Fake News Friday | CBC fails to debunk “bugs conspiracy theory”
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
183.0064
Summary
The idea of eating bugs as a way to replace meat is not a conspiracy theory. The people that actually create these farms admit it themselves. And the developers of this factory even admitted it themselves! And then they said this is going to be the biggest cricket factory in the world.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
Hello, everyone, and welcome to another edition of Fake News Friday.
00:00:15.760
My name is Andrew Lawton, joined, as always, by Harrison Faulkner for another week of debunking
00:00:23.160
the much-needed debunkables that we get from a lot of mainstream media.
00:00:29.020
It's been good. I feel good that I've now resumed my normal position on the show, Andrew,
00:00:33.240
or at least some things that are normal, because we're still in that sort of influx of co-hosts,
00:00:38.080
hosts, and all that, but it's good to be back and good to join you once again.
00:00:40.920
Yeah, we try to throw us all off kilter, so we never just get too comfortable or complacent where we are.
00:00:46.180
It's a great strategy, really. Let's talk a little bit about this one here.
00:00:49.920
So we've seen that conspiracy theorization, and I guess that's the name for when you just start
00:00:56.820
calling things conspiracy theories. It's become a favored pastime of the media.
00:01:01.500
In particular now, CBC claiming that insect protein, that eating bugs, is a conspiracy theory.
00:01:11.280
how a London, Ontario cricket plant found itself at the heart of an international conspiracy theory.
00:01:16.960
And they talk about how this so-called conspiracy theory has been circulating for a month.
00:01:21.840
It's been in English, it's been in Chinese, it's been around the world in the UK and the US and all of that.
00:01:27.300
And it involves a factory in my neck of the woods in London, Ontario.
00:01:31.580
Now, I am not in on the conspiracy. I want to make that very clear.
00:01:34.600
But the point of it is that they're saying that people focusing on this facility,
00:01:40.700
this plant that's making crickets for human consumption,
00:01:43.840
which was a tweet that was put out by the developers of this factory, is a conspiracy theory.
00:01:53.140
People saying, yes, we are going to be eating bugs in the future,
00:01:56.340
and a plant saying, yes, we're making bugs for people to eat.
00:01:59.100
Well, exactly. When exactly does a conspiracy theory become a fact
00:02:04.600
when the people who are actually involved in the production of this farm
00:02:08.260
are admitting to talking about, for example, creating crickets for human consumption?
00:02:13.020
And then Ellis Don, the developers of this factory, Andrew, as you said,
00:02:18.300
They said this is going to be the biggest cricket factory in the world.
00:02:21.340
This is going to be a, they're going to revolutionize the human diet, things like this.
00:02:27.100
And I find it bizarre, this weird sort of CBC cleanup act almost,
00:02:32.260
trying to cover for this cricket farm when this cricket farm isn't really doing the job themselves.
00:02:39.200
They say they're trying to, they say in the article that the cricket farm is now
00:02:43.260
not talking about human consumption because it's fueling conspiracy theories.
00:02:47.240
They're only talking about creating crickets for animal consumption.
00:02:50.420
But we all know, Andrew, that it's not really a conspiracy theory, is it?
00:02:54.320
That the idea of eating crickets, the idea of eating bugs as a way to replace meat
00:03:03.480
The people that actually create these farms admit it themselves.
00:03:07.320
So it's very bizarre to me that when you've got Aspire, the actual company,
00:03:15.320
on Twitter, they talk about, they wrote a tweet that says things like this.
00:03:20.140
Throughout history, insects have been a part of our diets,
00:03:24.640
We spoke with The Economist earlier this week and discussed our new facility.
00:03:28.140
So not really saying, Andrew, that these crickets are not for human consumption.
00:03:35.760
Aspire pioneers precision insect farming at scale,
00:03:38.880
realizing the potential of nature through the power of tech
00:03:42.040
to enable innovative industries to create products and materialize
00:03:45.080
that prioritize the health and sustainability of our world.
00:03:48.120
If it's just for animals and not humans, Andrew, why don't they say it?
00:03:54.000
Yeah, I mean, the reality is when you talk to environmentalists,
00:04:00.040
is that meat consumption is terrible for the environment.
00:04:09.540
Bovine flatulence is the big issue that they all like to warn about in the United States.
00:04:13.780
So they basically say that, yes, all of us should be vegetarians
00:04:18.600
So it's not all that surprising when you see companies
00:04:21.520
that are coming up with alternatives to meat like crickets
00:04:24.420
because there is a growing appetite, no pun intended,
00:04:27.540
of people that are going vegetarian or going vegan even.
00:04:30.900
And I don't know how the vegans are on the crickets,
00:04:32.660
but I think some of the vegetarians are good with it.
00:04:34.500
But it's when you have people talk about this in like a central planning way,
00:04:38.920
like we need to start moving other people off of meat
00:04:42.280
as opposed to just letting people decide for themselves.
00:04:45.000
And this is where you talk about the World Economic Forum,
00:04:47.760
which promotes at great length the idea of cricket eating as the future
00:04:55.380
But it's not a conspiracy theory when it's happening.
00:05:02.060
no, no, no, this thing that you're looking at and using their own words for
00:05:12.180
And they've decided to go after this Aspire cricket facility,
00:05:16.020
this cricket factory, perhaps because it's the biggest in the world
00:05:21.080
But at the beginning of August, the Toronto Star wrote an article about this company
00:05:30.060
And then in the article, so from one month to the next,
00:05:34.080
how conspiracy theories can go from being complete fact, absolute fact,
00:05:38.180
one month and the next month, they're a conspiracy theory or the other way around.
00:05:41.560
A conspiracy theory starts one month later, it becomes fact.
00:05:44.800
A month ago, these people at the Aspire cricket factory were talking about
00:05:51.960
given the dire state of the world's food supply,
00:05:54.000
it's increasingly tempting to create a new alternative protein.
00:05:56.980
That's what the Star was talking about just a month ago.
00:06:00.480
I mean, people must be reading this and thinking,
00:06:03.320
hold on a minute, did I just not read an article a month ago
00:06:05.660
saying that this is exactly for human consumption?
00:06:08.400
This is the kind of stuff that I think drives people nuts.
00:06:11.780
Yeah, so basically when they say it's a conspiracy theory
00:06:15.220
that folks are talking about this cricket factory in London,
00:06:21.860
which is what are people saying and how does it differ from reality?
00:06:28.900
if you were saying this was a conspiracy theory,
00:06:30.960
is if you were arguing that this specific factory
00:06:37.020
and I mean, it did get some government funding,
00:06:40.660
I mean, they do talk about why we're eating bugs and all that.
00:06:43.580
I don't think there's anything nefarious about the factory itself.
00:06:46.420
I think there's a market and they're going along with it
00:06:48.380
because clearly if you can make some money off of people
00:06:50.840
that are going to be eating bugs, then fine, do it.
00:06:55.940
even in the CBC article, where they can point to
00:07:00.240
and what people believe that isn't actually correct.
00:07:03.740
And even there's this one professor, they quote,
00:07:08.060
oh, it's all part of the anti-government sentiment,
00:07:10.280
and they're tapping into the same things we saw with the Freedom Convoy.
00:07:13.300
And then she says, this is a cricket factory to make pet food
00:07:21.220
So where's the fake news really coming from here?
00:07:23.240
The so-called experts or the so-called conspiracy theorists?
00:07:28.500
this professor says the evidence is pointing to animal food,
00:07:34.280
have been talking about human food the entire time.
00:07:47.460
that come across the headlines will read the headline,
00:07:52.200
and then those that get to the first paragraph,
00:08:04.520
then they'll start questioning everything they see.
00:08:08.480
The legacy media are trying to define conspiracy theories,
00:08:25.600
why don't you talk about what's happening in Alberta?
00:08:33.660
and it was Jason Kenney standing with Mark Mielke,
00:08:36.380
who's a part of the Winston Churchill Foundation,
00:08:58.180
and Winston Churchill is certainly one of those.
00:09:14.460
And the usual procession of people trying to rewrite history,
00:09:19.280
talking about how Winston Churchill is not deserving of monuments,
00:09:27.420
this is Jason Kenney's way of declaring what we must celebrate,
00:09:36.600
So we're building a monument to Winston Churchill,
00:09:55.980
and this part really got under my skin, Andrew.
00:09:59.840
why would we need a new monument of Winston Churchill,
00:10:01.820
when there are schools named after Winston Churchill,
00:10:08.040
that's enough for a man like Winston Churchill.