The Candice Malcolm Show - October 21, 2021


Trudeau’s disastrous visit to Tk’emlúps First Nation

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Bringing common sense back to politics (Ft. Aaron Gunn) Ford stands his ground amid fake news narrative

Episode Stats


Length

17 minutes

Words per minute

185.51

Word count

3,215

Sentence count

168

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

7

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau finally visits the Dikimailles First Nation and things get pretty awkward. We ll talk about his disastrous visit. Today's episode of The Candice Malcolm Show is brought to you by True North Media.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Prime Minister Justin Trudeau finally visits the Dikem Loops First Nations and things get pretty awkward.
00:00:05 We'll talk about his disastrous visit. I'm Candice Malcolm and this is The Candice Malcolm Show.
00:00:13 Hi everyone, thank you so much for tuning into the show, tuning into the podcast.
00:00:18 We've had a busy week here at True North on Monday.
00:00:20 We did a live stream covering the Alberta municipal election as well as the referendum question on equalization.
00:00:27 I had Aaron Gunn on my show yesterday. He's running for leader of the BC Liberals and he sounds totally different than a normal politician.
00:00:36 He speaks with common sense and conviction and he's not afraid to discuss issues that are thorny and to go against the woke left mob.
00:00:44 Well, in all of the excitement that was going on this week, I didn't cover this trip that the Prime Minister took to Kamloops, to the Dikem Loops First Nation.
00:00:52 And I want to go through it on the show today because it was pretty awkward, pretty uncomfortable for the Prime Minister to finally go and I want to unpack that.
00:01:02 But first, if you're watching this video on YouTube, I'm going to ask that you like this video.
00:01:07 Don't forget to subscribe to True North and make sure you hit that red notification bell so that you don't miss any of our videos.
00:01:13 If you're watching on Facebook, please like this video, share it with your friends, leave us a comment, and don't forget to head on over and like the True North page.
00:01:20 Finally, if you're listening to this show in podcast form over on Apple Podcasts or Google Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts,
00:01:27 please don't forget to subscribe to The Candace Malcolm Show.
00:01:30 And if you like the content, if you like the show, don't forget to leave us a five-star review.
00:01:35 It really helps us out. It helps our ranking and helps other people discover The Candace Malcolm Show in searches.
00:01:41 So that really does help us out.
00:01:42 So today I want to talk about this awkward, awkward trip that the Prime Minister took to Kamloops.
00:01:48 But I'm going to give you a little bit of background first because there is a lot of underlying stories and narratives here
00:01:54 and the underlying stories are so important to the stories.
00:01:58 So in case you've been living under a rock and you haven't been paying attention to the sort of prevailing media narrative
00:02:03 over the past six months or so, it all started here.
00:02:06 I'm talking about the unmarked graves found at residential schools.
00:02:09 The story that blew up across the international media led to really egregious claims against Canada,
00:02:14 accusations of mass graves, which were untrue, accusations of genocide that Canada committed, which is untrue,
00:02:21 horrible, terrible, unfair comparisons, basically saying that Canada's residential school programs
00:02:27 were the equivalent of the Nazi Holocaust against the Jews, which is just absolutely wrong on so many levels.
00:02:34 And I'm one of the only voices, I think, in Canada who has been willing to come out and challenge this narrative
00:02:40 to say that it's untrue, to talk about the facts, to bring the narrative back to the facts of the story
00:02:45 and to talk about how so much of the sensationalism, the moral panic that came from this story
00:02:51 was not in fact tied to the facts on the ground or tied to reality.
00:02:55 It really, really got sensationalized.
00:02:57 I had a piece over at tnc.news that went viral.
00:02:59 It's the most read piece in the history of True North.
00:03:02 It's called Six Things the Media Got Wrong About the Graves Found Near Residential Schools.
00:03:07 I encourage you to head on over and take a look at that if you haven't already.
00:03:11 And things got so out of hand from that narrative, from that false narrative that the legacy media pushed
00:03:15 and the moral panic that they created, that we then saw dozens and dozens of churches across Canada,
00:03:21 over 50, get vandalized, desecrated, or burnt to the ground without really much of a reaction,
00:03:28 without really any kind of outcry, outroar from the political class.
00:03:32 Instead, we saw people, elites in our society, actually cheering them on, justifying it,
00:03:38 making excuses for the arsonists and for the vandals.
00:03:40 It was really quite something, one of the worst displays of behavior in recent memory in Canada.
00:03:46 And it all originated from this band, from the Takenloops First Nation,
00:03:50 from a press release that they put out saying that they had confirmed that there were unmarked graves on their property.
00:03:56 And again, if you go back to my piece that I wrote, many people would assume from the narrative,
00:04:03 from the way that the media reported on it, that there had been some kind of an excavation,
00:04:06 that they had actually found the remains of children.
00:04:09 They weren't, they didn't.
00:04:10 They used ground-penetrating radar, which is a very rudimentary technology.
00:04:15 And basically, all that they determined was that there was some soil movement.
00:04:19 And even the lead researchers came later, did a press conference where they explained that they had no way of knowing
00:04:26 how many graves were there, how many bodies were there, whether they were children, whether they were First Nations.
00:04:31 We don't know any of that.
00:04:32 It's all sort of unconfirmed in speculation.
00:04:35 However, it still blew up into this huge narrative.
00:04:37 So that's the first important context and background.
00:04:40 The second important piece of background for this story today is that this chief, Chief Roseanne Cashmere,
00:04:47 was very public in inviting Prime Minister Justin Trudeau to come to her ceremony on Truth and Reconciliation Day.
00:04:53 So September 30th of this year, Canada observed Truth and Reconciliation Day the first time in our history.
00:04:59 The holiday was created by Justin Trudeau and the Liberals.
00:05:02 Instead of taking up the invitation from this chief, from this very high-profile chief,
00:05:07 and her reserve that everyone knows is the one that started the whole narrative about the unmarked graves,
00:05:13 Trudeau instead chose to lie to the public to say that he was in Ottawa in official meetings
00:05:19 when, in fact, where he actually was, was in Tofino.
00:05:22 Instead of observing this national holiday that so many Canadians do,
00:05:25 so many Canadians instinctively understand that our history isn't perfect,
00:05:30 that there were things that happened, that we all deeply regret programs
00:05:33 and federal government initiatives that were wrong,
00:05:37 that have had very negative impacts on First Nations, Canadians, and those communities.
00:05:41 And I think residential schools is absolutely one of those.
00:05:44 In no way, shape, or form have ever defended residential schools.
00:05:47 I don't think that they were a good idea.
00:05:49 I generally oppose large, sweeping federal government programs,
00:05:53 especially ones that break up families and remove kids from their homes.
00:05:56 My criticism was always about the media narrative and the way that they talked about the story
00:06:01 in a way that was sensationalizing it and pushing ideas that weren't true.
00:06:06 So all this is to say that Trudeau got into big, big trouble for not commemorating this holiday
00:06:11 that so many Canadians did observe, rightly so, 1.00
00:06:14 and taking steps towards more reconciliation, more fairness,
00:06:18 and more quality of outcome for First Nations Canadians.
00:06:21 So instead of doing any of that, Trudeau was off on the beach, and it was very, very bad.
00:06:25 So that's all the context.
00:06:26 Now, here we are on Monday.
00:06:28 Justin Trudeau is finally in Kamloops.
00:06:31 He's at the Kamloops First Nations,
00:06:32 almost three weeks after he skipped the original invitation to visit on Truth and Reconciliation Day.
00:06:37 And when speaking to the press, this is what I'm talking about when things get awkward,
00:06:40 because Chief Roseanne Kashmir, good for her,
00:06:43 she is absolutely unintimidated by the Prime Minister.
00:06:46 She's not impressed by him, and she lets him know it.
00:06:48 So here we see the two sitting side by side,
00:06:51 Prime Minister Justin Trudeau sitting next to Chief Roseanne Kashmir,
00:06:54 and she absolutely slams Trudeau. 0.94
00:06:57 She absolutely destroys him while he is sitting right next to her.
00:07:01 And just watch the look on Trudeau's face.
00:07:03 He is just being put in his place, being shamed in a way that MPs in Ottawa,
00:07:09 you know, maybe it does happen from time to time with Conservatives,
00:07:12 but Trudeau is usually just so smug when it comes to any criticism.
00:07:16 So to see him being criticized very fairly and rightly by a First Nations woman, 1.00
00:07:22 a strong First Nations leader, a strong woman, is absolutely classic.
00:07:27 So here is the clip.
00:07:28 It's about two minutes long.
00:07:29 And just watch, just look at the look on Justin Trudeau's face. 1.00
00:07:33 What a sad, sorry, pathetic excuse for a leader in this country. 0.99
00:07:37 When we imagined welcoming Prime Minister Trudeau to our community, 0.99
00:07:43 it was envisioned that it would be an opportunity for him to interact
00:07:48 with a wide array of survivors, intergenerational survivors,
00:07:52 and many different First Nations as part of September the 30th,
00:07:57 the first National Day of Truth and Reconciliation.
00:08:01 Two letters of invitations were sent to his office to participate in our event.
00:08:08 For us, it was to show his commitment to rectifying the historical wrongs of residential school
00:08:15 and to grieve with our residential school survivors,
00:08:20 whether in person or by a virtual prerecorded greeting and message for all of us here.
00:08:28 Instead, in the middle of truth-telling, cultural grounding, and sharing that unfolded
00:08:34 as part of the commemoration of the very first National Day of Truth and Reconciliation,
00:08:38 in this arbor, a journalist quietly informed us that the Prime Minister Justin Trudeau
00:08:45 was on vacation in Tofino.
00:08:49 The shock, anger, and sorrow, and disbelief was palpable in our community,
00:08:56 and it rippled throughout the world, to say the least.
00:09:00 Today is about making some positive steps forward and rectifying a mistake.
00:09:09 So, pretty devastating stuff, pretty awkward for the Prime Minister,
00:09:13 and again, good for Chief Kashmir for just putting him in his place.
00:09:17 And while on that visit to Kamloops, that wasn't the only bad thing for Trudeau,
00:09:20 he also got fact-checked by a First Nations group
00:09:23 and basically got called out for saying something that wasn't true.
00:09:28 So, here's a story in the National Post about it.
00:09:30 It says, Truth and Reconciliation Centre disputes.
00:09:32 Trudeau claim all residential schools' records have been transferred.
00:09:36 It's time for that to be true.
00:09:38 So, here is just a bit of the background.
00:09:40 So, while Trudeau was in Kamloops, he told the media that all requested documentation
00:09:44 Ottawa has on residential schools had been turned over to the National Centre
00:09:48 for Truth and Reconciliation in Winnipeg.
00:09:50 We will continue to look to make sure that there are no others that we have remaining to turn over,
00:09:56 but we have, in our understanding, turned over all of those records.
00:10:00 Well, that is not true according to the National Centre for Truth and Reconciliation,
00:10:04 and they have rebuked his claim on their website.
00:10:07 They wrote this on their website.
00:10:09 It says,
00:10:10 At present, we are still waiting for Canada to provide the final versions of school narratives
00:10:14 and supporting documents used in the independent assessment process to the NCTR.
00:10:20 That's the National Centre for Truth and Reconciliation.
00:10:21 The statement also reads,
00:10:23 At present, we are also still unable to access Indian hospital records, federal health records,
00:10:29 and day school records.
00:10:30 All of these records are crucial not only to support missing children research,
00:10:34 but to fully and truthfully document the residential school system,
00:10:37 the children who died in the schools, and the ongoing legacy.
00:10:41 The statement ended saying,
00:10:42 If the Prime Minister is telling all Canadians and Indigenous peoples
00:10:45 that the National Truth and Reconciliation Centre holds all the records,
00:10:48 it's time for that to be true.
00:10:50 So again, pretty devastating stuff for a Prime Minister who virtue signals a lot
00:10:54 and likes to pretend that he is very empathetic and caring
00:10:57 and that he is the one that is going to help First Nations people in Canada
00:11:01 when we all know that that's not true.
00:11:03 We all know that Justin Trudeau doesn't really care about this stuff.
00:11:05 He only cares about appearing like he cares.
00:11:07 He doesn't actually like doing the hard work and following through on his promises.
00:11:12 And so that is all coming to light, and it is pretty amusing stuff.
00:11:16 And now all that being said, I think it is important,
00:11:20 especially on this show, on the Candace Malcolm show,
00:11:22 that we dissect the statements that both sides make.
00:11:25 So we don't let one side get away with statements that aren't true
00:11:28 just because the other side is saying things that aren't true.
00:11:31 So one of the things that Chief Kashmir had said
00:11:33 is that the findings have been confirmed,
00:11:37 that the unmarked graves have been confirmed.
00:11:40 Well, that is not exactly true.
00:11:42 So to this day, there's still no follow-up and no proof
00:11:45 about that story of the 215 unmarked graves.
00:11:48 In fact, as I mentioned earlier in the show,
00:11:50 when they finally did do their presentation
00:11:52 and released the report that they had
00:11:54 that was done through a local university,
00:11:56 the main researcher said that the 215 number wasn't even true.
00:12:00 So you remember all those headlines,
00:12:02 215 unmarked graves, 215 children found.
00:12:05 215 was the number that we heard over and over again.
00:12:08 And that number has sort of become a rallying cry.
00:12:10 You see it in stickers.
00:12:12 You sometimes see it on store window fronts.
00:12:14 A lot of people use that 215.
00:12:16 You see it a lot on social media.
00:12:18 Well, according to the lead researcher who did the report,
00:12:21 she said that that 215 number isn't even accurate.
00:12:23 It isn't true, that the claim is more something about 200.
00:12:27 They expect roughly 200 graves that were found.
00:12:31 And she reiterated the idea that it is basically impossible
00:12:34 to confirm whether this is true,
00:12:36 whether these are actually graves,
00:12:38 who these graves belong to,
00:12:39 whether they were children at the residential school,
00:12:41 whether they were from a previous generation,
00:12:43 whether they were First Nations,
00:12:45 or whether they were the European settlers
00:12:47 who were there at the time.
00:12:48 We just don't know.
00:12:49 The only way to confirm that would be to do excavations,
00:12:53 to dig up and find the remains,
00:12:57 do carbon dating on the bones and all that kind of thing,
00:13:00 which is something that isn't happening at this point.
00:13:02 There's no plan to do that.
00:13:03 I can't imagine First Nations people wanting to do that, 1.00
00:13:06 wanting to dig up a burial space,
00:13:09 especially a sacred burial space.
00:13:11 So really, there is no confirmation.
00:13:13 There's no confirmation.
00:13:14 We still have a claim.
00:13:16 Even, like I said, the lead archaeologist,
00:13:18 a woman by the name of Sarah Bilio,
00:13:20 had to clarify that these results are probable
00:13:22 and that they are not confirmed.
00:13:24 This is what she said back in July
00:13:25 when they did that presentation
00:13:27 that was supposed to show the results
00:13:29 and confirm all this information.
00:13:31 She said, all residential school landscapes
00:13:33 are likely to contain burials and missing children,
00:13:37 and remote sensing, such as ground-penetrating radar,
00:13:39 merely provides some spatial specificity to this truth.
00:13:43 According to the Globe and Mail,
00:13:44 she also stressed her findings can't be confirmed
00:13:47 unless excavations are done at the scene,
00:13:49 which is why we need to pull back a little
00:13:52 and say that these are probable burials.
00:13:54 They are targets of interest for sure.
00:13:57 She said the sites have multiple signatures
00:13:59 that present like burials,
00:14:01 but that we do need to say that they are probable
00:14:03 until one excavates.
00:14:06 So again, the main researchers, the scientists,
00:14:08 the archaeologists say that these are probable graves.
00:14:11 And so when you have the chief of a First Nations
00:14:14 coming out saying that it is confirmed,
00:14:16 that's a political statement,
00:14:17 that is not a factual statement,
00:14:18 that is not based on the facts on the ground.
00:14:22 And there's more.
00:14:24 Chief Kashmir has also claimed
00:14:25 that some of the bodies were detected
00:14:27 were as young as three years old.
00:14:29 That again, this is not confirmed
00:14:31 by ground-penetrating radar.
00:14:33 We can't confirm any details about the individuals
00:14:35 or how they died.
00:14:36 This is from a University of Lethbridge professor
00:14:39 named Dr. Paul Vermitz.
00:14:41 He says,
00:14:41 the radar isn't going to tell you who's down there,
00:14:44 nor is it going to tell you what they died.
00:14:46 He said that during a event hosted
00:14:49 by the Society for Academic Freedom and Scholarship,
00:14:51 as well as the Frontier Centre for Public Policy.
00:14:54 And according to the Canadian Archaeological Association,
00:14:57 it is not possible to identify grave locations
00:15:00 or the absence of graves
00:15:02 with 100% certainty using remote sensing.
00:15:05 They also say that archaeologists
00:15:07 will likely assign different levels of confidence
00:15:09 to their results in much the same way
00:15:11 as a weather forecaster predicts
00:15:13 the likelihood of the rain.
00:15:15 Now, all this isn't to downplay or diminish.
00:15:17 The experiences were,
00:15:18 which from all accounts were pretty horrific
00:15:21 for First Nations individuals
00:15:22 who did attend these residential schools.
00:15:24 It is just to say that we should take some caution
00:15:26 when we're talking about the story.
00:15:28 We should recognize that it is a very,
00:15:30 very heated subject.
00:15:32 Many Canadians feel a sense of remorse
00:15:33 or they feel ashamed by the way
00:15:35 that First Nations peoples were treated
00:15:36 in Canada in many instances.
00:15:39 And, you know, the feeling that they have
00:15:41 is that we want to right this wrong.
00:15:43 But by pushing stories that are sensationalized,
00:15:47 that are not really based on truth,
00:15:49 all it does is raise the temperature
00:15:51 and enables the sort of bold, far-left people
00:15:53 who just want to, like they said, 0.55
00:15:55 burn it all down, burn down the churches, 0.95
00:15:57 erase Canada, destroy our history. 0.99
00:15:59 We have to be pretty careful
00:16:01 and try to stick as closely to the facts.
00:16:03 The facts are bad enough as it is.
00:16:04 We don't need to exaggerate them to make them worse.
00:16:07 And when it comes to the story of the unmarked graves,
00:16:09 we should try to stick with the facts
00:16:11 and not allow the media and left-wing activists
00:16:14 to blow it out of proportion to sensationalize it.
00:16:17 Yes, horrible things happened at residential schools.
00:16:20 Were they mass killing fields
00:16:21 that we can equate to Nazi Germany?
00:16:23 No, they weren't.
00:16:24 That's not what they were.
00:16:25 That's not what happened.
00:16:26 That's not what the stories over the summer
00:16:27 of the unmarked graves proved.
00:16:29 In fact, we don't even know for certainty
00:16:31 what it is that we're talking about.
00:16:33 And it's important to stick to the facts
00:16:35 and the truth when we are reporting
00:16:36 when we're talking about such a sensitive issue.
00:16:39 Regardless, it was a very, very bad day
00:16:41 for Justin Trudeau, a bad week.
00:16:43 He was put in his place.
00:16:44 And I think that most Canadians 0.95
00:16:46 are starting to see through his nonsense
00:16:48 to recognize that he likes to virtue signal.
00:16:51 But when it comes to putting his money
00:16:53 where his mouth is,
00:16:54 when it comes to walking the walk,
00:16:55 he just isn't there.
00:16:56 He doesn't care.
00:16:57 He's not authentic.
00:16:58 And he was rightfully put in his place
00:17:01 this week in Can Loops.
00:17:02 Thanks so much for watching.
00:17:03 I'm Cadis Malcolm,
00:17:03 and this is The Cadis Malcolm Show.
00:17:05 Who's the Cadis Malcolm?
00:17:11 Who's the Cadis Malcolm?
00:17:18 Hello?
00:17:18 Hi.