The Candice Malcolm Show - December 13, 2023


Trudeau votes for HAMAS

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Hanukkah is the new Christmas (and they’re both cancelled!) Is Elon Musk really spreading “misinformation” about Canada?

Episode Stats


Length

14 minutes

Words per minute

183.34

Word count

2,661

Sentence count

161

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

15

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Justin Trudeau and the government of Canada voted in support of Hamas at the United Nation on Tuesday. Despite Canada s long-standing policy of support for Israel, Justin Trudeau has stabbed Jewish Canadians in the back. He is now calling for Israel to more or less surrender to Hamas, all in pursuit of winning votes for his Liberal Party of Canada.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Justin Trudeau and the government of Canada voted in support of Hamas at the United Nations on
00:00:04 Tuesday. I wish I was kidding, but I am not. Despite Canada's long-standing policy of support
00:00:09 for Israel, Justin Trudeau has stabbed Jewish Canadians in the back. He is now calling for
00:00:14 Israel to more or less surrender to Hamas, all in pursuit of winning votes for his Liberal Party
00:00:19 of Canada. I'm Candice Malcolm, and this is The Candice Malcolm Show.
00:00:30 Hi, everyone. Thank you so much for tuning into the podcast. So it has been an interesting week
00:00:36 for Canada's foreign policy when it comes to Israel. In the span of less than 24 hours,
00:00:40 Prime Minister Justin Trudeau went from breaking bread with Jewish Canadians, lighting the menorah
00:00:45 to commemorate the Jewish festival of Hanukkah, to condemning Israel at the United Nations,
00:00:49 and more or less calling for them to surrender to Hamas. Yes, Justin Trudeau voted in favor in 0.95
00:00:55 support of Hamas at the United Nations. So how did this all happen? We're going to go through the
00:00:59 timeline on the show today. So this was a scene in Ottawa on Monday evening, Monday, December 12th,
00:01:04 at a ceremony on Parliament Hill. Justin Trudeau was there, Chrysia Freeland were there. They were
00:01:08 showing their support for Jewish Canadians and paid respect to the religious holiday of Hanukkah,
00:01:13 the festival of lights. Now, it may seem a little mundane to acknowledge Hanukkah, but honestly,
00:01:18 in 2023, as I talked about on my show yesterday, it actually takes some courage as a woke,
00:01:23 progressive politician like Justin Trudeau to attend a Hanukkah event. Leftist politicians
00:01:28 from Calgary Mayor Jody Gonduk to California Governor Gavin Newsom have decided to either
00:01:34 cancel or completely avoid Hanukkah celebrations, lest we anger our pro-Hamas constituents.
00:01:40 Well, Justin Trudeau did show up, and here he is wishing a happy Hanukkah to Jewish Canadians.
00:01:45 Hello, everyone. Tonight, Jewish people in Canada and around the world will gather around the menorah
00:01:51 for the first night of Hanukkah. I know the past two months have been incredibly difficult for
00:01:57 Jewish people. On October 7th, the world watched in horror as Hamas committed acts of unspeakable 0.96
00:02:05 violence against innocent civilians. Since then, there has been a disturbing rise of anti-Semitism
00:02:13 that is making people feel unsafe in their schools, their workplaces, and their communities.
00:02:18 We've seen unacceptable, hateful acts that no parent should have to explain to their kids,
00:02:25 and that no rabbi should have to explain to their congregation.
00:02:28 I want to be clear. Our government stands with you. We will never accept any form of anti-Semitism
00:02:37 or hatred, and we will always speak up for Israel's right to exist and right to defend itself.
00:02:45 The story of Hanukkah is a reminder that light shines brighter than darkness, and right always
00:02:51 prevails over wrong. It's also a reminder of the resilience of the Jewish people who've persevered
00:02:59 through periods of unfathomable difficulty before. Canada will continue to stand with Israel and with
00:03:06 Jewish communities around the world as we persevere through this as well. I hope that the lessons
00:03:13 of Hanukkah and the glowing light of the menorah bring you hope during this difficult time. I also
00:03:20 hope you can find comfort and peace as you celebrate your traditions. Whether you're watching the kids
00:03:27 play with dreidels, frying latkes, and eating sufganyot together, or listening to the heroic story of the
00:03:35 Maccabees. And as we begin the new year, I want you to know that we will continue to stand with you.
00:03:42 At around the exact same time as Trudeau and Freeland were on Parliament Hill with Jewish Canadians
00:03:48 showing their support, Trudeau's very unserious foreign affairs minister, Melanie Jolie, was over
00:03:53 at the CBC doing an interview where she announced or introduced a bizarre new initiative that seemed
00:03:59 to undermine Canada's support for Israel and its right to defend itself. So in this interview with
00:04:03 the CBC, Melanie Jolie said that her government will eventually support an accountability system to
00:04:08 investigate Israel's military conduct during its war against Hamas. But interestingly in this interview
00:04:13 when asked about the ceasefire resolution at the United Nations, Jolie says she's still looking at
00:04:18 different versions of the expected resolution and that basically they hadn't decided how they were
00:04:23 going to vote. So that was Monday evening. Jolie really showed no intention that they would support
00:04:27 a ceasefire resolution at the United Nations, but then Tuesday morning came Tuesday, December 12th,
00:04:32 and Canada decided to break its long-standing support for Israel by voting in favor of a ceasefire at the
00:04:37 United Nations. Now make no mistake, a call for a ceasefire is support for Hamas. It's a call for 0.98
00:04:42 Israel to stop fighting against Hamas, to allow Hamas to live another day, to survive, to regroup.
00:04:47 It's basically calling just for Israel to lay down its arms, knowing full well that Hamas doesn't 0.57
00:04:52 really listen to ceasefires. It doesn't really respect ceasefires. They continue to fire rockets.
00:04:56 They continue to wage unprovoked attacks on Jewish civilians. We saw that during the very
00:05:00 recent humanitarian pause when there was a massacre at a bus stop in Jerusalem against civilians,
00:05:06 including a pregnant woman who was murdered and Hamas took credit for it and Hamas celebrated it
00:05:11 basically. So we know that a ceasefire only really applies to Israel. It's telling Israel to stop. So 0.63
00:05:17 why this sudden change in policy? Well here is Melanie Jolie explaining why the Trudeau government flip-flopped
00:05:23 on this issue. Here's that clip. We must recognize that what is unfolding before our eyes will only
00:05:31 enhance the cycle of violence. Well this will not lead to the durable defeat of Hamas which is necessary 0.97
00:05:41 and the threat that it poses to Israel. With the future of Israelis and Palestinians in mind, 0.77
00:05:49 Canada is joining the international call for a humanitarian ceasefire.
00:05:56 We have done so in a joint statement with Australia and New Zealand earlier today
00:06:02 and we have done so this afternoon at the UN. So somehow we're supposed to believe that stopping
00:06:08 the war will help Israel defeat Hamas. Something about cycle of violence doesn't really make a lot of
00:06:15 sense. Let's read from the news story. This is from CP on this issue. The headline says Canada breaks
00:06:20 with long-standing Israel stance at the UN in voting for Gaza ceasefire. So Canada voted in
00:06:26 favor of the non-binding resolution of the United Nations on Tuesday that calls for an immediate
00:06:30 humanitarian ceasefire between Israel and Hamas in a move that broke with years of Canadian policy
00:06:36 and shocked Jewish groups. The vote at the UN General Assembly represents a shift in Canada's long-standing
00:06:40 position of siding with Israel on major resolutions at the international body and arguing the Jewish
00:06:46 state is unfairly called out in global form. We'll continue reading from the CP story. It says the
00:06:51 liberals say the carnage in the Gaza Strip led Canada to change its attack. They quote Melanie Jolie a few
00:06:56 times from that clip that we just played. Then it provides a bit more context about the war. Then it
00:06:59 goes back to another quote from Melanie Jolie and she says thousands of children are now orphans.
00:07:04 Countless Palestinian civilians in Gaza are suffering without food, water, fuel or medicine and their
00:07:09 homes have been reduced to rubble. So I'm sorry but the fact that thousands of children are now orphans
00:07:14 is because their fathers were part of Hamas. They're part of Hamas. They chose to join a terrorist group.
00:07:19 I don't quite understand why that's Israel's fault. Same with the idea that Gazans are suffering without
00:07:24 food, water, fuel or medicine. We know that Hamas steals those supplies. We know that Hamas controls all 0.65
00:07:29 those supplies. Why is it that Israel is getting the blame for this when it is clearly Hamas that 0.95
00:07:34 is doing those things? This is the kind of stuff that just makes you shake your head about the
00:07:37 things that Melanie Jolie says. The things that she freelances about and that she's allowed to say
00:07:41 she really doesn't know what she's talking about. So okay literally up until hours before the vote
00:07:46 happened Canada's position, Trudeau's position was that they did not support the ceasefire. They have
00:07:51 been saying that throughout the war that they do not support one. They supported a humanitarian pause
00:07:55 but they did not support a ceasefire. Canada supported Israel's right to defend itself,
00:07:59 to recover those hostages, to eliminate the terror threat on its border. It was the NDP,
00:08:03 the left-wing NDP and a small handful of left-wing Liberal MPs who supported a ceasefire,
00:08:08 who independently put out that statement saying that they wanted a ceasefire but the Trudeau
00:08:12 government did not. In fact interestingly even now after the Liberals have come out and moved
00:08:17 their support away from Israel, some Liberal MPs are publicly breaking ranks with Trudeau,
00:08:22 with the Liberal Party. They have made statements on social media and let me just emphasize that this is
00:08:26 something that is very rarely done in Canadian politics. Party solidarity is very strong in
00:08:31 Canada. You very rarely see a Liberal MP breaking ranks with the Prime Minister or a Conservative MP
00:08:36 breaking ranks with the Conservative leader. So first we had Anthony Housefather on Twitter,
00:08:41 this is what he writes. In my view any cessation of hostilities requires Hamas to release all 0.88
00:08:45 hostages and lay down arms and surrender. Hamas, a terrorist organization, is entirely responsible for 0.74
00:08:51 starting a war. I disagree with our vote at the United Nations today. Good on Anthony
00:08:56 Housefather to speak his mind. Likewise we had Marco Mendicino on Twitter also putting out a statement,
00:09:02 also saying this, I disagree with Canada's vote at the United Nations today. I do not support his
00:09:07 call for Israel to agree to what is effectively an unconditional ceasefire at present that would
00:09:12 only place in further jeopardy the safety and security of Israelis and Palestinians in Gaza. So
00:09:18 good for those Liberals to speak their mind and to remain principled. Now oddly after the vote,
00:09:23 Melanie Jolie jumped back on Twitter to add a bunch more facts and a bunch of more demands that are 0.98
00:09:29 actually counter to what the United Nations had voted for, counter to what she said in those stories
00:09:34 to the Canadian press and to CBC. So she writes this,
00:09:37 Hostages must be released. Foreign nationals, including Canadians, must be able to leave 1.00
00:09:42 Gaza and more aid must be able to enter. Hamas must lay down its weapons. Canada supports efforts
00:09:48 to a sustainable ceasefire, which cannot be one-sided, but none of those were conditions to
00:09:54 the ceasefire that she voted at at the United Nations. So in a nutshell, this is the problem with
00:09:59 the United Nations resolution. It only focuses on Israel. It's telling Israel to stop. It ignores the
00:10:04 party that wages the war, the party that endangers its civilians by fighting in plain clothes as
00:10:09 militant combatants in heavily dense, heavily populated civilian areas. It ignores the party
00:10:15 that doesn't care about ceasefires. It doesn't acknowledge ceasefires. And that, of course,
00:10:19 is Hamas. So Melanie Jolie, of course, was called out for her response. This is CJA,
00:10:24 the Canadian-Israel-Jewish alliance. They wrote this, Empty words. You just voted for a UN resolution
00:10:29 that intentionally and explicitly included those considerations. Minister Melanie Jolie,
00:10:35 you cannot have it both ways. Well, that is exactly right. Now, many Canadians, especially
00:10:39 Jewish Canadians, are probably now wondering, what led to Justin Trudeau's change apart?
00:10:44 Why did Canada suddenly shift away from its longstanding position? Why the sudden flop?
00:10:48 Why the sudden knife in the back to his Jewish allies? Well, the answer is quite easy. This one article,
00:10:55 published about four days ago, says it all. So here it is in the CBC. It says,
00:10:59 Group representing Canadian Muslim donors pulls back from Liberal Party over stance on Gaza. From
00:11:05 the letter, it says, Representing influential Canadian Muslim donors to the Liberal Party of
00:11:09 Canada has dropped out of the ranks of the party's top donors, citing Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's
00:11:14 disinclination to call for a ceasefire in the Israel-Hamas conflict, CBC News has learned.
00:11:20 In a formal letter sent to Party President Sachit Mehra on November 27th, the group, which says it
00:11:25 has 400 members, says that it has called on Trudeau repeatedly to request a ceasefire. The leader does
00:11:31 not appear to be interested in truly listening nor interested in giving true value to international
00:11:36 law. With broken hearts, we must depart to the Laurier Club, the group said. The donor club is mostly
00:11:41 made up of Canadian Muslim professionals such as lawyers and doctors formed in December 2014. The group
00:11:45 helped Justin Trudeau to win his first election victory in 2015. Well, there you go. Now we know
00:11:51 that part of the reason that Justin Trudeau won his first election was because this group of
00:11:56 influential Muslims, 400 Muslim donors, who the CBC is telling us helped him win. So that's the reason. 0.85
00:12:03 It's just that simple. For Justin Trudeau, it is all transactional. It is about votes. For his entire
00:12:08 tenure as Prime Minister, since he was running for this position in 2015, Trudeau has put the Liberal Party
00:12:14 and its electoral interests ahead of the well-being of Canada, ahead of our unity, ahead of our national
00:12:19 interests. I wrote a book on this topic back in 2016. It is called Losing True North, which became
00:12:24 a number one bestseller. It sold tens of thousands of copies, which is really unprecedented for a Canadian
00:12:29 political book. But there was a lot of interest in it and the words that I wrote are true. It is
00:12:34 still happening. Trudeau has a deliberate policy to change Canada's long-standing immigration
00:12:38 tradition. Orient our immigration towards intake from the Arab and the Muslim world. And rather
00:12:45 than making attempts to integrate and to assimilate these new Canadians, rather than telling them to
00:12:49 leave their tribal hatreds at home and to come to Canada and embrace Canadian values, Trudeau has done
00:12:54 the opposite. He's told them that they can remain exactly as they are. He's fueled radical Islamists 0.72
00:12:59 and he has defended them at every opportunity. Under Justin Trudeau's tenure as Prime Minister,
00:13:03 Canada has welcomed more than half a million Muslims and Trudeau wants to make sure that every
00:13:08 single one of them will forever vote for his party, will forever vote for the Liberal Party.
00:13:13 And that is what this is all about. Jewish activist Anthony Cook pointed this out on Twitter last night.
00:13:18 He says, the Liberal Party understands demographics. They're making a choice based on a very cold and hard
00:13:24 political reality. There are far more Muslims in Canada than there are Jews. And as time goes on,
00:13:28 the disparity will likely continue to grow exponentially. That's all there is to it.
00:13:33 I think that's right. I think it's that simple. There's just one more element, which is why I added
00:13:37 this tweet. I said the demographic shift didn't just happen. It was a deliberate change in policy
00:13:41 by the Trudeau libs. They prioritize immigration from Arab and Muslim countries for this reason.
00:13:47 So the demographics are going to continue to shift in that favor, which is why eventually we knew that
00:13:52 Trudeau was going to make this jump. Well, it happened on December 12th. The mask has slipped and
00:13:56 Canadians can now see the truth. Justin Trudeau doesn't care about principle. Justin Trudeau doesn't really
00:14:01 care about democracy or stability in the Middle East. He doesn't really care about supporting 0.99
00:14:05 an ally or fighting against radicalismism and terrorism. No, he doesn't care about those things.
00:14:10 Justin Trudeau cares about himself and he cares about the Liberal Party of Canada winning the
00:14:15 most votes. That's all there is to it. I'm Candace Malcolm and this is The Candace Malcolm Show.