The Candice Malcolm Show - June 01, 2022


Rupa Subramanya joins True North!

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Covid has torn apart our social fabric (Feat. Dr. Matt Strauss) Trudeau’s Wokest Week (Ft. Andrew Lawton)

Episode Stats


Length

33 minutes

Words per minute

191.42

Word count

6,351

Sentence count

300

Harmful content

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

10

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Rupa Subramania joins The Candice Malala Show to discuss her new role as a columnist at the National Post and a podcast host at the True North Centre. She's also a distinguished fellow with the Asia Pacific Foundation of Canada and a regular contributor to the Wall Street Journal and Foreign Policy Magazine.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 True North continues to knock it out of the park. We have doubled in size over the past year. We now
00:00:04 reach over 10 million Canadians each and every month across our platforms. Our stories are being
00:00:09 picked up by our competitors in the legacy media. We're having a real influence on politics and
00:00:14 public policy in this country and we're helping to shape the political culture in Canada. Today
00:00:20 I'm very excited to share some big news with our audience. I'm Candice Malcolm and this is The
00:00:24 Candice Malcolm Show. Everyone thank you so much for tuning in. So today I am delighted to announce
00:00:41 that True North has hired one of the brightest journalists in the country, a rising star in
00:00:47 conservative political circles. I'm proud to announce that Rupa Subramania will be joining
00:00:51 True North as a columnist and a podcast host and Rupa joins me on the show today. So Rupa,
00:00:57 thank you so much for being here. Thank you so much, Candice. I'm truly excited to be part of the
00:01:03 True North Center team and I'm really excited about my show and I have lots of good things coming up,
00:01:11 lots of great topics and ideas and guests and I'm really looking forward to tackling the important
00:01:17 issues of the day that matter to us as Canadians and hopefully issues that nobody in the mainstream
00:01:25 media wants to touch or they give short shrift to these ideas and I hope to take them on head on and
00:01:31 have meaningful discussions with my guests and so I'm really, really excited about this.
00:01:37 Well, we feel very lucky to have you and it's been great to connect with you over the past few months.
00:01:42 For people who aren't completely familiar with you, Rupa is also a columnist over at the National
00:01:47 Post. She's written for the Wall Street Journal, Foreign Policy Magazine. She's a distinguished fellow
00:01:52 with the Asia Pacific Foundation of Canada. Rupa, you live in Ottawa and I think a lot of Canadians
00:01:57 came to know you and came to see your journalism firsthand during the trucker convoy because you were
00:02:03 doing something that your colleagues in the media failed to do which was just go out and talk to the
00:02:08 truckers and get to know them and try to understand what was motivating them and what they were there
00:02:12 for and what it was all about and it seemed really like basic, basic journalism but no one else was
00:02:18 willing to do it. Instead, they were all too happy to just sort of parrot Justin Trudeau's
00:02:22 dismissals of the truckers and his criticisms of them. You know, some of the most interesting things
00:02:29 that we heard was that, oh, these truckers are a bunch of racist white supremacists and here you are 0.91
00:02:35 as an Indian woman and you said that you felt safe and comfortable and that people were nice and kind 0.98
00:02:40 and welcoming. You didn't see any of those kind of attitudes that the media were trying to tell us
00:02:44 about the truckers. So you really did outstanding work. I'm wondering if you could just sort of tell
00:02:49 us about why you approached the trucker convoy so differently than everybody else in the media or so
00:02:56 many other people in the media in Ottawa. Well, several different things. So I approached it as a
00:03:01 resident of the city, as someone who was just very curious about what was happening in my neighborhood
00:03:07 and I had heard about the convoy before it even arrived. I'd heard about, you know, I'd read about
00:03:14 some of the key players and that and what Justin Trudeau said about the unvaccinated and the protesters.
00:03:21 So I was aware of all of this, the narrative that was already in place before the protesters even showed
00:03:27 up and I was just really intellectually curious to see what was happening in Ottawa. So I walked around
00:03:32 and I spent about eight or nine hours that day in the bitter cold and I saw something
00:03:40 extraordinary. I saw people, you know, it was people of different backgrounds. It was like Canada Day
00:03:48 in the winter. It felt like a winter carnival. And I, you know, I saw some diversity in the crowds as
00:03:57 well. And it was just a very, very, you know, it was a joy. It was, it was joyous. This, it was,
00:04:06 it was almost cathartic for a lot of people to be there. People who, you know, we've been under,
00:04:11 we'd been under a lockdown for two years, under restrictions for two years where, you know,
00:04:15 many of us couldn't even see our loved ones. And suddenly there was this explosion of emotions
00:04:21 right here in the nation's capital and that too, in some very, very cold conditions. And that to me
00:04:29 indicated that, you know, people were there because they were really committed to the cause.
00:04:34 They were really dedicated to it and they really believed in it and they were willing to spend
00:04:38 hours on end to make their voices heard. And by, by the end of that, I, you know, I, I came home and I,
00:04:46 you know, I, and I, and I tweeted saying, you know, I think the elites in this country, the political
00:04:51 establishment, the media establishment have really misjudged what is happening here. This is much
00:04:55 bigger than anything anyone expected. It was bigger than anything I had expected. So for me, it was
00:05:01 an eye-opening experience. And, and also what was interesting was that, that first weekend, I got a lot
00:05:09 of messages from some, some of my journalist friends who work for very well-known publications,
00:05:14 including the New York Times, the Wall Street Journal, the Financial Times, and they were, they,
00:05:19 they were trying to understand what was happening in Ottawa. They asked me, why is there no actual
00:05:25 on-the-ground reportage of what is happening in Ottawa? It seems pretty big, but all we keep hearing
00:05:30 is that there are a bunch of white supremacists and they're being caricatured. Where are the stories?
00:05:35 Where's the actual on-the-ground reportage? And, and I was, you know, really struck by that question
00:05:41 because everything that we had, uh, that was being reported on, if you can even call it, that was
00:05:47 just someone's opinion, you know, or just, uh, uh, just, just talking from, uh, just directly from
00:05:54 the, uh, Justin Trudeau's talking points. And, but yet there were all of these people with very
00:06:01 interesting stories that come, uh, they, they, they, they driven long hours to get to the city.
00:06:06 Um, they were there in the cold. They were, uh, and keep in mind that, um, Ottawa was still under a
00:06:13 semi-lockdown at that point. And by the end of the first weekend, the Rideau Center closed, there were
00:06:18 no washroom facilities anywhere. Uh, you know, people literally were just out there all day. Uh, you
00:06:24 couldn't eat anywhere. You couldn't grab, uh, you know, the only two things that were open were the
00:06:30 McDonald's and the Tim Hortons. So there was really nothing you could do except be there to make your
00:06:35 voice heard. And, um, and so, you know, it just kept getting bigger and bigger and bigger. And I felt
00:06:42 that the best way to tackle, so I started tweeting the best way to tackle this corrosive narrative.
00:06:47 And I really thought it was a very corrosive narrative that was, that was, that was, uh, being pushed by,
00:06:53 uh, you know, some, some important journalists and large sections of the media. And of course,
00:06:58 the, the political establishment as well is that I thought I would tackle it in a humorous way. I'd be,
00:07:04 you know, that I wanted to be sarcastic about it because there was no other way of taking it on.
00:07:08 Um, you know, I couldn't be serious about it. I just had to be, I had to, you know, mock the
00:07:14 situation and that's exactly what I did. So here I am a person of color. I'm walking around,
00:07:19 you know, and I'm walking in the badlands of Ottawa. That's, that's how I, um, described Ottawa
00:07:24 to my, to my, uh, you know, while tweeting and that here I was being mobbed by people wanting
00:07:30 to give me a hug and they were handing out food and I felt very threatened. And, uh, and I was just
00:07:36 being, you know, ironic about the whole situation. And, uh, and at first I think people were a little
00:07:41 confused because sarcasm doesn't always translate well on, on social media. Uh, but then people started
00:07:46 to get an idea of where I was coming from. You know, I said, wow, you know, this is, you know,
00:07:50 I'm, I'm really, um, stunned by this, but you know, you know, you know, first people from Montreal
00:07:55 are coming to Ottawa to party. And that's exactly what was happening. Um, uh, Ottawa became, um,
00:08:01 this destination to, to party, but at the same time, you, you, you, you know, you were also protesting.
00:08:06 You were also exercising your right to civil disobedience. And, uh, um, and, and so all of those
00:08:12 things were happening. So I, my tweets got a lot of traction. I think it resonated with a lot of
00:08:17 people because, you know, I was, I was saying something, something that was different. It felt
00:08:22 like I was in an alternate reality from, from what was being reported on by large sections of the
00:08:27 media. I, uh, um, you know, what I was experiencing there was completely at odds with, at odds with what
00:08:33 was being reported. And, and that was the reaction of many of the protesters themselves. You know,
00:08:38 they, you know, they, they tune into, um, your, you know, whatever it was, the CBC, the CTV,
00:08:45 CTV, and, uh, and, and they would, they would, they would find that the reporting of it was, uh,
00:08:50 at complete odds with what they'd experienced, especially this, this was especially a strong
00:08:55 feeling among people of color that I had interviewed. You know, they couldn't believe that
00:08:59 they were, um, somehow, you know, that, that they were being, uh, that it was the, that they were
00:09:04 being told that they were part of some white supremacist movement when, when, you know,
00:09:08 they experienced something totally different. Um, so I felt that I felt at that point and I've
00:09:13 been, I, you know, I've tracked media propaganda for a very long time in various countries. I knew
00:09:18 exactly what was going on here. And, um, I knew, I knew that this, you know, what was happening here
00:09:23 was rather insidious and I wanted to, um, you know, put a, put a correction to it. And, uh, and that's
00:09:32 exactly, I think what I did by, by tweeting about it. And then I was asked to write about it and,
00:09:38 uh, and I'm glad I did because I think that was an important contribution to what was being said out
00:09:42 there and, uh, um, and, and it challenged that, that, that, uh, that narrative, uh, I think in a
00:09:50 substantial way. And I was happy to play my, my, my role in that.
00:09:54 Well, good for you. And absolutely that, that piece that you wrote for Barry Weiss and her
00:09:58 sub stack, uh, was absolutely must read, uh, essential reading for anyone who wanted to really
00:10:04 understand the trucker convoy. And I've said this on the show before, but the photographs that
00:10:08 accompanied your piece were just absolutely stunning and beautiful. And I think that the
00:10:12 whole thing was incredibly well done. Uh, well, Rupa, I, I, I wonder, because to me, the, I am
00:10:19 similar. I've been monitoring the, uh, Canadian media, uh, for a very long time and I've had criticisms
00:10:25 about them for a very long time. It seems to me that every time there's new, new story or a new
00:10:30 narrative that comes up, they sort of ratchet it up more and more. And the trucker convoy was like
00:10:36 peak Laurentian elite biased media. Like they had no interest in telling the story. They only had an
00:10:42 interest in pushing the narrative that they, that they previously decided on. And, and, and to so many
00:10:47 people, to your point that that was a turning point for them because they saw on social media or
00:10:52 with their own eyes in Ottawa, what was happening. And then you juxtapose that with the very, very
00:10:58 inflammatory things the prime minister was saying, which was being backed up by a very, sorry, uh,
00:11:03 loyal servitude press. And, and, and it was really quite something. I, I want to ask you though,
00:11:10 you know, you, you, you sort of work, you sort of have a foot in both, um, uh, in both ponds with
00:11:15 independent media now and, uh, legacy media and you're a freelance journalist and you've written for
00:11:20 all of these incredibly prestigious publications. Um, so what, what, what are your thoughts on the
00:11:26 current, uh, legacy media and what do you think about the sort of new upstart, um, environment
00:11:31 where there's a whole bunch of new sort of either independent people doing subsects like Barry Weiss
00:11:36 or in, uh, independent media organizations that, that stay removed from government, uh, like True
00:11:41 North. I think it's a very exciting time to be an independent voice, uh, because I think the
00:11:47 public is starting to see, um, the, the, uh, you know, they're starting to see what, what's happening.
00:11:53 Uh, and I have these conversations with a range of different people, um, um, who were, uh, you know,
00:11:59 they, they wouldn't, um, they would only believe what was said on the CBC or, or, or, or, or on a
00:12:05 mainstream, uh, outlet. And that's starting to change. They're starting to see what is going on here
00:12:12 because some of some, some of what is being said is at complete odds with what they themselves are
00:12:17 experiencing, just like with the protesters at the freedom convoy. And even if you were not here
00:12:22 protesting, um, a lot of people sought through the propaganda and, and started questioning it. Um,
00:12:30 and I'm, I'm seeing, so I think this is a very exciting time for independent voices to make their
00:12:34 mark. Um, um, and, um, and as far as the legacy media is concerned, as far as the established media is
00:12:41 concerned, I think, um, I think they're going to have to, uh, start taking note. Uh, you know,
00:12:47 my piece for Barry Wise probably resonated more than anything that was written in, uh, in the Canadian
00:12:54 media, in Canadian media. I, I, I, I think it was, um, um, um, there's a space for that, for that,
00:13:01 for that kind of reportage. There's clearly a market for that kind of reportage. Uh, uh, there's a market
00:13:06 for alternate opinions, I think. Um, and like I mentioned, the public is just very, uh,
00:13:11 starting to see through this and, uh, and, uh, and our craving for something that is different.
00:13:15 Um, and, uh, and I think, uh, and I think the mainstream media justifiably feels very threatened
00:13:22 by what is happening in the independent media space. Uh, and, and just as well, you know,
00:13:26 because I think competition is good. Uh, I think, uh, plurality of, uh, different voices is better than
00:13:33 just one, uh, uh, hegemonic, um, uh, narrative that is in place thanks to, um, you know, state-funded,
00:13:40 uh, media organizations. I think it's very important, um, what, uh, independent media is
00:13:45 doing, and I'm so grateful for, uh, the True North Center, uh, and, um, media outlets, um, like
00:13:52 the True North Center for what they're doing, because if not for them, uh, you, you, you'd just
00:13:57 be fed on this constant, you, uh, you know, it's constant propaganda and, uh, it's, it's not entirely
00:14:03 a hundred percent propaganda. Of course, there's some genuine bona fide reporting from the mainstream
00:14:08 media establishment. It's just that when it, I've, I've noticed that when it comes to polarizing
00:14:12 issues, whether it is reporting on the COVID-19 pandemic or is, or it's the protests, um, there
00:14:19 seems to be an agenda at play and, uh, and it's a clear agenda, uh, at work that wants to project a
00:14:26 certain kind of narrative. And, uh, and that is where it gets very problematic for me. Um, I, and
00:14:33 the media is a large space. Let me put, let me make that very clear. I write for the National Post.
00:14:37 They're incredibly supportive, uh, of my opinions. They're, um, you know, I, I, you know, I have a great
00:14:42 platform with them. And so it's not, so, you know, when I, when I say the media, you know, we, we have to be
00:14:48 very careful because there are, there are players in the, in the mainstream media establishment like
00:14:53 the National Post, for example, that do, um, good work. And I'm not just saying that because I write
00:14:59 for them, but I genuinely feel that they're the only ones who, uh, give me a voice, uh, give me a
00:15:04 platform. And, uh, and that's important to recognize as well. Uh, but like I said, competition is good. Uh,
00:15:10 we really need to have a contestation of ideas. Um, and this is where the independent media outlets play,
00:15:17 um, uh, uh, uh, a very important role. Yeah, it's interesting. I mean, the National Post hosts
00:15:23 some of the most fantastic thinkers in Canada, people like yourself, Rex Murphy, Barbara Kay,
00:15:28 Conrad Black. Uh, but then they're also part of the post media chain, which often picks up,
00:15:33 uh, Canadian press news stories where you get the sort of same regurgitated, uh, insider sort of
00:15:39 perspective, which, which is, is, you know, it's unfortunate. There's obviously bigger issues at
00:15:43 play, uh, with the legacy media. Rufa, one of the things I've noticed recently is that some of
00:15:49 the better sort of reporting and opinion pieces on Canada and specifically on Justin Trudeau
00:15:55 come from abroad. Um, you know, we had during the tracker convoy, the New York times, uh, reporting
00:16:01 on things that, that several times legacy media journalists, people like Rosemary Barton at the
00:16:05 CBC, uh, would, were openly criticizing and telling the New York times to take this down because
00:16:09 it's, it's wrong. Well, it wasn't wrong. It just didn't fit with the Trudeau narrative. Uh, you
00:16:14 know, the idea that they were breaking into vehicles and arresting people at gunpoint, that
00:16:17 was sort of like an inconvenient story that, that, um, the Canadian media didn't want. Uh,
00:16:21 one of the other things I've noticed is a sort of disconnect between, so in Canada, if, if you say
00:16:27 that Justin Trudeau is acting like a dictator or that Canada is going down a tyrannical or authoritarian
00:16:32 path, uh, the media sort of like clutch their pearls and say like, that's reckless and, and, uh,
00:16:38 you know, hyperbolic, how dare you? Uh, more and more, we're hearing that opinion, um, being
00:16:44 taken from people around the world, outside observers, uh, people who are critical of,
00:16:48 of Trudeau. And, uh, I saw that you shared a piece by a Rav Arora, who's a great young
00:16:54 writer from Vancouver. He wrote a piece in the New York post, um, titled once a liberal
00:16:58 democracy, Canada is now an authoritarian state. So it's a great piece. I encourage reader, uh,
00:17:04 viewers to go out and read it. Uh, Rav argues that Canadian government has taken away,
00:17:08 has taken its power to extreme levels. He tells a story about how he almost wasn't allowed back
00:17:12 into Canada, um, despite, um, you know, being a Canadian. And, um, he, he, he also makes a point
00:17:18 saying that, you know, his family left India when he was a child and he feels that, you know, Canada
00:17:23 is not necessarily more free than India. Um, I'm wondering, uh, if you, if you can give us your,
00:17:28 your thoughts on, on Rav's piece and, and sort of generally that direction that not only is Canada
00:17:34 heading towards this direction, but you don't see these kinds of, uh, opinion pieces much in
00:17:38 Canada, increasingly you are seeing them around the world though. Uh, exactly. I, uh, very much
00:17:43 enjoyed Rav's piece and I shared it. Um, um, um, you know, I shared a very, uh, important quote from
00:17:49 the tweet where he says that, you know, the, the country that my parents left behind India, um, you
00:17:54 know, seems a lot less authoritarian than Canada at this point, because he's unvaccinated and he can't 1.00
00:18:00 get on a plane and, uh, and he's essentially a prisoner in his own country. I think that's, um,
00:18:05 I, you know, I'm very, um, uh, sympathetic to that point of view. Um, I, I, I, you know,
00:18:11 I know a lot of unvaccinated people and they're really struggling. It's, um, in Canada is an outlier
00:18:17 in this regard. Um, uh, India country that I'm also very familiar with having spent a lot of time
00:18:23 there has no vaccine mandates, uh, in place. In fact, the Supreme court of India said that vaccine
00:18:28 mandates, um, were, uh, were unconstitutional and, uh, in a, in a recent ruling, um, and, uh, that,
00:18:36 um, you know, you can't, uh, and, and, uh, and, uh, emphasized on the importance of bodily autonomy.
00:18:43 Uh, it was an extraordinary ruling and, um, and it makes, made me question why, uh, you know,
00:18:49 what is happening with our courts here? You know, why aren't we seeing this kind of, um, uh, you know,
00:18:54 why aren't we seeing this sort of thing happening here? Uh, and, and, and, and, and so a lot of
00:18:59 people like Rav, you know, feel that the country that they grew up in, and I, I will say this as
00:19:05 someone who spent, um, 25 years, uh, you know, I came here as a teenager and I've been, you know,
00:19:11 and I've been here for, uh, for, for a long time. And I can tell you that I don't recognize this
00:19:17 country anymore. I don't, I don't, I don't, um, uh, recognize what, you know, I don't understand
00:19:22 what is happening here. I don't know why Canada is an outlier here. Of course, there are problems
00:19:27 with India. I wouldn't say that, uh, you know, India is necessarily freer than Canada. I think
00:19:33 that would be a little bit of an exaggeration if one were to say that, but one can certainly point
00:19:37 to the fact that, um, Canada is heading in the wrong direction. It is an outlier in the advanced
00:19:43 West. It is, it's an outlier among major countries in insisting on, um, vaccine mandates on the two
00:19:50 dose, uh, vaccine mandate, which makes absolutely no sense. You have, um, uh, research, uh, upon
00:19:57 research coming up from various credible, uh, health agencies from across the world, whether
00:20:01 it's the CDC, whether it's the UK, uh, or it's the UK health authority, uh, or UK health agency
00:20:07 that show that the two dose vaccine, uh, regimen is actually not very effective at this point
00:20:13 where if you've done two doses, um, you're, you're, you're really the vaccine effectiveness
00:20:19 has essentially gone down to zero. So, but, but the diff, but the thing is I can get on
00:20:24 a plane, uh, and I can, uh, apply for a federal government job, uh, but the unvaccinated can't. 1.00
00:20:30 And that's the, and that's what's, um, very cruel about the situation. Um, and, and, and also
00:20:37 we've, we've completely ignored the fact that, um, uh, a lot of unvaccinated people probably
00:20:42 have, um, a great deal of natural immunity at this point. At this point, everyone's more
00:20:47 or less been infected. And so you have, uh, immunity from vaccination and you also have
00:20:52 immunity from having recovered from COVID-19. Um, yet, yet the government insists on these
00:20:59 vaccine mandates, which absolutely make no sense. So I, I appreciate where he's coming
00:21:03 from, where Rav Aurora is coming from, and, um, I sympathize with it and it is an absolutely
00:21:09 frustrating situation to be in. Um, and, um, and, um, you know, I, uh, I, and he faced
00:21:15 a lot of pushback, um, on the piece. Um, in fact, I think a lot of people thought that
00:21:19 I was writing the piece. Um, uh, your, your, your tweet sort of went viral, you know, because,
00:21:26 because you're from India too, it kind of seemed like maybe you would have it, but, but yeah.
00:21:30 The reactions were, you know, borderline xenophobic, outright, you know, racist in, in a sense. Uh,
00:21:39 they, they thought that I'd written the piece or they thought that he had written or, or they
00:21:44 correctly assumed he wrote the piece and they told us to go back to India. If we felt, uh, that things
00:21:49 were so bad here, why are you here? Go back to India. Um, Rav's response was, well, I'd like to, 0.59
00:21:55 but I can't get on a plane. Um, uh, I think that was his response. And, uh, and honestly, that,
00:22:01 that kind of response is extremely xenophobic and problematic. And it comes from, um, the so-called
00:22:08 liberal left, you know, and, uh, because they're, they're supposed to be better than this, but,
00:22:14 you know, it doesn't take much to, uh, for, for these kinds of sentiments to, uh, to, to, to come out
00:22:20 as anytime I criticize Canada, I'm told that I, you know, I should just go back. Well, why should I?
00:22:25 I chose this country, you know, I chose to be here and I choose to remain here and I will, uh,
00:22:31 fight for what is right. And, uh, and, and that's really the best response you can give to such
00:22:36 people, but it was quite extraordinary the pushback because I think, I think, um, Rav, uh, touched a
00:22:43 nerve, um, um, and in a way that my piece, my piece did something similar. It touched a nerve. Um,
00:22:51 um, and I, and I, and I think, I, you know, I, I will quote this and I'm paraphrasing here, but the
00:22:56 New York times correspondent who, um, covered the protests, uh, for the New York times, uh, was I
00:23:02 think interviewed by Canada land shortly after. And, uh, and her parting shot was that, you know,
00:23:08 I don't think Canadians are used to seeing themselves in this manner. And I think that's,
00:23:13 that's, that's what's going on here. That, that explains the, um, the pushback that, uh, at least the
00:23:19 pushback that she was getting. And I think that really does sum up the pushback, um, describes the
00:23:24 pushback that Rav and I, uh, have been getting. Right. Well, I mean, what happened to the whole
00:23:29 Canadian is a Canadian is Canadian. In Rav's case, he moved to Canada when he was four years old. So
00:23:33 it's not like he, you know, it's not like he grew up in India and, and, and has a place to go back
00:23:37 there. It's like his family made this choice. And interestingly for him, you know, he's a, he's a young
00:23:42 guy. I think he's in his early twenties. And the reason that he didn't get vaccinated is because he got
00:23:47 COVID and he had natural immunity. So you're right. He probably has stronger immunity and a better
00:23:51 chance of being okay than, than, than most other people. Yeah. And that is the science. That is the
00:23:57 science. There is actual science there and we are completely ignoring it. And that is just very
00:24:04 perplexing. Like if I can go to Germany tomorrow and I can show a proof of, um, I can either show
00:24:10 proof of vaccination or proof of a negative COVID test or proof of recovery. A lot of European 0.96
00:24:14 countries accept proof of recovery. Uh, what makes us so special? Why are we so different
00:24:19 here? Uh, it's not just Canada, but it's also the U S. Um, and you know, then it leads to all
00:24:25 of these questions, you know, then it leads us into this rabbit hole of, uh, conspiracy theories.
00:24:30 You know, what is going on here? Is it the pharmaceutical companies? We bought all of these
00:24:34 vaccines. Maybe they're just, they just want to push this on us because they bought all of these
00:24:38 vaccines. I'd rather not go there. You know, I'd rather like take on the policy for what it is
00:24:43 and criticize it. But, um, but it is quite extraordinary that we, uh, are an outlier,
00:24:48 uh, in, in much of the world. And, uh, and we're just, it's, it's, uh, needlessly punishing,
00:24:54 uh, five or 6 million Canadians for, uh, making a medical decision.
00:25:00 Well, absolutely. And, and, and the bizarre decision this week for the federal government,
00:25:04 the liberal party and the NDP to extend these travel restrictions sort of indefinitely. It's like,
00:25:10 you know, we can't, we can't even at this point admit that most of these measures are no longer
00:25:16 necessary. Some of them were never necessary in the first place. It's like they're, they're completely
00:25:20 sort of stuck to that. I, I want to ask you this, Rupa, you recently wrote on some of the various
00:25:25 polls about Canadians, particularly new Canadians and new immigrants, how they're losing confidence
00:25:31 in Canada and the direction. And I think this is what you're talking about. Touched a nerve with a lot
00:25:34 of liberals is that, uh, well, the Leger poll commissioned by the Institute for Canadian
00:25:39 Citizenship found that 30% of new Canadians age 18 to 34. So they were more likely to move to
00:25:45 another country within the next two years. You know, Canada is a country that sort of prides itself
00:25:49 on, uh, being very welcoming to immigrants. Uh, all of the political parties are very pro immigration
00:25:56 and Canada is sort of held up as this country where pluralism works and immigration has been
00:26:01 successful. Um, and yet, you know, under this direction of all people, Justin Trudeau, the
00:26:06 person who sort of champions, um, diversity as our strength, he says it all the time. Um, and yet
00:26:11 under his leadership, especially young immigrants, which are the ones that really Canada wants to 1.00
00:26:17 recruit because they're the ones that help our economy and help us grow and help balance out the
00:26:20 aging population and the demographic crunch and all that kind of stuff. Increasingly, they don't want
00:26:25 to come to Canada. They want to live here. I think this creates a huge problem, uh, for Trudeau.
00:26:29 So why don't you tell us a little bit about your research and your reporting on this area?
00:26:34 Well, um, so I think, um, if I, if I remember correctly, uh, that poll, uh, talked about how
00:26:41 a lot of people were losing trust in the government. Uh, there was an increasing loss of trust in the
00:26:47 way government works and that there was a lack of democratic accountability, um, uh, um, that, that,
00:26:53 that people were generally feeling. Um, and that is very, um, interesting, uh, because, um, you know,
00:27:02 normally new immigrants, um, are not necessarily looking at these issues. Um, I would say they're, 1.00
00:27:08 they're, they're focused on the bread and butter issues. They're looking at the, you know, they're
00:27:13 looking at employment options. They want to send their kids to school. Um, they, they want to earn a
00:27:19 living. Uh, so the fact that they're focused on these other issues is quite extraordinary. Um,
00:27:26 and I think it is a general sense of malaise that everybody's been feeling, especially over the last
00:27:31 couple of years. Um, and, uh, and, and, uh, new immigrants are not, um, um, immune from that. Uh, 1.00
00:27:38 in fact, I would say that new immigrants have also, um, uh, probably, uh, been at the receiving end
00:27:44 of some of these, um, harsh, um, harsh restrictions, uh, whether it's the mandates. I, I, I, I've met a
00:27:50 few new immigrants who, uh, don't want to be vaccinated. Uh, and, and they have, they, you 1.00
00:27:56 know, so it affects them directly. Um, and, and just this, like, as I said, there's a general sense
00:28:01 of malaise, you know, where are we going here? You know, uh, and, and there's a lot of other stuff
00:28:06 going on here as well. New immigrants tend to be generally very conservative. I think new immigrants 1.00
00:28:11 probably, and I can't speak for all new immigrants, but generally conservative new immigrants are not
00:28:16 necessarily interested in wokeism. This is not something that they identify with. Um, if you tell,
00:28:22 um, a conservative new immigrant, uh, that, uh, a woman is not really a woman or that, uh, there is no
00:28:29 such thing as a woman, uh, they're going to be shocked at these kinds of views. And, uh, and I, I,
00:28:35 and, and so there's a cultural element to this. I conjecture, um, I don't have, um, data to back
00:28:41 this up, but I do think that there's a strong cultural component to the way, uh, new immigrants
00:28:45 feel about being in Canada because Canada in a sense has completely, um, you know, uh, bought into
00:28:53 this woke narrative more than any other country, maybe except for the United States. Um, but, uh,
00:29:00 certainly, you know, European countries, you know, there's a great deal of, um, you know,
00:29:05 there's a contestation of these, of these, of these narratives, uh, much more than, uh, what
00:29:10 we're seeing here. And, uh, so there's a strong cultural component, um, economic component. Sure.
00:29:17 Uh, new immigrants are always struggling to find jobs. Um, uh, the, the fact that they come here, 1.00
00:29:22 uh, highly skilled and can't, uh, translate those skills into, uh, meaningful employment here,
00:29:27 that continues to be an issue. I know the Ford government is working on changing that. Uh, but,
00:29:33 you know, there's still a lot of PhDs and doctors driving taxis. Um, so there is still an economic
00:29:39 component. It's still, it's, it still matters. Uh, but I think increasingly there's also a cultural
00:29:44 component to these, um, to these, uh, to these, uh, to, uh, to this general feeling of, uh, malaise
00:29:51 and that, you know, they're not happy being here. Absolutely. Well, another news story this week is
00:29:56 that the true government is decriminalizing drugs in British Columbia. I know that's one issue that,
00:30:01 uh, for, for my, uh, my husband's family is from Iran and that's something that they just really
00:30:06 can't wrap their head around, uh, just from like a human dignity perspective. Why is Canada allowing
00:30:11 people to use heroin and these other hard drugs? Uh, there's such, there's such a huge disconnect.
00:30:16 Um, and, and it is really interesting to see, uh, Trudeau. Uh, I, I, I think he's really jumping
00:30:21 the shark with so many of these issues where he's just so incredibly out of touch with the people he
00:30:26 reports to, to stand for. Well, Rupa, I, I can't, I can't tell you how excited we are to have you as
00:30:31 part of the team. It's such an honor. And I'm really looking forward to your, uh, your, your
00:30:36 contributions with us. Uh, tell us a little bit about your podcast, uh, what viewers can expect
00:30:41 and what kind of issues you're going to be diving into. Well, um, no, it's an honor, Candice. And I'm
00:30:47 so thrilled that I'm doing this for the True North Center. And I'm really excited about what,
00:30:52 what, what is going to come in the coming weeks and months. Um, and, uh, so first of all, I'm
00:30:58 going to be, um, it's going to be, uh, about 20 minutes or so, and we'll, uh, have, um, uh, you
00:31:04 know, I'll have a guest on, uh, and I'll obviously pick the topics and these are topics and ideas
00:31:10 that I care about. And so it, it, it, it's, it'll be similar to the kinds of things that I, uh, write
00:31:15 about, uh, but the difference being that we'll, we'll, we'll have more in-depth, uh, conversations, uh,
00:31:21 and, and, and also talk about things that I couldn't go into my column. Um, so it'll be
00:31:26 everything from all of the issues that we care about and the issues that don't necessarily
00:31:30 make it into mainstream media conversations. I think that is very important for me. I do want to
00:31:36 pay, you know, give some attention to these, to these, uh, to these issues and, um, and, and, and,
00:31:43 and, and that's basically where, where I'm coming from and hopefully, um, it'll stimulate, um, an
00:31:50 interesting, uh, conversation around these topics, uh, as we go on. Uh, and I, my, uh, viewers, my
00:31:57 listeners don't necessarily have to agree with me. Uh, I think it's, it would be good, uh, if, if, if they
00:32:03 actually disagreed with me, I think it would be, it would spark a discussion around these things,
00:32:08 uh, around these ideas. But, um, so I, you know, I, I, I want them to be able to, uh, uh, get something
00:32:14 out of these, uh, discussions. I want it to be intellectual. I want it to be stimulating. Some
00:32:19 of the topics may be provocative, but I'm, I'm, I'm not shy about being provocative. So, um, so I
00:32:25 think, I think, uh, it, it, it, it, it hopes to be very promising and I'm really looking forward to it.
00:32:30 Well, that's great. Rupa, I can't wait. Your, your first, uh, episode's going to air next week. So
00:32:34 everyone, uh, stay tuned for that. Uh, thank you so much, uh, for joining the show and, and thank
00:32:39 you for joining us and welcome aboard to True North. Thank you so much, Candice. It's a pleasure.
00:32:44 Okay. That's Rupa Subramania now with True North. I'm Candice Malcolm, and this is the Candice Malcolm
00:32:48 Show.
00:33:04 I'm Candice Malcolm, and this is the Candice Malcolm. Thank you so much, and thank you.
00:33:10 Thank you.