The Candice Malcolm Show - May 02, 2025


The Biggest LOSERS of the 2025 Canadian Election

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Trump EXPOSES Carney, CBC fakes story of conservative in-fighting (w⧸ MP-elect Andrew Lawton) CBC journalist HUMILIATED twice in ONE DAY, Carney Liberals SLAMMED in new press freedom report, will Alberta SEPARATE?

Episode Stats


Length

31 minutes

Words per minute

196.02

Word count

6,209

Sentence count

412

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

22

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Candace Malan and Wyatt Claypool recap the results of the Canadian election and talk about who are the winners and losers. They also discuss the possibility of a third party winning a majority government, and whether or not that's even possible.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hi, I'm Candace Malcolm, and this is The Candace Malcolm Show.
00:00:04 Happy Friday, everyone.
00:00:05 We have a great show for you.
00:00:06 Obviously, we had the big election on Monday night.
00:00:09 Thank you, everyone, who tuned into our live broadcast.
00:00:11 Our goal was to replace the CBC.
00:00:14 We didn't quite get there, but we had a fantastic night.
00:00:16 Great guests, great insight.
00:00:17 We had a decision desk making the live calls.
00:00:20 So we really appreciate everyone who joined us.
00:00:22 Because the election went so late, our broadcast ended at 2 a.m., not all of the dust had sort
00:00:26 of settled.
00:00:27 So we're going to do a recap today of the election and talk about who I think are the
00:00:32 biggest winners and the biggest losers of the campaign.
00:00:36 There were a lot of losers, and we're going to go through them all.
00:00:39 Before we get going, I'm just going to ask you to quickly like the video.
00:00:42 It really helps us with the YouTube algorithm.
00:00:44 Just takes a second of your time, and it really helps us out.
00:00:46 Thank you so much.
00:00:48 Okay, to join me on this episode, we're going to have a lot of fun today on The Candace Malcolm
00:00:51 Show.
00:00:51 And I am pleased to be joined by one of my favorite political commentators, Wyatt Claypool.
00:00:56 He is the founder of the National Telegraph and a political commentator based in Calgary.
00:01:00 Wyatt, thanks for joining us.
00:01:02 Absolutely.
00:01:02 Thanks for having me on.
00:01:04 Okay, so let's just go through the final count.
00:01:06 We have the, this is as of Friday morning.
00:01:08 I think most of the votes are in, but there will be, of course, a few recounts.
00:01:12 So the way that it all finished is that the Liberal Party of Canada is sitting at 168
00:01:16 seats.
00:01:17 They got 8.5 million votes, 43.7% total.
00:01:22 And then next we have the Conservatives' 144 seats, 8,089,000 votes, which represents 41.3%.
00:01:30 The NDP had seven seats, 1.2 million, which was 6.3 seats.
00:01:34 Interestingly, the Bloc also had 6.3% of the vote, but they have a much more efficient
00:01:39 breakdown because they only run candidates in one province in Quebec.
00:01:43 So they got 23 seats for their 1.2 million.
00:01:47 Green Party effectively got wiped out in this election.
00:01:49 One seat for their crazy leader, Elizabeth May, and 1.3% of the vote, 240,000 in change
00:01:55 votes.
00:01:56 And the PPC also got wiped out, zero seats, only 140,000 votes, 0.7% of the campaign.
00:02:03 Interestingly, there was a flip.
00:02:05 So the Liberals lost a closely contested seat to the Bloc Quebecois after vote validation.
00:02:10 I think it ended up switching by like 70 votes, which is enough to switch it over.
00:02:15 So sometimes in democracy, it really comes down like every single vote matters.
00:02:18 This election was so close.
00:02:20 It was really won just in a handful of seats across the country.
00:02:22 Remember, the magic number to get a majority is 172.
00:02:26 Liberals finished at 168.
00:02:28 It looks like I think there'll be a handful of recounts, but my guess is it'll roughly stay
00:02:32 the same at 168.
00:02:35 And so I know that there's been some speculation about this idea that all the Liberals would
00:02:39 have to do is convince four NDP or four Green or four Block members, or not Green, one
00:02:45 Block, four Greens to just cross the floor and come on over to the Liberals.
00:02:49 I think that's highly unlikely because just as you may say you can find four people from
00:02:54 other parties to cross the floor to the Liberals, you could also very easily have four Liberals
00:02:59 be convinced to cross the floor to the Conservatives to spoil it for Mark Kearney and be given,
00:03:04 you know, a special position in the Conservative Party.
00:03:06 It goes both ways.
00:03:07 We've seen that happen before.
00:03:08 So I don't see any pathway to Mark Kearney magically coming up with a majority here.
00:03:12 What do you think?
00:03:13 Well, you're right.
00:03:14 It's an arbitrary argument that, well, look, they only need five seats.
00:03:19 So why don't five NDP MPs move over so then they can fill the speaker position and they
00:03:25 can have their full majority without having to tie break votes?
00:03:28 It's like, OK, but and I've said this in many shows before, there is a reason why the
00:03:33 Liberal Party and the NDP are different parties.
00:03:36 It's not just because they just decided they like the color orange better.
00:03:40 Jagmeet Singh had very much obscured the differences between the Liberals and the NDP, but like
00:03:45 what many NDP MPs have said, they are not crossing the floor.
00:03:49 And I think that they'd be fools to not see what the party is going to be like once they 0.56
00:03:53 pick a new leader. 0.95
00:03:54 They have been through three cycles with the same guy.
00:03:57 At least give someone else a chance for a bit.
00:03:59 And if they're smart, they'll actually try and re-embrace the blue collar labor vote
00:04:04 they used to have back in the day.
00:04:06 And they'll probably treat this minority government more like Jack Layton treated the 2004 Paul
00:04:13 Martin minority government.
00:04:15 Because back then, Jack Layton understood, even though, yes, the Liberals are more like
00:04:20 them than they are the Conservatives, that he needed to be able to pull the plug if he
00:04:25 was actually going to be able to gain more political power.
00:04:27 Jagmeet Singh lost because he had no red line that he was willing, if crossed, to pull the
00:04:33 plug on Justin Trudeau and just let him sink.
00:04:36 Well, and we know he came out the week of the campaign and basically just said, we purposefully
00:04:40 propped up the Liberal government, even though we didn't agree with it, because we were just
00:04:43 dead set against Pierre Polyev and the Conservatives winning majority, which is totally counter to
00:04:49 any type of principle or even good strategic management of a political party.
00:04:53 Okay, I want to move on to talk about the PPC vote split.
00:04:56 There was a lot of comments and concern over this.
00:05:00 So from our account here at Juno News, we found that there were three seats where the
00:05:05 PPC vote was the difference, was the difference.
00:05:08 So Brampton East, you can see here that the Liberals got 23,600 votes.
00:05:13 The Conservatives got 21,600 votes.
00:05:16 So the difference was fewer than 2,000.
00:05:18 And the PPC came in right there with 2,300, enough to spoil it.
00:05:23 One riding over in Brampton, North Caledon.
00:05:26 You had the Liberals with 22,600.
00:05:29 The Conservatives with 22,000 and change.
00:05:31 And the PPCs with 600 votes.
00:05:33 Again, that's the difference, more than the difference right there.
00:05:36 Finally, just a little bit further over, in Kitchener-Costoga, the Liberals won with 30,000.
00:05:42 The Conservatives, 29,000, almost 500, basically.
00:05:46 And the PPCs with 700.
00:05:48 So such small margins and such a small number from the PPC.
00:05:51 I, again, I don't know for sure that every single PPC member, every single PPC voter,
00:05:58 sorry, is also a Conservative voter.
00:06:00 I think that a lot of people who go to the PPC are just protesting the system.
00:06:04 They're protesting the two parties.
00:06:06 They are anti-establishment.
00:06:08 And so I don't know that those were easy, easily, you could easily turn those people
00:06:14 into Conservative voters when it's such a small number.
00:06:17 But at the same time, obviously, it's frustrating to Conservatives to see just those three seats.
00:06:21 Obviously, three seats won't make a difference.
00:06:23 Like we talked about, the Liberals did win by enough to have more of a comfortable minority.
00:06:27 But still, every seat does matter.
00:06:29 So what do you make of this line of arguing?
00:06:32 I would sort of probably split those two areas into two different situations with the PPC.
00:06:39 In Brampton, the situation wasn't so much that, oh, don't they know that they should
00:06:44 be voting for the Conservatives in order to stop the Liberals?
00:06:48 They should be trying to get rid of the Liberal government. 0.98
00:06:50 They're obviously, like, super corrupt.
00:06:53 The problem was, is that in Brampton East, the PPC candidate, Jeff Wall, had tried to
00:06:59 contest one of the Ridings Conservative Party nominations and was arbitrarily kicked out.
00:07:04 And so it was less that he was running for the PPC because he liked the PPC and more so
00:07:09 that he was looking for an easy political vehicle to go after the party after having removed
00:07:14 him as a candidate.
00:07:15 And he ended up having a few other Hindu Canadians join him in running for the PPC in the Brampton
00:07:22 area out of protest.
00:07:24 People can agree with it.
00:07:25 They cannot agree with it.
00:07:26 They can say maybe he should suck it up and just get over it.
00:07:29 It's just that's politics at the end of the day, that if you end up messing with the wrong
00:07:33 person, they may not just go home and feel sad about it.
00:07:36 They may do something about it.
00:07:37 And then in Kitchener, Conestoga, this is more of, I would say, a lot of PPC guys, and
00:07:46 I even voted PPC in 2021.
00:07:48 I couldn't possibly vote O'Toole, and I'm in a safe Conservative riding.
00:07:52 But the people who are left over, I would say, are very much like the Green Party.
00:07:57 They are too anti-establishment to vote for any mainstream party.
00:08:00 And they will never come over because their actual list of demands will shift just so that
00:08:07 they can keep saying that they're a little bit too pure for the Conservative Party.
00:08:11 I made a video at one point where I had gone over some of the issues that PPC people were
00:08:17 having, some of the candidates on why you should vote for them, not the Conservative.
00:08:21 It was easily debunkable that they were saying, well, you know, Polyev has never stood up against
00:08:26 gender theory.
00:08:27 Well, Polyev has never stood up against, he never stood up against lockdowns or mandates.
00:08:31 He never did like this or that.
00:08:33 It's like, it's, you can just easily verify he did.
00:08:36 But these people, even if you ended up showing them that he did, it's still not good enough
00:08:40 because that's not the point of the party to actually get some principled policy position.
00:08:45 Is this to be better than the Conservatives?
00:08:47 No, that's absolutely right.
00:08:48 And I think that the idea is that you always vote for the most Conservative candidate that can
00:08:53 win, right?
00:08:53 And I like Maxine Bernier.
00:08:55 I think, I didn't vote in the leadership contest because I'm not a Conservative Party member,
00:08:59 but I would have been happy if Maxine Bernier had won the leadership of the party after Stephen
00:09:03 Harper stepped down.
00:09:04 I thought he was really good on cultural issues, really good on economic issues like supply
00:09:07 management.
00:09:08 He barely lost the leadership race to Andrew Scheer, right?
00:09:11 And it seemed like he could have had a great future in the party.
00:09:14 He decided to leave.
00:09:16 And I get the protest, right?
00:09:17 I understand in 2019 why you might have voted for Maxine Bernier to protest against the Conservative
00:09:22 Party going too soft, specifically on immigration, refusing to talk about it.
00:09:25 In 2021, definitely the COVID issue was madness.
00:09:30 Like, I'll tell you, Wyatt, watching the 2021 debate, all candidates debate with the leaders
00:09:35 and seeing that ridiculous propaganda video that they all put out promoting the vaccine,
00:09:40 speaking in unison, speaking like, honestly, like, it was creepy. 0.52
00:09:44 And to have the Conservative do that, like, the whole idea of a Conservative is our values
00:09:48 are different and they articulate the differences and they don't just succumb to the liberal
00:09:51 narrative.
00:09:52 So seeing a leader succumb to the liberal narrative, I'm all for it.
00:09:54 I'm all for, in 2021, voting for the People's Party.
00:09:58 But this time around, I just didn't see the imperative.
00:10:01 I didn't see the push.
00:10:01 Go ahead. 1.00
00:10:02 Yeah, I was just going to, I hated that stupid, we're all in this together video. 0.99
00:10:07 I don't know, there's never a moment where speaking in unison isn't creepy or as if it's 0.99
00:10:14 going to put people at ease because all these people are reading a script.
00:10:16 But yeah, the PPC now, they're basically a dead party.
00:10:20 The only thing I find annoying, because the thing is, I don't even not support small parties.
00:10:26 I flew on my own expense to Ontario in February just to hit doors for the new blue party of
00:10:32 Ontario because I don't think that Doug Ford is a good premier and I don't think the
00:10:36 PC party is doing anything conservative.
00:10:39 So you should be trying to prop up an alternative.
00:10:42 The problem is, my problem with the PPC, and this is a problem with all the elections,
00:10:46 they don't even try.
00:10:48 That's the problem.
00:10:49 I don't like when people take small donor money and they basically just burn it on pretending
00:10:55 like they're going to be standing up to the system or something like that.
00:10:58 I completely agree with that.
00:11:00 We'll get to more.
00:11:00 Okay.
00:11:01 I want to get to the biggest winners and the biggest losers in the election.
00:11:04 We'll get to a little bit more on Maxine Bernier in that.
00:11:06 First, I want to start with the winners.
00:11:08 I'm not going to sugarcoat it.
00:11:09 I'm not going to lie to the audience.
00:11:11 I will say the biggest winner of the election was Mark Carney and the Liberals.
00:11:14 They pulled off something absolutely remarkable.
00:11:16 It was spectacular.
00:11:17 The reversal in fortunes that we saw in this country.
00:11:20 Mark Carney took a party that was down and out.
00:11:23 There was a certain point at the early part of 2025 where the NDP was actually pulling ahead
00:11:28 of Justin Trudeau and the Liberals, it was possible that the Liberals were going to get
00:11:32 wiped out.
00:11:33 Mark Carney showed up and managed to do something that just rarely happens in politics, a total
00:11:38 reversal of fortune.
00:11:40 He had the legacy media working in overdrive for him.
00:11:43 They crafted the perfect narrative.
00:11:44 It was, I've said it before on the show, it was like a black swan event where you had 0.87
00:11:48 Donald Trump making these ridiculous comments, Canadians getting really worried about the 0.58
00:11:52 literal annexation or the effects of trade wars. 0.89
00:11:55 Mark Carney coming in as this sort of stable, competent, middle-of-the-road banker.
00:11:59 We know that that isn't true, but so many Canadians fell for it and you have to hand
00:12:03 it to them for being just so manipulative and so good at it.
00:12:07 It's like they're so good at being evil and they pulled it off.
00:12:10 Unbelievable.
00:12:11 I think more winners in this election were certainly independent media, independent citizen
00:12:17 journalists, content creators, podcasters.
00:12:20 You saw a whole new class of individuals, so many of them we had on our show.
00:12:24 But they were there breaking it down, getting huge numbers on platforms like YouTube, TikTok,
00:12:30 X.
00:12:30 I mean, there's like 20 or 25.
00:12:32 And for me, I've been doing this independent media gig for the last, I think, four elections,
00:12:37 2015, 2019, 2021, 2024, 2025.
00:12:41 This was the first one where I really felt like I just had good company.
00:12:45 There were so many people around saying the same kind of thing, doing the same kind of
00:12:48 thing.
00:12:48 It didn't feel so lonely.
00:12:49 I think in previous elections, it was just like true north and the rebel basically fighting
00:12:53 against everyone.
00:12:54 And this time it felt like there was more of a critical mass.
00:12:56 Obviously, we didn't have enough to push it over for the good side, for the conservatives.
00:13:01 But I think that the future is being laid out in front of us.
00:13:04 I think that the legacy media really have lost their grip.
00:13:07 And I hope and I pray that this was the last election that they were actually able to set
00:13:12 the narrative because, yes, we put cracks in the narrative.
00:13:15 They still said it, though.
00:13:16 And so I think, yes, we were the winners, but the legacy media still had their day.
00:13:22 Just a few more winners election.
00:13:24 I think new conservative MPs.
00:13:25 I'm very excited about a handful of freshmen or first time elected MPs.
00:13:30 People like Andrew Lawton, who we had on the show yesterday, former True North journalist.
00:13:33 Matt Strauss, who was an incredible fighter for the fighting against the madness in a group
00:13:39 thing during COVID.
00:13:41 He was elected.
00:13:42 Aaron Gunn, documentary filmmaker and independent journalist out in British Columbia was elected.
00:13:46 And David Bextie, Kian Bextie's father, was elected.
00:13:49 So there's a whole slate of new conservative candidates that I am very excited about.
00:13:53 Final winner for me was Danielle Smith and for the future of Alberta.
00:13:58 She just came across as being so strong, so confident in her views, really speaking differently
00:14:04 than the crowd and being able to articulate herself.
00:14:07 And I think that the movements, the strategy that she's had post-election, changing the
00:14:11 citizenship initiative, referendum requirements, and coming out demanding a reset in the relationship
00:14:17 with Ottawa.
00:14:18 I think Danielle Smith definitely came out as a big winner of the campaign. 0.99
00:14:22 OK, Wyatt, what did you think of my winner's list?
00:14:23 And do you have your own?
00:14:24 I thought especially the one about independent media is good, not just because I work in
00:14:29 independent media, you know, you don't exist just to gas each other up.
00:14:34 But genuinely, you're right.
00:14:35 Back in the last election, there wasn't really a big collection of people covering the news.
00:14:40 It was, yeah, just a few collections of networks, a few niche YouTubers, and that was it.
00:14:47 I'm going to add another winner to your list.
00:14:50 It hurts me to say it, but a big winner of the night was Bruce Fanjoy, a man who had been
00:14:56 mocked for probably two years trying to take on Pierre Polyev in Carlton.
00:15:00 And was he helped by a big boundary redistribution?
00:15:04 Yes.
00:15:04 Was he helped by the fact that Pierre Polyev really didn't have time to run his own riding?
00:15:09 Yes.
00:15:09 But, you know, if you win the seat, you still get the credit for it.
00:15:13 But I will even add that the Conservative Party still had a good night.
00:15:17 There were certain areas, you could say, that the southwestern Ontario Conservatives did really,
00:15:23 really well.
00:15:24 We won Windsor West and both Windsor ridings, despite some of those not having gone Conservative
00:15:30 since 1935, I believe.
00:15:32 And so there are a lot of good highlights around the country for the Conservatives.
00:15:36 The fact that the Conservatives' vote has actually become far more efficient than it was in previous
00:15:41 elections.
00:15:42 In previous elections, they could win the popular vote and still come in with only 119 seats.
00:15:48 And now you can actually lose the popular vote and you can come in nearly almost at what
00:15:52 the Liberals had.
00:15:53 If one point just shifted from the Liberals to the Conservatives, it may be a completely
00:15:58 different election.
00:15:59 And I think you're right where the thing that the legacy media did and Mark Carney had
00:16:04 done, yes, they won the night, so they get the credit still.
00:16:07 At the same time, it's one of those tricks you can only pull once.
00:16:11 And my evidence is Chinese interference in this election did not go very well.
00:16:15 The CCP had no effect.
00:16:17 Chinese Canadians voted Conservative by quite a large margin because you can't pull the 1.00
00:16:23 same trick twice.
00:16:24 In 2021, they scared Chinese Canadians into thinking the Conservatives blame you for COVID 0.99
00:16:29 because you're Chinese, which was ridiculous. 0.97
00:16:32 But if you live potentially in a small media bubble of mostly listening to a few Chinese 0.92
00:16:37 publications sent to you over WeChat, you may be influenced.
00:16:41 This election, it didn't matter what they did.
00:16:43 It just did not work.
00:16:45 Chinese Canadians didn't want to hear it. 1.00
00:16:46 And they were just going to vote for whoever was going to perform well on drugs, crime and
00:16:51 taxes.
00:16:52 Absolutely.
00:16:53 And we can go through some of the writings that have a high Chinese population, like
00:16:57 Markham Unionville, like the Richmond writings out in British Columbia that did go Conservative.
00:17:01 So again, yeah, I did an entire show on Tuesday of the good news from the election.
00:17:06 And I did think that the Conservatives overperformed.
00:17:09 They picked up a lot.
00:17:10 I mean, I was going through some of the writings, Wyatt, in the 905, like Richmond Hill, the Vaughn
00:17:15 writings.
00:17:16 I mean, they were winning with like rural Alberta number.
00:17:19 Now I know David Bexty got elected with over 80%.
00:17:21 So there was no riding in Ontario where a Conservative got more than 80%.
00:17:25 But I mean, Melissa Lansman, one with a higher percentage in Thornhill, which is basically
00:17:30 Toronto, than Michelle Rempel did in Calgary, in King Vaughn, 62%.
00:17:37 So, you know, big numbers for the Conservatives, very close to Toronto.
00:17:41 So I do think that there is some good news. 0.87
00:17:43 OK, let's go through the losers.
00:17:45 Everybody wants to know who are our biggest losers of the election.
00:17:49 Number one, by far, far and away, the absolute biggest loser in the election, probably the
00:17:56 biggest loser in Canadian political history.
00:17:58 That award is going to go to Jagmeet Singh and the NDP, absolutely wiped out, losing
00:18:04 party status.
00:18:05 Jagmeet Singh loses his own riding, will go down in history as a laughingstock and a total
00:18:10 joke who enabled the worst government in Canadian history.
00:18:13 And I want you to get a load of this, Wyatt, because I noticed this from an individual named
00:18:19 Brett Cameron on X.
00:18:21 He posted this.
00:18:22 He writes, the number of campaigns that failed to get 10% of the vote, thereby not qualifying
00:18:27 for a juicy Elections Canada rebate check to repay bank loans and replenish the local
00:18:33 war chest.
00:18:34 You can look at this chart.
00:18:35 First of all, it is so absurd that taxpayers subsidize political parties in this country.
00:18:40 I mean, this is so ridiculous that the Elections Canada gives you a rebate check for the amount
00:18:44 of money that you spend on the campaign if you hit a certain threshold. 0.97
00:18:48 It's just silly.
00:18:48 But anyways, I disagree with the policy, but this is the reality of it.
00:18:52 So here is a list of conservative, liberal, NDP, block, green, and PPC, the number of
00:18:56 campaigns that they ran, and then the number that were below the 10%.
00:19:00 So conservatives had two below the 10%.
00:19:02 Libs had one.
00:19:04 The NDP had 296 out of 342 that were below 10%, meaning they won't get the rebate, meaning
00:19:13 I think the party is going to go bankrupt.
00:19:14 I think the party is going to go bankrupt because if you know political campaigns, a lot of
00:19:19 times, like he said, they take out bank loans.
00:19:22 They're literally running their campaign on debt in the hopes that the government is going
00:19:26 to write them a big subsidy check afterwards.
00:19:28 All they have to do is get 10% of the vote.
00:19:31 The NDP just didn't accomplish it.
00:19:32 In 87% of the ridings that they ran in, they're not getting the money.
00:19:36 Likewise, the block, sorry, the Green Party didn't make the threshold in 98% of the ridings
00:19:43 that they ran in.
00:19:44 They only made it in four ridings and the PPC in 100.
00:19:47 So the PPC is not getting any money.
00:19:48 The block is only getting it for four ridings.
00:19:50 And the NDP, 87%.
00:19:53 I predict that the party could go bankrupt.
00:19:55 What do you think, Wyatt?
00:19:56 100% they might have to sell the Layton building because that's how they usually were funding
00:20:01 their campaigns.
00:20:02 You bring in a good chunk of donations.
00:20:04 You put that up as like proof that you can fundraise to a bank.
00:20:08 Then you take out a massive few million dollar loan on the Jack Layton building in Ottawa.
00:20:13 And then you run a bunch of candidates.
00:20:15 And what I've heard from NDP insiders is it doesn't matter how that money was raised and
00:20:19 spent.
00:20:19 They just act like a kleptocracy after the election and steal all of the rebate checks 0.81
00:20:24 that every single riding was given until they actually pay off the building.
00:20:27 And then the local ridings can start to fundraise their own money again, knowing that they
00:20:32 will have to pay back their rebate to the party at once the election is over.
00:20:37 The thing with Jagmeet Singh too is that he probably didn't even benefit the liberals against
00:20:43 the Conservatives as much as he thought.
00:20:45 The blue collar ridings that the NDP held, the Conservatives grabbed them.
00:20:50 That's why they were winning so well in Windsor.
00:20:55 It's not that those were NDP ridings before, but the whole point is that the NDP had a substantial
00:20:59 vote there.
00:21:00 Oftentimes with the ridings where the Conservatives came in third, but they ended up grabbing up
00:21:05 pretty much 100% of the NDP vote because the type of person voting NDP in that area is
00:21:10 far more likely to go Conservative if the NDP pulls out and just puts up a paper candidate
00:21:15 and barely tries.
00:21:16 And then the other ridings that the NDP lost were in like downtown Vancouver, downtown Toronto,
00:21:22 where you should be competing as hard as possible because this is a riding where it's either
00:21:27 going to be Liberal or NDP.
00:21:29 But Jagmeet Singh had managed this election so poorly that it's basically just because of
00:21:35 the personality and character of some of their MPs that were able to hold on that got them
00:21:41 through.
00:21:41 So he ended up stripping out every single virtue for somebody on the left that the NDP held.
00:21:47 And so now the party basically came in a distant, distant fourth for what?
00:21:54 The benefit of giving like Mark Carney a slightly bigger minority when they could have had those
00:21:59 seats?
00:22:00 It's really interesting.
00:22:02 I don't know what will happen with the party.
00:22:03 They've got their work cut out for them, whether they do want to rebuild or whether they just
00:22:07 want to fold and put their votes in with the Liberals and then we'll have a real two-party 0.99
00:22:11 system in Canada.
00:22:12 But it's hard to imagine them recovering.
00:22:14 I want to move on because we've got a few more names to get to here.
00:22:16 So we talked about them quite a bit at the beginning of the show. 0.97
00:22:19 But Maxime Bernier and the People's Party were losers. 0.81
00:22:22 And the losing didn't stop for Maxime Bernier on Election Day. 0.99
00:22:24 He came out afterwards on X and he was just whining and he sounded like a sore loser.
00:22:29 I'm going to read what he had to say here on X.
00:22:31 He said, so in this election, the PBC lost roughly 700,000 of its 840,000 votes from 2021,
00:22:38 83%.
00:22:38 That's not a flex, man.
00:22:39 That's embarrassing.
00:22:40 You got wiped out and that's how you're responding.
00:22:43 He writes, I suspect the vast majority voted for the Conservatives having to succumb to the
00:22:47 don't split the vote.
00:22:48 We must beat the libs at this time hysteria. 0.91
00:22:51 No, that's not true.
00:22:52 I will admit I voted for Maxime Bernier and the People's Party in 2021 as well for the opposite
00:22:56 reason probably that you did, Wyatt.
00:22:57 I was living in Rosedale at the time, University of Rosedale, Christopher Young's riding, and
00:23:03 the Conservatives had absolutely no hope.
00:23:04 So my vote did not matter.
00:23:05 And I figured I might as well do the principal's vote.
00:23:07 I liked Maxime Bernier better than Aaron O'Toole.
00:23:09 I didn't want to reward the Conservatives for running a terrible left-wing campaign.
00:23:12 So I voted for them.
00:23:13 And this time around, I didn't succumb to the don't split the vote hysteria.
00:23:16 I just put my vote back to the party where it usually is because last time around, it
00:23:21 was a protest vote.
00:23:21 Okay, I'll keep reading from Maxime Bernier.
00:23:24 He says, and yet that strategy failed.
00:23:26 We still have another liberal government and Poliev couldn't even win his own seat.
00:23:29 That's fair.
00:23:30 But the insane CPC trolls and the fake independent journalists and influencers paid by the CPC
00:23:35 are still accusing the PPC of helping Carney.
00:23:38 So all of a sudden, we're fake independent journalists.
00:23:40 I have interviewed Maxime Bernier on my show half a dozen times or more.
00:23:43 I've happily helped promote his cause through my platform.
00:23:47 And then the second I'm critical of him and others, he calls us fake independent journalists
00:23:52 and accuses influencers of being paid by the CPC.
00:23:56 I don't see any influence of that.
00:23:57 So to me, this is just poor form.
00:23:59 And then he goes on to say that Poliev dropped the ball and that the PPC is a better place
00:24:04 to vote.
00:24:04 This just comes across as very petty.
00:24:06 And yes, just to rub it in a little bit more, the People's Party of Canada got 141,000
00:24:10 votes across the country in this election.
00:24:13 That is fewer people than read my emails every single morning.
00:24:16 That represents 0.7% of the population.
00:24:19 And I'm sorry, Maxime Bernier, you didn't even come close in your own riding.
00:24:23 You lost by a landslide.
00:24:24 The Conservative candidate there got 60% of the vote.
00:24:26 You got 5.8%.
00:24:27 You only got 3,600 votes in your own riding.
00:24:32 This isn't really a political party anymore.
00:24:34 This is sort of just like a personality.
00:24:36 Like Maxime Bernier should just become a podcaster or become a public intellectual and go back to
00:24:41 leading the movement through ideas rather than through politics because he didn't even try
00:24:46 in his own riding.
00:24:46 He could have done what Elizabeth May did, just put all of her resources into meeting people,
00:24:50 getting to know everyone in the boats.
00:24:52 I mean, he used to represent that riding.
00:24:54 I don't understand why he just doesn't do better there.
00:24:56 He needs to have a seat in parliament if he wants to be a politician.
00:24:59 Otherwise, I just don't understand what the whole point of it is.
00:25:03 Wyatt, what are your thoughts?
00:25:04 Someone should go back and analyze, and I have, analyzed that race from 2019 when he
00:25:09 was trying to win re-election in Boas back when he was the incumbent.
00:25:14 And the problem was that he only lost by 10% back then.
00:25:18 I think that he was almost intentionally trying to lose because he only lost by 10% in 2019.
00:25:23 Basically never showed up.
00:25:24 Did no pre-canvassing before the election of his own riding.
00:25:27 Maybe was there for four or five days during the actual election in 2019.
00:25:32 And he was off in rural Saskatchewan and Alberta and British Columbia,
00:25:37 getting votes in places where they were maybe going to get 3% or 5%.
00:25:42 And Maxine Bernier then, in a race where, again,
00:25:45 if he just flipped 5% of the conservative vote to himself, it would be a tie ballgame.
00:25:49 And he, as like a French politician who was very much anti-immigration,
00:25:55 could have easily gotten a lot of Bloc Québécois voters to probably swap over
00:26:00 to vote for him if he was going to be in an even stronger voice on that issue.
00:26:03 I just don't think he really cares.
00:26:05 I had him on my show in 2021 and never again because he continues to lie about actually making
00:26:11 a constitution for his party.
00:26:13 That's the funny thing.
00:26:14 He always goes after establishment parties for being very hierarchical at the same time
00:26:19 that his party is effectively a dictatorship where, by the way,
00:26:22 he frequently swaps in candidates for other people that he just happens to like better
00:26:27 even if a nomination went on in a PPC writing. 0.97
00:26:30 So the man's a complete hypocrite when he has full power to be as principled as possible. 0.94
00:26:35 The thing, too, is at least Maxine Bernier has proven that the American podcast circuit 0.97
00:26:41 does not get you votes.
00:26:43 One, the PPC for some reason couldn't get over two-thirds of the candidates on the ballot.
00:26:48 But the man did a podcast tour with every single major conservative influencer in the U.S.
00:26:54 And turns out it doesn't matter because most, like, it sounds shocking,
00:27:00 but Canadians don't watch a lot of American political news.
00:27:03 I know political Canadians will do that because they're interested in the U.S.,
00:27:07 but there was no way going on the Patrick Bette David podcast was going to help Pierre Polyev.
00:27:14 So thank you to Maxine Bernier for proving that nobody cares.
00:27:17 That's a really good point.
00:27:19 Okay, I want to quickly go through my final losers.
00:27:21 I'll just group them together.
00:27:23 The final losers for me in this campaign were the legacy media,
00:27:27 and shining in that was the CBC.
00:27:29 They were just so offended and so hurt by the things that happened at the debate,
00:27:34 and they couldn't hide it in their face.
00:27:36 They just came across as so unprofessional, so petty.
00:27:38 And I want to couple in with the legacy media,
00:27:41 the legacy media's favorite pollsters and the poll aggregators,
00:27:45 because they just got it wrong.
00:27:46 They got the election wrong.
00:27:47 I want to show you the 338 aggregate polls.
00:27:50 So this is taking all the fancy legacy media polls that happened during the campaign on any given day
00:27:54 and creating an aggregate list, so, like, kind of an average of them.
00:27:59 And here is what they had the day before the election.
00:28:03 Sorry, let me just pull it up here.
00:28:04 They had the Liberals at 43%, Conservatives at 39%, NDP at 8%, Block at 6%.
00:28:09 Okay, how did the election actually finish out?
00:28:10 The Liberals at 43.7%, so, okay, not terrible, 43% to 43.7%.
00:28:16 The Conservatives, though, at 41.3%, so they got them off by a full 2%,
00:28:21 and they got the NDP off by 2% as well.
00:28:25 So, again, like, why would we ever trust legacy media,
00:28:28 and why would we ever trust their pollsters again when they just got this one so wrong?
00:28:33 What do you think, Wyatt?
00:28:33 And that's aggregating some of the good ones with the bad ones.
00:28:37 The particularly bad ones were showing a 5% to 6% lead for the Liberals before Election Day.
00:28:44 So some polling is actually pretty good, but the thing is you have to be very selective with who you follow.
00:28:50 There isn't just this, oh, so you're denying the polls.
00:28:53 If I look, like, at an ECOS poll and it's saying a plus 8 Liberal victory, I'm saying that's not realistic.
00:28:58 When, I think it was some of the ones like Liaison Strategies and Research Co. towards the end,
00:29:02 we're still saying plus 5, plus 6 Liberals.
00:29:05 Like, well, that would have been a wipeout.
00:29:06 That would have been, like, 210 seats.
00:29:10 And, no, like, but just because Abacus or Main Street did a better job
00:29:15 does not then mean I'm going to be thinking,
00:29:18 oh, the polling industry is great because if you average it, it's not that bad.
00:29:22 But the polling industry outside of a couple of firms still has a really bad problem under polling conservatives.
00:29:29 And the thing is that you wonder how many people end up looking at it saying,
00:29:33 well, I'm not going to vote because the conservatives are losing by 6 or 7 points
00:29:37 based on these five pollsters, and there's only two that are even saying it's somewhat close.
00:29:42 Got to show up and vote because if the turnout was higher than 70%,
00:29:45 I think that would have actually carried the conservatives at least close to winning,
00:29:49 and it only came in, I believe, at, like, 68 and a half.
00:29:53 Yeah, well, that's totally the thing.
00:29:55 I think that the purpose of the polls in many ways, Wyatt, was to demoralize conservatives,
00:29:59 showing the Liberals with a huge lead, signaling to Canadians that the right thing to do was to vote Liberal,
00:30:04 was to put your elbows up, fight against Trump,
00:30:06 that whole ridiculous narrative that was constructed by the legacy media. 0.87
00:30:10 And so they were trying to demoralize. 0.66
00:30:12 I think that there was that sort of shy Tory effect
00:30:14 where they just didn't want to tell pollsters the truth.
00:30:17 And you're right.
00:30:18 When you take away the handful, the small handful of good ones like Abacus and Main Street,
00:30:22 which are at least not as biased as the other ones, the rest of the polls were even worse.
00:30:28 Okay, folks may be wondering why we haven't talked about Pierre Polyev and the conservatives.
00:30:32 Did we consider them a winner?
00:30:34 Did we consider them a loser?
00:30:35 We're going to do another segment where we're going to talk entirely about Pierre Polyev
00:30:38 and the conservatives and what we think they did right, what we think they did wrong.
00:30:42 So you're going to have to stay tuned for that.
00:30:44 All right, folks, thanks so much for tuning in.
00:30:45 I'm Candace Malcolm. This is the Candace Malcolm Show.
00:30:47 Thank you and God bless.
00:30:48 You're watching Juno News, Canada's fastest-growing independent news network.
00:30:58 Our team works day and night to bring you nationwide coverage of the issues that matter,
00:31:05 honest reporting of the stories that put Canadians first.
00:31:09 From far and wide, Juno is doing the work to turn the dial in the right direction,
00:31:17 bringing you the news from the field and in the studio.
00:31:21 Wherever it takes us, we get the job done.
00:31:25 For you.
00:31:26 For Canada.
00:31:27 Subscribe today and help us replace the CBC.
00:31:37 Go to junonews.com to join the fight.