The Candice Malcolm Show - August 13, 2025


PRIVATE property now INDIGENOUS land? B.C. Conservative Leader John Rustad responds

Topics
Hosted by
Guests
Mentioned
A victory for freedom! Canadians want more EVIDENCE on unmarked graves + Juno's 6 month anniversary (feat. Keean Bexte)

Episode Stats


Length

29 minutes

Words per minute

183.15

Word count

5,355

Sentence count

322

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

A bombshell judgment was released by B.C. s Supreme Court on Friday, declaring Aboriginal title over land in Richmond, including private property. If it stands, it has massive implications for private property across the province.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hi, I'm Candace Malcolm, and this is the Candace Malcolm Show.
00:00:04 We have a great episode for you today, folks.
00:00:06 We are joined by John Rodsett, leader of the B.C. Conservatives, in just a minute.
00:00:10 And also, this episode is sponsored by Unsmoke, but more on them a little later.
00:00:14 I want to start by talking about an issue in the news, and I'm going to bring this up with John in a moment.
00:00:19 And that is a bombshell judgment that was released by B.C.'s Supreme Court.
00:00:23 So you might have seen Carolyn Elliott on X posting on Friday,
00:00:26 bombshell judgment released by B.C.'s Supreme Court declaring aboriginal title over land in Richmond,
00:00:31 including private property.
00:00:32 If it stands, it has massive implications for private property across B.C.
00:00:37 She says, read for it for yourself.
00:00:39 I'm going to read a little bit from a Globe and Mail report.
00:00:42 The headline says, major land claims ruling, says B.C. Indigenous groups,
00:00:46 has claimed to a portion of the city's port land.
00:00:49 So Vancouver First Nations has won a major court victory,
00:00:51 with the judge declaring it has title to a portion of land in the Vancouver area
00:00:56 that includes currently active industrial operations on the Fraser River.
00:01:00 Justice Barbara Young of the B.C. Supreme Court declared that the Cowichan tribes
00:01:04 have established aboriginal title to roughly 800 acres in the city of Richmond,
00:01:10 as well as aboriginal right to fish and food.
00:01:13 Her 863-page ruling from a trial that stretched 513 days over five years,
00:01:20 from 2021 to 2023, was issued Thursday and published online Friday.
00:01:24 The court ruling in what was billed as the longest trial in Canada's history,
00:01:29 no kidding, represents a milestone in the country's continual societal
00:01:32 and legal reckoning of Indigenous reconciliation.
00:01:35 The decision follows a line of similarly important rulings,
00:01:39 and there will almost certainly be legal arguments and appellate cases.
00:01:43 I hope so.
00:01:43 I hope that there are challenges to this case,
00:01:46 because it is truly disturbing and unsettling, folks.
00:01:49 You see the land-back activists, people demanding land-back,
00:01:53 saying that this is unceded land.
00:01:55 You know, those land acknowledgements that we're forced to hear
00:01:58 any time there's a public press conference now from politicians,
00:02:01 all saying that Canada is basically an illegitimate country
00:02:04 and that the land actually belongs to the First Nations.
00:02:07 Well, this court ruling is legalizing that,
00:02:11 is putting precedent into that,
00:02:13 saying that, yes, First Nations have title to the land
00:02:16 and they can take it back if they prove their case really interesting.
00:02:21 Not only that, I'm going to read a little bit more from this Globe and Mail report.
00:02:25 There are three different First Nations groups or bands
00:02:28 that all have claims over the same part of land in Richmond,
00:02:33 and they're pitted against each other.
00:02:35 So I'm going to read a little here.
00:02:36 It says,
00:02:36 The Cowichan tribes case, like many before it, is particularly complicated.
00:02:41 It says that the case pitted regional indigenous groups against each other.
00:02:43 The Cowichan are based on Vancouver Island,
00:02:45 but in centuries past had an annual summer village on the Fraser River,
00:02:50 or so they claim, and that is where they fish for salmon.
00:02:53 The Musqueam and Tawassan tribes have long lived around Fraser River
00:02:57 in the B.C.'s lower mainland.
00:02:58 The Musqueam upset over the court ruling on Friday morning.
00:03:01 They called it devastating and said it impacts their own title and fishing rights.
00:03:05 The land in question is within Musqueam's traditional
00:03:08 and unceded territory, writes the Globe and Mail.
00:03:11 Chief Wayne Sparrow said in a statement that Musqueam are extremely disappointed
00:03:15 that the Cowichan would go against our shared Salish Coast protocols.
00:03:20 It was emotional.
00:03:21 I want to read just a little bit more.
00:03:22 It says the Cowichan claim involved 1,800 acres,
00:03:25 and the court declared title on roughly 40% of that.
00:03:28 There are some privately held properties.
00:03:31 This is important.
00:03:31 But lawyers involved in the case say that if the ruling stands,
00:03:34 that land would not be affected until the properties are sold.
00:03:38 So you can keep your land for now, but you lose all value and all equity
00:03:40 because when you sell it, it's not going to be yours.
00:03:44 Justice Young declared that the land titles held by Canada and Richmond
00:03:46 to be defective and invalid.
00:03:50 Defective and invalid.
00:03:51 So the property to your home and to your land,
00:03:53 well, a judge may declare that that is defective and invalid,
00:03:56 and therefore you don't actually have title to your land.
00:03:59 Again, from the Globe and Mail piece, it says if the Cowichan's win
00:04:02 is upheld in future appeals, they could eventually take control
00:04:05 of the land in question and use it as they see fit.
00:04:09 Justice Young, a decade-long veteran of the court,
00:04:12 suspended the declaration on land titles for 18 months
00:04:15 so the Cowichan federal government and city of Richmond
00:04:17 will have the opportunity to make necessary arrangements.
00:04:20 Much more remains.
00:04:21 She writes, and then she continued to say that a period to allow
00:04:25 for an orderly transition of lands is in keeping with the principle of reconciliation.
00:04:31 Did you get that?
00:04:32 The principle of reconciliation means an orderly transition of the lands.
00:04:38 So for all those people calling for reconciliation,
00:04:41 all of the focus on that, at least for the land-backed people
00:04:44 and what I consider extreme radicals in this position,
00:04:48 reconciliation means an orderly transition of the lands.
00:04:53 This is unbelievable, the direction that we're heading.
00:04:56 I want to read a little bit from a legal blog.
00:04:59 This is written by University of Saskatchewan's law professor, Dwight Newman.
00:05:03 He writes, the less certain future of private lands in British Columbia
00:05:08 and basically just says that the judgment has a much broader implication
00:05:14 that any privately owned lands in B.C. may be subject to being overridden by aboriginal title.
00:05:21 So yes, that is exactly what this means.
00:05:25 Now I'm going to bring John Rudstad on in just a second
00:05:27 because as reported by Juno News,
00:05:29 he wants an urgent appeal of the aboriginal title ruling which threatens public policy.
00:05:35 But first, I want to thank our sponsor of today's show, which is Unsmoke.
00:05:39 Look, folks, it's time to modernize Canada's rules on nicotine.
00:05:43 Alternatives to cigarettes like heated tobacco vaping products and oral smokeless products
00:05:46 don't burn tobacco or produce smoke.
00:05:49 They aren't risk-free, but the growing body of scientific evidence
00:05:51 shows that they have the potential to be substantially less harmful than smoking.
00:05:55 Despite this, Canadians are banned access to critical information or even some of these products.
00:06:00 Nicotine pouches remain banned in convenience stores.
00:06:02 Current laws ban communication about the risk of these products compared to cigarettes.
00:06:08 The evidence is there.
00:06:09 The tools exist.
00:06:09 Canadians should have the freedom to know about them.
00:06:12 Learn more at unsmoke.ca.
00:06:15 Okay, I'm very pleased now to be joined by John Rudstad.
00:06:18 He is the leader of the B.C. Conservatives.
00:06:20 Rudstad served as leader of the official opposition since 2024
00:06:23 when the B.C. Conservatives narrowly lost that election,
00:06:26 winning 44 seats, losing by just one seat.
00:06:29 It was an incredibly close election under Rudstad's leadership of the Conservative Party.
00:06:33 He's had its best showing in over 70 years.
00:06:36 So welcome, John.
00:06:37 Thank you so much for joining us.
00:06:39 Thank you for having me on.
00:06:40 Okay.
00:06:40 Well, first of all, I want you to comment on this bombshell landmark ruling
00:06:45 and what it means for the people of British Columbia
00:06:48 and more specifically, property owners in British Columbia.
00:06:52 Yeah, this is a huge decision.
00:06:53 When you look at a court case that finds title underneath private land,
00:06:59 the reality for all of us as Canadians, as British Columbians,
00:07:03 is they are too are incompatible.
00:07:05 Indigenous rights, Indigenous title cannot coexist with private property rights.
00:07:10 In your private property rights, for example,
00:07:12 you have the right to put up a fence and say no trespassing, right?
00:07:16 It's your private property.
00:07:17 You can use it for the things that you want to do.
00:07:19 But when it comes to Indigenous rights and Indigenous title,
00:07:23 Indigenous population have the right to use property,
00:07:29 to use land, to carry on with traditional ways.
00:07:32 And there's nothing you can do to stop it because that's right.
00:07:35 So the two are in direct conflict and really cannot coexist
00:07:40 and should not coexist on the land.
00:07:43 And so this has created a huge problem.
00:07:45 And I talked to some of the homeowners that are impacted by this particular case
00:07:49 and they're concerned about their future.
00:07:52 They ask, like this one lady I talked to, single mom, 0.99
00:07:55 this is her life savings she put into buying this piece.
00:07:58 And she's wondering now, have I lost my life savings?
00:08:01 What does this mean?
00:08:02 Do I have rights anymore?
00:08:04 They're worried about how this impacts the value of their property.
00:08:08 So there's a huge number of questions that are outstanding on this issue.
00:08:13 But I think it's more than that as well.
00:08:16 It's the precedent that is being set here for the whole province,
00:08:19 quite frankly, the country.
00:08:21 But it follows on the heels of some legislation that the NDP put forward
00:08:26 in British Columbia on the Haida, on the Haida Islands,
00:08:30 where they actually define title on the entire islands,
00:08:33 including underneath private property and infrastructure.
00:08:37 And so they set the precedent.
00:08:38 And now the court case here has now confirmed that this could exist anywhere in the province.
00:08:45 And in British Columbia, 120% of British Columbia is claimed by First Nations.
00:08:49 So you better believe all private land across this province could now potentially be subject
00:08:53 to having an Indigenous title underneath their private property.
00:08:57 Well, from the Globe and Mail report that I read from,
00:09:00 you could tell that the individual bands don't even agree with each other, right?
00:09:03 This was given to the Cowichan Band, which is a Vancouver Island band.
00:09:07 Of course, Richmond's not in Vancouver Island.
00:09:09 And it's got competing claims from the Musqueam and the Tawassan.
00:09:12 And so, I mean, it's hard to kind of comprehend.
00:09:16 I want to bring it back to the private property comment that you made,
00:09:18 because in this Globe and Mail article, it says that there are some privately held properties,
00:09:23 but lawyers involved in the case said that if the ruling stands, that land would not be affected
00:09:28 until it was sold, until it was sold.
00:09:31 So meaning that the value that you would have the equity in your home or in your land
00:09:35 that you were planning to use as your retirement nest egg or pass on to your children when you pass away,
00:09:41 that's basically gone.
00:09:42 Because when you try to sell it, no one's going to want to buy land that is held,
00:09:46 that a court has ruled is going to be held by the First Nations.
00:09:49 I mean, how would you assure any private property owners or anyone considering buying a home in British Columbia
00:09:55 that this couldn't happen to them next?
00:09:57 Well, that's why this should never happen.
00:09:59 Private property and infrastructure should never, ever be on the table for a title declaration,
00:10:05 whether that's by court or whether that's by negotiation.
00:10:08 But really, when you wind this case back, this started in 2019.
00:10:12 David Eby was the Attorney General.
00:10:14 At that particular point, they should have recognized the risk that this would have had for private property owners
00:10:19 and sat down and negotiated a settlement and dealt with this as opposed to allowing this to get to this stage.
00:10:26 And really, this government has completely thrown private property rights, private property ownership, you know, under the bus.
00:10:34 Think about the chill that this will put on British Columbia from an investment perspective.
00:10:38 If you want to build housing or if you want to put in a warehouse and put in some manufacturing
00:10:43 or if you want to build a mine or any type of activity that's now in the land base,
00:10:48 you no longer have any certainty that the private property you're trying to build on could remain private property.
00:10:57 It may not down the road.
00:10:58 And so the other interesting piece of this is, of course, in the HIDA legislation,
00:11:04 what it says is that with Indigenous title, Indigenous law can apply.
00:11:10 And so what does that mean?
00:11:12 How does Indigenous law potentially impact or even override your private property rights?
00:11:18 Could they put taxation in place?
00:11:20 Could they say what you can and can't do with the property?
00:11:23 And, of course, you have no ability to vote for that government because that's an Indigenous government. 1.00
00:11:28 And so if it was taxation, for example, that would be, you know, taxation without representation.
00:11:33 So there's a whole lot of question marks.
00:11:36 And this, like I say, this case should never, ever have gotten to court.
00:11:40 It should have been resolved outside in terms of negotiation.
00:11:42 But now that it's there, the government of the day, the NDP government,
00:11:46 needs to clearly define what they are going to be fighting for in terms of defending private property rights.
00:11:52 Well, 100%.
00:11:53 I think a lot of people will say that this is all sort of downstream from the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of the Indigenous People, known as UNDRIP.
00:12:01 There was another case in British Columbia that came out earlier this month in August, August 9th.
00:12:06 This is from the CBC.
00:12:06 The Okanagan Falls may need to change its name in order to become BC's newest municipality.
00:12:13 So basically, according to UNDRIP, one of the things that it requires is that First Nations have the right to designate and name their own communities, places and people.
00:12:24 And so because of this, Okanagan Falls may have to rename.
00:12:28 I mean, we've seen a lot of this, John, in British Columbia where places have had to rename.
00:12:33 Look, I grew up in BC.
00:12:34 Back when I grew up, we used to call it the Queen Charlotte Islands.
00:12:37 I know it's Haida Gwaii now, technically.
00:12:39 But we see these kinds of stories all the time, including recently Trutch Street in Vancouver was given a new name that I wouldn't even try to pronounce because I think it's unpronounceable.
00:12:47 What do you make of these changes and what do you make of UNDRIP more broadly?
00:12:54 Well, as the Conservative Party of British Columbia, we are committed to repealing the DRIPA legislation, the Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous People Act.
00:13:01 It doesn't make sense.
00:13:03 Any legislation that gives rights to one group of people over another will never end well because ultimately it creates friction.
00:13:12 It creates resentment.
00:13:13 It is the opposite of reconciliation, and reconciliation should be the goal of what we're trying to do.
00:13:19 So DRIPA is something that we would repeal and remove in British Columbia to get away from this case, for example.
00:13:26 That could happen in the Okanagan Falls area.
00:13:29 The other piece, though, is there are values in UNDRIP that are worth using when we work with First Nations as a guiding principle, but that's what it should be.
00:13:37 It shouldn't be legislation and using it as this hammer.
00:13:42 So I think, you know, I don't have a problem with renaming, you know, for example, the Seedish Sea or Haida Gwaii, these types of things.
00:13:51 But when it comes to, you know, many other things, look, we need to make, we need to understand that in British Columbia, Indigenous people are somewhere between four and five percent of the population.
00:14:01 And we need to be able to respect rights, but we also need to be able to respect the rights of all British Columbians.
00:14:07 And we're all Canadians.
00:14:09 So we need to make sure that what we are doing is reflecting all of us in terms of our true history and, quite frankly, what our future needs to be.
00:14:18 Look, I want to push back just a little bit about the renaming.
00:14:22 Like, I understand that, obviously, British Columbia was inhabited before the Europeans came and that some of the names come from Indigenous words.
00:14:30 I mean, even Okanagan, it's not an English word, right?
00:14:33 It's clearly derived from a different language.
00:14:36 But what I see often now, John, it almost feels like it's deliberately confusing to people that you cannot pronounce the words.
00:14:45 It's not written in an alphabet that's recognizable.
00:14:48 And so with the case of Trutch Street getting renamed and then the signs that were unveiled, you can imagine in an emergency situation someone's trying to call for help and they can't pronounce the words.
00:14:57 And it seems to me that that is done intentionally to confuse or to alienate people.
00:15:02 And I just don't understand why they have to introduce a new alphabet.
00:15:06 English and French are the official languages of Canada.
00:15:09 So why would you rename streets and cities and places into words with an alphabet that we don't recognize?
00:15:16 Yeah, you know, the interesting thing is when it comes to Indigenous languages in British Columbia, we've got, I think, it's 64 different dialects, 32 different languages with Indigenous people.
00:15:27 So they didn't have a written language.
00:15:31 And so when they're trying to translate how to pronounce words that cannot be easily spelt in the English language or the English dialect, they're trying to figure out how do you actually spell that.
00:15:45 So they've tried to come up with an alphabet that is English, is what we use, but it also is supplemented to reflect the sounds that they use as part of their naming.
00:16:00 So you're right.
00:16:02 There needs to be clear cases where something like that can work and something that makes sense and some cases where it doesn't.
00:16:09 A street name, you know, for example, if the street name is on a reserve, in that type of thing, in many places around the province, it has a First Nations name.
00:16:23 If you're talking about, you know, Main Street down the middle of a city, really is that kind of what you would need to be doing with the names?
00:16:30 But, you know, in terms of a street that might be directly attached with First Nations territory within a First Nations reserve, I don't have a problem with that kind of a sort of name changing.
00:16:41 Now, there is some issues.
00:16:43 Yeah, there's no question there's going to be issues in terms of it.
00:16:46 But that's part of what we need to be thinking about also in terms of reconciliation.
00:16:50 And I'll just give you an example from my home community, Prince George.
00:16:53 I was born and raised in Prince George.
00:16:55 There was a park that was there.
00:16:57 It was called Fort George Park.
00:16:58 Well, that used to be a Claytonay community.
00:17:04 And they were forced out of that community and relocated to a community further upriver.
00:17:10 And so when it came to looking at reconciliation, they made a decision, the city made a decision to rename that park Claytonay Park.
00:17:18 And there was a whole bunch of people that were opposed to it and concerned about it.
00:17:24 Why would we do this?
00:17:25 Until they learned the history.
00:17:26 And then they went, oh, okay, wait a second here.
00:17:28 Maybe this makes sense.
00:17:30 And so, you know, reconciliation is not an easy path to be walked.
00:17:36 But once again, when you look at it, you've got to think, how does this impact people on a day-to-day life?
00:17:40 In particular, this is why the private property infrastructure, why those sort of issues are such a big issue.
00:17:46 Because now you're talking about seriously impacting people's day-to-day lives and building their future.
00:17:53 Yeah, well, you certainly raise a good point about reconciliation and the idea is, you know, creating a future where we can live and coexist in peace.
00:18:01 But sometimes you see things in the news and online, John, make you concerned about whether we're actually heading in that direction.
00:18:08 And this was something that I posted on social media.
00:18:12 The Adams Lake Indian Band put up a sign recently that said, no trespassing, no illegal activities, and no settlers.
00:18:19 And I see that as very inflammatory language.
00:18:23 And saying that certain people, based on their skin color or their heritage, are not allowed in other parts of the province or of their community.
00:18:33 I mean, that's concerning.
00:18:34 Look, I spent some time in high school in Campbell River.
00:18:37 And sometimes we'd go on to the Native Reserves to visit friends or meet up with people or, you know, just to drop by and say hi to someone.
00:18:44 And the fact that they would erect a sign like this in Adams Lake saying, no settlers, I don't know how strictly that's enforced.
00:18:50 But it's a sign that, when I saw it, made me feel really uncomfortable.
00:18:53 I wonder if you can comment on that.
00:18:55 Yeah, I agree.
00:18:55 It makes me really feel really uncomfortable.
00:18:57 It's the opposite of what reconciliation should be.
00:19:00 It just is.
00:19:02 You know, we need to recognize that this is Canada.
00:19:04 And even though, you know, Indigenous people might have been here for 10,000 years, they still have came here from somewhere else. 0.99
00:19:11 Just like everybody in this country, they came here from somewhere else. 1.00
00:19:15 And we need to recognize what we've built as a country.
00:19:17 And I think the other thing is we need to understand Canada's history.
00:19:21 I mean, if Canada wasn't here as a country, what would have happened?
00:19:25 The Americans probably would have come up here and done the same thing that they did in their country, 0.78
00:19:30 which is declare them a sovereign nation, bring in the army, attack them, wipe them out, and conquer the area.
00:19:36 And so Canada, in a way, is the whole reason why many First Nations rights have even been protected and exist today.
00:19:45 And so this is why we need to think about this as Canada and British Columbia.
00:19:49 And we need to understand that this is part of reconciliation, how we bring this together and have that understanding.
00:19:56 Because there's resentment, there's issues on both sides of the border, or both sides of the issue.
00:20:01 I looked at, for example, in the Okanagan, there's a beach in the Okanagan that is beside a First Nations reserve.
00:20:08 And there's a sign on the beach saying, Indians only.
00:20:14 And I looked at that, and that's hugely offensive to me, that it's a public beach, that the foreshore is crown land.
00:20:23 It's not owned by an indigenous band.
00:20:26 And to put up a sign like that, first of all, I mean, it's racist.
00:20:29 But second of all, it has that potential, that connotation about, you know, one group versus another.
00:20:37 I thought the whole idea is that we're Canadians, and we're trying to find a way to reconcile and to become one.
00:20:43 But this is also a huge problem with our Constitution.
00:20:45 Like, our Constitution has created many of these problems and issues we have today.
00:20:50 When the Constitution came in 1982, and we had Section 35, which is what has enshrined indigenous rights, which includes title,
00:20:58 it was defined at the time as being this empty vessel of law that the courts would fill.
00:21:03 Well, I think what we're seeing now, particularly with this case now with the Cowichan,
00:21:07 and what we've seen through this is maybe that has gone a little too far.
00:21:12 Maybe we need to be rethinking how to address this to be able to make sure that we recognize and respect
00:21:19 and reconcile the indigenous people, the people that were here before us,
00:21:24 but also the rights of all Canadians and how those things come together.
00:21:29 Well, I think that would be a much better path forward to focus on the positive things,
00:21:34 the friendships, the treaties, the partnerships that were formed between the early Canadians
00:21:38 and the First Nations instead of dwelling so much on the things that we've focused on.
00:21:44 Okay, John, I want to move on a little bit to talk about your opponent, David Eby,
00:21:48 and his record in government, so B.C.'s debt has been skyrocketing in the first two years.
00:21:53 This is in the Vancouver Sun, basically saying that they have increased provincial debt by almost 50%
00:21:58 in almost two years, just two years in office.
00:22:02 Eby inherited provincial debt of $89 billion a year,
00:22:05 and at the end of its first year, it had soared to $133, up $44 billion.
00:22:10 What would you do differently?
00:22:11 Well, this has been absolute insane spending by this government,
00:22:16 especially when it comes to the operating from the actual budget as opposed to the capital side.
00:22:25 And so they've gone from what was about a $5 billion or $6 billion surplus
00:22:29 to what a lot of people are estimating saying it would be an $18 billion deficit in just over two years.
00:22:36 How do you destroy the finances of this province so quickly and have nothing to show for it?
00:22:44 Nobody can point to anything in this province that is better under the NDP.
00:22:48 Anything, whether it's crime, whether it's drugs, whether it's housing,
00:22:51 whether it's affordability, whether it's our economy, nothing is improving.
00:22:55 And so it really makes you wonder how and where they're spending this money.
00:22:59 And you look at our capital, yes, we need to invest in roads,
00:23:02 and we have to invest in hospitals and schools.
00:23:04 The budget, the amount of capital that is allocated this year for capital projects
00:23:12 is the equivalent of all the cost overruns on the projects that they're running.
00:23:18 So this has been just incompetence in terms of how they're actually getting projects done
00:23:23 and the way they spend money.
00:23:26 And there isn't a single thing.
00:23:27 They've been in power for eight years now, not going on the ninth year.
00:23:31 There isn't a single project that's actually completed in terms of highways or bridges or anything like that.
00:23:35 Everything is still a work in progress.
00:23:38 And you look at it and think, how could this be that nothing could have gotten done over that period of time?
00:23:43 Well, you mentioned crime, and we have some statistics here.
00:23:46 Violent offenders in BC, why can't it catch and release bails, are failing.
00:23:50 So Vancouver recorded 6,256 violent crimes in 2023, including 4,900 assaults,
00:23:56 a rise of 451 incidents compared to 2019.
00:23:59 The data shows that basically these policies where they can't keep bad guys behind bars
00:24:05 is obviously failing all Canadians, and particularly in British Columbia.
00:24:10 So I'm wondering if you can comment on, again, the crime rules and what you would do differently.
00:24:15 So in this province, for whatever reason, the judges and our Crown prosecution have decided
00:24:21 they don't want to put people in jail.
00:24:23 We've got, for example, this Youth Correction Centre that I've heard from.
00:24:28 They have a capacity of 46 people.
00:24:30 They have typically between four and six people in there with that capacity.
00:24:35 So you kind of look at it and you think, well, we're not committing less crime.
00:24:39 How is it that we're not utilizing these facilities for what they need to be used for?
00:24:43 We need some significant change in British Columbia, and I think quite frankly,
00:24:47 likely in Canada, but certainly in British Columbia, when it comes to dealing with crime.
00:24:51 And the approach that we're going to take on it is, first of all,
00:24:54 we're going to push for guaranteed minimum sentencing.
00:24:56 And this is especially targeted at these prolific offenders.
00:25:01 The police tell me that 70% of the crime is being committed by 30% of the criminals.
00:25:06 And so when you look at that, there are so many of these people that should be behind bars.
00:25:13 And we just, we seem to be treating them all like they're the same.
00:25:16 Like they might be 30, 50, 100 different infractions, interactions with the police,
00:25:22 and yet they're still out on the streets.
00:25:23 And so what we'll do, we'll push for guaranteed minimum sentencing.
00:25:26 We've got to push for bail reform.
00:25:28 Those are federal.
00:25:30 And so we need to be pushing for those.
00:25:31 But what we can do in provincially is we can actually use the Mental Health Act if we had to.
00:25:37 And so we want to change the court system so that there's a streamlined process for these
00:25:42 prolific offenders.
00:25:42 They get into the courts immediately instead of having to wait, you know, a year or two years
00:25:46 or sometimes getting thrown out because they don't have the ability to get to court.
00:25:50 We've got to do that.
00:25:51 But where we have these prolific offenders, particularly these prolific violent offenders,
00:25:55 if the courts will not put them behind bars where they need to be, then we're going to
00:25:59 have to look at using things like the Mental Health Act because that's the only tool we
00:26:03 have as a province.
00:26:04 So if somebody is at risk of harming themselves or others, they can be held and treated and
00:26:10 not released until they're no longer a risk.
00:26:13 And we might have to start looking at that.
00:26:15 And here's, he'll become the rub.
00:26:16 Of course, there'll be a Section 7 challenge from the Charter because you're taking away
00:26:20 their rights.
00:26:21 And we may have to use the Notwithstanding Clause if need be because we need to get these
00:26:25 people off our streets enough, enough of protecting the criminals' rights.
00:26:31 We need to start protecting the citizens' rights so that they can be safe once again in our streets.
00:26:36 A hundred percent.
00:26:37 And honestly, I think it's a compassionate thing to do because so many of the people that
00:26:40 you see on the streets suffering out in the open using drugs, they also have mental health
00:26:45 issues.
00:26:46 And that's something that's sort of often ignored by the progressive side of things.
00:26:51 John, I know you are undergoing a leadership review for your party, which wraps up in September.
00:26:55 And then you have an AGM that is coming up in the fall.
00:26:59 So I'm wondering if you could tell us a little bit about that process.
00:27:02 Sure.
00:27:02 Well, actually, the AGM is not out for a little while here yet.
00:27:06 But yes, the leadership process is going on throughout the province.
00:27:09 And this is standard for any political party in terms of a leadership review that needs
00:27:14 to be done.
00:27:15 Our old constitution said that every year there had to be a leadership review, regardless
00:27:19 of whatever the circumstance was, and it was to be done online where people got a chance
00:27:23 to vote by email or whatever the case may be.
00:27:25 We looked at it and went, that's not really a very, first of all, it's not stability, but
00:27:31 it's not a right way to do it.
00:27:33 And so we decided we would give people an in-person opportunity to vote as to whether
00:27:39 or not they like the leadership of the party and they like the pledge that I've put forward
00:27:44 in terms of our priorities as a party and as a leader.
00:27:49 And we'll see how that process goes.
00:27:51 But I've been touring throughout the province and been meeting with members right across
00:27:55 British Columbia and people are quite happy with what we're doing.
00:27:59 They like the direction that we're going.
00:28:01 Most people are likely, certainly, you know, wish we had won the last election.
00:28:06 It was 257 votes away from us being government as opposed to them being government.
00:28:11 It was that tight an election.
00:28:13 But yeah, so the process is ongoing.
00:28:15 We'll know by the end of September what the will of the members of the party is.
00:28:21 Great.
00:28:21 Well, we look forward to having you back and hopefully you can tell us more about the update
00:28:26 from the AGM and continue.
00:28:29 I mean, it's wild how close that election was in B.C.
00:28:32 Reminds you folks how important it is to get out there and vote.
00:28:35 That's John Rudd said, leader of the B.C. Conservative Party.
00:28:38 Thank you for your time.
00:28:39 All right, folks, thanks so much for tuning in.
00:28:40 We'll be back again tomorrow.
00:28:41 I'm Candace Malcolm.
00:28:42 This is the Candace Malcolm Show.
00:28:43 Thank you and God bless.
00:28:44 We'll be back again tomorrow.