The Candice Malcolm Show - September 10, 2021


Trudeau goes off the rails against independent media

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Exclusive True North polling shows the Liberals have blown a spectacular lead CBC town hall shows why O’Toole must defund the CBC

Episode Stats


Length

17 minutes

Words per minute

201.02

Word count

3,427

Sentence count

209

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

6

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Candice Malan gives her thoughts on the French debate, Trudeau goes off the rails against independent media, and why strategic voting could be the Tories' Achilles Heel. The French Debates Commission is the biggest loser in last night's debate, and we'll talk about why.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 The Debates Commission is the biggest loser in last night's French debate, Trudeau goes
00:00:04 off the rail against independent media, and we'll talk about how strategic voting could
00:00:08 be the Conservatives' Achilles heel.
00:00:10 I'm Candice Malcolm and this is The Candice Malcolm Show.
00:00:17 Hi everyone, thank you for tuning into the podcast.
00:00:19 Today it's a big day for us at True North because we have a live broadcast coming up
00:00:24 a little later on this evening.
00:00:25 We're going to go live and give you analysis and live reaction to the English debate.
00:00:32 The English debate is happening tonight from 9pm to 11pm Eastern.
00:00:35 We'll be live at 8pm.
00:00:37 You can find us on YouTube or Facebook, so make sure you check that out.
00:00:40 Now, today I want to talk about the French debate that happened last night because really,
00:00:46 let me just tell you, it was awful.
00:00:47 It was awful.
00:00:48 I watched it and I sort of wish I didn't.
00:00:50 I can't imagine how many people watched it.
00:00:52 I don't think very many.
00:00:53 The format was terrible.
00:00:54 There were way too many people on stage.
00:00:56 Look, if we want to have a debate about ideas where we invite all the candidates, all the
00:01:01 national leaders, that's one thing.
00:01:03 And we can have a debate, definitely include Maxime Bernier.
00:01:06 It was ridiculous that one poll yesterday was showing that he was polling at 10% and
00:01:10 yet he wasn't at the debate.
00:01:11 Meanwhile, we have Anna May Paul, the leader of the Green Party, polling somewhere around
00:01:15 2-3% and she was there.
00:01:17 She was really out of her place.
00:01:19 Look, I sort of feel sorry for Anna May Paul.
00:01:21 She has a pretty terrible party that seems to be going after her for her Jewish heritage
00:01:25 and it's just really ugly over the Green Party.
00:01:28 But watching her on the debate stage last night, she just seemed out of her element.
00:01:32 She didn't really have substantive ideas on most issues.
00:01:35 I could say the same thing about Jagmeet Singh.
00:01:37 I could say the same thing about Yves Blanchet, the bloc leader.
00:01:40 None of them really, really had substantive ideas for the country and looking at the stage
00:01:45 last night with the five leaders, they basically all agreed on most of the issues.
00:01:50 Most of the things that they were talking about, they all sort of agreed.
00:01:53 They had little differences here and there with their plans and in order to really care
00:01:57 about those differences, you actually have to trust the politicians to actually follow
00:02:00 through on their issues.
00:02:02 It's totally irrelevant to hear what the NDP thinks about an issue because they're never
00:02:05 going to be, they're never going to form government.
00:02:07 Jagmeet Singh is not going to become the prime minister.
00:02:09 So it's sort of irrelevant and it lost its flow because there's just too many people
00:02:14 on stage.
00:02:14 So I would have much preferred to have two different debates, one with just Trudeau and
00:02:19 Erin O'Toole, the two people who might actually become prime minister and have a battle of 0.86
00:02:23 ideas between the two of them where they really hold each other to the fire and then have
00:02:26 another debate where we have all the party leaders and let them talk about all their
00:02:30 various different ideas.
00:02:32 At least Maxine Bernier has a different perspective on most issues.
00:02:34 So it would have been a breath of fresh air to just have something different on stage.
00:02:38 But instead, we had more of the same.
00:02:40 They spent half the night completely bashing Canada's energy industry, all trying to one
00:02:45 up each other about climate change.
00:02:47 And it's really interesting because the issues that conservatives care about, the issues,
00:02:51 True North's own poll, we asked and we found that the issues that conservative voters care
00:02:55 most about are government spending and debt and jobs in the economy.
00:02:59 And those two issues were just barely, barely touched upon in the debate last night.
00:03:03 So it was a total failure.
00:03:05 Now, for me, I'll just say the most interesting part of the debate wasn't the actual debate
00:03:08 because the format was just, like I said, so bad.
00:03:12 There was barely any pushback.
00:03:13 There wasn't really any holding anyone's feet to the fire.
00:03:15 There was sort of one passionate moment where Justin Trudeau really lost it at the bloc leader
00:03:20 and said that he's just as much of a Quebecer as the bloc leader.
00:03:24 I mean, to anyone outside of Quebec, you just kind of roll your eyes at how much these guys
00:03:28 pander to Quebec and how obsessed they are with their French Quebec identity.
00:03:33 You know, this is supposed to be a national debate.
00:03:34 You're supposed to be prime minister of Canada.
00:03:36 The most passionate moment from Trudeau was him defending being a Quebecer.
00:03:40 Like, OK, like, good for you.
00:03:43 We all know you're from Quebec, Justin Trudeau.
00:03:45 But for me, the interesting part, again, is the scrums afterwards.
00:03:49 That's when journalists get to ask their own questions.
00:03:51 Again, most journalists are just as boring as these politicians, so most of the questions
00:03:55 weren't that interesting.
00:03:57 But, of course, as you probably saw, the Rebel News had an emergency court injunction, and
00:04:02 they were, once again, accredited at the last minute.
00:04:04 So if you followed True North for a while, you know that back in 2019, we were in the same
00:04:08 position.
00:04:09 Our reporter, Andrew Lawton, was also barred back then.
00:04:12 We took him to court.
00:04:12 I took him to court.
00:04:13 I was in the federal court in Toronto in 2019, and we won.
00:04:17 We got our journalists in.
00:04:18 And it was a great victory for us here at True North, but also for free speech and media
00:04:23 independence, free press all over Canada, journalists all over Canada.
00:04:27 So that was a great moment.
00:04:28 They did it again this year.
00:04:30 And once again, a federal judge said no to the Debates Commission.
00:04:33 No, you cannot pick and choose who is and who isn't a journalist.
00:04:36 The Rebel are just as much journalists, and they deserve to be there.
00:04:39 So it was great to see the Rebel. 1.00
00:04:41 They add a little bit of color, a little bit of character.
00:04:43 And unfortunately for the Rebel and their journalists, some of the politicians in the
00:04:49 debate last night just flat out refused to answer their questions.
00:04:51 So I'm talking about Jagmeet Singh, the NDP leader.
00:04:53 He was asked a very substantive question about his support of big pharma.
00:04:57 Traditionally, the left has not been big fans of big pharma.
00:05:00 And Singh himself rails into billionaires and big transnational corporations.
00:05:04 And yet, when it came to big pharma, he seems to be an ally.
00:05:07 So Rebel asked a good question.
00:05:09 Singh said he wasn't going to answer.
00:05:10 Unfortunately, for Singh, the very next question was also from another Rebel reporter who put
00:05:15 a great question to him and just said, look, this question isn't from me.
00:05:18 This question isn't from the Rebel.
00:05:19 This question is from millions of Canadians that want to know your opinion on this.
00:05:23 Don't they matter?
00:05:24 You know, you're the guy that says that we shouldn't marginalize people, that we should
00:05:27 be diverse and inclusive.
00:05:29 And yet here you are refusing to answer questions from someone because you perceive them as being 1.00
00:05:33 right wing and sort of made Singh look really stupid, made him look like the airhead 1.00
00:05:37 that he is. 1.00
00:05:38 Once again, he refused to answer that question. 0.99
00:05:40 So that was pretty pathetic to see. 0.93
00:05:42 Here we have a debate where they refuse to let a right wing leader in and they refuse to 0.96
00:05:46 answer questions from right wing media.
00:05:48 They're completely excluding part of the country.
00:05:51 And that's not good to see.
00:05:53 Now, Trudeau's own Andrew Lawton was in there.
00:05:55 He asked some great questions.
00:05:56 He got a question to Justin Trudeau where he asked about genocide in Canada's history,
00:06:00 whether Trudeau believed that we were committing genocide.
00:06:03 Of course, Trudeau gave a non-answer.
00:06:04 And he asked a good question to Jagmeet Singh, the NDP leader, about Singh's position on hate
00:06:10 speech and regulating free speech on the internet.
00:06:12 So head on over to tnc.news to check out those clips because you're going to want to watch them.
00:06:16 They're really great.
00:06:17 I want to show you one clip from the debate last night.
00:06:20 This is what it looked like when a rebel journalist got a question to Justin Trudeau.
00:06:25 And you can really see how Justin Trudeau turns and starts really just lashing out at this
00:06:30 reporter, blaming them for spreading misinformation, saying that they don't report the science.
00:06:35 And then how he pivots to start complimenting his friends in the media and really trying to,
00:06:40 you know, make them feel good, make them feel warm and fuzzy.
00:06:43 I mentioned this the other day on the show as well, that Trudeau loves to do this.
00:06:46 He loves to give a little shout out to the journalists, make them all know that he's on
00:06:50 their side, that he loves them.
00:06:52 It's not these journalists that are the problem.
00:06:54 Trudeau loves journalists.
00:06:55 He just doesn't like the right-wing journalists.
00:06:57 And he really, really demonizes, again, Canadians who don't want to get vaccinated, Canadians
00:07:02 who are skeptical of vaccines, Canadians who are sick of lockdowns.
00:07:06 You can see how he pivots and really starts demonizing, starts dividing and pitting Canadians
00:07:11 against each other.
00:07:11 So let's show that clip.
00:07:12 The only reason that I'm allowed to ask you this question is because today the federal
00:07:17 court ruled that the government doesn't have the right to determine who is or is not a
00:07:22 journalist.
00:07:23 This is the second election in a row that the court has to overturn your government.
00:07:28 Do you still insist on being able to make that decision and why?
00:07:33 First of all, questions around accreditation were handled by the press gallery.
00:07:38 Organizations like yours that continue to spread misinformation and disinformation on the science
00:07:47 around vaccines, around how we're going to actually get through this pandemic and be there
00:07:54 for each other and keep our kids safe is part of why we're seeing such unfortunate anger
00:08:02 and lack of understanding of basic science.
00:08:06 Your, I won't call it a media organization, your group of individuals need to take accountability
00:08:14 for some of the polarization that we're seeing in this country.
00:08:19 And I salute all extraordinary, hardworking journalists that put science and facts at the heart of what
00:08:26 they do and ask me tough questions every day, but make sure that they are educating and informing
00:08:34 Canadians from a broad range of perspectives, which is the last thing that you guys do.
00:08:39 So again, you can see Trudeau straight up blaming the rebel for the rallies, for the protests,
00:08:45 for the anger that he's seen on the campaign trail at his rallies.
00:08:48 Again, this is Trudeau just trying to divide Canadians, pit us against each other, and really
00:08:54 creating a boogeyman out of the rebel, saying that they're to blame for all the problems
00:08:57 in the world.
00:08:58 It's kind of scary to see a leader of a party, the prime minister of Canada, really targeting
00:09:03 and coming down on one specific organization.
00:09:06 Now, regardless of your view of the rebel, love them or hate them, if you think they're
00:09:09 legitimate journalists or you think they're just provocateurs, it's still a little scary,
00:09:13 a little disconcerting to see the prime minister of Canada, the leader of a political party,
00:09:18 really demonizing and coming down on one media outlet, sort of blaming them for all the troubles
00:09:23 in Canada.
00:09:25 That should make you feel uneasy, regardless of what you think of the rebel.
00:09:29 Now, I want to shift gears a little bit here.
00:09:31 So yesterday on the show, we told you about the exclusive, independent and scientifically valid
00:09:36 poll that True North commissioned about the election.
00:09:38 We told you about how the liberals blew a spectacular lead in the campaign and how it's too close
00:09:43 to call.
00:09:43 The election is too close to call.
00:09:44 Our poll had the conservatives up by two points, but the way that the vote is distributed,
00:09:48 really it could become a minority liberal government or a minority conservative government.
00:09:52 It's too close to call.
00:09:53 Right now, what we saw was that young male voters have really come over to support the conservatives.
00:09:59 Meanwhile, the liberals have maintained their support of older women, women over 55.
00:10:03 And we also tapped into that huge gain of support by the PPC, by the People's Party and Maxine
00:10:09 Bernier's party, as he's seen a big grow in his popularity at the expense of the other
00:10:14 protest parties, the ones that were included in the debate while Maxine Bernier was excluded.
00:10:19 Well, today we're going to dig even deeper into that national poll.
00:10:22 And to do that, I am joined by Hamish Marshall.
00:10:24 Hamish, nice to see you.
00:10:25 Great to see you.
00:10:26 See you, Candice.
00:10:27 So one of the issues that you asked Canadians about and you identified was what issues do
00:10:32 they care about in this election?
00:10:34 What issues are driving the vote in 2021?
00:10:36 So why don't you help us by breaking that down, Hamish?
00:10:38 Sure.
00:10:39 So we asked people what are the two issues that they think are most important facing Canada
00:10:43 today.
00:10:44 Number one, probably not a giant surprise, is getting through the COVID-19 pandemic.
00:10:49 30% say that climate change and the environment is one of the most important issues.
00:10:56 30% followed by government spending and debt at 25% and then affordability and the cost
00:11:00 of living behind that and jobs in the economy.
00:11:04 But what's really interesting about this actually is what issues you care about varies a great
00:11:09 deal depending on who you're voting for.
00:11:11 So conservatives care a lot about government spending and debt.
00:11:15 It's their number one issue by a long way.
00:11:16 51% of conservatives say it's one of those two most important issues, followed by jobs in
00:11:22 the economy at 32%, and then COVID comes third at 28%.
00:11:27 Whereas liberals care about something else entirely.
00:11:30 Liberals really care about the COVID pandemic.
00:11:33 And that's actually one of the reasons, 52% of them say it's the most important issue.
00:11:38 What's actually interesting about that is that liberals were most concerned with the pandemic.
00:11:41 And I think that's one of the reasons why calling an early election has backfired in Trudeau and
00:11:47 turned off some liberal voters or dampened some enthusiasm, perhaps a little bit, because
00:11:51 they're the ones that care the most about it, and holding an election in the middle of it
00:11:55 maybe doesn't jive with that.
00:11:59 They also care awful about climate change and the environment.
00:12:01 45% say it's one of the top two issues.
00:12:03 And then health care, outside of excluding COVID, is the number three issue.
00:12:09 The other thing that jumped out for me is that issues that have been talked a lot about in
00:12:13 the media aren't necessarily cutting through to Canadians.
00:12:17 So obviously, we've had a big blow up in Afghanistan and the fall of the Taliban and foreign affairs
00:12:23 in the front pages of the newspapers, leading the newscasts for much of the last month.
00:12:27 But only 2% of Canadians say it's one of the two most important issues.
00:12:32 And then Indigenous reconciliation, which we heard an awful lot about in the spring, and
00:12:36 a lot of pundits were saying it was going to be a dominant issue of the campaign.
00:12:40 Again, only 7% say it's one of the most important issues.
00:12:44 So that shows that often media-driven issues aren't what people actually care about.
00:12:52 The other thing that we asked that I think was very interesting is we asked people, what
00:12:55 about the lockdowns?
00:12:57 Had lockdowns changed their view about government?
00:13:00 And we basically give them the choice between choosing between lockdowns made them more
00:13:04 concerned about the power of government.
00:13:06 35% of Canadians say that lockdowns made them more concerned about the power of government.
00:13:11 But 65% say that lockdowns made them grateful that government has the power to take steps to
00:13:20 look after them.
00:13:21 So not a super strong result.
00:13:24 But it is encouraging that there's 35% of Canadians that have that freedom-focused approach.
00:13:29 What's most interesting about that is Quebec, where we've seen some of the biggest anti-lockdown
00:13:33 protests.
00:13:34 Actually, that number who are more concerned about the power of government has risen, is
00:13:38 even greater.
00:13:39 It's 48% of Quebecers are more, lockdowns have been more concerned about the power of government.
00:13:44 Maybe that's because historically, Quebecers have been more okay with the power of the state,
00:13:49 and they've got bigger room to grow in terms of concern.
00:13:52 But it certainly makes an interesting point that what's going on in Quebec in terms of
00:13:57 the big protests is real and is concerned to a lot of people.
00:14:01 And maybe, just maybe, that can help Maxime Bernier and the PPC, especially in his own
00:14:06 riding.
00:14:07 He's got a long way to go, so we'll see.
00:14:08 I'm not making a prediction that he's going to run off with it.
00:14:10 But it does show that there's a fertile ground for his message there.
00:14:14 Well, and everyone was circulating that poll yesterday that showed that the PPC was at
00:14:18 10% nationally.
00:14:20 Now, I know that our poll showed something a little different.
00:14:22 I think we were something around 4% or maybe it was 6%.
00:14:26 I can't exactly remember.
00:14:27 But still, definitely growth and a lot more appetite for Bernier's message than in 2019.
00:14:35 Oh, one of the interesting things that you tapped in on in this poll, Hamish, is the
00:14:40 idea of strategic voting.
00:14:42 So every election, especially when it looks like a conservative is doing well and they
00:14:46 might even win, we fall back to that old liberal strategic tactic of scaring progressive voters
00:14:53 and getting them to strategically vote in favor of the liberals.
00:14:58 You asked a couple questions about this in the poll.
00:15:00 So what did we hear about strategic voting?
00:15:02 So we asked everybody who said they were voting either Green or NDP, we said, if it looks like
00:15:07 the conservatives are going to win, would you vote for the liberal candidate in your
00:15:12 writing in order to stop a conservative government or conservatives from winning?
00:15:17 And the answer is, on the whole, a lot of them would.
00:15:21 20% say they're very likely to do so.
00:15:23 Another 21% say they're moderately likely to do so, which means overall it's 59% who say
00:15:29 they're not really likely to do so.
00:15:30 But, you know, if you take the NDP vote and the Green vote combined, even if just that
00:15:35 20% say they're very likely to do that to stop the conservatives, they'll move to the
00:15:39 liberals, that works out to 4.6% of the vote.
00:15:42 If you add 4.6% of the popular vote on where the liberals are sitting today, we're in an
00:15:47 environment where the liberals will be able to win the election by two or three points,
00:15:51 assuming that everything else stays the same.
00:15:54 So this is going to be a huge focus of the liberal campaign over the next 10 days.
00:15:59 It's going to be a big focus of Trudeau in the debate tonight in order to drive those
00:16:05 voters over.
00:16:06 We've already seen the NDP vote drift down.
00:16:09 We've got them at 20% previous polls earlier in the campaign of a 22, 23.
00:16:14 So I think somebody once had them at 24.
00:16:16 So they're already drifting down.
00:16:18 The liberals have got a little bit of their mojo back.
00:16:20 If they can continue that trend, pick up another 3% or 4%, it's going to be very, very
00:16:25 difficult.
00:16:26 It faces a big, big strategic issue for O2O.
00:16:30 Wow, that's really interesting.
00:16:32 And again, yeah, the final week of the campaign coming up next week, that's something that
00:16:35 we're definitely going to be watching.
00:16:37 Well, Hamish, I really appreciate you joining us to break down the poll.
00:16:40 It was really interesting.
00:16:41 And tonight is the big night.
00:16:43 We're going to be going live during the debate before and after.
00:16:46 Hamish will be there with me the whole night to break everything down and to provide
00:16:49 that analysis.
00:16:50 So make sure you tune in starting at 8 p.m. Eastern.
00:16:53 Thank you so much, Hamish, for joining us.
00:16:56 My pleasure.
00:16:56 And tonight's going to be a lot of fun.
00:16:57 Absolutely.
00:16:58 All right.
00:16:58 Thank you so much for joining us and see you again later tonight.
00:17:01 I'm Candice Malcolm and this is The Candice Malcolm Show.