28 trying to be what Aaron O'Toole was last election. And so, as you just said a real perfectly earlier,
00:28:33 where conservatives are now dragging Carney and liberals over to the right side. You know what the thing
00:28:38 hasn't been mentioned once this election campaign so far, Candace? Identity politics nowhere to be
00:28:44 found. And I think that's a big win for regular people because we're able to talk about things
00:28:49 that people actually care about and not about some of these niche topics that the liberals tried to
00:28:53 champion as a big part of their platform. And that was, sorry, that's just one last thing I wanted to say.
00:28:56 Well, it's interesting you say that as, as if it's a win, I agree. It's, it's nice to not have those
00:29:01 issues shoved down our throats anymore. Clearly they've gotten the memo that Canadians don't care and they 0.99
00:29:06 don't want that, right? Everyone live their own life. I don't care what you do. You shouldn't care
00:29:10 what I do as long as it's happening like in your personal life or whatever. But I, I still think
00:29:15 that it's important that we get an idea of where our political leaders stand on these issues, right?
00:29:21 So any, anytime there's a divisive social issue that the media think that they can trap a conservative
00:29:27 and get them to say something, they'll like, they'll go for the jugular, right? And they'll be ruthless.
00:29:32 And we saw this in the 2019 campaign with Andrew Scheer, where they made a big deal about the fact
00:29:36 that Andrew Scheer is a practicing Catholic and therefore he believes that gay marriage. I mean,
00:29:42 this is not a thing for Catholics, right? And that being gay is a sin. And they made that the biggest 1.00
00:29:47 issue of the campaign, right? They, all they wanted to do with former prime minister, Stephen Harper
00:29:51 was exposed, like who is pro-life on his team and make it seem like they were radical Christian
00:29:57 nationalists or whatever, right? And same thing with Pierre Polyev. Uh, I think it was last year,
00:30:02 Daniel Smith from Alberta came out and banned, uh, sex changes basically for kids, um, cross-sex
00:30:09 hormones and sex change operations for kids, right? And the media thought this was a great opportunity
00:30:16 to try to get Pierre Polyev on record. And so they pushed him, they scrummed him, they made him take a
00:30:21 position on that as they should, right? That's the role of the media. They, they, they, they sensed
00:30:25 that there was maybe an opportunity to get him to say something that he hadn't planned on saying,
00:30:30 and they pushed him on it. And he came out and he made the correct decision. He said, you know,
00:30:34 children shouldn't have these kinds of drugs. It's not for children, right? You can't consent to that
00:30:38 kind of thing. And yet they won't ask Mark Carney. They won't ask him his, where he stands on these
00:30:45 divisive social issues. They won't ask him whether he believes there's two genders or a thousand
00:30:49 genders. They won't ask him whether he believes that these sex change operations and, and cross-sex 0.53
00:30:54 hormones should be available to children. He hasn't said whether he believes that boys should be able
00:30:58 to play on the girls' force. My, my only point is that the media are all of a sudden totally
00:31:02 uninterested and there's no curiosity to find out where the prime minister stands on these issues.
00:31:07 They're happy to push conservatives on them, but they don't care in, in, in not even that they don't
00:31:11 care. They actively campaign against anyone who does care. Yeah. It's almost, you know, to a degree
00:31:17 where it hasn't been brought up this campaign at all. Cause they'd almost don't want it to come
00:31:20 back on them. And there is something to be said to Candace where, you know, you I'm a big fan of,
00:31:26 you know, using the measure that you use upon others. And I think that is something that I would,
00:31:31 I would welcome against the liberal party. Like, okay, you know, media, you've made this a big
00:31:34 issue up to this point. All of a sudden Mark Carney's in, and we know that he has some more conservative
00:31:40 values. We won't say nothing about it, but we know he does. And, but you're not going to question
00:31:44 him directly on these things. Like he would have here, Paul, you have to say, you know,
00:31:47 two years ago or Aaron O'Toole four years ago or Andrew Scheer six years ago. So, um,
00:31:54 I do agree. There is a point to that, but I also kind of, you know, I stay, I think I stay in my
00:31:58 ground to a lit to a degree where I am happy that identity politics is nowhere part of this election
00:32:04 right now. And cause it is already overall, it is a distraction in a lot of ways, um, to like,
00:32:09 you know, the issue of being able to afford your home health care and be able to, um,
00:32:14 get power back on our dollar. So, yeah, fair enough. Okay. Let's talk about Jagmeet Singh quickly,
00:32:19 because one of the interesting things in Canadian politics is that in order for the conservatives to
00:32:24 win, they actually need a strong NDP, right? You need to have that vote split that happens. And for
00:32:30 folks that don't know what I'm talking about, basically the conservatives poll at 35 to 40%,
00:32:34 that's not enough to form a majority. But what happens is because the Canadian left is kind of
00:32:39 split, there's more like the hard left wingers, the environmentalists and the union folks,
00:32:44 traditionally. And then there's more of the centrists and the bankers and the business class,
00:32:48 which is the liberals. And in order for the conservatives to get through, there needs to
00:32:53 be some kind of a split in mostly in kind of competitive ridings, say in and around Toronto,
00:32:58 in and around Vancouver. And then in Quebec, there's a different vote split that happens with the
00:33:02 block. But when the NDP collapses, as we saw earlier this month, the NDP hit like rock bottom,
00:33:11 like single digits, that does create a clear path for a liberal victory. And so I think that,
00:33:18 interestingly, conservatives and the NDP can have some kind of a shared goal in that, you know,
00:33:24 they actually want the conservatives would actually want the NDP to be a bit stronger. And it's also
00:33:29 interesting, because if you have a left wing constituency in Canada, say, like 40% of the
00:33:34 country's left wing, you kind of imagine, okay, you have this guy who's a central banker, who's
00:33:41 probably a multimillionaire, we don't even know, because he won't disclose his assets, but he's
00:33:45 probably a multimillionaire. And he's made all of his money through Wall Street, Goldman Sachs,
00:33:51 globalist sort of positions in the WEF and United Nations. I mean, he's a banker, right? That's not
00:34:00 typically the face of the left, right? Like there's a person who encompasses the values of left wingers
00:34:08 who usually fight for the workers, for the little guy, you know, people in the unions. Interestingly,
00:34:12 I think one of the unions just endorsed conservatives for the first time. But I think that Jagmeet Singh is
00:34:19 making a very good point here, where he's talking about how Mark Carney contributed to the housing
00:34:25 crisis through his business, through what Brookfield Athletic Management does. And that the more that
00:34:32 Jagmeet Singh can hit these points, I think it is beneficial, just in pointing out to left wing
00:34:38 Canadians, hey, this guy isn't your champion, right? He's totally an elitist and out of touch. So I want to,
00:34:43 we'll play this clip of Jagmeet Singh, and then I'll have you react to all that, Josh. So here's,
00:34:47 here's Jagmeet Singh speaking at a campaign stop in Montreal on Monday.
00:34:52 The fact that he headed up Brookfield, and Brookfield is a large corporate landlord in Canada
00:34:57 that engaged in rent eviction. At a time when Canadians could not find affordable homes,
00:35:03 he saw a way to make more profit for his company. And now I don't fault him for making profit for his
00:35:08 company. I fault him for proposing that somehow the person that fed the housing crisis, that rent evicted
00:35:15 people, that jacked up the price of homes that were affordable, that bought up affordable homes,
00:35:21 then turned them into unaffordable places, that somehow that guy could be trusted to fix the housing crisis.
00:35:27 What do you think? One thing about Jagmeet is he's always engaged in hyperbole when it came to
00:35:36 attacking Polyev. But this, everything he said was spot on. There was no hyperbole needed. It was
00:35:42 actually refreshing to see Jagmeet Singh do what the NDP are supposed to do. And that's advocate for the
00:35:50 working class and be like, yeah, this guy you want, or they're telling you that you want. He is not, 0.95
00:35:56 he doesn't, he plays for the bad guys, you know, the eat the rich, all those, you know,
00:36:00 he's one of those. I just want to let you know. You know, and I think that was a big statement
00:36:05 coming from the NDP, because it's one thing to hear Polyev, Lansman, or someone step up in the
00:36:09 House of Commons saying, you know, Carney this. But when he got Jagmeet Singh in the NDP saying,
00:36:15 no, trust me, this guy stinks. And you do not want to vote for him, I think is, it's a huge
00:36:21 proponent. I think I can't remember who the MP was, but it was another NDP MP who stood up at a
00:36:25 press conference a couple weeks ago saying the exact same thing about Mark Carney. And I thought
00:36:31 that was a huge win. So we literally, we clipped that on our show, we posted on social channels,
00:36:36 like, we're like, yo, great job, NDP Canada, way to stick it and making sure you are holding them
00:36:41 accountable. This is good behavior. And we want to reinforce good behavior coming from the left
00:36:46 wing. When the because when we agree on things, I think it's important to advocate and acknowledge
00:36:50 that we agree on this. And we want to see this out of our politics. So I think it was a big move.
00:36:54 Right? Yes. Send that clip to your left wing friends and family members who are considering voting for
00:36:59 liberal, because you're exactly right. Like, Mark Carney is just not a good figure to lead the political
00:37:05 left. And it may be an unintended consequence of Mark Carney seeing Pierre Polyev as his biggest threat
00:37:11 and taking a few steps back to the center, I would argue, or maybe towards the political right,
00:37:15 is that he leaves a lot of space open on the left. I wish that the NDP had switched its leader. I wish
00:37:21 that they had kicked Jagmeet Singh out after the last election and had someone else someone new in there
00:37:27 because it's hard for me to take serious anything Jagmeet Singh says after propping up the liberals for
00:37:33 four long years and allowing so many scandals. And it is interesting because say Jagmeet Singh had forced an
00:37:40 election two years ago when Justin Trudeau was starting to plummet in the polls after, frankly,
00:37:46 after the trucker convoy and the use of the emergencies act, the illegal use of the emergency
00:37:49 act. At that point, Pierre Polyev would have won the landslide. And it's possible that Jagmeet Singh
00:37:55 would have been rewarded by becoming leader of the opposition and having a real stake in our political
00:38:01 system and having that opportunity. But because he chose the cowardly route, which was to just prop up
00:38:06 Justin Trudeau, he is being punished. And I think that a lot of Canadians want to punish him,
00:38:10 not interested in going back to the NDP. But I will say that I agree that this message that Mark
00:38:16 Carney, I mean, for goodness sakes, if that's what Brookfield Asset Management was doing in Canada,
00:38:21 buying up homes, evicting tenants, renovating them to make them so expensive that Canadians, 0.84
00:38:26 many Canadian families can't afford to live in them. Like that's not exactly a record to be proud of.
00:38:32 Yeah, especially, and that was one of the points the NDP MP made was like,
00:38:35 they're one of the biggest tax dodgers in Canada. But so people who want, who are like,
00:38:39 please give me more tax. Well, there, there it is. There's the big guy who's not, who's avoiding
00:38:45 paying tax. That's a big conversation to be having. And I'm seeing this live in my life right
00:38:50 now, Candace, where my nan, hardcore NDP her whole life, Chrysler worked at the factories union big 1.00
00:38:58 on that. I asked her, you know, two years ago, my, Hey, what are your thoughts on Jagmeet Singh?
00:39:03 You're like, Oh, I can't stand them. He's, he doesn't stand up for anybody. And I'm like,
00:39:07 who are you voting for? Oh, Pierre Poliev. And I was like, Oh, interesting. Okay. That's,
00:39:10 that's a big move for you. And then, you know, Mark Carney gets installed into the liberal
00:39:15 leadership race or the party. And I asked her, Oh, what are your thoughts now? Mark Carney's
00:39:19 more centrist. What are your thoughts on there? He's like, no way. He moved his headquarters from
00:39:23 Canada, New York. I have no interest in that. He doesn't care about workers. He doesn't care
00:39:26 about unions. The only pro union person on this ticket right now is Poliev. I can't believe I'm
00:39:32 saying that, but I'm voting conservative, but you can't change my mind on that. I was like,
00:39:35 gee, this woman's bled orange her whole life. And now within the past handful of years has gone 1.00
00:39:41 conservative, which is incredible. Wow. What an incredible shift. Well,
00:39:45 I hope many more Canadians have that, have that moment and, and come around. Um, and interesting
00:39:50 to see, we even have unions endorsing the conservatives for exactly the reason that you
00:39:54 said, uh, Josh Udall with the elevate podcast. It's been such a pleasure to have you on. We'll have to
00:39:58 have you back. Thank you so much, Candice. Really appreciate it. All right. Thank you so much,
00:40:01 Josh. That's all the time we have for today. I'm Candice Malcolm. This is a Candice Malcolm
00:40:05 show. We'll be back again tomorrow with all the news. Thank you. And God bless.