The Candice Malcolm Show - June 15, 2020


The CBC should be defunded, not the police

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
The far-left has hijacked the George Floyd protests Under Trudeau’s watch, Canada is irrelevant

Episode Stats


Length

55 minutes

Words per minute

203.06

Word count

11,203

Sentence count

609

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

7

sentences flagged

Hate speech

18

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Candice and Sam discuss the concept of "gaslighting" and what it means to be "gaslighted" by the mainstream media, and how it impacts our ability to understand and understand the world around us.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hi, and welcome to True North Update. I'm your host, Candice Malcolm. I'm joined today by a
00:00:09 special guest host, Sam Eskenazi. Sam is a contributor at True North. Actually, funny
00:00:14 enough, he was one of the original True North fellows back when True North was more of an
00:00:19 immigration think tank. So, Sam, it's great to have you back with True North and great to have
00:00:24 you on the program today. For sure. Thanks. It's a pleasure. And I think that, you know,
00:00:28 it's funny because, yeah, I did want to get involved because I was really interested in
00:00:31 what you guys were doing. And now I'm back. So it's great. It's great. And yeah, you've been
00:00:36 doing some great videos. I think one of my favorite videos you did, Sam, for True North was you were
00:00:41 talking about how something about how people are getting gaslit and you kind of gave a historical
00:00:48 explanation of what that means. Because I didn't even know what the origin of that word was, but
00:00:54 it comes from a movie. Is that right? Yeah. So it came from a movie. I think it was
00:00:58 in the original one, I think it was in the 40s. I forget now the original one, but it's
00:01:02 basically in the movie, the husband tries to manipulate his wife and make her think she's
00:01:06 going crazy when he's really the one pulling the strings. And it bothered me because everyone
00:01:10 always spoke about the government or just things they don't like as being hypocritical. But 0.76
00:01:15 it's not always hypocritical. Like if I'm a smoker and I tell you smoking is bad, but I
00:01:19 tell you at the same time, I'm also trying to quit. That's not the same hypocritical as what
00:01:24 you would normally think. So gaslighting is really when you say one thing and then literally
00:01:28 do the opposite and make it sound like they're the person who's doing the thing that they're
00:01:32 accusing you of. Exactly. And it's such a helpful example. I think that over the past few weeks,
00:01:37 Sam, there isn't a better word to describe how the media is treating the public, particularly
00:01:42 when it comes to the protests and how some of the protests have become very violent. So you
00:01:47 have the mainstream media saying that the protests are completely peaceful, repeated over and over
00:01:53 again in straight news stories and news reports, TV anchors, you hear it on CNN, but even read it in
00:01:58 Canadian newspapers. And they'll always say, you know, these peaceful protests. And then, you know,
00:02:02 it doesn't take too much to just go online and see videos of looting, arson, violence to read stories
00:02:08 about how police are being ambushed in many cities, that there's been many police officers that have
00:02:13 been killed. And it's like, wait a minute, why does the media keep telling us that these are
00:02:18 peaceful protests when they're clearly not? It's like, and I think that the concept of gaslighting,
00:02:23 when someone is deliberately lying to you to make it seem like you're questioning your own sanity,
00:02:29 and you're questioning your own ability to understand the world around you, it is such a
00:02:33 dangerous concept. And it's quite literally happening. So I appreciated that video, because it
00:02:39 helped me more clearly understand a framework to really try to understand and explain what we're
00:02:44 living through in this in this present time. Yeah, thanks. And I think really, you can see it when
00:02:50 they say that someone's speech is violence, whether that's on campus or on the media, people are being
00:02:55 shut down, as you know, we're gonna, I'm sure we're gonna get into, but they're saying that speech is
00:02:59 violence. And then when you see these protests, which are getting violent, like literally just
00:03:04 physical violence, the standard textbook definition, then they're saying, oh, no, that's just people
00:03:09 expressing their anger. That's, you know, people reallocating resources or some other weird
00:03:13 euphemism. So violence has become something that I'm now saying. So if I were to be harsh with you,
00:03:17 I might, you know, I'm being violent. And yet, people doing textbook traditional violence, that's
00:03:22 just something else. That's right. Yeah, I literally read in the National Post that there's a movement
00:03:27 to get rid of the term, the word Dundas Street. So Dundas Street in Toronto goes through the whole
00:03:33 city, there's Dundas Streets all over Ontario, trying to get rid of them, because apparently the
00:03:37 namesake Henry Dundas has, you know, had some unsavory episodes. And because of that, we're going to
00:03:44 change all these names, apparently. And in the National Post article, which again, National Post is
00:03:48 supposed to be a conservative newspaper. We learned that the experience of walking down Dundas Street
00:03:54 is violence towards black and indigenous people in Canada. So somehow just having a street name is
00:04:02 violence. But then, you know, to your point, actual violence is just is just speech when when it's,
00:04:07 you know, left wing protesters that are carrying it out. We had that New York Times magazine reporter
00:04:14 who's behind the 1619 Project come out and just say flat out that violence does not mean looting and
00:04:20 rioting. Violence means actual physical violence against people. And so it's unfair that they're the
00:04:25 same. This is the same word because she claimed that looting and, you know, destroying private 0.82
00:04:31 property and all these things that she claims can easily be fixed. That's not real violence. So
00:04:35 we're definitely living in some strange times, Sam. And I think that's why it's great to have
00:04:41 smart people like you helping explain what's going on and why we should see see through some of the
00:04:47 media nonsense. And speaking of media nonsense, Sam, I think the story that the big story in Canada,
00:04:53 as always, I mean, this has been the case going back to, you know, Don Cherry getting canceled.
00:04:58 You know, we have this, this culture, this cancel culture, where if you do one thing that steps out
00:05:03 of line, according to sort of a mob of woke tyrants that determine what what is what is right and what
00:05:10 is wrong, you can lose your entire livelihood, your career can be over, your reputation can be ruined.
00:05:16 And we saw this happen this week, really sort of a surprise target, because usually it's the CBC and
00:05:24 the left that's driving this, this idea that we should cancel people. I mean, it was just last
00:05:28 week that the CBC was part of a movement to, to punish and get rid of Stockwell Day, the former
00:05:34 leader of the Canadian Alliance, because of remarks that he made saying that systemic racism in Canada
00:05:39 doesn't exist. Well, this time around, it was CBC host Wendy Mesley. So Mesley has been suspended
00:05:45 from her position after she used, and this is what they say, this is a quote, a word that should never
00:05:51 be used, unquote, during an interaction with co-worker. So we don't know exactly what word it was, but I
00:05:56 think we can all kind of take a guess, because apparently she was talking about it was in the context
00:06:01 of race, she said that she was quoting another journalist, who was having a discussion about race. So this is
00:06:07 we're talking about a private meeting at the CBC, you know, a meeting among the probably staff at her show,
00:06:13 the weekly, where they're planning out the next episode. And Wendy Mesley supposedly said this, this word
00:06:19 that should never be said. And because of that, there was sort of a internal movement to have her
00:06:25 displaced. And so, I mean, it is kind of kind of sad, that, you know, we've come to this where you
00:06:32 can't even say a word in a private conversation, that's completely in context of a quote of something
00:06:37 that someone else said. But, you know, apparently, some words are off limits in our society. Fair enough.
00:06:42 But the idea that she got canceled over it, I don't like seeing it, even for someone like Wendy
00:06:48 Mesley, who, you know, I'm not a big fan. And I don't like her style or her approach, Sam. But,
00:06:53 you know, some people say she has it coming. And if you live by the SJW sword, you got to die by the
00:06:57 SJW sword. I don't think so. I don't think that we should ever cheer on mob justice like this. But
00:07:04 what's what's your take on the whole cancel culture and Wendy Mesley falling victim to it? 0.88
00:07:09 Well, there's two problems. And the first problem is when you have a culture that the axe comes down,
00:07:14 the hammer comes down on you, anytime you slip up, then you're just living in a very stressed out
00:07:20 way. Because you're not sure, especially when the rules are changing, as they are all the time now,
00:07:24 where something, you know, five or 10 years ago, a couple years ago that you used to be able to say,
00:07:29 or that you think you can still say, suddenly you can't, and you're not really clear on that.
00:07:33 And it's very stressful. It's very, it's not good for the soul to live in such a way. So that's the
00:07:39 first problem. The second is it eliminates the concept of a teachable moment or people growing,
00:07:45 people learning. I used to work at B'nai B'rith, which is a, it's a Jewish human rights organization.
00:07:50 And we used to be sort of the antisemitism watchdog. There, I did a lot of work regarding
00:07:56 their annual study on antisemitism. And I remember a case specifically where there was a former CFL
00:08:01 player who tweeted a number of antisemitic conspiracy theories. And so we reached out to,
00:08:05 he was on the Alouettes. And so we reached out to the team and said, listen, like, this is what we
00:08:09 got. And we received no response. The draft happened to be going on at the same time, which I guess
00:08:14 they were super busy, but we didn't get a response. And so we issued a public statement. But the point
00:08:19 is we didn't call right away for the guy to be fired. We ended up speaking to him, speaking to the
00:08:24 manager of the team and saying, listen, you know, I don't know if you know that what you're tweeting
00:08:27 there is like super, super offensive. It's just plain wrong. You know, it could lead to, you know,
00:08:31 serious problems down the road, whether it's actual violence against Jewish people or something,
00:08:34 you know, this is just bad stuff. So what we'd like to do is we'd like to help you understand
00:08:39 why what you tweeted was bad. And maybe you would like to, you know, do a podcast with us,
00:08:45 do a video with us, do something with us to help explain to people why such and such
00:08:49 antisemitism that you did was bad or why racism in general is bad. And that's a teachable moment
00:08:53 for him. That was a moment where we took someone who we could have just shut down. We could have
00:08:57 said, you know, hey, you get fired. That crushes dreams of being a professional athlete,
00:09:02 you know, just totally crushed the man. And what was that going to accomplish for anyone?
00:09:06 Now, I'm not saying you can rehabilitate or that every person is going to be open to
00:09:10 some sort of education, but we're not even trying at this point.
00:09:13 It's a really good point because I think a lot of times we have a lot more in common than we think.
00:09:18 And the idea that someone would just get completely shut off or blacklisted,
00:09:21 it doesn't really help anyone because even say that there are a group of people that hold sort of
00:09:27 these illiberal views. If you just cancel one of their, you know, colleagues or friends or someone
00:09:32 who thinks like them, it's not going to make the idea subside. It's not going to make the idea go
00:09:37 away if it is a dangerous idea or if it is sort of a mainstream idea. You know, the best way to
00:09:43 confront it is to actually, you know, combat it and say let's have a discussion and conversation
00:09:48 as opposed to just trying to silence it, which is sort of the, I think your approach that you had
00:09:53 with benign birth is much, much better than the cancel culture approach because it doesn't really
00:09:56 accomplish anything other than ruining a person's life. And then the mob just moves on. Like they
00:10:01 don't think twice about it and they don't really care. They're just there for that, that moment of
00:10:05 sort of pleasure that you might get from seeing your enemy, you know, fall. And then, and then that's
00:10:10 it. Even, even, you know, last week we had a whole bunch of people on the left and even people in
00:10:16 the mainstream criticizing Rex Murphy for a column where Rex just basically said, Canada is a great
00:10:22 country. Let's not forget that. We're different than, than other countries that have really,
00:10:26 really, really dark histories when it comes to things like slavery. Canada doesn't have that.
00:10:32 Obviously we're not perfect, but our society is not completely characterized by racism is the point
00:10:37 he was making. And everyone just totally overreacted, mischaracterized what he said,
00:10:42 tried to sort of do a bait and switch where they said, oh, Rex is saying that there is no racism in
00:10:47 Canada. That's clearly wrong because here's two or three examples of racism, which doesn't,
00:10:51 didn't disprove Rex. And, and they basically just said, you're an old white man. You don't have
00:10:55 the right to talk. I would, I would have found it much more interesting to see some kind of a debate
00:11:01 or, you know, if there's a couple of people that say, hey, Rex, you're wrong about Canada. I would,
00:11:06 I would much more, I'd be much more interested in having a podcast or having a discussion about that,
00:11:11 as opposed to them just saying like, you're wrong, old white man, and you don't get an opinion.
00:11:15 You're not allowed to talk about race anymore, which essentially is, is what happened. And it's kind of sad.
00:11:20 Yes. That's the thing. I mean, you know, there's things like the Indian Act. There's some
00:11:25 obviously terrible history that's happened to, to almost any country. You can't, you can't find a
00:11:29 country that hasn't engaged in some slavery or terrible, terrible history. I mean, people act
00:11:33 as if it was just the United States and Canada or just the United States that engage in slavery.
00:11:37 I mean, it was a global institution for hundreds, thousands of years, pretty much. But the thing is,
00:11:43 we, we have to remember that Canada is not a strictly homogenous society. There are some
00:11:47 countries and societies that are super homogenous. And I think we should, we should grade ourselves 0.94
00:11:53 based on how well we're doing or where we're headed, not necessarily the mistakes that we've
00:11:58 made. And there might be mistakes that we should point out and say, Hey, we're still making that
00:12:01 mistake. I know I've been working a lot on, on first nations and indigenous stuff, and there's a lot
00:12:06 of complaints about the Indian Act, but that doesn't mean that Canada as a whole is moving in the wrong
00:12:12 direction. Now, now you could debate that. You could say, I think it is, but saying that
00:12:17 Rex Murphy should be fired or just, you know, eliminated from, from public society because he,
00:12:22 he dared to say such a thing. Ultimately, again, that's, that's not going to help. That's not going
00:12:26 to teach anyone for someone who's may, who may not be aware of, of all of Canadian history to just say,
00:12:31 well, you know, Canada's super racist and Rex Murphy should be fired. They're just not going to
00:12:35 understand what's going on or, or, you know, what the different, like, what's, what's the deal here?
00:12:38 Absolutely. Yeah. I think that there's definitely more of a need of, for, for learning or teaching,
00:12:44 teachable moments, like you said. And, you know, it's kind of interesting because the CBC
00:12:48 is this sort of like, it is this large Canadian institution that it dominates the media landscape.
00:12:56 They get $1.2 billion in taxpayer money every year. And they've sort of established themselves
00:13:01 as like the arbiters of truth and the sort of front lines of the SJW wars on our,
00:13:08 in our society, culture wars. And so it's interesting to see this sort of dynamic of,
00:13:14 you know, they're, they're kind of out there saying that we should silence other voices that
00:13:19 we don't agree with, or that, that the CBC should continue to dominate the media landscape
00:13:24 and crush out the competition. And then when it comes to their own institutions, they're
00:13:28 more than happy to throw people under us. Sam, I just think this is a big example of how corrupt
00:13:33 the CBC is, how, how, how they've just gone wrong. I mean, they just, whatever the purpose
00:13:38 was originally, that's clearly not what they're doing anymore. And I think, I think they're past,
00:13:42 past their due. So there are a lot of calls for, suddenly there's a lot of calls for defunding the
00:13:47 police, for abolishing the police, for reforming the police. I think, I think before we get into
00:13:53 conversations about that, why don't we talk about defunding or abolishing the CBC? Because I'm,
00:13:58 I'm more than happy to talk about ways to cut government for ways to cut back on spending and
00:14:02 to have, you know, a fair, free society. I think, I think that would be a good place to start. And
00:14:07 I'm sure there's lots of others. One example of CBC just outright failing. This was a tweet that
00:14:13 came out. There's a comedy show run by the CBC called This Hour is 22 Minutes. Their Twitter
00:14:18 account is sort of notoriously unfunny. And I don't know who runs it, but I always feel like it's some
00:14:24 intern that they're like, Hey kid, just tweet. Cause I don't know. It's always so ignorant and so dumb,
00:14:28 but they, they posted this tweet this week and it says, new report shows that when it comes to 1.00
00:14:34 leadership, Canada's political parties aren't getting more diverse. And if it's even possible,
00:14:39 the conservatives seem to be getting paler. So I feel like this is a tweet like void of any reality
00:14:45 because, uh, first of all, you know, Canada's political parties aren't getting any more diverse.
00:14:51 I don't know that that's factually probably true. I mean, there's four major parties and one of the
00:14:57 leaders is Sikh. So that's pretty diverse from a Canadian perspective. I don't, I don't really
00:15:02 understand the tweet. And then to go even further, the conservatives are getting even paler. Well,
00:15:06 Sam, there's four leadership candidates running for the current leader of the party. And one of them is
00:15:12 Leslie Lewis, who is a black woman. So presumably when it comes to diversity, that's, that's sort of,
00:15:18 you know, doing a lot better than the other parties, because at least we have a conservative
00:15:23 black female that's in the running. That's one of the top four contenders to, to become the next 1.00
00:15:28 person to take on Justin Trudeau in the next election. So this, this tweet just obviously
00:15:33 didn't, uh, put a lot of research or thought into it before it came out. What did you, uh,
00:15:38 what did you make of it? Well, see the thing with the problem with this, the problem with this game
00:15:43 is that if you want to play the game to the end, then no one is ever going to win. And I'll give
00:15:48 you, I'll give you an example of what I mean. So in the tweet, they said that the party's getting
00:15:52 paler. Okay. Look at me. I might be pretty pale. People might say I'm pretty white, but both of my
00:15:58 parents are from the Middle East. My mom's family is from Syria and Northern Israel, that whole region.
00:16:03 And my dad's family is from Turkey. They have been for hundreds of years, both of them. I have my
00:16:07 family tree on both sides, but yet I might be considered a white person or have white privilege or be white
00:16:13 passing. And a Syrian refugee is now a person of color because they happen to be literally from
00:16:19 Syria where, because I was born here now I'm, I'm suddenly not. And so just saying that the 0.95
00:16:25 party's getting paler in and of itself, I can pull apart that entire tweet on literally one word that
00:16:29 you chose to smear the party or to talk about our politics. Like there's no end to this game because
00:16:36 again, you know, I just dug up their tweet and exposed a flaw in like two seconds. So you really have to
00:16:41 look at the representation of the party, the party members, do they have some sort of policies or
00:16:47 some sort of, you know, is there something that's preventing minorities or people of color or, or
00:16:52 something else that, that is stopping them from getting engaged, though it is somehow making it
00:16:56 unattractive to be engaged with that party. Now, if you look at just standard conservatism or small
00:17:01 government, fiscal conservatism, that kind of stuff, I don't really know what's, um, what's interesting
00:17:06 or disinteresting to any person based on their race, ethnicity, gender, whatever. That's just,
00:17:10 you know, just policy things. So it's pretty offensive in and of to say, to say that. And
00:17:15 if you look at the house of commons, I don't think you can, you know, adequately make that,
00:17:19 make that statement based on the representation of what the population of Canada truly is.
00:17:23 Right. It's like the lowest common denominator, like ignorant tweet. And you're right, 0.99
00:17:28 using that word paler, there's just such a racial implication that like being white is bad. So being 0.99
00:17:34 paler is like a dig, I guess. I don't like race based, you know, I mean, I guess that's the 1.00
00:17:40 basis of comedy is usually poking fun at people and stuff like that. But really, this is where
00:17:45 our government resources are going. And again, I, you know, the basic like knee jerk accusation that
00:17:50 comes from the far left against conservatives is that they're racist. And I think the basis of it,
00:17:55 it's usually a ghost hunt. They're trying to find justifications, but I think the basic
00:17:59 rationale is that conservatives tend to be more prone to tradition and promote, uh, protecting
00:18:04 institutions and stuff. And so they, they think that that must be because they're trying to like
00:18:08 maintain some kind of privilege, which is, is, is such a misnomer. And it's, it's sort of a lazy
00:18:13 argument, Sam, but you know, the reality of course, is that the first ever Muslim MP in Canada was a
00:18:18 conservative, Raheem Jaffer out in Edmonton. Uh, the first ever Chinese MP was a conservative,
00:18:24 Douglas Zhang. The first ever black member of parliament in Canada was a conservative,
00:18:29 Lincoln Alexander. So, you know, it's, it's an easy, stupid punchline joke, but the reality 0.99
00:18:34 is empirically untrue. And, and, and in fact, the conservatives do attract a large number of 0.99
00:18:41 people from diverse communities, mostly because they promote that sort of traditional ideas,
00:18:45 sort of family at the forefront. And when you think about immigrants and people that come to Canada,
00:18:50 you know, they come as a family unit, family, community, church, that's everything to them.
00:18:55 And, and, and I just say churches as a, as a, as a coverall for any religious institution,
00:18:59 uh, be it, you know, whether they're Jewish or Muslim or Buddhist or whatever, uh, you know,
00:19:03 those are their core institutions that they believe in. And those also happen to be
00:19:07 the sort of core values among conservatives, which is why conservatives tend to be pretty
00:19:11 diverse. So lame attempt there at this, uh, comedy by the CBC. And again, I think, uh, instead of
00:19:17 focusing on defunding the police, we should be focusing on defunding, um, divisive institutions
00:19:22 like the CBC. But Sam, let's talk about that mainstream idea, that suddenly mainstream idea that's
00:19:28 come about in the last two weeks, that it is time to defund the police. So you see it everywhere.
00:19:34 Uh, you know, I, I, I've mentioned this a couple of times, but it drives me crazy. Like the front
00:19:39 cover of the weekend version of the, the weekend edition of the national post last year, last weekend,
00:19:43 sorry, said defund the police. And that, you know, even in the supposedly conservative, uh,
00:19:49 newspaper in Canada, you know, you see it in the Toronto star and you kind of expect it,
00:19:52 but when you see the national post, it's like, okay, wow, this is totally become a mainstream
00:19:57 idea that you hear on every news station, every radio station. They're all talking about it. Even
00:20:02 the city of Toronto has now announced that they will be slashing their budget by $122 million,
00:20:08 which is approximately 10%. And when I first heard that, I was like, okay, uh, I'm sure there's 10%
00:20:13 redundancies and, and, and, uh, things that can easily be cut without people noticing. Uh, hopefully
00:20:18 that equates to maybe a decrease on taxes because I live in Toronto and believe me, the property taxes on
00:20:24 my house are absurd and the land transfer tax and all that other stuff. But no, uh,
00:20:29 the money's not going back to taxpayers, Sam. It's going towards other services that they decided
00:20:34 to reallocate. So it's not, it's not actually trimming government. It's just punishing the
00:20:37 police presumably for, uh, you know, something that happened in another country. Uh, what,
00:20:43 what do you think of the whole defund the police movement and how it's become so mainstream?
00:20:47 Well, so, you know, from, uh, from like a marketing or advocacy perspective, I understand
00:20:52 they make shocking accusations or shocking headlines. These are like attention grabbers,
00:20:56 right? You say something sort of outlandish that is devoid of context that, you know,
00:21:01 nobody really understands. And you're like, oh my God, they, they want to defund the police.
00:21:04 Like what's that? But the problem is you have to then follow up with some sort of policy,
00:21:09 something that you actually want to talk about. So now if you want to say, as we were just saying
00:21:15 here, you know, the police budget is inflated. There's too many redundancies. They're not effective
00:21:20 in the roles that we expect police to be effective in. You know, they've been, for example, they've
00:21:25 been saddled with a lot of mental health issues. A lot of the calls that they report to, um, you know,
00:21:29 it might be, it might be a mental health issue and there might be some other way that we can deal
00:21:33 with that better, but without that plan. And that's, that's the problem with, um, you know,
00:21:38 when you start becoming this sort of like large mass protest movement is there's ultimately no
00:21:43 clear or coherent messaging. So maybe the original people who came up with this
00:21:47 defund the police actually mean let's move money from police to other services. But the problem is
00:21:53 then the message is totally, totally diluted because now every single person is putting a
00:21:58 hashtag and they're putting their own spin on it. And if you're a policymaker, I mean,
00:22:01 let's just think about it rationally for a second. You're a policymaker. You actually want to do this
00:22:06 thing. You know what? The people have spoken. I want to defund the police. Okay. So I'm just
00:22:10 literally just going to slash budgets. That sounds pretty conservative to me, just cutting
00:22:13 people's budgets pretty flatly. Um, what, like, what are you supposed to do? Where's,
00:22:17 where's the advice? Where's the recommendations that are, that you're being given as a policymaker?
00:22:21 What, what do you take away from this? Yeah, that's a great point because, you know,
00:22:25 conservatives have long been calling for things like reform in public sector unions. I think one of
00:22:30 the major issues that we're finding with, uh, you know, when it comes to police brutality,
00:22:35 particularly in the U S is that bad cops can't get fired. And a lot of that is because of police
00:22:41 unions and public sector unions that have negotiated. So, and here in Canada, I was just
00:22:46 reading this morning that the average, uh, the average police officer in Canada gets paid a hundred
00:22:51 grand a year. Uh, that's a, that's a pretty good salary. I'm not saying that they don't deserve it.
00:22:54 I think they probably do. But the idea that, you know, these public sector unions, uh, wield so much
00:22:59 power and control that they often do end up with sort of inflated budgets and lots of money that
00:23:05 can sometimes go towards things that aren't the best use. I'd be all for that, but you're right.
00:23:09 When they come forward with this, like really extreme sort of inflammatory statement, like
00:23:14 defund the police, I think, I think they lose many people that might otherwise be on board. Like,
00:23:19 you know, if, if you, if you might be on board, you know, like you and I are to maybe going through
00:23:25 the police department, seeing if there's too much money being spent or thinking about ways that we can
00:23:29 make the police service more effective, or maybe, you know, in certain cases, not always using
00:23:33 police officers, but using other types of workers. But as soon as you hear the defund the police,
00:23:38 it's like, what are you talking about? So it's like anarchy. And, you know, I would be for cutting
00:23:43 literally every other program in government. I think that the, the, the very last thing that you
00:23:48 should get rid of, you know, even in a perfect ideal society would be police. The, the, the basic
00:23:53 role, the foundational role of the state, after all, is to preserve order, law and order.
00:23:59 So, so you can get rid of literally every other government department and, and, and it's really
00:24:03 the security and safety of the people that is foundational and we need police. So the inflammatory
00:24:08 idea, I think, loses a lot of people. And, and then even when you dissect it a little more, Sam,
00:24:13 because I have been reading into this a little bit, I, I, I try to at least understand the arguments
00:24:17 that they're better being made. And a lot of times it's like, hey, you know, if you have a homeless
00:24:21 person or if you have someone who's suffering from mental illness or someone who's addicted to drugs,
00:24:25 it's not always the best idea to send a police officer in to deal with them. Like there are
00:24:29 other, you know, you could send in a, a health ex, mental health expert or addictions therapist
00:24:34 expert or a social worker into these situations instead of always relying on the police. Well,
00:24:40 my, my, my only criticism of that is that that's like literally already the policy in a lot of these
00:24:44 police departments, especially in Canada. I think a lot of times we see a conflation of issues in
00:24:49 Canada versus issues in the United States. And the reason that police end up sometimes going into
00:24:54 wellness checks and sometimes going in to deal with people who are suffering from, you know,
00:25:00 drug hallucinations or that kind of thing is usually because they are considered armed and dangerous.
00:25:04 So, so a social worker cannot go in because it's not safe for them. So they send up police because
00:25:09 it's their job to deal with violent situations. So again, the idea I think is just sort of overblown
00:25:16 and they're capitalizing on this moment where there was a really horrific example of police brutality
00:25:21 in the United States. And so they're trying to use that to see sweeping changes in Canada.
00:25:26 And I think that we should resist against that.
00:25:30 I think it's funny you touched on that. We've been chatting about this. It, it bothers me to no end
00:25:35 the importation of American rhetoric. I mean, you know, on one hand, I don't blame people. We're steeped
00:25:41 in American movies. We're steeped in American culture. Um, you know, people in, in other countries
00:25:46 don't know what, uh, you know, a senior, junior, freshman, all that kind of stuff is. And we, you
00:25:50 know, we tend to, if you watch enough American movies, you know, you know what this is, even
00:25:52 though it doesn't exist in this country. And so it's not surprising that you might feel that problems
00:25:57 they have in the States is a problem that we have here. The problem is that we're not having
00:26:03 conversations about issues in Canada. We can't talk about what's going on here. And when you want to
00:26:08 try and solve a Canadian problem, like what's going on on the streets of Toronto with, with gun violence or,
00:26:13 or anti-black racism, we can't look at that because we're so busy talking about police brutality in
00:26:19 the States. We're not looking at whether that brutality exists in the same form here,
00:26:24 whether racism exists in the same form here. Um, you know, I've, I think I've heard a long time
00:26:28 ago, something about how, uh, Canadian racism is more polite and sort of, you know, a joke about
00:26:33 how Canadians are more polite. And so fine. Maybe our, our discrimination is different in this
00:26:38 country, but we can never look at it because we're so busy protesting about something they're doing
00:26:42 in the States. We're not bothering to look at what are the causes or what are the effects on,
00:26:46 on the populace in this country. And it's really unfortunate because the people who are suffering
00:26:51 are going to continue suffering because no one is ever going to have that conversation in this
00:26:54 country. Unless we start abandoning this American rhetoric and have real Canadian discussions that,
00:26:59 that goes for every political leader of all, of all stripes and all levels.
00:27:01 Uh, yeah, absolutely. Like, and, and I think one of the other things that happens there is that when
00:27:05 Canadians do make that point that you're just making like, Hey, look, America has a very different
00:27:09 history than we do. And therefore we don't have the same issues as a result of consequences of
00:27:14 history. Then you sort of get accused that like saying, Oh, well, you just glossed it over. Like,
00:27:19 like you're defending Canada based on saying we're not as bad at the U S, but that doesn't mean that we
00:27:23 don't have our own problems here. It's like, no, we should establish some ground rules. Like Canada
00:27:27 was established after slavery was abolished in the British empire. So Canada as a country never had the
00:27:33 institution of slavery. It never existed in Canada, quite the opposite. Canada was the location where 0.99
00:27:39 a lot of freed slave from the United States came to have their freedom or, or, or after the war,
00:27:45 the revolutionary war, um, a lot of black Americans came to Canada because they were promised freedom
00:27:51 by the British empire. So, you know, there are important points in history that we should point
00:27:54 out to say, why are history different? We never had the discriminatory Jim Crow laws like the United
00:27:59 States did. That's not to say that, that no racism exists in Canada, Sam, it's just to say that we
00:28:04 have a different historical experience. We should base our conversations on what's happened in Canada,
00:28:09 Canada, and not to your point, trying to import the rhetoric from the United States. It's a really
00:28:13 good point. But again, a lot of that is lost today because there's just, uh, everyone is afraid to have
00:28:19 these conversations and, and everyone is afraid of getting canceled or, uh, you know, having the mob
00:28:25 come against them. Well, it's not just Toronto, Sam, that's talking about defunding their police
00:28:30 budgets or reducing the police budgets. Uh, budgets are under review in Vancouver, Victoria,
00:28:36 Edmonton, as protesters call for anti-racism reform. So hearing from local politicians in all,
00:28:42 all, uh, a handful of Canadian cities, uh, with the same, same rhetoric, same ideas. Um,
00:28:49 there is a black lives matter petition to divest police funding in Edmonton. So take away the funding
00:28:55 from the police and put it elsewhere. And, uh, yeah, they're really starting to gain traction. So,
00:29:01 uh, interesting times. And I hope that, uh, you know, politicians can, can, can find the nerve to
00:29:08 defend, uh, police institutions because they're just so foundational. Premier Ford in Ontario did
00:29:13 say that he opposes, uh, the defunding of police and we got a clip of that. So let's, uh, let's play
00:29:18 Premier Ford saying that he does not believe in defunding the police. All right. Thank you. My next
00:29:24 question is for the Premier specifically. Um, and it's on another topic. Premier, there are calls to
00:29:29 defund police services right across North America. The OPP is a billion-dollar operation under your
00:29:35 purview. What are your thoughts on defunding police in general? And specifically your thoughts on
00:29:40 defunding the OPP? Well, I don't believe in that for a second. I think we need a strong, uh,
00:29:47 police, uh, within our communities. What we do need to do is have higher standards. We need to, uh,
00:29:55 focus on more training. I think I'm a big believer as, as Chief Saunders always believed,
00:30:01 uh, in community policing, get involved in, in the community, learning, uh, more about your community.
00:30:08 Uh, that, that's what I believe in. But, uh, I just don't believe in, you know, uh, cutting, uh, police
00:30:14 budgets. I just never believed in that. So good to see a little bit of voice of reason left in,
00:30:20 in some politicians anyway. Uh, but you can't say that across the board. So there was a Black Lives 0.99
00:30:26 Matter protest, Sam, out in Alberta, in Edmonton. And this is a pretty shocking story. So they barred
00:30:33 entry to the event of Alberta's Minister of Municipal Affairs, Casey Maddow. So he's banned from speaking at
00:30:41 this event, at this anti-racism protest. The problem is that Maddow, who was born in Africa,
00:30:48 is Black himself. So I think this really points to the idea that these protests are not really
00:30:53 about race. They're more about ideology. So they would rather hear from a white guy who just happens
00:30:59 to be part of their ideological tribe than an actual Black person who is in a position of authority and 0.51
00:31:04 power in the country and can speak about his experiences. They, they don't want to hear about,
00:31:09 they don't want to hear from him because he happens to be a conservative, which is pretty
00:31:13 disappointing, but not at all surprising. So Alberta Minister of Municipal Affairs, Casey Maddow,
00:31:20 took to social media to record his own video. And this is what he had to say.
00:31:25 Hello, Casey Maddow here. Last Friday, I was invited to speak at this stage behind me about my lived
00:31:35 experience with racism. I was looking forward to standing with the organizers and our community
00:31:41 until the NDP and the allies intervened to have my invitation rescinded. To add insult to injury,
00:31:49 the NDP MLA for Edmonton Whitemouth, Rocky Pancholi, told me to, and I quote, reflect on why I wasn't
00:31:57 welcome. Well, Emily Pancholi, I have reflected and all I can see is that I am Black and yes, I am
00:32:07 conservative. This is the same NDP whose propaganda armed press progress called me a white supremacist
00:32:14 during the last election. An election where my opponent told voters to vote as if their skin was not
00:32:22 white. I say enough divisive NDP politics. I have always spoken openly and honestly about my lived
00:32:32 experience with racism. Racism is real and we all must work together to fight it. The scourge of racism
00:32:40 is bigger than our politics and it's also bigger than our political parties. Let's stop the divisive
00:32:48 NDP and left-wing politics and vow to destroy racism together. So that must be pretty disappointing
00:32:56 to not be welcome at an anti-racist protest. You know, even if that's something that he strongly
00:33:01 believes in, but you're not welcome as a speaker just because of your political affiliation. What
00:33:06 do you make of that, Sam? Well, again, you know, this is the problem when you start playing this game
00:33:11 is that you either get to a situation where nobody wins or you simply sideline people who
00:33:18 should not be because they're probably... Look, his black experience is probably similar to a lot
00:33:23 of other black Canadians. The fact that he's a minister... If I saw him on the street, I would
00:33:27 have no idea who it is, right? If someone is a racist person, his position is not preventing him
00:33:32 from suffering racism or institutional racism or any other type of difficulty that is going to be caused
00:33:38 because of the color of his skin. At the same time, you know, focusing simply just on how much melanin
00:33:44 is in his skin ignores other factors that may contribute to your experience. So for example,
00:33:50 you might have, you know, different, you might come from a different class, right? You might come
00:33:54 from a different, you might have a different mother tongue, different language. You might be an
00:33:57 immigrant or not an immigrant. You might be in a poorer part of the country or wealthier part of the 0.99
00:34:01 country. You might be from a more rural place or more urban place. All of these things are going to
00:34:05 contribute to your, you know, your life experience. You know, I don't like these buzzwords. I almost said
00:34:10 lived experience, but I believe in the concept, you know, people's life experience does make a
00:34:14 difference. But saying that he has literally nothing, like, that's what it is. He has literally
00:34:19 nothing of value to add. You, sir, have nothing of value to add to this conversation because you
00:34:25 happen to be a member of the UCP. Like, that's insane. He clearly is going to have some experiences 0.52
00:34:30 the same as other people. But to tell him that, you know what, you're probably of the wrong party.
00:34:35 You have nothing to contribute to this conversation. Quite the opposite. You should bring him there
00:34:40 and tell him, oh, hear what he's got to say. I had this experience. I had that experience. I'm like
00:34:44 you. Okay, Mr. Minister, I'll tell you why you're not like me. Because A, B, C, D, and this is what
00:34:50 you're missing. And this is what you need to advocate for. What happened to that? What happened
00:34:54 to reaching out to, like, he's literally in a position of power. Why can't we try and get him on
00:34:58 our side? Try and explain to him. That's, again, what I used to do for many years is advocacy. And that's
00:35:04 trying to get politicians to do something that you would like them to do, which is hopefully for the
00:35:08 betterment of society. So it's not just lobbying for, you know, some sector or something. But
00:35:13 what happened to reaching out to politicians? They're never going to agree with you or even
00:35:16 understand you if you just sideline them. But, you know, I guess it's much easier to sideline
00:35:21 them than to have some difficult discussions and maybe realize that you are not 100% correct,
00:35:25 or the way you're looking at something is not the only worldview. Right. Well, they're not really
00:35:29 interested in having a conversation or learning anything. They're just more interested in pounding
00:35:33 their fists and asserting their control. I think this proves because you're right. You know,
00:35:38 if they had allowed Minister Madhu to come and speak, maybe they would even find that they had
00:35:44 shared experiences with him and they could bridge a gap between the other party of the other ideology
00:35:49 and say, wow, you know what, we have more in common with conservatives than we thought,
00:35:53 creating more unity in society, which is what we really need right now. We need to talk about the
00:35:58 things that unite us, as opposed to things that divide us. So again, just pretty disappointing
00:36:04 stuff. Next story I want to talk about, Sam, which is kind of interesting and a little bit,
00:36:08 I don't know if this is a conflict of interest or what, but we learned this week that the Canadian 0.95
00:36:13 Foreign Affairs Minister, Francois-Philippe Champagne, has two registered residential mortgages
00:36:19 with the state-owned Bank of China in London, which opposition says opens him to personal
00:36:28 financial vulnerability at a time when Beijing relations are at a standstill. I find this just
00:36:35 a little bit of an odd story, just, you know, the facts of it. You know, why does the Foreign Affairs
00:36:40 Minister of Canada have two multimillion dollar properties in London, England? He's not from England,
00:36:46 England. He's French. So why does he have, and then he has these massive mortgages. I mean,
00:36:51 1.7 million dollars for one home and 1.2 million dollars for the other. I don't know the value of
00:36:56 the home, but, you know, usually you can't get a very big percentage mortgage when it comes to
00:37:01 properties that big. And then why would he go to a state-owned Chinese bank when there are like
00:37:07 hundreds of other banks that he could have gone to, including Canadian banks? It just seems like a
00:37:11 really weird story. And I feel like it does sort of make him vulnerable or a bit of a conflict
00:37:16 because we've heard him defend China so many times. And it's like, well, the guy's doing business
00:37:20 with the Chinese government state-owned banks, and he's the foreign minister representing Canada.
00:37:26 I don't know why this stuff wasn't disclosed a lot earlier either. What did you make of this story,
00:37:30 Sam? Well, I think it's really what the Conservatives said, but to expand on it, it's if you want to turn
00:37:37 the screws on someone, right, you want to influence them and you want to apply some kind of pressure.
00:37:41 So you could apply pressure because he's a foreign minister. You can say that as China,
00:37:45 you know, we're going to do something about trade. We're going to, you know, bar this or purchase
00:37:49 that. You know, there's a lot of things they could say. If you want to turn the screws on him
00:37:52 personally, and I don't think it's a stretch to say that China or the Chinese government has used
00:37:58 Chinese industries or Chinese companies to affect, you know, the relations or to meddle in different
00:38:05 political interests in other countries. But look, it obviously leaves him open because that's
00:38:09 something they could turn the screws on him. They could suddenly decide that either they're selling his
00:38:13 mortgage, they're renegotiating, maybe he's up for an interest rate renewal. Suddenly they're going to,
00:38:17 you know, quote him at a 27 percent interest. Again, it's not that, you know, even if he loses
00:38:22 this house and he goes bankrupt, it's that's not to say that he's going to now suddenly do whatever
00:38:27 China says as the foreign minister. But it's simply, it's something that it's not necessary,
00:38:32 you didn't necessarily need to do. And even if it, this just so happened to be that he had the mortgage
00:38:37 from this bank, he probably should be, or any government official should be aware,
00:38:41 and especially him as the foreign minister, he should be aware that this is something that you
00:38:45 are now vulnerable on a personal level, that if you were, if you're going to have this risk,
00:38:50 you should think about it and you should make sure it's not coloring or influencing your decisions,
00:38:54 because it might, like, we're all human. You know, I don't need to fault the guy overly,
00:38:58 but we're all human. If they're going to tell him suddenly we're going to cancel your mortgage or
00:39:01 we're going to, you know, do something to you personally, he might, you know,
00:39:04 he might change a couple of words in a speech or he might soften something that he wanted to say.
00:39:09 Right. And that's, that's not good for the country. That's not how
00:39:11 foreign relations should be conducted. And so it's, it's, it's a, it's a blind spot. 0.97
00:39:15 It's a personal vulnerability. Is it the end of the world? I don't know yet,
00:39:18 because it hasn't happened yet. They haven't done it to him, but it's definitely a vulnerability.
00:39:22 And it's a, it's a very fair point. Well, we don't know that it hasn't happened yet.
00:39:26 I mean, I know that he refused to say the word Taiwan, maybe, maybe they already airtight 0.93
00:39:29 in the screws, Sam, but no, I think, I think the real concern is, is not even something
00:39:33 actually happening. It's just the appearance. Like, you know, the guy's a Canadian minister
00:39:37 of foreign affairs, you know, for Canada. Why is he off doing, doing business with the Chinese?
00:39:42 It looks bad. And it makes people question, you know, exactly where his allegiance stand,
00:39:47 in some regard. And, you know, interestingly, this week as well, Aaron O'Toole, leader of the
00:39:54 Conservative Party has released a very substantive policy platform. I think it was like 50 pages,
00:40:01 which is a lot better than what Peter McKay released a few weeks ago, which was like,
00:40:04 you know, eight points, and each eight points had four bullet points, and there was not much
00:40:08 information. So this is a bit more of a substantive piece of policy proposal. There were some pretty
00:40:14 good aspects of it. He has some interesting ideas about reducing emissions and sort of promoting
00:40:22 Canadian energy, but bringing in different methods of collecting energy, including nuclear. He has some
00:40:30 policies on allowing more competition in Canada for airlines and telecom companies. He has detailed
00:40:38 further his plan to eliminate funding for the CBC. So he talks about eliminating funding for the
00:40:44 digital operations. He wants to privatize English language CBC television. And this was really
00:40:49 interesting too. He plans on invoking the notwithstanding clause to bring back mandatory minimum sentences
00:40:55 for serious crimes, including murder, kidnapping, sexual assault, and trafficking of illegal guns.
00:41:02 The criticism came because this policy platform was not costed, meaning we have no idea how much it's
00:41:07 going to cost. We don't know the full impact. Although he did have a policy where he said that every
00:41:12 dollar that he increases in spending would directly correlate with a reduction in a dollar of government
00:41:17 spending elsewhere. So presumably, it wouldn't grow, but he had no timeline for balancing the budget,
00:41:23 which I don't like to see that. But you know, we have no idea how much Justin Trudeau is spending.
00:41:28 Justin Trudeau just sort of stuck his foot on the gas when it came to spending. And I think we're
00:41:33 going to have about a $250 billion deficit this year. So it's hard to say exactly when you would
00:41:39 be able to get rid of that one when Trudeau hasn't even given a fiscal update because he doesn't even
00:41:44 know how much he's spending at this point. So that's pretty interesting. And one of the things I was
00:41:49 pleased to see was that Erin O'Toole's immigration policy seems to be reflecting
00:41:55 some of the policies that we've reported on here at True North. So there is an emphasis on private
00:42:01 refugee sponsorship, which I am a big fan of, and I've been writing about that for years.
00:42:04 There is also a little bit about reducing the need for skilled labor, immigration, temporary
00:42:14 foreign workers until the Canadian economy recovers, which just makes basic economic sense.
00:42:19 So I was pleased to see that. I don't quite understand why he wants to increase
00:42:23 family reunification policies, which don't do a lot of good for the economy or for combating
00:42:30 aging population. So I didn't like that. But I was pleased, Sam, to see that he – it looks like 1.00
00:42:36 he's paying attention to True North and reading some of our stuff on immigration. That's good.
00:42:41 And then speaking of immigration, we had a new report out this week that showed that the vast
00:42:47 majority, Sam, the overwhelming majority, three-quarters of Canadians, would like to see a total
00:42:52 pause on immigration. They would like to completely halt our immigration programs for the time being,
00:42:56 until the economy recovers, until the coronavirus threat has passed. So this is based on a scientific
00:43:02 research poll conducted by One, which is a research company based out of Toronto.
00:43:07 Three-quarters of Canadians, 76%, strongly agree or moderately agree with the statement,
00:43:12 Canada should temporarily pause immigration until a vaccine is developed for coronavirus
00:43:16 and the unemployment rate drops down to pre-coronavirus levels. What I found really
00:43:21 interesting about this study, this poll, Sam, is that it doesn't really matter what demographic
00:43:27 you're looking at in Canada, whether it be by age, by region, by province, by language,
00:43:32 male or female, at any education level, any income level, any political party that they voted for,
00:43:38 every single category had a majority of people saying that they wanted to pause immigration,
00:43:44 which I haven't seen that before. I mean, 67% of Liberal voters said they wanted to pause,
00:43:48 89% of Conservative voters wanted to pause, just an overwhelming majority of people. So it seems like
00:43:55 it's pretty common sense policy, although I haven't seen any Conservative leadership candidate propose it,
00:44:01 and I certainly haven't seen any of the other political parties willing to talk about it. I know
00:44:06 people think right now there is a pause on immigration, because Justin Trudeau's announced that
00:44:09 the borders are closed. The border closure, however, mostly just applies to tourists. People who come
00:44:15 for work still get in. The temporary foreign worker program is still up and running. There are
00:44:19 still lots and lots of immigrants coming to Canada. So the immigration programs right now have not been
00:44:24 paused, but Canadians would like to see a pause. What did you think about this study? Well, you know,
00:44:28 everything is wild now because of the coronavirus crisis. I think people are examining an issue
00:44:36 that I don't think they thought about, or they've been thinking about it in a way that is strictly,
00:44:41 you know, political rhetoric. Immigrants are maybe a group because they are all newcomers to this 1.00
00:44:47 country, but there are different types of immigrants. And I don't mean, I'm not all talking about where
00:44:52 they're coming from. I'm simply talking about, are they students? They get work visas, they become
00:44:56 permanent residents, they're refugees. So there's literally different types of immigrants. And I think what
00:45:02 people in this country are thinking about right now is that we have so much crazy stuff going on.
00:45:08 When you bring in people, and we need to bring in people at some point, right? Population is a
00:45:13 resource. Ultimately, our economy can only grow and grow at a much faster rate if we have more people.
00:45:18 The US economy is not only successful and large because of the type of industries that they have,
00:45:23 but they have a very large population. So the more people you have, that's going to have a direct
00:45:27 effect on your economy, especially for a growing economy, or the way that we're looking to grow
00:45:32 our economy as opposed to large countries that already exist. But I think people want to have
00:45:39 that conversation about what does this mean? Hold on. Everything is kind of crazy. Let's pause this.
00:45:43 And I think that's for a lot of people who were talking about immigration. I think that's a stance
00:45:48 that we've always taken. I mean, I had questions, not even concerns. I just had questions about,
00:45:53 for example, the Syrian refugees who came in. I had questions. I was not opposed to bringing in 1.00
00:46:01 refugees. And I think Canada is a successful country. We've been blessed. I think we can,
00:46:06 even if it's strictly a helping people out kind of thing, or bringing them in because we need them,
00:46:11 and we like their skills. But I had questions because some of these people, they're coming from
00:46:15 a country in which the society is steeped in antisemitism. And so I simply had questions. I wasn't
00:46:21 opposed to anything. I didn't take any firm stance. I literally just had questions. And I think way
00:46:25 back years ago, that's something you and I spoke of. And I think a lot of Canadians are now starting
00:46:29 to have questions. And that's okay. We can have questions about what is immigration in this country
00:46:34 going to look like? Where are all these people settling? Are they all tending to go to Toronto,
00:46:39 Montreal? What are all these things going to look like? Are they going to integrate? And what does that
00:46:45 mean? What does it mean to integrate? There's a lot of questions that you can have without ever
00:46:50 discussing anything that's remotely politically difficult. And I think we need to have that
00:46:54 conversation. And I hope that this survey will mean that, I hope the survey means that people are
00:46:59 having that conversation in their own houses and with themselves. Because I think it's a conversation
00:47:03 we need to have. Exactly. I think you're right. And I think that, I mean, I think you could even go
00:47:09 beyond questions. I mean, I've been studying this issue for years and years and years. And I have more
00:47:14 than questions, I have concerns. I think that there are major issues with integration in this country. A lot of it is
00:47:19 policy-driven. As an example, Justin Trudeau eliminated the English language or French
00:47:24 language requirement for a lot of new citizens. He cut down the amount of time he had to spend
00:47:28 in Canada to become a citizen, down to just three years part-time. And you can see the repercussions,
00:47:33 not just of those policies in the last few years, Sam, but of decades of open immigration without the real 0.94
00:47:41 dedication towards the heavy lifting, the difficult part, which is integration and making sure that
00:47:46 people fit in. And that's why you see in cities like Vancouver, my hometown, you know,
00:47:51 you have entire areas where you'll never hear English spoken. And all of the signs are in Mandarin.
00:47:56 And you just don't even really feel like you're in Canada. And you have people going to public
00:48:01 schools in Richmond, BC. And, you know, if they attend a pro-Hong Kong, pro-democracy protest,
00:48:08 they get threatening letters from sort of their classmates who are pro-Chinese-communist
00:48:14 dictatorship, who are bringing their attitudes to Canada. And I find it disheartening to look
00:48:20 at my country and see that kind of stuff happening. And so I think it's only natural when you have
00:48:26 a really large-scale immigration program, like we do in Canada, that every now and then we just take
00:48:30 a pause and say, okay, we've let a lot of people into our country. Let's make sure that everyone's doing
00:48:35 okay. That people are settling, that we're remaining sort of a harmonious, united country.
00:48:41 And I think taking pauses every now and then from immigration, just to ensure that the people who 0.77
00:48:46 are currently here feel that they are connecting to the Canadian family, I think it's important. And
00:48:52 I hope that people look at the report that True North put out in the scientific study that we had
00:48:58 commissioned and yeah, ask some of the questions and talk about some of these issues that you and I
00:49:03 are talking about here. Well, that's also the thing. I mean, it's not just we don't want immigrants or 1.00
00:49:08 we like immigrants, we don't like immigrants. It's literally the people that are here. Are they 1.00
00:49:13 able to fully participate in Canadian society? Are they going to be able to partake of all the
00:49:18 benefits? I mean, fine, they're going to have responsibilities as well, but we don't want people 0.61
00:49:23 to come to this country to then be prisoners in their own community, in their own language,
00:49:28 and never be able to fully participate in the labor force. It must suck if you can't really go 0.73
00:49:33 out for a walk in the evening downtown and then sit at the cafe because you don't know the language.
00:49:39 I mean, that's got to be pretty depressing if you're just shut out of parts of society. And
00:49:44 obviously it's difficult. You move from a different country, you might be older, it might be more
00:49:47 difficult for you to learn the language, acclimatize. The problem is really, are we making an effort to
00:49:52 reach out to these people? And that's what you just said. We want to check on the people that are
00:49:56 here, make sure that they're doing okay, they're fully participating. And I think that the rhetoric
00:50:00 from critics who simply, I don't even know why they jump on this, but critics want to make it
00:50:06 sound like you're after something totally different when the concern is making sure that people are
00:50:11 okay, they're doing well, they're fully participating in Canadian society. And that
00:50:15 means you have to acclimatize yourself. I couldn't move to Japan and refuse to speak any Japanese at all
00:50:20 ever and expect that I'm going to now fully partake in Japanese society. It's just,
00:50:24 it's not going to happen. I might be able to live, get services, et cetera, but I will never be able
00:50:27 to fully, fully partake in society. And that would be to my loss.
00:50:31 I totally agree with that point that you're making. And I think that there's also a public
00:50:34 safety concern. You know, the example that the Trudeau government used was say, hey, you come to
00:50:39 Canada and you're 65 and you're never going to join the workforce. What's the point of learning
00:50:43 English? And as soon as they eliminate the English language requirement, you're reducing,
00:50:47 you're eliminating the incentive for anyone to even try to learn. And so you're right,
00:50:51 they feel isolated in their community. What if heaven forbid, there was an accident and they
00:50:55 needed to reach out to emergency services and call 911? I mean, how would they even have that
00:50:59 conversation? You know, how would they be able to make friends in their community? How would they
00:51:03 be able to branch out? I mean, you're talking about a pretty lonely existence. And this is what the
00:51:07 government is, is sort of encouraging, creating incentives towards living that out, which I just
00:51:12 think is wrong. I think that as Canadians, we should take a stand and demand that our politicians
00:51:17 do more to encourage people who move to Canada to really join the Canadian family,
00:51:22 to participate more broadly in society, you know, to have that unity among all people,
00:51:27 instead of sort of isolating in these closed cultural community, which creates all kinds of
00:51:32 problems. Well, Sam, we'd like to end the show on a positive note. This is kind of a funny positive
00:51:39 note. I know Justin Trudeau went out to those protests last weekend. So after months and months of
00:51:45 nagging Canadians not to go outside as you know, it's our civic duty. And every time we go outside,
00:51:49 we're endangering people. Trudeau decided to break free of all those rules that he himself
00:51:55 set and go to a protest, basically to virtue signal. One of the things that kind of bugs me
00:52:02 is that he got down on one knee, which I don't quite understand why he did that. I think that going
00:52:08 down on a knee to me invokes the kind of argument that the cultural argument was happening in the US
00:52:13 for a couple of years around Colin Kaepernick, the San Francisco 49ers quarterback who decided to
00:52:18 kneel during the national anthem because he thought that America was a systemically racist society and
00:52:22 he didn't want to stand for the national anthem because that would, he thought, would sort of be
00:52:26 paying homage to a country that he thought was awful and racist. So the whole kneeling thing,
00:52:30 I think, to me, it conjured images of Colin Kaepernick. Some people say, oh, it's, you know,
00:52:34 in solidarity. And it's a sign of sort of peace and promoting kind of greater understanding.
00:52:43 I just thought, again, it was sort of woke, performative art. But apparently I'm not alone.
00:52:48 So True North analyzed the Twitter responses to tweets from CBC News and CTV. And it turns out that
00:52:56 70%, well, 69% of Twitter users responded negatively to these videos of Justin Trudeau kneeling. So maybe
00:53:04 his virtue signaling and his performative art didn't pan out as well as he has expected. What did you
00:53:11 think of that story, Sam? Well, you see, again, I'm all for, he wants to make some sort of symbolic
00:53:17 gesture. Fine. But you are the prime minister of this country. You can actually affect change on
00:53:24 literally any issue you think is a problem in this country. If you're going to go and take a knee and do a
00:53:30 photo op about any issue, I expect you to have some substantive or, or literally not substantive,
00:53:36 call for questions, call for solutions, call, like literally say, I want to help. I'm listening.
00:53:40 I'm listening. You know, what do you need to tell me? But that's not, it's just, I'm going to take a
00:53:44 knee, which again, has no, as you said, there's no real Canadian context. It's not clear what that
00:53:49 does in Canada. And if you're going to see, you know, fine, it's showing solidarity. All right,
00:53:53 I'll take it. As long as you're going to show me that he's going to do something, he's going to
00:53:58 say something. Now, so far, I haven't really seen anything substantive from him. I, you know,
00:54:02 there's always, there's always hope. Maybe there's no chance, but there's always hope.
00:54:07 So, you know what, if he's going to do something, fine. If not, you know, photo ops and, and virtue
00:54:11 signaling, like that's sadly, we've seen a lot, a lot from this prime minister on virtue signaling,
00:54:16 like the, the fake feminism and a lot of this stuff, which that, that's the gaslighting back to, 1.00
00:54:21 you know, to, to come, kind of come full circle. That's, that's the gaslighting saying,
00:54:24 you know, he's super woke. He's not racist. He's the guy who wore blackface. So, you know,
00:54:29 just going to leave it there. That's a good, good place to end the show. Well, Sam, thank you so
00:54:34 much for guest hosting the True North update. It's been a lot of fun and we thank everyone for,
00:54:39 for tuning in and viewing True North. Don't forget to check out our website, tnc.news to stay up to date
00:54:44 with all the latest. I'm Candace Malcolm, and this has been True North update. Have a great weekend.
00:54:51 We'll see you next time.