The Candice Malcolm Show - February 09, 2024


Make Canada Great Again?

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Poilievre (finally) gets it right on the trans issue Here’s how the legacy media is misleading you

Episode Stats


Length

46 minutes

Words per minute

206.84

Word count

9,654

Sentence count

629

Harmful content

Misogyny

9

sentences flagged

Toxicity

20

sentences flagged

Hate speech

25

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this week's Off The Record, we discuss Ben Shapiro's new music video, the Canadian government's new policy protecting kids from sex-change operations, and the ridiculousness of the media's coverage of the trans issue.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 So wait, so YouTube demonetized us for the Ben Shapiro thing?
00:00:04 Yes, exactly.
00:00:05 They, they, we, we put in a dispute, we followed the rules and it was, uh, I don't think it
00:00:10 was YouTube, but I think it was Ben Shapiro and Tom McDonald themselves who rejected us.
00:00:15 But do you know what?
00:00:16 It's funny because the internet right now, YouTube is filled with like Ben Shapiro reaction
00:00:20 videos.
00:00:21 And then Ben Shapiro even did a video reacting to his reaction videos.
00:00:24 So you would think that he would want people to promote his song and his music.
00:00:28 Like, but then when we did it, we get demonetized.
00:00:30 So unless it was just over the dancing, the dance moves might've just been, YouTube was
00:00:34 just offended by that.
00:00:36 It's totally possible.
00:00:37 It's like the, my pillow guy all over again when I had him on my show and we like, couldn't
00:00:41 post on YouTube for a week.
00:00:42 Well, it's not that bad at least.
00:00:44 Yeah.
00:00:44 But that was, didn't that happen like eight months later?
00:00:46 It was like Andrew interviews this guy and it was totally normal and totally fine.
00:00:49 And then like six months later, he does something controversial and they like go back and demonetize
00:00:53 our whole channel.
00:00:54 Yeah.
00:00:55 All right, guys, let's get this started.
00:00:58 So, all right.
00:01:05 So, Hey guys, thanks for being here.
00:01:08 Thanks everyone for tuning in.
00:01:09 This is off the record.
00:01:10 Our second episode.
00:01:11 The first one was last week.
00:01:12 I think it went pretty well.
00:01:13 So we're going to keep this format going and talk about the week's news from a little bit
00:01:18 more of a casual, relaxed perspective.
00:01:20 And I know we talked about this a lot last week, but I just wanted to talk about it, mention
00:01:26 it quickly here.
00:01:26 More fallout from Daniel Smith's policy, protecting kids from trans surgeries, basically from, from
00:01:34 being pushed into getting sex change operations while they're still children.
00:01:39 And it's just really been remarkable to see this whole thing unfold.
00:01:43 I was pleased that Pierre Polyev came out in the middle of the week and finally let us know what the
00:01:49 conservative position was on it because they've been relatively quiet up to this point.
00:01:53 I think he did take the right position and fall in the right place.
00:01:56 But I just like, I still can't believe the way that the media has handled this issue and
00:02:01 the way that some left-wing politicians, Justin Trudeau, Jagmeet Singh, have just been completely
00:02:06 hysterical.
00:02:07 I just don't understand why they think that talking about trans issues for children is
00:02:13 anything that's going to be popular.
00:02:15 Like as soon as, one of the things that Pierre Polyev did was that he, he got journalists to
00:02:20 explain exactly what policy they were talking about, because they would do this thing like,
00:02:23 why are you in favor of restricting healthcare to kids?
00:02:27 Which is propaganda.
00:02:28 That's a euphemism.
00:02:29 Like we're not talking about access to healthcare.
00:02:31 We're talking about elective surgeries for sex changes for little kids.
00:02:35 And, and, and once you make the journalists say that, then, then you, they've already lost
00:02:39 the argument.
00:02:40 Harrison, what's your position?
00:02:42 Well, yeah, the journalists were exposed a few days ago when one of the journalists asked
00:02:46 Pierre Polyev if he felt that only adults should take puberty blockers after they discussed
00:02:52 this, after they had this discussion.
00:02:53 And, and, you know, adults don't take puberty blockers because that's the whole point.
00:02:57 It exposes the fact that the, the, the, the base position of the media here is whatever
00:03:04 the conservatives are saying has to be wrong.
00:03:07 And whatever the left is saying has to be right.
00:03:10 And they can't even use their own judgment to realize what they're talking about is, is 0.99
00:03:13 completely ridiculous. 0.96
00:03:14 So I think Polyev is right. 0.89
00:03:15 It took him a bit too long to finally admit to it, but at least he did come out and admit
00:03:20 to it.
00:03:21 Well, one of the things that was really interesting that I learned this week was that taking testosterone
00:03:26 is actually illegal and, and human growth hormones are illegal in Canada.
00:03:31 So in some cases, it's not even possible to take it when you're an adult.
00:03:35 It's only, they only give it to children.
00:03:37 They don't, they don't even allow adults to take it.
00:03:39 I think if anything, it's just exposed this entire issue is like more Canadians are now 0.88
00:03:45 aware of the crazy stuff that's happening in our country to kids.
00:03:50 Like, like there was one clip that I found really amusing where a journalist was kind of
00:03:54 complaining to Danielle Smith about the onerousness of one of the policies, which was that every
00:03:59 time you talk about sex ed to children in your classroom, you have to write a report.
00:04:03 And the reporter was like, Hey, like, like, are they supposed to write a report like every
00:04:08 day?
00:04:09 Like that's, that's like so much work.
00:04:11 And Danielle was like, well, I'm sorry, but if they're talking about sex every single day 1.00
00:04:17 to students, I think we've discovered a good use case for this policy because they shouldn't
00:04:22 be doing that.
00:04:22 Obviously.
00:04:23 Yeah, there, there's a lot of gaslighting on this though.
00:04:26 Cause I remember like when, when Danielle Smith first came out and was talking about the, um,
00:04:30 in, in Alberta, the, uh, sex reassignment surgery component, you had people say that
00:04:35 doesn't happen.
00:04:36 She's, she's banning something that doesn't exist.
00:04:37 No one does that.
00:04:38 And literally news reports, uh, that came out yesterday, uh, national post, there were eight
00:04:44 transgender surgeries for minors in 2022, 2023.
00:04:49 So you may say, okay, eight, it's a small number, but still eight is, is, is above
00:04:53 zero.
00:04:53 So when you have people saying this doesn't happen, it's not there.
00:04:57 And then, oh, well, what do you know?
00:04:58 It's happening.
00:04:59 It undermines the entire argument.
00:05:01 Yeah.
00:05:02 This kind of reminds me of the whole like libs of TikTok thing.
00:05:04 Like people who there's a, there's a very popular account on Twitter who people who don't
00:05:08 know that the, the, the account, the person who runs the account literally just takes clips
00:05:12 of people on TikTok.
00:05:14 So people who have, you know, on their own decided to post videos, public videos on their,
00:05:20 on their, on their TikTok accounts.
00:05:21 And she just stitches them together and shows them to a different audience on, uh, on Twitter.
00:05:26 And, you know, the left is like, oh, this is a hate crime.
00:05:29 This is hate speech.
00:05:29 She's targeting trans people and she's putting them at risk. 1.00
00:05:32 It's like, it's like, no, no.
00:05:33 They're just speaking in their own words.
00:05:35 She's just giving them a platform, right?
00:05:36 She's just letting you know what they say, what they do.
00:05:39 And it's usually teachers, uh, they're talking about how they're confusing their children
00:05:43 and how they talk about sex in classrooms and how they're making kids, uh, you know,
00:05:47 reconsider whether they're boys or girls.
00:05:48 So just really the worst of the worst.
00:05:50 And, and it's happening.
00:05:51 We know what's happening because we see it in this, in this, through this TikTok account.
00:05:55 And then the same kind of gaslighting that you're talking about, Andrew, that, that they'll
00:05:58 be like, this doesn't happen.
00:06:00 No, no one's, no one's doing this to kids.
00:06:02 It's like, yeah, we see through you.
00:06:07 Yeah.
00:06:08 Sorry.
00:06:09 I was like waiting for a question mark.
00:06:11 And then I thought Harrison was going to say something.
00:06:13 I thought Harrison was like awkward live to date moments that we'll, uh, all just have
00:06:17 to hope the audience finds endearing instead of horribly unprofessional.
00:06:20 No, I thought Harrison was about to jump in with somebody.
00:06:22 Okay, good.
00:06:22 It was two on one.
00:06:23 Where were you, man?
00:06:25 Yeah, exactly.
00:06:25 Left you guys hanging there.
00:06:27 No, I mean, it's just say words. 1.00
00:06:29 It's, it's pathetic. 0.99
00:06:30 It's crazy. 1.00
00:06:30 The media were exposed for just basically taking whatever the left is, is saying and believing
00:06:36 that that is the only acceptable position to have.
00:06:38 I think Paul Yev is right when he says Justin Trudeau will eventually have to back down
00:06:42 from this because common sense and just what the majority of Canadians think isn't going
00:06:47 to stand up to this.
00:06:48 The majority of Canadians don't want children to take puberty blockers and do, you know,
00:06:53 basically cut their own body parts off.
00:06:55 It's not going to last.
00:06:56 So eventually the prime minister will likely have to, uh, step down from this position and
00:07:02 be asked the kind of questions that Pierre is being asked.
00:07:04 So double standards everywhere, but it's just the usual media playbook.
00:07:08 Yeah.
00:07:09 Although I will say that the media did their job this time because we didn't know where
00:07:11 Pierre stood.
00:07:12 And, and I do think that it took them pushing him and, and you can see there was one press
00:07:16 conference that he did.
00:07:17 And Justin Ling, who's like a left-wing reporter was asking him these annoying questions and
00:07:20 they were full of propaganda.
00:07:22 And it was like, why basically like, why do you hate trans kids?
00:07:24 And why won't you give them healthcare?
00:07:26 And you can see Pierre just kind of lost his patience.
00:07:28 And then that was like the moment where he first came out.
00:07:30 And then the next day he was in the House Commons, he was getting scrummed and the reporters
00:07:33 were doing their job.
00:07:33 Like, where do you stand?
00:07:34 What's your position?
00:07:34 What's your party position?
00:07:36 And he, he finally let them have it.
00:07:38 And it was great.
00:07:39 So, uh, good, good for Pierre for landing in the right place.
00:07:41 Okay.
00:07:41 I want to talk about this other story that happened this week, which was that we learned
00:07:44 that it was the prime minister's office.
00:07:46 It was prime minister Justin Trudeau's own office that invited that Nazi veteran to, uh, 0.71
00:07:52 reception and, and to, to be at the House of Commons.
00:07:55 So we, we all remember this very embarrassing, uh, moment that happened last September where
00:08:00 the entire House of Commons gave a standing ovation to a Nazi and basically interesting 0.90
00:08:05 component of the story.
00:08:06 I know you cover this on your show, Andrew, but, but just, just to, just repeat it.
00:08:10 It's like at the time when the, when this happened, the scandal came out, the government blamed
00:08:15 it entirely on house speaker, Anthony Rota.
00:08:18 He ended up resigning, but there were some interesting quotes from the time.
00:08:22 Uh, so we had liberal cabinet ministers insisting that this person, this house leader could not
00:08:28 stay on the job because what he had done was just so beyond the pale and so reprehensible.
00:08:31 So we had Karina Gold saying, I can't see based on the conversations I've had, how he can continue
00:08:37 to have the support of liberal members of parliament.
00:08:40 Then you had Melanie Jolie, the foreign minister saying what happened on Friday is completely
00:08:43 unacceptable.
00:08:44 It was an embarrassment to the House of Commons and Canadians. 0.92
00:08:47 So we had all of these liberals at the time saying that because of what Anthony Rota did,
00:08:52 because he invited this Nazi, it was all his fault. 0.81
00:08:54 It was a hundred percent him.
00:08:56 Nobody else knew what was happening.
00:08:57 This guy's to blame and he just can't be in cabinet.
00:09:00 He can't be in this position anymore.
00:09:02 Well, well, oops, because now we, now we know that it wasn't, it wasn't Anthony Rota.
00:09:07 He was just a fall guy.
00:09:08 He was just the guy that they decided to throw to the bus.
00:09:10 It was actually Justin Trudeau's office that sent the invitation.
00:09:13 So wouldn't all those things now apply to the prime minister, just using liberal logic
00:09:18 here, if, if what Anthony Rota did was so terrible, then now that we know it was actually
00:09:22 Justin Trudeau, why aren't they saying the same thing about Justin Trudeau?
00:09:27 Andrew, I'll, I'll let you take it from here.
00:09:29 Well, I should just clarify, it was a set, it was a separate invitation.
00:09:33 So Anthony Rota had invited him to the House of Commons.
00:09:36 Justin Trudeau invited him to this reception in Toronto where he, he didn't end up attending,
00:09:42 but he was going to be there and it was honoring Volodymyr Zelensky.
00:09:46 And, but, but the rules still apply.
00:09:47 I mean, the current framework you've just laid out there of, you know, guy who invites
00:09:52 Nazi to public event resigns is still something that should apply.
00:09:56 And, but, but we saw Trudeau doing that Trudeopian thing that he loves doing with this, which
00:10:01 is that Canada apologizes.
00:10:03 I apologize on behalf of Canadians as though you Harrison, you Candace, me, our, our video
00:10:09 guys, Jacob, Philly, like they were all the ones that did it, not just Trudeau.
00:10:14 And now we know it was not just Anthony Rota.
00:10:17 It was also a Justin Trudeau's office.
00:10:19 So, you know, yeah, maybe giving the apology on behalf of a larger group of people was warranted,
00:10:24 but the group of people was his office.
00:10:26 And it was amazing that now all of a sudden it's, oh, whoopsie, just an honest mistake.
00:10:30 When it was Anthony Rota, it was something that had to cost him his job.
00:10:34 When it's Justin Trudeau, it's, oh, well, you know, we just, you know, the name was given
00:10:37 to us on a list and we just, oh, you know, who among us hasn't?
00:10:41 Didn't he do this with blackface too? 1.00
00:10:43 Didn't he apologize on behalf of all Canadians when he was coming?
00:10:46 That was a learning opportunity for all of us.
00:10:47 So yeah, so the guy next door does blackface and we all have to learn more about race relations
00:10:53 in Canada.
00:10:54 Yeah.
00:10:54 Yeah, it was, it was a joint learning opportunity.
00:10:56 Harrison, what was your take on this?
00:10:58 Well, the level of incompetence from the prime minister's office from inside this Canadian
00:11:03 government is reaching such dangerous levels that it's becoming like a national security
00:11:08 issue here.
00:11:08 These people literally can't even understand very basic historical facts.
00:11:14 The reality that if you were fighting against the Soviets in World War II, you probably weren't
00:11:20 on the side of the allies.
00:11:21 This is very basic stuff.
00:11:23 And clearly some people in the PMO had no idea.
00:11:26 And it's not like these invitations, you're just a junior staffer writes this stuff out.
00:11:29 It doesn't go through other people.
00:11:32 Nobody caught this.
00:11:33 Everyone else did once it made it, once it was public.
00:11:35 Once the standing ovation had already been given to a Nazi, but no one had caught this 0.83
00:11:40 inside the PMO.
00:11:42 And of course they have to just blame the speaker.
00:11:45 They have to find a fall guy.
00:11:46 Good soldier, Anthony Rota, for just taking it and not exposing the PMO on his way out
00:11:50 for doing this themselves.
00:11:52 But seriously, this is unbelievable here. 0.89
00:11:55 The people inside the PMO are dangerously incompetent.
00:11:58 It's kind of freaking me out.
00:12:00 Well, I think it maybe says something about our history and the whole liberal mantra of
00:12:04 like, let's erase everything that happened like prior to, I don't know, 1965 or prior
00:12:10 to the Charter Rights and Freedoms.
00:12:11 Like Canada's history starts with Pierre Trudeau.
00:12:13 And let's not even learn about World War II or not even learn about Canada's contributions.
00:12:18 It's like, as soon as I heard the introduction in the House of Commons and it was like, this
00:12:23 guy fought against the Russians.
00:12:26 It's like, well, that obviously, to your point, Harrison, that should ring alarm bells.
00:12:29 The fact that the conservatives also stood up and applauded was deeply shameful, but
00:12:33 at least they could be forgiven for getting caught up in a moment, right?
00:12:35 You're at an event and you're not really paying attention and you're focused on something
00:12:39 else and everyone's standing.
00:12:40 And it's like, okay, this guy's a war veteran, you stand.
00:12:43 But it's like, you know, the people who are organizing this event, right?
00:12:47 Like it was a high profile thing.
00:12:49 They had Vladimir Zelensky.
00:12:50 This is like going with whole, the whole like Justin Trudeau, you know, fighting for Ukraine
00:12:55 is fighting for democracy, et cetera, et cetera.
00:12:57 Like you know that a lot of eyeballs looked this stuff over, a lot of thought went into
00:13:02 it.
00:13:02 And the fact that none of them know even basic, basic history about what happened during World
00:13:06 War II is pretty, pretty sad.
00:13:09 But Andrew, did you have any final thoughts on this one?
00:13:11 Yeah.
00:13:11 I mean, everyone got so into the whole, over the last 10, 15 years, everyone's a Nazi
00:13:17 thing.
00:13:18 And it's amazing how that everyone is a Nazi except for the literal Nazi. 0.72
00:13:23 The literal Nazi is not a Nazi, but everyone else is a Nazi. 0.90
00:13:25 That was the one imbalance I found when this thing first came up that I've been reminded
00:13:31 of the last couple of days.
00:13:32 Well, and, and I think this is not, this has not been a strong week for Justin Trudeau.
00:13:37 You saw that in the House of Commons.
00:13:39 I want to play this clip where Justin Trudeau, he's trying to go after Pierre Polyev, but
00:13:45 it really doesn't land.
00:13:47 And I think I could give you some credit, Harrison, because you've been talking for a
00:13:51 while about how Justin Trudeau is trying to run against Donald Trump and not Pierre
00:13:55 Polyev.
00:13:55 And this was sort of a weak attempt at that.
00:13:58 So let's play this clip here.
00:14:00 Speaker, what we hear from the leader of the opposition is under the previous conservative
00:14:06 government, everything was perfect.
00:14:08 And what he is proposing to do is to make Canada great again.
00:14:14 That is not what Canadians want.
00:14:16 He is pining for a nostalgia that, quite frankly, Canadians do not feel.
00:14:21 They remember.
00:14:22 Yeah.
00:14:23 So that just didn't really land.
00:14:24 I do like the part where he was trying to, he was trying to insult to the conservatives
00:14:28 by saying that they thought everything was perfect under Harper.
00:14:30 And then the conservative side all starts cheering, like, yeah, everything was great under Harper.
00:14:34 That's exactly right.
00:14:35 And then it was just also going well for Trudeau.
00:14:37 And then he tries to land this, like, make Canada great again.
00:14:41 Maka-ga. 0.94
00:14:43 It doesn't roll off the tongue like Maka-ga does. 1.00
00:14:45 Maka-ga. 0.94
00:14:46 It doesn't work so well.
00:14:47 Yeah.
00:14:48 And it just didn't land.
00:14:49 And I think that if most people just heard that sentence, you know, Pierre Polyev wants to
00:14:53 make Canada great again.
00:14:55 It's like, yeah, who doesn't?
00:14:56 Like, that's exactly right.
00:14:58 That's what he does want to do.
00:14:59 And the conservatives should have all, like, leapt up and started doing the standing ovation.
00:15:02 But it's like, you know, people don't, people aren't as obsessed with Donald Trump and this,
00:15:08 like, line, one line from, like, 10 years ago.
00:15:11 It was almost, I mean, nine years ago, 2015, that he first came up with that make America
00:15:16 great again.
00:15:16 It's like, you could just tell that Justin Trudeau is so inside this, like, bubble of political
00:15:22 mudslinging that he's obsessed with it and it's not working.
00:15:26 I don't know.
00:15:26 What do you think, Harrison?
00:15:27 Yeah, well, clearly they can't run against Pierre Polyev, they can't run against what
00:15:32 he says to Canadians because it works and it's working with the conservatives.
00:15:36 Where's the art of subtlety gone in politics these days, guys?
00:15:40 I mean, they can't, the liberals can't even be clever about their approach to try and make
00:15:44 Polyev to seem like some sort of Donald Trump, Donald Trump reincarnate in Canada. 0.55
00:15:50 They put him up on a split screen with Donald Trump and every other week they've got some
00:15:55 sort of split screen between what Polyev is saying, exactly how that's what Donald Trump
00:15:59 says, and now they're bringing out the make Canada great again line.
00:16:02 The reality is Canadians are pining for the nostalgia of a pre-Trudeau Canada.
00:16:07 Clearly, things are much worse after this guy's been in power for eight years.
00:16:12 That's not even a very controversial thing to say.
00:16:14 The majority of Canadians seem to agree on that.
00:16:17 I don't think this is going to land at all, but this is what they want to do.
00:16:20 They're going to, all throughout 2024, they're going to run off the U.S. election, basically.
00:16:27 They're going to try and make the conservatives out to be the Republicans, make Pierre out
00:16:30 to be Donald Trump, and, you know, I guess good luck to them.
00:16:33 It's not going to work, though.
00:16:35 Pierre Polyev is such a different political figure than Donald Trump.
00:16:38 They really don't have a lot of overlap.
00:16:40 Like, sure, yeah, they both believe in, like, I don't know, smaller government and, like,
00:16:44 it's just so trivial.
00:16:45 Like, when it comes to their actual personalities and where they stand, like, their age, everything
00:16:51 about them is so different.
00:16:52 It's just a weird comparison.
00:16:54 What's your take, Andrew?
00:16:55 Well, yeah, but it's just, like, politics and political media coverage are like that
00:17:00 in general.
00:17:00 It's the same reason that Justin Trudeau for the last, you know, decade has been, you
00:17:04 know, comparing and blaming everything and everyone on Harper.
00:17:08 It's, you know, the Harper years, the Harper years.
00:17:10 And at a certain point, it's like, you've been there for now nine years.
00:17:13 I think it's hard to blame Stephen Harper for your government's poor performance, but
00:17:18 it's either that or Trump.
00:17:20 They just cling to, like, the easiest comparison.
00:17:22 And I mean, the one thing that Trump has done, which is really annoying, he didn't do
00:17:26 it, but has been done around him, is that it's become the laziest, easiest comparison
00:17:31 for anyone.
00:17:32 It's like you're a stand-up comedian.
00:17:33 You go on stage.
00:17:34 You don't even have to tell a joke.
00:17:35 You just be like, Trump, am I right?
00:17:37 And everyone will just like, oh, yeah.
00:17:38 And, you know, journalists can just say, like, Trump.
00:17:41 Like, I once got into an argument with someone when I did my old radio show, I was defending
00:17:46 the zipper merge.
00:17:47 The zipper merge, which is a piece of urban planning where, you know, when a lane is closing,
00:17:53 it's actually most efficient to alternate, to use both lanes right up until the merge
00:17:57 point instead of, like, you know, two kilometers out getting into the lane that's continuing.
00:18:02 The reason I share that boring bit of trivia is because I was talking about this and why
00:18:06 studies have shown zipper merge is fast.
00:18:08 And someone said, you're just like Trump for saying that.
00:18:11 And I'm like, was Trump like a known fan of the zipper?
00:18:14 But like, but it's just, it's the only thing people know how to, it's the only insult people
00:18:19 know now.
00:18:20 Yeah, but I-
00:18:21 I want to say this as well, Candace.
00:18:22 The liberals always try to rail against the conservatives for importing American-style
00:18:26 politics, right?
00:18:27 That's their line against the conservatives before they even tried to-
00:18:30 And Hillary Clinton at their convention.
00:18:31 Yeah, exactly.
00:18:32 They're trying to make-
00:18:34 They try to blame the conservatives for importing American politics.
00:18:36 What could be more, what could be more American politics than making your opposition out to
00:18:41 be like the Republican front runner? 0.99
00:18:43 It's ridiculous. 0.97
00:18:45 Make a tax Canadian again. 0.98
00:18:46 That's my slogan.
00:18:47 Make a tax Canadian again. 0.54
00:18:49 We have to make-
00:18:49 Bring back Canadian arguments in politics. 0.55
00:18:52 Macca.
00:18:52 Macca works much better.
00:18:54 No, it's, it's, it's, it's really, no, there's some good points raised.
00:18:58 And yeah, the exact idea that any, any, anything bad you do is, oh, you're Trump.
00:19:04 But I just, I just don't think it's going to work.
00:19:06 I think that Trump was deeply unpopular, especially in Canada during the beginning part of his
00:19:10 first term, but I don't think that's there anymore.
00:19:13 I think that people kind of see through it.
00:19:15 They don't, they don't see Trump the same way.
00:19:17 He doesn't carry the same fear and hysteria that he did in 2016.
00:19:20 So again, if this is a liberal strategy, good luck, because it doesn't seem to land.
00:19:24 Okay.
00:19:24 I just want to quickly, quickly cover this story, which is the NDP wants to make it illegal
00:19:29 to say good things about Canada.
00:19:31 Seriously, seriously.
00:19:32 So Charlie Angus, an NDP, MP, long time member, tabled a private member's bill, Bill C-372,
00:19:40 known as the Fossil Fuel Advertising Act.
00:19:43 It was tabled earlier this week.
00:19:45 Basically, it will criminalize the promotion of fossil fuels.
00:19:48 You can go to jail, you can pay a fine up to $1.5 million, up to two years in jail for
00:19:53 promoting Canadian energy.
00:19:57 This is real.
00:19:58 This is real.
00:19:59 And, you know, it's not going to pass.
00:20:01 It's not going to go anywhere.
00:20:02 The NDP is sort of just like the fringe, weird character in Canadian politics.
00:20:08 They hold the balance of power, sure.
00:20:10 But, you know, this is the direction they're going.
00:20:13 These people truly hate free speech.
00:20:15 They don't want you to say nice things about Canada.
00:20:18 They don't want you to be proud of your country.
00:20:19 They don't like working class jobs. 1.00
00:20:21 They don't want cheap energy.
00:20:23 Like everything.
00:20:25 This just shows us so much about the Canadian left and where the NDP wants to take this country
00:20:30 if they were given any more power.
00:20:33 Andrew, any thoughts on this one?
00:20:34 Yeah, I mean, the basis for what he's doing is he's trying to say that, and it says it in
00:20:39 the legislation, in the preamble, that it's based on this climate crisis and that we have
00:20:44 to, he said in his remarks, start treating oil and gas the way we've treated big tobacco
00:20:48 companies.
00:20:48 He made the comparison between, you know, oil and gas saying that, you know, oil and
00:20:53 gas is good for the Canadian economy to, you know, what is it?
00:20:56 Bensman and Hedges, Rothman and Benson, Rothman, Hedges, whatever, you know, one of the tobacco
00:21:00 companies is saying that, oh, you know, tobacco smoking is good for your health.
00:21:03 So he's trying to use that precedent to say that the crisis caused by fossil fuels outweigh
00:21:10 their right to free speech.
00:21:11 But it's kind of amusing because I'm just imagining, like, I don't know, you know, Ontario
00:21:15 if we have them, but I'm sure in Alberta, there are these, you know, oil and gas weekly
00:21:19 word or whatever.
00:21:20 And I'm just imagining like going into the variety store and, you know, like with your
00:21:24 head down and being like, hi, I need the magazines in the back room, if you know what
00:21:27 I mean.
00:21:28 And the guy says, what are you looking for?
00:21:30 Playboy or oil and gas weekly?
00:21:32 And it's, you know, it's oil and gas weekly.
00:21:33 It's in the plastic cover and more like the cigarettes where, you know, you have to get them
00:21:37 to open the case and, you know, quickly close it.
00:21:39 And but it's insane because they're trying to stigmatize a sector that is the lifeblood
00:21:45 of the Canadian economy.
00:21:46 And it has been.
00:21:48 And every every industry is connected.
00:21:50 So even like, you know, fancy bankers and and marketing executives in cities like Vancouver
00:21:54 and Toronto that think they're above and removed from oil and gas.
00:21:57 It's like, no, no, it's all like like oil and gas is still the Canadian economy.
00:22:01 Yes, we're diversifying.
00:22:02 But but resources have always been Canada's core economic engine.
00:22:07 And just, yeah, it's it's it's wild.
00:22:10 Harrison, what's your take on this?
00:22:12 Well, this is insane.
00:22:12 I can only I'm thinking about what was going on in Alberta when their power grid basically
00:22:17 shut down.
00:22:17 And, you know, no one is allowed to go on social media and say that, oh, I really wish
00:22:21 we had natural gas to to stay warm in the coldest day of the winter.
00:22:26 Otherwise, they might get fine for saying something like that.
00:22:28 They might get fine for noticing that actually, you know, the wind and the and the solar isn't
00:22:33 keeping them warm in like minus 40 weather.
00:22:37 It's just absurd.
00:22:38 It's very NDP, though, right?
00:22:40 This is not I wish I was surprised when I read this story yesterday, but it was more it
00:22:45 was more just like, oh, Charlie Angus is speaking.
00:22:47 Oh, of course.
00:22:48 Of course, he's putting this this bill forward.
00:22:49 I would have been a little less surprised had it come from Elizabeth May.
00:22:53 But NDP, that's pretty close these days.
00:22:56 You're right.
00:22:57 And just like the core of their of their thinking is that they hate free speech.
00:23:01 They want to ban it.
00:23:02 They say that what they what this is.
00:23:04 This kind of takes me to the whole like post truth argument that we don't agree on the facts
00:23:10 anymore.
00:23:10 So what Charlie Angus is saying is that he is the arbiter of what is true.
00:23:15 And if you disagree with him, it is disinformation to the point where you should go to jail, which
00:23:22 you know, this is this is authoritarian.
00:23:24 This is authoritarianism.
00:23:25 It's not it's we're not talking about like a democratic parameter here.
00:23:31 You're talking about demonizing speech that you personally disagree with.
00:23:35 It's it's insane. 0.67
00:23:37 It's insane.
00:23:37 But I think we can just if this is the rule and this is what we're now allowed to do,
00:23:41 I think some conservative needs to introduce a private member's bill saying it is illegal
00:23:46 to promote the virtues of socialism in Canada.
00:23:49 Socialism has killed millions of people.
00:23:51 It's very harmful.
00:23:53 It's harmful to the economy.
00:23:54 It's harmful to people's lives.
00:23:56 So anyone who does that is endangering people.
00:23:58 So you can't promote the virtues of socialism.
00:24:01 The good news is the NDP will save money on its ad budget when they're not allowed to
00:24:04 run any.
00:24:05 They're not allowed to speak anymore because.
00:24:08 Yeah, sorry.
00:24:09 Charlie Angus.
00:24:09 It's like the it'll be like when Elizabeth May got pulled off stage by by at least the
00:24:14 rate.
00:24:14 We'll just have to pull Charlie Angus off stage like he's gone on too long at the Oscars,
00:24:18 like Marlon Brando's substitute.
00:24:21 There's a dated reference.
00:24:22 But yeah, we'll have to.
00:24:24 It'll just be great.
00:24:24 It'll sanitize political discourse in this country.
00:24:27 No, that would be some top level trolling if the conservatives were to actually do that. 0.90
00:24:31 I would I would applaud that just for trolling, not because I would actually want that
00:24:35 to be the case.
00:24:35 But speaking of socialism, let's try that transition.
00:24:38 Great segue.
00:24:39 I love it.
00:24:40 Speaking of socialism, everything in Ottawa speaking of socialism for the last few years,
00:24:45 the NDP have been on this sort of crusade against grocery stores in Canada and sort of
00:24:50 blaming the companies for the sort of consequences of Justin Trudeau's pandemic policies.
00:24:56 So the idea that they printed a lot of money, they gave away a lot of money during the pandemic
00:25:01 that led to inflation.
00:25:03 There was a whole bunch of supply chain issues when things were started to get back up again
00:25:06 because the government shut down the economy and then it took a while for the economy to
00:25:10 get caught up.
00:25:11 That whole time, rather than looking at the economic picture, the left, the NDP and some
00:25:19 liberals just accused the companies.
00:25:21 It was all the company's fault.
00:25:23 It was law, blah.
00:25:23 It was greed.
00:25:24 It was big grocers that are causing high food prices in Canada.
00:25:27 It's not the government's fault.
00:25:29 There's inflation.
00:25:29 It's law, blah, blah's fault.
00:25:31 So it was all corporate greed and profiteering.
00:25:33 It just seems like the Ottawa bubble just sort of really hates law, blah.
00:25:37 So it became a big scandal this week when Justin Trudeau alerted the country that Pierre
00:25:42 Polyev's advisor, Jenny Byrne, is actually lobbying for law, blah.
00:25:48 So let's play this clip of Justin Trudeau, you know, again, pointing the finger and basically
00:25:53 saying that it's all the Conservatives' fault now that your food prices are too high.
00:25:57 Pierre Polyev has been standing up for months now, pretending that he cares about high grocery
00:26:07 prices faced by Canadians.
00:26:09 And it turns out that his top advisor is working as a lobbyist for Loblaws.
00:26:18 I think Mr. Polyev owes some explanations to Canadians.
00:26:21 Okay, so Mr. Drama, Mr. Drama Queen, they're giving his, you know, explanation and his super
00:26:29 serious voice that it's all the Conservatives' fault that prices are too high.
00:26:33 Well, oops, Pierre Polyev came back at Justin Trudeau in question period with his own response.
00:26:40 So let's play that clip.
00:26:41 You're getting desperate if he has to blame Conservative campaign workers for the fact
00:26:49 that he raised food prices, especially when, Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister's new marketing
00:26:57 director, Max Veliket, did marketing for Loblaws for four years.
00:27:02 Don Guy, Don Guy, the Prime Minister's chief pollster, works for GT & Co., which collects
00:27:11 checks from Loblaws.
00:27:13 As does Dan Arnold, his other pollster, getting checks from Loblaws.
00:27:18 Are they the ones that forced him to quadruple the carbon tax on our family?
00:27:23 Gotta love the drama, the fake drama question period.
00:27:26 Like, oh my goodness, can you believe it, fellas?
00:27:28 They're all lobbying for Loblaws.
00:27:30 Like the Scooby-Doo mask moment of like, look behind this Galen Weston mask, it's the
00:27:35 Liberal pollster.
00:27:37 Yeah, so it turns out that a lot of political staffers have side hustles as lobbyists.
00:27:43 A lot of these guys work for companies and they also work for political parties.
00:27:47 And so just to go back to Justin Trudeau's like huge dramatic moment about how it was all
00:27:52 Pierre Polyev's consultant's fault that food prices are too high.
00:27:56 Yeah, that didn't land very well.
00:27:58 And then Andrew came in with his own scoop, which was that even the NDP, even the socialists
00:28:03 who have long been calling corporate greed the culprit.
00:28:07 Well, Andrew, I'll let you explain your own scoop.
00:28:09 Yeah, so Don Guy, who Pauly, I've mentioned, co-owns this GT & Co.
00:28:13 with Brian Topp, who's a longtime NDP advisor and chief of staff and whatnot.
00:28:18 And Brian Topp and Don Guy in business together.
00:28:21 Their business lobbies Loblaws as recently as last year.
00:28:25 They had an active lobbyist there.
00:28:29 So it's kind of rich here that you have these folks saying, oh, well, anyone who works for
00:28:35 Loblaws is the problem.
00:28:36 And I should just say, Jenny Byrne, who Justin Trudeau was talking about in his criticism
00:28:40 of Polyev, doesn't actually lobby for Loblaws.
00:28:43 She owns the firm who has lobbied and does lobby for Loblaws provincially in Ontario.
00:28:49 So it's the exact same as right here, where the owner of the company is the liberal and
00:28:55 NDP advisor.
00:28:56 And then that company is getting contracts.
00:28:58 So completely analogous, apples to apples comparison.
00:29:01 But of course, the criticism only works when it's directed towards the right.
00:29:05 I mean, I guess there's two things.
00:29:07 One, it just shows you the inside world of Ottawa and how basically insincere it all is,
00:29:11 because they'll sit there in their political posture.
00:29:13 But then when you look at, you know, you mentioned Galen Weston, Andrew, who's the owner, very,
00:29:18 very wealthy, self-made Canadian.
00:29:21 You know, he donates to the liberals.
00:29:22 He also donates to the conservatives.
00:29:24 Like you can play this game all day long.
00:29:26 You know, there is a lot of political connections and a lot of crony capitalism and corporatism
00:29:34 when it comes to these big Canadian corporations and government. 0.93
00:29:39 So it's just a silly game to go down, a silly hole to go down. 0.87
00:29:42 Harrison, what's your take? 0.93
00:29:44 Yeah, I think all Canadians will take from this is the fact that basically everyone in 0.70
00:29:48 Ottawa, when they're not a staffer, they're lobbying for a company.
00:29:52 And then when they're not lobbying for a company, they're creating good little political
00:29:55 one-liners to rail against the company that they were lobbying for.
00:29:58 And let's be honest about something as well.
00:30:00 The people in the House of Commons sitting behind Justin Trudeau and sitting behind Pierre
00:30:05 Pauliev making all those ridiculously dramatic faces and weird noises.
00:30:09 They also, many of them were lobbyists before entering politics as well.
00:30:13 So it's just the world of Ottawa.
00:30:15 No Canadians should be surprised. 1.00
00:30:17 And again, it's one of those weird, cheap political attacks where the people who came up
00:30:21 with this didn't have the foresight to realize that they were going to just have this rebounded
00:30:25 back on them.
00:30:26 Well, it is kind of interesting because, I mean, there's an interesting broader debate
00:30:31 about like why things are so expensive in Canada.
00:30:34 And you can look at like how our banking industry, our airline industry, our telecoms industry,
00:30:38 they're all heavily regulated.
00:30:40 And there's a lot of rules about who can participate in these markets.
00:30:43 And because of it, Canadians do pay much higher rates on a lot of things than Americans.
00:30:49 Everyone knows it's way cheaper to fly in the U.S. than it is to fly across Canada.
00:30:53 Like you get a flight from like L.A. to New York for like 70 bucks, right?
00:30:58 And if you're flying from Vancouver to Toronto, it's like $800.
00:31:02 Like it's just like a totally of a mark because they have so much more competition.
00:31:05 And I think that there is something about how the Canadian government regulates these
00:31:09 industries that causes, you know, this kind of like price.
00:31:13 It feels like price gouging, but it's really just a lack of competition.
00:31:17 But then at the same time, when it comes to this issue of grocery stores, it's like, it's
00:31:22 like, well, we try it.
00:31:24 Sometimes they do bring in competition.
00:31:26 It'll be like an American chain that tries to open.
00:31:28 We saw it with Target.
00:31:28 I know Target is more like a big box store, but they tried to come into the Canadian market
00:31:33 and they just couldn't make it work.
00:31:34 It was just too expensive because of our prices, because of everything else.
00:31:37 And it was interesting.
00:31:38 There was a committee meeting yesterday or earlier this week, Wednesday, and basically
00:31:43 they brought an expert to talk about why food pricing was so high.
00:31:46 And he basically said it's because of the carbon tax.
00:31:48 It's because of the taxes on truckers and the taxes on, you know, it's all passed through
00:31:53 back to the consumer.
00:31:55 And so there are different problems in the Canadian sort of pricing system.
00:32:00 But this whole theatrics of like, let's just blame the companies and then blame the lobbyists.
00:32:05 And then in terms of we're all lobbying, like it just misses a point.
00:32:07 It just shows like how Ottawa just sometimes it's such a bubble.
00:32:11 It looks bad on all parties, but they don't talk about the real issue.
00:32:14 They kind of bypass it and play these political games.
00:32:17 Andrew, what's your take?
00:32:19 Yeah, I think you're right about that.
00:32:20 And I think it's also very difficult.
00:32:22 Anytime someone, even with the carbon tax, tries to put a single cause on this, because
00:32:27 there are layered and overlapping phenomena.
00:32:30 You have the carbon tax, you have inflation, you have regulation, you have labor costs.
00:32:34 I mean, that was one of the big things for Target, why Target had such a difficult time
00:32:37 in Canada compared to the US, because the labor and supply chains were just not what they
00:32:43 were used to.
00:32:44 So Canadians that live near the border that had been to American Targets were going to
00:32:48 Canadian Target and being like, oh, this is like, this isn't what I thought Target
00:32:51 was.
00:32:52 So the company decided to pull out.
00:32:54 So I think with Loblaws, the liberal government has wanted to take away any of these factors
00:33:00 that it has responsibility for.
00:33:02 And I would include in that definitely the carbon tax to a large extent inflation.
00:33:06 And it's a lot easy to look at the rich guys that run the companies and say they're the
00:33:11 problem when that is a gross oversimplification.
00:33:15 And I would say if you were to list the top 10 reasons that grocery prices are high and
00:33:20 unaffordable for many Canadians, CEO salaries, I don't even think it's going to be on that
00:33:24 list.
00:33:26 Yeah, that's right.
00:33:26 It's an easy, it's an easy scapegoat.
00:33:29 And again, I think when it comes to the cost of living, it's not just in the food, it's
00:33:33 not just in the grocery stores that we see this issue, it's across the board.
00:33:37 And so Harrison, you had a great report looking at the housing crisis and the rise of these
00:33:42 slumlords in Toronto.
00:33:43 I couldn't believe some of these pictures that you were showing, man.
00:33:46 And so why don't you, why don't you walk us through the story?
00:33:49 Yeah.
00:33:49 So over the weekend, I was on, I was on X and Reddit.
00:33:52 I don't usually go on Reddit, but I was on there because I followed this subreddit called
00:33:55 Canada Housing 2.
00:33:57 And I started to see these unbelievable rent listings, these slumlord listings pop up,
00:34:03 pointing out just how unbelievable the state of the rental market is in this country, particularly
00:34:07 in Toronto and the GTA.
00:34:08 And I want to just highlight for you some of the listings that are available or that were
00:34:14 available.
00:34:14 They might've already been taken by people who are just desperate to put, put a roof
00:34:18 over their head and to do so without having to spend thousands of dollars.
00:34:22 But this is, this is utterly insane.
00:34:24 So we first saw this listing, this is for $500 a month.
00:34:29 Okay.
00:34:30 And this is in Scarborough, we believe.
00:34:32 Take a look at this guys.
00:34:33 This is what you can get for $500 a month.
00:34:35 That is smaller than a jail cell.
00:34:37 I've been told in the comments of the video, at least you get like a nice lamp and a bedside
00:34:41 table and you get some fresh air, but you don't have finished walls.
00:34:45 This is like in the back corner of some basement.
00:34:48 It's just terrible.
00:34:50 Um, and this is what's available for $500.
00:34:52 Put that up, put that up again, Jacob.
00:34:55 Is that blood on the comforter?
00:34:58 I think that's, I think that's just the artistic design of the artistic blood splatters.
00:35:04 All right.
00:35:04 A new phenomenon, uh, you know, concrete brick basement apartments.
00:35:09 It kind of fits with the, with the jail, with the jail house, uh, style.
00:35:13 I think if that, if that really were what it, what it is, but hold on, it just, it just
00:35:17 gets even worse here.
00:35:18 So let's put up this next listing that we have, because this is just, this is just ridiculous.
00:35:24 I think this next one is for $400.
00:35:27 It's in downtown.
00:35:29 I said it was downtown Toronto.
00:35:30 It's not really downtown Toronto, but again, compared to Scarborough and Brampton, this is
00:35:34 right in the heart of the city for $400.
00:35:36 You can live in the hallway on a mattress on the floor of a really dirty house.
00:35:41 Let's just call it what it is.
00:35:42 This is listed on the, on Facebook marketplace.
00:35:45 It might still be available right now.
00:35:47 This is where you, you can, you can rent this out to live on a mattress in a hallway. 0.89
00:35:52 It's just ridiculous.
00:35:53 The state of, uh, of the rental market here. 0.69
00:35:55 I want to show you one more because it is just, it's just absurd.
00:36:00 Now this one is an exclusive listing.
00:36:02 As I noted, it's exclusively for females who are renting this place out and you have to 1.00
00:36:08 share this bed and single room with a boy.
00:36:12 And on top of the $300 and sharing of the bed in the room with the boy.
00:36:17 You have to do the cooking for the, uh, for the landlord here.
00:36:20 I I'm not joking.
00:36:21 This made its way to blog to so you can take their word for it.
00:36:25 Um, it's also been listed on the slumlords of Canada, Reddit page.
00:36:29 And I just want to read the description of this listing for you.
00:36:32 So you get an idea of who, you know, who the tenant is or who the landlord might be room
00:36:36 available for girl and sharing with boy, good behavior.
00:36:40 Girl must know cooking. 1.00
00:36:41 Rest of the work boy will do.
00:36:43 Washroom is in sharing and kitchen also.
00:36:46 So $300 for, uh, for exclusively for a woman to rent out this apartment. 0.99
00:36:52 I have one more for you that I just found.
00:36:54 This is in Brampton.
00:36:55 A house in Brampton has apparently been multiple rooms in this house have been rented out.
00:37:00 People are now living inside of a car in the driveway of this Brampton house and urinating
00:37:07 on the side of the house.
00:37:07 So this is the state of what, of what we're working with here in Canada.
00:37:11 The slumlords have taken over and living conditions have plummeted all because of insane levels 1.00
00:37:17 of immigration to this country.
00:37:19 And of course, inflation that has made basically everything way too expensive.
00:37:24 It's just terrible.
00:37:25 I didn't know you had to pay to be a live-in chef now.
00:37:28 That was, uh, I thought it was like, I went, cause I always imagined, you know, when I,
00:37:32 you know, strike it big, I pay to have the live-in chef. 0.77
00:37:34 I didn't know I could get paid to have someone come into my home and cook for me every day.
00:37:39 That sounds like actually a pretty sweet deal.
00:37:40 Well, I wonder who ends up not for the person living there.
00:37:42 No, if the chef has to pay for the food, then it's not really, you know, it's more than $300
00:37:46 a month and you're really, you're really, you really got a bad deal.
00:37:50 I mean, this is sad.
00:37:51 It's, it's unbelievable what people are willing to do and to live in.
00:37:56 And look, I mean, I think when you're young, you're willing to, you know, live in pretty
00:38:00 rough living conditions.
00:38:02 I know a lot of guys that go up to camps and they live in pretty brutal conditions for
00:38:06 a couple of weeks so that they can make some money and come back in.
00:38:09 But, but that's not even what this is, right?
00:38:11 This is like, they've allowed so many international students to come into the country.
00:38:15 A lot of them don't have any option for housing.
00:38:17 That's what they do.
00:38:18 It's like, oh, let's just get like 20 guys to live in a basement.
00:38:21 I mean, I can't imagine that first one you showed it looked like a jailhouse.
00:38:24 I can't imagine what the rest of the basement looks like.
00:38:26 Is it just like, is it just like a dorm room or like a, like a hostel full of beds on the
00:38:31 floor and an unfinished basement?
00:38:32 Like that's, that's, that's pretty rough.
00:38:34 And I, I, I'm usually not very kind.
00:38:37 I, there's this trend that I really don't like, uh, which is like a bunch of, you know,
00:38:41 younger people complaining that they can't buy a house and blaming it on the prime
00:38:45 minister.
00:38:45 It's like, you know what?
00:38:47 Uh, yeah, it's tough and you got to save up and you got to make sacrifices, but let's
00:38:51 not just sit here and like blame our prime minister.
00:38:53 If you personally are like in your thirties and you can't afford to buy a house, like
00:38:57 you got to own some of that.
00:38:59 Some of that is personal responsibility.
00:39:01 Like you need to save up.
00:39:02 You need to make good decisions, like live with roommates and save your paychecks until
00:39:07 you can afford something.
00:39:08 And, and, and I get the fact that down payments are like super crazy now.
00:39:11 I was like, well, don't buy a house in Toronto, like go move somewhere else.
00:39:14 Go live in a different part of the country.
00:39:16 Go live in Saskatchewan.
00:39:17 It's still relatively cheaper.
00:39:18 Go live in Edmonton.
00:39:19 You can, you can still, you know, afford to buy something a little bit better there
00:39:24 or, or other parts of the country.
00:39:25 But, but then when, when you, when you see the situation, you just think about the
00:39:28 people who are forced into that situation and that that's the only option they have.
00:39:32 It's like, this is a problem.
00:39:34 And I do think a lot of it is immigration related.
00:39:36 Andrew, what's your take?
00:39:38 Well, I think a lot of it is immigration related.
00:39:40 I think there is something to, I, I, I don't know if I, I think some people who are in their
00:39:45 thirties that got a later start in career and life, I I'm, I'm very sympathetic to them
00:39:51 not being able to do it because for a lot of people to have a single family home, if they
00:39:56 are single and have a single income, it is incredibly difficult.
00:39:59 I will say though, I thought there was a lot of truth to the point that people are a lot
00:40:04 too picky, a lot more picky than they should be on location.
00:40:07 I think a lot of people, like I I've heard stories and I've known people that have made
00:40:11 the decision to move, you know, hours and hours outside of the cities because they can
00:40:15 get a start there.
00:40:16 And in the remote work economy for a lot of people, not for, not for everyone, um, you
00:40:21 can do it.
00:40:21 So I think, I think if you're stuck on this fantasy of living in Toronto or Vancouver, just
00:40:26 because you want to be, and not for any professional or significant reason, I think you should probably
00:40:34 try to shake that because that's the only way you'll be able to do it now.
00:40:37 Yeah, I think that's right.
00:40:38 Like I, I can kind of relate to it too.
00:40:40 Like, look, I grew up in Vancouver in a neighborhood where I think the average single family home
00:40:45 is now like $3 million.
00:40:46 And it was not like that when I was growing up.
00:40:48 Like it was, it was, it was a fine middle-class neighborhood, but it wasn't to the extent it
00:40:52 was, but even, you know, by the time I graduated high school and left university, which we're
00:40:57 now talking about, you know, like 15 years ago, 20 years ago, there was no way, there
00:41:01 was no chance that I would be able to buy a place in that neighborhood.
00:41:04 And it's kind of sad because Vancouver has gone through this like a long time ago, you
00:41:08 know, 15, 20, 25 years ago.
00:41:10 And, and, and, and I always thought Vancouver was like an anomaly.
00:41:13 And then it's like, it's almost like that phenomenon that happened in Vancouver, uh, caught
00:41:18 up to the rest of the country and it's now happening in like so many other cities.
00:41:21 And so it does show, I think that something's fundamentally wrong.
00:41:24 And I think in Vancouver, it was very clearly driven by immigration, by wealthy foreign buyers,
00:41:30 Chinese buyers coming in and just liking that neighborhood and buying out all the houses 1.00
00:41:34 and kind of like displacing the people who had lived there prior.
00:41:38 So there's definitely structural issues.
00:41:40 When I say I'm annoyed by this whole trend, because I just, I just think it's like a simplistic
00:41:45 attitude for conservatives to say like, I can't afford a house and it's the government's
00:41:49 fault.
00:41:50 It's like, it's like, come on, take some, take some responsibility, man.
00:41:53 But I, I hear, I hear your point, Andrew Harrison, any, any final thoughts on this?
00:41:57 Yeah.
00:41:57 I mean, one of the questions that I asked at the beginning of my show on this topic was
00:42:01 the people who were responsible for bringing in all of these people into our country and 0.99
00:42:07 flooding the country and these, and these pockets of our population where houses are now
00:42:11 unaffordable knew full well, what was going to happen, what the consequences were going
00:42:16 to be. 0.96
00:42:16 These are not dumb people. 0.99
00:42:17 They knew it was going to happen. 0.88
00:42:18 So it makes you wonder if it wasn't obviously done for Canadians, even though the government's
00:42:23 responsibility is to make sure that Canadians are taken care of first and that they can 0.63
00:42:28 hopefully live in the cities they grew up in.
00:42:30 So if it wasn't done for Canadians, who was it done for? 0.58
00:42:33 And I think that that is a question that needs to be asked.
00:42:35 It looks like it was done for corporations who could benefit on a, on a massive amount of,
00:42:39 of cheap available labor.
00:42:40 And also for these colleges to benefit from insane amounts of, of students paying three
00:42:45 to four times the tuition fees.
00:42:47 I think there is something to be said about, you know, people having to be realistic and
00:42:50 people having to be less picky about location.
00:42:52 But the reality is, I don't think it's fair to say to Canadians who are now looking at this
00:42:57 country and realizing that the life that they were expecting when they were very young,
00:43:01 that's totally out of reach is their fault.
00:43:04 And it's not the fault of people who made these decisions in the first place.
00:43:08 Um, I think there's a lot of, a lot of, of frustration and anger that is, is coming
00:43:14 from this situation that the government is not paying attention to.
00:43:17 I think the opposition doesn't want to accept the kind of anger that's actually coming from
00:43:21 young people in this country, but it is there and it's growing.
00:43:25 And this is exactly why.
00:43:27 Well, uh, you pointed this out because, uh, Pierre Paglia put out a really informative,
00:43:31 great video about the housing problem in Canada.
00:43:34 And I think he made a lot of really, really strong points in that video, but there was
00:43:38 one sort of like elephant in the room that he just refused to acknowledge, which is immigration.
00:43:41 I don't think he mentioned it once.
00:43:43 And you, you made a point on your show of going through the comment section.
00:43:46 Like people notice, people know that there is this problem when it comes to mass, mass
00:43:52 immigration, Canada has the highest immigration levels, uh, I think in the world, definitely
00:43:56 in the G, in the G7.
00:43:57 And that is having an impact and you got to talk about it.
00:44:00 You have to find a way to talk about it because it's an issue, uh, that's important.
00:44:04 Andrew, I'll give you the last word to you.
00:44:06 No, I don't really have one.
00:44:08 I mean, I, I asked Pierre Paglia when I did my year end interview with him about that.
00:44:11 And he did admit, yes, immigration, it's just raw numbers has an effect, but still wouldn't
00:44:17 go to the point of giving that number of, of how many is enough of what the system can
00:44:23 sustain.
00:44:24 So, uh, where he left, it was saying that yes, we'll tie immigration to housing.
00:44:29 So if you read between the lines, he is saying, yes, I mean, theoretically we could reduce
00:44:33 that number, but he, he still, for reasons we've all talked about on our respective shows,
00:44:37 doesn't want to come out and say that in black and white terms.
00:44:40 Okay.
00:44:41 I said last word to you, but I just want to make one point of that because I made me think
00:44:45 of your interview and one of the things that I didn't like about what Polly have did was 0.72
00:44:48 that it was a purely economic math based equation.
00:44:50 Like to him, it was just about the math and nothing else.
00:44:53 And it's like, at some point you have to recognize that there is a deeper cultural, uh, issue here
00:44:59 that, that, that, that many Canadians are concerned with, like whether people are being integrated,
00:45:03 whether it's a good idea for our communities, whether this is having a good effect on things
00:45:07 like cost of living, how it's influencing people in your generation, Harrison, and people just
00:45:11 coming out of school and people just trying to like, like there are,
00:45:14 you know, more broad, uh, questions that need to be answered.
00:45:18 And I, I, I mean, maybe, maybe libertarians like these kinds of answers, but when he just
00:45:22 said it was like purely numbers, it was just a hundred percent on math and nothing else.
00:45:26 I, that, that my heart sank a little bit.
00:45:28 I was, I wasn't, I wasn't.
00:45:30 For the last time, Candace, libertarians can care about values too. 0.98
00:45:35 Every, every time you're just like staring daggers into my soul when you crap on libertarians.
00:45:39 You know, I was, I, I consider myself libertarian for a long time and, and I, and when it comes
00:45:44 to government spending, a lot of things are libertarians still, but I do think these deeper
00:45:49 values questions matter, Andrew, they matter.
00:45:51 All right.
00:45:52 All right.
00:45:52 I think we'll cut it off there.
00:45:53 Thanks so much everyone for tuning in.
00:45:55 And, and just as a reminder, remember that the show is called off the record.
00:45:58 So everything you just heard was off the record.
00:46:06 Oh, we didn't talk about the, uh, the guy that wanted me to do more rap dancing.
00:46:10 So we'll have to bring back the dance moves in the next show. 0.63
00:46:12 I was going to say, Andrew, you ditched the wine for what is that a coffee?
00:46:16 Yeah.
00:46:16 I, I, I was running behind this morning.
00:46:18 So I just, I should have put some Baileys in it just to keep on brand.
00:46:21 Yeah.
00:46:22 Yeah.
00:46:23 Yeah.
00:46:23 I, well, I was like, you know, let's keep it to 45 minutes.
00:46:26 And, and so I totally forgot about the comments.
00:46:28 Well, I promise we'll do comments next week.
00:46:30 That's okay.
00:46:31 That's okay.
00:46:32 They, they don't know.
00:46:32 Well, unless this is in the banter reel, then they'll know.
00:46:34 But other than that, they didn't know.
00:46:37 Okay.
00:46:38 Right on.
00:46:38 Yeah.
00:46:38 I think we should keep it in the banter wheel.