The Candice Malcolm Show - June 09, 2021


The politicization of terrorism

Hosted by
Mentioned
Is the media narrative getting away from the facts of this story? Trudeau embarrasses Canada on the world stage (again)

Episode Stats


Length

13 minutes

Words per minute

180.36

Word count

2,356

Sentence count

128

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

15

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Candice Malan talks about the politicization of terrorism in Canada, and the reaction to the London, Ontario attack that left 4 dead, including a 9-year-old boy, and a 15-year old girl, in critical condition.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hi, I'm Candice Malcolm and this is the Candice Malcolm Show.
00:00:07 Today, on today's episode, I want to talk about the politicization of terrorism that
00:00:13 happens in this country.
00:00:14 I'm talking, of course, about this absolutely horrific attack that took place on Sunday
00:00:19 evening in London, Ontario, where a driver drove his truck into a family, killing four
00:00:26 people, including a 15-year-old girl, and leaving a nine-year-old boy in hospital in
00:00:31 critical condition while his entire family is dead.
00:00:35 It is absolutely gruesome.
00:00:37 London police have said this attack was premeditated and deliberate, and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau
00:00:43 has said that this is an act of terrorism, as the family was Muslim and they were dressed
00:00:48 in Islamic clothing.
00:00:51 Now, this is absolutely a horrible story. 0.94
00:00:54 There is nothing worse in my mind, absolutely nothing worse than the killing of children,
00:00:59 especially in Canada, especially Canadian children.
00:01:01 And look, I'm generally opposed to the death penalty.
00:01:04 I don't think that the government should have that kind of power.
00:01:06 But in cases like this, I think it was just absolutely despicable when it comes to killing
00:01:11 kids.
00:01:12 I think that we should just throw the book at this despicable man, that we should lock 0.98
00:01:15 him up and throw away the key. 0.94
00:01:18 I don't care about any of the other circumstances.
00:01:20 It's just absolutely appalling.
00:01:22 And what we're seeing in response is just an absolute outpouring of support for this
00:01:28 community, of love, of compassion, of solidarity.
00:01:32 Canadians are rightly upset and angry that this would happen in our country.
00:01:37 We want to make sure that newcomers and that all Canadians feel safe in our communities and
00:01:42 feel welcome.
00:01:42 We especially want new Canadians and newcomers to know that one deranged young man who committed
00:01:50 an evil act does not represent the broader Canadian community.
00:01:55 In fact, the broader Canadian community loathes this man and is completely against him.
00:02:00 Whatever his motivation, it doesn't matter.
00:02:03 His act was evil.
00:02:04 It was abhorrent.
00:02:05 And it was despicable.
00:02:06 For example, Canadians universally condemn murder and we universally condemn crimes that seem
00:02:12 to be motivated by anti-religious bigotry.
00:02:15 Full stop.
00:02:16 But that is not what I want to talk about on the program today.
00:02:19 What I want to talk about is the reaction.
00:02:22 What we're seeing in the media and by politicians specifically on the left and how they are reacting
00:02:27 to this despicable attack.
00:02:29 So almost immediately after the news came out and the details were learned, the left-wing
00:02:34 media pounced and they started declaring that conservative politicians and conservative
00:02:39 media were to blame.
00:02:42 Now, what many in the media and many politicians started pointing to was something called M103,
00:02:47 which was a 2017 liberal motion which sought to condemn Islamophobia and conservatives
00:02:54 by and large voted against it.
00:02:56 There was just one conservative who voted for it and that was Michael Chong.
00:02:59 Now, this is what the Toronto Star wrote in their story about this attack.
00:03:04 As politicians across Canada express their sadness over this weekend's fatal attack on
00:03:09 a Muslim family in London, Ontario, community leaders are asking some of them to explain why
00:03:14 they opposed a federal non-binding motion condemning Islamophobia in 2017 and to explain their
00:03:22 apparent change in position.
00:03:24 Okay, there's a lot wrong with this statement.
00:03:27 And so since everyone's talking about M103, I think it's worthwhile to go through what
00:03:32 the actual issue was when it came to that motion, why conservatives were against it.
00:03:36 And to the Toronto Star, there hasn't been an apparent change in position.
00:03:40 You can show sympathy for a Muslim family that was killed and you can condemn it and you can 1.00
00:03:44 find it abhorrent without wanting to get into the political debate about the term Islamophobia.
00:03:50 And that was what it was.
00:03:51 It was a politicized debate about that one word, that one word Islamophobia.
00:03:56 And it's also worth noting that the liberals at the time were deliberately creating a wedge
00:04:01 issue and the media being the media completely misrepresented what the issue actually was and
00:04:06 why conservatives didn't vote in favor of it.
00:04:08 So at the time, many conservative MPs, as well as conservative commentators, myself included,
00:04:14 opposed the language in the motion that term Islamophobia was never defined.
00:04:19 And that was a problem.
00:04:20 And it was intentional.
00:04:21 They intentionally did not define that word.
00:04:23 The word itself is obviously very controversial.
00:04:26 It was very politicized.
00:04:28 And to many, the word doesn't mean bigotry or hate or an irrational fear of Muslims.
00:04:34 It means criticizing Islam. 0.99
00:04:37 It means that the religion and the political doctrine are sort of out of bounds in terms
00:04:42 of criticism, which is the case in most Muslim countries in the world.
00:04:46 So Raheel Raza, who is a Canadian activist and the founder of the moderate Muslim group Muslims
00:04:51 Facing Tomorrow, she said this about the term.
00:04:53 She said, the term Islamophobia was coined after 9-11, you don't have to take my word 1.00
00:04:58 on it, it's all electronically available, by an operative of the Muslim Brotherhood, who
00:05:03 actually said, and is quoted to having said, that they would throw this term out there so
00:05:08 that there is no questioning, criticism, or any kind of discussion about Islam and Muslims.
00:05:14 So Raheel Raza was just one of countless Canadian Muslims who opposed M-103.
00:05:20 Tarek Fatah, another one, he's my colleague over at the Toronto Sun.
00:05:23 He says, quote, I hope to make the MPs realize that if they include the word denouncing Islamophobia
00:05:28 in their proposals, they will infringe on the inalienable right of Muslim Canadians to
00:05:33 critique their own religion, as has been the rich tradition that has been stifled by mullahs, 0.97
00:05:39 kings, and caliphs by murdering us. 0.98
00:05:41 Fatah was one of the organizers of a group called Muslims Against M-103. 0.92
00:05:46 They hosted an event that was attended by several high-profile Muslim activists.
00:05:51 Raheel Raza, who is also there, said this,
00:05:54 We are entrapped by the use of the term Islamophobia, which is not clearly defined.
00:05:59 As I read and reread the text of the motion M-103, I can agree with the overall intent,
00:06:04 but without the use of the term, because Islamophobia can and has been used to confuse the masses
00:06:10 and stifle free speech.
00:06:12 So conservative MPs were taking their lead from these Muslim activists, and they therefore 0.99
00:06:17 opposed the term Islamophobia, but not necessarily the intent behind the motion, and that was
00:06:23 why conservative MP Scott Reid simply asked the liberals to remove the controversial term
00:06:28 Islamophobia, and instead replace it with the more concise term, anti-Muslim bigotry.
00:06:34 And if they would have done that, the conservatives would have been happy to support the motion,
00:06:38 but they didn't because they were trying to create a wedge issue.
00:06:41 This was all politicized.
00:06:42 They kept in that controversial word, knowing that conservatives would be against it, and
00:06:46 knowing that they could use that to repeat the lie that conservatives are bigots, and 0.97
00:06:51 of course the media, being the media, are all too happy to play along, play dumb, and repeat 0.96
00:06:56 that idea that conservatives didn't condemn Islamophobia because they're just bigots, 0.97
00:07:00 and that's that.
00:07:02 That's that, and that's what the media decided to run with, and then, again, we're seeing
00:07:05 it this week in the aftermath of this attack, repeating the same lie that the conservatives
00:07:10 didn't support that one motion because they are bigots.
00:07:14 And now it really doesn't help, by the way, when conservative politicians are suddenly
00:07:17 more than happy now to use this politicized term Islamophobia, which we've seen this week
00:07:22 from conservative leader Aaron O'Toole.
00:07:24 What they're really doing is validating the left-wing narrative that they have had a change
00:07:28 of heart, or that the conservative position somehow in the past was wrong, that it was rooted
00:07:33 in bigotry.
00:07:34 That really doesn't help anything to go back and say, hey, efforts like the niqab ban, efforts 0.97
00:07:40 like creating a hotline to help abuse children who are the victims of cultural violence, like
00:07:46 honor killings, that creating resources to help them really just stems from dog whistle
00:07:51 politics or anti-Islamic bigotry.
00:07:55 The reality is that those efforts are taken to do community outreach.
00:07:58 Most of them came from requests from within the Muslim community, and that was why they had 1.00
00:08:03 those kind of efforts, not because there was some kind of hatred.
00:08:07 So when the conservatives concede and say that, yes, we were bigoted in the past, all
00:08:12 they're doing is seeking strange new respect from the media, and they end up validating
00:08:16 the unfair characterizations pushed by the left-wing media and also throw fellow conservatives
00:08:21 under the bus.
00:08:22 And speaking of throwing fellow conservatives under the bus, there's another narrative coming
00:08:26 out of this attack, which we've seen so much in recent weeks.
00:08:29 Anytime there's any kind of a big news story, we fall back on this same narrative that Canadians 0.99
00:08:35 by and large are horrible, racist people. 0.96
00:08:38 We've seen it left, right and center in the past few months and years, this idea that all 0.99
00:08:42 Canadians are somehow racist.
00:08:44 So we had a conservative out in London validating that. 0.88
00:08:48 Jeff Bennett, who is a 2014 candidate for the Ontario PC Party in London West, he unleashed
00:08:54 a tirade on Facebook condemning the city of London, Ontario as racist.
00:08:59 This is what he said.
00:09:01 Now, I see people expressing shock that a racist terrorist would drive his truck into the pathway
00:09:05 of a Muslim family going for a walk.
00:09:07 London is better than this, they say.
00:09:09 I can't believe this happened here.
00:09:11 Bull S. 0.65
00:09:12 He says, I won't say the word, but bull S.
00:09:14 I knocked on thousands of doors in the very neighborhood this atrocity occurred.
00:09:19 The terrorist may have been alone in that truck on that day, but he was not acting alone.
00:09:24 He was raised in a racist city that pretends it isn't.
00:09:28 Now, of course, the left-wing media is applauding this individual as brave and courageous for
00:09:33 turning on conservatives and saying the same thing that the left says about the country,
00:09:37 which is that we're all horrible racists.
00:09:39 You know, it's a really funny thing.
00:09:41 If you're a conservative and you suddenly want the respect of the media, all you have to
00:09:44 do is throw your side under the bus and repeat the very worst accusations about conservatives
00:09:50 and about all Canadians.
00:09:51 And then all of a sudden, suddenly you're a star in the media.
00:09:54 So I hate seeing that.
00:09:56 Obviously, there are racist people out there. 0.96
00:09:59 I'm not saying there aren't, but the classification that this was all done, but the idea that all
00:10:04 Canadians are racist is just nonsense.
00:10:06 You can see that now by the outpouring of love and support for Muslims in the aftermath. 1.00
00:10:10 If Canadians were truly these awful racist people, you wouldn't see that. 0.65
00:10:14 You would see people, you know, being indifferent or celebrating, which really you're not seeing 0.93
00:10:18 that other than maybe in the darkest quarters of the internet.
00:10:21 It's just not happening.
00:10:22 By and large, Canadians are good people, good-hearted, and they're not racist.
00:10:26 Now, it's really unfortunate that this PC candidate was trying to blame the broader community
00:10:32 in London, saying that this stemmed from a group of people that wasn't just one individual
00:10:36 in the car.
00:10:37 It was everybody.
00:10:38 You know, that's basically the opposite of what we're usually told.
00:10:41 When it came to the Danforth shooter who unleashed his deadly rampage in Toronto, he killed
00:10:47 a small child and a teenage girl.
00:10:49 We literally heard the opposite.
00:10:51 Even after ISIS took responsibility, even after we learned that this individual attended
00:10:55 a radical Muslim mosque, and even after it came out that his parents had told two different
00:11:00 stories.
00:11:01 His mom and his dad said opposite things when it came to his mental health background, as
00:11:06 well as the stories about where he had traveled to and whether he had gone to terrorist hotspots.
00:11:12 We were different stories.
00:11:13 None of that mattered.
00:11:14 What the media said was, A, don't blame the broader community.
00:11:17 This was an individual act.
00:11:19 Two, he was acting out of mental illness.
00:11:22 Don't look at his background or his ideology.
00:11:25 Those had nothing to do with the attack.
00:11:27 It was only mental illness, nothing to do with his ideology.
00:11:30 The media told us not to call it terrorism.
00:11:33 They said that that would be playing into what ISIS wants.
00:11:36 And finally, the police initially refused to name the perpetrator, and the media were
00:11:41 not showing pictures.
00:11:42 They refused to show pictures of this individual.
00:11:45 Well, this is kind of the opposite of what we are seeing now.
00:11:48 We're seeing blame the entire community.
00:11:50 We instantly call it terrorism.
00:11:52 The police named the individual right away and said it was deliberate.
00:11:55 Media were posting pictures of this guy, not just now as a 20-year-old, but finding pictures
00:12:01 of him when he was a teenager.
00:12:02 There was one image of him when he was like 15 years old, and no one's talking about whether
00:12:08 or not he was mentally ill, and everyone's saying that he must be a right-wing extremist
00:12:12 and that he must have been influenced by conservative media and conservative politicians.
00:12:17 And who can forget, in the instance of that Danforth killer, the media actually urged Canadians
00:12:23 to embrace the killer's family and to reach out and support them.
00:12:28 Of course, none of that's happening with the media right now.
00:12:30 The left-wing media is more than happy to politicize this tragedy.
00:12:33 They're more than happy to use it as a club to beat conservatives.
00:12:36 Look, this country is heading in a very dangerous direction, and the liberal government is more
00:12:40 than happy to take advantage of a gruesome attack to push their own radical agenda.
00:12:46 They did this exact same thing last year after the massacre in Nova Scotia.
00:12:50 They used the emotion and the fear of that attack to push through sweeping legislation
00:12:55 to ban legal firearms, and I'm sure they'll do it again if we let them.
00:13:00 Thank you so much for tuning in.
00:13:01 I'm Candace Malcolm, and this has been The Candace Malcolm Show.